The REAL Gloomhaven 2.0 | Reviewing the Crimson Scales
Transcript
hello welcome to gualou thank you for being here today we're bringing you a first impressions of the Crimson scales specifically The Trail Of Ashes but the cryson scales system as a whole the single biggest most ambitious fan-made board game expansion board game project that has ever existed if you don't believe me when I say that here's a few stats to keep in mind this is a fully printed published created project they sold and delivered at cost with no profit going to anyone involved in the project a total of 8,000 copies two successful printings a Miniatures expansion metal token upgrades cuz well they had the budget for it an art book a big box campaign the size and scale of the original game and on top of that there has been a amazing substantial demand for a third printing which at the moment doesn't look like it's going to happen primarily because Gloom Haven's off doing other things a second printing a mapbook they're being weird and wild and we're going to get to that at the end of this video I am personally shocked that this is not a official printed they don't need to do it for a profit no one else in this
project did why is this not printed published and for sale on the Gloom Haven store if you have a community of people that are this insane about your product yeah I don't know we'll get to those hot details in a moment all right we're on we're set up for scenario 3 in The Trail Of Ashes campaign we've played through quite a bit I am familiar with jaws of the lion Gloom Haven Frost Haven and Crimson scales in the past the more big box expansion but never as a campaign the most I've played as a campaign is actually the digital version of Gloom Haven the rest of it has all been sporadic most of the time like this yeah someone comes over that knows Gloom Haven very well they set up we play through four or five scenarios and then they leave yeah you however I have played I I've avoided the digital I've never played the digital and I've got some my groups have suggested why don't we just do the digital it's so much easier I'm like no this is a board game and my whole point is to get people together I have played Gloom Haven I started it got halfway through it co happened reset did Jaws of the lion all the way through to completion um you know back to Gloom Haven again restarted because we didn't remember anything that had happen and you know playing through and we're almost done with Gloom Haven uh you know original Gloom Haven um I have CL Crimson scales this is my first time you're one of the original backers supporters the second second wave yep second wave with trail of bashes with the Miniatures I went all in on that
thing um once I saw what this thing did and what was involved uh you know I was getting my first impression the magnitude of this game this you know expansion it's amazing it's it's such a an indepth well thought out the story lines the character development the balancing this is a Gloom Haven game absolutely through and through and it's just the magnet of it is phenomenal and that was one of the reasons why I backed it yeah I it's it's a pretty incredible thing I I mean the community that is behind this is a group of DieHard Gloom Haven fans right these are these are the people that lived on Discord and on BGG Board Game Geek and on Reddit and built communities built private servers and communities around designing creating and expanding this universe one of the leads of this m eisenbach uh who is a close friend of mine uh but a close friend of mine through Crimson scales I met him because he produced this and from there I've grown to admire respect and uh really just genuinely appreciate the guy and the man and the work that he does but this is the foundation this is where I came across this Insanity I I've never met the guy and I only know him you know through your stories here in these last couple days I was already impressed with him based based on the passion that he put into this project a nonprofit
project at that it just speaks volumes to someone's you know involvement in our community our board game Community the dedication their hardworking nature their selflessness to do this much work holy cow okay so let's set up what First Impressions I don't want too long of a video we are working right now on a series of gameplay videos we are like I said we've set up episode 3 I'll cycle through the cameras so you can see like how ridiculous we're trying to make this I mean six full cameras filming this process stay tuned get excited we're going to have we're going to have at least 10 episodes before you go home uh and then you're scheduled to come back so if people respond if they engage if they enjoy the content we're going to keep filming producing and Diving through Trail Of Ashes is something like 22 Episodes yeah and my goal my Mark is to over the course of this next year this is one of the games I wanted to obsess over so over the course of this next year I like to at least get Trail Of ases Ashes filmed produced and displayed on the channel absolutely absolutely let's talk about our first impressions though let's talk about where we are right now when it comes to what Crimson what we're noticing about Crimson scales what it's doing well and right what we're expecting or anticipating going forward um my my overwhelming theme of first impression is it feels just like Gloom Haven it's Gloom Haven there are new conditions there are new uh characters um there's obviously all newly drawn out
