Skip to main content
Loading video...

Treasure Island Board Game Review

Transcript 15:39

only have been away for the last month traveling the world I guess went to Canada went to Germany to shucks and essence feel big podium conventions and I spent a lot of time having fun playing games with friends and meeting new people and and now I'm back here in England and it looks like this and all my friends are away and you know what I am not the least bit sad because here at FBI we work very very hard to show you that best games to find the most hidden gems and I am so happy to report but this time around we have uncovered an actual trip okay get ready because this game is tre cool it has horses it has pirates it even has a plastic ruler because geometry is fun Treasure Island is a game that asks you to do exactly what it says on the tin one player playing as Long John Silver will secretly mark a location with the tiniest X on this map and then it is your job to find it to illustrate just how stupendous this task is I have enlisted the help of a line to find a needle I have hidden in this pillow whilst she's keeping herself busy let's take a brief look at the roles Treasure Island is played from two perspectives

one player who takes on the role of Long John Silver and the rest of the motley crew who will blindly try to dig through every inch of this island trying to find his treasure aside from your special abilities all the time you can do one of three things one of those free things is moving up to six miles or in this case six inches but because publisher matakohe knows that podium is essentially kindergartners at heart the way you actually move in this game is by putting a measuring ruler and then drawing the distance with a coloring hand and then once you actually get to where you want to go another thing you can do is you can search for treasure and you do that by placing this circular tool and drawing a circle in the middle of it and going long-john is the treasure there it's not you can also do a mini combination of both actions by moving only three miles and then searching with the small search tool after each search long John will sheepishly hand you a cardboard tray chest it's most likely empty but it could hold a little bonus or even the coveted treasure itself and if you found it right you've won the game talking of which let's see if the lane has won a game so any luck with the needle as Long John Silver a man named after his underway you will still take turns always before another player but what you do isn't entirely up to you and is

dictated by the game for example the game add force you to give out a clue to another player out of a selection of bad worse and actually this doesn't look that bad at all I'm gonna oh oh no no no I think I've just ruined myself for example the game won't give you a choice of naming two players one of them is closest to the treasure whereas the other one is irrelevant but crucially you don't have to tell anyone which one is which and mask that alone isn't enough to reveal anything everything you say can and will be used against you in a geometric code of pirate law later a player might ask you to give a compass clue which is you taking yet another transparent and gorgeously understated measuring tool and it eliminates waves of territory in two directions or a clue might ask you to draw an eight mile circle centered around a miniature and the treasure is somewhere within that eight mile radius and of course you get this thing to play around with because you're a child at heart but what you're doing is you're drawing your own noose every nugget of information that you give out will be noted corroborated remembered and used to hang you with the rope wolven from the trail that you have yourself laid out what's best is that some clues a public whilst other clues are given out in secret and in that way each opponent dominates your brain space with its own individual mind map of information for example at the start of

the game you'll give each player one of these tokens they will eliminate one of the eleven areas in the game telling them that hey you know that the treasure is definitely not there and you don't have to go there and search for it but the other players might still wander over and draw their circles or a player might ask you through the course of the game to give them a compass clue which means you'll Center this giant compass tool around the miniature and eliminate two areas telling them hey the treasure is definitely not there so then each time you're forced to make a selection out of three clues to give them you're not just making a selection out of free bag clues you're making a selection out of free bag clues that are weighed up against what you think they know or what you think they think that you know that they know but the real beauty of it is that it was it may seem like a vicious net of coloring pens about to ensnare you piling layers and layers of stress so much stress that you will wish you brought an extra pair of long johns a clever pirate will use all of this to their advantage while so much of the game that Long John is playing is based around figuring out who knows what so much of the rest of the game that the other players are playing is also based around figuring out who knows what let's say that Long John just gave someone a compass clue and suddenly they're making a beeline all the way across the map and did they actually figure out where the treasure is always long John just

messing with them each time long John is forced to give a clue he's also forced to put a facedown token underneath it most of these tokens simply state that this clue is true however two of these tokens say that this clue could be true but it could also be a lie so twice per game you have the opportunity to confound bamboozle and lead you opponents on a wild sheep chase let's say I'm playing as long John and I just gave a clue that the treasure is self of the blue miniature which is definitely not I your first instinct is that I'm an idiot I have but two lies and I wasted one of them by clearly giving out false information because if what I said is true then the amount of territory left to search would be so minuscule that I'd lose the game before I could say yo-ho-ho and a bottle of Tizer so you check what's underneath that token and find out that it is indeed a question mark which means what I said could have been true but it could have also been a lie which tells you absolutely nothing as the game goes on the noose gets tighter and tighter not only because the clues eliminate large portions of the map but also because each search another player performs tells you exactly where the treasure isn't and in fact for a game where no one is meant to be cooperating you'll find yourself banding together with other treasure hunters sharing tidbits

