Skip to main content
Loading video...

Off with Their Heads: My Favorite Mechanism

Transcript 5:21

Hi, I'm Jamie from Stonemire Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in the game off with their head which combines something akin to trick taking with a rolling right game and a way that I really enjoyed it and actually scales really well up to four players. We played it at three and every turn of this game each player is playing a playing card from their hand simultaneously with all other players and in a three-player game the deck puts one card into play that you get to see first before you do that. So all players get to see that card always ends up basically being four cards in play for because in this game you're looking at the best card of those that are played which depends on the number on the card and also the rank of the suits at that time which changes every every turn of this game. Um you're looking at the best card, the worst card and the cards in between and that determines where you get to write things. Here is this game.

So, if you have the the top card, the best card, you will write the number based on the the number and the color of the card that you played up here on the top. If you have the worst card, you would go down here. And if you have a card in the middle, you go here. And actually, best and worst really aren't the best or aren't the best words to use for this because it is all relative to where you want to write a number. There are certain times where you like if in the game that I played, for example, I was focusing on being in the middle. And so I wanted to try to play the middle number. I was trying to guess what other players might play. I had the information about what the deck had played because we were playing a three-player game. And I was generally successful in trying ending up in the middle. If I tried really hard to end up at top, I think I could have done pretty well doing that. Same with the bottom.

You could choose a card that is clearly the one of the worst cards that could be played. And you can go ahead and play that and focus on the bottom. I think that's a pretty neat system. I want to put this game in a category of games, a growing maybe category of games where the cards that you don't use matter later on. Um, for example, uh, in fact, I specifically I was thinking games like um, oh, there's a rolling right game that that is kind of set in the Old West that does it. I'm sorry, I'm forgetting about the name right now. There is also Apostocracy which recently did it where you build this deck of cards over the course of the game and then at the end of the game you play a brief game of wis very basic trick taking with the cards that you have in this game you are setting aside two cards each round in each of the three rounds they're kind of showing it to you here at least there's five cards you're setting aside two cards per round over three rounds and at the end of that you get to score your poker hand that you have left using those cards. So, this player did a good job setting aside kings and queens. They ended up with a full house here at the end. They're going to get a bunch of points for that. And you actually get five extra points if you have the best poker hand relative to other players.

It's also a tiebreaker at the end of the game. I really like this mechanism. I like this idea of deciding which cards are really important for you to use now versus setting aside some cards to use later. Um, even as I was talking about this, I I've we've seen this used in um in a game like Dune Imperium. which cards do I play during the round and which cards do I save to use for their bottom ability at the at the end of the round? Um, you could probably think of other examples in this category, but it is it is a category that I'm really enjoying. Might talk more about that soon, but I really enjoy that mechanism and off with their heads. That decision of which cards to keep, which cards to save for later. A few other things uh mechanisms that I liked about this game. I like that it was fully simultaneous. We're not taking turns to see which cards to play. We're all playing at the same time. um that's keeps things moving at at a pretty brisk pace. There are benefits that you can get from completing I'll call them characters.

Thematically they are characters, but really they are just short-term goals saying things like complete a mushroom and then you that helps you complete a specific character that wants you to complete a mushroom up here in the top row. Um, and there there's just a nice balance of uh there's a little bit of luck, a little bit of lack of agency in the game, just enough so that the game can stay fresh. Like if you had too much control in this game and you could just always focus on one area and do exactly what you wanted in this area, I think it would feel sy. But you don't quite have that much control. you just have just enough control to be able to f to kind of be steer the game steers you in a slight direction even as you then are trying to steer in that direction from then on. It's hard for me to describe that a little bit but I I think the simultaneous play of the cards and this best worst middle system um helps to add it helps to keep the game fresh because you don't have quite complete control over the outcome of each individual turn. But yeah, overall lot of good mechanisms in Off of Their Heads. And I particularly enjoyed the uh the decision of which cards to play now versus which cards to save for that poker hand at the end of the game. That's Off of Their Heads. I'd love to hear your favorite thoughts and mechanisms. If you can think of any other games that do this thing where they're asking you, okay, do you want to play this now or do you want to kind of set it aside to use later?

Apistocracy is granted a little bit different than that because you are you are building towards something at the end of the game similar to a poker hand, this mini game of wis, but you are not choosing which cards to set aside in that game. So maybe it's a little bit out of that out of that category. But yeah, let me know your thoughts in the comments below. Thank you.

Progress saved