Skip to main content
Loading video...

Women Won the Vote and Left a Mark (w/ Tory Brown) | Board & Book #2

Transcript 1:04:41

Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire and welcome to my new YouTube series. This is the board and book series where we talk about the books and media behind cool board games. Uh, and with me is Tori Brown. She is the designer of Votes for Women and she's going to talk to us about some of the stuff behind the game. How you doing today, Tori?

Hey, Liz. I'm well, thank you. How are you doing?

I'm doing great. It's so fun to have you back on. Um it's uh it's just always delighted to chat. But uh

it's the best. I really enjoy talking with you.

Um so for people who have not played Votes for Women, uh you want to do a quick overview of of what that is.

Someone out there hasn't played Votes for Women. I don't believe it. But on the off chance, uh Votes for Women is my game about the American women's suffrage movement. Uh yes, you can make a board game about that and just about anything. It is a card-riven game played out on a map of the United States of the 48 states that existed in 1920 when the suffrage movement successfully ratified the 19th amendment to the constitution ensuring that no state or no nation and that America could not um prevent someone from voting on the basis of sex. It didn't um ensure voting rights largely on the basis of of race. There's still work that we are doing. Um, you know, the the work continues, but the game itself sort of starts in 1848 when the Senica Falls Convention uh took place and over the course of seven decades marks not just the work of the suffrage movement, the events, the um organizing, the campaigning, the lobbying that took place, but it also invites a player to play as opposition and helps us understand opposition to social movements, the financial and um and political ical and ideological interests that oppose rights generally, which again the work continues to uh oppose those kinds of movements. And what better way to understand them than to sort of crawl inside and to have the agency of that player and understand how all of those factors wo together for

this unsuccessful attempt to to stop the 19th amendment from being ratified.

Yes. So, one thing that I found very notable over the times that I've played this game, uh, is that you did a really good job of bringing in real people with little snippets about what they were really doing. Uh, and that there were just so many little things in the game that reflected historical reality. Uh, all the way down to having different colored cubes that you could put in the states to represent um, representatives of the suffrage movement. um because you might be able to split the movement apart uh and so it sort of represented a lack of intersectional solidarity uh in a movement. Yeah, the the people are what attracted me to this story and the ability to tell it in a board game forum. And as I started researching, I just sort of like pulled up a a Google sheet and started filling out cells and sort of organizing them on a timeline.

And there are books and events. You know, certainly the Civil War is represented and then reconstruction and all, you know, the things that are happening. But what I loved most were finding these people, finding these primarily but not only women who gave almost their whole lives or their all of their time and effort and energy to this work. And there are names, bold-faced names that I went into this project knowing. Certainly Susan B. Anthony and Alice Paul are a few of those names that hopefully everyone learned about in history class. But a movement is by definition thousands of people, the most of which we will never know their names. But I was able in the research and the sort of organization of the game to find folks that interested me, folks that spread across the country because this wasn't just happening in Washington DC like so often we sort of put a spotlight on this is where politics happen. The suffrage movement was happening in street corners and in state houses across the country and women who were representing their community, representing their family and their interests were getting involved at a very local level. And so the the cards in the game that are able to represent that vast diverse swath of women and their interests and their um allegiances

uh through the card play was just like I think kept me going through uh what was quite an extensive research project through archives and historical societies, books um and and different media. And so, you know, being able to find a picture and add a little snippet about these women made um made the project super worthwhile and I hope make it intriguing for players to see these faces and learn these new people's names and their accomplishments um beyond just the sort of usual suspects.

Yes. Yes. Very much so. So to that end, uh you have come here with some books and other media to tell us about uh in relation to suffrage and the the learning material behind this game. Um so if we want to read something, watch something, check something out to help us understand for women and the history behind it, what is something we should read? I'm actually going to start with something that you probably don't need to read. Uh, and there's an interesting story behind it. Just bear with me. Um, in the late 1800s, the movement had really stalled out. There really wasn't a lot of progress being made. There had been some victories out west where states as they were territories becoming states had infranchised women in some ways to attract women into a state where there were, you know, um, men were represented. You know, it's like 10 men for every one women. And that's not the makings of a society. Um so the movement had had these sort of early successes in the the mid um to late 1800s but it kind of stalled out and Susan B. Anthony uh uh Elizabeth Katie Stanton and uh Susan Gage had uh developed this project of mythmaking where they essentially put themselves at the middle of everything meaningful that happened to make themselves the mothers of the movement.

And it's this really fascinating endeavor of understanding that like history is written not only by the victors but by the people that decide to write things down. And a lot of the reason that we have a Susan B. Anthony silver dollar and we might know Elizabeth Katie Stanton's name is because they [snorts] told us to they wrote it down and they put it and they approached a fellow activist by the a woman of the name by Lucy Stone and said like hey like we're collecting papers. It was this like seven volume enormous endeavor of like kind of dry like look what we did kind of um text. And Lucy Stone says to them, "No way. You don't need any of that stuff. History will decide." And that's just not how history works. Right? Like we know a lot about the work that Lucy Stone did from some of her work, but she's just not given the same kind of prominence that her fellow activists claimed for themselves.

