Beyond Solitaire Podcast 119: Kevin Bertram on the Business of Historical Games
Transcript
thank you it's ad break time Beyond Solitaire is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are cooking up some exciting things in the educational gaming space cartini from Darkness to light designed by Sharia iowandini and published by ion game design is coming to Kickstarter on June 6th and will feature a curriculum guide written as part of a partnership between ion and clgs Rising Waters the second game from clgs will be fulfilling soon and you should keep your eyes peeled for updates on the launch of their next release 500 year old vampire I also want to put in a word for myself if you like this podcast and want to help me do more projects related to history and gaming please go to patreon.com Beyond Solitaire to support my channel for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and I am here on the podcast with a very special return guest Kevin Bertram of Fort Circle games how you doing Kevin I'm doing great how's it going so um I'm doing great as you know uh because it's a very big week for both of us because this is the week that you've made the announcement that you're publishing night witches I have to be honest it's a it's a story that I'm really excited about and to be able to have it play in a game narrative I think is just just awesome so yeah I'm I'm so excited that uh we're gonna be publishing night witches I've been following your uh you and David's design work on it and I was like oh that'd be a good game for us to publish and you know we'll do it right so uh so I'm so happy we're going to be working together so
that's great yes you'd better do it rights or else no kidding uh but I actually had you on here today partially to talk about that because our business is now intertwined but I've talked to you about your business before I had you on the podcast in June of 2021 to talk about being a ages ago to talk about being a new historical games publisher and what your vision was and how you wanted things to go and uh I guess the the how do you feel things have been going over the last two years with four circles so I think they've been going great uh with one caveat is you know there was a Slowdown with the you know the pandemic production got slowed so we're a little behind where I would like to be now um we're you know going to be publishing our third fourth and fifth game this year uh but I would have liked to probably have that done last year but other than the the the immense amount of time we put into each game um it's going great because you know shows are Tripoli kind of set a standard and then I think Tori's design votes for women you know pretty clearly exceeded that and is you know getting the brave reviews that her game deserves and you know I think we did some different things uh by putting lots of historical documents in making sure that the mechanisms were really closely tied with what they're representing historically I think that um you know the you know we have a copy
editor which I don't think a lot of uh board game or just at least in our space app and so you know there's not the the um the typos or problems with gameplay that seem to have played some of the higher some games recently in our industry so you know I'm really super pleased that I think that you know we're doing everything right and I think that you know the marketplace is rewarding Us by you know votes for women is almost sold out and we're gonna have to do a reprint for the holidays this year and there's a lot of demand for I mean we can see the excitement building on Twitter about not only night witches but volkaruki's game on the hunt for Blackbeard Tully rosen's game about the Supreme Court Gilberto and I's follow-up to shores of Tripoli which is the Halls of Montezuma so I think you know I just can't be happier to be honest about how things have went awesome and so I think the other reason that we are a good designer team and publisher matchup is it you know David and I have been super open about what we're doing with our design process basically from day one actually our very first conversation officially about night witches was recorded for the podcast so it's been like a very public Enterprise the entire time uh and you also like to overshare about your business details in a uh well it's not really what we're sharing but share in a substance called negotium ludorum which I helped you name yes indeed thank you thanks the business of games um but you give a lot of very specific information about how you're doing as a
publisher and I I wanted to kind of start by talking about that why you chose to do it and how that has felt well I so I like doing it because I think it helps in a couple of ways when I started you know I talked to a couple Publishers but I kind of decided pretty early on I think I'm going to self-publish and I just decide to self-publish and there wasn't a lot of guidance out there there is some Steve Jackson games has a you know a report to their stakeholders that's kind of helpful it gives you a little bit of behind the scenes um uh Jimmy stegmeyer does a pretty good job of that um uh dominating James mathie who has since passed uh was pretty good about talking about all the kinds of things like shipping and warehousing and art like all the things that go into producing a game but I always felt like they were always leaving a little bit out and that's no criticism of them like everyone has their own style and what they want to share and and I just wanted to go a little deeper into the numbers and kind of explain why we do certain things so like we had air mailed some games some votes for women game so at least people in the United States would get there before the holidays who had been Kickstarter Packers we thought that was important that was expensive so we went through like why did we do that what was the you know the cost and the benefit why do I attend a certain convention or you know try to to you know partially it's a it's a way to rationalize decisions I've made to myself that they make sense but it's also to kind of explain like why we're doing certain things and you know why I I think we're
