Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lords of Waterdeep vs Marvel Age of Heroes - Comparing the two games from the same designer!

Transcript 18:45

hello everyone I'm Stella and I'm Terence from Maple University and this is Marvel Age of Heroes from wizkids yes why am I excited about this game it is from the same designer as the well-loved 20 2012 game Lots Awards a team remember how many times we played this at the near the start of our journey and we played this many times and it could be a long game so I remember one time we played this so long at the Meetup they almost shot we had to Chuck everything from the table to the Box just like indeed yes it's by uh by one of the two designers of Lords of water these yes sorry yeah Rodney Thompson yeah this is a X-men theme yes yes so this game has got similar feel to lots of water deep so if you for those who like that then this would feel like that a different theme so I'm gonna give you an overview and then what we think of it yes so this is a this is an X-Men game um I think Marvel these days people think Avengers but eventually they'll think X-Men again I do miss the X-Men movie so come on 2025 I think it's only 25. and X-Men was X-Men was the comics that I grew up with that was the one um hey did you so did I well one of the comics so this is fundamentally a worker

placement game each player has a pair of X-Men so I've got uh the southerners here Gambit and Rogue uh depending on your Play account you'll have somewhere between three and six meeples which are these standees which show your X-Men front and back and for the most part they just behave as workers but there'll be some effects some upgrades that'll be specific to one of your particular X-Men then in turn order you'll go back and forward making worker placement actions on anything showing a an icon like this the game the round kind of plays in two halves in the first half you place at the top of the board or onto the xjet so if I place someone at the top of the board I would take that action if I place someone onto an xjet this is just six workers who can be then placed in that order at the bottom of the board during the second half of the round ultimately the aim is to get points and a lot of your points will come from defeating the enemies although there are three different scenarios in the game so exactly how they all work and how many points each thing is worth in each one is going to vary from Scenario it's a scenario the major ways to defeat these there's essentially a contract of resources so

red yellow and blue which are physical attack mental attack and willpower you'll be trying to make combinations that correspond to the point scoring lines on these cards and then when someone has gone on the xjet you can go there spend those resources and get the points once a an enemy is gone there's some additional bonuses these will then be changed out for other enemy cards and eventually the scenario and the end game is triggered by defeating the major enemy so it could be a longer or a shorter game depending on how long it takes the players to get there otherwise the basic actions on the board are pretty straightforward you've got actions here that let you gain resources and you've got actions that let you draw cards and you've got actions that let you play cards the types of cards in the game you've got Ally cards when you play an ally it goes onto a space with this green icon you mark it with your player color and it's a new action space and then if any if you take you can take it do the effect here it would be getting a couple of these non-hero pawns that you can use in most of the spaces if another player I didn't give you meeples for example if another player took it there we go then I would get the benefits shown here so there's various different benefits there these ones tend to be about building up your resources

then there's team up cards so you can have an effect that lets you play a team up card these are other ways to defeat the enemy so here instead if I found one of the enemies lines that had a PSI on it instead of paying the resources shown here I could pay the resources on here and put my marker down on any one of these there are event cards one soft effects that you would resolve from this effect and then discard and then you've got Evolution cards and these are personal engine building benefits for your X-Men and these are the ones that apply to a specific X-Man like I said before yeah for example right this is a rogue one I could play this here and then after a signing Rogue I could draw a card so these you can build them up they start to get expensive as you go along the board but these give you some nice little engine building bonuses is it raining I think it's raining wow I didn't expect it's going to be raining here anyways I don't know if you can hear it kept going too much now that's all they can hear yeah I know how to listen for it I know it's soothing isn't it raindrops get fouling on my head no on the roof all right continue well that that is pretty much it actually so you play those four types of cards as that goes on more and more action spaces are going to open up more and more ways of defeating the enemies are going to open up and many of these cards will

