Skip to main content
Loading video...

SETI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence - Discussion

Transcript 27:47

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And Brad and I are doing a discussion over SETI, the search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Quite a mouthful, so let's just say SETI. And this ended up being a game that I was not even going to check out. Mainly because like funny enough with our review over Galactic Cruise, it was the same situation. It was a heavy euro that I mean I was just like, you know, I don't really have any interest in those. And I don't know really what compelled me to get it. Well, I think you bought it and then I was like, uh, sure, just for content, let me give it a shot. And I love this game. Yeah, a lot of people talked about big time. That's what got me to buy it. Yeah, exactly.

Like I remember a lot you like I remember seeing a lot of people raving about it. It's doing extremely well online. Um which so are horrible games or terrible terrible games that do well online. Um so it's just kind of a crapshoot in terms of you know what you deem as popular. Um, but I mean CGE is solid. They're one of the mo like the OG publishing companies and you know almost for sure that they're not going to make a bad game. At worst they'll make a mediocre game like Sanctum. Yeah, that's what I was going to say. Like Sanctum Sanctum could have been good if they supported the hell out of it, but they literally just were like and it's not selling. We're done. Which is fair. Um, but I remember a lot of people liking S Sanctum and it's always so awesome to see it to play a CGE game from, you know, early 2000s to now and their component quality has not changed at all. Their their bags are I don't know how they do it. So, at the very least, you know, you were going to get a well prodduced game. Um, and this one is just it it's it's right up there with where I want my euros to be. Like maybe a a a touch of I think a steeper learning curve in this game, but it I mean to me the hype is real. It's phenomenal. Every time I've played this

game, I've had radically different experiences um and different strategies and goals and but it's not an easy one. I think it's an easy one to kind of teach, especially if you've played it before, but playing it feels almost like a struggle. That was a This is It goes right along the line. I I'm assuming their Galactic Cruise is going to come out before this one, maybe, but I'll try and put it out. But uh like these kind of games, these mid high, you know, complexity games requires the um you know, the more you play it, the better you're going to get. Yeah. You know, so again, if you're playing with somebody you haven't that doesn't it's their first time, it's going to be a disparity. Yes. Do with anybody just which can be disheartening though. Yeah.

cuz people people want to be good at something, you know, right off right off rip. And these kinds of games can just be like disheartening to play whenever you're you feel like you're struggling for two and a half hours. Um that's why whenever we were first playing and I was like teaching you, I was like money is tight because that was a wakeup call for me. Like one of the first things that I did in my very first game was like, "Oh, this three cost card is really good." And then I'm like, "I guess I pass, you know, and the game's not it's not like you have a million rounds to, you know, up an engine. It's like I passed after doing one action in a in a game with five rounds, right? So, it kind of has that." And I don't know if Everddale was the one who kind of coined that gameplay, but it's definitely the one that I refer to the most of that kind of effic like you need to be as efficient as possible and if you are it it'll be less and less of a struggle as the game goes on. Um almost.

So with that with that all being said, Brad, what do you think of SETI extraterrestrial intelligence? Um, overall I can tell it's a good game. You know, I just need to play it more. You know, we played it, you know, the the few times that we played it and stuff like that and it's there is a learning curve. Yeah. You know, I mean, that's there's things that I thought I was doing to get all these points and come to find out it didn't work that way, right? And stuff like that. Or you have to go like a roundabout way to get it. So, there was some things like that. Um, this fits that that kind of Euro deal. Again, again, I'm comparing this to Galactic Cruise because it's we've played them. We just played them. Yeah. Um, it's hard. This one is not as bad as Galactic Cruise as far as you you could catch up in this one. It's just it's still super difficult if you get far if you get behind. There are there are big swings you can do in this game. Yeah. Um unlike the Galactic Cruise where if you're in the lead, you're pretty much going to be in the lead. Yeah. This one is like more point salady like a lot of things. Two points here, two points there, three points here. But I mean I never I never got close to you in this last play. Yeah. Like like I you know you beat I you beat me by you know 70 70 points 64 64 points. I mean you know so it's and it's always difficult to tell when those happen. I know there was one big play of like there's a 15 point swing there and this is mainly because