doing things the right way and and if I you know and if I realize like oh something we've done is not the right way then I'll you know I'll call myself out on that and say well we've decided to make a change here and now here's why in fact that's something that's coming up uh By the time it's already the hot by the time this posts there will be an arm article about shipping and warehousing and using Amazon up and like we made a change in how we handled some things because we found a less expensive higher quality way to do it and so you know I shouldn't keep that information to myself I want my fellow Publishers to know and I want people who are looking at being designers to know there there's also you know a sort of a marketing aspect to it of that you know the more I share about how we do things I think there's more of a sense that people who like our games will identify and have a little more emotional investment in seeing our success and I think that's just natural right it's like oh I know more about this company I appreciate what they're doing I'm gonna definitely make sure to check out their next game and and I think that's value that's certainly not the reason I do it but I do recognize that there's some small benefit for that so yeah so one of the things I noticed in response to the night which is news last week is I've received multiple comments saying that people were happy that night witches would receive the quote Fort Circle treatment and I am very uh impressed actually that people feel that there is a fourth circle treatment two games in like that's quite the
impression so what can what are what are things that you're putting into the fort Circle treatment and then you don't have to give exact numbers but how much more expensive is it to do it that way than it is to not do the fourth circle treatment like has it been worth it sure and to what extent well it's not worth it if you don't sell a lot of games but if it gets popular then it is worth a lot of so uh so the things that we do is uh you know we took a test with the shores of Tripoli and we included one historical document in it plus you know an essay written not by just some random person but like by a person she did her PhD she's now a professor at the Naval Academy she wasn't when she wrote it but who knew a lot about the first Barbary war and that that reaction to that was really strong and so with votes for women uh I initially said told Tori Tori and I tell the story a little differently but I think my version is right as I said let's find some documents uh let's start with three or four and then go from there and she said here's 14 documents and I'm like let's include them all looks great and so then we went forward uh and I think that you know there is some extra cost to it uh but I think it it it immerses the player in the history and if we're making history games you know there's a reason we're doing that we want people to enjoy history and like when you do research about a game you get fascinated about it and then you want to share that fascination with other people and they can access some of
that most of that by playing the game but I think there's that little extra Edge where there's a historical essay that explains some of it there's documents that like really place you in the setting and so uh that's sort of the standard that that we do we also you know we don't skimp on the production right like our boxes are known that you can use them as armor during a zombie apocalypse we definitely insist on the you know the best wood pieces we can get I'm St I wish our wood pieces could be heavier but you know they're as heavy as as we can currently produce that they have act you know that the that would make sense um you know we hire like I mentioned earlier we hire a copy Editor to make sure there's not typos and you know it's not going to be perfect like there's a card in votes for women where there is spelled t-h-i-e-r and no no I'm sorry it's receive is spelled wrong uh r-e-c-e-i-v-e-i-e anyways it's spelled wrong uh don't put me on the spot on a Sunday morning to spell um and so like but you know we try to make sure that like we want our games to be treated the same way like a pandemic would or a root wood or any of these games that sell you know 100 000 copies or more that you know we want to put that same level of effort into it even though our games right now are selling you know five ten I think votes foreign by the end of the year also ten thousand with the second printing right and so it's a smaller you can write like historical gaming is Niche but there's
no reason why we shouldn't do it at the highest quality that we can so yeah boy that sounded like propaganda on our part but I really believe in what we're doing so that's why I'm so passionate about it I mean it does make sense so third question then is so you're choosing deliberately I think that the first few games that a publisher puts out are important because they're kind of a defining set of choices so you know what are you looking at when you're thinking about picking up games and then you know you're picking up a lot of new designers a lot of very you know interesting like very American history Concepts um and also you know how are you how do you feel your choices are currently different from other Publishers in the same space so like a GMT a dvg um well you're in historical cancer you're doing it different yeah well I mean obviously the number one is that our games are not exclusively military war games right like I would say you know votes for women comes out of the war game and tradition but it's wargaming not quite even an election but a campaign to you know ratify an amendment um Paul's Montezuma has is really it's a half political half military game so the American player had is really the Polk Administration they're dealing with Congress they need to get you know treaties with Britain signed and if they want you know the 10 regiments Bill to pass so they get a bunch more troop like so they've got a manage the political
