Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Game that Mogs - The Old King's Crown

Transcript 28:34

Every once in a while, a work of art comes out that questions my understanding of sanity. A work of art that is so mindbendingly polished or complex or beautiful that you question what sacrifices it took to actually make it. and the sheer abundance of raw talent that was involved. And I sit here today looking at the old king's crown and contemplate the monumental act of determination and will it exudes onto my weak and feeble psyche. Now, before I begin, I have a tragic confession. I've seen thumbnails, headlines, and comments of people lifting the old king's crown to the stratosphere. But I intentionally kept myself in the dark. Whenever there was a comment online or a YouTube video or a section, a podcast about this game, I would avert my eyes, block my ears, and forbid myself from attaining this sacred knowledge. I wanted to play this game raw. I wanted to experience it without any bias or preconceived notion of what it was. Of course, I could feel the hype swirl around me as if I was in a washing machine, but I intentionally insulated myself and cocooned myself away. And I'll be honest, the first Kickstarter didn't even register on my FOMO sensor at all. So, I'm late to the party, but a buddy of mine got this game in the used market in some ways he didn't elaborate on. So, we ended up playing and playing and playing. And much like a newborn who has discovered object permanence, I have many thoughts and feelings about the illusorary nature of The Old King's Crown. So, let's get into it.

Let's start off with a super quick summary. The Old King's Crown is a competitive game for one to four players that is centered around gaining influence over a vacant throne of a crumbling kingdom. You'll play as one of the four asymmetric factions trying to gain influence by winning clashes across four, five, or six rounds, aptly called years. In each year, you'll go through the spring, summer, autumn, and winter phases of the game. At the dawn of each year, you determine player order, and then in spring, you can bid for these powerful asymmetric kingdom cards, as well as prepare for the battle that will come by placing your herald and supporters. Summer is the juicy stake of the game. This heated season is a series of three vicious clashes by simultaneously revealing your faceown card in each region, then going through the day actions and resolving nighttime effects for each clash. After summer is done, the winds change. Autumn has you journey with your cards to get these valuable lore tokens to buy specific faction cards or to govern with these gavl symbols to influence the court. As well, you also resolve any autumn actions from your player board and hand.

Then lastly, winter. This is mostly a cleanup phase, but you can still resolve some of those frosty winter effects and prepare for the next year. That's a super slim overview, but the way to really see it is everything is centered around those three summer clashes. All the other actions and abilities really exist to supplement and add richness to those three lanes and their mechanics. And everything is immensely varied. There's 51 kingdom cards, four star and asymmetric abilities, your king's favor ability, the asymmetric cards in your personal store, the council spaces, the six reward spaces. This game is overflowing with variety and weird little combinations that you can make up in a moment. And that's really the gist of the Old King's Crown. You use your various abilities during the spring, autumn, and winter phase to then prepare for the battle phase in summer. You win combats, you score points on the board or from whatever abilities you may have, and then the highest score wins.

The aesthetic. Okay, so I wanted to talk about this game from a gameplay perspective. I truly did. There's a ton to chew on from purely ludic angle. The way all the systems interlock, the bluffs and the myster, the tricky asymmetry between the factions and the kingdom cards, I respect all of it as a complete rich package. But it's impossible because in a very real way, the gameplay is secondary to the aesthetic. And this isn't a slight on the gameplay. I actually think the moment to moment game is good, even great sometimes. But there is no doubt that The Old King's Crown is a majestic looking game. It has that unmistakable visual aura that can only be explained in the simplest of terms. It mogs. It mogs other board games. And I think there's something to be said about this. A lot of people, subconsciously or not, will attribute positive qualities to something that is beautiful. The looks maxers know it as the halo effect. It's a cognitive bias where positive traits are attributed based on your perception of attractiveness. And look, you've probably felt the halo effect in your own life. There are countless anecdotal accounts of people who had a glow up and then the world just started treating them as more intelligent, capable, and funnier than they are. And you might be thinking, The Old King's Crown is a board game. How does it looks Max and benefit from the Halo effect? And I think in a really weird way, it does. It is a game that is treated oddly by people who play it. It is at its heart a main game of combiveness and bluffs, but it feels more than that from its aesthetic. It feels uniquely ceremonial, like you're walking through an

