Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Western Contingent, Episode 33: "Are Publishers Responsible...?"

Transcript 50:24

Got to hit that record button twice cuz we're recording now. So, you need to hurry and get this party started.

I am ready. I think I'm ready. Actually, I'm not ready.

Hello everybody and welcome to another episode of the Western Contingent. I am Tim from Las Vegas.

I'm Sam from the Pacific Northwest. Welcome everybody. So, here we are again, Sam. Um, yes. So, uh, before we get started real quick, I just wanted to make, uh, uh, a couple of announcements. So, number one, starting um, well,

I guess everybody will see this after,

um, the event, but WSBG is the World Series of Board Gaming is starting. Uh, we're loading in today and that'll be starting tomorrow. So, looking forward to that. And also, Dice Tower West Las Vegas Board Game Convention. Um, our early bird room sales end September 30th. So,

Oh,

yeah. So, please, if you plan on coming and you want to get a great rate on rooms, um, our rooms are selling fast. Our, um, uh, badges are selling fast. We are, uh, probably going to be, not probably, we're we're projected right now to be more than 10% growth over last year. So, we're really excited about that. It's it's looking really fantastic. Yeah. So, please go ahead and get your rooms. Get those in and get excited for another great event uh in March of 2026.

Yeah. Yeah. The rooms are nice, too, people. Don't don't um I'm just want to put that little plug in there. My wife and I stayed in a very nice room. We had a sprawling view of the sphere. We were on that side of the uh and that was interesting. We had to close both sets of our curtains at night.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. cuz there's a huge light bulb outside. But it was really cool to look at. It was really cool to look at. And we like we like dark dark rooms when we sleep anyway. So it it didn't bother us at all.

So it's it's u very comfortable rooms. Not too far away either. Uh you get your steps in, but it's not too far away from the actual convention hall. So

yeah. Yeah. Go ahead and do that for Dice Tower West Las Vegas Board Game Convention in March of 2026.

Yes, sir.

So what you been up to, Sam? what's been going on the past week for you?

Well, um it it's really just we are on kind of like autopilot right now, man. We are um just getting into the beginning of the school year trying to keep the kids with their heads down uh in their books, but they also have to do all of the extracurriculars that they're uh signed up for. Football is is in full swing for Aiden. He actually had his first game last Saturday and he's pretty excited. He's he's the punter and he is um a defensive end and he is a winger on the offense. So, he's playing in all arenas as far as that's concerned and he's really excited about it. He got some good pressure on the quarterback from the defensive side of the ball. He actually got to score a rushing touchdown. Um that was his first touchdown of his high school career. So that was cool. Got to c catch that on tape. Um well tape. Why do we use the word tape anymore?

That's what it is. Right. No, I mean

No, it's all digital now. It's all dig.

Right. Right. Right. That's

But it's the phrase I got it on tape.

Right. Yeah.

But um so that was that was cool to watch. Um they won their first game, so that was a cool thing. It was a nailbiter as well. Um a lot of good defensive play. Um some mistakes on both from both teams on the offense, which kind of kept both teams in it. Um and uh so it was it was a good um it was over in Idaho as well. So it was a six-hour round trip, but I was able I'm not supposed to do this. I actually texted my wife right before I did it. I said, "I'm about to do something and you can't stop me because I I had to go by myself. My wife had to work." And um I stopped by a Barnes & Noble, but that's She told me to do that. She didn't tell me to do this other thing. Right across the street from the Barnes & Noble was a crispy cream donuts.

Oh. Oh.

And she didn't she couldn't stop me. And so, but I I I bought I bought a dozen of the Harry Potter themed. I bought the Harry Potter dozen,

which I didn't have any of the Harry Potter ones cuz that's too much. I had two. And over a three-day period, I had two. And that was my thing for like the quarter. But man, I love crispy cream donuts, dude. They're so good.

They are. They're they're they're really good. It's funny because, you know, uh, when I grew, I grew up, so I grew up in the Northeast and over back there it was Dunkin Donuts was king, right? And a lot of different parts around the country, you have different, uh, regional things.

Um, you know, doughnut shops, pizza shops, hamburger shops, sandwich shops, whatever. And I had never heard of Crispy Cream, you know, because I don't know what part of the country that sort of originated in or was big in. um until I I I don't know, it might have been even when I came to Vegas in the '90s or something like I I had never heard about it. But yeah, they're they're they're very good. They're very different. And all those different kind of doughnut brands have their own uniqueness about them too in a sense, you know.

