Skip to main content
Loading video...

Canvas Finishing Touches Review - Beyond The Base Game

Transcript 9:51

hello welcome to the show this is the broken meil a show where I talk about boarding card games and this is beyond the base game a little minseries where I talk about specifically expansions to games because most people don't really want to this is the second of three videos I have done to Canvas this is you know kander has been very nice to supply me with review copies of all all the canvas material the base game and the two expansions so I've already done Reflections which was the one that came before this is finishing touches the newest one again in one of these big boxes we'll get on to that in a minute but you know this is basically another light Edition doesn't add much complexity just adds a couple of rules and adds a bit more content so what do you get in here well a little bit more than you did in the previous one although this there no board in here this board is from the previous set so I'd be kind of weird to ask why you would buy the third one and not buy the second one this this is kind of assuming that you would buy them all in sequence that you would buy canvas then Reflections then this one because if you buy this one you won't get the board from the previous one and then that would be just kind of weird but here you have basically more cards with a new gimmick to them much like the previous one had mirror cards you now have blend cards and you have a Score Pad you have a Score Pad it's it took you only what the third iteration to put a score pan in the game man and there's not even that many pages on it I mean you'll be done with this after a little while you might want to laminate this and get one that's dry erase but man finally they actually put

a score pad in here but they give you silver ribbons now which silver ribbons are basically just flat two points they appear on cards if you get them that's fine but then you get these four big giant frames here with some little backs that you need to assemble annoyingly you can't put them back in the box assembl cuz they will not fit but essentially what they are is four frames and this adds a competitive race element to the game where essentially you can take one of your art pieces I mean I'm just going to take a a transparency for example and once you've created an art piece with fre of these if you have the most of a particular symbol and this new wild symbol you effectively get to put your card inside the frame itself and you'll get bonus points for doing it but if somebody beats you on the number of symbols they can also cover your card get points and then at the end of the game there is some additional scoring if your card is still in a frame and that's pretty much it I mean it looks cool you know to have this frame with your picture in it I mean that is quite a cool little gimmick although you might need to remember which one's yours that's the only thing but it's uh you know really really simple as simple as that there's not much else to explain I mean race to get the frames that's kind of it I mean what do you expect the rule book is again only four pages and most of it is set up and a couple of rule changes which is pretty much what Platinum ribbons are I think yeah they call Platinum not silver whatever and you know rule changes to the solo mode and one to two player mode that's it I mean hell even the setup diagram assumes

that you've already bought reflections with the board so you know reiterating what I said earlier but pretty much it's just the blend icons and these so what are the blend icons well I put them back in their uh you know little sleeve thing cuz I wanted to separate them out for the time being but essentially these function just like art pieces in general except now there is a blend icon little pink brush on some of the color swatches and essentially what they are is that they're treated the same as normal icons but they're kind of like copies they duplicate an icon next to it and I just found a perfect example here right Majestic World painting so here I've got a you know color swatch symbol there so kind of universal color swatch symbol now if I put this one on top I get a paint brush that blends with that one there so effectively I've copied the s to the next one and that's it I am done talking yeah that's pretty much what the icon is the only additional icon is a silver shiny little foil star which is basically a wild symbol they call it a creativity symbol and it counts towards the frames that you're trying to get but it also just counts as a wild symbol of your choice and that's what the expansion adds and I got to say as much as I gave you know a little bit of leeway to Reflections one thing I will say these expansions is that they are not particularly cost effective by the time you have bought all three of these you are spending in the region of 90 to1 to get this for what is a super fluffy light game I mean even if you include everything in here it is super light and

fluffy which is definitely a positive you can throw everything in the kitchen sink into a game and it will be perfectly simple and straightforward to teach to non- Gamers it really will if you're that desperate you can separate out the sleeves they do have icons on them but do you want to go through all these transparent sleeves to find the ones that are specific to an expansion I sure as hell don't and it's not something I've had to do nobody has struggle to get this game it's probably physically impossible not to understand the Simplicity of this game do you do well at it that's another story when you thrown in both expansions but a great Gateway game should be so simple to pick up but then give somebody good choices a little bit of depth and allow them to come back and enjoy more plays but man this expansion just feels like you know much like the previous one where I feel like you've chopped up your base game in order to make more expansions because I mean a race element and one icon on a card you could have had that in the base game I mean this could have easily been a base game component why did this need to be in an expansion also now left with this storage problem because you saw how much room these frames took up they take up a good amount of the box which I've got to assemble every time which is kind of annoying you've then got more cards these will not fit in the deck box that you have here so you're going to have to store them in baggies you will not be able to store this in anything less than two boxes you cannot fit this all into one box it's not physically possible but you could probably do it in two but then

you have a picture that doesn't quite make sense because again they've gone with this gimmick of put the three together and you have a beautiful picture so one two and come on here we go three yeah it looks absolutely gorgeous but it's a gimmick and for practicality purposes it's an annoying gimmick and I wish they didn't do this but sadly it's the way it'll be so if I want to keep this game I now need to keep at least two if not all three of these boxes and then when you get them out you've then got to open up all three boxes and then you've got to set it up and then you've got to take it down which the take Down's not exactly easy once you've got all this stuff together because you've got to separate out all the sleeves get them together get the frames disassembled put the board away get the ribbons together it does add a little bit of extra faf to what is not meant to be a faffy game but at least it doesn't add any extra length the game length is still 30 minutes with five players regardless it does not take any longer it just might take you an extra 30 60 seconds to explain the game after all this so all in all it's nice but I'm going to have to be a bit harsher with this one I was maybe a little bit light on Reflections because I do like the mirror cards and Reflections I do like the fact that this board added more choice so there was a bit more impact to the game if you took out the stuff that's in here you wouldn't really miss it it just adds a bit more but not a lot more like so little you'd think why is

it an expansion so I got to duck it a little bit for that not to mention I've now got to store three boxes instead of anything else I'm giving this one a 6 out of 10 it's above average it does the job it's not complex it you know adds a lot more variety all good things but when you factor in the value here when you factor in just how chopped up this game feels when you've got both expansions I can't give a similar rating to like I did for Reflections to this one you know it just especially for the money you pay for this I mean you're paying a good 30 to 40 for this I think I forget how much they cost but they you know they're not cheap and all you're getting is one new icon and some you know some objective scoring which didn't even need to be in these frames I mean you could literally just have a space on a board and just said there you go that's it but grounded it looks good but is it worth the cost of a full-fledged expansion as well as another box of storage H that's a question you're going to have to ask yourself 6 out of 10 overall it's nice but don't feel that you need to rush out and grab it I think the first one is better over all that's certainly worth grabbing if you really enjoy canvas this one is if you really really really enjoy canvas so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele if you like what you see them thumbing up on YouTube thumbing up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the page please get those thumbs in not this way that way please and of course don't forget to let me know your comments what do you think about canvas and the expansions in general do you think that the gimmick of the storage is a pain do you hang them up on your wall do you

like the fact that you know it's all chopped up and sold to you in bits you know let me know your thoughts down below and of course check out the other canvas videos if you have not already done so until next time remember regardless of whether you are also gagging for a score pad or not it's still only a game so take this add up your scores and be proud they finally put it in and take care and have a good time bye for now

Progress saved