And so this history of the women's rights movement, this um seven volume collection is this like heygraphy to thyself that you know has created a lot of um of I guess like a a a shared myth but isn't necessarily reflective and does not include the vast swath of women that were doing this work. So I would say put that seven volume history aside and instead check out recasting the vote by Professor Cahill. This vote was this book was uh published in 2020 uh around the 100th uh anniversary of the 19th amendment and around the time that I was uh was working on votes for women. And it is a celebration and a catalog of a few women of color who made their mark on the suffrage movement, who were intimately entwined, who were leading, who were um in essence, you know, not just uh on the periphery, but at the very core of redefining citizenship, redefining Americanness, and redefining women in the popular imagination of the the country. And the book does this really great job of sort of chapter by chapter this sort of like first era, second era, third era, going through these women's stories and talking about the the challenges they faced, their tenacity, the sacrifices that they made in order to essentially be a part of this work and put their stamp on a

movement that maybe didn't always acknowledge their existence, their personhood, or their right to citizenship. And so, um, it's really well written. It's really compelling in a kind of like just like I like, uh, sort of like let's take this story and really flesh it out. Um, and, uh, I thought it was was really great and I hoped in votes for women to do a similar reflection of diverse women in different places that were doing this work and not just the same five names that we've all heard or hopefully have heard. Um because again I thought that the discovery as an aspect of vote of playing votes for women would be an integral part of what makes it interesting and fun to play and not just the sort of um like I said usual suspects.

Oh man, that makes a lot of sense. I really want to read this now. Um do you mind if I go on a weird tangent?

Do it. Okay. So, I've been reading about historical memory in relation to reconstruction recently for another project. Um, and what's fascinating to me about this is that the women who launched the Daughters of the Confederacy also had a huge fight about who the actual founder was that lasted for years that turned into this like internal struggle between like different people. And I just find it really fascinating thinking about like women's movements starting in a time when women are relatively disempowered and how women like claim power for themselves um by I guess making sure that they get credit for things especially because I think it's really hard I don't know I don't know what socialization was like at this time but I know that I've been socialized to feel weird taking credit for things

and so um I just wanted to just kind of note like that super fascinating.

And on the opposition side of uh votes for women in that sort of like 1900 like that sort of reconstruction to 1920 era is dominated by cards like the Daughters of the Confederacy. And when we think about the monuments to Confederate generals that were such a flash point in 2020 after the George Floyd uprising and the reckoning that we had around public memory and I mean certainly the conversation in Charlottesville around whether we should be deifying Confederate generals treasonous traitorous bastards, right, who tried to destroy this nation over keeping human beings as chatt slavery. like they write it in the the Articles of the Confederacy. This isn't sort of like my my li whatever take like they they're very honest and clear about it, you know. Um so as you know these women whose husbands, brothers, sons perish in the Civil War uh are now grasping for meaning, trying to make sense of what they've lost over what and why. They create this mythology that the north really does help fuel the lost cause, right? That this idea that there's this gental way of living in the south and that we all sacrificed in order to maintain our way of life that was about hospitality and about sort of being

southern ladies and gentlemen. It is entwined with rejecting suffrage, denying women their right to vote because there's this myth like women are are we take care of the plantation or the home depending on your class or you know um or sometimes taking care of the home means the brute physical labor that's required of very low paid servant class. Um, and so the Daughters of the Confederacy and other groups come out and it's like a a a breeding ground for women's opposition to suffrage. And I think that idea right that like even though they are denying themselves active citizenship in a country where they are trying to make memory and trying to claim credit and trying to make meaning that it's still somehow dangerous to be in the political sphere with our vote even as they are trying to do all of this work that theoretically could have been made easier or um uh meaning more meaningful with political participation to get these monuments erected to um prevent some of the kinds of um you know integrationist policies that had been a part of reconstruction and then um were rejected again thanks to northern interests fueled by folks who stood to

profit and to gain their own political power. And then ultimately we see the um the rejection of suffrage amendment as uh fueled by white supremacy and that in essence these women were willing to give up their right to vote in order to deny it to black women and that any chance of them assembling political power would risk a loss of their own political right. It's sort of zero sum theory. if if black women get any power, then I have less power because somehow power is a pie where there's only a few slices to go around. And so, um, I the that trench of opposition was absolutely new to me. I didn't understand that connection between white supremacy, the sort of the lost cause mythology that these women were invested in and their opposition to suffrage.

So, for people who want a bonus book recommendation, this is literally sitting on my desk. Uh, I have Dixie's Daughters by Karen Cox. Um, and so this is an actual like this is I think her dissertation, but it's like been re-released with a new forward because it's still relevant. Uh, but it's literally about the goals of the Daughters of the Confederacy, its formation, and like how they got into schools and how they handled funding monuments and the way that they tried to prop up men while also gaining power of their own is really a fascinating read. And I think understanding folks you don't agree with, again, like this isn't a like endorsement of their ideology or worldview, right? But if we are interested in a thriving multi-racial democracy, understanding that these people aren't just like there's not a a a switch that flipped to like that they decided to be opposed to these things.

that there's a whole sort of like internal ethics as such as it is and a whole way of viewing the world that creates that kind of ideology and that worldview and that if we are ever to undo it, we ought to understand it and be curious about its internals so that it can be dismembered.

Yes. Um so a couple of interesting books to read but that's not all you brought to this conversation. Um, so you also have a movie recommendation and this is a movie I have not seen. So tell us a little bit about it.

