Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Witcher: Old World - I should love this game (but I don't!)

Transcript 26:04

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, in today's video, we are taking a quick look at The Witcher Oldw World. And along with the base game, I got a pretty good bundle. I think it was off of eBay. And we are also taking a look at the adventure pack, which is an expansion that just adds a ton of random encounter cards and also playing with the monster trail expansion, which I think adds quite a bit to the game. So, on paper, The Witcher Old World seems like a game I should love. Uh, it plays well solo. It's not a campaign game. It's a zero to hero kind of one and done style adventure game. There are a ton of encounter cards. And when I say a ton, I mean a ton of encounter cards once you start adding in those expansions. And uh that's pretty cool. I think it does a pretty good job of feeling like the Witcher, of doing the things that you would do in a Witcher video game, exploring the world, learning about the monsters you are hunting and fighting those monsters. And it all fits in a relatively small box because I don't have the minis version. And so everything you're seeing in this video today fits back in the base box with a little bit of room to spare. So those are all things that I value in board games. But this game has kind of fallen

flat for me and I actually do prefer the older fantasy flight Witcher adventure game. And I think the main reason why is that to me the Witcher old world, it kind of feels like three various games or like three kind of different elements kind of sandwiched together to make a game. and those various pieces never coalesce into the feeling of a great adventure game for me. Now, I don't hate the game. I don't like intensely dislike it. It's just fallen a little flat and that surprised me a little bit just because of it contains so many things that I enjoy. But because it is all contained in a relatively small box.

It's not one of those giant like cubesized boxes, I am more apt to keep the game in my collection and, you know, return to it in the future to see if maybe it hits a little different. Maybe I will uh grow to appreciate uh this game. But let's take a little look in detail into what you are doing in the Witcher old world. So, in uh The Witcher Old World, you will be playing as a Witcher. And with the expansion, there are six different Witchers that you can play from six different schools. And in the game I was playing uh this week, I am playing as uh a Witcher from the school of the viper. And so, they kind of focus in in in poison. So the main thing you are doing in a game of Witcher the Old World is you are moving on this map from location to location and you are taking advantage of the various location actions in order to upgrade your Witcher stats. And the Witchers share three stats in common, combat, defense, and alchemy. And then each of the various Witchers has a special skill that is unique to them.

And so my school of the viper, they have venomous steel and you also have defense. Now this part of the game to me kind of feels like a worker placement game. There really isn't kind of a grand sense of adventure while you are exploring the map. You are just kind of moving along these paths from one location to the next doing what it says on that location when you land there. So, if you land here, you get to draw a potion. And potions are things that you can use in combat. They will give you special advantages against monsters and allow you uh to do more powerful attacks and draw more more cards from your deck and things like that. And uh at the base game, at the base level, a Witcher can hold up to four potions. And then they can use a certain number of potions in combat depending on the level of their alchemy skill.

And the way you move from one location to the next is you will use cards from your deck. So this is at its core a deck building game. And each Witcher has its own starting deck of around 10 cards with the expansion. Each Witcher will have one special card that they will add. The cards have different colors that's that correspond to strong attacks, weak attacks, uh defensive magic or offensive magic. and they will give you bonuses to your defense. You they will give you bonuses to your hit. They will allow you to draw more cards and combat and so on. And you can also combo cards, which is one of the neatest things about this game. One of the things that I think is really cool is the deck building system and how the uh different cards combo. Because if I were to play this yellow card in combat, this has a purple tab. And so I can combo a purple card off of that yellow. Uh, another card that we have here up on offer to buy is this kind of a grayish color card and that gives you a defense, but then you can also combo a red or a yellow card off of that card. So, you can build some interesting uh combinations as you are building your deck. But one of the other things that you are using your cards for is during this kind of like worker placement movement uh uh portion of the game is each of the cards has an icon that corresponds to a different terrain on the board. And so to move from this