experimental art exhibit about the ancient history of a long lost land. And you're not just playing a board game where you're trying to put the bigger number on the table than your rivals. The aesthetic has convinced everyone that something earthshatteringly valuable is happening on your table and that you are indeed witnessing the struggle of a once great land. The details in each and every artwork speaks of a story greater than the one being told. It speaks of legend and of myth and something beyond what you can experience, but you can feel the wispy incantations as you lay down your cards. It is by all reasonable measures a culture and a people translated into tarotized cards. I think the best example of this is that each faction starts with the same set of cards in their deck, but only in mechanics.

Through tremendous effort, each and every card arc is unique. And when you compare cards side by side, each with identical powers, you can see how the factions tell a unique story. Like how the Uprising's Ruse card has multiple cheaplymade wooden planks, a temporary, hastily put together taunt from people who use what they can find. On the other hand, the nobility has a carefully laid stone monument adorned with weaponry and purpose, an imposing, resilient entity that will last generations. The gathering has a leafy scarecrow draped in moonlight, a fusion of nature and mysticism. And lastly, the clans use an anchor, a left behind tool from a previously fought battle. Even without explaining what the factions do mechanically by just comparing these four artworks of the same card, you can tell exactly how they play differently.

Their aesthetic is the purest means of describing their differences. It's a form of communication and storytelling that just mogs about every other game around. It feels like something valuable is happening beyond the numbers and the traits that each card has. And I honestly can't think of many games that feel this captivating to look at. A playable historical art exhibit that bends and sings under your hand. And if you decide to never actually play the game and you just occasionally decide to flip through the cards for visual pleasure, it is already worth the cost. Okay, what about the actual gameplay? Does it also mog? I find this game a bit paradoxical. It is a game with dozens of abilities with countless permutations, but ultimately it's a big number game. Each of the three clashes are essentially decided by who has the biggest number by the end of the fight.

Its core mechanic, what it judges, can best be described as who's taller and who height mogs who. And on top of this simple number contest, the game is shockingly simple in the way it operates. The game gently clasp your hand through each season as you gracefully progress through the years by moving this marker through what is essentially a board-siz player aid. There is no ambiguity on what needs to be done at each step. No weird esoteric upkeep, no fiddly bookkeeping. It is clean and beautiful and will gracefully dance with you through all of its steps. But the truth is, while the levers and pulleys that you'll be interacting with are highlighted with a bright yellow felt pen, there's a frighteningly large shadow that looms above your little tableau, and that is the knowledge wall. The mechanical gameplay, the auctions, the place of cards, the symbols you can activate at any given moment. That's easy breezy. By the second round, you'll understand the rhythm with eyes well attuned to each symbol. But the knowledge wall is what stops you from actually playing the game well. You'll essentially be flailing around for three to four games at minimum before you are comfortable at expressing yourself in the old king's crown. The fact is this game wants you, no actually requires you to understand each and every word of the entire table before you actually have the luxury of indulging in it. It is a game that has wild and often surirly moments of gameplay that will be too bitter for the pallet until you become accustomed to it. Let me give you an example of this. In a game I recently played, I got the kingdom card, Book of True Names. And this was in the very

first round. I explained the card to everyone. Everyone understood the power of it. And then the game marches by. 2 years passed until I actually used its ability. And it was understood. The power was known. But what wasn't known is that I bought one of my faction cards that also had the air symbol, which was held in my hand even though my air was previously discarded. And it was only at that moment Arrival was like, "Oh, dang. If I remembered the symbols of the cards you bought, I would have played this round differently. And I know this is 100% a skill issue. The kingdom cards are public knowledge. That rival knew I had that card in my hand. But did they know? Did they truly know? Was every permutation that could exist in a four-player game considered, or was it offiscated by the skill wall that is harder to peer over than one might anticipate? I don't believe they truly knew of the single interaction I had available because there is so much to know. Remembering to consider the book of true names and the queen long ago and all of the other dozens of unique abilities in each and every combat becomes this constant knowledge check.

