Crystal Palace Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today i'm taking a look at crystal palace which is a pretty involved euro strategy economic game designed by carsten lauber and published by capstone games this one accommodates two to five players and takes around two hours to play on average the game is set on the world's fair in 1851 and the idea is you want to be the nation who showcases the most impressive inventions at the fair and but essentially what it means is you're trying to get the most victory points so the setup of crystal palace is going to look like this where you don't actually have a main board per se you just have a series of these micro boards all kind of determining a different part of the game and different actions you can take so you've got the patent office here you've got the british museum the bank of england westminster the reform club the london times port of london waterloo station and you've got the black market over here as well and additionally each player has their own personal player boards which look like this which track a number of different things such as these storing spaces where you can put these tokens and cover up these potential end game points that you may lose if you don't cover them up you've also got this newspaper track here which can give you little kind of abilities that you can use at any time and you've got these little personal objectives which differ from nation to nations you can see that my um my uk nation here wants to get along this track corresponding to westminster additionally you have the buzz board here which is another track you're trying to climb to get bonuses along the way and potentially invest in these spots to get more income and points as
the game goes on to the right of this track you've got your income track which determines how much money you're going to take from round to round you know you want to be making sure that you're high as possible on that track because money in this game is extremely tight you also have the resources such as these cogs and light bulbs you've got these loan tokens and you've got the money itself as well as all the different bits such as the cards etc but let's talk about how the game actually works so the game is going to play out over five different rounds two in 1849 two in 1850 and then the final round in 1851 and each of those rounds is going to be broken up into seven phases here depicted on the bottom of your player boards the first of which is probably the most significant part of the game and probably the most unique part of the game so simultaneously each player is going to have a number of dice here and they are going to secretly manipulate them to how they want so you could they could put them all threes or they could put you know whatever whatever orientation they want of these dice and bearing in mind that the higher numbers are better than the lower numbers but bearing in mind that every pip here you place on these dies means that you have to pay a pound for so you know if you want to go all high that's perfectly fine but you have to make sure that you have that money in your bank to be able to finance those moves and the idea is that you're trying to put these dice in the orientation you want in order to claim the different workers placement spots on these boards here so you can see that each of these boards has a number of different spots where dice can be placed um ranging in different numbers and that this is basically the minimum number that you
can put on that particular spot so you need to have at least a three on this spot and you also want to be the person with the highest number on there because that means you're going to pretty much secure your option to take that action because you can see even though there's four dice placement spots here there's only actually three action spots in order to do that so say four people put dice there only three of them are going to actually resolve that action and alternatively some spots have further bonuses you can get on them or even punishments such as this one here where if you place on this spot you're gonna automatically pay an extra two pounds so once all players are happy and have revealed their dice simultaneously you're gonna pay that money and then whoever's put the highest pit value or the total combined highest pit value of their dice are going to be the first player and whoever's put the lowest is going to take um one of these um newspaper points by going up this track here which will let you do different things at any time such as i'm spending four of them to get an additional die um you can spend three to go up the income track two to get a cog one for one money ratio and you can even do this alternative actions such as spending four to get a light bulb five money to get a cog or one light bulb or one cog to get a pound and then in turn order you're going to be placing your dice that you've just manipulated onto the different action boards and then once they're all placed you're going to start resolving all the different action boards in order so the patent office here lets you reserve one of these patent cards which is a big way you're going to get points and basically the inventions in the game so you can see here that this
beer glass counter requires two cogs and five light bulbs in order to build it and this part at the bottom here is going to be the reward for doing so and even some of them have a little bit of a punishment too such as losing money but normally it's worth doing that and you can also see here in the top right hand corner that you are usually incentivized to build things earlier in the game because you can see here if i build this beard glass counter in 1949 i'm going to get massive 24 points but if i wait until 1951 then i'm only going to get 13 points additionally you don't actually buy these outright and just um have them straight away you're essentially reserving them um to be able to build them later in a in a future round when it comes to phase five um i did mention as well that some of these spots have this little assistant action which you can take immediately if you go in one of those spots and that corresponds to two different things and the first of which is to do your personal objective here which can get you in-game points and the second of which corresponds to the black market here where you can optionally pay an amount of money to put one of your little helpers on that track and paying the amount of money if you need to and what that means is that when it comes to a later phase in phase six you're going to get the corresponding bonus to the right hand side here additionally if you don't want to place a new one on there you can move another one up to the next available spot in order to keep them on that track and keep them pushing up because at the end of each round everyone on the black market is going to slip down one spot potentially kicking you off that board you can also see that some of these