I think not many people have seen it. Um, so the movie I recommend is a movie called Iron Jaw Angels. It was um, it premiered at Sundance in 2004 and was distributed or released by HBO. So it sort of had this like made for TV movie kind of imprint on it even though they weren't involved in the development, the production. The movie Iron Jot Angels follows Alice Paul and Lucy Burns from 1913 where they return from England where they had been schooled and understood uh more militant tactics that were a part of the British suffrage movement and bring them stateside that had been very the movement had been very gental very focused on being well-behaved proper ladies politely petitioning the government for their rights. Lucy Burns and Alice Paul are like, "Well, that's not working.

Clearly, we got to do something different." So, the movie tracks them from 1913 and the Grand Procession during Woodro Wilson's uh inaugural parade up until the vote in Tennessee and the ratification of the 19th Amendment. Um, the the movie itself is a little strange. It the acting is phenomenal. Hillary Swank plays Alice Paul. She does a wonderful job. Angelica Houston plays Cherry Carrie Chapman Cat, who's the leader of the Old Guard, the National American Women's Suffrage Association, who they definitely butt heads over tactics and strategy, and there's a big split. I think like you were talking about earlier in Votes for Women, My Game, the suffrage movement is represented by purple and yellow cubes that sort of get laid out equally. They don't have a different meaning, but the opposition is able to divide or exploit those purple and yellow cubes. And the idea in designing the game was that the movement wasn't a monolith. There wasn't just like one person at the head that directed everyone to do what they do.

Over the course of 70 years, there's factioning. there's uh groups merging and then splitting apart and merging and splitting apart and different um ideological shifts including over race as well as tactics and whether to focus on a state-by-state strategy or this national amendment strategy. And the movie does a great job of simplifying but yet um you know sort of explaining or depicting that mo that split. Um the like I mentioned the movie is a little bit strange in some of its directorial choices. Uh it uses um modern music in the first twothirds of the um of the the movie. And so if you know the band Vertical Horizon, which was it [snorts] had like a few they had a few hits um in the '90s, it opens with the the music from with it opens with this song from Vertical Horizon, which is very strange and very like what what movie am I watching? What's happening here? And goes through a few there's a Lauren Hill song that plays during the 1913 procession. It's strange. Uh, and they kind of abandon this approach by the in the last third of the movie that goes through the um when the suffragists who had been picketing at the White House were imprisoned at the Aacoin workhouse and uh tortured and um uh force violently force-fed and um that they it sort of just drops. They just forget that they were doing this. Uh which

actually helps the movie quite a bit when you don't aren't sort of pulled out by Vertical Horizon songs which I love. I had I had a vertical horizon CD. I saw them at American University. Yes. Anyway,

uh another strange thing that this movie does is uses sort of like hyper um editing techniques that probably would have been more at home on MTV. My sense is that they were trying to appeal to like a younger crowd and misunderstood that like shiny music and editing choices don't is not actually what attracts or engages an audience but like compelling human drama and these um stories about people that we can identify parts of ourselves with or learn something new about our history and how we sort of move through um history together. So like it's a movie. It's a two hours long. It it glides over a lot of stuff. There's like a very brief brief appearance of Ida B. Wells that's sort of yada yada yada and some of the racial divisions in the movement. Um, and you know they the Alice Paul and and Lucy Burn are sort of shown basically like inventing lobbying when Modwood Park a card in my game was is credited is like acknowledged in history as like a fun a transformative figure in the movement's approach to lobbying on Capitol Hill and essentially becomes the first the founding director of um the League of Women Voters based on her strength of organizing and ability to to work Capitol Hill all opposes. It's just like not mentioned, right? But it's it's a mo it's a movie,

right? And they're going to it's a historical interpretation, a historical sort of, you know, they're you know, you want to read history, read a thousand books and you'll get a thousand stories. You want to watch history. Well, here's a few movies and they'll give you bits and in pieces. Um, but like I said, I think it does a great job of um of giving us faces and heartbeats to a lot of these women to understanding some of their motivation. I mean, even just the idea that hunger striking was a tactic borrowed from Irish political prisoners in um the past where they after um Alice Paul had been studying and working there in the British movement and the inter relation to not just tactics but strategy and what's like emotionally compelling. Um it's it's super interesting. There's like it's like it looks beautiful. They did a great job on like historical dress and um the the sets are great. If you just like can can get over there's a weird kind of romantic subplot that does not make any sense at all. So in in essence though for me like this movie came out in 2004. I was working it was my first job. It was a an internship that I turned into my my first political job working on the March for Women's Lives which ended up being a 1.2 2 million person margin Washington DC that borrowed heavily from the suffrage movement including using these huge purple white and yellow banners the colors of the national women's party to

represent different state delegations it was sort of a call back to that 1913 procession so I am working on this huge political mobilization trying to defend reproductive rights economic rights doing all these things and like one day at our office a box shows up and it's all of this like merch street team gear from the Iron Jaw Angels production office. Notebooks and stickers and all this kind of stuff. And so for me, this movie is just sort of like embedded with this experience. I had this wonderful eyeopening, backbreaking, tumultuous experience of organizing a march for 1.3 million people. Um, and so even just that like hearing Vertical Horizon takes me back to that moment.

