Qwinto Review
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing Quinto in this two to six player game each turn some dice will get rolled and then everybody can write down a number onto their player sheet equal to the sum of all the Pips on those dice underneath this very simple rule set you have some great Pusher luck aspects as well as quite a few interesting decisions which is surprising for such a simple looking dice game first I will go into the rules on how exactly writing those numbers down goes and then I'll jump into my review here's the starting setup for a game of Quinto each player gets a scoring sheet from this large pad here and then they have a pencil and there are only three dice in the game each turn is quite simple the active player decides which of these three dice they want to roll it could be one it could be any two or it could be all three once they roll them they're gonna see what the value of all the Pips are in this case that would be nine but before anything else happens the active player can decide to re-roll this up to one time so they might say they don't like nine they maybe want something bigger they'll roll them again and hey look at that now we have a six a five and a three so that's going to be 14. at this point the active player as well as every other player who is playing the game gets to write the number 14 down and any open slot on their player sheet that is matching a color of one of the dice that were rolled so when all three dice are rolled that 14 can go on each of these rows for instance they might look over here and put the 14 right there this person over here might decide they're going to put the 14 down here and once everybody has decided whether or not they're going to write a number in the uh active player is going to pass to the left it's
important to know that the active player must Mark something down on their sheet when it's their turn however every other player can choose to write something down or not if the active player has no legal spot or they don't want to write a number in then they're going to check off one of these four penalty spots down here now let's talk about what makes something legal the most important rule is that numbers must ascend from the left to the right so at the beginning of the game when you put down a 14 it doesn't really matter where you put it but now that means that only numbers less than 14 can go over here and only numbers higher than 14 can go over here it's also important to know that you're never allowed to have the same number in a specific column so this means I can no longer put a 14 here or a 14 here so play would now shift over to the next player and they might for instance take these two dice and they would roll them and maybe they decide that's fine they're not going to re-roll now every person can put a 10 down but only in the purple row or the orange row and that's all the rules for playing the game you're going to keep going around the table until one player has filled up entirely two of their rows or once one player has four penalty marks at that point the game ends and you go into scoring so now let's talk about how we score our sheet at the end of a game this is an actual scoring sheet from one game that I played so if you look around the bottom you're simply going to fill in the slots that are applicable we'll start with these three colored squares they are associated with the three rows you'll get one point for each number that is in a row as long as that row is incomplete so if you see this orange row they have all these empty slots they got five points for that but now if we look at the yellow row they completed this and when you complete a row you instead get victory points equal to the number
in the farthest right Zone that is why they put a 16 down here and they have two empty slots for the purple which is why that is worth seven points so now let's talk about the Pentagon scoring down here you may have noticed that there is one Pentagon at each column where there are three numbers but then no pentagons where there are only two numbers you get victory points equal to the number that is inside the Pentagon however you only get that if the entire column is filled in so in this instance this column is filled so they got five points but for this one they didn't get another five points because this slot is empty and then they were able to grab this 13 over here because this column was full finally you subtract five points per penalty that you've taken in this case they had one penalty for five and their final score was 41. once everybody's added up their points the person with the high score wins so now let's review Quinto and let's begin with the Positive points the first of these is that there is very little downtime in this game because almost every turn you will have something to do even if it's not your turn uh the only real difference between it being your turn and it not being your turn is that you get to decide which dice to roll and if it is your turn you must write something down on your paper but when it's other players turns what they roll is super important and you are likely going to be writing down the number that they ended up with on probably eighty percent of their turns uh the first many turns of the game everybody will be writing the numbers down once you get into the late game you're gonna have situations where they end up with a number that you can't legally put on your sheet but it's just great it's very rare where you actually have like a lull in the action because occasionally someone might AP a little bit on where to put a number down but