You are being quizzed on not only what the opponents will do, but what they can do. And I'm going to sidetrack just for a second. I really don't want to get started on this, but the council mechanic. those three little protruding sections from the top of the board like a guy stuck at Norwood level four. Equal parts vital to your faction success and impossible to explain for a first timer. And it becomes this counterintuitive song and dance each game where you have to explain that you want three powerful cards in the clash. Maybe because you also want to have a card to journey and govern with. And while journeying can be explained a little bit like a deck builder economy, governing has more steps and the value is less tangible for a new player. These two actions, the jouring and governing become a constant teaching moment that is hard to explain without actually just telling the player to do it. That yeah, maybe you do want to put your seemingly powerful deadly card in a governing position and to save your powerful master at arms to journey.

Every single clash becomes a bluffing game, a tactics game, and a knowledge check. You will inevitably fail in at least one of those categories. The game quizzes you on whether you've addressed every possible action your opponent can take. It wants you to remember every card in their hand, every action available from their faction's tactics, every kingdom card on the table, and it's all there. It's all deducible. You can work out the likelihood your opponent is holding a deadly or a flank card and play out every clash with every daytime action accounted for, but to climb that knowledge wall and to pass the checks takes time. It's not something you can clear in your first or second playthrough. It feels great when you finally don't need to read the text on the board anymore, but the client to look beyond the wall is challenging. In every other aspect, the Old King's Crown is friendly. Its core mechanics are handholdy. The artwork is all strikingly beautiful, but all of that is in service of inevitably making you realize your own fallibility.

Bluffing tension. I think there is a bit of a mechanical tension in The Old King's Crown. A bluffing game requires understanding of what can be done. Think of a pure bluffing game like Skull. You're playing each moment with only two options, flower or Skull. You never really feel quizzed on what could be a potential option. The Old King's Crown has that element. You can truly understand what can be done. You can understand the pathways and the logic of each clash before they happen, but it takes true effort. It takes real time. So for someone who plays once or twice, what should feel like a clever misdirect using asymmetrical powers instead feels like the deadliest word of all, random. And this is something I heard people at my own table say that it felt no matter where they put their cards, the end result felt beyond their control. that was too swingy and there are too many variables to consider to actually plan out and come up with a clever misdirect.

And I understand that side of the game. I do. And I also understand that after 20 plays, this isn't a problem. This game is far, far more deterministic than it actually feels. It only feels random because that core aspect, what can be done, is shockingly vast for a game that is centered around three faceown cards around. I think after a first game of the old king's crown, you'll hear people mumble. It felt a bit random. I didn't know that was possible. If I had known like it worked like that, I would have done something else instead. And often you hear this with any heavy game. But the Old King's Crown takes it further. Partly in the frequency of these supposedly random moments, but also because new players say these things sheepishly, like they failed an exam or said something stupid on a date. Playing this game will often make you feel like your brain could only fit in the interpupilary distance of a goldfish.

The game is too beautiful to be at fault. The Halo redirects the blame internally. An ugly game with this much hidden knowledge skill checks would scare away new players at the box. The old king's crown invites us in then presents a wall that is too steep for a casual enjoyer of cardboard. But that's fine. That's the beauty of it in a way. It is treated with reverence at the cost of our confidence. And to further add on to the stack of paradoxes that is The Old King's Crown, I do think at the absolute perfect level, at the highest of the high, with the biggest giga brains, it is a game that falls into the paradox of skill. This is to say that at the highest level, with everything 100% understood, the difference in player skill is so narrow that a lot more of the game will depend on luck. Let me give the simplest form of this. Imagine an endgame scenario in a two-player game. Both players know exactly which three cards exist in the other player's hands. Due to the public discard and loss pile, and dependent on where each card goes, the outcome will be 100% different. At this point, the herald, of course, is a tool to indicate intent. But any player will know that these heralds are not meant to be predictive. So there can be legitimate scenarios where it is a 33% mixup on who can go where, which will dictate the victor. So, there is this immense skill in creating scenarios from the very start of the game specifically to avoid these 33% mix-ups entirely.

