Black Orchestra: Resistance - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Black Orchestra Resistance, which is the expansion to Black Orchestra. Um, this ended up being an expansion that was kind of, you know, completely out of nowhere considering the Black Orchestra came out in 2016. So, in games that have that, you know, that were released years and years ago and then an expansion comes out very recently, I've had very bad experiences with that just because it's like, okay, this game is clearly not, you know, in the zeitgeist. It's not it's not, you know, extremely popular. So, an expansion so many years later is always kind of intriguing. Now, let's go ahead and get one of the major negatives out of the way, which I mean, I think just for a lot of people might be uh a problem. It actually ended up being a problem for me in that this expansion is done by a completely different company than the original first printing. Uh I had actually forgotten that there was a second printing for it that is done by Tabletop Tycoon I think is who the company is. So the cards and the tiles that you get and the uh the conspirators that you get all have completely different um like layouts. So, like this
looks completely different than the first edition. Um, the cards are slightly bigger than the than the first edition. And the color hue is different. Um, as well as the tokens. The tokens are the biggest deal because they're the items um on that are just supposed to be again shuffled in with all other items. And they are very clearly a different color. I don't know if you can see it from where I'm at right now, but it's extremely noticeable. And apparently it was noticeable in the videos they were releasing during the campaign. And I guess at some point that was corrected, but then something happened where it wasn't corrected. So that's extremely unfortunate. And I understand that it's it's difficult to try and print it to where it matches a completely different company's, you know, method of printing. But what they I just feel like what they should have done is just reprinted all the tokens for the expansion.
um or have an option like an add-on to pay to have them reprinted because it's annoying. Someone in a forum actually came up with a pretty clever idea of just taking the items and put them in like a bag, like a token bag or maybe a cup and just maybe using some type of marker, black cubes, red discs on the locations to denote how many are there. So whenever you are looking at them, you can just draw from the bag and it's still random. And I actually kind of like that idea more than how it is right here. Uh all that being said, it it's slightly understandable. Normally for a lot of companies, I would rip on them. Uh but I think it's slightly understandable in this case. It's still very annoying. Uh now with that being said, let's go ahead and get to Resistance as an expansion. It is a modular expansion, which is the best kind of expansion that comes with three different ways to play. And to simplify it all, it's kind of ways to make the game easier or harder. It's a basically a difficulty scaling on top of what was already a way to make the game more difficult, which was just kind of increasing how much support Hitler has at the beginning of the game. But I think each one of these modules is extremely solid. I really liked all of them. Now what I will say and it does say oh use these in any combination or where was it can be added to the game for additional variety and new strategy.
It doesn't say anywhere that they can't be played together, but it also doesn't say they can because, and the reason why I say that is because for setup on every single one of them, you're adding in cards to either the conspirator deck or to the event deck. And each one tells you how many like a different number of cards to remove from the deck. And it doesn't say you don't it doesn't say whether you add all those together. If you throw in all expansions, do you remove like five cards from each deck? do you you know which one do you do? So it's a little weird in terms of the setup of the game, but with the rules of all of them, it actually works out really well. So you can play with all of the modules in setup just might be a little weird and the game might last a little bit longer um than what you're expecting it to be, but let's go ahead and go through them.
So, the three expansions or the three modules is Red Orchestra, Horsed Copcow, and the Chrysowl Circle. I'm assuming all of these are based on historical facts. I did not look any of this up, so I don't know if the Red Orchestra was a real thing or if Horus Copcow was a real person or if the Chrysowl Circle was a real thing. But all of these, I think, are fantastic. So, the Red Orchestra introduces um missions. There's this mission deck that and teleprinters that you put out on the map and those teleprinters uh can it's just an action really to put them down. A lot of the expansion stuff has you roll dice just to do kind of a check. Maybe it adds suspicion, maybe it doesn't. That's really what the die roll is. But the missions are uh incredibly varied. You are I mean one of them was like they'll give you a prompt on how to complete the mission and a reward for doing it. On top of that, each successful mission that you have adds to the number of dice you get during plot attempts. Um, so like for example, raise resistance pace uh place pamphlets in stage two and three locations equal to the number of players. Pamphlets are another item you can place out. The reward is all conspirators in stage two or three raise their motivation by two. uh forgery expert, go to Zurich, discard any three cards. Then each conspirator searches and takes any card from the conspirator deck, shuffle the deck. So these are a lot of them are kind of difficult to do.