Uh but Crispy Cream is Yeah, they're uh they're fantastic.

Yeah. Um I I don't know where they're from either. And while you were talking, I'm starting to look it up because now I'm curious. I think I know Midwest is a term for a region of the country is Mid East. I know the Middle East is not part of our country, but is like cuz I'm I'm thinking that's where they came from. My dad is the one that introduced me to Crispy Cream and he's from Indiana. Um so I'm just trying to see if there is a

there could be there could be a term M East. I'm not sure because it always cracks me up like so um it's it Connecticut is right on Long Island Sound so we're on the eastern seabboard actually and a lot of times when people say oh you know I grew up back east I get excited I'm like oh and they're like where and they'll be like oh Indiana and I'm like that's not east but it is east you know

it's mid east middle east but yeah um ah I can't there's so much maybe facts um online or Oh, come on. I don't want any of that. Are crispy creams kosher? You're eating a donut, dude. Why do you need to worry about being kosher? Oh, I I know why. Please don't hurt me. I know why, but that's that just was a

Just type in

Where was Krispy K Cream founded? Just type that in, right?

I guess so. I was trying to be nice and go to their actual website, but where was

That's so good. founded. All right. Winston Salem, North Carolina, June, I'm sorry, July 13th, 1937.

Yeah. So, that's southeast.

Yeah. Yeah. Well, yeah, it is. It It is kind of southeast, isn't it? North Carolina. Although I have trouble calling North Carolina part of the South, but because it's North Carolina, but um

but it is.

But but that's that I guess. But that's that's interesting. I I would have never guessed North Carolina, but 1937, man, they're almost 100red years old at this point.

Wow.

Yeah, I know. I mean, a lot of those things have been around a long time, man. Like a lot of

You guys have got an awesome doughnut shop,

Pig Box,

right down the road from the convention center.

Yes. Well, it's Are you talking about

the name of the place?

Well, there's there's there's the bagel mania, Seagull's Bagel Mania, and they have a pink box in there. Um, but there may be another

That's the one I'm talking about.

Okay. Yeah. You know, pink box,

you got you have to kind of walk down the road. um kind of almost the road runs perpendicular to the road that um the the hotel is on

and you got to walk down that way.

On Paradise, it's it's I believe it's Convention Center Drive. So, yeah, you just go out the end of the convention hall and a lot of people take that walk. It's maybe a 15 minute walk uh up to the Bagel Mania place. Um

maybe a quarter of a mile. It's not far at all.

No, it's not far at all. Um but it is Yeah, that's Yeah. So, come out. There's a lot of good stuff around there.

You do not work off all the calories that you will consume even in a round trip.

No, but it's still worth it.

Yes. Yes, it is. I can attest to that.

Yeah.

So, how about any games? You've been playing any good games lately this past week?

Um, actually, yeah. Um yesterday my wife and I um you know we we switched recording these from Wednesday to Thursday because um my wife's schedule at work changed and she's free in the mornings on Monday, Wednesday, Friday to do stuff and so um taking trying to take advantage of that. Um we played four gardens yesterday um live on the flip side and it's a dice tower essential. It's put out by Arcane Wonders. Originally, it was put out by Korea Board Games over in Korea. Um, it's actually they ran a design contest over there in 2018, and this one was the winner of their 2018 design contest.

And, uh, Arcane Wonders picked it up and brought it over. Uh, I believe 2020 is when uh, it's it's listed as being um, released here in the States. And it's it's a it's a neat resource management uh procurement management and then usage game where you're basically trying to build four gardens in your around this pagota. And the four gardens are supposed to be honoring four different gods. And those are the four different tracks that you're trying to gain um um uh influence on I guess. Uh and those are the going to be the points at the end of the game. There are some bonus tiles that will give you extra points, but the the vast majority of your points are based on how far along these four different god tracks that you have gone. Um, but it's it's got an interesting um mechanism because the pagota that is the 3D element of the game. It's kind of like the toy factor of the board game um has on its roofs um different amounts of resources. And the cards that you're playing out of your hand are generally going to be used um for a number of different things, but the main thing that they're used for most of the time is manipulating what um what um shelf or I'm sorry, not shelf, what roof, what roofs are facing you because that's going to determine

