Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detective City Of Angels Board Game Review

Transcript 11:12

Hello, welcome back to the channel. And this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, but we might do a few playthroughs in the near future if you behave yourselves. But today, we're going to be talking about a deduction game. We're going to be talking about detective City of Angels. And in this game, you will be taken on a role of a 1930s, 1940s detective. You'll be trying to solve a number of cases before the time runs out. and then the chisel, the dungeon master type character, will win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, be telling you what we do like, what we don't like. Then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Detective City of Angels is worth your time and bother today and in the future. So, remember, if you're new here, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, and all that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you after this.

Bollocks. So, Detective City of Angels, how do you play this game? So, Detective City of Angels is a kind of like a crime type deduction game. One player is going to be the chisel. They're going to oversee the game and be giving certain types of information to the players and then all the other lot are going to be detectives trying to uncover the person that was guilty of the murder, where it took place, and what weapon was used. Right? So, first of all, the chisel. They're going to take a little book that tells you all the scripts and stuff that is going to be used in the case that you've selected. They'll take the case cards and they'll put them face down on the matching lettered card spaces on top of the city board. You'll take the response cards and an arc sleeve as well. Yeah. You'll place the evidence remove cards and the evidence remove markers next to the chisel board. Right. You'll take the suspect standies are mentioned in the case file and you put them next to the board. Right. So, the detectives will get a little deduction sheet. They'll get a pencil obviously because you can't rub your [ __ ] finger, can you? And they'll get a detective case book which will detail all of the [ __ ] that's going to happen in the case. Right. Each detective will also get a little miniature, a solve token, two briber tokens, four action cubes, eight leverage markers, eight knowledge markers in that color. You'll give a leverage cube to the chisel. Stick it on their board. Right. So, what you're going to do, you're going to choose a case. You'll read the case briefing. The chisel will already have gone through all this [ __ ] so they should know the case inside out. And the case briefing will tell you where to put the suspects on the board. So, you put the standies on those spaces, won't you? So, this is a competitive game, but you'll have to sort of work together to uncover a lot of the information. A detective can make

a guess at any time as to what the three different requirements of solving a case are. And if they get it right, they win. If they don't, then they get a second guess at the end of the allotted time. Yeah. If the allotted time runs out and nobody's correctly guessed all those three components, then the chisel will win the game. So, on your turn, you will have a variety of different actions that you can take. You can do the move action. You'll see that the board is divided into different regions. You can move to any location that's in your current region. You can move to the location on the border of a region and then cross over into a new location. So, you're going to have to always move to the edge and then move into a new region. Right? You can do the search location action. The chisel will check the deck of search cards. If the location is mentioned, they'll give them the search card and the player will read it. If not, they'll give them a generic search card telling them that they've discovered [ __ ] all. You can search a suspect. You can go to a location where a suspect is and you can try and grab the suspect's balls. Yeah, the chisel will hand over a suspect card. You'll read it and you'll do what it says.

Sometimes it will tell you to archive the search card. You'll end up sticking it in the archive bit on the board, right? You can question a suspect at the current location. This is the meat and potatoes of the game. So, we'll cover this in a little bit more detail in a sec. Yeah, you impatient [ __ ] You can analyze, which means you're going to get one scratch, which is basically money. And you can kick back. This is a way of getting protection money from local fugs because you are a bit of a bent copper, right? And you'll get money equal to the number of players in the game. Yeah. So, if you want to question a suspect, you can ask one question, right? You must have knowledge of the case. So, you're going to have to make sure that you have got a knowledge token on that piece of evidence. If the piece of evidence is turned up, everybody's got knowledge of it. So, you can do whatever you like with it. Right? These questions that can't really ask them in detail. It's going to have to be something like if there's a knife as a piece of evidence, then you're going to have to ask if the knife was used by a suspect or something like that. Yes, it's not as open as you would like it to be. Once the detective has asked a question, the chisel will look in their book and see a number of responses. They can choose to give the detective a load of [ __ ] They can give them what's called the best response, which may not necessarily be true, right? You'll take the card, you'll stick it into the wallet, you'll hand it to the detective. They'll look at it, and they will decide whether or not they want to challenge your response. Yeah. If they do, they'll give you a leverage marker, and then you'll tell them whether or not it was true or [ __ ] Yeah. And if it was [ __ ] you got to give them the correct response. Right. There's also ways of doing bribes and stuff. You could put your snitch token down if one of them is like a bluff, one isn't. And this is a way of other players getting to look at

the final response card, right? And that is basically all the actions. Yes, like we said, you can have a crack at solving the case before the end of the game. If you're wrong, then you still get another crack at it in the form of a final guess. And if detectives manage to correctly identify the three components that make up the crime, they will be the winners of Detective City of Angels. So, do we like Detective City of Angels? So, the first thing that we quite like about this is that it is highly thematic. Yeah. You ever seen LA Confidential or what's that video game that was released on Xbox 360 years ago? I can't remember what it is. Or you played those Tex Murphy video games. Yeah, you'll get an idea of how the theme comes across and it is [ __ ] strong. Yeah, especially if you have got the voice actor stuff for the case files. Yeah, it used to be free. Used to be able to get it on Van Rider's website, but now it's through a payw wall, I think, for a Fiverr. We paid for it. And is it worth a Fiverr? I feel like a little bit ripped off. Yeah, the fact that it was free, but it does add an extra element to the game. Yeah. And the voice actors are all professionals and that and it really does sound good.