location in a forest to this location in the mountains, I would need to play one of my cards from my hand that has that mountain icon. and then I can move there and then I could take advantage of this location's uh special uh ability here by gaining a potion. These areas here are Witcher schools and we can pay to upgrade our stats. And as we upgrade our stats, we will also upgrade our Witcher level. Uh right now my combat, all of my stats are at level two. And so I am a level two wizard. Now I can push these up to the next level. And as soon as they all get up to level three, then my Witcher goes up to a level three. As you gain levels in defense, you will also raise your shield, and that will allow you to tank more damage when you get into combat. But to me, this element of the game really does feel like a worker placement game and not an adventure game. And you only have one worker, your your Witcher. But I think it handles it pretty well. That's this part of the game is pretty cool. Um, at the end of each one of your turns, after you have moved to your final location, you can visit multiple locations on a turn. Then you will have to choose what you want to do during phase two. In phase two, you will have to have some kind of encounter. And a lot of times, those encounters are going to be from these encounter cards. And you can choose to

have an encounter in the city that you are in because all the spaces are kind of cities or populated areas or you can choose to have an encounter in one in the surrounding wilderness. So if you have the adventure pack expansion, uh you get hundreds of these adventure cards and also these kind of more involved quest cards. And I think these are really cool, but they do lack a little bit of excitement because most of them are the same type of card. And so if I chose to have an adventure in the city, I would draw this city card. And each one of these cards will have a little story that you read and then a choice of two options. Then you choose one of those options and then you read the outcome below. And pretty much every single one of these is the same. And one of the things that I always look for in a really good deck of random encounter cards and adventure cards is being surprised when I read it, being surprised when I draw it, of never really knowing what is coming. And while the story would be different, you really never do anything except read a little story and then choose how you want to respond to that. the results are different, but I never feel excited when I draw one of these cards. And I think one of the reasons why is that the uh Witcher Old World, it it lacks a simple

mechanism for conflict resolution. The main conflict in the game after you have played some turns, moving around the world, strengthening your Witcher, getting new cards for your deck, and learning about the monsters is are those monster fights. And in a solo game, you have to defeat three monsters. And we'll talk about the monsters in detail um in just a bit, but you have to defeat a level one monster, a level two monster, and a level three monster, and get a special kind of uh trophy that corresponds to one of your skills, getting one of your skills up to level five. But that is really the only conflict in the game. And that conflict uses your deck of cards that you have been building. and it is more involved than simply, you know, rolling some dice and adding a bonus that you might have to one of your stats. But because the game lacks a simple mechanism for conflict resolution, there really isn't any conflict in the adventuring outside of those major battles that you will undertake when you choose to fight one of the monsters. And so your stats that you've been leveling up and the various things on your Witcher board, they don't really come into play while you are exploring the open world. You know, you will never draw one of these cards and it'll never tell you to, you know, check your combat, do a combat check, or make

a defense roll or test your alchemy or your intelligence or something like that. And I think that's kind of a missed opportunity. It makes this element of the game on the board feel pretty disconnected from the action of fighting these monsters. They're not integrated very well. And it also means that every time you draw one of these cards, you just kind of know what is going to happen. Now, sometimes that isn't the case. Sometimes you will draw one of these cards and it will tell you to draw one of these more advanced quest cards and you might have to go to a certain location and you can put a little quest token on that location and then when you reach that location you can actually read the more advanced quest card. Sometimes these will lead to special items that you can get.

Sometimes they will lead to companions that can uh join you as an adventuring party. Uh, sometimes you will get upgraded armor and things like that. Sometimes you will roll a d6 and just to uh generate a random number to find the outcome. But again, most of these are just another little story with two choices that you will have to make. The stories can be interesting. I think they fit the world well, but I would have loved to have seen a more simple mechanism for conflict resolution so that could be introduced into the adventuring portion of this game just to add a little bit of friction as you are moving around because you are moving around just so freely on the map. And that's why I think it kind of feels more like a worker placement game than an adventure game during this phase. But it can be a little bit of fun and it is nice to have a whole bunch of different cards in order to draw those random encounters. So with the monster trail expansion that replaces the smaller monster cards from the base game with these larger, more involved monsters.

And I think this element is actually pretty cool. And this is kind of where it does feel a little bit more like the Witcher video game than the fantasy flight version than the the Witcher adventure game because you kind of have to go out and explored in order to find these weakness tokens. And these weakness tokens will be placed on random spots on the map determined by these location uh tokens that are used to randomize spaces. And when you move on to a space that has a weakness token, you get to draw it and then you learn something about the monster that you are tracking. And that's really cool because that does kind of emulate that idea in the Witcher video games about learning about the monsters, learning about their weaknesses, learning about the terrain that they are in. You know, what what are they weak against? What are they strong against? uh what type of creature are they? You learn about them. And that's really neat because as you draw one of these, you get to flip the card over and then you read the corresponding number. So if I had discovered weakness, weakness token three while exploring the map, then I could read number three here on the Arcus. And this says that Arcus Arcuses are semi-transparent, which makes them easier to for camouflage.

