Skip to main content
Loading video...

Merchants & Marauders - Gameplay & Discussion

Transcript 42:06

hello everyone I'm Matt Evans and welcome to board game Replay in this series we try to capture the experience of playing a board game by sitting down for a postgame discussion talking about various elements of that game and then during our discussion we're going to be cutting back to replay clips of moments that we found fun or exciting now today we're going to be playing merchants and Marauders designed by Christian markuson and Casper aard and published by zman games and before we get into this game as usual I'd like to offer a brief rules overview uh just for those who aren't familiar with this game and to give you a little bit more context for our discussion we're definitely not going to be covering everything but just give you the basics of what's going on here but that said if you're already familiar with this game and you don't need any of that I'm going to put a link up here as well as one in the description of this video you can click that skip right by it okay so in merchant and Marauders players are going to be taking on the role of captains in the Caribbean during the Golden Age of piracy they're going to be hoping to gain 10 Glory points uh by completing various Deeds here throughout the throughout the Caribbean anything from picking up and delivering Goods um to missions and rumors that they they might happen to encounter upgrading their ship or even destroying their enemies in combat now that last one is where this game gets interesting as you can see the title is obviously merchants and Marauders and most of what I just mentioned there is Merchant type stuff well again that's where this game gets interesting because everyone essentially starts the game uh with a clean slate they all start as Merchants they're all good guys and basically throughout their Adventures at any time one of the players may decide they want to switch and become a pirate and they do that in a couple of different ways the first of which is a merchant raid they might decide that that merch ship they're sharing a space with looks great

and choose to raid that ship for goods and gold they can also as I mentioned attack other ships and ship to ship combat you can attack other Merchant players at the table or you can attack the neutral NPC naval ships that are cruising around and anytime you perform any of these actions you're going to immediately become a pirate because you're going to gain a bounty all the ships in this game have a captain associate with it obviously and each of those captains belongs to a particular nationality so whenever you choose to attack one of those ships you're going to gain a a bounty with the country associated with that captain now as I mentioned once you gain this bounty that is what officially makes you a pirate you now become a target for not only the country that you upset but all of the other NPC naval ships on the board basically not only did you anger Spain but all these other guys see there's a bounty that Spain's willing to pay for your head so they're going to come after you as well the NPC ships as well as all the other players any of the other Merchant players they can come after you to try to collect on that Bounty as well and these bounties compound the more time you attack Spanish ships or or any ships for that matter the more your bounties rise with that with each of those countries and making you more valuable to the other players so you become a pretty big Target playing a playing a pirate it's a heavy risk situation but the rewards can be great now that doesn't mean playing strictly as a merchant is a cakewalk either it's also very challenging to play as a merchant because you're going to be going around doing some of those things I mentioned trying to be making good trades but there's going to be events coming up in the in the event deck here like crazy weather that comes up there there's actually even pirate NPC ships that are going to spawn and they're

going to be chasing after you trying to steal your goods aboard and obviously any of the other human players playing as pirates they're going to be coming after you as well looking for that juicy ship filled with goods and gold now that basically covers sort of an overview of what you're going to be doing in the game but I definitely want to cover a few of the mechanical things as well okay so at the start of the game players are going to be given a captain card here which has their various skills down here with different numbers as well as a unique special ability here and these numbers at the bottom of the card this just represents how good they are at that particular skill uh so here this first one is seamanship and he's got a three that means he rolls three dice whenever he performs a seamanship check and these dice are all the Pips go from 1 to four and then the five and six baces have this skull and cross bones here and that represents success so if you're doing a seamanship check this guy would roll three dice hoping for at least one of those skull and crossbones to come up uh some skill checks in the game reward you for having additional successes but the vast majority are just looking for that one symbol next you're going to choose a ship for your captain and you can either choose the highly maneuverable Sloop or the less maneuverable flute but holds quite a bit more cargo you can adjust the stats here this board here this what these little cubes are they represent the various stats for the ship and throughout the course of the game you're going to use this to either track upgrades that you get for the different areas of your ship or any damage that you take is going to be shown in that track as well speaking of upgrades these are where they would all go there's various different things that you can do to make your ship stronger have better uh defenses hold more cargo better cannons that sort of thing you can also buy these onot abilities like