Instead, positioning yourself into predictable outcomes, win or lose. And even those 33% mixup aren't pure luck. There's conditioning. There's the mind games. But that three card mixup is the closest thing in this game to actual uncontrollable output randomness. Another super simple example is just imagine the perfect kingdom card is drawn just before the decayan battle and you happen to have top deck your 11 power card. And these of course are the simplest example of the paradox of skill wherein the skill gap is so narrow that at the absolute highest level of play it's almost entirely deterministic and therefore the minutia the little tiny moments of randomness will actually play a bigger role than you'd imagine. The thing is, I think if you have infinite time and infinite knowledge, it is possible to path out every single permutation in the Old King's Crown for each clash with near full certainty. The randomness is at best trying to figure out which path an opponent will go down and what cards might be in their hand versus their deck. And even that isn't 100% true output randomness. And this isn't a critique on the game at all.

This is more just trying to explain the phenomenon I kept hearing. New players would constantly call this game random, but that is a consequence of not knowing the possibilities due to that knowledge wall, not an actual true form of output randomness that decides the game. The Old King's Crown is extremely deterministic, almost blindingly so. And almost every form of randomness you encounter, like the kingdom cards, do have direct methods of controlling and even interacting with it from other players perspectives. It only feels random to newcomers because the game is surprising in what could happen. It is not random in what does happen. Surprise and randomness are two different things. And the surprise element of the Old King's Crown is the one that's most featured in its initial gameplay. The reality is our minds can't always comprehend the outcome and interactions of what is a deterministic system. And we feel that as random, but it isn't.

So, I sat with this for a while. This uncomfortable feeling that was conveyed to me when playing the Old King's Crown. People called it randomness. But what I think is a better way to frame it is the amount of expression of control. What I mean by this is that in life in every waken moment we are suffering through an endless amount of obligations of duties and tasks and a structure that is overpowering our own decision-making. Brush your teeth, go to work, keep the middle manager happy, follow traffic laws, eat and rest. But in games, we have the ability to express our own decision-m to exert control on a small scale. However, in The Old King's Crown, that control often feels like it's removed from us without consideration and without us actually having the knowledge that it could happen. The sad reality is that in a game with four people, your power of control is equivalent to everyone else. So, what does that mean? It means that only 25% of your plans will actually succeed.

That you are only in control of the game and your intentions and you can fulfill them about 25% of the time. In a way, this feeling can feel like randomness, an act of God that we had no choice in. But it's not. It's just that that feeling is a consequence of everyone having a huge amount of control, but it's all conflicting with each other's sense of control. Your power is strong, but it's unwieldy and always in conflict with everyone else. So, in another paradoxical way, the Old King's Crown gives you a ton of methods to implement your own power over the board. But the actual feeling of control you have is limited. In the minutia of each clash, you try to act with precision. But precision is not really in the nature of the game for 90% of players.

