Great Western Trail: New Zealand - Board Game Review & Comparison
Transcript
hello everyone this is Cinema and this is Johannes and you are watching board gaming rambling and today we are talking to you about Great Western Trail New Zealand from Alexander Fisher and egg Spiller it plays one to four players and 75 to 150 minutes we're back we're back back back with a new Great Western Trail game yes are you not excited yes I am so excited you're like yes we have it here yes we have it it's a game we've played it no stress no stress and yeah we have saying Norwegian which makes no sense to say in English basically it's no stress in like uh tracksuit which makes no stress in a track suit which makes no sense in English and today we are talking about Great Western Trail a New Zealand it's very hard not to say great was in Argentina oh yeah because it feels like that was just wired and also it's a wired with the music Great Western Trail View city land doesn't work that well yeah it works it isn't iconic in the same way and this video is not going to be about songs it's going to be about the game yeah but this is not going to be a traditional review we are basically gonna say you hopefully know how to play with us and Trail if you don't there's other videos about that great western Central Argentina we did a video about that this is going to be the differences and there are quite a few of them so we just have to jump in basically if you have never played Great Western train you are trying to move around do actions deliver sheep in this one that's basically the
main difference that's the one-way street with actions along the way one is Rich slash rondelle it's kind of like actually a rundown but it's looks like a one-way street because it's it feels like that in most one way reason other games are you get you don't go one time do you that's true but they don't having a nail for example yeah I I agree with you it's kind of the same thing but not uh okay let's talk about this game yes we're gonna talk about the differences the first one is that cows are now yeah that is a huge difference yes look at this now I don't want to play the game anymore what kind of shape is this it's a Dorset horn and this is Suffolk probably on this is a Ryland and this is Lincoln and then we have Romney that we have a little English Leicester yeah salsa and this one we know Merino wool yeah because we that's something that people they're very cute I already forgave them for not being cows yes yes so that's it that's the end of the video the key sheep are now cows well yes
it has the same value as before like when you send them away but you also have this share of value which is yeah which is the amount of wool that you get when you share your sheep shave a sheep yes and you have to play in a game save a ship the Lego game when you you play the time because some of the actions on this one-way street is now that you can share shape and get money for the wall before we go any further this is a reboot puppy yes we have to say that and I forget sometimes but no I said it and you know it continue and there's also now a new worker which is the Cutters man Cutters man it's a sharer or a sheep Barber if you will and then the amount of sheep that you can share depending on how how many of those workers you have and also if you don't want to go for like a strategy win series you also have some buildings both of the neutral buildings and some you can go for if you go over a heavy building strategy and you build for example this building here which you need five Builders and you can then share basically three different as if you had the three of the sharers which is a pretty nice nice thing so you can basically get food for the show dude yeah so this means because when you share the Sheep when you sell the world there's some new like places you can then place your disks to
unlock axillary actions and stuff like that but the biggest change is that you can now get money throughout the round oh yeah because when you play Great Western Trail the original Great Western Trail the money you have at the beginning of like your round to this uh rondelle one-way Street and it's the money you have right there so yeah you can like throw away one year or two to get like two coins but that is very very little here you can actually get like four five six seven coins or eight nine yeah 13 like yeah 100 I'll go there um but yeah so yeah it makes it basically like it makes the game the money is less tight yes I don't remember exactly how that was in Argentina but I felt like I had more money in this game than I had also in Argentina the next thing there's no train no the train is gone and now we have a ship that will be moving around on a map and we're gonna show you so I don't know where sorry when I took those away to show I don't know because I wouldn't nobody knows nobody knows let's see it so there you can move both the forwards and backwards which there are three like main routes to go and chew out this this journey that you can take it's not a one which read nor everyone down no it's not it's tracks yes there are different locations that you can stop on and to visit to say hi to people unlocked like scoring bonuses places to deliver later and so on and it makes the game pretty different because like in a Great Western Trail if you don't move your
train at all you're gonna have to pay so much of your income to the location to basically get to the location here it's the collocations have like set values that you have to paint so if you have a value of 18 you're gonna have to pay six yes it's no doesn't matter where your train is doesn't because the train isn't there so it doesn't matter where it is it doesn't do all of those things doesn't matter it also makes this strategy kind of more interesting because the train strategy in Great Western Trail is basically move the train and get points and it's kind of the same here but you have kind of three different locations one of them is kind of like is is like the stations yes where you get the station monster here it's called Harbor monster tiles but there's also called some money and you get some points and some cards we're gonna talk about later and you also have two different ones where you unlock uh locations to deliver a rule and deliver a ship and also you have like the third one where you basically just pay a coin and two of them you put out these small trading houses let's take a look at the player board yes because the player board is also quite different it's like bigger it has better stronger faster you track here for gold which we're going to talk about later it also has like rooms for all these training houses so if you go for like a sailing strategy you can place a lot of them out getting different bonuses along the way like permanent wool permanent of these Awards and so on ribbons like a ribbon ribbons like that and the thing is I feel like like you can of course go for a very lightly movement in the Great
Western trade with a train I feel like you can even more ignore moving on this map in this game yes I agree which is good yeah absolutely but I think it it is also fun to get some of the bonuses oh yeah but you don't obviously you can go for very little or very much and I like that in the game in general and and also I went super heavy for this in one game I played not with you and I play with a friend uh you're also my friend thank you another friend um and that was I went super heavy for this got to the end of all three tracks and so there's many points to get here as well yes we have so much things to talk to uh let's talk about chords yes because the cars are very different in this game it is a new type of card that you can unlock in different ways um and some of them are always in the game yes and some are mixed up so you play with like four out of 10 different ones every time you play and you can for example use then the new resource which is gold to buy some of these cards and the cards um doesn't take space on your hand and I think that is very interesting because all of the cards have like a bonus that when you play it you draw a new card back on your hand so it's like free actions it feels real life reactions to me and it's another thing that makes the game a little bit less tight because there's the the third one which is in
the box is getting two coins yes and if you have like three of those and you are lucky to get them like oh that's six coins and you get the chords back and it's kind of like but the thing is it feels now more like a deck building game because you can build your deck kind of differently but these not still not like a deck building not an annoying game but they're called like deck building cards and you're gonna get them into your hand um and they're bonuses basically but as I said making the uh the the game a little bit less tight yes I like that some of the cars have bonuses that are a little bit specific but then they always have the ability to for example take a coin instead I I really enjoyed that so I don't like take up dead space in your hand I like the fact do you basically set it but that you're using four out of 10 of the sets so that you have variability yeah uh because a game where you the car that gives you like this one is always in it moving on the Pathfinder track which is a new track yeah we're gonna talk about soon uh and and then there's a car that can be in the game that also moves on the podfone track but gives you a coin and and I went like I went I got all three of them in the two playing on that plane and either adjusted the top and got loads and loads of money for that cool so there's like different like in Great Western Trail I feel like but more in-game survivability kind of like Angel Innovation where to just talk about Terra music all of that there's a way to look at the border Milago this game this these things are very good yes and these things will make the game better so we are now basically
like not saying a lot about what we think so what do you think about this change do you like the new cards I think I said that I like oh you did yeah but it's easy because there's so much stuff to cover that we have to remember that I like the shape I like the cards yes do you feel like these bonuses they because for me they are fun like I enjoy oh I got those cards it's very fun I like but it's also I said it many times already makes the game easier yeah and is that okay yeah I think that it is okay I remember back to playing do you remember um great person Trail and Great Western Trail Argentina that it feels so hopeless and you get like in the beginning and you get a degree of that as well it hasn't been a game where I haven't been like okay I have two lost resorts to deliver to this really bad place this because yeah you get need some time to get your get your strategy going but it it hasn't given me that really hopeless feeling that I often get in the beginning with the original Great Western Trail I agree let's briefly talk about the Pathfinder track yes how does it work what does it do what is it it is very simple it's basically a new check that gives you victory points gold uh gives you more movement and you can also get like choose here is really interesting you get to choose between another movement yeah or that these Hazard the hands the hands basically are
free to you which I feel like both are very powerful and I always struggle to be like what is the smartest to do this round and also it's another small change is that the price for paying the price for movement on these hands is the same with all fairy accounts yeah because earlier with two players it was one for both but now it's the same as one for the black and two for the green that's true um big change over here oh yeah this is huge actually here we have a worker market and now we have a new completely new type of time yeah called the bonus tiles yes so all of the like now there's like there's was one two three I don't remember Argentina I think it was the same yeah when you come up here and you paint them or you put them in here you have an A and A B there's only two Banks yes and the A's are only workers and Hazards yes and the bees are only bonus times yes which means that every time you reach uh Wellington you have to put a b tile in this track right here and that makes the game go steadily forwards it can't you you can't hinder it's going forwards and you can't like progress it more than it would have naturally no well and the other one says like tiny things like sometimes I'm gonna put the hazard to hope that the game lost a little bit longer I can't do that here and also these workers um yeah they have their own space instead of being like on the the the end of game is pack I'm trying like I haven't thought about this before now why do you think that is why do you
think this change is here like when they're basically what it does is and you're like don't ask me this basically what it does is that it would depending on how many of these are in the market they're cheaper they are yeah cheaper they are a lot of cheap jokes than this and and these are the same this is of course less a lot shorter but these are the same like going up and down in price like it did in in the other two so I don't know that's mine no absolutely but I think that uh yes in the original game sometimes I could be like okay I know that you want a builder for example let's then place this Builder over on the very expensive spot right here and I hope that you have to pay a lot for it or I want a something else the locomotivist I don't know that is not the word engineer engineer yeah yes and I can place him a very cheap place but I kind of get that satisfied yeah yeah I got it now but I get the same satisfaction with these bonus Styles as well sometimes I can do that strategy like or like the Tactical thinking with those instead of the the workers or the people and as in Great Western Trail the other two it's basically a bit like uh random which of these workers comes out and you might draw a little hazards you might draw a lot of workers in the beginning of the game as well you're gonna draw one of each is going to be here and I'm going to draw like a a set
number yeah so you can start with like loads of workers in the market or you can start with lots of Hazards which also of course changes the game out how it how it feels yeah because even though money is less tight it's a huge difference between paying five and paying eight four oh yeah because that money isn't that tight doesn't mean that money is loose money is still tight let's talk a bit about the the bonus Styles and do you want to tell me and the people uh what are they yeah and they are spending the money that it says sometimes spending gold or gaining gold yeah gaining either a um bonus that are instant or some points at the end of the game for example and some of them can also give you those cards that we talked about earlier and you have a joker worker as well that is nice that you have to pay a goal to be able to place and can be any type of worker and these are these are interesting they are kind of they're very different like they're not like game changing like wow but they're kind of something like this and the deck building things are big changes yes like it makes the game feel different like if you go get a lot of money you can buy this and get loads of points like the one time we played you had like so many points here and it's also a few of those that give you loads of points for gold so you can like if those come out you can try to get a lot of gold to buy those you have to pay money and go on but you get like eight points for each of the tiles yes so uh so um so much stuff going on there and I
I like this like it's it's different it's not like as I said wow this is so cool but it's a different thing and makes the game feel different yes and all of these changes makes it feel more like a little point-sality to me than the original game um and there's many things to do here and many things that are unique for this game yes I agree yeah that was the end that is the end of my sentence usually I'm good at the understanding that yeah sentences and and then others begin yeah but yeah it feels more like a Sandbox I I as I said like there's you can go heavy for like going have a train it's not it's a strategy kind of but you have to do something else going heavier for the shape here is pretty good you can get quite a few points for that and you can go for like the sharing strategy you can go every four uh the uh the the market as you can in the other game um haven't tried I wanted to but I haven't tried like a super heavy building strategy it kind of feels hard like in greater than Trail I remember like the expansion to Great Western Trail race to the north made the building strategy more viable yeah uh but I I haven't gone like for a super heavy building strategy because it's kind of the hardest thing to do yeah I tried and I think that I got did it okay but and it it always ends up with me thinking oh I if I continue doing just this I have to deliver to the very bad