chain shot grape shot or grappling hooks that basically have a really powerful ability but you can only trigger it once and then the token goes away now on a player's turn they're given three actions and those actions are typically move Scout or Port A Move action is pretty simple a single move action gets you to move to one adjacent c-space or into a port inside of a c-space and you can use these move actions however you like you can move two c spaces and into a port but each space that you move cost you one of your actions the next action is Scout now I mentioned Merchant raids earlier and attacking other players that's basically how you do that you basically if I'm sharing a space with one of these Merchant tokens here or another player or NPC ship I can roll my dice for my scouting check on my Captain's card if I'm successful I can then choose to attack those ships uh the third action is the big one and that's where a lot of the action in the game happens is in the port so if I move my ship into a port if I already have my ship there and I take a port action I now unlock like a dozen other things that you can do inside of a ports where a lot of the core of the game happens you know anything that you could do in a c Port that's what you can do in this game buying and selling Goods recruiting crew mates selling ship parts upgrading your ship that sort of thing now I mentioned the way to win this game is by acquiring 10 Glory points and there's a lot of different ways to do that the first of which is by selling Goods that are in demand all these little icons on these different spaces here represent Goods that are currently in demand at those ports so if a player sails to that Port takes the port action and then sells three or more of the good that's in demand they're going to get a glory Point as well as a substantial amount of gold in order to sell Goods though you have to buy Goods so

obviously one of the other Port actions you take is buying goods and you can see your good cards look like this you can buy any number of them that you want as long as you've got the space for it on your ship another way to gain Glory points is by completing missions or rumors while you're in a port you can claim a mission so down here if I was docked in this port I could claim this Mission and then attempt to complete it it's generally a pretty involved thing it requires a fair amount of time but the rewards are pretty substantial in addition to the glory Point you'll probably get a bunch of gold or maybe even a new ship or or something great you get a lot of good stuff from it you can also while you're in a port attempt to acquire one of these this is a rumor card you can roll a skill check against your Captain's skill if you're successful you'll gain one of these rumors and you try to complete it as well it's kind of just a lighter version of a mission and uh but yeah the rewards aren't quite as good but you'll still always gain a glory point for it another way to get a glory point is to acquire a gallion or a frig and you can do that by visiting the shipyard inside inside of a port and buying a bigger ship so you've got these gallions and frigs which are just much larger much better versions of your starter ships there's actually a secret way to gain Glory points as well and that is through the stash action if you're inside your home Port you can stash gold inside your little Treasure Chest here and every 10 gold that you stash not only does it keep it safe from other Pirates but every 10 gold you stash is worth one Glory point and you can gain up to five Glory points from doing this and the cool part is you don't even have to tell anybody you're doing it you can get all the way up to five Glory points in the regular game while you've got 50 gold stashed and then say hey I've got 50 gold in here I'm going to win next turn so I

mentioned Merchant raids earlier and this is another way to gain Glory points in this game so I've set one up here in front of us basically when you start a merchant raid you're going to draw three cargo cards from the top of the deck and you're not going to pay attention to the goods necessarily you're just really looking at these symbols at the bottom right at first and in order to succeed a merchant raid you can't have any damage take one any of these stats off a track basically if anything falls off here from taking too much damage you're going to fit fail the merchant raid these symbols at the bottom right here represent what parts of your ship are going to be damaged so here I'm taking a damage to crew a damage to Cargo and this symbol over here is an escape symbol so that's not going to deal any damage but if there are more Escape symbols than my maneuverability then the merchant ship is just going to escape and I fail as well so here taking a crew damage I can afford and A Cargo damage I can afford so I'm going to succeed this Merchant raid right now however I'm only going to gain eight gold because you add up the value of these numbers at the bottom in order to get a glory point from a merchant raid you have to gain at least 12 gold so when you start a merchant raid after you reveal the cards you're going to roll your seamanship dice hoping for as many successes as possible if you are successful you can use these to swap out these cards you can discard this card if you don't like it's going to hit you in the wrong spot and blow up your that part of your ship uh or you can draw additional cards to add to this and maybe hope to increase your value or you can just discard and draw as one single action just replace a card so this is all about pressing your luck here so I've got two successes I'm going to use it to draw an additional card boom all right this is only worth two more so I'm only at 10 gold right now