But we played the Portal Games Detective and it sort of sucked. Yeah. It was too complicated and game dragged and a lot of the cases are too confusing and really really difficult and not really that. Felt like you were in like a episode of [ __ ] Hong Kong fooy most of the times. You know what I mean? This is completely different to that. You do get a sense of dread. the clock is ticking and sometimes well the people I played it with cuz I was a [ __ ] chisel you obviously it's my game in it. They panicked and they made a complete balls up of their guests and they were kicking themselves at the end. Yeah. So yeah, a highly for thematic game that is if not the most game in this type of genre. Right. So the second thing that we really really like about this is that it's really interesting to see the evidence be revealed as the time goes on. And that tells a really [ __ ] nice story, doesn't it? as you're moving around different locations, evidence is going to be revealed. You're going to have to go to that location and have a look at it yourself, unless you use your snitch ability, and it's just really nice to see the narrative and the way that the story weaves the different elements together be revealed as you are plotting your way through this game.

Right. So, the final thing that we really like about this is that some of the clues that are revealed are going to be exclusive to the player that discovered them. Yeah. They're going to be archived. Yeah. So that means that it rewards players that get in quickly and actually take a chance of going somewhere. Yeah. And obviously the other detectives are going to be scrambling around thinking, "Fucking hell, I can't go all that now." But you can because a lot of the evidence is going to be revealed and made public as you get closer and closer to the finish line. Yeah. And I think thematically the game says that the detective gets hold of the evidence, then the police do, and then the police release evidence to the other detectives. Yeah. So obviously this ties into the other pro mentioned before this is that it's for thematic. It just means that there's a mechanism for detectives to get a leg up on the other ones without actually busting the game. You know what I mean? So, what don't we like about Detective City of Angels?

So, the first thing that we don't really like about this is that it is a oneandone affair. There's I think nine cases in the box. The first one is really really short. It's like an introductory thing and once you've played through them all, you are basically done. Everyone's seen everything. Obviously, the chisel can play through the game with other players. Yeah. But why they want to do that, I don't know. And that's another thing is that if you are the chisel, the chances are you're always going to be the [ __ ] chisel because nobody else is going to want to bother to learn two different ways to play the game. It's a bit like when I started playing D and D years ago in the early ' 80s. I own the game. I had to be the dungeon master and I never got to be the player. Yeah. And that was really frustrating. And the same applies to this. So, second thing that we don't really like about the Detective City of Angels is that being a chisel is largely a really [ __ ] boring affair. Yeah, I found myself just falling asleep [ __ ] thinking, well, all this comes down to is choosing whether or not a piece of information is true or false. Everyone else is [ __ ] about having a laugh, moving their stuff around, trying to guess all the stuff.

But the chisel, there's no hidden information. There's no sense of reveal. There's no mystery, and it's just a case of like trying to trip up the players. But sometimes you don't really want to do that cuz it drags the [ __ ] game out. Yeah. So, you're sort of damned if you do, damned if you don't. And personally, I don't know, it just brought back memories of playing D and D in the ' 80s. Not that I didn't like playing D and D in the 80s. Sometimes you just don't want to be that [ __ ] [ __ ] that's sitting there doing far. Do you know what I mean? So, the third and final thing that we don't really like about Detective City of Angels is that the map is largely pointless really. I mean, you're going to be moving around it obviously. Yeah. But there's nothing to differentiate between all the different areas and it's just a bunch of locations. Yeah. There's loads of empty space. Doesn't actually feel like you're moving around Los Angeles. and the map feels a little bit empty. It feels like there's loads of different voids in there and moving from one location to the other doesn't really feel like you're sort of changing your environment in any sort of way. Do you know what I mean? So yeah, the map's too big and there's not enough on it. So to summarize, is Detective City of Angels worth your time and bother today and in the future?

So we're going to say I really really wanted to like this game, but it just fell short for me. Yeah, Detective City of Angels is an admirable attempt at a clue-based deduction game, but the need for a DM type character lets it down heavily. The Chisel Roll. Yeah, okay, there is a cooperative mode, but that's not the real point of this game, is it? The Chisel Roll is dull and can be relegated down to selecting a true or false choice. Add to that the empty map and the one and done nature, and value for money isn't really screaming in my ear. Do you know what I mean? Having said that, this is the most thematic game in the I don't know what do you call it? Detective genre. I mean, think about like detective by Portal Games, Chronicles of Crime, or even Police Precinct. Yeah. So, yeah, this is the most game that we've played of this type. But truth be told, it misses the mark by quite a significant margin.

Yeah. So, there you go. That is Detective City of Angels. Remember, if you are new here, consider subscribing to this channel with the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] and we will see you next Tuesday.

Progress saved