And so it's very personally meaningful even if it gets like a three on letter box because of these sort of like weird choices that the director made.

Oh, that's really interesting. Yeah. You know, sometimes the most impactful or meaningful media, it doesn't mean it's the best, it just means it meant something.

Yeah. Yeah. And like you you take take what you want from it, right? Like um you know my mom had this this idea of like fish and bones, right? that like a fish needs bones and when you cook it, it's going to have, you know, have the bones in it, but that means you like go around the bones if you don't need it. And so, um, you know, there's some bones to pick out of Iron Jot Angels, but I still think like, you know, it's like a nice snapshot. Um, an interest, incredibly compelling arc, the sacrifices, the physical toll, the um strategic choices. Um, you know, it's it's it's really inspiring and a little weird. You know, that's probably true of a lot of important things that have happened in history. Very inspiring and weird.

[gasps] Um, all right. And so you you had such a fun approach to this because you have something to read, we got something to watch, and we've also got like a bunch of stuff to look at.

Yeah. So, you know, I had the opportunity I was invited to speak to a public history class, right? And this idea of public history as distinct from history, right? Like academic history, you know, you're in archives, you're cataloging, you are sort of developing a narrative based on the historical record and maybe you publish a book. Maybe that's, you know, a dissertation that gets to become a a book. Um, it can tend to sit on a shelf, right? people have to self- select into watching Iron Jaw Angels or you know borrowing recasting the vote from the library but public history sort of creates a different idea and what I hoped Votes for Women would do as a board game is reach folks that wouldn't normally pull these books or these movies off of the shelf that they would see it on a YouTube channel maybe like this one or at a board game convention or wherever it might be on a review channel and be interested because of the the mechanics and the gameplay and the look and feel of it and hopefully then be sort of like come to the theme based on that. I think public history does that. It sort of puts us and our stories out there in a way that makes it easier for new audiences to to take a look and to get interested and be curious about. So I have developed I curated a just very small sample of

public murals dedicated to the suffrage movement and I think that they are you know public art as a way to like the the urbanist in me loves beautifying a city giving life to blank walls to spaces that were just sort of like easily ignored previously. You invite a super talented muralist. You give them a whole lot of paint and maybe like a scissor lift or a cherry picker and [clears throat] suddenly you have life, you have interest, you have transformed a block. There's nothing like walking around a city like Philadelphia and you turn a corner and there's this piece of artwork that tells you about the history of that place, the you know, someone notable that lived or worked there or just is really pretty and cool. there's some like weird koi pond in a wall, you know, a couple of blocks from my house that like I don't think it means anything, but it's neat and it just looks more interesting than the plain brick wall. So fortunately, these suffrage murals do mean something and they do give us an opportunity to learn about something or someone or to catch an eye and to remind people about this incredible movement, this remarkable achievement. I mean, the Daughters of the Confederacy understood this idea, right? They worked diligently to erect public monuments, to put at the

center of town squares these huge memorials to these different Confederate soldiers and generals because they understood what we preserve and promote in the public square tells a meaningful story not just to people who agree but to people who disagree and who ended up on the other side of that. And so I think these murals are a wonderful way to us for a city or a property owner or a community to make a declaration about what's important to them. The kinds of heroes that we deify or we even just respect and revere and the idea that we create life by preserving our past.

All right. Should we have a look at these?

Let's go.

Woohoo. All right. Uh the first is a mural that just went up in Washington DC and this is Mabel Ping Hua Lee. She is represented in the Votes for Women deck in the um in the late era. She was a Chinese American woman who because of the Chinese Exclusion Act was not allowed to vote in 1920 when the Suffrage Amendment was um was passed. Right? like she was denied her vote based on her race and ethnicity and she I think it's clear knew that as a suffragist that the 19th amendment would not be sufficient to give her access to the ballot box and give her full citizenship and and um and the right of representation.

But she dedicated herself to the effort anyway. She understood that it was an important step and that her community could be a part of um of rallying for this and that like the protecting the rights of some citizenship citizens could be an important step and like a um creating momentum for their own community which in fact did happen. Um uh a few years later the the Chinese Exclusion Act was repealed and Dr. Pingquali was able to um was able to vote alongside her community. This is a um a mural by the artist of the name Ja Ru and it was um it's going up in Washington DC's very diminished Chinatown uh by the 1882 Foundation. And so it's a public art that recognizes uh a Chinese American hero, a suffrage hero. And like look at it. It's pretty.

The yellow rose was the symbol of suffrage. So, um, suffragists and even members of state legislatores when they were voting for or against the ratification of the 19th amendment would wear suffragists and pro-suffrage sides would wear a yellow rose on their lapel and anti-suffragists would were represented by a red rose. So, you could really look around a room or a chamber and see, you know, get a bit of a nose count on um on who was supporting and who was opposing. And so the um the artwork is stunning, the symbolism is rife, and this message that a vote is your voice continues to be one of the most compelling messages we see in public polling and me in focus groups around why people vote. um that it is a way for us to speak to power in a time where it feels like a lot of us have probably never been more powerless as lots of money and interests are dominating our political discourse, our media, right? Corporations um this idea that um uh that our voice in government is represented through our vote. It's not our only voice. We have lots of ways to petition the government. In fact, the whole suffrage movement was about using voice to gain that vote. Um, but it is uh it is like a it's a really compelling message.

