Village Green Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at village green which is a small box card game designed by pier sylvester and published by osprey games this one accommodates one to five players and takes around 30 minutes to play so set up the game is going to look like this we have these two decks of cards and three cards of each of those decks laid out so you've got the blue deck here which have these scoring cards on them and which is going to be the way you're going to score points and you're going to have these green cards here which were the actual icons on them which relates to the scoring objectives each player is going to have their own little tableau of cards which is going to make a 4x4 grid of cards in the top left you're going to have this village card here which doesn't really do much apart from offering you a point if you don't use its benefit by the end of the game but i'll touch on that a little bit later on the top row you have three randomly allocated scoring cards and the idea is you're going to build a a four by four grid of cards with again these scoring cards on the top row and in the left most column and in these nine spaces in between that's where you're gonna be putting these green cards um each player is going to be given three green cards at random to consist of their hand and then the game is going to begin so on a player's turn they can take one of two possible actions the first of which is to draw a um a scoring card and place it on there on their own little village here and when you take those scoring cards if it's not a solo game you can actually overlap the pre-existing scoring culture so let's just take a look at some of these scoring cards so these cards here are looking for these yellow roses in this column and each one of those is
going to give you three points each and you've got the color combination card here which you're looking for a set of each of the flowers in the same colors and you know you're going to get the relative amount of points here potentially losing points if you get certain colors this one here is looking for lawns and so it's going to correspond to a card like this and again the more launch you have you get a massive potential up to eight points if you have three lawns in this column so yeah you're going to be looking at objectives here and trying to build towards something with these green cards and of course that is going to be the second option which is to draw a green card either from the three face up ones or you can take one from the um from the deck here face down and add it to your house let's just say for example uh i'll take this lawn card because i know that um that i'm looking for lawn cards for that particular criteria and then i'm instantly going to replace that card and with one from the stack so now of course i'd have four cards in my hand and i'm gonna choose to play one of those cards into my village so let's go for a no-brainer one here and shove my first lawn into this column here because i want to be building towards lawn cards for this lawn scoring objective and then it's going to go on to the next player however if it's a solo mode of course it's going to be your turn again we're going to do the same thing so let's um let's take another card here so maybe i'll go for um go for this card here and i'm going to go for this one here which is going to score me a point for each of my building cards in this particular row now so again i'm going to replace the um that card from the from the stack and then it'll be my next
turn again and i'm going to be drawing a card from the center here and perhaps i'd play this this building card here because this row is now looking for buildings so i'm going to get two points for each building in this row however whenever you place a building you must immediately draw a scoring card again from either the face up ones or from the face down ones so let's just say i'll take um i'll take this one here and aim towards building something in the future these lily cards um however something i do need to touch on is the restrictions in which you can place these cards or not because um this is actually quite a restrictive game and you have some quite um quite dominating um criteria that you can when you can account place cards so first off when you start placing cards next to each other they have to be of either the matching flower type or of the matching color so i could place this for example because the um that particular flower matches this flower i could place it here because these lawn cards don't have any restrictions on them at all and however in the future i could not place this um this lily card here because again it's not matching a um the flower type or the color type i could put it here like this i could put this card here like this i could i could even put this card here like this because this one is matching this flower type this color and this flower type as well so again the more cards you build out here you're going to find yourself backed into a bit of a