what resources you're going to be able to get. Um, and then there's also on the cards that you play that give you that that u that collection action. Um, it tells you whether you're going to collect them from the bottom up or from the top down. And that that is an interesting way of doing things because you only have at the start of the game, you only have four storage spots for resources and once you've filled those up, you can't take anymore. But you have to take resources in the direction of the arrow on the action card. So you it it's it's a neat decision space because you can you're going to be able to uh manipulate um there's four different uh levels of the pigota and you can um manipulate different levels of the pigota and then that's going to determine what resources you get whether you know going up or going down. Um, that was interesting and it was a it was a fun puzzle to try to interact with in order to get your resources. Um, but there's also a huge aesthetic part of it because once you have um completed all of the resource requirements for your groundwork cards, they flip over and they become a uh panorama card. And um each panorama has a different number of cards that you put into it, but it's it it's very picturesque after you complete these panoramas. It's a really fun game.

Doesn't take that long at all. I think it's um uh it it says 45 minutes on the box, but um you're probably going to go from about 45 minutes to 60 minutes. But um I I I just really enjoyed it. It was the first time we played it. It was a learning game for us and uh the rules are short enough to where I think we did everything uh proper. We didn't leave anything out. It was really enjoyable though. It's got a huge good um aesthetic quality, good table presence, uh good toy factor, and there's good mechanisms behind it. So, I think it's very well deserving of that Dice Tower Essentials line, and uh Arcane Wonders, I think, was very wise to bring it over. Um it has it's a great game. Four gardens.

Nice. Nice. Yeah, I haven't uh I haven't played anything new this past week, actually. Just been playing playing a lot of the uh the oldies, but goodies are things that I just really like. And uh you played STI again,

played Stuper Mundy like three times.

Um yeah, played Up or Down, introduced some people to Up or Down. Uh the card, they loved it.

Um I loved it. It's such a I I really enjoy that game. Uh played River Valley Glass Works a couple of times,

Rome. So I just been playing a lot of again that that that's what I enjoy. I enjoy

playing Yeah. playing the same G because you know just this this you know every time you get together there's one group I play you know so every single time it's like a different game you know and it's just it's like you know it's just that's not that enjoyable to me you know what I mean it's it's enjoyable to me like I'm doing this 10xing of of Galactic Cruise and last week when I played Galactic Cruise was the first time I scored over 200 so I was quite excited about that you know because that that was our fifth week in a row and Um um it took me you know it's it took me a while to you know gro things, you know, I'm just learning and but when I sat down it felt good cuz I sat down and I'm like within like the first couple minutes I had a plan. I'm like oh yeah this that you know. So I like that evolution of

but I don't want to ever get to the point of like the WSBG players, right? I'm never looking to get to that point where where they play like 300 times on BGA over a year and things like that. They know every card. No, that that's to me that's I don't want to get to that point either. I just want to get to the point where I can just really feel like I'm I'm know the game, you know?

Well, yeah. I I would totally agree with that. I I can't see myself ever being I will take part in the tournament. Um, but I I don't think I'll ever be good enough to win tournaments unless it's just, you know, uh, a fateful occurrence. I'm not that person that memorizes all of the different cards and I can't count cards. You know, if I'm sitting at a poker table, I I can't do any of that stuff. So, I I'll never be good at good enough, I think, at games to win tournaments because those people are just on another level. And I and I would imagine that some of them at least are similar to me. They they're just joining the tournament because it's a game that they enjoy and they they want to be part of the tournament. I I can't fathom that all of the people that enter these kinds of tournaments are those kinds of, you know, very tournament-minded people, if that makes any sense.

Oh, no. I I agree 100%. Yeah, for sure. The second one that I want to talk about then is um a little card game called Odin. Comes in a little tiny box that is like this big and it's basically just about the size of the cards um in the rule book. It's about that big. And uh it is a ladder climbing game where you have to play cards out of your hand that are of a higher value than what has been previously played into the middle. The first person starts off with with one or more cards. Uh generally speaking, they're going to start with one. Um but that represents their number. So let's say that they play a five. Now the next person can play one card that's higher than a five or they can play two cards that their values are combined as digits to make a higher number. If you play multiple cards, they have to be either the same number or they all have to be the same color suit basically. Um, so I could play two ones which would constitute the value 11 and that would go out into the table and and basically then I would have to take the five and put it into my hand. Now that there's an 11 out there, the next person has to do the same thing. They can play two cards or they can play three cards, but again, they all have to have the same number or they all have to have the same color.