side while also still Prosecuting a war and and then the Mexican player is really not only the Mexican play you know the Mexican Government but also like there's an anti-war movement in the United States that is beginning and so they're basically everyone opposed to the Polk Administration and that political piece is you know super valuable to informing the military piece Jason Matthews has an outstanding um talk that he gave to the Georgetown origami Society talking about you know how political and Military discussions were were set were separated mostly by Rand and that kind of set the standard and that's unfortunate because they should be actually considered together so that was a long discussion about Paul's Montezuma um but we're looking at games that are they don't have to be military at all you know um the our game on the um history Supreme Court that Polly Rosen has is definitely um about you know it's not a war at all but it's a long campaign for affecting you know how what the shape the Supreme Court is um my wife is actually designing a game on the history of the guano trade which is you know it's an economic Euro game for lack of a better term um but it's still rooted in the history and so you know we're not a war game publisher I guess is is the nub of it we're a historical game publisher and that gives us a little wider um uh audience to work with
um I want to jump back and answer one other thing about what the fourth circle what we do is uh we try to we what we do partner with a charity for each game that we publish so the shorts are Tripoli is about the Marine Corps and the Navy and so we partner with Toys for Tots which is run by the Marine Corps Reserve we're doing the same for the hall to Montezuma um the votes for women we've partnered with the League of Women Voters the Supreme Court game we partnered with Supreme Court Historical Society obviously we're having discussions about who to partner with for night witches um same with hunt for Blackbeard we're not sure who we're going to partner with yet but probably some kind of preservation uh in North Carolina and so we also try to tie what's happening in the game back into you know the real world sort of and how people you know how it's relevant to uh real people in the real world so I was a little jumping around question answering I hope you don't mind no I actually really don't yeah you know this podcast is a very free-flowing excellent uh and you know actually I wanted to ask you too so I know that Ford Circle is going for kind of a crossover appeal so there are people in the more traditional War gamey space who are playing fortnite Circle games and then you know there's an attempt to kind of punch out into uh the the hobby at large would you say that you are seeing success with that particularly with votes for women and if not what do you do next what's the next move I I think we are starting to see
success particularly with folks for women um so we had a fairly small print run 3600 games um and but that's because I was getting a little nervous I'm like well this resonate I thought it would but um you know I've been a pretty small Kickstarter because short as tripley hadn't been published when we did the kickstarter for votes for women so there was no Fort Circle way that people could could point to um and I think that if you judge by like the reviews of more mainstream publication you know NPR is talking about votes for women polygon and you know some of the video game uh mostly uh Publications are talking about what's room and so that's nice to see um the sales partially as a failure on our part because we're not in distribution yet although we have those Agreements are under discussion it sort of depends on source so like our local store has it was the best-selling game in March which was women's History Month um and so there's obviously an ability for it to be a good seller but you know it's taking us a little time to build those relationship with retailers and you know distributors in our industry are are hesitant to take um take on new Publishers if they only have one or two games in their library but now they're all knocking on our drawers so you know we'll we'll evaluate that as we go forward um and what's really surprised me is even though both of our first two games are really fundamentally American
history uh the demand from overseas has been really strong both um in the Asia Pacific region and in from Europe so you know that that makes me you know rethink we made a small error in votes for women and that we use the state postal codes for each state and didn't think to include in a a chart that explains like SC is South Carolina and Mt is Montana uh because we thought it'd just be mostly Americans playing it and so you know in the second printing now we're gonna we already put up a sheet on Board Game Geek that has the state abbreviations um so uh you know we do fix our mistakes but um yeah but it's really exciting that it seems to have that the approach that we're taking is resonating because uh you know I I just recently turned down a design about D-Day that I think is actually a great design and I think it'll do really well it's a designer who has a couple has signed a few games but you know kind of like in between between a new designer and an established designer and I think it's going to be great but I just didn't I couldn't make it fit within our line because it wasn't it wasn't quite historical enough and also there's you know 50 games on D-Day 100 games 200 I don't know how many games on D-Day and so um yeah I think we're trying to find new things that Engage New audiences so yeah nice so speaking of engaging audiences