Some varieties can also be mistaken for force undergrowth. And so my bonus would be before creating the life pool, raise your shield level by one. It may exceed your defense level. So here you've learned that the um the the aracus has a really good natural camouflage and so they are often you know waiting in ambush and so you know this and so you are more prepared when you are when you choose to fight the the Iraqis. you know that you need to be careful about uh the terrain that you are exploring. So that's really cool. I like that idea a lot. I think the monsters feel unique and that's probably the coolest thing about this game is how unique and different the monsters feel. Now the uh monster trail expansion also adds the ability for these monsters to have up to four different types of special attacks.

And so that is also really really cool. So when after you have done exploring, you've gotten a few weakness tokens, you've leveled up your stats, uh you've earned a few cards for your deck. Let's talk about the deck building really quickly. So along the right side of the board, you will keep all of the cards that you can buy. At the end of each one of your turns, you have to buy a card to add to your deck. However, there are also a number of different opportunities to uh destroy cards from your deck, to uh to callull your deck, to get rid of cards that aren't working with your build, with the combos that you are putting together, so you have a better chance of drawing those cards that you want. So, I think that deck building is actually uh pretty well implemented as well. Uh, one of the issues I had in uh, games of uh, of Clank that I played was there weren't enough opportunities to callull cards out of your deck to remove cards that weren't working. And it never really felt like you were building a character through the deck building.

But, uh, this game uh, The Witcher does a pretty good job of making you feel like you are putting together a build. And that is another thing that you know uh emulates the uh video games. And there are a large number of cards available especially when you start getting the expansions. And I think these cards are really nice. I think the art is overall really good. And I think the art on these cards and the monsters looks really nice. I do have a little bit of issue with the board art. It just looks a little dull. I prefer the more vibrant look of the Fantasy Flight Witcher adventure game. And that's just because one of the things I appreciate about The Witcher 3 is how bright and colorful and vibrant the world is to explore. This feels a little more sedued, a little more uh uses more grays and browns, but the art on the cards is really nice. And there is a lot of variety to the different types of cards.

They will have different costs, and the higher value cards are worth it. They will give you more opportunities to perform more combos. They will give you more damage that you can do. But sometimes these like heavy attack cards, these red cards, you know, they might do more damage, but on your next turn, you will draw fewer cards into your hand because you've exerted yourself in that in that strong attack. And I think that's a really neat uh way to kind of show the difference between uh light attacks and heavy attacks. So building out your character can be fun. However, however, it can also be a little bit frustrating when cards aren't coming out that you need in order to build those cool combos. Once you get into combat, so if we were fighting this level one Arachus here, uh they have a life pool of 10 cards. And so you would take your enemy deck and your enemy deck at the beginning of a game using the Monster Trail expansion will have 16 cards in it. and you deal out a number of cards based on their hit points. So, uh the Arachus would have 10 cards in their deck. So, one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, 10.

And so, that would be uh their deck. When this deck runs out, they are out of hit points. So, your deck is also your hit points. And so, that's another reason why you may want to keep some cards in your deck that maybe aren't beneficial to your build because these are also your uh your HP. And so when you get into combat, you would take the cards that you have in your hand, try to build out a good combo in order to remove cards from the enemy's deck. And then depending on if you go first, you could do that and then the monster would take its turn. And in a single player game, the monster just flips over a card. And then we have two different types of attacks. Normally in a competitive game, you uh the the other players would be playing the monsters and they could kind of choose what they want to do. In a solo game, you roll a dieice. On a one to a three, you do the charge. On a four to a six, you do the bite attack. And then depending on the strength of the monster, they will do different points of damage. Or they might also tri trigger other abilities that might force you to discard cards or maybe lose a potion or something like that. During combat is the time when you can also use your potions. And the potions will give you different uh benefits in combat. They will allow you to draw more cards or maybe cycle through your deck in order to find the cards that you want. And then with the expansions, you also have access to bombs. And so, as you guys know, the Witcher will craft