scenarios it is the challenge of the scenario the way the game plays how the conditions are affecting you know even the new conditions it feels just like Gloom Haven one of the things that for me is a Hallmark of Gloom Haven as experience is how you get to the very end of a scenario and you're right there about to lose and Crimson scale so far has hit that te every time I've played it previously we've played the last two scenarios it has been a pucker of a finish every single time and we're just like we're not even focused on playing the game or no we're not even focused on filming the video we're just sitting here enjoying playing the game Talking laughing bantering it feels like I'm sitting down and playing Gloom Haven for the right reasons for the right reasons and and with a new Twist on the mechanics engine with a new Twist on the characters and with a little bit more fun and complexity like I feel like you can feel the love and creativity by the people who designed this because they're they're people who finished the campaign themselves and then went back to obsess over it and there's just something unique about for instance Frost Haven M there is something unique about the way Crimson scales feels like a love letter and the way Frost Haven feels like it's trying to reent the wheel it doesn't want to be a copycat it doesn't want to it it wants to be Gloom Haven but it wants to be its own thing Crimson scales makes no attempt to do that yeah it just
says hey you love this game we loved this game we finished it why don't we do more more of that why don't we give you more of that yeah the balance is identical the game feels and matches the print quality and design of all of this I mean look at these player boards the artwork was paid for and hired by uh you know the team behind this right they didn't take profit to pay for this artwork this was commissioned before they even started doing an official Printing and it's the same artist it's the same Artist as original Gloom Haven so stylistically someone could walk into the room right now and they would have no idea that this was not core base game Gloom Haven absolutely I mean you know tokens tiles printing artwork cards new characters there's a couple and I don't think it's one of these but uh there's new character attack modifier decks you you can't tell the difference it's all seamless it's just like a just it's just more Gloom Haven and I don't have any problem with more Gloom Haven in fact I want more more Gloom Haven the only thing that I've seen that is a slight difference is some of the cards like you can see right here the print quality is a little bit different and the reason being the reason being because I didn't notice it slightly it's slightly different no not that the ink oh the ink I was say the cards are identical and and the reason being is because for any company anywhere it
is n impossible to get exactly the same ink print from one printing to another you've seen you've seen uh companies that have put out a second printing of their game M those cards don't match the first expansion cards struggle with this really hard because if you just want to incorporate a few simple Cards into or an upgrade into your core base game yeah cardbacks have to match and uh that's a terrifying that's a terrifying problem or you just get customized sleeves and you hide that the story here feels like a love letter to Gloom Haven and feels like a group of people that wanted to just have fun and move forward with it and I find that interesting because original Gloom Haven was never about the story like I I haven't sat down and played Gloom Haven and thought to myself I'm excited to come back to see what happens next in the chapter I've thought that scenario was a lot of fun and challenging my character is cool and I love the mechanics yeah now I could be wrong I again I I play through story I'm not as deep as you are into the story so I could be missing this but from what I've seen online as well there's a universal opinion that if you want storytelling in your game Gloom Haven's not where you go there are better storytelling Campaign games out there there's no question about that but I do appreciate even in the bass Bloom Haven you know the storyline to it and I I also have the for teller so all the audio and like that so we'll we really get immersed in it and you know I put it on the you know the good speakers and all that stuff right I'm just I'm just
enjoying the narrative that's being told here I'm having fun with it absolutely I mean the core of Gloom Haven is mechanics are amazing the balance is amazing The tension's Amazing you don't you don't know how you're going to get through the scenario and somehow you figure out a way and you do it um that is exact it's identical yeah this is identical to that yeah it's just new conditions new characters and another big thing for me when it comes to just like my general First Impressions like what we've seen and experienced so far I haven't came across a design Choice whether it's a mechanic's Choice whether it's an enemy AI deck whether it's either of our characters that we're playing or any of the new items we have access to I haven't came across a design choice that doesn't make sense I agree with that and I pick up on these things a lot because I'm a thematic first player I I I will notice if something doesn't match a character I will not if a mechanics engine doesn't fit into the larger scope of what's being done and I haven't came across something right now that feels off-kilter or feels off balance or feels like it's taking me out or jarring me out of the game here's an example of where there's a design choice that actually enhances the experience you get poison in base Gloom Haven poison that's it it's it's it is what it is it doesn't stack here you've got an ability and some characters can do a poison three or a wound to and there's different numbers you can do poison two things of that sort but it's like wow I that was you know I'm sure there's a great reason to not have it in the base
