Sheriff of Nottingham - Gameplay & Discussion
Transcript
hey everyone I'm Matt Evans and welcome to board game replay we've got another special episode for you here today another one that we shot out of Gen Con 2014 now this time we had a very special guest join us Rodney Smith have watch it played he was kind enough to come by our room and sit down and play a game of Sheriff of notingham with us and we've recorded that and we've got it cut up into our usual replay episode and we're going to get to that in just a minute but before we do that for those of you who aren't familiar with our show board game replay is a series we try to capture the experience of playing a board game with a with a group of friends and the way we do that is we sit down for a postgame discussion we talk about the various elements of the game and during that discussion we're going to cut back to instant replays of moments during the game we found fun or exciting so you're going to be able to join us in those moments now again I'm going to get to the video in just a second but before I do that for those of you who are not familiar with the rules of this game it's it's a pretty straightforward game I'm going to give you a brief rules overview really quick and just so you know what's going on for our discussion but for those of you who actually do know the rules to this game you're already comfortable you can actually click this annotation right up here jump right to the main video all right now Sheriff of Nottingham is a three to five player bluffing bribing Style game where players are going to take turns being the Sheriff of Nottingham which is this greedy Sheriff that's been appointed by Prince John to basically hassle all the merchants coming into the city stealing their Contraband basically just trying to get himself more money this game is played over a series of rounds and each round the sheriff is going to rotate to the next player in clockwise order and all their players are going to be playing as the merchants for that round trying to get their goods into the City and the object of the game is to get the most valuable Goods into into the city more than any other player the way
you're going to do that there's two different types of goods there's legal Goods apples cheese bread and chicken and then there's Contraband which is like pepper Mead silk and crossbows that you're not allowed to bring into the city you're going to have to sneak them past the sheriff so the way this is going to work is the merchant players every round they're going to have a market phase where they're basically going to do a little draw and discard basically they end up with six cards in their hand essentially and they're going to use those cards to try to bring different Goods into the city whether they're legal or illegal they're going to choose anywhere from one to five items and they're going to place them in this little Merchant bag here so I'm going to place four items in here once every player has done that the sheriff is then going to question each player and ask them what they' brought into the city now players can tell the truth about this or they can lie the only thing they have to be honest about is the number of items they're bringing into the City and they have to mention one legal good so for example I just put four items into my bag here I'd have to say I've got four pieces of cheese sheriff or four chickens or four apples even if I have something completely different in my bag once all the players have done this the sheriff is then going to start a timer at equal to the number of merchants currently in the game so here if I was in a three-player game there's two Merchants we start a timer for 2 minutes during that 2 minutes the sheriff is going to BL try to bribe and blackmail and try to do anything he can to find out what's in those bags try to read the players because what the sheriff is really after is he's trying to find you with Contraband because if he catches you with contra if he opens your bag and finds out that you lied about anything I've got got two cheese which I told the truth about I'm going to be able to keep them here put them
next to my player board but I've also got two Contraband so this means I just got busted I have to pay the sheriff now a fine equal to the dollar amount here on the bottom of these cards so I've got to pay him four for each of these cards so that sheriff caught me in a lie there but if I was actually telling the truth the sheriff actually has to pay me a fine based on all the legal Goods I was actually bringing in now during this whole phase while that timer is ticking down all the players can be wheeling and dealing with each other they can be bribing the they can be saying hey Sheriff I'll pay you five gold open his bag and they can be throwing money around at each other they can be begging the sheriff not to open their bag they can do whatever they can play whatever mind games they want to do during this phase but once that timer is up the sheriff is all done and any player who hasn't had their bag open they get to walk right into the City and whenever player gets by into the city they're going to take all their legal Goods that they brought in with them and lay them out in front of their player board here there's all the different spots for the legal Goods but any Contraband that they had actually made it through they didn't get inspected that actually goes face down here in front of their player board so everybody at the table knows that you've lied and brought in illegal Goods they just don't know exactly what illegal Goods that you brought in and that's basically the game it's just multiple rounds of that with players taking turns as the sheriff until everyone's played the sheriff a certain number of times uh depending on the player count it's a little bit different once that happens we total up all the the victory Point values of all our legal Goods all our Contraband any other gold that we have remaining and also there's some bonuses depending on the the player who has the most and the second most of each of the legal Goods of some bonus points there but for the