Oh, yeah. Kind of makes me want a yellow rose lapel pin myself.

Yeah. I have the really fun um earrings that I wear to to events. um that I think it's um the the symbolage the symbolism of um of the suffrage movement like they really got it like and they used public art and commissioned political cartoons. Um there's this amazing artwork. I probably should have dropped it in um the called the awakening. Uh it was a centerfold of the um the map in 1915 of all of these states out west that had been granted suff that had fought and won suffrage. Um and this like there's this depiction of lady liberty with the torch of enlightenment marching to the east to bring that enlightenment and that liberty to the rest of the country that had not yet infranchised women. um because the suffragists understood that um literacy rates were still pretty low in the the 1900s. And so, you know, a treatise, an op-ed, a a flyer weren't going to connect with as many people as the the the map. The map became this really important visual history of u and vis like visual communication tool to talk about some women can vote, many can't. Let's finish the job. Let's pass the 19th amendment so that everyone can have what these women out west have.

That's really interesting. All right.

Okay.

This this is this also looks sick.

So uh this is a mural by it's uh by Shepherd Ferry and he has a co- um Sandra Chevier, a French um muralist. So Shephard Fairy of Obey the Obama Hope poster, right? really well-known um uh muralist and and artist. Uh this is in Austin, Texas. And I was in Austin. I think I was in a cab or like a a lift or whatever as we like drove by this and yelled out stop jumped out and was just like uh so this went up around the um the anniversary of the suffrage movement in 2020 but does not depict any one specific suffragist.

Um as you can see we have um Wonder Woman here. We have this composition. we have all of these like beautiful symbols of um the um of women's equality and peace. And so this is on the side of a hotel in Austin, Texas. And again, like it's just so stunning. It is impossible to ignore as you are moving around um and going through the capital of Texas. And so I love it. There's just so much because you've got this huge side of this building.

Yeah. there. You know, you can scroll in and see little bits of a whole lot of stuff. Um, incredibly compelling. I love it. Maybe my favorite even though it doesn't actually depict one specific suffragist, which I love. like the rest of these do uh or you know have like but I think again like the the role of the artist to interpret and to tell us a story through their images beyond just the historical record is why we ask artists to interpret and to um to create these kinds of um these kinds of images.

Yeah. I just I love how bright it is. Just a total eyecatcher. I mean, Wonder Woman breaking the chains. H so good.

Incredible. All right, more visual feasting. Uh what is this?

Visual.

This is another um uh a mural that I've seen in person. I was out west for work and um a group of co-workers and I took a quick trip up to Cheyenne, Wyoming uh to say that we've been to Wyoming essentially. Uh, but Wyoming was one of the first states where women could vote and they take it very seriously. They're very proud of that history. They call themselves the equality state. And so this is a mural depicting the um that like that pride that Wyoming has in the parade through downtown Cheyenne as they were organizing for the vote. Women from DC, women like Susan B. Anthony and others would come to different states to help them organize, to put together a lobbying campaign and to work. But like these women from Wyoming, from their communities show up and walk down the streets sometimes to like really terrible treatment. People yell, sometimes angry men throw rocks and other things at these women.

It was a very daring move to so publicly support this movement in not even just those early days into the 1900s and 1910s. But that courage and that willingness to dawn a sash, to carry a sign, to step out in the public square and make known your fierce ideological passion for something so important as our citizenship, our voice in our government where we are required to follow laws that we've had no part of passing. Um, I just find so inspiring. And so, um, it's like 19, I'm sorry, 18, uh,70s and these women are out there in their pett coats and their long dress speaking out for suffrage. I just love

Yeah, this is really, really cool. Also, I love that these

Yeah.

Oh, just such a different um visual style. I mean, if you compare it to the last piece, right, this is like it you it's almost like you'd have no idea that this was part of the same effort, the same, right? Like cataloging or marking some of the same, you know, and I love that, right? The diversity, what fits in a community, what makes sense, what tells a story to that specific audience is going to be different in Cheyenne, Wyoming versus a Austin, Texas.

Yes. Yes. And I love that what we've seen so far is from so many different places because I mean there's a visual version of this for anywhere, not just DC, but also Texas, also Wyoming.

It is remarkable. And one of the great things about uh the um the suffrage centennial is that Congress like really kind of got ahead of it and they formed the Congressional Suffrage Centennial Committee and they had they um they put money towards it. And one of the best things that the committee did were um were funding efforts to uh digitize suffrage history archives at state capitals. And so it gave me access while I was researching to these stories of women that wouldn't necessarily like their work wouldn't have shown up in the Library of Congress, but were meaningful and were real impactful leaders in their states. Um there's a woman named Gertude Wheel in North Carolina who was tireless in her effort to bring suffrage to North Carolina. And the first time she got legislation introduced in the North Carolina State House, I think it was like 1889 or 1892, was very um you know, sort of in mid of um the project. Uh the the bill to grant women the vote was referred to the committee on insane asylums because even in 1892, state legislators could troll with the best of them, right? and a bill giving women the right to vote was obviously something crazy that you wouldn't take seriously. And she kept at it. She like dust, you know, dusted off her boots and and and kept

going. Um, but I didn't know much about her. there's not a lot about her in the national record, but because there's been so much um investment by, you know, folks that cared about it, um there's now a book about her life and um some of her records and papers are accessible in the I think it's like Greensboro um historical society and some of the universities there in the state. So again, thanks like it takes work to preserve history and to tell a story and when we take it seriously um it stands for um you know for decades if not centuries and you know now maybe someone in North Carolina can be inspired by Gertude Wheel and work on efforts that then you know even if their bills are referred to the committee on insane asylums they'll they'll keep going.