and I'm going to have to take a damage to masts now I'm going to push my luck I'm going to go for one more time and I'm going to draw an additional card and look at that I've got another four here that puts me up to 14 total gold and this is just another Escape symbol no more damage so this ship isn't going to get away and I'm only going to sustain let's see masts crew and cargo so cargo masts and crew none of these were damage enough to knock them off the track but I am hurting but now I'm going to gain 14 gold and a glory point now the last and probably most exciting way to gain Glory points in this game is through Naval Combat Naval Combat takes place over uh just a number of rounds where players are choosing an action the action can either be to fire your cannons attempt to board or flee then players are going to take they're going to choose that action then they're going to roll their dice for their seamanship check whichever Captain has more success is is going to succeed with their action so if you chose to fire your cannons and you succeed you have more successes than the other player you're going to fire all the Cannons on your ship whenever you fire your cannons you're going to roll a die and whatever the pit value shows that's what section of the ship uh your opponent ship is going to become damaged if you roll the success symbol your opponent gets to choose where the damage goes now as you start damaging player ships and these cubes move down these tracks whenever they get off of a track they get more and more setbacks obviously from from like your cannons taking hits means you have less cannons to fire now makes it harder and harder but also if you ever take damage to a spot that has already sustained damage like let's say your cannons were already gone and you take another hit to cannons that goes directly to your hole now and

if your hole is ever destroyed your ship blows up and you sink the other player wins one of the other things that you can do as I mentioned you can also try to board if you're successful in a boarding attempt you no longer roll your seamanship dice you're basically on the other player ship you have boarded their ship and now you're having crew combat crew combat basically just means that you're now going to be rolling your lead leadership dice whatever your your sword symbol is here and trying to gain successes for every success you roll with your leadership dice this happens simultaneously both players are rolling it for every success you roll you kill a crew member from the other member ship but you can never kill more crew members than crew that you have yourself so if you only have one crew and you roll two successes it doesn't matter you'd still only kill one of this guy's crew and this just continues you basically keep rolling your leadership dice picking off your crew mates until there's no crew left on one of the ships that player would then win the crew combat and have the opportunity to not only not only win the the combat but he can also loot anything on the ship cargo gold and you can also steal the ship as well now there are quite a few more rules here that I didn't cover this is a really big game but I think that should give you a pretty broad overview of how this game works and the basic mechanical things going on but even us today I've played this game many many times and I still use these great two-sided guides this is from the esoteric order of games if you're going to pick this game up you're going to play this at some point I highly recommend going to their site I'm going to put a link to them in the description of this video they have excellent excellent guides that basically condense a giant rule book into essentially a little two-sided

piece like this and it actually covers the vast majority of the rules so it's great for little quick lookups and clarifications for things like that like things like Port actions there's so many different things you can do having a quick guide to justo have them all right there it's excellent so I think that covers it for what I want to tell you about the rules for this one without further Ado let's get to the game e and then second AC move out and then oh I moved here leadership roll please fail come on roll like I do yes a no I think that's game I think that's game I have 10 victory points team a all right well we'll see if we can maybe catch up to you maybe maybe maybe you still have you have one turn we all have one turn left too all right Brian I end a round so let's finish that up I need to discard one of these here next round new event violent storm players currently at C

have one less action no Brian and Isaac one less action any four random hits at at the end if not God that's rough Brian anything to do I'll just Port all right well then the action no I don't care yeah if if he can't get to 10 doesn't matter draw rumor see what happens no my Rumor was was Port action here draw a new one maybe you get do something I same on I could have done I should have done shot right just roll your dice what's your leadership three whatever your chest is the chest icon okay so you never know it could be go to San Juan and get what is it is it it's go to San Juan it's do Port action at San one you already in the exact same thing as this but you can't do it though you're already in the port he's do he is Cur yeah but it say say take a port action you you just got that card it doesn't it doesn't work oh so it's even better cuz like your next turn you just sit still and P the biggest slap in the face I'll go I'm going to move up here I'm going to move out up and Scout oh yeah if you get 12 from a raid you can still get points yeah I know I know I'm saying I'm going for the tiebreaker with you but it's not going to put me up enough over top yeah and it says I'm going to do Spanish cuz that's the plus three if I do oh really yeah so this what this is what I was kind of counting on but let's see you have 50 gold Bank we'll see I don't know yet huh ow yeah