So, at the end of the day, what is this game actually about? It's a big stick competition. All of it. All of the mechanics, all of the steps, the auction, the council, the journeys, the supporters, it's all in service of a simple premise. Who will have the biggest number at the end of the clash? Of course, the four factions approach this thick measuring contest in different ways. The clans are mobile flankers with compounded forces. The nobility sustain prolonged conflict across multiple years and hold great sway in the councils. The gathering manipulates the lost pile and can flip a combat's rule midfight. The uprising destroys and removes enemy forces with ease. It's a stacked buckla of crispy mechanical asymmetry. But at the end of the night, when the deadly abilities have culled, all that really matters is who's left standing. and that big old number in its corner. It is a simple low cortisol system at its soul. And that's fine. That's a reasonable way to frame a game. Who stick Mogs who at the end of the night? But this at times feels surprisingly brick dumb. Like it's not that deep. Put a big card, protect it or buff it from what you predict your opponents will do. Win big victory points if you position your buddy Herold or if you use him as bait. It's a game that at its core is a big old stat stick versus other stat sticks. Then you add in all of this wackiness, the abilities, the asymmetry, the powers, the traits, the archetypes, those insane kingdom cards, and then you resolve the combats, and it's just an application of your planet versus the disruption of your enemies. That's really the game. That's all there is to it. The game is a paradoxical mix of complexity and

simplicity. A game that holds your hand and it makes you climb a steep wall. It can feel like complete luck at the start and then ramp up into this skillful outplay fiesta until the difference is so narrow that sometimes it can just feel like a mixup. It is beautiful and kind and gentle and then at times it is mean and conflicted and stubborn. It is simple and complex. Hey, it's Big Pasti from the future in the editing room. And I think there's something that I've circled in my mind that needs to be brought up for the old king's crown. A concept I find more and more validity towards is that discovery is the game for the vast majority of people. Like I talk about this paradox of scale, but really truly it won't be a thought for 99% of us while we play a game like The Old King's Crown. On the other hand, what the vast majority of people will experience is purely its discovery phase. Most people who play a game like this will play it two, three, maybe four times their entire life. And for a game like this, those initial plays are almost exclusively the discovery phase. It's uncovering the mechanics, the interactions, and feeling that surprise when XY Z kingdom card and faction ability interact. And I think in a lot of ways, the Old King's Crown is actually really, really painful as a game during that discovery phase because it's so punishing and there's so many mechanics that you will feel powerless against as you actually discover the game. Of course, absolutely. There are practically endless amounts of ways to counteract this on a strategic level, but at that discovery phase of the game,

you will feel surprisingly powerless. I would argue from a purely gameplay perspective, other heavy combative interactive games have a more lenient and graceful discovery phase. And if discovery is the game for most people, that is where the enjoyment is. To discover the mechanics is the actual engagement most people will have with the game. So, I think it's a consideration worth at least some analysis, and it probably deserves a full complete video down the line. But, I'm going to drop this here so we can all ruminate on it. The question I come back to, the one I sit and ruminate on at 2:00 a.m. is if this game looked like the 2007 classic Hamburg, would we be talking about The Old King's Crown? Would the gameplay be captivating enough to push beyond? I don't know. I think most people would bounce after finding that immense cliff of a knowledge wall and just move on with their lives. There would absolutely be like 12.5% of players who would just be enthralled by the gameplay and find it absolutely magical. But it doesn't feel like that's why most people play this game or at least not the entire purpose. I do think the aesthetic muscle of the game, the unarguable beauty of the way it latch spreads and frame mogs on your table is the greatest strength of the game in a very real way. When you see this game, you want to play it for the simple fact that it almost honors you with its presence. It unfolds a ceremony that is sometimes confusing and can be considered niche, but simultaneously you feel blessed for being able to hold these cards in your

hand and admire them. The game is an aesthetic fictional historical gigachad, and it creates this aura of greatness and sacredness the moment you sit down at the table. So, when a new player sits down and gets blindsided by a completely deterministic, brutal knowledge check, they don't actually blame the game. They blame themselves. Why? Because when you're sitting at the table with this aesthetic masterpiece, and you don't understand how a combat resolved, there's a psychological weight of the Halo effect, and it fools you into thinking that's your fault. An ugly beige game with this much hidden complexity and control removal would be called clunky or fiddly or too cumbersome or that you didn't have enough control in the game. But not the old King's Crown. It is crafted. It is meticulous. And if there is a fault, it is ours for failing to meet its standard. But even after all of this, for some reason, I feel like there's something missing. And maybe the clearest way I can describe what's missing is by comparison. Other games that the old king's crown reminds me of are those cutthroat cole royally games that I talk all the time about. It shares a kinship in design philosophy to a game like arcs or root. And people who like those kind of games will find a home in this kingdom. But I think there is a sense of captivation I felt in those games that I don't find in the gameplay of the old king's crown. I find it has less of a hold on my mind from a ludic perspective. Sometimes after I play a game like Arcs, I flip through all the components, thinking of all the combinations I want to try the next game, but I didn't really feel that way

