Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 14:18

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games aled and today I'm doing a discussion over undergrow the newest game by Elizabeth Hargrave of course of renowned wingspan Fame and of course this was a game that I had backed because of pretty much name alone and also the nature theme because I just really like love that genre so the game that's about mushrooms or fungi in general and to me this is about as exciting of a game about fungi as it could be like this one just I don't know it doesn't really do much for me overall I think the systems are are fine they're solid the gameplay itself is solid it gives me that General Cascadia Vibe where you are kind of manipulating a board building out your own board you sending seedlings and roots to gain access to various fungal abilities and trying to fulfill goal you know goal objectives which is kind of like how what Cascadia does with the overall goals that are out there to do and it's it's it's it's there it's a game I don't know like this one it feels

like there's like there's Elizabeth design of wingspan which is just insanely popular and has proceeded to just sell unit after unit after unit but then like everything else that's been done afterwards has either been good to okay you know there's mariposas with the butter the migration of the butterfly there's Fox experiment and then now there's this one and I feel like every time that I've played one of one of the other games I liked mariposas for what it was Fox experiment was okay and then now there's kind of this one which is not necessarily bad like I like the idea of you have these tiles and the tiles for the deluxe components um like these wood wooden tiles are very very nice but you're placing them out in this grid to then put your seedlings adjacent to a bunch of other tiles and then eventually you can place your roots utilizing resources of potassium phos phosphorus and nitrogen as well as carbon to put out more fungal tokens and then you have like this root Network which you use to absorb carbon and to activate the ab ility of most of these fungal tiles you put carbon onto them which you then absorb through your seedlings and eventually grow trees and every time you absorb carbon which is kind of the point of the game you go up on a track and once that's

kind of the timer of the game because you need to absorb carbon to be able to score the tiles adjacent to where you have roots and it's not again it's not a bad system the fact that you have access to various Powers based off where you're seeds are and where your roots are pointing and you could spend resources to pull carbon from other tiles into your seed to grow a tree and you're limited on trees but if your tree is there then you have roots to all adjacent ones and that'll score you points the uh goals that are there give you kind of a drive to get a bunch of points at the end like the bat for example is uh you move up on the track each time you make six carbon in one turn okay well that's pretty neat I don't I don't mind these goals they're double-sided for various abilities and I also really like the fact that there's like a goal tracker that's really cool for just ease of scoring the race of who can absorb the most carbon and you get a benefit each time you move up is really nice um it's it's a again not a bad game I I don't know for some reason it just didn't really work for me like you you have pretty much access to any tile that you you could theoretically want uh and then

you have access to placing roots in anywhere that you want so I never found it super compelling to try and create a network of of fungi uh like one of my tiles was the yellow tipped coral and that got two points plus a point for every adjacent yellow type mushroom okay well I happen to draw a bunch of those so that will net me a bunch of points and oh look over there that that location has four points of a fungal so I'll use my reproduce to place down and then you know put a root pointing at that one and because it's super easy to really absorb carbon you're almost guaranteed to kind of score it even though you are limited on on your trees so it it seemed like there isn't really ever hard decisions to make and because every action is pretty much easy to do yeah you can be strapped for resources but because there's like the Central Forest board you're able to always kind of get the resources you need in general anyway so it's like yeah okay I'm typed for resources oh I'll just do this one action and get those resources that I need to then place any tile that I want and just kind of start absorbing carbon it and some people might like that they might like the Casual nature it is neat for nature games and they do

in this one what I love nature games to be about is you know they have a well it's called an art guide but they have basically a fact book on every type of Mushroom in the game as well as about all of the uh the animals for the scoring which as uh nature games tend to be they're very depressing because it tells us how many of them aren't Left Alive and that's that's always fun to realize um but yeah there's the general scoring is nice the the components are great it looks great on on the board the artwork's fantastic I'm kind of torn I wish I kind of wish that some of that the art was actual photos because that's always nice when it's set in our world and these are real things that it's like oh hey there's a real photo of the the dead dead man's foot that's pretty cool but for what it is the art is very nice I think it's by Beth so no who did the art yeah art by Beth soel um so I mean that's not really that big of a deal and yeah that's that's I mean honestly that's pretty much it uh it's not a horrible system like you also have these four action tokens that pretty much to activate a type of mushroom which there are four types you have to have this available to you so even though you can get a mushroom that is a really good