of the way that the alien species come out. Um, I think for anyone who might have issues with this game, kind of funny enough, could have the exact same issues as Galactic Cruise is that both of those games are all about efficiency. And yet there's the air of randomness from these cards where it's like, oh, hey, that's perfect because I'm going to be able to do this and, you know, I'm going to get 15 points there and because of this card, I'm going to get to do this that will allow me to get a token and oh, lucky me. I got, you know, the card that let me get, you know, two, three of those tokens that I can turn in for 11 points. So, I just got a 26 point swing in one turn. And for the person that's doing that, that feels amazing. But for everyone else where it's like, okay, I mean, I didn't get to draw a card like that. Like, what am I supposed to do about something that lets you just get a token and 11 points?

Well, because that's how I started the game because we start the game with five cards, put one under, we have four cards. Of those four cards, they were all three cost cards. Yes. So then it's just like you really can't afford to pay. No, you absolutely can. And stuff like, don't get me wrong, one of my favorite things, funny enough, with this one and Galactic Cruise is the cards. Like these are awesome. They're both multi-use cards of either, you know, a free action or turning them in for resources or I mean they're all unique. So you have a [ __ ] ton of cards to go through all with flavor text which is amazing of based in reality. Uh you know there are scientific stuff that is real um except the aliens but but again with how tight the game can be I feel like in a multiplayer game you're going to have different people who are struggling more than others through no fault of their own. It's just like I'm not getting the cards that you're getting that are free or cheap, so I have to keep burning them. But I feel like you're not going to do well if you're always ditching them for a [ __ ] publicity or a movement. That's that's so like Euro games that have those big decks of cards are like Arc Nova. So cards that pop out, you know, maybe really easy to put in your enclosures or Yeah. Yeah. Or do different stuff where any of these Euros that have that deck is going to be like that. That's true. You know, and they generally get a pass because I think

people, at least I can only really speak for myself. I don't know how you are, but I prefer decks like this because that adds more replayability. If it was 10 cards, it's like I I hate games where it's like here's the meta, you know? So, no, no, I agree with you on that. It's just you just have to know that. Yes. like as coming into a game like this if that's going to be something that's going to be a problem. And I mean I haven't played this game enough to be like oh what's the strat? I mean I every time I've played I've done something different. Like this last game we played I was cracking up because I was like I've only put one rover out this entire game. What have I been doing? Um and the aliens came out a lot quicker than they did in games past. So then I was kind of just really focusing on those.

But yeah, when I look back I'm like, "Huh?" Cuz the game I played before, I was like, "Oh, 25 points to go on Titania. All right, I'm getting that moon tech immediately." Like, I'mma ramp up my publicity, spend it, get the moon tech. So now I can land on all these moons and get a [ __ ] ton of bonuses for that. And that's of I mean it did really well but there's but and then this one is just like oh by the end of the game I finally got one on Neptune and that's cuz I was really trying to get that 25 point swing um for the mua mwa alien. So there is an air of like like efficiency and struggle even though there's only three resources you know energy credits and uh data it's tight like I I mean you finally got ways to where if you were gaining income was three four five only six but like I was getting I'd get six income for two cards. Yeah. But again, that's another thing is like if if money's tight, which it is, if you're not getting the cards out that allow you to then income them and slot them in, you're only getting three income every single income phase, which is only four