Some might be situational, some you might top deck. Um and the rewards are always great. Now, the teleprinters are kind of interesting because they have two tokens that go towards each one, and that's how you get more missions out. but they can also just be removed by having Hitler or any of his deputies go to those locations. Uh so the missions are meant to make the game easier mainly because of the fact that you're getting huge rewards for really, you know, easy mission uh goals to complete and the fact that it adds how many dice you get. Now, one thing I didn't find in the rule book or in my plays of this is if you spend those missions to do that or if it's just like a passive every it says every future plot, but I I could still see that being taken as like a I mean any future plot, any one future plot, you can spend any number of those cards to add a dice. Or if it's just a passive umbrella, all future plots for the rest of the game will add this many dice. So, the more missions you complete, it's going to make it easier just because you've done all of those to allow you to uh basically increase your chances of completing a plot because for the most part, completing plots in Black Orchestra is not the easiest thing in the world. You have to have a lot of things line up to make it work, which again is incredibly thematic, and I that's why I love uh the plots in this game. Uh, in fact, this very game we
just played, we had almost everything go right for a suitcase bomb, but we were like one fortifi or one target away uh from it. So, it just didn't go off and that was our only explosive. And I was like, that is so legitimately thematic that it's like the suitcase bomb in real life didn't work and it didn't work in this game. and we ended up getting it with a poison parcel mainly again by completing a lot of missions and having a lot of items come our way that they needed to. So if you want to make the game easier or maybe play on a harder difficulty but you find that just kind of an arbitrary way to increase difficulty um then the missions are just a very nice change of pace because they're just really good and uh I mean you have a lot of them. So the red orchestra is a is a really good module. Then we go to horse cop cow which is apparently some basic you know private eye his own he's another not a deputy but he's another resource or another person that moves around the board and he starts in stage two. So once stage two hits you have a new action or not a new action you have a new uh uh step at the end of your turn. So after you draw and resolve an event, then he moves and he basically hyperfixates on whoever has the highest suspicion. And whenever he moves, he always just moves closer and closer to you. So you're constantly trying to evade him because every if he lands on
your space, you have to draw an encounter card. And these encounters are very hindering. They basically rely on you being um if you're alone like pay it forward. If you're alone, the next conspirator cannot conspire and has only two actions next turn. But if you're with conspirators, apply the effect above and increase the suspicion of all present conspirators by one. Um attracting attention. If you are alone, Hitler moves to your location. If you are with conspirators, Hitler, Himmer, and Gobles move to your location. So these are just bad that constantly happen. Some of them are a little bit better because you can you have a choice. You can play it safe like suspicious documents increase if you can play it safe increase your suspicion to extreme or take a chance. You roll a dieice. If it's the bird go immediately to prison otherwise no effect. So there is a I mean and he's just constantly if you don't move and you have the highest suspicion then he will just constantly after everyone's turn cause you to draw these event these encounter cards. And the problem with this is um you uh you lose if the deck runs out. So it's kind of another timer on top of the events that are going on. So it this is what you add to make the game harder.
And he definitely makes hard cuz he'll make you lose items, he'll make you lose cards, he'll send you to jail, he'll he'll, you know, he and his innate ability regardless of if you start your turn there or he just happens to land there, he prevents you from interacting with any items on the location. So, he's kind of a dick, but I really actually kind of enjoyed his presence. He wasn't overbearing. Like yes, these encounter cards suck and yes, they're a timer, but it never felt like unfair, especially whenever I was act like we were trying to get a plot to go off, so I was I kept staying in a position, but he kept having me drawing counter cards and yeah, they were they were hindering, but they weren't debilitating. It wasn't like and because of that, we lost like and just out of my control. flipped that card and the actually I think actually one card kind of threw a wrench in a lot of plants because I went around I had um it was it was a plot where I needed a bunch of poison. It wasn't the poison parcel, but um it was something else where I could Oh, poison gas, I think, is what it was.
And that was my only plot card in in in my hand. And I think one of the interrogation cards had me remove it, which sucked. And I had no way to fish it out. So, that sucked. But I actively chose to stay there. And it's not like there's nothing you can do. There is an action that you can you can do where you just roll a dieice. If you don't roll the bird, then he you can move him a space. So you can you can control a little bit about where he's going. So that was horse copcow. I liked him. Probably out of the three modules though, the horse cop cow is my least favorite. Um just because everything else everything else is like for the players. It makes it a lot easier. He's the only one that makes makes things a little bit more difficult. And the last one, the Chrysowl Circle is also great.
uh because it gives you allies and these allies have amazing abilities, but it's a double-edged sword. So, where the copcow one makes the game harder and the red orchestra one makes it easier, this one's kind of both because until it basically adds all the extra tokens that are mismatched and look like Um, it adds ally tokens and you can recruit allies, which are like these tokens that have special abilities that could be used by anyone at any time. But you have to recruit allies if you want to make plots easier. So there's the um there's the ally board that I mean just the very first one. Note, no plot may be attempted without a recruited ally. So the more you need or the more you recruit, the easier plots actually get. Otherwise, they're they're progressively harder. So even if you have one ally or if you have no allies, you just can't attempt a plot. But if you have one ally, then plots have minus one target and plus one bird and all plots require reckless. So even though you have an ally, you can still attempt one, but it's insanely difficult and you'd have to have god tier rolling.