cards have a person associated to them and basically what that means is that if you have a matching pair of the actual invention itself and the matching person from this board here then you can get an additional four points for doing so at the british museum lets you take one of these little telescope tiles and put them on your player board either getting an instant reward or an ongoing reward so you can see this one here will get me a cog and two money instantly but this one here will get me a pound every single time it comes to phase six and when you take one of these you're going to put them on your little board here covering up one of these spots um as i mentioned earlier each one of these empty spots at the end of the game is going to make you suffer negative two points you've got the bank of england here which where you get these um these different share tiles from and they are going to help you go up the income track and even get you victory points so this is quite an important part of the game that's quite sought after you've got the westminster track here which basically means that you get rewards as you go along such as getting money or getting to use a tile again or getting light bulbs but additionally the westminster track helps you when it comes to the next board which is the reform club where you can buy these people because you can see when it comes to phase four in the game each of these different characters has a wage that you need to pay depending on how far you are along on that westminster track so you can see here this um queen victoria card will cost me a massive six pounds if i'm only on the first spot of the westminster track but if i get to the black area right at the end it's only gonna cost me two pounds
per round which is not so bad and these are much like the patent cards where you know the earlier you build them generally the better they get or not always but this one here actually gets better the more you um the later you build it but again they correspond to the patent cards and will cost you resources to buy them but you get those instantly so you need to make sure you have the funds in your pocket ready to spend the london times board is basically ongoing objectives that you can claim so each round or yeah each round in the game is going to correspond to a certain objective criteria so you can see here the first one in 1849 requires to have a certain amount of assistance on the black market uh the port of london board gives you these one-off bonuses that you can take once per round such as taking these assistant actions getting cogs um getting a new die into your fold so you've got more options or taking one of these ticket actions where you can forfeit a dice die in order to get an amount of points and again the earlier you do that the more points you're going to get so it's a bit of a speculative punt and then you go to the waterloo station which basically gets you these rewards such as getting two light bulbs a light bulb when activating a six tile or getting a light bulb and two up the buzz track when you get to certain points on the buzz track here you can get these one-off bonuses again such as unlocking a new die or getting character cards or getting these telescope tiles but when you get to these poster marks here you can optionally choose to give up one of your two discs to claim that spot which will give you an ongoing bonus every single round for example i
put my disc here which means i have the option to go two more up the buzz track or take two pounds every time that part of the game triggers but the further you got this track and and kind of forfeit those bonuses as you go you can potentially get these higher ones such as getting a massive income of points every single round and additionally at the end of the game whoever's got the highest up these tracks gets an amount of points you know the first player's gonna get six points second four and third two points and that also um relates to the black market as well where again the first second or third person up there highest at the end of the game is gonna get three two or one points respectively so once you've picked your dice you've placed your dies you've resolved all the action boards you've paid your wages activated only four tiles you have the option then to purchase or build two of your reserved patent cards get paying the resources to do so getting the rewards um if you want to and um getting the points and even them the pairing bonuses if you have the corresponding people after that you're going to take your income based on where you are on the income track and then everybody has to go down three on that income track which is another reason why you want to keep pushing up this track here because every round you're going to keep falling meaning that you're getting less and less money round after round you're also then going to get any rewards based on the buzz track everyone is then going to slide down on the black market track and then you're going to re-rack all the different resources and things all the cards ready for the next round okay so let's get into my review of crystal palace so i think the main thing to talk about and the starting
point i should start with is the actual dice bidding mechanism itself i think that mechanism is absolutely fantastic and i'm massively surprised that it's never been seen before this game where you have your dice here you can actually choose the orientation of these bids but bearing in mind that it's going to cost you a pretty penny if you want to guarantee those first dibs on all these different action spots and striking that balance is a really crucial decision now you don't just spend too much because maybe somebody's bid or low on their dice and you don't want to you know overspend and you know when you could have got it for cheaper but additionally these boards are very tight so that if you don't kind of go quite confidently to a higher bid then there's a good chance you're going to get shut out of taking an action at all and striking that balance is a really strong part of the game and that all ties back to the money management and the economic side of the game so this game is probably one of the tightest games in terms of money management that i've ever played now you do start with a nice little um bunch of cash but before you know it that cash starts bleeding away and away in a way and you're just pretty much scraping for every single pound you can get which means that you really are fighting over these shares tokens to make sure that you keep climbing this track because every single round you are falling down on this income track which can be crippling if you do not manage that and get there just isn't the opportunity for people to get these tiles every single round meaning that somebody is going to have to pay and you're already on that knife edge as well at all times in taking these loans
because whenever you go below a set well whenever you run out of money and you have to pay your money you have to take one of these loan tiles which are going to suffer make you suffer a massive penalty in points but they'll give you a 10 a 10 pound loan and then you can pay back those ten pounds at a later date in order to reduce that negative point but that's still you don't want to be doing that because again suffering negative five points each um or for every loan you'd have is um going to really cost you at the end of the game while i absolutely love that money management of you know how much can i spend how much do i need to keep back to pay my input to pay my employees because again they're gonna cost money um can i reduce that by going on that westminster track how much money have i got incoming next round through these bonuses and things um and even like the upgrades and income track and just that economic puzzle of mapping things out to the precise level knowing what you can spend and what you can't spend is where the game really shines but you have to understand that that is potentially going to turn a lot of people off because of the potential for analysis paralysis here so i think it's kind of the elephant in the room when you have a game that can be this perfectly and precisely mapped out you are going to get people trying to mid-max every single placement which is fine and a big part of the game but bearing in mind that this is what you're getting into when you play this game it is a very strict a very tight and a very precise style of economic game which is going to lead some people into that zone of you know taking long drawn out very cash carefully planned turns rather than just going with the um you know going with the gut reactions hoping things work out
you know if you do that it's probably going to cost you where if you are more kind of mathematically inclined and like to map things out and you don't really mind taking that bit of time to ponder over your turn to make things you're getting getting things right if you are that type of player then you're probably going to get a lot out of this game there is also another layer of potential analysis paralysis because when you actually map out all your dice and um you know worked out perfectly what you need to pay what you can pay where you mean to place them and because you're doing that simultaneously secretly and then you reveal you then kind of have to very carefully remember exactly when you intended to place each of your die which is um which can be annoying because sometimes you think you know i really want that one to go there i want that to go there i've wrapped this up perfectly but when it comes back to your turn you might forget where you intended to have to work it all out again and start from scratch and despite me really enjoying the tightness and the money management part of the game i do think that falling three down on that income track every round is a little bit too punishing um so you did feel like you were really working hard just to keep your head afloat in the game which i suppose is that good kind of tension you know i never have actually found myself forced to take a loan so maybe i'm just being a bit pedantic there but maybe two would have been a bit better for me the tightness for the worker placement spots themselves is also palpable and that does again tie back to how much you're going to bid for these um for these dice faces because you know sometimes you both really want this spot here and you both prepare a really high um high die face so therefore you end up spending all that money and then
somebody's going to get shut out which can become very frustrating if you have bid quite a lot of money because again because money is so tight but that really is dependent on the way you look at it you know that does just really ramp up the decision space and how much you have to plan things and prepare for contingencies i also think that the variation of the different inventions is great they all offer really cool rewards and even sometimes hindrances and you need to kind of map out what the net gain is going to be from that but i also think that the attention to detail on the way that the score is fantastic because if you have a certain type of car that's going to constantly give you a benefit each round then it's probably going to be worth fewer points if you get it earlier whereas if you buy it later and you don't get the rewards or the benefit from it so many times then you get compensated through victory points and i think this is actually a part of board gaming that is massively ignored i've only ever seen a few games utilize this as it should be to keep things bouncing to keep that incentive to purchase these cards later in the game even if you wouldn't squeeze the benefit from them time and time again so i do really like that but something i wasn't massively keen on was the way that these cards pair with the characters themselves because often the partnerships won't even come out because you can only ever have kind of three characters available each time and three inventions available each time yes you can reserve them and um keep them back for a later turn and wait until the character comes out but sometimes just passively you'll find yourself getting those four extra points where somebody might work equally as hard and not get those four extra points
so that's something i didn't think was completely necessary for the game the desire to go all to all the different locations is great you need the um you need the cards of course to get your points you need these telescopes to stop you from um suffering all those negative points and to get the ongoing benefits or one-off benefits the um you know the shares themselves are crucial to make sure you've got the income and the points there uh the westminster track while the benefits aren't great you want to be making sure that you're not having to pay those wages every single round and the characters are a bit cheaper and can offer some cool benefits as well um the objectives offer a good way to climb up that buzz track to get to those checkpoints these ones here will give you a little injection of resources that you might need or get you on that black market track make sure you're getting more income each round and um again the same applies to the waterloo station so everything is great and you want to go to everything and you'll find yourself kind of dipping your toes in all the different regions all the different boards and which is what you want you know there's not a part of the game that's completely neglected so there are a ton of decisions you have to make and you know balancing it all together is all part of this euro economic simulation puzzle which i think is very well executed and even the actual the way the game flows and you know the pacing of the game is decent you know it is seven phases which is normally a bit overkill but they are all pretty digestible in their own right and um it's not going to be too much of an overhead just just after a round or two to understand how it flows and how it works so yeah i'm surprised actually how well it does work and how smoothly it operates and despite it being a relatively heavy game now i will say that the black market is probably the part of the game that feels the least
intuitive out of everything um because there is this option where if you're in this kind of part of the board here that when you place when you're working you can slip down and take one of these cogs and it just felt a little bit unnecessary in a bit i don't just felt a little bit extra and a bit too fussy for me now i did mention at the start of the video this game does take around two hours to play on average that is going to be give or take depending on that player count and i will say that kind of corresponds to the uh the scalability of the game i really can't ever see myself ever wanting to play this with more than three players to be honest because there is so much mapping out and so much potential for careful planning and that meticulous ap style of gameplay and whereas if it gets that four or five player account it's just going to become too long too paralyzing and even the bidding mechanism is going to become a bit too chaotic and just too unpredictable where you can't really get into the head of your opponent and understand what they're going to do i think the replayability for crystal palace is decent you know everybody's got their own different nation board here and there's a ton of these and they're double-sided for all these different objectives just to give a slight different feel um additionally the setup of the buzz tracker is going to be different from game to game where all these different things go in different spots of course the different characters are going to come out of different orders uh the the inventions are going to come out in different orders and you've also got these um london times part as well where again from games game the actual objectives that you go for is going to change and therefore might kind of change the pacing of the game and change what you're going to go for in terms of strategy the interaction of the game is passive which is probably what you want if
you're playing a game like this anyway but i will stress again that the competition and the fierceness to get to these work placement spots is really hot so you need to make sure that you are um you know bearing in mind what the other people are doing and you can't just hope for the best and think that you know what i'm going to get a nice spot there because even if you do it's probably going to cost you extra money which you might not be able to afford so yeah you really do need to consider about what the other people do and they are going to really dictate what you can and can't do on your turn once again ties back to the planning and just general interaction of the game so again not only have you got the competition of the action spots but maybe you both have the same character maybe you're both after the same invention so it's just all that kind of classic euro passive nature which you'd probably expect from a game like this i think the production for this game is generally of a very high standard and it does have that more kind of classical beige style style euro feel and but the cars themselves will look great and they're over high quality iconography is generally good there were a few things we had to look in the rulebook to see how some characters worked in things but that was generally an exception um and i would say that i would have much preferred this to be on maybe one larger board because it feels a bit messy and a bit scatty to be all these different boards um sprawled around the table and it becomes a bit of a table hog you know once you've got it all set up there's just stuff everywhere which can be a bit yeah bit too much um consuming in terms of the space it takes but um everything else works fine you can clearly see what everything does all the cardboard stock is of a high quality the dice is decent all the wooden pieces are decent you know these assistants and things and even all the cardboard tokens
such as the money the wooden resources and the loans all the high standard and which you probably expect from capstone games okay so let's get into my final thoughts on crystal palace so straight up i think this game is rock solid there's a lot to be enjoyed here if you like this style of game the tightness and the way you have to manage your your funds and your resources is so tense and it's a really kind of engaging part of the game i enjoy a lot maybe a little bit too punishing at times but again that's that's what you're kind of signing up for if you get into this game i do think that if you like these style games you're pretty much a banker to enjoy this one but i think if you're on the fence with a game like this this isn't going to change your mind or isn't going to have anything unique enough or interesting enough to make you think yeah this is the game that's going to break that trend and maybe try an economic euro simulation game like this but um i would say that the kind of main takeaway for me is the actual dice bidding mechanism itself i think that's a brilliant idea i'd love to see it be used again in different games because i think it just adds so much interesting choice and when it's tied to you know how much you're going to spend for doing that it's just a brilliant idea and again i'm surprised it hasn't been used before there's a lot of plates you need to spin when playing this game keeping your money afloat um making sure you're covering up all these negative spaces getting your income um obviously buying the cars themselves um everything is worth dipping your toe into and exploring it all and it all comes together pretty smoothly considering now that does have a couple of rough edges for me
but i think that really takes away from the gameplay experience itself i think it's rock solid and i can see why this game is so revered um i think the issue for me personally is that i have so many dice placement style games that i'm not sure if this one really stands above the rest i think it's probably on a similar level um but i'm not sure if the actual dice placement system that i enjoy a lot is enough to make me keep it around so despite me enjoying the game a lot i'm not sure if it's going to cover place in my collection for long term but i certainly think if you enjoy this style of game this is definitely going to check out it doesn't do anything tremendously new but it does what it does well and it you know it works well for a heavier style game it does you know it works remarkably smoothly and it makes a lot of sense once you get the initial rules overhead out of your system so it's a solid game a very tight punishing game but again if you enjoy that style of thing you're probably going to enjoy this one a lot um and i say this one is definitely worthy of a shield of quality i can't certainly take away from the gameplay itself and i think it's um definitely has a certain pedigree of being a well-designed well ironed out and a clever game that's going to absolutely frazzle your brain at times