So, um, if I had a red, uh, one and a red two, I could play those two out and then that would replace the 11 that's out there and I would have to take one of the ones into my hand and the other one is discarded. Whenever there's multiple cards in the middle of the table, um, and you beat it, you have to take one of the cards and the rest are discarded. And basically, you're trying to get rid of your hand because when somebody goes out, everybody else that's that still has cards in their hand, those cards are worth one point each. You play to 15. Whoever has the least amount of points is the winner. We played this game, I think, five times.

Wow.

But it wasn't because we enjoyed it that much. We kept getting to places because the rule book is strangely written and we kept get we kept getting to places we're like, "Well, what happens now?" And I'd have to go back to the rule book.

Oh. Oh. Um, this happens now. Well, that changes everything. Okay, we'll start over. He did that like four or five times, which was frustrating because I am a seasoned gamer. I should be able to know how to play this game. But oh my goodness, it was like there's there's not much here. This has got to be a simple game. And it is, but how they worded things in the rule book, I'm like, what in the world does this mean? And so we had to kind of all put our heads together to figure this out. And and by the by I think the fourth game, we understood ex everything. And so we played once and then we played it twice. So, we really I'm really only counting it as two plays because the other three were like this is not how this game is supposed to be played. Um, but it was I need to get it to the table again so that I can teach people the correct way to play it from the very beginning and then see how it goes. It's a very fast game though because there the the possibility for you to get seven or eight points in a hand uh is likely. So, generally speaking, you're only really going to be playing about two hands, maybe three if people are really savvy on on getting those cards out of their hand during the course of the of the round. But, we did have a good time, but I just need to get it to the table a little bit more so that we can get some more valid plays in.

You know, that kind of brings us to the topic we're going to talk about this week, folks. and that's about like sort of publishers responsibilities or things like that as far as you know instructions, rules, components, all that kind of stuff. So Sam, why don't you uh go ahead and read the uh note.

Absolutely. Well, this is a topic that was sent in by a uh one of you, one of our audience members, and it was just something that they have been um uh dealing with, I I guess, or or um they're just kind of going into this. This is part of their experience. they've had they've had a similar experience with uh multiple publishers and multiple games. And so the question that they raised was do you think publishers, developers, whoever, you know, basically that's the umbrella that's being uh thrown out there should be responsible for providing kits, that's in quotation marks, uh to rectify the kinds of mishaps that he's been uh having uh difficulty with. For example, some of the um some of the games that he has purchased uh came with u cards that had um uh mistakes in them. There were m there were mistakes in the rule book that affected gameplay and and all of that kind of stuff. And many of the publishers have just been putting out PDFs uh and having people download them.

And so um that's the question. And then the follow on question is, is a PDF um uh is that good? Is that good enough? Well, I won't go into all of the detail. He gave um basically four different games from four different publishers. So, uh just to just to exemplify the fact that or the idea, maybe not the fact, but the idea that um it is not a small problem within the industry. So, that's where we're at. It's a question that we're going to um entertain and explore.

Yeah. Well, I think we need to start off with exactly, you know, I guess with the publisher, right? Because if that's where they're talking about the the situations are emanating from,

you know, like uh misprinted cards, missing component, whatever, blah blah blah.

You know, I I think a lot of people um you know, for example, you know, like that whole um Ace of Spades thing that happened at uh with that card game. Um, and people are wondering, well, you know, nobody saw this or blah blah blah. I just don't think people understand that

some of these companies when they print games or or do things that there may not be the actual dozens or hundreds or however many eyes necessarily seeing a product. So a lot of times when you get a misprint or like a grammatical error or certain things like that, it it before it goes to print, it really may not have been seen or gone through that many people to sort of evaluate it or vet it. So I think that is one of the big problems um that I have noticed a lot of times within the industry is there is a sometimes an overexpectation and an underdelance like right an over expectation on the audience of what they should get. I don't know if it's an over expectation. It should be an expectation that you get a 100% proper product and there's just not enough on the back end on the publisher end uh a lot of times putting out because

you know you've seen it right like as soon as a game comes out

there will be a hundred comments on BG hey this is wrong this is wrong this is wrong you spelled this blah blah blah blah blah because now you have thousands of people seeing something where before they did it and you're like how come they didn't catch this before so I think that's one of the the big problems starting with the publisher and where is their what they should do better.