Amazing. Gotta keep going.

Gotta keep going. This also looks amazing.

Oh. Oh, there it is. Okay. Um, so Frankie Pierce is an activist in uh Tennessee and this is from Nashville. You might be noticing that there are a lot of state capitals represented. I think because of again the suffrage centennial and the role that state capitals play, the state legislatures play in ratification of constitutional amendments, right? Like again this is like article five of the constitution for my game. I didn't invent it. Uh John or um uh James Madison invented it when he was writing the Constitution. Um so we're seeing a lot of this artwork in uh in state capitals, which I love. Like I think that it makes sense. There's more in lots of other places, but these were just some of the ones that I picked out. Um this is the mural of a procession.

Again, just like we saw in the Wyoming um mural. These processions were really important for the suffrage movement to assert power to show just how many women uh were uh you know active and were willing to step out onto the streets to to you petition for their voice and for their citizenship. Um the quote I love we are asking only we're asking only one thing a square deal. This idea that this isn't a special right. This is the right that all of you have was a really important and compelling point. It wasn't about special privileges. It was about equal access. This sort of equality piece comes through. Other suffragists make arguments especially in the early campaign about how like women are so good at cleaning up. We can clean up dirty politics. We can clean. We're so great. Like some of them really dive into some like misogynistic and kind of like weird not weird arguments, but they're trying to convince men in 1870 to give them this right. They are grasping for um for ways to communicate why this isn't a threat, why this helps preserve sometimes racial power, other times the sort of political power that a certain party has enjoyed in a state. Um and we get to then this sort of like end period while World War I is raging while wood President Wilson is on the national the international stage explaining why democracy is so important to America and why giving people a voice

in their government matters and we're willing to to sacrifice young men overseas for this right like the the nature of the debate really shifts to this this is democracy this is, you know, taxation. Um, we're currently living in taxation without representation. We want a square deal, not sort of special rights. And so, um, Frankie Pierce is this great local activist in, um, in Tennessee. And we can see again, right, like a totally different visual style. And this is on the side of, uh, like there's a little tunnel through a park in Nashville. Uh, but like as you're going by it, how could you not notice it? And if you're walking by, how could you not stop um and take a look at the the heaving masses that are, you know, that are marching along to to accomplish this square deal. I think it's wonderful. So, even if we don't have Frankie Pierce's face, we have right like her words and um and all of these other people.

Yes. I want to drive by more things that look like this. This is really nice.

Public art is the best. And the intersection of public art and public history is, as you might tell, be able to tell a sort of special interest of mine.

Definitely all to the good. All right. And we got one more image.

Yes. Uh the we have two women here. Uh one is Mary, the first on the left is Mary Louise Botnau Baldwin. She was a member of the uh Chipawa tribe and came to Washington DC as a law clerk for her father who was serving in the Indian Affairs Bureau um as a part of the Department of Interior. She became one of the first native women to earn a law degree and became a leading activist for suffrage rights even as women in uh indigenous communities were very torn about their identity as as citizens of of sovereign nations versus America. And so she's a bit uh uh much like uh Zit Kalasa um who's also in Votes for Women as well as uh Mary Louise Botnau Baldwin. Um a bit of a controversial character. Um you know, there's not unonymity about whether it's a good idea for indigenous native women to work toward suffrage because why would they get involved in America's affairs? They're a part of their sovereign nations. um she takes the other side and starts petitioning, organizing. She's a part of this meeting in 1913 where she's a first native women woman, one of the first native women to meet with uh Woodra Wilson um in effort to to build support for um for suffrage and eventually loses a position of power

in the National Congress of American Indians over this issue. She's like in as an incumbent like someone runs against her and it's like she's too distracted. she's like not representing our interests. And so again, like these women willing to sacrifice, right? Um and you know, access to power that they have in order to accomplish this goal. Um I think is really interesting. And we also have uh Mary Church Terrell and the other panel of this. Um, and this installation is in Sacramento, the capital of California, and a number of sort of much like a number of uh women of color who were active in the suffrage movement, similar to uh the Recasting the Vote, the book that we talked about. Uh, Mary Church Terrell is a resident of Washington DC.

She speaks four languages is an active um activist for uh the anti-war movement which was very controversial in um in the suffrage movement. It was seen basically as treason not to support world the great war and Wilson's effort as women are activating and agitating against Wilson during 1917 1918 as men are being sent overseas. Um, you know, some women sign up as Red Cross volunteers and become very active in supporting the American war effort and are very critical of women who continue to continue to agitate for suffrage. This another big divide in the suffrage movement. Um, Mary Church Terrell, her son, serves overseas, so she is both giving as a mother but also organizing as a suffragist. and she goes on in her career, in her um activist life to help integrate lunch counters in Washington DC in the 1950s as a woman in her 60s or 70s is like dragged out of people's drug uh popular um chain of um of drugstores and lunch counters um and is this like you know a matriarch of rights and equality across gender and racial lines.