times throughout the game. So, I don't know. Like cuz in Galactic Cruise resources were tight, but it's like, "Oh, I'll just go place my worker over there and spend a coin or spend a credit to get some resources." Yep. So even though you didn't you weren't swimming in resources, you had ways to go out and get it here. It's like, how the [ __ ] do I get funding? Like how do I get money? Pass. Just quit the round and then get your money, right? Um, I mean, I guess the only other thing is like one of the texts, one of the blue data texts gives you one credit. So, I don't know. I don't know where you're at on like how tight this game is, if that's something that like is a turnoff or or if it's just one of those things that you just have to know going in and plan accordingly. I think it's that the latter. I mean, I think you just the more you play it, the more you're going to know. Yeah. And then I don't know what the expansion's even going to add. I don't know either. It's gonna add more alien races, which you would expect it to since five. I would hope so. I don't know if it's going to add it. It I could see it adding cuz what is your your starting? They're the same. you. So, I'm I'm wondering if you could do kind of like a prelude where there's gonna be different starting uh I would as well. Yeah. So, that could be that would be a good thing to do cuz then everybody has a little

bit there. Maybe somebody gets, you know, 2 two where they're getting two cards to Oh, yeah. Less. I know. But spitball her four money and one energy and you something like that. Energy is just as important though. I don't I don't know what that would um Okay. An expansion for SETI introduces powerful asymmetric organizations each with unique abilities, strategic advantages, and starting conditions that redefine how you approach the search for alien life. It it almost seems like it's kind of their uh exped like lost runes of Varnac expedition leaders expansion, right? Which is cool. Any more aliens? Um, three new alien species, each with their own unique twists, and over 40 new project cards inspired by realworld initiatives. Quick start cards designed for use with the organizations let you skip the slower opening round and dive straight into the action. That was finally, it introduces signal tokens, a subtle but meaningful new mechanism that enhances scanning efficiency.

Sounds like it's a good good expansion. Yeah, almost sounds like it's kind of I mean, obviously more aliens is always going to be great. We'll get to the aliens in a sec, but yeah, kind of like a like a prelude thing, which we just mentioned in our Galactic Cruise discussion, is almost a given for like terraforming Mars just set the set the bar for for that kind of thing. Um, which is perfectly fine. I don't actually have a problem uh with the way this game starts because it is only five rounds and a lot of the game is set up, but at the very beginning of the game, it could be a lot of like, okay, I have these four cards and okay, there's you're like the randomized board setup. I I guess I'll just I'll just go this this way. I could see if it kickstarts you at the beginning, then that would help because maybe that would get these out quicker, aliens out faster. Um, and stuff like that. Yeah. Which I I do have a negative about the game and it's it coincides with my love for the alien species cuz I if if this was just the game, it'd be fine. I really really like the addition of the alien species. The only one I haven't cuz I randomize it every single time. The only one I haven't seen is the exertions.

Um, but I've seen the Masamites, the Anomalies, the Omoa, and the uh um was the Centurans. Yeah, I was I was say the Carth Carthaginians. I'm like, that's not right. Um, and the Centurans. And they are radically different, which is awesome. But my negative for them is I feel like there should just be one that comes out. And the only reason I say that is because you never really get to pop off for them. Like you're never really getting to see all the cards that they and I mean it's not like they offer a [ __ ] ton of cards, but to even get more cards, you have to be able to get traces.

and you're not ra running rampant with traces. Mhm. So like you have to be able to place one on a spot that isn't already taken that lets you get a card. So I don't know. I I feel I don't know. I don't know if it would be good with just one alien race if it' be too little, but two almost feels a little bit too much. Maybe it's just to add for the replayability cuz you see all the cards all the time. And that's true. You know, maybe that's what their thinking was. Yeah. Or maybe it would just get too tight if if it was like a four player game and there was only one alien race. So, um at least in the in the very least what they should have done is in a lower player count game, like maybe a two-player game, only one alien races out, but then three and four there's two. Yeah. Um which they kind of they kind of go around that with the dummy tokens for whenever you pass 20 and 30 points, you take a neutral marker. And this is how this is how you get them out uh quicker cuz the game opens up as soon as they come out. Maybe maybe just house rule and don't have the dummy markers at two players and just put one out. Yeah, I'd be curious. That'd be a way cuz then it would just be the two people going for the one. Yeah. And it wouldn't have to worry about Right. You know what I'm saying? Because it does add an element of because you are competing for those spots. So, it's like if I don't know it because there was a moment in this last game we played where it's like I could cross and I had to put