various bombs. And these bombs are kind of like potions. They're a little more powerful, so they cost a little bit more to get, but you can hold a certain number of bombs and then you can also use those in combat. And the expansion, the monster trail expansion also adds another module. And that's kind of that that's one of the things that I do like about that expansion is that you don't have to use everything. You can choose to use some, none, or all. And we also have the mutagen deck. And so when you level up, rather than getting another type of bonus, you can choose to grab one of these mutagens. And so, you know, the Witchers are always kind of experimenting with these different ways to mutate themselves to make themselves more powerful. And so, that's another thing that you can do. Uh, the main focus of the game is to defeat all three of the monsters that you have randomly selected at the beginning of the game.

And that's pretty much it. you want to defeat level one, level two, and level three, those monsters will be placed out on the board at the beginning of the game using these location tokens. And so you are exploring the map, going to these various places in kind of a worker placement style game to take advantage of those bonuses, leveling up your Witcher, buying new cards for your deck, putting together good combos, and then choosing when you want to take on one of the monsters. And as you defeat each of the monsters, you will take the smaller corresponding card that came in the base game, and then you will get a trophy. And in a game of the Witcher, you need to get, I think it's 1 2 3 four uh trophies in order to win the game. So, you will get three trophies from the monsters that you have defeated. And you need to get one trophy by raising one of your stats to uh the the top level to level five and then you will get another trophy. So, I think all of the various elements of the Witcher old world all feel pretty good. I think they are interesting. I think the monsters are interesting. Tracking them down, learning about their weaknesses. Kind of feels like you are hunting the monsters and learning about their terrain, learning about their various uh weaknesses and strengths. I think that is really cool. Um, I like the deck building. I like all of the adventure

cards. I wish there was a little more variety. I wish there was a simpler mechanism for conflict resolution such as maybe just rolling a single d6 and adding your uh stat value so that there could be a little more friction, a little more tension in the adventuring part. So I think all of the the various elements are pretty cool, but for me they never really coales. They never really come together to create a kind of grand sense of adventure. And that's mainly why I think The Witcher has fallen a little short for me. I could see some people really liking this game, especially people who like to have the choice, who don't like D uh dice driven combat, who want to put together a build, who are interested in becoming more efficient at putting together a build and knowing when to kind of press your luck to get to that battle stage.

So, I think for some people this game will work, but so far it hasn't really worked for me. and and um I'm hoping maybe it will. You know, I'm going to keep this game just because, like I said, it can all fit. All of this stuff fits in the base game box. And I think that is excellent uh small box games or or normalsiz box games, I should say, or that that's a big plus for me. It just makes it easier uh to keep. And I do want to play this game a few more times. I think this game might actually be a really good twoplayer game. The turns can be a little long because you're doing a lot on the map. You are moving to a lot of different locations. The combat is kind of involved and it can uh drag on. So, I I don't think I would want to play this with any more than three players. But I think as a two-player game, it might be best because really at its core, what The Witcher Old World is is a race game.

It's like Talisman. It's a race game. you are racing to defeat those uh monsters and to get those trophies before the other Witchers do. And one of the things you can do in a competitive game is you can actually fight other Witchers to get their specific trophy for defeating them. So that's kind of cool too. So that element would add some tension to the adventuring part, to the overland part. I have seen on BGG that somebody has made a solo mode where you are competing with another Witcher and so that actually might add the drama that actually might add the tension that I am looking for to allow all of these various elements to kind of coalesce into an exciting adventure game. So that might be the thing that I look at next.

But um yeah, I hope you enjoyed my look at The Witcher oldw world. I know uh The Witcher is kind of uh back in vogue right now with the uh remaster hitting the same week that this video will be posting. So, I'm actually looking forward to diving back into uh The Witcher 3. I never uh beat The Witcher. I have some issues with it, but I do like exploring that world and maybe this new remaster, maybe it addresses some of the issues I had with the game. And so, I'm going to be checking that out. The Witcher is on a lot of people's minds right now. So, I thought it would be a really good time to dive into The Witcher Old World. So, let me know if you like the game. Let me know if you've tried that that uh solo variant on BG. Maybe that maybe that's exactly what I need to really love The Witcher Old World. We'll talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Progress saved