uh okay so the way that I first came to know about you and about your work is that you have a reputation on the street as that guy who's very generous with review copies yeah thinking about review copies like hand over fist and all of us in you know media land Know It uh and so I guess my question is has it been worth it and where did you come to that philosophy because I've dealt with Publishers who are super stingy with a few copies people who are super free with review copies like where why did unit falling where you did on the Spectrum and has it paid off so if you buy a GMT game you mostly know what you're going to get or a compass game or a game from Milton Bradley right like they have an established brand Fort Circle does not have an established or did not at least have an established brand and so I calculated it out of that I would give away probably a thousand games you know and like summer donations and schools or whatever but like it makes sense because so if I if let's say you're a reviewer you have a very small Channel and I send you one game well shorts Tripoli cost about twelve dollars to get here well with art and stuff what's called 15 and then I send it to you and say that's another 15 uh so that's thirty dollars but if I sell a game and a half at from our website that I've basically paid for sending you that game and so when am I out by doing that well if I made my money back because you introduced our game to one and a half
more people then it's just a net net but then if that those people buy another game or another game or another game then you know now we have a customer and you know it it warms my heart when I see someone come on and board order both votes from insurance Trip Lee at the same time I'm like yes because like that's someone who's bought into the fact that we're making interesting history games so um yeah so I don't see why it makes sense not to send a copy to almost anyone there's a couple that I've regretted there was someone who you know I S just gave shorts or Tripoli of five and votes for Roman six on Board Game Geek I had sent uh the reviewer one of each they played votes for sure Tripoli once didn't review it and uh traded it away according to their Board Game Geek and then they give votes for him in a six which I'm like all right you're not for us and so I probably won't send like now I know that Reviewer is not in sync with what we value in a game so I'm not going to probably send that review another game in the future right and it's not and I don't mind if the review is negative or not but it's that they just don't appreciate the direction of what we're trying to do and so I'm like so I'm gonna be slightly more judicious but you know I send review copies to Hungary and Romania and I have no idea if that pays off but a I don't want to like I want to make sure that people in other parts of the world know we care about them as Gamers I mean I
know that sounds a little silly but like that it just seems to be you know a good corporate sense and and as long as they're engaging in the gate with the games in uh in a way that is you know in good faith even if they don't like the game I'll keep sending them games because that's one thing I worry about is like people say oh I have to think that oh I have to give a good review for you to keep getting review copies and no I mean the Washington Post gets books from Simon Sean and Simon Schuster and even if you know the post or the New York Times Booker or the booker New York Review of Books slams a particular book by them they're going to keep getting review copies of the next books because that's just the way a normal healthy industry works and so you know as long as I think that reviewers are at least engaging with the the games in a good faith manner then they should just keep getting games whether or not the reviews are positive or not so interesting yeah I think that you know I don't want to talk about our current meta at the day this is recorded but um you know as usual the discussion of money and media creation and all that um has re-emerged and I guess this just makes me want to ask you so I know as a publisher you have paid for some Services uh you have bought a tutorial of us where I'm in from me yes um but you've also paid you know plenty of other people for you know tutorials for previews for leverage and I know you
send copies as well so I guess what just what has been the correlation between money spent and what you get back and then what are you finding worth it so I should clarify we only paid for one video for the shores of Tripoli which was a playthrough video we've paid for three playthrough videos of votes for or tutorial for I guess because you did two tutorials yes and then we had another tutorial in playthrough and that was the goal of that is to reach multiple audiences but we've never paid for anything other than that oh and then when we ran the shores of Tripoli tournament um I hired Zilla Blitz to help me like do Recaps of how the tournament is going and he was obviously paid for his time for doing that but that wasn't reviews but it was I guess related to the event and so we would never pay for a preview we would never pay for a review um because that's not how professional reviewing Works whereas if we're hiring someone to make a tutorial that's very different or like you know in our games we actually say like go to a URL to come look at how to play the game we think that you know different you know a big Mantra of what we say is different people learn differently and so that's why if you want to learn historical game or if you want to learn something about history right you can read a book you can go to a lecture you can play a game like there's lots of different ways to uh learn and similarly people learn board