better roll some successes oh you got grape shot God freaking grape shot at least I'm going to trade that in you just got to draw one it's only hope even if I draw five it's not going to do it 8 9 10 doesn't matter no plus three yeah oh yeah you're right drawing one cannons cannons but it blows it up I lose it wait I lose it I drew I drew a canons I got nothing I can do I think you can still win without cannons no no as soon as something goes off the track you L yeah it was close it was close even then like that would have been hilarious so not so like dude just draw same one oh I can't do it I just draw can't do it dude that came down to the that was so close cuz like yeah I mean I have 50 gold did you have 52 bro yeah yeah that was 50 goals so you guys so yeah if either of you got one viory point it would have been a tie it would have been a tie and you'd win because you are just slightly further up the track than us so that was that was really really close there gone do want to uh well I I didn't think you get a little closer did you have some stuff to sell setting his own if I could take all three of my turns i' love to cuz he got two actions he started and see hey did you start and see this turn Jeremy no you didn't you were in the P did you stash anything Isaac uh so I'm so sorry that was a bummer no I'm like it was super close I don't think I after three times playing this game I still don't understand it too many freaking rules for me to understand uh I have no I have

no grasp on the board uh it's a lot it's a lot of game dude this is not my luck to well here's the thing right like so I think that we've played this what three times now four times now with you guys um I I think I mean luck is definitely a factor that's one of the things like this is a super big game with a ton of rules it's got like that that Euro style like pick up and deliver like economic like you're supposed to like you know understand the value of goods like selling goods and demand like there's all those things but there's a lot of dice rolling it's a lot of presser luck stuff like there's a lot of hey I'm going to take this rumor and sail four spots over here and chance it if you fail it's like oh yeah it's heartbreaking or like you go to do a merchant raid and you get crushed you know like it's said those he was on his way just to get to hear like two storms slowing down that's wasting one or two turns at least it could be you one or two more turns probably would have tied or won I think for the for this case like with the the outlier of Isaac I mean Isaac got really hampered on luck like he had some bad luck but I mean the fact that we're all kind of say I I don't know if that's necessarily true I don't I don't think it had I had I have a hard time understanding the goal uh in situations the thing I found interesting is like we were watching you for that game going God Jeremy just keeps getting so lucky he keeps getting so lucky and like yeah some of the stuff you were having was lucky but I wouldn't say either one of us was particular L really lucky with anything and we almost won so like there's I think there's enough elements of stuff going around that that and like there's a lot of player interaction nobody nobody did anything to stop me we didn't really go after you

and we didn't like I was kind of ribbing these guys like guys go for it go for it but like they're merchants and they have a whole system down so like why would they do that you know what I mean like would tier one ship too you had a tier one ship with some good upgrades but yeah still you weren't really going to stand much of a chance against a frig with four Glory cards got the yeah I had the with an extra Cannon yeah was rough an extra Cannon and swivel guns yeah I was pretty I was pretty well off oh man there was only uh only one pirate too yeah it was just me nobody else went for it I was I originally planned to go pirate cuz like the last few games I played pirate and it was fun and it seemed a little bit more difficult and like a little more chance so I wanted to do it again but I didn't draw any good captains for it yeah and we actually house roll too when we when we pull the captains at the beginning we pull three like just cuz it seems to be normally you're supposed to just a b more of a it's like one or two or something I think the rules actually just say secretly draw a captain secretly pick your ship and then place your stuff secretly we just like draw three captains and pick one that you think looks fun you know that's we should explain the the beginning ships I I mean depending on what you go with like you can pick pirate like pirate or Merchant is is irrelevant at the beginning of the game and basically you just choose a character that you might think will be good one way or another and then you choose a starting ship and the starting ship kind of a little bit of shoehorns you into what kind of style of play high combat value then it's like cuz there's no other way to really boost your dice roll your seamanship other than maneuverability yeah exactly I mean the the the merchant if you're going to be Merchant you want to ship with cargo cuz you be picking up and delivering the basic the cheapest easiest ship that you

start with is the flute and has four cargo is crazy and I mean the pirate ship is a Sloop it's crap on all of its stats it's really really low cargo really really low people and then it has what is it like yeah it's one on everything except maneuverability which helps you with Merchant raids and I was getting smashed by Merchant raids I I raided I think four times this game and my four Merchant raids I think I had one or two of them that I actually got a victory point from so I was getting pounded I was get a lot of money well you also failed some too I failed one I succeeded two and I think I got a victory point from one of them or something like that but yeah I will move out of port and then over here I'm going Scout what yes one success so three cards French or English ew not I want a port here so I'm definitely not taking the English Bounty I'm taking French Bounty okay the two ships that are on the bo are you attacking yeah I'm going to go ahead and attack give me that little circle token there oh sorry oh wa Lord you got to be like that uh three cards right for this so you have a bounty of both ships that are on the board right now yes I do oh cool I drew two of the stupid things again what is it crew and crew I could survive that though at least really really hopefully not fail just laughing at me it's like you're attacking all the ships with water balloons both only cost me one each oh right um so two successes so you one at time damn it what's that