And I think that's pretty neat. I find that very inspiring. She didn't just like, you know, say like, "All right, we did it." She kept at it because liberation is like a lifelong endeavor. And, you know, the work to free us from the kinds of um of racial, gender, you heteronormative bonds uh are, you know, ever ongoing um and ongoing. And so, um, I find that like her story, especially, you know, um, what she continues to work on and do and mix it up with the young kids, a lot of college kids and her, um, you know, getting heckled and sometimes, you know, like you see people dumping food on these activists in the 50s and 60s, um, to be so remarkable, um, so inspiring.

Yeah, this is amazing. Um, so we've reached the end of our actual images. Now I just kind of like talk about our overall takeaways. So I feel like I learned a lot from this. Um you know I'm um I'm I generally gravitate towards learning things from reading.

Uh but this was so cool for me because it really made me think I guess and remember the value of not just what you're I guess consuming privately but what we're all putting out publicly and that's board games, right? like board games as public history, board games as public art are it's it's so unique. It's so and so not only are you reaching new audiences and inviting people to play at your table or sort of, you know, sitting on a shelf that anybody can can pull off and doing these sort of different events, right? Like there's all of that that's happening, but then you're also giving people agency, which is something a mural can't do. It's something movies don't really excel at. They don't say like, "No, what would you what would you do here?"

Right? Like the agency of like you know my game at a very pivotal point asks people which branch of the road do you want to take? Right? And it's this question over white supremacy and over, you know, a quick jolt of strength in the South by jettisoning the rights of of African-American women or to sort of carry on and continue as you were. And what players, especially in the first round, don't know the first time they play is that there's a a real cost to playing that card to saying, "I'll take the quick hit. I'll take those those cubes in the south. I'll take a strategy card. It sounds so great." The opposition really then empowers a lot of action a few cards down the road. and I well you and I were together at Circle DC where I was able to give a talk about my game and one of the questions that came up in the um the panel that was hosted by the MIT game lab was about this southern strategy card and I talked through it and they say like you know most players are just like whip whip whip whip whip like here's the event text okay I'm going to discard in order to lobby right like you're just sort of like humming along in the game but like there's a real choice here and I had a player come that who was present at the panel who then

sat down at the table, played that card, got pummeled and came up to me and was like, I heard you say it. I was you told me what would happen if I played it and I did it anyway because I was just whip whip whip whip whip playing the game. And a book very rarely gives you that opportunity to make a mistake, but to like try a path that

the historical figures were presented with, right? Like this was actually a choice that they had to make. And so, um, you know, and whether you try to go as hard as you can at Congress very early on, which is just a death nail to your chances, it is there's just too early to get Congress to pass the amendment because then you get creamed out in the states, whether you never lobby and you never get Congress on your side, right? like the choices, the strategic decision-making that you have to make in the decision space on the board are representative of the kinds of choices that suffragists were making. And you get to choose, you get to decide and what would things have turned out like if and what you know, I think that that um that way to tell history is so compelling

for real. Um, it's also great. I don't know. The other thing that this is conversation has made me think about is how much history again can get lost without concerted effort.

Oh.

Um, how I mean, you know, you think, oh, like really losing stuff is for antiques and it's for forever ago, but like not really like this didn't happen that long ago and we're already having information.

That's right. I mean, I I will tell you now that every antique store I go into antique mall, I'm like, do you have anything from suffrage? Do you have is there any suffrage? right? Like I try and um I've there's I [snorts] I now have a book written by Anna Howard Shaw who was a a late era suffrage leader of the American Women Suffrage Association. I have this um uh copy the cover of a magazine that essentially is sort of making this argument about like um you're denying women the right to vote while you're giving the right to vote to black men and immigrants and criminals. like gh like white women des it's it's racist and xenophobic the cover of this magazine, but it was an argument that was being made at the time. Um, so like I I've been able to find a few gems of the suffrage movement, but it's really hard. Um, you know, you would think with all of the posters, ephemera, u, postcards, all of the stuff that comes in the box, right? like the game Votes for Women comes with 13 historical reproduction documents because I was able to find those postcards, those sample ballots because someone decided to save them, digitize them, and make them available in the Creative Commons.

um that then players who open up the box can sort of like just it's like history lightning bugs come floating out and like illuminate a kind of time and space um based on language and on telegrams and on sort of all these modes of communications. Um and I think things are absolutely lost. the uh women who were working on that memoir of the um the movement, seven volumes. Uh it was all being all these papers and things were being kept in the attict of um of Matilda Gage's I think I said Susan Gage earlier is Matilda. They're keeping and the house was nearly condemned. Uh that like they nearly lost it all in this like house glass because it was just too much stuff just being stored in a library. There was like a very fortunate like the library of the librarian of Congress in 1920 was friends with a number of the suffragists and was able to take a bunch of that stuff and bring it into the collection. So the Library of Congress has a wonderful national archive but without money, time, interest, um we will absolutely continue to lose more. And the stories that get lost are not of Susan B. Anthony who's writing her own history and Alice Paul who's getting movies made after her. It's the um you know Mary Louise Botno Baldwins and the Mabel Ping Hules who aren't um at the center of things but are such compelling stories and are easier to identify with

in some ways because they're not like these like mythical figures.