in the Old King's Crown. I did flip through all the components, but it was more to admire the aesthetic value and feel the vibe of this amazingly crafted world in my hands. And at the end of the night, when you pack up the Old King's Crown, you realize it's a game that demands multiple playthroughs. And I like these kind of games, the games that make you chew on them and want you to approach them differently each session. But I don't think the core of The Old King's Crown is necessarily my favorite. The moment to moment rhythm of the game feels rather mechanical at times, and the flowchartesque handhold in the game provides is absolutely wonderful for guidance, but it does sometimes feel like you're playing a game with training wheels on while trying to ride through a tornado. Hey, one last note from the future. If you're interested in more Big Pasti, check out a nearly 3hour long interview I had with Neon Gorilla. We talk about like 30 different topics from Sunlets Eulogy, the game I'm working on, to whether or not all games are art. We go pretty hard and there's a ton of swearing, so just a heads up. Also, don't forget to follow my own game on Game Found. Each follow helps it out algorithmically and you get a $5 discount, so it's a win-win and the single best way to support this channel.

So, where do I stand in all of this? The Old King's Crown is substantial. It has that core machinery and a ton of personality to go along with it. Underneath the gorgeous physique, there's a good game, a tense, bluff driven, asymmetric game with real skill expression in that middle band that you're going to find yourself after five or six plays. There is a real soul and flame that runs it. But it is also impossible for me to look at this game and pretend that the aesthetic isn't creating a halo effect. If the Old King's Crown looked like Hamburg, I don't think it would feel as transcendent or as impactful as it is within my algorithm. If the game looked like Hamburgum, I think it would still find praise for its push in complexity of what is ultimately a fairly simple system. But most people would be turned off due to its massive knowledge checks. And some people would recognize the core gameplay loop as perhaps not as captivating as other cutthroat competitive games. It would not be the Instagram darling that stuns people into a form of awe and admiration. It would be an enthusiast game with niche appeal.

But it isn't because The Old King's Crown as it is now mogs. It is a game that mogs. Okay, one last asterisk before I give a final score. Obviously, it goes without saying that I don't think the designer of the Old King's Crown is an adherent to looks maxer philosophy. He's a handsome enough fellow for sure, but no, I would instead argue that the Old King's Crown is the culmination of a general movement of creating more and more polished and dare I say beautiful games. Look back just 15 years ago and games didn't have this as a priority. So, The Old King's Crown is just a game that I feel has perfected the aesthetic element way more than other nicel lookinging games and is to me a clear beneficiary of our subconscious biases we have towards beautiful things. There is still a game, a sometimes great game underneath the beauty. But to deny its aesthetic value and how our perception is influenced by that is to act in naivity that is both uninteresting and limits the curiosity we have of the power of beauty. It isn't wrong to like beautiful things and it isn't wrong to think about how beauty creates bias in our little soft fleshy fickle brains. So I know I often end these videos with a number out of 10, a succinct summary of how I feel about this game and I struggle to give it a single number. So I'm going to split it.

The aesthetic value is 10 out of 10. This is the first 10 I've ever given anything on this channel. And the gameplay is a good 7.8 out of 10. Even great sometimes, but it's not something I find fantastic. And you can weigh those scores however you like. But that's what I'm settling on for today. I think that's all I got for you. Thank you for watching and bye.

Progress saved