games differently some people can read a rule book and they get it some people like to have a tutorial so people like to have a short tutorial or a long tutorial and so you know we want to make sure that our games are accessible to as many people as possible because they have different learning styles that they should be able to access it um there is no way that like there's no chance that the money that we've spent on paying for tutorials pays for itself in the sense that that's generated sales but that's not what how we should evaluate it similarly you know we pay a copy Editor to make sure we don't have glaring horrific typos well the copy editor doesn't sell more games but the copy editor like a a tutorial sets a standard of of of what you can expect from one of our games so you can learn it you know it's gonna the copy editor make sure there's high quality the top development work make sure like the game works there's not broken parts of it and then the tutorial along with a well-written rule book means that people can understand how to play the game and that's just a cost of good and so it's not a marketing expense I don't think of it as a marketing expense at all I don't I don't even quantify it as such I want to account for it that's a cost of good whereas sending out review copies that's marketing right if that makes does that distinction make sense yeah you know it's interesting I I turn it differently mainly because I can see review copies as marketing for you I
really dislike it when people tell media that they account as compensation because I don't think the Washington Post or the New York Times think so yeah yeah exactly so like you know we come at it from different angles right but I think that you're right um I guess you know I just think it's very interesting to hear you say it though because in a world where we typically think oh well you know it's just given that Publishers who want their games to do really well are going to pay previewers to make all the previews it seems like that is not something that you've had to do no and and I I certainly understand like there's a natural uh at you know inclination to be skepticism or cynicism but I don't think that's true and I I think that the reviewers that I respect and like the best or don't have that reputation but maybe that's because you know maybe there's a maybe there's a relationship between those two things so like damn throw I actually probably do not have a very similar attitude about games I like to dance through I think he enjoys more avant-garde things I enjoy things that are a little more rooted like I can definitely tell there's distinctions about what we appreciate in a game but a damn throw review I'm gonna take to heart because I understand that he is engaging with the game in a critical manner that is interesting and important and so while my might not always agree with him I know that is a top-notch top quality definitely ethical review and I
think there's a number of of reviewers like that and I could list them I don't know like what's the point right but I think we can all think of several people like that um and so I don't have any expectation that those reviews are bought and and nor did I before I was a publisher right obviously you know there is a you know radio went through its Paola system in the United States and certainly you know I'll be honest so polygon wrote an excellent review of votes for women and I saw just on our Amazon and per and website that we sold on the day that review came out about five thousand dollars worth of games more than we would sell on a normal day and I also know I got calls from reviewer or from Source saying hey we need more games this review came out which sold out a bunch and so like there's certainly value to a review that gets a wide audience um but I don't I don't even know I don't think it I don't think it pays off to like like a dice tower review doesn't move the needle for the most part you know a review from you I mean great and like we see some increase in sale but it's not like it's not game changing polygon has really been the only uh review that's really been game changing you know I know if the guys from the players Aid review something like I'm gonna see 10 15 sales that day right and that's good but like it's not worth it to try I mean I don't
think that the economics makes sense to be buying reviews like that now maybe in these massive miniature games you know Kingdom Death monster kind of stuff maybe there's enough money flowing and the costs of the games are so much that maybe it makes sense but I I just I just don't see it all from the Publisher's side you know Essa I say YouTube like I see a ton of content creators and I get that like this seems like a fun thing to do but like it's actually like you've got to be good at and it's hard to make money at it and so you know I mean I'm appreciative of the hard work that people do but like I don't know I just I don't know there's a lot of people who want to be game board game reviews because it seems really cool and then I don't think they realize that it's a lot of work and then when they realize it's a lot of work I think someone get frustrated I don't know I don't know I'm it's something I it's not a skill set I have so yeah and I mean of course I comment from different perspective and you know obviously I can't review your games anymore really I can cover them but I can't I don't feel ethical reviewing them because at this point our business is combined yeah yeah like and even more you know for example you know absolutely talk about how I feel about a chip Theory game I'm An established chip three fan girl and they've paid me for tutorials as well I disclosed that at the start of a video immediately um but you know as you get deeper in the industry you know it's the the number of things that you can