of information not too much because if you tell them everything you know and they don't tell you everything they know then you're at a steady disadvantage but just enough to steer them in the right direction so then their searches just let you know a little bit more here's another thing that's nice about this game the details things like an actual cardboard treasure chest or a hidden compartment in the box full of gold coins or consider this if this game wasn't the genius that it is how would Long John Silver actually win well they'd probably have to confound the treasure hunters for a number of rounds and if they haven't found it by the end of those rounds then long John would win except that would be anticlimactic and boring after a few rounds a few clues and tidbits the game will ask us to place Long John Silver's figure on one of these towers on the map eventually our treasure master will break out and make a beeline for the treasure if they reach it before we actually manage to find the treasure ourselves that's it they've won the game immediately we're pressed into a corner and to cooperate because if we place Long John right next to where the treasure is accidentally they'll win the game as soon as they break out we want to buy ourselves a little bit of time and that's what's gonna force us to share just a little bit of that private knowledge that we have and just like that with a little bit of dressing up and the theatre magicians touch this game becomes fabulous and my word is it brave there's a long history of hidden

movement board games from the sleek and elegant Scotland Yard to the bloated anger gang xuan fury of dracula and the reason there's so many of them is because well it turns out that hide-and-seek is really fun and it isn't just hide-and-seek it's smart and clever because it's asking you to analyze clues and eliminate information engage that detective part of our brain a part that has a surprising amount of endorphins in it but Treasure Island doesn't want to be just another hidden movement game instead it wants to be a hidden movement game where the hidden movement doesn't move part of the joy / frustration of these games is that the hidden object is always on the run always evading you so to flip that on its head and say there is no movement with a hidden object it's always so frustrating when you lose track of it but here you'll always zeroed in always getting closer than to take that and somehow make it continuously feel exciting and clever that is a tall order and the attempt on its own deserves copious amounts of hours I'm sorry I wanted to say like praise but in a piratey way and it just came out as ass that's not the only thing that makes this design so fresh Treasure Island feels wild and untamed like a picture drawn by a five-year-old and it's easy to like it if you're the parent of the thing that made the drawing but if you're anyone else you will most likely go uh-huh

that's very nice and that's actually the best bit because whilst on the surface it seems wild and untamed actually underneath it there's a real cohesive structure and it takes real skill to design something that appears to be all over the place but is grounded underneath you just don't see it we don't want to make it sound like Treasure Island is a game for people who are into gaming because sure it does innovate on established ideas and it does subvert ropes but at the same time it's incredibly accessible after all it is just draw a line and then draw a circle is the treasure in there yes no if no keep playing until it's in there it's incredibly welcoming and everyone can enjoy it and we would undoubtedly recommend it but predictably this is a time for just a few tiny caveats because the amount of joy brings is parallel to help invest it the players are into this idea in fact just having one person not buying to the concept of deducting the needle in a haystack can bring the atmosphere of the entire table down as they gripe and groan about drawing geometric shapes with coloring pens a critique observed by friend of the channel John Perkis check his channel out that's a minor complaint because we're talking about edge cases here but let's take the accessibility critique a little bit further if you're color blind good luck playing this game whilst the board is double-sided and does contain a more polite friendly version you are still playing this game with red and green marker pens and after some testing

with a colorblind vision and we found that if you have red color deficiency there's no way you're telling these apart of course this could potentially be solved by buying friendlier coloring pens but we'll have to leave that experimenting to you let us know all your results in the comments but that's not where the accessibility story ends because my word and I do mean word this rulebook get ready for some championship level front light with phrases like we will see later how to raise the doubt about that Oh to do so he materialized the treasures location okay we're poking a little bit too much fun but this is just the mere sampling of the idiosyncratic translations that make this rulebook just too much of a chore to learn the game from black out is also peculiar in this game with three to five players being the treasure hunter is great because not only are you working with the information that long-john gives you but you're also bouncing off of other players but if you're just playing a two-player game then long John gives you all of the information and there's nothing to bounce off of whereas if you're playing as loads on the two-player game is great because you suddenly thrust into a Tom and Jerry game and if you're a millennial enough familiar with that reference then Hannibal Lector and Clarice Starling what do you mean you're also not familiar with those anyway my point is that if you introduce more players into that equation and you're playing as long term suddenly your game becomes a little bit wishy-washy making this game have no ideal player account but unless this

directly eliminates you from being able to play the game and what a shame that would be we found none of the other reasons to be strong enough or good enough for us to not actually recommend this fantastic and lovely game the only strong criticism we could come up with is that we're not entirely sure about the longevity of the game yes technically each time long-john draws and next they draw it in a different place and they're giving out different clues but the puzzle you're solving is still the same puzzle but even if the magic wears off there's still that rush of tension and excitement as the game draws to a crescendo I swear to you even the coldest of hearts will start beating like a wardroom when you realize that the treasure is just one or two searches away but long-john has gotten out of there tower will a lucky shot winning will you share information just to stop Long John from winning because they've been a naughty player Treasure Island is one of the most riveting exciting and drop-dead gorgeous games we have played in the last year and you know what we I always love to find a good excuse to muck around with coloring pens again so do yourself a favor and get this game and to see us out here's a little bit from Millay I've already searched this home

someday cause you're mad Oh subscribe

Progress saved