Yeah. Well, from that aspect, that's something that I have been a part of with Monster Fight Club. When I worked for Monster Fight Club, I actually was the assistant to the project manager. Um, and that's one of the things that he gave me uh to do was to help him um kind of go through all of the different cards that were when I was working there. It was it was the uh Badlands. um Mr. Tor's Arena of Badass Badassory or something to that effect. I can't that's probably a I think that's right. Anyway, um that's the game that I was working on. And there were so many cards and whenever there was a little back and forth with the uh IP holders about the the the different kinds of of uh artwork and graphics that we could use on the cards.

And so there was a point at which we had all of the cards vetted. we had all of the cards um the way they were supposed to look and then we had to go back and change them and then they had to go back and we had to re-edit them again. But again, like you were saying, this wasn't a team of 10 people doing this work. It was it was literally me and two graphic designers um that were working on the the graphic design of the cards and and putting all the elements in and all of that kind of stuff. It was literally three people, right?

Um and we're talking hundreds of cards that we had to go through. So, um, it's very correct. You you are absolutely on point with with that place to start at. Um, but another thing that I'd like to add into that is that during that process, you're going through iterations and when you're dealing with um, uh, uh, digital content like this wi-i, which is this, which is how you have to do it, so you can send all those files to the to the to the factory when they start creating it. Um, it's it's a lot easier than you would think to screw up when you are taking one iteration and saving over it or you're taking it. Uh, and it's just really simple to make a very

it it it's the difference of one click or in the wrong place or, you know, putting it in the wrong file folder or whatever to where now all the work that you've done is like, well, where did that go? And so we and again I the team at Monster Fight Club did such a good job at keeping everything exactly the way it was. But even or the way it was supposed to be and but even then there were times where um somebody in the rush of trying to meet a deadline or trying to do this that you know a mistake was made and and we had to backtrack a little bit. So again, I'm I'm not trying to share any I don't think I'm sharing any secrets. I think that could probably be said about any company that you talk about. AB:

Absolutely.

That was just my experience with it. So just to um I I will say that um there's there's multiple editors for the rule books usually and there are usual like with us we had an editor that did all of the work and then when when he was done with all of the work that he did um with uh the editing and the writing we had a person that wrote it then we had a person that edited it and then I would go through and and uh find things that I thought um weren't worded correctly and that I would have a discussion with the editor about well what did you mean by this because it seems like you're meaning this but uh after because I knew how to play the game it seems like you're telling them to do this but you're actually supposed to do that you know that kind of stuff and and sometimes we would change the wording sometimes we wouldn't but there's I say all that to say this

you would think because you do a job where you have to edit certain kinds of documents and all of that kind of stuff and you are good at it that everybody is going to be good at it. So when you believe that way it's very easy to be hyperritical when it doesn't work or when something goes wrong. And I I would just encourage people to resist the urge to be overcritical when this kind of stuff happens with board game companies.

Yeah. But again, Sam, I mean, I can understand what you're saying maybe, you know, to be overcritical, but but but the truth of the matter is, you know, we've talked about this before.

Yeah.

A lot of the companies sort of have to rush a product to pay the bills, right? That that's what happens a lot. So, a lot of times they put out uh games quicker than they probably should have made them go through the vetting process um because, you know, they they have bills to pay. And um you know, on the reverse, on the other side, you know, and again, I I I keep trying to find things wrong with like Galactic Cruise. Um you know, I told you I've been, you know, 10xing it, playing it every week. I love the game. It's like my number one game of this year. Um, and I I'm just so impressed that like it seems it again, not that I've read every single word or know blah blah blah, but it seems like they've done everything right, the insert, the rules, and I'm like that because they they went through a lot of play testing, a lot of this, a lot of, you know, a lot a lot a lot a lot a lot of eyes.

But then I look at a game I'm looking at right here, you know, Teayot Tiwakan, the Deluxe Master Set from Board and Dice, an established company that's been around for years. And when that came out, look how many mistakes there were.

And I'm kind of like, how, you know, like it just seems like there's a like like to me when you say shouldn't be overcritical. Should I not be overcritical? I mean, why shouldn't I?

Right. I think well I I think well I think there's a line between become being critical which is what I think you're talking about and being overcritical where and the level of overcritical for me would be you missed you missed the article a or the 15 times in the rule book that would for me that that would be very close to being overcritical. Okay we missed some articles. Got it. Okay. You were still able to learn how to play the game and it wasn't like it was a a poorly written. We just grammatically missed a few. You know, that kind of stuff. To me, that would be over critical. Something like what you're talking about where there are literal mistakes where um it affects how you can or cannot learn how to play the game. That's that's different in my opinion. Um, so I I I think there is a difference between being critical, which I think is fair because people paid their hard-earned money for these things. So there is a level of um uh critique that should be expected and is absolutely warranted because

when you buy something and you pay like our audience member said who brought us this as a topic, when you pay the amount of money that companies are asking you to pay for these games right now, you kind of expect it to be polished.