ethically review decreases yeah well and it's such a small industry I I so this is a total non-sequiturer but I trust me it really comes around so you know I coached College debate and for lots of reasons declining College budgets that Community shrank from in the 90s to now like probably it's 20 of what it was size-wise right and so there's only so many schools and people go undergrad here and then they go to graduate school here and at some point like how can you be judging debate rounds like there's all these ethical and then you like might teach at a camp in the summer to get like and so there's all these ethical entanglements because it's such a small community that makes it really difficult and I I think that the board game industry is a little bit wider but you know when people straddle jobs so like you were just a reviewer but now you're a reviewer and a designer and that changes your relationship with the industry you're fine I mean I'm you're fine with all the other but now you have a professional economic relationship with Fort Circle yeah of course you can't review our games now that makes sense so yeah um yeah yeah it's just an interesting process to go through especially because everybody is so buddy buddy in the industry and I think within the kind of historical game space like we all know each other maybe we don't like each other but I generally like everyone I've had a good experience I like everybody who likes me so
but what it sounds like you're saying though is that you know all this sort of perception of money flying around everywhere and it being really really key and all of that is not exactly the truth that like no you don't need to go drop four thousand dollars on a video or something like that in order to make your game survive no um you're better just spending that four thousand dollars sending a review copy to every reviewer who will take it um and and I I should caveat as I'm talking about you know our branch in the industry where you know ten thousand twenty thousand copies is really good sales right when you get to the hundred thousand two hundred thousand right those are different numbers I don't know like all right you know yeah I'm not talking about that because I don't have any real experience with that but in the kind of you know a good like you know I think votes ruined by the time it's all said and done we'll probably sell 25 000 copies over kind of a five year and then there will be like a a small residual tale uh going out that's great for us that's a huge hit as far as I'm concerned but it's you know it's nothing to asmode and it's nothing to obviously to Milton Bradley you know Hasbro um it's nothing to wizards the coast Hasbro um so uh yeah so I'm talking about the the I don't think we're at the lowest end of the tier like we're not like 500 uh
print run but you know 5000 print runs that's sort of where we're at maybe we'll grow a little bit depending on as we grow and as you know we have known designers publishing things but um yeah so then the next question I guess is like do you want to grow oh yeah like I mean did you what's what's the ambition versus what I think you can achieve you know I'm so curious I I was having this discussion with Jason Matthews and uh I think that reasonably keeping the same high quality of work you know the development work and I think that I can publish four games a year like one a quarter at that rate um I probably need to have one or two more graphic designers that I like working with like I love Mark rodrigue who does all the maps uh Bridget Delicato has done a lot of stuff on votes for weight in particular for us like I love working with both of them it would be nice to develop a handful more of like like people who like I can like I don't like we're just on the same page and that's really helpful that really makes the that process better if we were trying to get to eight games a year you know then I would definitely probably need to bring on someone who handled more of the logistics because like I handle all the customer service I make sure everything gets shipped where it needs to get like I do all of that um so
you know I'm not saying like I'm a hero I'm a one person you know like obviously I get help from My Wife and we hire you know a copy we hire lots of people who are you know arms like uh 1099 employees to do a lot of stuff but um you know I'm only one person and I'm in my you know I'm 51 I'm almost 52. I don't move at the same speed that I did when I was 22 or 32 and so I I maybe we could do eight games here maybe six I maybe I could do six and maybe like if you know my wife came on full time to help me instead of uh doing her job but you know we want to make sure the company's really safe before we did something like that or you know bring on a logistics person to run a warehouse for me and handle some of the customers I don't know so yeah so but I you know I'm averse to doing that in in a previous life I had a tech company and I hired willy-nilly because I needed people quickly and I had you know 25 people and now I don't want that I don't want 25 employees so but if I had one or two people I had to bring on so we could make six eight games here I'm sure I'd do that interesting so um at what point would you consider for a circle to be stable and how do you know that you're at that point how do you set that goal well we're not it's we're not not stable right now but it's not a quite uh it doesn't support a full-time lifestyle right like you know it's still not a it's not generating that much money uh I think it needs to you know I