have different uh Point scoring means as well so here for example if you've placed on this one uh banshee's the leader of Generation X and at the end of the game you'll get at the end of the round you'll get six points for every meeple you placed on a Generation X cards this one's an X-Man but they'll be some of these which belong to different factions and so you can you can start to level up your points in those ways as well um as mentioned there's three different scenarios so it doesn't just mean different enemies this is the first scenario I've set up and there's a lot of different enemies that you can Shuffle in as well so plenty of difference from game to game the game will start to escalate so we've got this generic extraction Zone space here and from round to round or for after every three rounds these will start to level up to more powerful abilities at the end of the game it just gives you this easy way of getting resources or points and it's really going to drive the end game um I think that really that really covers it I love it so I was like waiting for it like so I love lots of water deep it feels a little bit you can see that some of the mechanics probably slightly all like you can see the more modern games is quite different at times it's not a bad thing it's just yes I love love lots of water dream a lot of worker placement and this is similar it feels similar to lots of water tape where at the start

they are only certain spaces that you can go to but as the game goes you can play cards where people can go to as spaces in lots of water dip it was it's the building buildings and you can start going there benefits of the place so that's very similar yep you start getting rewards when players use your building yes yes and before the buildings are there there's only really one way to get each resource yeah so that feels very very similar yep yep so at the start like oh no where else I can't go but then

two complete missions on in lots of water dip where here you still need the resources but you go and fight enemies it's a very similar now there's something that is I think this is a bit more than Lots what it did which is the Synergy the combo so first you play these two and then they you know itch so each player board has got different sides and then different characters two characters you can play with and then the casa you play you try to find the right or I wouldn't say broken combo but it's almost like you're trying to find a broken combo that will give you lots of resources lots of points but then again it's not so much as broken because other peoples can have access to those as well yeah I got a very whistle Mountain feel okay when I played this game because that's something I thought always tended to come out in whistle Mountain very different type of game but as the tiles are placed in whistle Mountain they set up these little combo sets that you can just kind of work and score heaps of points on while it's there yeah this this has a bit of that Vibe you know I Gambit has a power that this one here after you assign Gambit and play a an event card you get four points so you just use your Gambit meeples to play lots of events yeah yeah exactly and I feel like in with two players it feels attack it could be a tad longer um with two players it also

depends on the the enemies and how it turns out and so on but if in the higher play accounts you only have as you mentioned earlier less number of meeples so your actions are quite more restricted more limited you get less points and you know it just feels different in a way yeah I would say the two biggest differences between this game and Lords of Water Deep let's say the gaining of resources and the way this works very very similar with the exception that I feel like you've got more meeples than spaces to stop whereas that was less the case in water do um the major difference is that instead of going and getting the mission card and then resolving it from your hand they're all out here on the board and it's all first come first serve and it makes this it makes your choice of placement here on the xjet quite important and there's also some events and Powers up here that let you jump straight to placing something here and bypassing this queue and that using those at the right time becomes very important as well and it was you know it's deceptive but that was that timing and placement thing sometimes it feels really straightforward the powerful stuff gets used up quickly and then the turn order space gets used up um but there ends up being lots of different ways to manage that yeah yeah you I will I will say the first the first four rounds it felt like Russian railroads were there with like two

obvious first things everyone took and then someone took the turn order thing to make sure they got it next time yeah but it really started to open up as the game went on correct especially these ones right I just thought oh I really want to upgrade I really need to to be first player because I want to do this one there's only one space there but then you know there are other cars that let you do that too so also there's heaps of options for these cards as well um there's a recommended set for your first play but each X-Men has a number of different powers and you can play with those combos as well it's card sometimes I feel like like no one wants um and it just stays there that's true there's a couple of reset mechanisms you always have to add a new card to there for someone else to get before you pick up but yeah there's an opportunity there on most of them yeah but overall it is for me and get ready for it was like two hours three hours it's longer than the like for a simple rules maybe attack could be a tat longer again um in a blur play accounts than the high play accounts I mean when I say a tat longer then your game is like long and you can just build build your engine which is actually if you like engine building that would be a good thing but yes so just watch out for that and overall it's it for me foreign yeah overall I think it's quite a fun