Yeah. And then I think the the note I want to close on is um I feel like a lot of this art at least the history behind it and you know even the book you recommended it's very much about I guess persistence in the face of resistance and lack of appreciation because you know I would say that frankly uh in terms of rights and stability of our government things are probably worse in the United States than I can imagine. Like I I it's bad. Um, but you know, these women had an uphill battle. They had food thrown at them. Their own communities got mad at them. They didn't just waltz in and like, you know, drop the mic and everything suddenly changed. That's right. Uh there's an interesting storyline in Iron Jot Angels about a woman who is married to a senator and he is a senator opposed to suffrage and she is very much in support and at a certain point he takes their children to his mother's house and essentially denies her access to her children in an effort to have her stop supporting financially and with her time the suffrage movement. And um and you know she's very wellto-do. She's educated. She's married to a man of prominence. And she essentially has nothing that's not at the grace of her husband who is willing to deny her access to her children and access to bank accounts and access to right. Like women really sacrificed

their relationships and their stability and their place in society to follow on something that they believed deeply in. Um, I think we that I I we are at an incredibly um fragile moment for American democracy, for our rights, for the ability of a multi-racial democracy to thrive. And I think when, you know, when I think about the idea of America with liberty and justice for all, I think about a multi-racial, like that for all is really meaningful to me. that we are a land of immigrants, that we are a place of opportunity where working hard should make a difference, right? But because of I think fascism on the rise, because of the oligarchy, because of the corporate capture, because of all of these things, it's an incredibly delicate moment. And so I think, you know, I think about things in a few different directions. One is to vote. Uh it was just a primary here in Maryland where I live on um on Tuesday and I went out and voted for some incumbents and for some challengers. Um you know it's like there was no line. I got a sticker.

It's like the easiest thing you can do. It's the lowest barrier of entry. If you do nothing else, go vote. But do like but do something else. I've had the privilege of being a poll worker in the past where I got to help folks understand their ballot, how to fill it out, and take them through the process. We need good, nonpartisan, diligent people to be a part of our elections in order to ensure free and fair elections for us all. And so, if you can take the day off, if you can take off a few days and do early voting of just election day, um the I got trained. I just like I sat in the conference room for an hour while they told me what my job was. I got snacks when I was a pole worker. And so, you know, if you're just if you're just in it for the snacks, that's like being an active part of free and fair elections is a great way to ensure that those elections keep happening, right? Uh I would also say, you know, groups like the League of Women Voters are the an like the inheritor of the suffrage movement. Every a dollar from every game sold of uh votes for games printed. So, uh, uh, votes for women goes to the, um, the League of Women Voters, and I think that that's super cool. Um, they are doing some, um, protect the vote, election protection work during the, um, election. And so, if you don't have time, you probably have money. And so, give money to, um, to folks. And if you don't have time and you don't have money, what you do have are friends and family and people in your community and talking to them, being a part of them.

If you have a neighborhood association, if you have an immigrant rights coalition, if you have a um environmental protection group, if you have a a school that's offering, you know, asking folks to come read to the second graders, right? Like being involved in your community is a democratic act. It is a way that we are involved in the future of our country and of our communities. And whatever you're comfortable with, maybe there's lots of people around or maybe there's no people around. Maybe it's just a check or maybe it's just your time. There are so many ways, right? Like the suffrage movement gave every way they can. One of my favorite stories is about um suffrage sewing circles that women whose husbands were opposed and they couldn't have, you know, materials in their house or couldn't read. They'd all get together with their sewing, right?

Like they'd have socks to darn and children's clothes to mend and whatever it was. And the one woman who could read would get the the newspaper, the pamphlet, the broad sheet about what was happening in different states and read to the rest of the women about what was happening so that they could stay involved and understand what's going on. Even if they couldn't read, even if their husbands didn't want any of that in their household, they could say, "I'm going to sewing circle." Not, "I'm going to be radicalized by my neighbors and then for right like start a suffrage sewing circle. start a a place, a coffee shop meetup where you read a book like Recasting the Vote or you go on a tour of public art in your community and talk about it and how it made you feel. It doesn't have to be join a big organization.

join together means someone you know or maybe a stranger to to to talk about common interest values and the reason that we are proud at this 250th anniversary to be Americans because there's a lot to be proud of. There's a lot to be afraid of. I'm not going to like I understand our history. It is uh uh nicely put complicated. Um,

that's one way.

But like fish and bones, there's so much to be proud of. And that promise of America, that promise of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for everyone is something I believe is worth being active for, worth spending time, money, and community on. So that's a perfect end cap, I think, for this conversation. Um, so Tori, first I want to thank you so much for coming on. It's always such a delight. Um, and I feel like I learned a lot, got some really good suggestions, and hopefully others out there feel the same.

Liz, this is such a pleasure, and I'm so glad you're doing this. I'm so glad you're connecting books, media, broader public ways that we express our values and our interests and our history. I think it's such like a worthy discussion. It's obviously something near and dear to my heart. I can't wait to tune in to the rest of the episodes and learn because I know that you'll bring us the most interesting people in the like the best games.

That's the dream. Uh all right, everybody out there, please uh like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and uh go do something with other people who live near you

or online. It

doesn't matter. Do it.

Bye, everybody.

Progress saved