think that probably 15 000 games a year if that's what we're selling that sort of meets the kind of threshold that I think is uh you know and and we have a number of titles so if we have one title that we over print and we have to sit on some stock but we you know that doesn't put the company in precarious situation cash flow-wise like and that just happens with time and and breadth right of titles and you know we're only selling two games right now that's still really small um so yeah I'm actually hoping that we can check in again in like another two years and see how that's gone because I'm very curious about it yeah uh and then you know you talk about kind of expecting votes from and have about a five-year major lifespan um what what is the lifespan of a board game I feel like some of them just flash the pan and disappear for my Consciousness utterly for like a month and then others last longer well it depends obviously and what we've tried to do is we've tried to do to pick games that would have a constituency outside of the kind of core Gamers that there are so the shortage of Tripoli still sells as well today as it did when it came out but that's because uh the Marine Corps uses it it's one of the games that the Marine Corps Association sends out to units uh it's used in the classroom at the Naval Academy and at several other schools
um there's just a natural like people are interested in the history of the Navy and the Marine Corps who aren't Gamers but it's an accessible enough game that they'll plant so I expect that we'll sell between 500 and a thousand copies of the shortest triplet every year for the next 10 years and votes for women you know as I don't think it'll be done with sales five years that's but I was just trying to say like over a five-year period and then it'll be a tail that lays out and I think votes room will probably be a little more than that it'll probably be more like a thousand fifteen hundred games here because there's always people interested in voting history and you know as political issues rise and fall there's more interest in it there's always people who are in you know women's studies or history like there's a constituent of people interested in the topic outside of the gaming community that that yet because the game is accessible because it has excellent tutorials because there's not a bunch of typos that people are like oh I can pick this up and learn it and so I think that that it will continue to sell a thousand fifteen hundred games after its initial big rush which is you know this year and next year so um right yeah actually yeah yeah yeah it does and then I guess I want to ask since we've talked a lot about marketing and the kinds of things you're doing what is the number one investment that you have made in your game so far that you think is the best choice ah I don't know like it because it depends on like is is a copywriter an investment
is spending an extra 50 cents in production for historical documents an investment and I don't I don't know like they're all pieces of that but like you know I have a pretty clear vision of what I want our games to look like and I want them to look good and be interesting and draw people in and and especially draw you know not hardcore Gamers or not war gamers in like I want you know the more casual hero gamer and so you know it's a total investment of what goes into the box how we're reaching out to people you know our Partnerships with Charities that introduces the game to new people uh like and so I've never really like I don't think you can but I'm but I haven't even tried to say like all right by including 14 historical documents we have increased sales by X like that's not I don't think that can be done and that's not how I approach it instead I'm like all right let's make this product the highest quality that we can make it and trust that that will be rewarded in the marketplace and early indications are that it is so is there anything that you have just stopped doing because you decided that it was Dumb and didn't work no not really um like I said there's a few like there's a handful of reviewers who just like our games aren't for them and that's okay I won't send them games and
they probably won't ask and that's okay um no now that sounds really no regrets regrets or regrets no I'm I'm pretty pleased at what we're doing like literally the only thing I wish is I wish that uh pandemic hadn't held up the production of votes for women so we could be a little bit further along in the process but other than that I'm super happy so that's awesome that's a question which I think a little bit different with marketing than what you typically see in the board game Space so you talk a lot about reaching people who aren't typical board gamers um you are making sure that you're sending copies to different sorts of outlets like you know polygon like IGN um you know the Washingtonian what do you think that that is going to become something that people more typically do is that you thing uh you know I hope nobody else does it and only we do it because you know we sort of have a monopoly on this uh no like hey I think I think if our mission is to widen the scope of historical gaming than if we're only talking to the same people then we're not fulfilling that mission to widen the scope of historical gaming and so that's why right like we reached out to NPR we reach out to um Washingtonian
um I have really high hopes that closer to Christmas uh or the holidays that the New York Times is going to have a story about votes for women and you know and those discussions have begun now and like I just think that these are the kind of things that if we want our industry to be taken seriously then we should be talking to more than just ourselves um when I turned 50 I set a goal for myself by the time I turned 75 that there's a Pulitzer Prize for historical board gaming that is a unlikely to be achieved a goal but like why not like these are these games are works of art at some level and and deserve to be treated as such and and if we're not going to treat them with respect then why should anybody else so let's go out and let's broaden that interest this kind of leads me to a final real question before we do like wrap up softies which is so you're a businessman and that is you know you want your business to be successful you also have a lot of very dream like ideas right about what can that's not bad though it's like about what can happen with like a Pulitzer Prize or let's take historical games seriously their works of art how much of your decision making is business motivated and then how much of it is just something that you just want to bring into the world creatively I mean you know the amount of cash flow
