Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mythwind - Board Game Review

Transcript 22:29

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about myth wind which is published by open owl Studios who did Supply us with this copy for review but the thoughts in this video are all our own and mywind is designed by Brendan mccal and Nathan L and in this cozy game you are working together to build a fantasy Forest town and you're doing this by being very different characters but first let's look at how it plays you start the game with a town board full of untouched land and one of four asymmetric characters each day starts with revealing the weather then you choose a town action which will consist of things like gaining resources for buildings building new buildings in your town Town gaining worker dice upgrading characters or going on adventures which are cards that give you choices that will result in various gains or losses once you are finished in the town everyone simultaneously takes character actions which will be different for each player the crafter makes and refines goods to sell to customers with a mini bag building game the farmer plants and harvests crops raises livestock and builds tools

through a polyomino puzzle the merchant buys and sells Goods with a goal of taking over rival Traders through Market manipulation and the ranger heads off on adventures packing spending and trading items through a kind of light deck building puzzle you keep doing this until the weather deck runs out then you resolve end of season effects and evaluate this season's goal card and you either save your progress or head into the next season and your continued quests to build your town and upgrade your characters one of the key things about this game in particular is it's for a very specific audience and I think you're going to know if it's for you based on the description of is it do you like games like stardew Valley and Harvest Moon games that have a very chill Vibe and you get to go in various directions but there isn't a point system there isn't winning there isn't specific like hard targeted goals you need to achieve yeah this is very much and we'll come back to the like who is it for but it's just so important for this game that it's something that we really do have to start off with because it's very much that Harvest Mooney like you are just you're grinding in this you are going to be working hard at getting your character to kind of build up slowly for each different game and there are Little Adventures you can do and there's building a town and there are

those that kind of little bit of underlying story like you see not as much as stardo Valley but like like you'd see in Harvest Moon or in other games like that like a farm Vish kind of game but it's it really is that so just know that that you yeah you can't you're not going to win and lose each game you're going to slowly gain stuff each game and it's just going to kind of build up over time yeah and that can be a difficult thing to wrap your head around like I found it challenging cuz I don't play those kind of games but if you play those games and you enjoy those games this has very much that kind of feel but a few things I really liked in it and number one are the characters I really enjoy that they do play very differently and so if you want to try out lots of different characters get a lot of time trying to figure out how each of them works and try and maximize them this is a great opportunity because they do feel very different yeah the asymmetrical characters remind me a little bit of Merchant's Cove where you are playing quite different games from the other players you're still kind of working towards the same goals which is like leveling up your skills gaining money doing stuff on the main board building up the town all that stuff but how you're getting there is super different and actually let's just run through some of those characters right now um so let's start off with you were two quite a bit and I think your favorite was the ranger yeah I really

enjoy the ranger for the ranger you get to go on these Expeditions so you're not even using the town board for a lot of the times and instead you are progressing along these cards and you're hoping that you brought the right tools to be able to succeed on those cards and turn them into Goods which will eventually get you coins and so the fact that you're not using the main the main Town actions makes it feel so different yeah it was my favorite one as well actually and I played it a little bit later and I played it solo and we'll talk about the player count a little bit later but it was I found it really interesting and it was the one that I played through a season by myself and immediately I was like I want to play another season because it plays so fast when you're playing this one solo especially you're just kind of zipping through because you don't really do that town board and because it is interesting that like did I bring the right things and then I'm trading them off and you feel that progression from section to section as you go through it so even though it is fairly simple I I really got into the ranger yeah it feels like a mini Adventure as well because you get a sense of like oh yes I managed to get all of these things out of this one outing the other character that I was was the merchant and I enjoyed the merchant so for the merchant you're manipulating a market so you're trying to decide when you want to sell Goods when you want to buy Goods you have a couple of Rivals that you're competing with and you're trying to like take them

over so your goal is just to have a lot of money to essentially buy them out and that I found is also interesting because the market really switches it goes up and down depending on the weather depending on the rivals depending on the customers yeah and I like that the merchant gives you such a goal as well because those buyouts you'll only do maybe one a season but they feel like oh I've accomplished this like it's a big accomplishment and it really feels like something so I felt like they leveled up slightly more satisfyingly probably than any of the other ones um the other two you weren't but I was was the farmer which is really meant to be kind of the entry level character but it's got interesting stuff you're doing a little polyomino puzzle with kind of with crops where you're getting those crops and then you're selling those crops um you also have cattle that you're putting together and you can breed those and you're also gaining tools that you're putting with that I will say though that it is fairly simple and there's this other bit where you're you've got to kind of clear out the bushes from your crops but you can't do a lot of that and they come back at the end of the season so it does feel a bit like I don't know why I'm bothering with this and then the last one is the crafter and with the crafter you are refining goods and gaining Goods where you're doing this through putting stuff in a bag pulling it out of a bag and then just kind of trading it to move those up and as you move those up you are fulfilling customer requests and