a dummy token out and I could have just put it over there on the blue. So, you couldn't even jump on that one. But, I was like, eh, I don't want to do that. So, I just popped them over here. And every time I've played this game at two players, it's always like that. It's like, eh, just put them on the one that we're not compet that we're not, you know, putting our own markers on. I don't know. It's not a big negative. I mean, maybe would actually impact the game a lot if it was just one alien instead of the two, but I will say, yeah, they're completely asymmetric, which is awesome, but not overwhelming. It's not like, all right, let's pull out the massive alien rule book and play this whole other [ __ ] game. Uh, nope. You just, okay, let's set them up real quick, read the new two things about them, and then we're back.

We're right back at it. And I think their designs are cool. you know. Yeah. Um I don't know. I don't know. You got you got anything anything else to talk about, Brad? I don't think so. I'm pretty set on it. Okay. Well, um I really like this game. I know whenever I played your copy and I played it for the first time, I'm like, "Well, I'm going to go buy my own." and then 3D printed an insert, which is sexy. Uh, organizes all can't wait for it to be obsolete in, you know, two months whenever the expansion comes out. But that's true. Yeah, it's like, okay, well, this is useless. Hopefully the designers for it uh come out just with like an updated updated uh printer. Um, I would actually almost like to see more endgame goal cards as well because there's only eight total uh because those are double-sided.

But this uh this game definitely I think deserves deserves all the hype. Um, and we haven't played it yet, but the same designer came out with Galileo of Galile. Oh, is they cuz I bought them both that same day. Oh, yeah. The same designer. Yeah. And this So, this came out before Galet. Okay. So, I'm interested to see kind of how that one. Yeah. Goes too. It's Oh, so like I mean because we did talk about both of the uh you know, we have referenced both them because we did play them, you know, the same day. uh between this one and Galactic Cruise, which cuz like they're pretty much the exact same like not theme, but genre and weight.

Like there's things I like about both of them. Yeah. Um I It's like I feel like this one is almost was easier to teach. That's what I was going to say. I think this one would be an easier teach, but I think of Galactic Cruise I like better. Yeah, it's like a the freedom to be able to do have more agency in what you're doing. Yeah. Uh seem to be more in that game. Now, mind you, I'm not as experienced in this game. I'm not really at the other one either, but like like I could see, you know, the more plays of this that growing, you know. Um I personally think that the other one would be easier. It was easier to learn Galactic Cruise like to to Oh, go like it was more intuitive like Yeah. But this one I think could end up being better, right? Cuz I I've taught you both of these, right? Um and the overhead like me teaching this to you, I was like, "Oh, I'm done." Yeah, that's the game, right? Galactic Cruz, I was like, "Okay."

So, it was it was Yeah. easier to teach. But I think if and this is just two games that we just happen to play at the same time. But if you're comparing both ma like super popular sci-fi heavy euros, one is easier to teach, but the other one is kind of easier to play. Yeah, cuz I think this one, you know, I made that point in the Galactic Cruise that I would never buy it. Yeah. Because I don't think Amy would be able to have the bandwidth to Right. learn it. Because your wife is stupid. No, I think this one she would have a better chance of picking up. Okay. Plus, it's more visual. Visual visual, more colorful, more Yes. stuff, you know, and the and your player board is not as convoluted.

That's true. And they they have just as good of a player raid, right? Um, so I mean, I think this one would be more apt to get played more. Yeah. Which is why I own it, but I haven't, you know, I haven't played my copy yet. Yeah. I've played his copy, right? Um, and me and Ariana were Oh, no. It wasn't this game. It was Beyond the Horizon. We were making a joke of like every time we had to spend a resource, we would just eat it. And then you're like, "Seth, did you forget to put my like resource chips in?" I'm like, "No, we ate them." I was like, "What would you do?" Did No, seriously, where are they? No, we actually we ate them. What the [ __ ] wrong with you? But I will say from what I've heard from Paul Grogan's uh like playthrough of this, the uh data cubes and the like the markers are all from recycled components from what I I don't I have obviously not looked into that. I'm just spreading, you know, fake news trying to make CGE look, you know, more environment. But that's that's what I'd heard is that the plastic for the debt is is recycled and these are recycled wood. So, that's really neat. But they also have this really cool QR code that is because you can just random like, you know, just take a thing and just spin it, but it actually tells you how to set it up. Uh, which is just extremely quick. Setup for this game is definitely a lot easier um to do. But yeah, they both have their their pros and very, at least for me,