mass no that's fine M good come on with these stupid cards oh but they're all different it's fine survived yeah you got six I got wait so hole 10 11 Mast crew and no no cannons awesome and then one Escape I have drained the deck of those cards you still only got 11 so I got all right somebody come over here and attack 10 11 oh my God whatever 11 Golds 11 Gold take if he would got 12 he would have got the victory point which I will definitely take 11 Gold and I will I get one good to bring with me I'll grab this guy it's like you get matter the more cards you draw and the more you get hit why does this keep happening you keep I think you needed more gear like the rate in the beginning was like what turn one or turn two you attacked yeah you had some really unlucky rolls but if you would just had like if you sailed around and picked up just a couple pieces of gear like that I think the hammock that's been their all game I think one that's you know that's that's that's a great point you make about this game there's it's so so much risk reward like you can take your time slowly cruise around each Port not risking anything hey you know I'm going to wait in the c space for another turn I'm going to like go make sure I can get this gear you can take your time and play it as slow as you want and maybe that'll pay off but if you play you can play I mean that's a safest bet you'll get lots of money you'll be safe you you'll put your gold in the stash so nobody can steal it from you meanwhile a pirate character can be risking it and going for it and they can triple your money in 2 seconds you know what I mean like a pirate character can just or they can lose raids three times or they can lose yeah and then you can get really hampered but like yeah you can play it or like well for pirates at

the beginning of the game I always like to go into a port first buy some of the the the special weapon stuff and then use those for the free actions for when you roll um for redistributing these cards just because you know the other thing like you said as a pirate so if you started your turn you you did a scout on your Zone and you won you can still go into port and do the and sell the goods all in one turn yeah that's exactly what I did my last where as a merchant you start the game you go into Port do a port action buy it now you have to go out sell it somewhere else or I mean you could stay there and sell it po it's the quickest you can do it is two turns with a pirate quickest you can do is sell it in one turn plus you get the gold from winning the raid yep and you get the goods that come up from the raid you get those goods saying you get the gold from winning the raid and then the goods you kept you can go and sell those too basically an early game so an early game pirate with a couple of ship upgrades is very strong pirate can be quicker but it's riskier Merchant is usually slower but usually less risk but you depends though I mean if you've got if you got the board swarming with pirates or like a bunch of ships go to war like now you still have to play it very tactically as a merchant too because you're like uh I'm not going to go near those ships over there that that guy's going to ruin me yeah if a pate came up or like you said if there was a war a man of war versus level one ship it's that's no hope I got away from one his first time playing he had man he was a Sloop versus a man War wasn't it a FR no it was a FR this game you had an insane Escape like like early game like that that little pirate ship attacked you you were only had one Scout he's like it's fine I'll he's not going to get me so I'm going to get out and then move

and he Scouts me right y uh y he's going to try to scout I'm going to do it I'm going to get you I'm going get you boy don't do it please right neck R please don't he got you he got you amazing amazing amazing you're dead all right no big deal uh do you want to do combat for the pirate ship then this is really not good for me it's a Sloop you're fine no it's oh it is a Sloop okay you're right so he's 222 2 222 one but he's got maneuverability exceeding two of yours so he rolls an extra die so he rolls four dice against Isaac's 3 that's not terrible so first thing you guys do you're going to get into combat with each other you go boom first one is shoo you have to shoot got to shoot you're going to roll your seamanship and you're going to blast each other with cannons and he rolls an extra one because you are underneath you have you have less Y what do you got that's cocked roll that one roll that one no successes lucky Isaac oh you shoot all one of your can you shoot all of your Cannons all one of them so roll a die now and just roll one die your cannons right this is your Canon you've succeeded in firing so now you see where it lands shoot all of your Cannons all one so it lands on three o crew nice boom you kill the crew all right oh God this is so bad for so now you decide now you decide right now he initiated the attack so Jeremy has to say I'm fleing you can't fle the only way you can flee is if you've lost all the crew and something else if you're playing in if you have no canids you can't you can't stick around um so you have to choose what you're going to do if you're going to stay in fight or you're going to run I'm going to um what do you got