most part that's the entire game so that should do it for the rules overview that should give you a pretty good idea of how things play in this game with that why don't we jump into our discussion you can see how our game went woo so that was it what are you saying I got taken to the cleaners I got pillaged let me pile my money up here sorry oh man so whatever a bakery over there let me pile up my money it'll take second you know guys it was a friendly game we don't have to I that is a lot of math Matt you're right I got 20 and apples plus another 20 your hand doesn't count right 40 and 50 I got 90 points your hand doesn't count well you had left is that on you got 10 something 10 that's ridiculous 116 wow really CU he was the king of chickens things I the king of the chicking chicken queen of bread 20 61 how good are your mics I know how good are your pretty good right there 16 114 114 but you got it by two 116
nailed it congratulations wow if he didn't if he didn't take me last turn dude that was rotten that was if I didn't take you and I didn't guess on him him I think I would had it I think you would Ronney went so hard so hard as the first and I haven't played with you guys before I'm think okay I I think these guys going to take advantage of me cuz I haven't played to call every one of these suckers let them know it's like you know you get in the jail you punch the guy you all know you got to worry about tricked you knew you were going to think that exactly what you said oh man right in the eyes what do you have that three chickens three chickens all right three chickens I like chicken all right yes what do you got Matt uh uh four four apples oh three four we unfortunately you don't know Matt how many Matt four sorry about that I a littleit uh two apples two apples lots of apples going around here yeah I have I have four apples they're in season so four app four apples how many apples and how many three app chickens okay she's sticking to the story staying with chickens all right interesting interesting I you know I want to believe the best of all of you I'm a I'm a generous Sheriff but I feel like one of you with the stable fine their teeth at me that was a lot of apples disgust that
was a lot of apples I think somebody's trying to hide under his hat okay uh listen I uh how many apples was it it was four and it was four what let's find out apples snap we're to find out oh snap I see uhoh this is going to cost me yes this is four apples oh how could I dare you how could I dare my four years of acting school have paid off eight eight Sheriff does not like to dip into his anday brutal I'll not be trifled with don't think just cuz I was off a little bit here that my radar is any more diminished are we are you sure about the chickens I feel it's a weird Club three three chickens still I I mean what am I going to do say there's not yeah you're I'll give you a dollar you look at his instead H you pay me a little more and all look at his instead what like $2 how about how about we say how do you say three three and and I'll look and I'll let you pass I'm trying to um I don't I mean that's suspicious enough to you right now I don't think so oops let's see what we got in the bag let's see what we got in the bag I feel like it's going to be one chicken two three chickens man you guys are Hest I got toay more money all right now
I'm getting a little nervous you guys might get a pass just cuz I don't want to lose any more money I want to uh I'm going to take I'm not I'm going to catch somebody yeah yeah I'm going to catch you are you are you going to are you going to offer a little I told you I had four oh you're messing totally taking advantage of it he doesn't know us very well I'm taking yours Jer that fake stter right there no one Li come on come on I need to make change crying out loud you thought you were going to punch Us in the nose we just punched you right back everybody then everyone got dirty yes we did we super dirty they got very tricky oh I found it interesting that and I heard about this game I I saw your video on it with with Scott Morris with talks and you you had talked about it's like wow that seems really fun and I saw kind of the basics of it but then sitting down to what to to actually play the game I'm starting to realize all the different levels because when you're the sheriff you have the thought of I don't you know I don't want to pick on that guy because he's way behind anyway I don't care and then there's the whole thought of how many cards people are saying they have and yeah if someone if someone says they have five apples like Jeremy you were like I got four and then I got three and and you're like no there's no way he's this many apples right and it can make you seem really sketchy if you say you have a lot of anything right but but but even more no even more sketchy if you say too little too little of something that was the most sketchy I think I think we have equ that actually something happened just like that and we
can watch it so I'm I'm I'm going to open your bag I'm not going to lie to you I'm going to open your bag because I don't care and I just want to know if you want me just move along if you think Rodney's lying I'll go to Rodney but I mean I I you really think that I'm going to believe that you have four cheese in your bag you were able to draw four cheese yeah that's why I took the piece of pepper so I could get some cheese yeah all right well I'm going to open your back there it is do you want I mean I'll stop if you got like I I'll go to Rodney instead cuz I'm like right on the fence with both of you on the fence me I got two bread in there yeah I mean you I see that the two is the suspicious part I feel like you could just put two of anything in them and I think oh that's believable cuz there's two the car draw is what it is it's going to be one of the other who's it going to be Isaac I mean I don't know if he's lying well I'm saying do you want me to open your bag Ian I mean you can do what you want why you so well if it's if it's just geez why don't you just tell him to open your bag then he can open my bag if he wants but I it I mean that's up to you all right I'm going to go all right fine I'll open Rodney's bag okay okay now I didn't even get a chance I didn't even get it I didn't I get to say okay well maybe I made a mistake about that did I play that wrong wow no no you can do whatever you want if you intended to not open up the B loaded with Contraband loaded loaded I saw through your loaded sorry I didn't give you a chance to go oh my gosh I got