places all of the so I have to do something else in addition to that so it's hard to focus mainly on that I think one thing that is kind of weird with this game yeah is that this game is the most complex great person thrill game I I think I feel yeah it has like because it has so many like it has and now it has the the ship has two values you have the whole board for the the movement yes you have two different markets you have this track you have like there's many I remember teaching Great Western Trail when I first got it was hard because there's so many Concepts and here you add like four final New Concepts on top of that so it has the most stuff to teach but still it feels kind of like the easiest one to to get stuff like they're less tight than the less the punishing one of them so it's kind of like it's kind of a weird thing because it's more complex but easier for me do you agree I agree but in the the core concept it's still the familiar Great Western Trail the DNA is is printed on on the game and so it feels like even though it has these tweaks and twists it feels very familiar to me so let's just I'm going to ask you a question now again which is do you feel like this for this country do you feel like it has enough changes yes you absolutely feel that you probably understood because this has I felt that with Argentina as well but this has more changes now I absolutely
agree so wait you can and who is it for yeah I feel like this is a medium heavy game as with both Argentina and the original game appeals to me and I feel like if you like recent Great Western Trail and you want more like that especially if you don't mind that it being a little little lip punishing than the original game I think this is something to check out I think that we have a space for many similar games in our collection for example Bros Birmingham and Lancashire and age of innovation and Gana project for example I feel like these are different enough to have both a place in the collection if you really enjoy three of them yeah these three have yeah they have something to different to bring to the table if you are into this stuff yeah if you want to own like one I'm not going to answer that because it's been a while since we played both characters in real and Argentina yes but if you want to own one it really I feel like if you want the tight core experience it's probably going to be great to some train if you want like that with just a little bit more it's going to be Argentina if you want a little bit less tight but add a little bit more stuff going on it's this one so it's that's gonna be like more that is so it's very much a personal preference it was it was really hard if I was being put on a spot now and only could keep one I don't think I could do
it no because I had to play the others first and two because maybe you should do like a a top tree a great western trailer and I would really like to play the original with the north uh expansions yeah because I can't quite remember what that was about we tried talking a bit about what we thought in the video as well but now it's the main segment for that and one thing we have forgotten to do okay for a while is is it fun yes we used to do that like is it fun and final thoughts so uh you want to go over before that there's something you can do for us before we give you the final thoughts and that is a very big thing it's basically uh very simple for you and big for us giving us a witch report yes and we we get victory points when you click that subscribe button down there you can also click the Bell button to get notification because every time we post a new video okay I'm just gonna wait here until you do it are you done did you click the Subscribe button oh okay yeah I think they did it fun first off is it fun yeah it is very fun I think that also Great Western Trail and Great Western Trail Argentina is really fun this is also very refined I like all the changes especially as you said the uh free action cards that I really like to call them they are super like I like games that give you positive reinforcement and it feels like okay I'm playing this I'm getting this I play that I I get this and it feels more like that in this game because in the original especially and
Argentina to some extent as well you feel like every time you go up this one-way Street like all the money is going out of your pockets and you pass these locations that you think oh I wish I could go there but I don't have time or I wish I could have more awesome cows in my hand and do better stuff and feel so frustrating but I like that as well but this feels more like more things coming in and going out um yeah I really enjoy it have a lot of fun with it and it is a very very very great game I think I'm going to give this a nine it's a great western Great Western Trail game um greater Central is a fantastic game a great essential Argentina is a fantastic game greater central New Zealand is a fantastic game there is so much to like here and and as you said they're giving kind of like different feelings I also enjoy that like positive thing oh I got these two Money Two money moving on the track doing this doing that boom boom boom I like that I also like the I only have to have money yeah I like that too I don't know I need eight of them there and 10 of them there that's more money and I have to pay you to move there and all of that I love that as well and now we have three Great Western Trail games giving you three different feelings and three different ways of playing and the core system of great design Trail is so good that it it really is okay for me in our
like the size of collection we have to have all three of them to have uh probably sometime I want to change out our original greatest and trail with a second edition uh because expansion is already out for the expense the circulation as well and because they're great games I like them I'm going to give it a nine as well and that's it yeah that's the end of the video and there is many videos to come these coming weeks and if you are going to spiel you can meet us there will be at the chili fox games Booth from 14 to 18 Friday a porta games will 10 to 14 on Saturday that's the easiest way to meet us and if you wanna if you see us in the Halls give us the is the secret sign you can find that out in the game on amount video that came out yesterday and that's it that's the end of the video yes thank you so much for watching I'm Johannes and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and bye bye