corner and sometimes you'll need very specific cards in order to place them onto your tableau one time during the game you can choose to flip your village card over like so and sacrifice the point on it in order to either wipe these um wipe a row of these cards out and draw a new three if you don't like the options available to you or you can actually choose to go past the restriction of not being able to place on top of the cards already there so let's just say for example i really didn't like this card i could choose to put this one on top of it and overlap the existing one and then the game is going to end once somebody has built their whole tableau of village cards here or until one of these decks run out so once that end game has been triggered you're going to take a look at all your cards and score up accordingly so the first thing you're going to look at is if your village card has been flipped or not so in my case it has been flipped so i'm not going to get the point on the reverse side of it and then i'm going to go through all the different cards systematically and see what my score is going to be so this one here the rose garden is looking for three points for every yellow rose in that column so i've got two yellow roses here for six points i'm looking for a color combination of um specific um flower arrangements here which i haven't achieved so i'm not going to get any points for that one this one here is looking for lawns so again i'm going to get lawn points i've only got one lawn here for a single point uh according to this card you've got this man-made features here which is looking for buildings so here you can see i've made two buildings which is actually going to score me negative points um because i was maybe being a bit optimistic there
i'm trying to go for the three but i couldn't get that achieved um the uh this one here is looking for these flowers here which again i haven't achieved so no points there and the final one here this uh symmetrical forestry it's looking for every two each of each type of tree is going to get you two points i've teased that twice here for four points now all of these um river cards all these pond cards are going to give you two points automatically so i've got four points there and something i should have mentioned as well although these um these lawn cards don't really do much in terms of um other than relating to these scoring cards you can't actually you can choose to lay cards on top of them um if you can as long as you abide by the restrictions so this would still be an illegal placement because it doesn't match this particular color or flower type but if you did you can place on top of lawn cards so that's how it's going to play i mean obviously the play with the most points at the end of the game is going to be the winner and if you're playing the solo mode which is pretty much identical you're just going to check your score against this um little chart in the book to see how well you've done so let's talk about how i feel about village green so first off i like how simple this game is i generally like puzzle style games and i like the fact this one is pretty much sticks true to that formula it doesn't try to bite off more than it can chew or be anything that it's not trying to be so i like the fact that it's just got two very simple actions either and take from this deck and play it or automatically add a card from your hand and then play a card to your to your green here so very simple just draw a
card and play a card formula and that doesn't ever kind of go off the rails and you can never get confused about what you can do on your turn i might also like the variability here and the variety of the different types of scoring cards there's a big deck here and every game you're going to have to build towards something else in order to get the most points out of them and it's all about mapping up these different cross hairs where these things meet to try and get the optimal amount of scoring i'm trying not to make them conflict with each other trying to make them all harmonize and get as many points as you can but at the same time you are always kind of putting a straight jacket because you have to abide by those placement restrictions of either being next to the same color or next to the same flower type and that is probably one of the main things i took away from this game was just how restrictive this game is so maybe from a video like this it looked a bit easier than it is in person but you'll often and very frequently find yourself and put in a position where you just can't play anything you want to play and you're gonna have to start building towards something else but of course the more cards you're placing out there um you can't actually overlap them unless you sacrifice your village card once in the game so it is a very tight puzzle and you have very little margin for making errors now i'm not saying that's a negative thing because it certainly isn't but if you want a more breezy relaxed kind of game then be prepared for some frustration and this game isn't maybe what you think it's going to be because it is a very tricky tight little puzzle um i also like the fact that you do have some mitigation what you're going to play because you do have a hand of three cards um so even when you're drawing a
card from the um from the green card here you don't have to play that one automatically you can keep stuff back in your hand for future turns and obviously build for things a bit later so you do have a bit of mitigation there and some play in when you're going to actually place these guards and commit them to your 4x4 grid um i think the balance of the game is generally good you've got some stuff here that of course is going to pull you in different directions some are going to score you negative points but again that kind of goes back to your uh the way you've actually activated things because you know here as i said earlier um i did want to start building towards these three cars but i couldn't get it achieved in time because one of those end game triggers would have happened before i got my third building down on this spot so um you know you do find yourself getting some negative points at time but that's that's perfectly fine and all part of the optimization puzzle so i think in terms of balance and stuff this game doesn't really have any issues i think generally the most efficient and the most the person who's worked out that puzzle the most um the best is going to be the winner um the time investment the game is pretty excellent to be honest you know this game does only take around 30 minutes to play um in a solo mode or in a two-player game you can get it done quicker than that so um it certainly doesn't outstand it's welcome and it stays within it's confines of what it's trying to be uh a nice little personally filler game the uptime of the game is generally good as well yeah there is a little bit of scope for ap but not not a tremendous amount because ultimately you are only um you know building a a 4x4 grid here um and but you are trying to place things optimally of course and trying not to um not try not to undermine your scoring but i