for stats over there brother you have crap crew so does he now pretty you can take a couple of hits man if you sck doesn't go crew or canw or cannons though I'm same with him same with him though it's a really weak ship that's true uh fleeing is almost impossible because you have to have hope they roll no dice which I just did no chance that again so you're going to shoot you want to shoot him you have a better chance shoot yeah I would do that oh man one success two success so but they both shoot you're going to fire all your cannons one and he's going to going to shoot one so you you roll one Cannon he rolls one Canon happens at the same time boom uh you get to choose where that goes and then Isaac you take a hit to four which is your or cannons oh no that's not good is it's time to flee or you can board I guess so I get to pick where this goes I pick oh all right that's the one that makes most sense so now your only option is to board or flee Isaac so the only problem with boarding right is if you board and you fail you lose all that gold I so don't want Isaac to lose this right now I want him to win this if you you have plenty of yeah you have a lot of you you can take a lot of hits you only has one Cannon I would just keep trying to flee since you lost your cannons before when you had cannons I would say keep shooting but now you lost your cans so what am I what am I rolling for fleing you just same thing but you say flee and you have you have I don't even know if you roll for it but yeah I don't think there is it's just Escape if your opponent made no successes okay so jery roll so he chose to flee no please

yes yes no way yes oh my God I'm so relieved for you like look at this pile of money you there you are so freaking lucky dude like the odds of you getting scouted were bad yeah whatever and I scouted you successfully and then I miss on four dice oh that's so good for me yes it is oh my God that was a it was uh I needed to be on that on that I needed to take Port there that I mean you were risky like the guys were on one die you have a 30% chance 33% chance to have him Scout you he happens to scout you and then he just kept like I was like I don't you had like what 40 gold on board with you right there and that guy was going to take all of it and it wasn't even a player it was an NPC too which made it even more like of an insult you couldn't even go get that player and get it back from them I thought that getting a new ship was going to turn over New Leaf cuz my beginning in my game was really really slow so I needed to take some risk I wish I wish Looking Back Now I had taken uh the opportunity to attack you when you were down M that may have been that may have been good I mean I didn't have a lot of gold on board but it might it might have well it might have slowed you down um that wouldn't necessarily helped Jeremy winning but yeah that was actually a good point Jeremy sort of we had we had that whole moment where we talked about it yeah if I attack you do I get the Bounty for the choose country get not become a pirate if you beat me you don't right no no no absolutely you're Vanishing

vanquishing if you defeat me you'll get five gold from a country of your Choice that's a good idea you don't get you don't get both bounties but thanks for destroying the pirate now we're coming after you true but if he lose he has four got maneuverability I literally will be rolling five and I shoot first what's your SE ship uh which one is that the wheel the wheel you'd have to board me crew combat me and then take my gold that way cuz otherwise you only get he'll get five gold for killing me and if you crew combat me and take my ship you get to keep the gold right if you destroy my ship you get but I only have one crew so that would here so it's going to be like a one of these like it's going to be stupid war is not huge right now you're you're probably in lead with all that money you just got right there anyway so you can play it safe and stay in lead or risk it get further in the lead or get pre- screwed cuz you'd lose all that yeah you that's that could be bad I mean that's I don't want you to attack me either cuz I don't like my odds I I would personally save up and try to get your next ship that's that's good one what's your go right now secondary ship is really good are those all ones yeah that's five so you have 22 right now 22 22 right now if you come and buy it here it only cost you 25 what if you come here it only cost you 25 to go to the next ship cuz it costs 30 you sell your ship for five yeah so you're three gold away oh yeah that's true and I could I can do cargo again right here right yep

do six more or you get uh it's not it's not French yeah I'll do that one two four man I'm all four keep the I wanted to talk it through that because I forget I forget the dice rolls I don't care if smash I know I'm fine he will likely succeed the attack so he's going to fire his one Canon guaranteed you have to R you have to roll success on your three dice otherwise you might get sunk too if you lose your crew or your cannons you're just sit and dck you can't do anything right beginning I was thinking I'm like man Jeremy's going to keep running away I'm like guys we got to go after Jeremy we got to attack him but like there's there's so much going on like there's this is just it's such an insanely huge game with all these different things happening that there's random events coming from the event deck you never know it's going to come there's random Glory cards random loot draws like there's it's it's the best like it's just so much craziness the game is always you can't solve it at all like it's not one of those games where you can be like well I'm always the best at this like it's always like an adventure because there's so many things going on that you can't just Master this game be there no sure way to success it's that's I would I would put this in the straty yeah you got straty go but there's so many things that from one to you got to be on your feet you like like Isaac had a lot of money and when you got the ship maybe at that point you could have considered switching to the frig and started going pirate instead of just swap in the middle cuz you got a quick if you got that frig real early you could have taken me and Brian out m i mean it's all easy to say now say now it always is yeah I think you're right I