game I don't think it is you're really good at at conveying your your actions together like okay you go there and then you can fight the bosses and the enemies and then at the same time getting points because your other meatballs are on certain locations yeah the first time we played I also completely I was in the box seat and then lost by 30 points just on one bad meeple placement as well because I completely wrecked my turn order in the next jet yeah it was the end you kind of like want to rush Russell accident I need to go there first and then four four resources towards the ends great compared to Tuesday and you can see that four three and two so blue usually tend to be the hardest one to get I think in lots of water Dippers certain resources a little bit harder to get as well yeah I think overall what I would say for this game is it feels it's definitely a lot of fun it's a bit of a light kind of random it's got a lot more chaos I think your typical yeah the typical worker place and because of that because the cards are going to mix things up so much and it's quite a big deck of cards it has a little bit of chaos it feels done so you know we made so many references to Lords of water detail it's a 10 year old game 11 year old game that um there's not that many games coming out like it because you know it it's a basic worker

placement game it doesn't have twists and turns it's kind of something that's been done to you know to put it in a in a blunt way but there's the combo though the combo was not really present that much in loss of water dip so there's a lot of you know as I mentioned earlier the combos are different like how do you make the all games I mean have you play it lost what is it please let us know if you haven't that's okay it's a white replacement game recommended as well but this is just more the combo that you can try to achieve to gain you even more resources or even more points yeah I think what I'd say for it is that you know that was sounding quite negative what I'm saying is there's nothing there's nothing new necessarily It's Kind it's it's a basic worker placement but there's enough fun stuff going on here um that can let you play in a number of different ways and I think that makes it really work quite well as a game I think that really makes it the sort of game that would that should be really replayable if I think back to where to you know if I were in my teens and I were playing worker placements at the time I think this would have a lot more staying power than lots of water deep because I think the Combos and the differences that would start to come out here um it would be a lot more varied from game to game very very yeah lots of replayabilities and that's not even taking into account the fact that there's three scenarios and they add

different cards to the deck and different ways for ends to trigger so this is the sort of thing where if you're if you're not the sort of people who are you know going through games one or two plays and passing them on this could have real staying power and if you like the X-Men then it's got all the characters there of course phase five or six or whatever is gonna bring the X-Men back so yeah maybe there's a big market for it coming in a couple years yeah maybe hopefully or if you play this if you look look it up it plays up to five thank you place up to five and it is one that I think is worth keeping that's what I think one thing I will say that is uh a small challenge for the game is that because there are a lot of cards there is a bit of ambiguity and confusion sometimes between how they work there's a lot of cards that let you do the effect of another card and the card will say this card and that card and sometimes it can be a little ambiguous exactly what the card is going to mean more so than I would usually like to see so I think that's probably a little bit of a downside um again with repeated plays you'll either work it out or you'll work out your own house rule of exactly how you want to do it it doesn't detract from the game as long as you get to a point where you know how they work we'll also just quickly show you who the playable sets are so we've got a Gambit

and Rogue Jean Gray and cyclops uh we've got Forge and storm it's a Duo yep yep virgin storm and interestingly they're not always even sets this one has four storm meeples and two of Forge yes uh we've got magic it's just magic very powerful if you like go filling for maybe Captain Marvel maybe I don't know uh Kitty Pride with Lockheed oh yeah and then everyone's favorite uh Duo Jubilee oh yes so everyone's favorite is it your favorite as well that's awesome everyone's favorite but they were a fun they were a fun car I know that's Jubilee always uh chilled Wolverine out a bit oh wow that's it there we go so so somehow please let us know please say something in the comments please let me know let us know that you are there if you have any questions any suggestions and anything you want to say about this game or lots of what I did please let us know oh I'm looking forward for it and if you haven't subscribed to us please do if you like and hit the Bell we have life let's show almost every weekend so hopefully we'll see you there as well and I'm on Instagram and that's it thanks for watching see you next time

Progress saved