ruined wow I'm just going go right to R snap beautiful I thought can I have change back at least to change please and like lightning hands here I didn't even I didn't even have a chance or anything like fine I'm not going to open your bag I like Snap ry's open oh man I didn't even I felt terrible about that man I could tell I could tell he he lifted up both bags what he wanted to do was get money out of me because he wasn't sure because I I said way too many and he was sure about you because he bet too low to be honest I was I was I wanted you to offer me a couple of bucks and then I was just going to rip it open anyway because I wanted to wait for you to offer me money now I'm giving my strategy I was going to wait for you to offer me like you guilty and then rip it open but you played it Stone Cold you played it really really well and poor Ronney didn't even have a chance to negotiate just I feel you a chance but you know but I added more money that way so it's awesome that's really where the fun of the game it's in that crazy stuff that happens negotiation and like there's a lot of games like this now with like the with the lying to your friends type theme and there's nothing more fun the reason those games are all doing so well is cuz there's nothing more fun than calling something out on a lie and being right about it it's so good and so when you snap that and you just see them their face is such a tactile element so good you hear it and it's like it's done I
want to look back to the designer that came up with the snap idea I want to say good job congratulations they must have engineered this button cuz that's a satisfying SN satisfying perfect sound it's great yeah and I I being being able to even play with the flap I mean you did you did it you did it well you're like you were playing with the flap you're like w w like everybody sees it happening and then you hear the it's all over it's done we're done to go man it's I I I'm so I Get So Satisfied by games with such a simple concept that have that that depth and it's not even mechanical depth it's just like the social depth like when we were questioning Jeremy L like he's saying he has five there's no way he's lying about five oh maybe he is because that's so ridiculous why would question you talk about it long enough and you're like yeah I think that's what makes the game so brilliant yeah I kind of banked I used that to my advantage the next turn too cuz I went with five and I actually had it which was crazy so they called me on it and they're like oh well whatever so next time like I can't call him on it again cuz it was actually right and then I got some silk by yeah you did get some silk by here here's the thing and this is what I I think about well I think about theme a lot that's like one of my big things about a game if I am not intrigued theme it's it's actually it's actually a killer for me so there's games like you have games like Game of Thrones and it's so theme heavy you're in it you are so in depth and this is light it's light on theme but you H you have an idea so you you have that idea
in your head that you're you are the sheriff you are the one in charge that's really all you need your imagination goes wild it gives you a nice Power Trip makes you feel powerful it's awesome it really gets you in the mood playing with the give me the bag I'm going to like pretend any what's doesn't feel like app it's that light theme that just gives it a touch that makes your imagination go wild good stuff awesome good stuff yeah that was a quick game we should say we didn't play a full game we we ran out we were a little short on time but we uh yeah I was mounting a comeback you but uh that's kind of the game in a nutshell or so we had a shorter game but I still think we definitely got a good experience for it and uh F defin want to play again yeah yeah I'm ready to play again we'll have to do it more this this week and again yeah CU obviously we're coming to you special here from Gen Con our very special guest Rodney Smith here us we're honored to have him over the show uh the r can tell how honored you were I feel very Dishonored well I'll also say this will probably the last time Rodney will ever be joining us on on our show here because we we invite him on the show he he proceeds to have to teach us the entire game and then they crush me absolutely crushed me for my trouble Ronney you're you're a true gentleman we really appreciate you being here thank you so much thank you so much and Jim Jim is our is not usually with us we're we're we're super happy to have you here man he's usually uh from out of town he's from out of town from Straight From Brooklyn Straight From Brooklyn Straight Out of Brooklyn man if only you were in
Compton it would awesome so that's Sheriff of nodding ham by Arcane Wonders that should give you a pretty good idea how it plays out U lot of fun if you like bluffing games and lying to your friends we had a blast we're ready to play again yep absolutely thanks so much everybody for watching we'll catch you again soon bye bye see you are you are you sheriffing first I'll be Sheriff first sure I think that makes it a little little bit easier thanks for teaching the rules there by the way come over hey R you want to play some games he knew the game well I was taught by Scott Morris that guy's sloppy so that's a video watch who spiked my drink I might have put a couple of bubbles of carbonation oh my I think