I mean I probably should have seen um that coming and just gone gone pirate it takes it takes a lot I mean i' I've played this more than anyone here because I played this years ago and I played a lot and that was just playing from that I'm more comfortable going that way because even then like you you've never really done a merchant raate I mean you might have played a couple of them last time I did not being not being 100% familiar with the rules you're less likely to take that strategy you know what I mean like I know the rules fairly well for this and I'm still I mean literally like look at next to me here I'm still sitting on a pile of rules yeah right CU there's so many little rules for this game yeah that I know them well and I'm like I'm comfortable going like you know what I'm a good guy right now I'm going to switch to a pirate immediately because like I might see that being opportunity take it I like I might be playing um a merchant for most of the game and then I say o man you know I've got a ship right now that can take some extra hits I've got a couple of Specialists that have really good abilities for merchant raid screw it I'm going Merchant raid and I can get two three victory points from a quick Merchant raid you know like and that's you might not see that if you're you know when you're newer to the game it takes you know this is a slower like Sunday afternoon type of game that you have to sit down with the rule book laid out you know what I mean so have an expert there to tell you yeah right right exactly and have somebody looking up even best thing ever right I mean but we were always looking up uh rules at least once a round if not more yeah once per round oh yeah there's a

little rule just to clarify we're doing something right I mean eight things you can do in a port there's a a specific order I mean the first time in this game for the first time ever I retired a pirate one more thing I was again I was comfortable doing it because I had played enough to go uh I kind of see an opportunity to retire right here at this I'm going to do you had four threat and three threat two different yeah exactly I mean I first of all I I went up toe-to-toe with a Mana War to get a mission done and it didn't work out as I almost got s dude this is even better than I thought I just have to get in combat with a naval have to succeed aboard one I I have to I just literally have to do one round of crew combat survive and I can say okay I'm gone and then I can succeed the mission survive is still going to be hard if you attack a man it's it's one round though that's the funny thing like I just need to be alive for one round of crew combat let's do this ready man of war I got you all right we got his stats on the board yep it's three cargo four yeah all right what do you get if you kill them can board a ship if you want that's not good holy CRA oh wow a five dice no successes for instigating Wars with man War you started it oh I like all those I like all those chees Choose Your Own Adventure and one to masts you only have a frig one mask right away unless you're blocking damage or something um and I get to ches the rest of them go yep why would you do this that's brutal to be fair he had five dice versus three

um cancel that hit that you are doing to my masts and then I'm going to roll a die and I hit you and roll that and now you take a damage on four so what is it my loose can your Loose Cannon so you take four whatever your four spot is or that guy takes so all right I'm going to um four wherever you want four hits so I will take one to masts um don't care about cargo boom boom fine that was so two to hits one to MK you can hold one you have one card left you oh yeah throw it in hole Yeah hole is probably well Mast is fun I just can't run I'm fine by that you have to sink them if you get if you lose your mask you have to sink them you can't Bard I guess so that's your think are you boarding or are you I'm totally boarding okay so boarding and he's shooting thank you one shot good Suck It come on hole oh you can't do hole do H car you choose I got to choose um this point can at this point I don't care about canons all right I'm boarding your stup sh uh his is two what your your sword is only one as soon as I as soon as I board I'm going to roll two dice is it on you yeah it is on both y we nice that's a dead crew mate one crew dead five crew absolutely ridiculous absolutely ridiculous wait is but we roll our leadership you you attack the crew that on the ship you're boarding or is it attack crew that's trying to board either way doesn't matter a little s can so as you get close they like ready your leadership is so