ability unless you have a way to reactivate it which some which the the four starting zones allow you to do uh they hey you know flip over your red action to unflip your yellow if you want to reuse a yellow ability that you have access to it's um it it is kind of a nice Dynamic of not being able to just Spam the same action over and over and over again and eventually you have to photosynthesize which will get you your carbon it's nice that you can't get locked out of actions if you misplay or you know strip yourselves of resources it's not like you're out of the game and you have to build back up uh to just try and start playing again if you if you run out of resources you have the availability to be able to get more and hell some of the tiles the fungi that get you a bunch of resources also give other people resources so that it doesn't seem like it's meant to be a cut throw game just for some reason for me there wasn't never really a whole lot of like forward planning it's oh all right this is what the mushrooms that I want to put down now I can absorb from that some of the tiles are are really good and the goals are relatively easy to accomplish and they can let you a whole bunch of points so it could be a feel-good kind of game and I don't know many games about funy so it is a unique theme in that sense so I

don't know it's it's a weird kind of review because I don't really despise anything about the game nor do I really think it's generic I don't I'm not sitting here going well I've seen this in a million different games uh I I really haven't uh but yeah it just it wasn't this could be a mood game just kind of maybe a a puzzl kind of game that fits those other genres of the the nature theme I would probably rank this funny enough as her second best like I might well mariposas did have that puzzle of trying to go out as far as you can and then breed higher level you know mushro mushrooms uh butterflies and then come try and make it back and I do like this more than Fox experiment so I might actually put this one above mariposas I don't know yet I'd have to replay mariposas to even find out if that game still stands stands the test of time time I mean obviously it's not going above wingspan wingspan's just too good of a game it's also the one that's been the supported the most but yeah this one is an interesting feel I guess so I don't really have much to say about it like they the the component quality is is fantastic they tried to go very green

with it which for games that the one thing about going green with board games which if you're going to go green uh I'm hoping these wooden pieces are made out of like recyclable or something whatever it's made out of because it'd be funny it's like we're going green no plastic and then they're cutting down trees to make these Deluxe components um it the one thing I'm fine with you know cards coming wrapped in recyclable paper I'm fine with no plastic on whatever the one thing I hate which luckily AEG uh somehow did correct is the game didn't come wrapped in plastic which makes sense but it came with tape on the edges now I've had it to where that tape either leaves residue or it tears the tears the Box luckily this game didn't do that which is nice um but yeah that always makes me nervous it's like okay I get it we're going green but at the same time I paid money for it and I don't want my [ __ ] to be destroyed uh it's with the way that they went about it it is actually done very well like the organization with these these types of boxes for the everyone's player pieces is done and it really uh like the Box can be reorganized which is very nice and this is a really awesome first player marker with the little little

mushroom so yeah it's good but I don't love it like I'm not like wow this is Elizabeth horra just is knocking it out of the park with this one uh and maybe to some people they are but I don't know I don't know maybe maybe it's a theme overall I think it's just I realize the fungus and fungi just don't don't tickle me like like birds do or something it's it's good if you're looking for a game in this genre uh for a spatial area control kind of puzzle Resource Management goal game this is a this is a good one to grab now where does that leave me on a scale of 1 to 10 I think even though I'm just kind of like meh about it I think I'm still going to give it a seven cuz they don't really have like many complaints if really any so I do think this is a good game but I can't really put it above S7 for any any discernable reason so that's it everyone that's my thoughts on undergrove let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a one for whatever time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the

channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved