This War of Mine Board Game Review
Transcript
Oh welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk about it bollocks but April top gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking from about eighty 2017 some people call it the dark some people call it blink it's this Ward mind the ball game and in this game what you'll be doing to be literally scrabbling around in the dirt tryna scavenge resources fend off threats to your house in order to survive til the end of the game in this video we will be giving you a very brief overview or the rules will be telling you what we do like what we don't like and if we will come back and will tell you whether or not this war mind ball game is worth playing today so if you know and please consider subscribing to our channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this board games for K so this war of mine how do you play this game so if this game is but unique it claims that it can teach you the rules actually played again in the fall of this journal document and this it claims to go to through the the rules and it doesn't do a good job will get too out of it so yeah this game you set the game I get you dip for all these cards out and you said I came up as the journal tells you
and then you'll work your way through one day which equates to one round and then you're rinse wash repeat and then you'll go through the audio vent decks and when you get to the end hopefully you've survived in tags the game starts off in the morning phase and it remembers to the day actions will be taken actions there you'll be down into the dust goes into the Aiden face and then you will be motivated scavenging you will fend off some nitrates and then it tells you will become dawn again and you'll have a few scraps along the way and so first finger going to do is you're going to draw the top card in the event that you are going to resolve that cards this could be good to cookie batter Germany's bad and that's the first thing that you are going to do so the next thing you're going to do is the player that holds the journalist in possession of the journal will move the character pieces to different locations different action spaces and then they will resolve simultaneously which is a bit ways similar so you resolve all the actions that these players are on other players can voice their opinion it will be even says you can quarrel about it but eventually but essentially the player that holds a journal is gonna be in control of their final decision so some of the actions that you can take you can take the action on show cards or think art so each shell cartoon might you might be blocks by rubble you might be able to search a heap you might be able to do and make saying out of a pair of furniture or you might be able to take a fitting from the fittings deck whether it's an idea when it's object and it build that so some of the fittings build you could build a workshop you could build bet you could build a radio you can even brew up some
moonshine to get drunk right and apparently that improves you want more route so some of the things that you might need you might need some items to negotiate some of the obstacles that you might find in the app so something you might need a lockpick to open a closed door you might need a shovel to remove the rubble there's only certain ways that you can move through the house based on a local charter you go on a safe sheet there's also holes in the house that you have to be worried about and you can also go outside during a date but there's a one in 10 chance you might get shot in the head by straights not the book so that's a bit dodgy that's the day face that's the action face that you could do so you got to remember that each character could perform only up to three actions but there the number of actions I could perform it's dictated by the conditions that they hold see if your character's miserable at one of the characters if you don't get a cigarette at the end of every day then it gets really miserable and you know you might be fatigued you might be you might be wounded so the all the different conditions do affect the amount of actions that you can do so it's a good idea to make sure that your part is in the best of health and mentally and physically done the actions and you're moving to the dusk face and this is where you basically gotta feed your people Agricola starting right so each character needs one food and one more and if you don't provide that then you raise their hunger level by one and that is always bad once you've dealt with dinner time then you move into the evening face and you will assign each character to one of four available slots right so you can tell a character to sleep in a bed miss will alleviate any fatigue that they've
accrued during the round a character can sleep on the floor and again this will alleviate some fatigue that they may have acquired you have to put one of your characters on guard to be in the rule book dust Terrier it's probably best to send somebody with a good prowess go to guard the door and you can have up to three characters that you can go on scavenger hunts or so you'll be send them outside to various locations so I can have a route around and see what I can find so while if you go remember if you go on a scavenger hunt then you will get 40 Co you have to raise everyone's fatigue level by one when they go scavenging so the way that you deal with scavenging is you will look at one of the three locations and you will choose one of them and you'll send two characters off to that location you'll choose any equipment you want to take the trade or any weapons that you want to take with you and you'll stick it in the findings space on the border you'll set the noise level to one because the more noise you make when you're out scavenging the worse things can get and why it always works if you if the game tells you to roll for noise you always have to roll higher than the current noise level and if you don't you'll have to draw a resonance card and generally the residents of the outside world are pretty vicious people to deal with so the way that these locations work is what you'll do you look at the number alongside a location you're gonna piss it in don't draw that number effects exploration cards and put them in the unknown space on a board right and then what you'll do is you'll go for it if that one ball armors organ each cup but you can also give up a certain number it's exploitation cards in order to get benefits so if you look at the locations card you'll see you can trade into
exploration cards for a benefit and some other cards might allow you to give up the circus you'll be burning through this deck of a quick or slow depending on what benefits or not so once you've burnt through the exploration deck then the scavenging phase ends anything that you've found it goes into the the find in space and you'll be taken the players and anything that they collected back to your house it during the door face but there's a limit that sort of stuff you can take based on the players inventory score right after you've dealt with a scavenge and fight you're gonna be dealing with nine right send them anyone let's put on a card spice to guard the house will then have to deal with the noise will draw the top card item right right deck you will resolve it it's more often than not gonna be a really bad fight so you if you have to resolve combat encounter you look at the child aboard it will tell you if you go on a non compact you will just wrote a great art if you've got the fuel carrying a weapon you are the yellow dye and melee weapon if it got farm you all the red dye and you have to get a certain number of successes so the more people you've got on the guard space the bell boy depending on the character's prowess score you get that many revolves during the night race face so you might also have to be told to take the crime wave cards from the side of the board that you place edge and start them then shuffle them into the nitrate scarcer might be an extra added threat that might appear during the game so once you've dealt with a nitrates and hopefully you've survived they're all the blood and guts and terror and threats that have tried to assault your house you will then go
through the dawn face what you will do you will take all your players back from their locations and all the stuff that they found they carried back into your supply you'll be able to heal up you'll be able to so I met some bandages if you've got any and then you will draw a faked card and this Morphin the knot will allow you to swap out one of the locations that you may or may not visit once you've done that then you will draw a narrative action card and when we plate this we've got Germany got the choice between two cards so you look at one you look at not one and they will choose one and put a shot for the other one back into the deck and it will give you more often and I'll give you a benefit like a visitor will come or you'll be able to get a benefit of some kind during the game another point so what you do you once you've gone through the journal you've got that to the beginning of it you'll start the round again you'll keep doing this until you are dead or you've gone through the whole of the event thickness to throw out the event thickness Peppard certain objectives that if you completely objective boil it's harm it comes up you'll get a benefit if you don't then you'll get a penalty so is this that's be mindful of us works but the main thing you need to do is you need to have at least one of your start survivors alive when you burn through your vent deck and that's roughly roughly how you played this war mine the Balkan so what do we like about this war of mine the board game thing that we fingers absolutely amazing about this game is the way this game is so richly the magic it's got great power work that really accurately evokes the
feel of the original video game and it looks as though they've lifted that same heart walk directly Hervey maybe the stills that they created for the for the video game so that's absolutely wonderful of these so it's a really sort Belleek and you've got this sort of monochrome or feel to the board but it's peppered with Reds that really avoid Sensodyne Jess I props to the artist who designed the artwork in his claim so the second thing that we really like about this game is the way that the book of scripts adds to the overall atmosphere of the game and what happens is during a game you look at some cards or different mechanisms in the game will tell you to turn to a specific paragraph in a book like a condor like a fighting fantasy sort of choose your own adventure type book and you'll read out the paragraph and then it will give you maybe you like a choice to make or take the role that I would give to do something on like nothing way up nothing will happen it really does add to the the tense feel of the gangs you never know what is gonna be revealed in that book of scripts and okay this the the right in in it isn't that great and there are kind of like weird instances where the book of scripts tells you to go outside and you just meet somebody and nothing happens overall the book of scripts does add to the theme of this game and that's always a good thing so another thing that we really like about this it's the way that the game by the way it's structured in the morning right the way through the nights of it to the dawn it's got this sense of sprawl it's got a sprawling nature so you know you might just be the first facial notes it might just be drawing an event card and then
moving through the house taking actions and then you might go so then you're gonna go scavenge it then you've got a deal with Knight Riders so it's got this even though you know you're just moving this these pieces around a border you're flipping cards or whatever does feel like there's lots of variation and lots of is it's bigger than the sum of its parts it's like watching a film you know those sort of straddles and loads and loads of locations but you comes together in a really complete whole yeah the fact that this there's so many really important portions to game is is a wonderful thing so the fourth and final thing we're going to talk about that we like about this game is the solo experience it's probably one of the best solo experiences that you can get I think in a ball game today we've completed a review of major night a couple of weeks ago and while it doesn't Rawal that this game does play best and at its best as one player for solo and you can't you can't play too but this game really is sort of suited to a very lonely experience and that's probably the nature again yet so what don't we like about this war of mine the Borg first thing that we found frustrating about this game sadly is this thing is the joke this way I get this this was rubbish this is mincer this was meant to teach you the game without reading the rulebook and what happens as you go through this and it gives you these references with an FAQ and you end up a trillion a rulebook and it's it's dense text it's very small text there's broken
text and it would have been better had they given you at least the option of reading the rules beforehand rather than flicking through their sisters it should have been just been a playwright like matron either what idea they gave you a walk for n - they gave you a proper rule book as well so this is rubbish so another thing that we really found frustrating about this as a loads and loads of rules are really unclear and the both the journal and the book of scripts mentions things that you you haven't come across it so you'll be gone through this methodically and until you've played it a few times we've gone through a few rounds we were left scratching oh it's it's like what does that mean what was well we haven't done combat yet how do we know what that isn't it will mention something on the board and you'll be like well is that this is is that do they mean this and this there's also cards that were very unclear okay one of the cards says look at this chart below and it's just got a load of items that you're gonna pick up and it's got a guy next to it an instant text at the bottom about the findings that you're gonna do and it's it doesn't tell you what you meant to do so we were just sat there going well we're just do listen and it's I think was the bloody thing but we're still 100% sure so yeah I think the fact that you're not actually giving a rulebook to clarify things before you get into the game it does lead to a lot confusion with some of the rules so another thing we found for Australian about this and I suppose we shouldn't found it frustrating because the games men to be hard right but we found ourselves with an abundance of wood we found ourself with abundance of the components we we never really
struggled for food the only thing that we struggled with was finding water we never managed to figure out where you've got water from in this game so is it seems a bit unbalanced did it froze all these things at you all these components oh yeah the essential stuff that you need is very short supply and you think well the fact you can't trade anything for water or food either you can't trade water for food components or wood or whatever and you can't do it vice versa either so it seemed a bit weird we had an abundance of one thing but of complete lack of another and so another thing don't we found frustrating about this is it's the same Sophos from the same thing the core box of eldritch horror suffered from and that is the lack of available cards so they sort of cheats or with a little bit by making you shuffle cards back into decks to try but you think that there's more cards and there are and okay you're taking a few cars out of going but you'll be shuffling in the visitors back in you'll be shuffling certain cards back into the deck you'd be using that exploration deck again and again and again it is there's not enough cards in here to have a substantial amount of replayability so the final thing that we're gonna moan about with this game is the fact that a lot of the choices just come down to a random doll whether it's the combat when you're rolling a six-sided die to try and guess our number of successes or whether your role in that black die to pick locks or whether the book of scripts tells you to do it or whether your role in that the die to see where you get our locations
there's too much randomness there's too much engine on a random dollar and some people might say that's for Meg due to the nature of the game but to me it's a lazy lazy mechanic and it's a lazy lazy design so to summarize is this war of mine worth playing today so we're gonna say yes is worth plan is a fun yet flawed experiment that steals other ideas from other games that once the same and it's polar opposite so you've got the book of scripts that the the tales of the Arabian Nights immediately springs to mind and that's like the complete opposite of this game thematically right and then also you've got the mechanisms that have directly taken out of Robinson Crusoe where you constantly battling against this impossible situation so so on one end this war mind ball kinase succeeds so you sort of you've got a contradiction air so whereas the terms of the Arabian Nights succeeds with the the book of tables aspects it again because it is a light HEIs a fantasy so a game it can do what it wants in the book of tales it can be as outlandish as it wants it can be as descriptive as it wants all non-descriptive as it wants it it doesn't matter because the game is a complete fantasy whereas this game is gritty is trying to be ultra realistic it's trying to put you into the position of somebody who is fighting for their life and there's just
not enough detail in the book of scripts to carry that sense of despair across accurately so whilst we think that this is genuinely interesting and a very intriguing game and we do wanna play again we did find ourselves we did find the game actually quite hilarious I mean it seems we're here I know the game is meant to be deadly serious way but for us it was so bleak and so disconcerting that we found ourselves laughing as some of the situations that came up like we when we had withdrew visitor cards we were shuffled these cars back into the deck and we helped but this God it kept turning up and we could over bring him into the into the shower and take his stuff and help he could help us through tasks and stuff or what you send him away and we send him away and he came back so we said I was him again he I had like Orion coming in tonight any came back again and it was just we found that absolutely hilarious and we found ourselves put in such a position where we couldn't get into the theme of the game at all really so we we went the other way we turned of and start laughing with the game that some of the ridiculously awful situation that a person and what some people might say that that's outrageous and it probably is but that's the way that that's what happened when we played it so it's a it's a contradiction in terms you know for us the tries to put you in a position of this person or these people that are fighting for their lives fighting for their existence and at the same time that is absolutely hilarious
alright so there you go that's this war mine we're gonna give it free enough stars out five is it's okay we do into a planet we we like seeing what's gonna happen but we're not going to take you seriously we don't feel like you know we're for loss when you play it's just a matter of going through the motions seeing what the game froze out I froze up here and trying to combat it as best you can whilst worrying about random 10/10 sided dolls so that's it that's this war mine remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to our channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you next time