certainly is a check on any dreams they get too wild uh so you know most I think I think the decisions are rooted in a business perspective because I think a broader Market more people buying our games is good for us I think that's you know self-evident and it's more of what are the methods to do that and there are certain things we could do like we could start making Fantasy games that whatever that would probably sell 10 times better but I'm not going to do that because that's not a space that I know and I'm all that interested in I mean I respect it but it's not it's not what I want to be doing um you know if I wanted to just make money I would not be in the board game Space um so I mean obviously there's some aspect of you know I'm in a space that I love but if it's a hobby then it's gonna be done at less better quality and not as serious it's not going to be as good as I would like it to be and so I have to approach it like a business I have to make business decisions I tend to err on the side of quality because I think that you know I can if let's say so in in Halls Montezuma right we're gonna have recruiting posters and newspaper stories and all kinds of cool things uh we have we have essays from both Mexican-American and an American on
viewpoints on the war like really try to give it all that good flavor and value you know how much more is that going to cost I don't know five thousand dollars maybe when it's all said and done but how much more valuable is that game how much more willing people will engage in it because that's in there so you know it's hard to measure exactly how much you know like we're not going to put 500 historical documents in there because I'm you know that's silly right but so like trying to find that right sweet spot of what is the product that we feel good about that we think will engage people you know is a process right what was in votes for women is different than what's in uh the shows of Tripoli and you know it's going to change over time we're going to find what that right sweet spot is you know you'd actually ask to find any regrets yes I wish I would have put more historical documents in the shorts Tripoli but I didn't have the full conviction that people would be interested in that so we put one just to test it out and there that was a mistake that I wish we did that's a regret second printing there's always the second printing oh yes and there will have to be and so yeah and we'll also probably uh you know we'll add a couple nice things just to make it worth buying so heck yeah all right so what are you playing right now for fun uh what is your Dune Imperium count and then what else are you playing for fun oh my God the duty perium count is super high so my wife and I started tracking in a app tracker with uh rise of IX and that's actually not that much that came out
this year and we weren't we aren't playing nearly as much as when we were doing the academic so that's why I'm looking down so we have played only this year only yeah well this is just one since X has come out we've only played that 196 games but we had played um the base game before X came out and especially during the pandemic when we weren't didn't have so much to do during the day uh we played that over 600 times and so you know that's a fun game to play um I really want my wife to play this game Union Stockyards that just came out um because I think there are a couple of things that the designer is doing that's neat in the game um but I you know you gotta play it to see if that's true but it's about slaughtering cows and pigs and sheeps and so I don't know that she's really jazzed to play it um but she'll give in I hope uh we're gonna be playing terraforming Mars in two weeks with another couple that we like playing games with um we'll probably play more games in the summer you know during the school year a lot is tied up with her daughter and so we don't play quite as much um but the British way just came littoral Commander just came but I'll probably play those with Jason Matthews not with my wife um I don't know what else is coming oh wow yeah and of course we're working on going to guanaguano but uh those discussions are hush-hush for now so but I'm very excited I actually I honestly
believe that will be our best-selling game more than even you know the magic of you and David Thompson with the night witches I think that's gonna sell very well too uh but I think Guana gonoguano just just I just think that that one's gonna be a home run I'm just gonna reiterate my desire for squishy poop tokens yes well I think that uh my wife does not want squishy poop tokens but but those can be a separate purchase so uh add-on yes so and and I I sort of share for her concerns about squishy group tokens but I think they're cool also so we'll see so fantastic and if you want to find you I mean obviously I'm gonna link everything in the shin nuts but where can you be found online um I'm Fort Circle at Twitter um I'm just Kevin Bertram on Facebook but I'm not on there as much um and then the fort Circle website so fort circle.com fantastic all right Kevin thank you so much for letting me take up some of your time on a Sunday morning to talk about business uh it's always good to hear from you oh it's a pleasure all right so hopefully we'll check in again about this in a couple more years like track the progress but for now everybody please like subscribe comment uh ask questions and most of all happy gaming
good