man people just keep going the action is pretty much non-stop in this game and I really like that positive number two relates to the inclusion of the reroll mechanic in the game now on the face of it re-rolling dice is like the most basic thing that you could really do in a dice game it's super not Innovative and I was expecting it to be there just to be a little bit of a luck mitigation Factor like oh you get another uh chance to roll the dice to get the number that you want what I was not expecting is the amount of excitement and tension that this tiny little thing added into the game every time somebody takes their turn that's not your turn and they roll the dice one of two things is going to happen you're either gonna want them to keep that die roll or you're going to want them to re-roll that die and the tension in that moment when they go to re-roll those Dice and half the people around the table go no and the other half people will go yes yes roll six this time roll six it's great like that simple little re-roll thing adds all these stand-up die moments where just people are groaning and people are cheering and you know also when's your turn it's great because you have that shot like there are times in the game where you're rolling one die and you just need one of two different numbers and then you know that you can roll it twice and you roll it once and you don't get and it's just that all that tension on that last roll and you're gonna either get a penalty or maybe get the thing that you want and either way there is a surprising amount of emotion that this tiny little additional single reroll mechanic adds into the game positive number three relates to The Pusher luck aspects to the game and the way they suddenly ramp up as the game goes on the first many turns you're going to write down a number on every single die roll and you're going to put it here and you're gonna put it there and someone might roll a 13 and you need
to think do I put that all the way to the very end or do I hope that someone rolls a better higher number than that at some point later in the game now 13 or 14 those are pretty good numbers because 17s and 18s almost never get rolled and you need to decide do you want to push your luck and leave one extra spot over there because you know if you complete that row and you put in a 16 well that's gonna be three more points than that little 13 or do you just cash out and just put the 13 there and as you start to fill in your board it gets more and more tense the first many turns of the game usually people just roll three dice roll three dice but then people start rolling two dice and then near the late game people start rolling one die and the push your luck is getting really big at this point because if you roll one die and you need to hit like a two or three well odds are not necessarily in your favor even if you get a re-roll but if you roll two dice and you still need a two or three and one color but you need a couple other numbers in the other one you are mitigating that look to a certain extent but maybe you just really need that low number because if you roll two dice it's much less likely to get one of those low numbers and it's just really wonderful push your luck aspects not only to where you put those numbers down but also what dice you roll and then if you re-roll because you have something that works but maybe you really want something that is just that much better and that all comes together really well so now let's move into the neutral points number one relates to the first time that you play Quinto and how odd and obtuse it's probably going to feel for you uh the first time I got it out I read the rules I got the pad I rolled the dice it was an 11 on all three colors I grabbed my pencil and I realized I could put that 11 down on any spot on the board they were all legal because I just started
the game now most of the spots on the board are probably bad for that 11 but how bad and how good and what am I actually doing here so I end up you know putting the 11 down on a spot and then roll the dice again and it starts to feel a little bit more natural and a little more understandable as the game goes on and by the time play your second game you've totally got it but every time I've taught the game subsequently I've looked around the table and pretty much everybody on that first turn is like I'm not really sure what to do and some people like just pick something and other people just kind of think about it a lot and I try to give advice um so this is just a thing to know that if the first time you play Quinto you feel a little on and off about it give it another shot because it's definitely a different experience once you've played a full game and this actually leads me right into neutral number two early mistakes can have very big negative impacts on late game situations and this is going to happen more often in that first play of the game but you will make early mistakes when you're five or six games in I've definitely seen that happen where somebody really knows how to play the game but they still put a five and then a blank and then a seven and then right above that blank they put a six in a different color and they can't fill that spot in there's only one there and you cannot have the same number in that column and ah crap and they kind of cross it out and like mutter under their breath fortunately it's a very quick game so this is not that big of a deal and it's kind of cool that there are such consequential decisions based off of where you put this little number down on the board and you really do want to think towards the future with how this is going to impact the probability of being able to fill in all the different spots so just know that you might really mess yourself over especially in that first game but you will get better at it and it's probably a good thing