Correct.

Maybe it's not blinged. Maybe it's not um super high value components and everything, but it's polished. It you can tell that it's been gone over multiple times uh for looking for those mistakes and for those nuances that uh are going to mess things up. Um

right. And then I think I think to me there should be more of an expectation if I'm funding you. So, if I went on Kickstarter or Gamefound and I prepaid and I helped

I gave you uh what's the term I'm looking for? Uh like pre- money, I can't think of the the word I'm looking for, whatever.

To to make the game, right? I I I So then you even to me the publisher, the game company has even more of a responsibility because it's not like just a game they put out and it's like they got all the ownership and it's kind of like they don't quote unquote owe the customer anything, right? Because it's just they're just pumping it out. But if like thousands of people gave you hundreds of thousands, millions of dollars to produce something and then you put out a product that has errors and mistakes. Yes, you that you can be overcritical to me about articles about things like that because it's kind of like you know people paid you like you couldn't have done this maybe without their funding. So you need to be extra special cautious in that case. I I would I would agree with one half of I would agree with one side of that argument. Um the the side that I would agree on is absolutely yes and amen. The the the the publisher absolutely needs to take the responsibility of getting it right very seriously. Um because people are funding your product. Absolutely.

Um, the only thing that I'm I'm wary of agreeing with is the the if I can use the eword, the entitlement mentality that comes along with a lot of crowdfunding backers. Um, and and that is a lot of a lot of people view themselves less as a customer and and okay, let me backtrack a little bit. I said a lot of people the the the outspoken majority of the people that we deal with on Kickstarter pages tend to view themselves as investors rather than a customer and I don't agree with that. Um yes you are giving them their money. So on one hand it does very much fit that investment model where you are basically paying for this product to be released. Um and you're and and without that maybe like you said the product isn't released. I totally get that.

But that doesn't make you necessarily an investor that now has some level of say in how the game gets produced.

I think there's a very I think there's a very fine line there that a lot of people

don't realize it's there or don't care that it's there because they cross over it a lot.

Well, right. No, I get that, Sam, and I I I agree with you on that point. I mean, and again, I don't want to get too far off topic, but you know, when you brought it up about that about sort of being an investor or being entitled or whatever. I mean, again, as you know, again, I don't want to get too far off off topic, but the publishers because that does upset a lot of people, right? When you've invested, you've given money, and then the company gets the games and they'll sort of release it at Essen. And you're like, how are these people who didn't back the game, why are they getting their game before I did

now? You know what I mean? So, I don't want to get too far off topic, but and again, that that's that that to me that goes into it. That's sort of like a a stab in the heart. It's like, wait, I gave you money for the past two years, a zero free interest loan essentially, I gave you, and now this person who didn't do anything for you is getting the product before I get it. like that's just you know so again but you know I don't want to get off topic but I I do feel that the company sort of puts yourself out there right if you're doing that to take people's money then in in essence I mean believe me I get what you're saying but in essence you're opening the door to them being an investor and in giving them a little bit of entitlement because you are you know what I mean so again I understand then it's not full, but it's sort of you're opening that door instead of just printing the product. Then nobody's invested, nobody's quote unquote entitled, whatever. That's just it. You just you just made the game. But if you open that door, it does open it a little bit for that. You know what I mean?

True. And and the saying, you give them an inch, they're going to take a mile. That that comes that comes up and that's absolutely true. And and that can be applied in a lot of different things,

but it doesn't make it right. Um, and the the way I the way I look at um crowdfunding anything is um I I say yes, I would like to have this game. Um, and from the way it looks right now, I'm in. I'm going to give him some money for it. That doesn't mean that I have the a stake in the success or the failure of that product. It just means that I would like to have it on my shelf. That's all it means. Um, it's no real different than if I were to walk into a store, see something on the shelf, put some money down on the counter, and take that home with me. It's just that the the the the obvious difference is now I have to wait for 18 to 24 months before I'm going to have that product in my hand. Um, I don't view it as an investment. I view it as this company is going to produce it.

They need some money to to to produce it. I would like to have it after they are produced. So, here's my money. It's a glorified P500. Um, and and you know, P500 is is way back in the day. I think some people are still doing it, the smaller companies where they pre-ell a number of games because that will give them the amount of money that they need to produce the game.