But as you recruit more and more allies, it gets even easier. So, if you have five allies recruited, then you actually get plus one um target uh during plots, which is great. If you have four, it even tells you in the rules, hey, once you have you basically need four cuz once you're at four, no modification. It's just normal rules. But these allies are great. I mean, draw three conspirator cards, ignore all birds during a plot, do not resolve an event this turn. uh draw five conspirator cards, keep one, shuffle the rest back into the deck. And these are all instants that could be done, you know, at any time. One of them just is like, oh, if someone's already in jail, you prevent someone from going to jail. It's they're they're really really good. Um, but with the ally cards, uh, you have you have a new, um, or not ally cards, ally tokens. You have a new action called uncover where if you want to reveal the tiles there, um, you need to roll a dieice and you need to roll a number. Doesn't really matter what number, but you just need to roll a number to reveal both of them.
And so it actually becomes more uh costly of an action to to take them because if you want the item or you want to recruit an ally, you have to attempt to do that. And recruiting an ally is also a die roll. So um sorry, uncovering it was just if you it was any result except a bird. Recruiting was rolling a number. So the one thing is if you are throwing in every single expansion into it, the die results are it it's kind of like okay which one just needed the the numbers uh cuz you you get like four new actions. So most of them are all just roll a dieice if it's not the bird and all all the birds just raise suspicions. Um everything else is is just good to go except recruiting. Recruiting was like hey drill the target still fails. You need a number.
So, it adds a little bit more die rolling, which is very minimal. But yeah, I really like the extra the extra um tiles, especially because the tiles can just be plus one motivation or minus one uh Hitler's uh military support. They can also be Gestapo raids. So, there's a risk there. But also, it doesn't really clarify if you can just flip one of them as just a generic action. Oh, if I go to a spot with two locations, can I just pick one to flip? I would assume you can, but if you want to reveal both, like a two for one special, it requires a a die roll. Uh, which is pretty much something you're always going to do, I would assume. So, the allies, I think, are great. I like the double-edged sword of kind of like, yeah, we need allies to be able to complete the plot, otherwise we just can't do it. But the allies are really good with their abilities, so we kind of want to get them more and more.
But we have to go out and find them. And so that like out of the three, the Chrysler Circle is actually my favorite module to throw in because I think it's just the one that would be easier as a module like because it's not really skewing with the difficulty. I mean, it is, but it's also not. So, it's just kind of the more involved one between the three. missions would probably be the next involved one and then uh the copcow is the easiest one to implement. So overall, like with this expansion coming out almost 10 years later, not counting second edition, uh it's a super solid one. Like if it is historically accurate, which again I'm assuming so, then I think it's great because what's also neat is every single one of the modules adds in new event cards. So you have a little bit more variety with those depending on which ones. Like if you play with all of them, you just throw all of them in. It adds more conspira conspirator cards. I think it only added one new plot though, so it would have been kind of nice to add more plots. But maybe maybe the maybe the plots are all historically accurate as well. Maybe they were all attempts on Hitler's life in real life.
I never thought about that. And then it also adds some uh new characters which have insanely broken abilities like the one that I just played with. she got to just not resolve events if it was if she unless it was a Gestapo raid, she could choose to do it or not. So, that is insanely insanely broken. And then the one my girlfriend was playing uh was able to go to stages one stage higher. Uh and in stage seven, no place was off limits. So that was also great because you're not restricted as much to various locations which helped incredibly against Copcow because she was able to go around and not and not be kind of so limited to where he's at. So yeah, like this expansion I think is awesome. It doesn't I mean it only adds to the game.
Like you could still play regular black orchestra and and be perfectly fine, but if you want to just up the game a little bit depending on your mood, h let's throw copcow in. Let's just have someone kind of chase us down. Uh oh, you know, I kind of want to do a little bit more. Let's add missions like make it a little bit easier just to get a quick game of Black Orchestra in. Or I want a little bit more involved uh thematic game like that that has some more strategy. Let's throw in the the Chrysowl Circle one. It's It's really really good. So, if you like Black Orchestra, I highly recommend Resistance as as an expansion. And the other nice thing is that it's a fairly small footprint expansion. It would fit in the base game perfectly fine uh because it really doesn't add that much components like a few tokens, a few extra cards, and the rest is all stuff from the uh base game. So, yeah, that's it. On a scale of one to 10, I think I'm gonna give this a I think I'm gonna give it a nine. I really really enjoyed it. There wasn't a single module that I was like, uh, probably wouldn't play that. Like that one kind of sucks. The other two are good. This one sucks. I think all three of them are great. And because they each and and the rules for them are literally like one side is setup and the other side is the rules. And the player the boards for them are also fantastic. They just tell you here's what the new action is and here's, you know, the actual just kind
of shorthand rules for it. So, they made it extremely accessible to learn the game and remember stuff like if you're just adding in one module, you don't have to flip in and be like, "Okay, which one?" You know, what was the new action? It's already right there. It's all organized in a spot. So, it's really a super solid expansion. So, yeah, that's another one. That's my thoughts on Black Orchestra Resistance. Let me know what you think of the expansion in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on.
Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.