especially considering the game is pretty quick so if you do mess yourself over well you lost and it's only been about 15 minutes of your life all right now for my one negative which might be a bit of a nitpick but in Quinto you have this big score pad and the cheats are not double-sided there are I don't know something like 70 or 80 uh score sheets in there and when you can play six players in this game you're gonna find yourself plowing through that pad quite quickly and it would have been really nice if you could have had another like double the amount number of sheets in there by printing on the back side uh I am going to be getting around this by laminating a few of these sheets pretty soon in fact I've already bought a set of wet erasers so I don't actually smudge with my hands so I can play this one going really far into the future because I've only owned the game for about a month and a half and I've already used a third of the scoring pads so I know that I'm going to use all of them at some point if I don't do something about that so it's a bit unfortunate that I had to spend almost the same amount of money getting the pens and the lamination as the whole game itself originally just to make it have a good longevity but this is going to happen for most lightweight games that have pads uh Quinto is far from uh special in this regard but I figured I'd mention it so now let's discuss the replayability of Quinto and if I'm being really honest with myself I'd have to say that from a mechanical perspective it's below average you have this Score Pad which I mentioned already that's not double-sided so you're going to run out of those sooner rather than later and it pushes you to either laminate or print more score pads out for yourself but also it seems like most games play out pretty much the same where everybody
rolls three dice in the beginning to get high numbers and then they shift into two dice to get those middle numbers and then one die near the end of the game to fill in those low numbers and that might be a bit of group think I suppose but it does mean that like between your third and fourth game you're pretty much playing the exact same game and between that fourth game and maybe your tenth game you're playing the same game if you like the game then that's awesome but from a strict replayability perspective there is no real difference between those perspective plays and I figured that's something you should know all right so now let's go into the different player counts that Quinto supports it is a two to six player game and I played most of those player counts and I will say that it's weakest at two players and the reason for that is that it becomes your turn too quickly and I know that might sound crazy like what board game it has a problem with getting back to you too fast but it seems like you have too much control when you decide the two dice or one die or three die that you need you roll them you write the number down your opponent goes and it comes back to you and you do it again and then it goes and it keeps coming back in every other turn you have a decision based off of what dice to roll and I think that a great part of this game is is being forced to write numbers in and not in the best spots like to have more turns before it comes back to you so that when it's your turn it feels much more special like okay finally I'm gonna just roll this one orange die because I just need a three and you know that just nobody else is going to get to that by the time he gets back around to you but if it's a two player game well then every other turn you have a shot to roll that orange die and try to get that one specific thing that you need I've played all the way up
to six and man this playing gameplay is great at six in fact I'd say it's probably best at five or six uh four is good as well and just the reason for that is because you're all playing at the same time like the game takes about the same amount of time no matter how many people are playing and I like how special your turn feels when it's rare like if it's a six player game and there's five turns before it gets back to you man that's a really important moment especially if you decide whether or not to re-roll because you know once that's over well it's back to being everybody else's turns and it's weird how that helps the game it adds tension and emotion and scarcity to the game and I just really like it I would play it two player again for sure but it's definitely best the more people you can get around the table in conclusion I've had a ton of fun playing Quinto I was expecting to enjoy it when I first bought it and read the rules it seemed like a game that I probably enjoy but what I was not expecting was the awesome energy emotion and atmosphere that this really boring looking simple dice game was able to to bring out to the table you have six people and people are cheering and swearing and holding their heads in their hands and throwing their arms about and people come over from other games in the game night and be like what are you guys playing and they just see these three Dice and these little pads with just numbers on it and they're like really this is the game that's making so much fun happen and I will admit this could be group think like this could just be the type of people that I play with has really worked with this but I don't think I've introduced this to anybody who disliked it and in fact we've usually played this game back to back especially when I've taught to new players they finish they
say well that was terrible uh I did really badly let's play it again because I'm going to do way better the next time we play and you know this game is so quick you finish it in 15 to 20 minutes depending on the number of players because if you have more people there's the possibility for a little bit more downtime as one or two people are thinking a little bit more than anybody else but oh man this game is so much fun I've had a total blast with it I expect to see myself playing this game for a long time in the future I love how tiny it is it can be brought to all sorts of places and it's just it's a super fun I'm rambling at this point I could not recommend this game highly enough unfortunately it's not the easiest thing to acquire I think I had it shipped over from Europe it doesn't have like United States distribution at this point but if you have a chance to grab this game I think I end up spending like 18ish dollars which seems like a lot for three Dice and a pad of paper I strongly recommend you do if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and Vlogs please subscribe to my channel also you can directly support the channel at patreon.com John getsgames thanks for watching