think that min maxing it has a cap on it and it isn't going to be a game that's going to have a massive amount of analysis process and keep you from being engaged in the game and replayability is is pretty good i mean at least in terms of the different objectives and things you know each game you're going to be going for different things as i mentioned um you're going to have a different bunch of cards coming out i'm obviously reacting to what's available from the from the drafting pool here you always have that option if nothing's good here you can choose to take from the deck and of course always fall back on your deck of cards so you're not just subject to the card draw um the interaction in the game is a bit of a double-edged sword in this one so on top of all the restrictions here you're going to find it you're going to find yourself looking for very particular cards at times and sometimes there'll be one card in the middle that you really need and if it's not your turn inevitably someone somebody is going to take that card from under your um from under your nose but um so that kind of ties into my thoughts on this one you know do i prefer this one as a solo experience or as a multiple player experience i actually think i prefer this as a solo game because you can really focus on your own thing here nothing else messing you up too much in terms of people taking cards you want which would normally be fine you know that doesn't bother me too much but because again because there are so many restrictions on your own board anyway that's just a layer too much and has a bit again adds a maybe a sliver too much um too much frustration into the game where as without that it would have been a bit a bit nicer but still has a good it's a good amount of restriction a good amount of puzzle to work out anyway um aesthetically i think the game looks
pretty nice some i like these kind of water muted and cards they look really cool when they're set up um you know really well painted and illustrated here all the scoring objectives are pretty well explained you can't really um misinterpret them so yeah i've got no issues at all it's just a bunch of cards ready and the card stock is is uh more than adequate so no issues at all with the production just a just a bunch of cards um and the theme i suppose is quite pleasant as well you've got this just making a little village green try to make the most most visually appealing garden which i'm you know very inviting and nobody's going to get really turned off by this theme or setting and the setup and tear down time as well just smash a bunch of cards down and you're pretty much good to get going no no real hiccups or speed bumps and getting this onto the table or from packing it away um the progression i think is generally good as well because the more cards you're placing you are really backing yourself more and more into a corner and leaving your options um again just kind of filtering your options down to um to points where you don't really have much say in what you're going to play from now and you need very specific cards as the game develops in order to get the most out of your scoring objectives um and um and comparison-wise you know there are a lot of these puzzly style games you're trying to do this kind of thing um however i do think this one's quite a nice one again it does have an extra layer on being restrictive and which you probably expect from a gate from a designer like pier sylvester um who's kind of not known for these kind of games but his games do normally have some kind of tightness and some kind of
again more restrictions to them that make you feel like you're in a straight jacket at times but yeah overall i think this is a perfectly pleasant game again there are a lot of games like this out there this is a good one um i still i'm not i'm not sold massively on the fact that you do have to buy so tightly by these restrictions and um you know why normally i think that's a good thing it sometimes left me a bit too frustrated um in this one now that being said i would happily play this one pretty much any time because it is so quick it does feel satisfying when you do pull these um pull these placements off and um you know do map up things perfectly it's not a massively scoring game at least not for me because i'm not very good at it but it's um yeah it is what it is really it's not great it's certainly not bad um it's just one of those i said a mediocre filler game that does what it does pretty well so if you're looking for something a bit different or something um something puzzly that anybody can really understand but still want it to be not so loosely goosey to the point where you're showered in points then check out village green and particularly as a solo experience so yeah normally i'm not a i'm not a solo gamer but this is certainly one i would whip out in a you know in a 15 minute game on my own to um to see what i can do with the cards that's um that are available to me so that concludes my thoughts on village green thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any
support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time