low boom doesn't matter wow you kill one of mine I've survived this one I'm going to take Lily off the ship and I'm going to get I I played that my my my shot on the man war was a mistake because I had doing the math in my head I was like looking down at all my swivel guns for killing crew I'm like dude I got this like this is going to be so easy but you only had the FR and I and I had I had the frig and I'm thinking like I had something to cancel a hit I had some swivel guns to shoot some crew I had five I was going to be rolling five dice to his three for his seamanship because of the bonus maneuverability I'm like I've got a really good shot at this first turn all five cannons ripped in my like miss you had five dice that missed oh I was so screwed and I hit with one I I didn't hit you with any Dice and then you just blasted shots it was four that you had to pick too that was the one thing that I forgot I was like this guy can't get me I'm going to board him get my mission done I'm going to walk away from this and then if you fail five I'm like whoops I forgot that he has five cannons aboard oh my God that was so at least I got the choose where most of the hits went and I mean after that battle I'm sitting there sweating going uh okay I'm I'm probably going to lose now cuz my ship was destroyed it was going to cost me so much to fix it and then I'm sitting here staring at this pile of 40 gold I'm like and I'm like sitting right next I was right here and I'm like oh my God I can go there and stash I'm doing that and I thinking like if I retire my guy I'm going to spawn a couple turns later I'm going to I was like I think it was like four victory points at that point so I'm like I can stash almost 5050 gold be really close to Victory start with a fresh pirate do one or two Merchant raids and I can win and I was just sort

of rushing for that as fast as I could but that's that's something I've never considered in this game before until we had played the last few times and kind of talked about they're like what we were talking about dying like when we were trying to explain the game I think to you we were saying don't worry about dying it's not that bad especially if you have the starter ship so you have if you have the big ship you lose your ship that's kind of a loss but if you still have the Sloop or the uh the star other ship um then yeah there really how much do you sell the second ship for 10 the Elder ship sell for 10 oh the big ship sell for 10 small for five for yeah so that like knowing I mean the first time we were we were setting up with these guys we were like one of the things is like be aggressive if you want to take the risks because like worst case scenario if you die you start with a new captain and you get 10 gold for nothing which is sometimes better than your current position on the board but if you've already stashed a bunch of gold it's awesome like yeah like you could go through a bunch of money in a bank start as a new guy in my hometown with all that stash available to me and a clean slate yeah you could go get like two or three victory points by spending all your gold and then or Glory points and then die and respawn and you still have the glory points and you've reset I actually want to mention to you guys um I was looking at the uh where is it there was a frequently Asked question there was like an advanced game rule that you can play uh what is it called the Cutthroat variant designed for groups seeking more frequent player versus player battles it should not be regarded as a fixed but more of an attempt to accommodate the expectations and wishes of some groups um and attempt to make sure everyone gets the Pirate game they deserve so there's two parts this off turn scouting a player May Scout for the active player immediately

after they move on his C Zone including moving from Port out to sea so basically you have the attempt I mean NPC essentially you work like an NPC and then there's um that's cool there's some circumstantial rules and then um the gallion maneuverability goes down to one wow um so just some interesting little some changes you can make if you really want to make the game Cutthroat those are both good May yeah I know right I wouldn't mind that that's that sounds like fun yeah and um also we have the expansion for this the Seas of Glory expansion which dear God that box is chalk full we have to be able to play this game without looking at the ru like once before we even yeah and the the expansion is like modular there's like 50 oh my God I think there's like almost I say 13 modules that you can expand on yeah I mean I I'm just excited that the board expands and then there's more loot types you can take long enough get anywhere anyways and I I mean I don't know how much more complexity it adds to the game but I am a huge fan of modular expansions because like you just play with what you want to play and try them out little by little true yeah add more variants like there's another boat type so you can have different stats you can more more yeah give you another option for It's like a middle of the road boat between like these like it's kind of like somewhere in the middle and you can play that I guess however you wanted depending on your upgrades yeah that's cool all right I think that wraps this one up we've talked certainly enough about this game um one of definitely one of my favorites for sure um yeah and apology it's been a little while since we put out another video it's been a crazy sort of schedule I haven't really said this I talked about it beforehand but my wife just had a baby I guess we had a baby as a family second baby and about 6 weeks ago so

that's been most of your time so I spent a lot of my time uh we're I'm still trying to get down and record with these guys as much as we can they're awesome to come over on a week night until 10:45 dear God uh so yeah that's really what a lot of the a lot of the delay has been um we're going to get more of this stuff in I'm I'm doing some solo videos and stuff that I've been trying to record sort of in my my free time here and there but uh we're still definitely keeping the series running there just been a bit of a pause in this one for the whole childbirth thing so anyway take up a lot of time yeah it definitely definitely cuts into the schedule just a little bit so uh anyway well thanks for sticking with us if you have been we appreciate it and thanks for watching as always hey thanks guys take it easy thank you you know that was bothering me right you know I mean it's like we just finish L up each other sentences sentences we don't finish each other sentences why does that joke never get old it's so perfect I answer my own question it's true

Progress saved