Correct.

Um, but this used to happen all the time. And um and again, I wasn't part of it back then and I'm not really part of them now unless you really want to make a strong connection between it and crowdfunding. Um but I I don't I I just can't see the investment side of things. I I get that it probably feels like it to some people because you are investing your money in a in a venture that's going to take a while to uh come to fruition. But again, you know, it comes back, I guess, you know, to the topic we were talking about where exactly is the responsibility, right? So, if a rule book has misprints, if cards are misprints, is just a PDF

uh suffice where now I have to go on the internet, download the PDF, staple it together, print it out, all that kind of stuff. or should the company like put out a whole new rule book and send it to you or a new Arata card like a an actual uh card with the correct phrasiology or whatever things like that. I mean,

yeah,

you know, that that's the question, too. And and and it's one of those things where so for instance, you know, when I own the game store, that comes down to who has responsibility. Like I would sell somebody a game in shrink wrap and they'll come back three days later and say, "Hey, um, there was a missing component and I'm like I'm like, well, what do you want me to do?" Like you're right. I mean, and but I understand where they're coming from, right? So this is sort of the same thing like there's an expectation on me where I sold the product so people are expecting me to rectify it right

and I'm like well I bought the product so like I can't do it like you know it was in shrink wrap I didn't touch it there's a piece of this in one of my and then so now you know it has who's goes back to the publisher should they be responsible so this is sort of that same kind of thing like where is the liability where is the culpability who do you go to to re uh to uh repair the situation how should it be rectified how should it be repaired And again there are levels right about what should be done. Is just a PDF sufficient?

But if we allow that, Sam, right, for just a PDF to be uh effic uh sufficient or whatever, then are we letting publishing companies off the hook, right? So,

yeah. Well, I I I got to see I got to see both ends of this spectrum, I think. Um I worked for a couple of companies. One of them had a lot of problems um with their rule books, the other one not so much. And um I will say that uh to just based on experience, I'm not saying what's right or what's wrong. First of all, let me let me first of all agree with you. I do believe that the publisher is where the responsibility lies in in situations like this. um if a card is wrong, if a component is missing, if a rulebook has um an egregious amount of errors in it, I think um all of the responsibility for all of those lies on the publisher, not the FLGs, um not the distributors, not any of those. It squarely lies upon the shoulders of the people who were in uh in charge of producing it because that's what the publisher is. It's the person that's in charge. Now, they're going to take all of those files and send it to a factory uh somewhere else in the world, but the the publisher is the one that was supposed to dot their eyes and cross their tees and make sure all of the ducks were in a row before they give it to the factory. So, it's not really the facto's fault fault unless they're using um uh materials that are different than what the publisher and the factory agreed upon. But the publisher, I think, is the person that or the the entity, let's put it that way, that should be held ultimately responsible. Now, um,

do I think a PDF is good enough? Um, I think for the amount of money that it would take to send physical replacements for some of these things, for some of these publishers, especially the smaller ones, that could be like a deal breaker as far as, you know, okay, well, if we're going to pay all of this money for this to send physical replacements for all these things to all of our people, well, we just we we we not only just we didn't break even anymore. Now we've lost uh $15,000 on this venture um because production, shipping, um materials, all of that adds up. So I think there are times when a PDF fix is absolutely viable because it's it's not expensive for the publisher and it's not expensive for the customer either. Um, and I think it's it's a good compromise to fix the problem. It might not, you know, it's not the best. You know, in a perfect world, the best solution is do it right the first time and it doesn't need a fix. But if you're already at the point where, well, crap, we did have those those errors and yeah, they're pretty big, but good night. We don't, you know, we we can't spend 20 grand to get all of that stuff made and ship it out to everybody. So, I think a um a PDF in many cases would be a good fix.

Yes. But but again, you're right because that that's sort of easy. It doesn't cost a whole lot. But but there are games I remember what about games that have a whole entire print run where there's one piece that doesn't stand up straight,

right? The mold might have been mold might have been wrong or something and the piece just doesn't stand up straight and there are thousands of copies out there that the game that that has that one piece, right? Like, should the publisher just say, "Ah, well, sand it down or use a cube or do something else or like, hey, I I paid 50 bucks for this game, and there's one piece that's just dysfunctional, and it's not just my game, it's all of your games."

Yep.

Go ahead and send us all a piece or give us a place where we can go get a piece or fix it, right? Yeah.

So, again, I think, you know, the the fundamental question is

um and again, there are levels is

the publisher has to fix it, right? I mean,

yes. what whatever it is, they have to fix it. Whether it's a

they have to provide a fix. Yeah.

Whether it's a new rule book or but they have to provide something.

Yep. If it's a physical if it's a physical component um like a miniature or something to that effect. Um I do know that um more often than not publishers will have an overage. they will make an overage of product so that they can have those in store

um or when missing components are there or when broken components show up or something like that they have an an a surplus on hand that they can send out to people as replacements. So I do know that that is a a common practice within the industry. So there is um because some of that stuff you just can't plan for. something gets broken in transit doesn't you know that just happens doesn't matter how good um your storage solution is sometimes it just happens there's nothing you can really do about it so they plan on that happening to an extent um but once those once that surplus runs out now you're talking about doing another print run um you know that that molds um to create them the first time they're super expensive um they're not as expensive once you've made the mold uh and you just have to make more of that that uh miniature or whatever it is. It's not as expensive them, but it's still a good chunk of money. So, it I think it really, you know, with plastic components, um, if I get a game that has a a dude that's, you know, should have had a V8, you know, and he's kind of leaning over and it's a plastic component, dude, just get a bowl, put some hot water in it, and fix it. Fix it yourself. There is something to be said for, okay, look, I got this product. It isn't the perfect thing, but I know I can fix that. I don't have to contact the publisher. I

don't have to ask them to send me a new one. I don't have to do anything. Um, I can take care of that. I think there is a level of ownership that's there once you receive a product. If you can tweak it a little bit and it's perfect or it's good enough, leave the publisher alone. But on the other side of that, if it's an egregious mistake, if it's a widespread mistake, I think publishers will want to know that. And and generally speaking, more often than not, publishers are are made up of of good people, honest people, and they want to do the right thing.

Correct. Yeah. So, at the end of the day, um, with this person who wrote this thing, not I'm not exactly sure of their situations or this or that, but I think we're all in agreement, and I think everybody can agree, publishers, consumers, or whatever, that there there should always be a yes. Right? If there is an issue with a game, whether it's in rule books, whether it's a miss opponent, yes, the publishers should just provide a fix. Now, again, like you said, you know, if it's, you know, if it's like, hey, you missed athe here, you missed an A here, you know, we all have to, you know, kind of pull it back. There's different kind of levels. However, there should be an alternative fix. If there are the and A's missing somewhere, great. print out it with with those put in the publisher print it out make it available so people can have the correct terminology if they're that concerned about it but at the end of the day I just think that yes the publishers should provide a fix regardless of what it is there should be something that is available to the people um to make their product uh uh uh to oh I guess I guess this I don't want to this is kind of weird how to put this but I I guess they should fulfill the expectations of the buyer right if if the If you buy something, you're expecting a complete full 100% product. So,

correct.

Right. So,

I guess whatever that takes to fulfill that

purchase of the customer to make them feel like they got that.

Yep.

Then those should be taken.

Absolutely. Totally agree with you. Totally.

So, rate in the comments folks what what you think about that and let us know your experiences, right? Let us know maybe the good and the bad, right? because there's both sides like companies like again like I just with with uh that Kinsson key with the Galactic Cruise I just think they did everything right you know blah blah blah. Um so let us know what companies um are you really happy with who provided excellent customer service who fixed things this that let us know the different types of fixes

right that companies have provided right what they've done to rectify situations

um that they may have gotten wrong or when they uh produced a game and may have aired. So that'd be interesting to know as well.

Yep. Please do.

Yeah. Well, uh Sam, as always, it's been another great week. Um we are, uh here again next Thursday. Um and so when I uh that's when we film, by the way. We changed our filming days. So I'll be able to talk about what happened at the World Series of Board Gaming.

Yeah. Looking forward to that debriefing.

Yes. And I hope you have a wonderful weekend, a good week, and all of you out there, again, remember, be kind to each other as always and try to play a lot of games uh with the same people or with different people like we talked about last week, right? Put up a flag in your house. Maybe somebody from the neighborhood will come on in and play a game with you.

I don't think that's going to happen.

Sounds great, though.

All right, until next time, folks. I'm Tim from Las Vegas.

Sam from the Pacific Northwest. See you guys on guys on the flip side. Bye-bye.

All right. Bye everybody.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games. We do top 10s. We play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.

Progress saved