game but the fact that they made that adjustment and it works as if it should have been there all the time and I don't I haven't like you said I have not had a moment where I went that's weird that's odd that's not like my Gloom Haven that I've played so many times or every time doesn't fit into a game in general right I'm I'm just playing through and it's it's just like getting more Gloom Haven and I said it a minute ago and I'll say it again more Gloom Haven is a good thing here's the other thing you're playing a character MH where I think the love language and the cool thing about fans designing this stands out yeah more than anything there the Fire Knight so for me it's got personal significance um you know I am a firefighter up in Michigan and this right here the character the cards some of the abilities you know we got an ability called forcible entry right that's where we go grab a set of irons in the real world and you know the door's locked and we need to get through it for whatever reason we can get through that door and you know hit hit hit drive drive and in the door we go right so that's that's something that I really appreciate is how this this character designed by a firefighter um hit the nail on the head and it's just to incorporate into the mechanics of this game and to see that it it's just another you keep reading things or getting cards and being like hey by the way this card yeah you never go in alone
yeah what we don't have is the lift assist card every firefighter knows you know we don't have the lift assist card we just go help somebody up off the floor it might be there it might be it might you might yeah it might be a level n it could be a really powerful heal right it's all you do every day basically you fall down I come pick you up any other any other big notes any other big First Impressions I'm really really excited to be bringing the gameplay here I'm thrilled that you and I are playing that we have another like day and a half or two days to sit and film and and just dive head first into this we're going to have a wild amount of content here on the channel so please stay tuned subscribe all the nonsense that we beg of you because it it makes like there's there's no way to explain to people how impactful those little actions are until they're behind a camera filming and trying to make their own content absolutely any other little things you have though when it comes to I mean we've covered it all for me it was the you know the the magnitude of the expansion how it feels like Gloom Haven the balancing the challenge and everything like that it just it's so seamless so here's my hot take M and I we I've mentioned this a little bit to you but I'm curious what your what your thoughts or opinion is going to be I don't understand I can't think of a business reason I can't think of a human reason I I do not understand why Seth lefair has not endorsed self-published hosted sold encouraged they've been involved they
did do the open IP they've allowed their their fans to create with their assets they've allowed their so I don't want to I don't want to take away from what they've done they've done something very few Publishers do they opened the door to their fans using their assets to create this world but when you have fans that create this world yeah go to this degree that that produce this type of insanity I want to see more people get access to this that's all like I want to see the creators of this rewarded I want to see people celebrated no one's making money on this right not a scent not a scent has been made by anyone people have spent hours days months of their life thousands of personal dollars from a number of different creators have been invested in bringing something like this to life and we just got news that there's likely not going to be a third printing to me I think and I feel like it's a disservice to all of the people that love Gloom Haven enough to make this that seair doesn't follow the lead of like doesn't set the lead as other companies other companies like Tuesday night games with their Mothership RPG series which which is an award-winning like globally recognized RPG system gives their their Community permission to use their rule set which is the copyrightable thing to create their own Mothership scenarios rules guidelines
expansions and they host on their website the the content available for people to get to download to purchase they they they encourage these creators to print create and then they Warehouse ship out and and celebrate right and in in this situation sepher has had to like they it's like they've tried to dance a fine line I here here's my take on it um this is where I come from the the fact that seair allowed this to exist I thought was an impressive decision and you acknowledge that I don't want to take away from that you figure you know the number of years M mty eisenbach and the team directly worked with Isaac not on any design but they double checked that they had permission and they they did all the account work NE they they they they worked hand in hand that takes a lot of trust if if you if I was Isaac and I'm got you know fans want to create some content and it exists out in the BGG forums and it's print and play stuff it's like okay that's one thing it's very different from this it's very different from this very different from this incredibly different and to trust the baby that you created it's spent years in development of trying to create Gloom Haven and to trust that somebody can bring this level of quality of the market and say all right I trust I think you can do this and I'm going to let you do it that that's no one for the record thought 8,000 copies would sell by the way the first printing I believe was 1500 or 2,000 after seeing it I'm surprised it wasn't more that's why
right now the third printing if they had one would would double that amount in a day absolutely so my hope is that right now you know Frost Haven's deliver you know I think it's all fully delivered FR delivered I don't know about GL Haven 2.0 Gloom Haven 2.0 is you know doing its thing buttons and bugs is showing up but here's the here's the interesting point of information go ahead with your your point I've got I'm going to hope and hold out hope that they'll Circle back around find a business arrangement in which you know uh the creators of You Know M MTI and you know Isaac and everybody involved can come up with some kind of a business Arrangement everybody get into a room and figure out how to make this a profitable business decision for all parties involved that's fair and Equitable but that ultimately at the end of the day brings more Gloom Haven to people like me I don't and I'll be in in my opinion I'm even more I'm even more fair to seph theair in some ways I don't think they need to pay any of the designers any of the creators I don't think they need to recoup costs that people have invested I don't think they need to worry about any of that why because all these people loved their game enough that they did it knowing it would not make them anything at all yeah I want to see this celebrated that's all I'm petitioning for I don't want people to make money on it I don't want people to like I want it to exist and I want whatever Gloom Haven 2.0 becomes I want to see a crimson scales version yeah
available incorporable to the production quality that this is and I think the only way that ever happens is if there's demand and pressure on sethair to celebrate their Community instead of worrying about the weird legality of the issue I'm sure that's where it comes from there's an awkward legal issue here right yeah if that's the case that's just lawyers the room and figure it out or the financial bottom line oh maybe they won't sell as many base Gloom Haven but you need Bas Gloom Haven to play this right here's the other point that I was going to make gloomhaven 2.0 it's not designed or improved by Isaac it's designed and improved by the Reddit mods those are the new creators of it buttons and bugs isn't designed and created by Isaac it's designed by another member of their community they're already working with people who are doing this they're already acknowledging them they're already celebrating them I I just don't want this to get overlooked yeah it's so cool it's so cool to see it I mean I've purchased fan-made stuff before you know what you know fan-made stuff gets you for about $150 cardboard tokens with soot residue around the outside A nice bright note letting you know that you'll get your whole game dirty if you order it and printed cards that genuinely look good but this this is $150 of fan created
content not the boxes we just held up not Miniatures not the scale and scope of Gloom Haven Crimson scale it's so impressive I I'm blown away at how good and how perfect this is and seamlessly fits into the Gloom Haven Universe it's amazing yeah one of the reasons why we're filming all of this content is because the original Creator the the pile driver of crimson scales M eisenbach and quite a few members of the team even Beyond him he was the primary designer and and orchestrator of all this they have currently launched their first ever board game inspired by the Gloom Haven Universe with a quote on the page from himself saying he wants more games like Ro in the world so they're celebrating it it's got a new mechanics engine it's not it's got uh cool new story it's an ethereal world I have a picture of it here it's live over on Kickstarter right now we're doing the gameplay we're diving head first into this we're celebrating talking about and highlighting everything that Crimson scales is because it's the exact reason why you should support back and help the people who made this create their own project yep um I've played the game it's excellent uh I'm very very excited to get my hands on it it is different enough from Gloom Haven that it won't feel like a rehash it is similar enough to Gloom Haven that if you enjoy Gloom Haven you will enjoy Rove period so swing over to the kickstarter
give them a little bit of love and support even if you just back for a dollar and tell them that you appreciate what they've done for our community and uh yeah I mean I guess if Isaac and the SE air team see this uh hi Isaac yeah I mean they can do what they want ultimately and and and they should do what is good for business I'm sure there's a lot of information that I don't have yep I think supporting and celebrating you know the heart of your company which is the Crimson scales team I think that's always the right thing for business I don't want to see this get in Fall Into Obscurity yeah yeah I mean I like I said I got my copies so I'm happy but I think the there's no copies left there's no copies left I I mean I have mine I'm just saying like like that's like what's out there is out there yeah and at the moment that's how it'll be all right thanks for watching we're going to go to bed and get up early in the morning and continue playing through this nonsense whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing go your own fan content I mean it can't be that that difficult right yeah no I think you can knock this out in an afternoon right at least yeah if not a couple couple afternoons I don't know that's that's asking a lot no a couple games a couple games in oh that's fair get a final girl expansion get a you know Crimson scales expansion or get a
get a a you know level 99 uh Millennium blades expansion going 20 more Spirit Island characters I mean I've got I've got rot that I'm working on right now like why not I mean just knock him out all right that's what we're going to do we're going to knock out expansions for every big game out there stay tuned bye