it feels it's a little bit it's feels slower than all of the other ones and because you can kind of just see where you're going and you're just kind of waiting to get there a little bit so this one I thought was probably the least interesting of the four I think perhaps in a Solo game it would feel a bit better because you're getting there a lot faster but it it just didn't have the same ump as some of the other ones for me and so the order for me would probably be Ranger first and then Merchant those were the only two I played and yours would probably be it sounds like the those two as well probably Ranger Merchant farmer crafter yeah I think that that would be my top L and so the other good thing that I really enjoyed as well is just the ease of being able to save your characters and so when it comes to Campaign games I think one of the most challenging things is being able to pack it away and then unpack it easily and that can be a real barrier but for this one the ease of which you can save a game makes it really simple to bring out and and keep playing yeah yeah it really does this is not like like Gloom Haven I feel like we're spending a lot of our time putting that away and bringing it back out this is like seconds like especially unpacking it again the all of the the city boards just go on top of each other everything saved nicely every every single thing that you've got in your board it's it's like a minute to put it away it's a minute to take it back out it that was a real plus but there are also some

negatives that we really need to talk about the biggest one for me was the rules the there's there's a lot of rules and there are a lot of big Rule books and they've got a lot in those Rule books but the problem is it seems to over focus on some of the simpler Concepts where they're explaining it to me three or four times and then there are these Concepts I really want to know about and those are all kind of Hidden Away in the back and there aren't play I really needed there to be playerid so there are little things in the back of the books that just kind of walk you through the season and that is helpful but it comes to these giant Parts where it's like for the crafter crafting refining but it's like I don't know what that means and I don't know what the icons mean and they're listed but they're not explained so there'll be an icon that just say refine but I really need to be minded what is refining cuz there are a lot of steps in that so those and there's some big Aras especially for the crafter which I thought was totally broken turns out that there was just a major part that they did not explain where and I'll tell you right now because it's so important where instead of only being able to refine one good a season as it says you can refine each good so each different good you can refine as much as you want to this makes the game way better and really changes it yeah I will say when it comes to the rules I do appreciate that the different characters have their own rule book it made it really straight

forward you were reading your character I was reading mine we didn't have to share one rule book but yes the back could definitely have a lot more explanation there were a few pages that I just had to almost just have open and out because those ones I always had to refer to so that did make it challenging and it it was in how it presented itself made it feel like a a more complicated game than it is it's a lot more straightforward than another asymmetric game like root for example but there is a lot of text and a lot of explanation that isn't as streamlined as it could be yeah I think I could explain this game to somebody top to bottom in 15 minutes and it took us a couple of hours to First understand this game so that was a bit of a barrier to entry but let's let's get into to some of the the other kind of specific category and let's start with the components which is a huge strength for this game so we already talked about how easy it is to save it those character trays are just terrific and how they go in the box is terrific there's a lot here that is just like as a Bard gamer that I'm just like oh like I love how everything goes in goes into everything else I also really like the Miniatures I think there's a lot of detail they look great I think the art looks nice I mean it does give me a Vibe of like a fantasy Forest Town which is what it's going for and I think the card quality seems pretty good as well yeah I think all of

that stuff's terrific the buildings um all of the art for the different buildings I think looks really really great they fit really nicely into the board everything they've really thought about like even taking cards in and out everything has this kind of little bit in the middle of it so you just push the outside and it comes out so easily I love that about it so yeah I think presentation wise I like there's I don't have a problem like I can't even usually I try and think of one thing that bothers me I don't know if there's anything here that really bothers me and speaking of the Town board we can talk about replayability and I think this is something that is going to feel a little bit more repetitive the longer you play your campaign I really liked the first year it felt really exciting there were a whole whole bunch of forest spaces that you get to flip and get a reward you're also really striving to build these buildings that feel really difficult to do and I liked having that goal of really trying to get like the metal or the meat or whatever I need to be able to make those buildings it gave us some direction however after a couple of years you've already uncovered all the forest spaces you've built a lot of buildings a lot of those buildings are giving you an income of getting you more of the building material making it easier and easier to build the buildings but not necessarily I didn't feel like the buildings that you're building later on paid off in a significant way yeah

the buildings almost exclusively the buildings help you build more buildings but then building more buildings helps you build more buildings so pretty quickly you feel like why am I building these buildings there are a few exceptions to that but for the most part the like five character spaces that you begin the game with are the five character spaces you're going to go to oh over and over and over and over but the adventure one I think is worth talking about because that is a big part of the replayability as well because the adventure cards are I think one of the most interesting Parts in the game the tricky is only one person's really going on them but still we always read them out we always kind of decide which one which of the things do we want to do and they feel generally fun and they kind of build to something cu the story here isn't linear but it does have a bit of a progression to it and there's little enough text on it and the text is well enough written that I found myself reading it and I found myself remembering some of the things and being interested in it yeah it was the right amount of text cuz it wasn't it was only a couple sentences so enough that you wanted to read it but without over stain it's welcome but I was always going to the adventure spaces CU it's just the the more fun Avenue and when you think about a Cooperative campaign I think at least I tend to think of a narrative and that's where you're getting that you you want to be going on an adventure so you're going to these Adventure cards but in terms of replayability is you spend a lot of those Adventure cards so there's some that stay in there but once

you have spent all the spent ones it could be a while before you add new ones and when the fun is going on like a surprising Adventure that's lost a little bit if you've reached like a stagnant point where you're not adding more yeah we got to the point in the last two or three games that we played where it's the same four Adventures that are kind of stuck in there that we're going to but now now we know the different results so we know what to do each time so that that is a little bit of a tricky um but let's the adventures also brings us to player count because only one person's going on those Adventures but four player count and I adamantly think this is by far the best as a solo game it doesn't play any different with one to four players you're going to everything's is going to play pretty much the same it's just the more people are doing stuff but because there's almost no interaction in this game unless you kind of want there to be or the I'm going to go to this town space you go to that town space mostly the interaction is me going are you done your stuff yet are you done your setup can we move to the next thing okay cool let's move to the next thing and then Jess going are you done your thing cuz some characters do a lot in the early stages some characters do a lot in the middle some characters do a lot in the end but they don't really cross over that much so it's kind of I'm waiting you're waiting I'm waiting you're waiting whereas when you're playing by yourself you're just kind of going going going going going and then move to the next season and I feel driven to be like oh I

want to I want to do a bit more I want to keep going from where I'm at right now whereas a two- player I didn't have as much of that yeah and I Think It's Tricky with certain character combinations there are some that are almost like you describe completely opposite for when they do their main actions and that can be tough other ones that aren't quite as drastic but you will get that with a four player game if you're playing all the characters there's going to be probably there's going to be someone that's slowing up the game so I agree I think it probably works well as a solo I haven't played it solo I'm not really a solo gamer I did enjoy it at two I wouldn't play it at more than two players but it does allow for players to dip in and out which which is nice so if you own the game and you really always want to play it with somebody it can be different people each time and they can be different characters so it is nice that it's very flexible like that you can switch characters you can have more characters one time fewer characters another time which is nice yeah very much so and because the story is so it's kind of lightly in there it's not that important that you're here for every single card that is R you could put them aside if people are really Keen but they not going to miss anything if someone misses two or three seasons and then comes back or if someone only ever plays one season it's going to be 100% fine but I really think this is going to be a game that shines for solo players and I think we've hinted at this quite a bit already but let's sum up who we think this game

is for and primarily it's for people that really like that cozy no wind condition building your own thing game that is probably best equivalent to Harvest Moon is that the the most apt comparison yeah kind of I think board game wise it's got a little bit in common with dor romantic in that way not I think dorf romantic has more immediate goals and it has more overall goals because this does have four envelopes but it takes a while to open up those envelopes and they're not terribly interesting when you open them up so whereas DF romantic you're getting these tiles and then you're excited to put in these new tiles but I think this this is really going to work for those folks who are totally cool with that grinding who just are happy just kind of putting their heads down doing this thing building it up building up building up and getting those little hits all the time but being okay without having any big like oh I did it or oh I just completed this or oh that was really close and I just crossed over it it's not going to have those it's going to have oh good I got one skill that last round oh I I bought out that one business depending on who you are I had that long adventure and then it's going to have another one of those so it's going to have just these little incremental bits that you're kind of building up building up building up and then once you get to kind of 10 games with a character I found you're going to be like all right I'm pretty much done

those and then you're going to start another character so if that is interesting to you then this is probably going to be a game that you're going to like it also works well for people who don't like a lot of player interaction in particular Nega ative player interaction it's a Cooperative game you are very much doing your own thing so if that sounds good this this is that kind of game yeah no one is going to mess with your stuff no one is going to hurt whatever you're crafting whatever you're building people are just going to kind of do their own thing well you do your own thing and every now and then you might go oh I did this and everyone will go oh great I don't really understand what that is but cool I like that there are people though that this is definitely not for because there there is no Wing condition as we said so if you need that like what is my goal you're not really there are little mini goals at the end of each season and you are going to kind of drive towards those but you really just do those in like the last turn or two we've generally found so there is not really going to be any kind of short-term or even long-term overarching goal that you're driving towards and I think that is going to be the biggest barrier because for board games in general that is what drives a lot of people a lot of board gamers are compet comptitive they want to beat their personal best they want to accomplish something new they want to try out a a new strategy and see if it's successful and you don't get that so it's just a very different experience I'll also say that I think they're kind of diminishing returns with this one at least for us a little bit because you

kind of build up your character to a point and then you feel like they're there you build up your town to a point and you feel like they're there but you're probably going to get 10 or so plays out of each character at least before you get there I think you're probably going to be okay with that so I think you can probably guess from everything we've said already this is very much a game for a specific kind of person and I think you'll be able to recognize if this is a game for you and that is it that is myth wi and we should also mention that while the first Kickstart I think is just delivered the second Kickstarter I believe goes live in March we've got a link to that in the description we don't make any money off of it but if you're interested you can find it there thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you played myth win or if based on the sounds of it it seems like myth win is the kind of game for you and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game

Progress saved