very very little cons. I think between the two, I think I like this one more, but man, they're both so [ __ ] good. So, I don't know. I don't know. Get them both. Just get them both, everyone. That's really like game. They're different. Oh, yeah. No, like it's literally just weight of the game, your heavy euro and sci-fi, right? But they're not cheap games either. This one's cheaper. This is much cheaper. Um, this is about half the price cruise. You also have a fantastic insert and components with collect cruise versus uh this one where I had to print a 3D insert. And if you're and if you're looking at shelf shelf size, this one takes up a lot less space. That's Yeah, that is very true. So, it's um I mean really it's got it's just almost like six of one, half a dozen the other.

It's it's they're very comparable. Um, I think I also like the realism of this one. Like I we didn't do it this last game we played, but like I like to read the flavor text and it's like like they have that the what is it the Hadron Collider where they're smashing atoms into each other. It's like they do this, you know, 50 million times a minute and I'm like what are we doing? Like what is that? It's it's awesome. This this game is fantastic. So that's the timer. Scale of 1 to 10. Uh what are you giving seti? Search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Did I give you gave collector an eight? Okay. At this point, how you doing, Bubba? At this point, I'm going in at a seven on this. Okay. Knowing that that with the aster that it could go up the more if I play this more and it gets Yeah. up there because I do see that this could definitely overtake that one. I got especially if I get it where I'm playing it more with my wife and stuff like that. Why? Why? Cuz I think this one the the supernatural ele, not supernatural, but the the extraterrestrial element. The other one was more like, oh, we're going on a little cruise. When there's that whole alien aspect, right? Uh it does. But right now, it's a seven, solid seven with the potential probably going up to eight, 85 depending on the more I play it. Yeah. I'm curious to see, well, you don't own Galactic Cruise, but I I'd be curious to see your thoughts on like the solo for both, right? Um, which I guess

I could always do. Uh, I haven't done like a solo review in forever. I just don't don't ever like I mean, Core of Discovery was I but I played that solo even though. Um, yeah, it's interesting. So, this is getting a nine from me. Um, which Galactic Cruise also got a nine, but it got an extra point because of the the quality of life um and the the insert for it. So, it got like a man. Wow. First time company from what I can tell. So, it got like an extra everything outside of the game. Gameplay-wise, it was like an eight. This one's a nine for gameplay. Like, I really really enjoy like just it just works for me. And it's not it's it's that same Everdell kind of thing where it's like it is tight on money specifically, but you you eventually just start doing a little bit better. You stretch it further. Um and that feels good whenever it actually does come out and then it's like, okay, I think I'm finally done. Like you're not ever going to get into a position where you're like, man, I can just keep going. You will eventually run out. It's like, all right, I finally got a pass.

and then it just all swoops in and resets. Um, and that just feels great. So, yeah, nine out of 10 for me for STI. Very excited for the expansion. Uh, got to get that pre-ordered. Also, I got to find the expansion for Galactic Cruise. Yes, I might be coming back. These Euros these Euros lately have been have been super super solid. Um, like I've been kind of eyeing some euros lately on Kickstarters like a little bit more because I completely fell away from them like on now I'm kind of like, oh well well they're they're getting pretty solid again. But you got to really be special like I'm not getting some Yeah. generic worker placement anymore. You got you got to really be stand out. Yeah, you you'll like endeavor deep sea I think. Oh yeah, that is another one.

That's a good one. So that's it everyone. That's our thoughts on STI. search for extraterrestrial intelligence. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved