Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kingdoms Forlorn: Dragons, Devils and Kings - Discussion

Transcript 56:14

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome to the discussion for Kingdoms Fourlor Dragons, Devils, and Kings. Now, this is a kind of preliminary discussion because we have not beaten the game. We are not even out of mob tier just yet. Nope.

Um, even though we have put what, 10 plus hours?

We put a lot of hours. This is a long time.

Yeah. Into the game. So, a lot of stuff could be taken with a little bit of a grain of salt. But, I mean, 10 hours, I think, gives more than enough to talk about pros and cons and how we're feeling thus far. And if you haven't been on the channel yet, there will be a secondary discussion for one of two reasons. either we quit, which is either which I mean if the secondary discussion comes out way early, that means we're probably quitting because we're not having a good time, or we finish it and then we'll do another one where we talk about how the game goes on. So, this is a massive game to to undertake for a a kind of review in any way just because of how far we're not.

We're we're so because it goes up to dragon tier at chapter five and

yeah, we played four sessions now. Three

three expeditions.

Three expeditions. Each one of us has done a quest. Uh, which is a long time.

And I guess that's a a positive for a lot of people, but uh it's a double-edged sword for me because it's like we've spent so much time to not really have gotten anywhere.

It does feel like we've just started getting going on this game.

Yeah. which I guess is kind of feels good that because in in ATO or other campaign games that Devon and I will know there there could be you know a lot of time where it's like man I really don't feel powerful but here in mob tier already I mean we fought the stonemason knight two times and the second time it was like

yeah I will say like like first impressions wise with this game they definitely leaned more uh like and I'm just comparing this to atto definitely leaned into more uh player favor. Yeah, I feel especi when it comes to like percentages and dice rolls like these thresholds are significantly reduced like sixes, fives to hit these guys.

Yeah. With uh cuz in in it's that's going to be a lot of comparison probably with De I plan on having us do a separate video and I want to get Kyle involved here cuz I don't want us to okay be bouncing back and forth on comparisons and then Kyle's like I have no idea what this other game is. But in comparison, every monster in atto had a 10 point had 10 hit point threshold no matter what. No matter what their level was, it was 10 hit points, but the number to hit was higher. So it's like, okay, this thing like it's a six to hit level one, level two, it's a seven, level three is an eight, and it went like that. Um, and it does do that here, but they've actually modified their hit points. Or if you have to fight him in an exhibition, how many wounds you start with? like Stoke Mason Knight if he's an exhibition. He starts with four wounds already.

Yeah. Damn.

So things like that. Um yeah, I'm I'm very curious on where you guys are sitting at this point in like are you liking the game? Is it is it kind like where where's where's your meter on this is I' I want to quit versus this is the best game I've ever played. Well, like you said earlier, um I mean it was easier this time this like now that we all have upgraded gear and stuff.

Mhm.

It was significantly easier to beat him on the third expedition. It when we move up to the next tier perhaps that changes.

It's hard to say at this point.

Um because this boss would have been significantly harder had we just had the starting gear,

right? I wonder if that's going to be the case where it's like, "Oh, now you're in the next tier. All right, all our mob tier stuff is dog [ __ ]

Got to make it through the next expedition before we finally get something from the loot deck

that gives us immediately better gear.

I don't know. I think it it is hard. I'm trying to temper my my comparisons between the two

cuz Yeah, I going into this I I just have to compare it to ATL. Um

I mean it's impossible not to. It's from the same company. There's so many parallels like going off your like your question like the meter meterage like I I am enjoying this game.

Yeah.

Um does it feel padded?

Yeah,

very padded. Uh now that could be unfortunate cuz we've done three starting quests and we've all gone to the same [ __ ] kingdom.

Um

so we're getting really tired of the principality of stone.

Yeah. Um, and you know when we're keep going to the same kingdom and surprisingly hit the same mobs repeatedly. We've done the Iron Cast dead twice and we've done the Stonemason twice.

Yeah. Both on your guys' stories.

And it's like we're learning that uh you know this tier system that they they really kind of bottleneck the the goods. Yeah. The you know cuz we're kind of like we're viewing our because our strength is kind of based on loot.

Mhm.

Um and you know at most each creature is dropping two.

They have two at mob tier. That's I mean it could expand. We don't know.

Yeah.

Um but right now having done the same kingdom three times in a row in the same tier, it's already feeling a scoch drive. It

Yeah. Like

so I mean it could be a lot better just what our experience has been so far.

Yeah. And we just randomly picked Well, I mean we just picked these nights based off what was interesting to us. But yeah, like I I don't enjoy the delve system because I find it to be repetitive and it's kind of like I mean don't get me wrong, the writing phenomenal. It's it's it's kind of like when we're you and I are playing Madara. I'm invested in the story. I care about what is happening for the Knights, but whenever that's not happening and it's like, "All right, let's just move here and gain a clue. Let's move here and gain a clue." When when are you getting to the exhibition clash? When did we get to the next story part? Like cuz I really don't give a [ __ ] about what we're doing gameplaywise, which is unfortunate because that's an hour of your time.

Yeah. Well, I mean I I share your opinion in the Dell phase. Yeah.

I do like the combat, believe it or not.

I mean, it's Well, the combat is

Oh, yeah. Atto combat. KDM combat.

Like I And I believe it I mean it's a it's grindy a little, but I mean it's

a lot of moving parts.

Yeah.

Uh almost too many.

But I do like how they treated mobs. Yes.

How they how they've incorporated them into their system.

That's the biggest difference between I mean you have your regular boss fights. Uh what Kyle, what are your thoughts on the overall combat? Because it's a triedand-rue system that Devon and I have seen again in their other game, but in the other game it was based off of Kingdom Death Monster. What do you think of the combat?

I mean, it's the best part of the game. Yeah,

like you said, like the delve portion, it just feels like we're trying to slog through it to get to the actual meat of the game,

which is the combat.

I think the delve lasts a little too long. Maybe maybe that's what it does is kind of catching.

I wish that cuz the higher levels, the different cards you go to, I mean, you see the same ones over and over. The exploration deck isn't exciting enough to be an event deck really.

Mhm. So, it's like, okay, the the bigger the card, the more threat you take, but then the more clues you get, but then the time stays the same. So, it's like, man, I kind of wish there was something that ramped up time, but then you almost need time to be slow because you're you're relying on getting to a certain location depending on the night story.

Like, for example, we if we didn't have to come across the uh the cathedral, we were two away from failing your quest.

Sure. or getting getting a different story event. So, it's like, okay, I get it. Time needs to be one at a time, but whenever it's just wander, it's like, oh, and man, I I [ __ ] hate the clue system. I think that is the most fiddly handwave inclusion of a mechanism cuz they couldn't think of anything else to do because it's so personalized to a knight. It's like, here's my story. It's all about me right now. Everyone focus on me. What are you guys doing here? Like we're looking for stuff.

Yeah. You're you're around and it's like oh I heard whispers of my sword being here.

I guess I'll get clues and it's not interesting in any way and because it's very difficult to fail.

Yeah. Just kind of give us something to do while the other person is, you know, continuing their story

pretty much. It's like, hm.

But the rewards you get from those like like I would have been

so much more useless without my sword that I got from my quests in the last one which I needed the clues to get.

Yeah. Thus padding. That's where I'm getting the padding feel. It's like, yeah, story is great. Love that. We love those. But then like the investigations, it's like I get two barely two pages to read while I'm collecting nonsense clues. Yeah. I mean,

or I get a I get a paragraph on my success and yours is like half a book. And I'm like, [clears throat] okay. I mean, I get it. It's all I got was a fortitude. They can't all be extravagant. I've explicitly avoided my sword

cuz I get to you get to choose what investigation you do.

And my [clears throat] I my first one gives me a weapon.

But I I'm like I I I understand the ones. You got your sword. It's great. You got your sword. It's great. I'm like, I kind of don't want to be handed something that's great, you know? I want to feel like I earned it. And me walking around, oh, we went left.

I guess I get a colored token. Anyway, here's my god tier weapon that I get. I don't know. It's just It's weird. I kind of want to see how how how challenging it is to not be handed a weapon that's going to wipe the floor with everything we fight.

I don't know. I mean, it's like the spear you got is not a bad weapon. It's right on the same scale as what we've been

No, it's really good. And that's from him.

Yeah.

Uh and that's where I appreciate the loot is that it it doesn't feel like mob tier loot, you know, where it's like beginning of any campaign.

Yeah. Something I have to comment on like again trespass comparison. I felt like their early weapons were just like, okay, this does

Yeah.

one thing opening one.

That's what you did. And this I'm like we're already like auto break one attack rroll one power reroll.

Yes.

Refresh this.

They almost feel like in this one because it's I mean the game is long, don't get me wrong, but like it's not it's only five chapters and we're about to get into chapter 2, they kind of want you to already hit the ground running

by getting this these really good gears. And so it's like this is mob tier. God damn. What's what's dragon tier going to be?

Is it like some oh I got my lightsaber? Let's just let's just mod like you would and I hit him and he's dead.

That's where you get the famisher,

right? So, it is exciting to see, but because you have to trudge through a quest, three investigations. It's like scavenge three, scavenge three, scavenge three. What's the point? We already got we can see everything.

So, it it's not exciting.

And I'm sitting here like, when do I get guys? Can I get an armor piece? we have 30 cards in our loot deck. Where's my armor? And it's like, oh, I guess I don't get one, you know? And in on Trespass, I mean, it's a lot more fiddly because there's actually a construction phase. Uh, I'm explaining to Kyle because they give you like in in these in atto, every wound card has resources on it. And so to craft gear, you actually have to spend resources. So you you're you're flooded with resources. So, you're given a ton of resources to craft items, but then you have to get technology that lets you craft more and better gear. So, it's a much more involved process. This is way more streamlined, but almost kind of too much. It's like, okay, we have this whole thing of crafting gear that was too much for people. Now, they like overc course corrected. Now, there's not enough loot.

And I guess their idea was that they were expecting us to constantly have they have a bunch of different mobs to fight. But if if story-wise we've fought the same things.

Yeah. I mean, can we see like our do higher tiers maybe have a little more gear? I mean, that seems to be kind of

hard. So, whenever I was looking through uh which I think it was kingdom gear I was looking through, I think each whichever one had the boots. Uh [snorts] I was kind of looking through uh each tier had six

six total

six total cards. So, about three each.

Oh, cuz I thought it was just the boots and the map for Kingdom Gear. Whatever.

Oh, and there was like a worm, too.

There was the pale blood worm thing and whatever had whatever I looked through last.

Okay. Yeah. No stress.

But essentially that deck had six total. So about six items.

So I'm pretty sure it's going to be the same number

cuz it's always like we get we get a consumable pool, we have our upgrade pool, we have kingdom pool, and then every single creature has its own exhibition and then full clash version.

Yeah. So

yeah. So I mean, and yeah, each each enemy does have its own deck, but that's probably two per tier.

So, and I'm trying to temper my things cuz it's like not every single game like this needs to be about gear building, right?

Um, nothing's touching Madara when it comes to character crafting, but man, I feel starved for options is kind of where where I'm at. So every time we're scavenging, I don't give a [ __ ] It's like whatever, just sell it. I don't even want to look through it. And whenever it's like, can I look through the consumables?

Yeah. And what you spend your money on isn't hasn't been super exciting.

Yeah.

You know, we had that outpost base. It's like, okay, we get some mercenaries. We're more useful.

Yeah.

Um they did make

the delve a little smoother in some instances. Um but just not a lot. I mean, okay, you get an orphan to open up a what's in the section and then it's like it already opened up in the story anyway, so then that was pointless. Uh, the mercenaries are you get two uses for the whole [ __ ] deal and they're worth a couple coins.

And the consumables shouldn't take up a gear slot.

Yeah, it's like you have a potion. It's like, can that be set off to the side?

It shouldn't take up a gear slot cuz you have to give up too much for it.

So, yeah, it's just so it's like, you know, our rewards just um little disappointing. Yeah.

I mean, granted, we accelerated quickly. I mean, we got our solid gear and we're feeling strong. So, that's good. It's making us feel strong.

It does, but it it it's also like they made us feel too strong too quickly cuz now it's like I think so because again,

we we can't even get to chapter 2 because in a three-player game, we have to do each one gets a quest. Then that means we get two investigations.

Mhm.

We have another thing we have to we have to waste. Mhm.

I We all get to investigate now, which all that means is we have to

go through and go and wander. Yeah.

Do individual

which is the worst part of the game. I feel like I hate the del system. So I'm I'm dreading that cuz at le pull us forward. I have nothing to look forward to in the sense of a story.

Mhm.

Except like, okay, well uh for my investigation, I need three green. Let's go south. And you're just wandering to get clue tokens.

It Yeah, like you said.

But I mean, if it's Could we go to a different kingdom? Do we get to deal with somewhere else?

Yeah. Cuz these we were scripted. We had to go to Spincipality.

That's true. Yes. Our only other kingdom is the sunken kingdom.

So that that would be nice.

That's true. This game feels like they wanted to kind of have a modular experience.

Like that is definitely a you know exclamation point. modularity.

And unfortunately, there's only two kingdoms out right now. So, it's kind of like it's like a video game when it first drops and they plan the uh the uh wedding the live service aspect. This is all down the road.

Yeah. Live service. Yeah. Big time. Yeah. The drop drag and drop your knights, drag and drop your kingdoms.

Yeah. So, I mean, as of right now,

drag and drop your mobs.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, based off your tier and and stuff. That's based off I mean there's a beastiary so that's those are your options. So yeah later on hey we're in king tier and these are all our mob options and when the game is fully out you have four kingdoms plus one you can delve into

and you have right now with what we have

we have we have the principality of stone.

Yep. And the sunken kingdom.

The sunken one. So we can just go there or we just we only go there from the principality?

No no it is a separate kingdom. it own separate kingdom own. It's it like there's yellow cards in there. These are gray. They're yellow.

Okay.

Um

so that's but you have the 10,000 succulent fears which introduces

none.

It's not its own kingdom.

Not kingdom.

It is a dive into like all the

Oh, it gives us the option to dig in deeper of the principality stone or the sunken kingdom.

So they each have like another layer pretty much essentially.

It's like you you find a door that leads down and

when we decide to try and do that

Yeah. It seems like

it's already overwhelming.

Kingdom underneath the kingdom, but it's not its own card system.

It's got its own card system.

It does not have it own card system.

Okay.

Um, so but I don't know. I haven't I have not sat down and read those.

Okay. I was just trying to get a full

but then there's two more kingdoms that are coming in wave two as well as I think each of those has at least one knight and then there were two other separate knights which is the whole game. So that kind of leads to the following question is what do you guys think of the uh uh structure of the game where it's we are not sharing a collective story. It's not like you're stand it's not like Gloom Haven or or Madara or any other campaign game where we are a party. I mean we are a party. We're knights traveling together but it's not like one overarching story where it's Yeah. You are dealing with your fronds, your your caretaker. Um,

that's yours.

He's gone.

Yeah. Yeah, he's gone. I can't wait till he comes back as a dragon to your boss. Pull out the insert. Fron Fron the swindler. Uh, to hit him, we need to roll a 15. Just says he [ __ ] you. In what way? Cuz you were traveling with a boy. Mhm.

You are dealing with your immortality, trying to undo whatever curse has bestowed upon that. I am trying to hunt the biggest monsters in the world to gain to gain to gain glory

to gain flesh.

I

to gain flesh.

I think that's super cool if I was playing solo because I mean even though I am invested in everyone's story, it feels a little disjointed. And I love the fact when you're reading a story and it's like if this person's in your party

Yeah. more of that. Like

I like less of that.

You like less of

I because I I thought

I would like little quips so you feel like you're traveling together. That my main complaint with his is like I didn't feel like we were with him.

I know.

You know, it was

Yeah. We're like you you had a moment though. That's why you Yeah. Like we were kind of like, okay, we like we don't really know this guy. Okay. He does. He seems to trust him so we'll trust him. But then we see how shitty it is. And you had a moment of an older man be like, I've seen like this guy [ __ ] sucks.

Right. Right. I mean, until then, it just sound it sounded very disjointed. I mean, it could be the order that we played it, too, because that was his prologue essentially as his character developing, getting rid of the caretaker and becoming his own knight.

Yeah. Realizing he sucks.

Yeah.

Um,

so, do we have to play an aimless expedition to get to the next chapter?

So, technically, yes. Either you are either questing, investigating, or free roaming.

But you have to do four. you do.

Okay.

Like before, which is why this game feels like they wanted you to have four knights because if if if everyone is doing a quest, that means everyone is also doing their an investigation,

right?

So by the time our four like let's say Roloff was a knight, he does his quest, we all get our third expedition or in investigation. Boom. Chapter 2.

Yeah. Everyone keeps questing.

So that feels like the way it should have been.

So if you're, let's say you do play solo

Yeah. with three squires.

Yeah,

you'd have to do your quest and then three expeditions that were aimless with three squires

pretty much.

Aren't there special rules for solo players?

I think there actually is. Uh well, I know there were special rules for five players,

but it still seems like crazy even for two players to do two expeditions.

Yeah, and that's kind of where my overall issue is with the flow and structure of the game. The modularity is cool. I know that was a thing you were really high on. I'm like I could see the huge positives of that

if there wasn't this weird like okay now what do we do moment because in atto which again is comparison it was a constant progression there was never a time of like I guess we'll just sail you know like that they'd be like ah well we couldn't beat the uh the nichin like well we got to figure out where he's at

don't know let's sail around until we find him

it always felt like progression towards the end of a major story. And that's kind of where I don't like the modularity. I'm sitting here like

Yeah. Cuz I'm like building to a boss, you know?

Yeah.

Yeah.

Like, so I'm sitting here like,

can we just house rule and just say we did our third investigation just to get to chapter 2? There's no rhyme or reason why you can't.

I mean, we've done the principality this many times. We're not getting anything new from it.

I know. They feel like it feels like they wanted you to do exactly what you said, explore a kingdom, learn the layout of the map.

Mhm.

Which is cool on paper, but there's not enough meat

to it to stay in the same tier. Like, yeah, we're going to learn new stuff in vassel tier.

Yeah.

Like, we're going to things open up. There's a lot of quests and loot and stuff that that depends on the tier you're in.

New enemies get opened up or they get harder. So even if you fight, you know, the egg knight again, he's a level two. So things definitely open up and they progress. But yeah, for it to come to almost a screeching halt, it's like, okay, now we're kind of like, what what do we do? Like I'd almost rather just be like in a three-player game, like in a three-player game, we do one less investigation.

Yeah.

You know,

I don't have a problem with that. I'd say house rule, honestly. I mean,

especially with how long it takes. Like, and maybe the way we play is not for this game. It works great for other campaigns, but like we play every maybe every few weeks, once a month for 10 hours.

Mhm.

And this game takes so [ __ ] long that it's like in a 10-hour session, we finish one person's quest.

It's bonkers how long this thing takes. It's the two It's the two encounter system.

It is. I mean because we're forced to a half cl an exhibition and then the full clash and that's all that's two setups that's two breakdowns

it is

um

so that just and then that not to not even including like the delve is it own setup and progression it

take it over saves its welcome you know cuz like any other game we played like our little travel step doesn't take very long it's fairly simplistic

okay cool

u you know a king death roll hunt table and then and a on's trespass You know, you move the boat, you you have the Okay, you get your technology, time goes on, now we fight again.

Yeah. Like, like whenever you're looking at the uh the timeline, which is kind of like your timer, you have 80 days to finish a cycle.

Mhm.

Um you move a tile and it's like, that's a day. And then you might have it's like, oh, hey, there's an adventure hub. Cool. Go into the cycle, read an adventure hub. It's it's it's kind of similar to the kingdom stories that you randomly get through the uh um through the expedition deck, but but yeah, it it it it's just weirdly structured. They definitely wanted it to be its own challenge.

Yeah.

Like they wanted it to be a whole another like draw to this game, I guess. I mean, certainly cuz it's I mean they have two different tracks. You've got threat, you've got curse, and we have time.

Yeah.

Um, and not to mention, I mean, they want us to wander. All the exploration cards, they lock up locations, then they block us from going back.

Then you have the ciphers, and then it's like, "All right, let's grab the cipher book." And all right. Nope. We don't see anything. You just You

And that slows [ __ ] down, too, cuz then we've got three characters, and we run into one cipher, and it's split between two books.

Yeah. Cuz he's from a different expansion. And so it's just it is slow.

Yeah. And then you read it and it's like, okay, there's a little bit of kingdom lore, but like at the end of it's like, ah, you don't find anything here.

All right. So, and then because the kingdom is the same kingdom, you read the same [ __ ]

Yeah, that's true.

So, you get to a point where it's like,

stop reading.

Yeah. I'm just looking. Do we get anything? If we get anything, cool. Let's look through it. But yeah, it's just there's almost they they they tried to simple it like simplify it almost too much.

Mhm. And not to mention the [ __ ] encounters that we keep skipping.

Oh yeah,

those thing. What are those called? They're just called encounters. Then there's expedition and then there's the whole Yeah.

Including those.

Yeah. that we try to avoid as much as possible because that's a whole other board I have to set up and then we have to take the minis and pop them down just to roll ones and be like, "All right, do we defeat them?" No. Okay.

Yeah. I think they intended this game to be a full [ __ ] like six hour sesh.

Yeah.

And that's you play the once and that's what you get.

So, how are we feeling about the game?

I know that sounded pretty strange, but you know. Go ahead. Sorry. Well, I mean, like, you want to start rating it?

No, no, no, no, not yet. Because I still have more to say. But it

I mean, positives.

Yeah. I mean, I still enjoy the game. I like the modularity.

I wish there would be a little more interconnectedness. I mean, like a central driving force would be kind of nice.

Yeah. Yeah. So far, I mean, again, supposed [clears throat] to be talking about the positive.

Oh, you're right. The positive. Well, I say it's fun, and that's the biggest praise I can give it. Like, I I look forward to playing it. I really do.

The combat's legitimately fun.

Yes. Yeah. The tried and true system of the combat, they I have yet to find a game that actually does mob fights as good as this.

Most mob fights in a lot of board games especially are

I think I'd rather slip my wrist. Like,

I mean, Madara Combat is a It's like 800 health. Are you kidding me? We do 30 a hit. Oh my god.

Bosses are pretty rough.

Yeah. And it's it's like it's streamlined. Combat is I mean the nightpool is amazing. They flood it with night night uh tokens. Um the strategy between players is still great.

Mhm.

This is the biggest addition to the game. Um are these cards. Devon, uh what do you think about the cards? You get to use them. Oh yeah, they're Yeah, they're fun. I get a lot of delve [ __ ] which is nice.

Yeah,

because I'm the tracker knight. Um

maybe be like significantly harder. I feel like I I'm wondering if I'm using monkey business, right? Because it's it seems broken on their exploration phase. As much [ __ ] as we get to dodge.

Um my my new my new Discord buddy uh did not clarify that you were playing. I mean, from when I'm I look I checked the rules several times and it's just the way it reads, it sounds like I'm doing it correctly cuz I just pay to put him at a place and he just stays there and then his effect is perpetual.

Yeah. Yeah. He did not say anything specifically. I mean, this is this is in part three. He didn't say you were playing it wrong.

So,

but yeah, like a lot of my more powerful abilities are are during the del. Like my combat abilities are, you know, here and there.

We all kind of have our staples. I I just I just feel like the problem with the delve phase is that it's not there's not really any way to strategize completely. It's just too much RNG.

Yeah.

Like there I mean you can help push the odds in your favor, but

there's just too many factors that are outside of your control and sometimes the story is just going to go the way it goes.

Yeah. Like I mean you have ways to kind of mitigate the random path. You have a way to Yeah. have a straw at the top two. I get to sit here. Um,

yeah. What are your abilities that you never use?

Uh, they all require fly.

Can I see your cards?

Sure.

Is I just like, yeah. So, those really use the cards ever.

No, I don't. They're nice.

Deep fog and discard.

Yeah. Which we never go in.

We always like I have a deep fog card as well.

I mean, we have the staple clashes, which is a very nice addition.

Okay. Yeah, you've got a fortify card. I've got a fortify card. Yeah.

Um,

I have the new one I got for one of my quests was I give you guys passion.

But that requires one of your new ones.

That requires flash tokens. So I have to already have those in the night pool or on my night board, whatever.

So if those don't come out, all right, I guess I'll just I guess I can't cook. I don't have anything on me.

You need flesh.

I need flesh.

Oh, during an encounter. Okay, we're about to perform a virtue test or false too. Very similar to a lot of mine at the start of the delve round.

Gain one threat place.

Yeah.

So,

I'm not like [ __ ] on the cards too much cuz it does feel like mob tier was kind of like we're all kind of the same. I mean, even in the Clash, we all have a standup card. We all have a reflex card. We all have a

uh

second chance

a second chance card. Uh, which is good because those in in other games other game atto uh were conditional. A a mortise draw had to give you sec or you had to have gear that gave you second chance. You didn't have a default, oh thank god I can willingly stand up.

Sure.

Um, which is great. I would much prefer to have that in in my hand than uh but we also never really use these for their secondary effect up at the top. That's rare. I mean, we can,

but but mostly I I'm waiting for those specific circumstances when I want to use the other effect,

right?

Like standup is very important. Um

I mean, what else?

Or like I have six cards available to me, but I can only actually have four,

you know,

right? So, it's like maybe maybe a lot of these slight issues that feel like weird janky mechanical decisions are ignored or are for later tiers.

Mhm.

I mean, I will I will be pleasantly surprised if that's the case. And I will I hope that's the case cuz right now I'm like I mean, my cards are [ __ ] useless. I don't I finally got to use my card that gave me second chance. I'm never knocked down. I only gain more flush whenever I'm at six six passion, [clears throat] uh, which is so rare to get. Um, but they did do a lot of slight improvements in combat. The heat aspect, uh, which is fate in at your chances of rerolls, your die mitigation cools down. You refresh it instead of it being a static thing that ticks up and you're like, I'm at my max, guess we're [ __ ] Uh, I feel like we're a lot tankier already.

Like our health is a lot.

So, we feel more

more powerful.

Um, I don't know. The cards I don't I mean, maybe it's just cuz I'm the fly shritter and I never get to use them and when I do they feel kind of like eh scared me.

Sorry. And I feel like it's a it's one of those things where we you may not be able to fully get your character fleshed out until

I mean hell your whole build is all about leash and unleash and it's like what's that? You even asked me what the [ __ ] is leash?

Well, I didn't I didn't even have that was my first card that had leash on it.

Yeah.

Like so yeah. Like uh yeah, we barely got to touch the surface of our abilities for specific characters except for him.

Yeah, cuz like

Yeah, you're right.

Well, mine's seems very supportive. I move the monkey around.

He's been using dragon tier cards this whole time. I don't get it. I'm good.

Yeah, I move the monkey around. That's really Yeah. And you guys both rely on like a building a very steadily, slowly building resource.

That's true. We are the heavy tanky boys and we're like, why can't we do anything even though we hit hard? Um, yeah. So, maybe it's like mob tier is your tutorial. Unfortunately, the tutorial takes 18 hours um to play. So, it I mean, I'm not I'm not quitting. And it sucks because I can only directly compare this to ATO, which is my favorite game of all time,

right?

It's from the same company. So, I'm just like

Yeah, cuz it does feel different like the time we're investing like story-wise, we're not being really uh what's the word? um rewarded I guess for like Yeah. Because at this point in ATL we would already be like maybe a third through a cycle.

Yeah.

As much time as we put in.

Yeah. I do think the story is is a lot more um streamlined like

Yes.

We're not constantly being pulled into like different things where it's like, "Hey, here's an event that's happening over here. Here's over here. Here's" And it's like

it can seem disjointed in I know the first one.

Yeah. Where it's like I don't remember who's this guy

right

here. I know exactly what your story is about where you're

all these nonsense Greek names.

Yeah.

Sorry. Greek.

Yeah. The Greek names where it's like

I'm stupid American.

Like Kyle's best friend. What was it? The Theo Theocles or whatever.

Yeah. Theopolis.

Theopoulos. Yeah.

That real modernday person.

Um

Theopoulos.

Yeah. So, I mean, I guess there's there's there's a lot to be desired, I feel. Uh, at least that's kind of where I'm at where it's like I'm interested enough to see how it how it plays out.

Yeah.

But we're probably going to have to house rule it. Either give us a free investigation like just to progress because otherwise what the hell else do you do? uh besides like, oh, we want to see what the sunk sunken kingdom is. Let's roam it.

Yeah.

Even though thematically that doesn't make any sense where it's like, hey, this horrible uh area that is all death and decay. Yeah, let's just go for a summer jaunt through it. It It just doesn't really And like God, they even have free roam. Like that's like giving your brother the unplugged controller. Hey, can I play? Sure, free roam. I don't really have anything else to do. Like I don't even know why you how you would ever fruit from unless you failed an investigation which

that's really it. That's the main source is to you know redo your investigation.

I guess if it's not there then you'd be pissed if you failed an investigation.

You get a little more like you get one additional loot card and you get to do Exactly. Yeah. Um and you could clean up an old investigation that you failed. So

pretty much Yeah. And so I guess it's there just in case you happen to not get the clues you need. So then you fail and you don't get your reward. So, it's like, "All right, well, I guess I'll free roam to try and get that again." Because if I remember right, are we supposed to be writing down what investigation we were on? So, that cuz if you let's say you did fail the one where you had to whoop up on that on that guy who challenged you,

we go to the third invest. Can you try it again or is did since you failed that one, did you have to write in that you failed that one and you have to pick a different one?

Didn't say anything. There was no like direction. It's just there's the success like read but there's no fail,

right? But it's like since you mark them like for like you mark an X here to show that you pass or that you started it but then if you fail you don't mark it.

It's like are you supposed to write in

I think you just leave it blank and then you can come back to it.

Yeah. So it's like all right cuz then so then what's the point of retrying an investigation if you fail to if you can just choose a separate investigation.

I mean it depends if you're wanting that reward. I guess it's also lets you go back to previous ones. I guess like from previous chapters.

Oh, really?

Like if you went like cuz we get five. We only need three. We have five total we can do.

Yeah. Well, I don't think you can do chapter one investigations when you're in chapter 2.

I I couldn't confirm that.

Yeah.

I think it's all self-contained. Um but I don't know. And don't even get me started on this [ __ ] rule book. [snorts] like the fact that it's 30 pages bigger and yet explains even less where I have not referenced the Q&A more times than this game.

And I get it. It's a these games are massive, but every single time it's like I feel like there's less rules here to play, but I'm I always feel like I'm just kind of like uh I uh what? Like I always just never really am 100% on anything. Mhm.

I'm always secondguessing myself even though I feel like I shouldn't be. Um, and that's even with you guys having read the rules yourself. Three people who have read the rules still can't ever confirm one thing and

a lot of importance and time in between sessions.

Like you said, a lot of the rules are ambiguous.

They are. Yeah.

Things

or hell, it's like they're just weird dumb things like overcome and overpower. Why would you make those two keywords that are Well, this one is if you fail the hit. Oh, wait. But if you're looking to overcome, it actually has the overpower in it. So

then the overpower is just over.

Only thing I can think of is that the overpower would be for mobs that they don't want to give you a reward if you fail.

Yeah,

that's the only thing I can think of.

Could be from later. I know based off cuz I've actually been involved in the discord and the Q&A section for that and it seems like this game has a lot more rattas like [clears throat] oh check out the arata on the web on the website a lot of FAQs a lot of Q&As's

that it's not just us

they seem to have dropped the ball quite a bit when trying to explain it

well they they felt like they had captured their lightning with Aon's trespass which they poured a lot of energy into and they did a really good job with but they're like, hey, we can just reuse these systems, modify it a little bit, cash in, and put in a little less effort with the modularity, which is always the big thing. So,

yeah, I mean, the biggest difference is, and Dev and I can attest to this, is that this is not

Still enjoy the game.

Yeah, this is not atto. They they not medieval atto.

Yeah, we wanted it more atto, but it it is not at

Yeah. So, it's maybe it's just I mean Kyle's the best example to be to I don't know if you do like it.

Should we go with a rating?

Sure. I can't really think of a whole

0.5.

I know you said the one is dog [ __ ] worse than that.

Yeah.

I mean, if it was just the combat like that I was rating, I'd probably give it like a seven. But like overall maybe a five.

Damn.

Damn.

I know it's a little harsh, but I I just need to see more.

Yeah.

I I I feel like that's that's my rating for the first tier.

For mob tier.

For mob tier.

I I feel like has the potential to be a lot better than that.

Yeah. Mhm.

And I like I mean like like you said, I mean the combat's fun and it's enjoyable, but um

I I did not

I don't like how the delve phase is set up.

Yeah,

I maybe it'll be different going forward, but

yeah, the delve is definitely the worst part of this game.

It No, I mean it really is. I mean, because it's just it's so involved.

Yes. that for for no reason. Uh that yeah, like you're you're looking to forward to the combat sections. Um I'm looking forward to the story sections, which usually t and I like the combat in this game a lot. [clears throat]

U but but yeah, I'm just kind of like and I was like that way with atto. I was I was hoping that the next tile flip would have a adventure hub or or or a rest and relaxation section. I was like, "Oo, yay." Um but that's it. Like it's like those those were an enjoyment to have. I wasn't like I need this because it was just anyway move on. So I don't I don't know. I'm definitely not at a five, but I can see exactly where you're at. I know cuz I mean it could it should only go up like from there.

I I can see it being higher.

Um we get into it. Kyle's like I [ __ ] love this game. Seven.

What do you mean? We got all the way to dragon tier. Yes.

Best game of all time. 6.5

and slightly above average. Um cuz I mean there are a ton of enemies we have not seen.

Yeah.

Oh yeah, for sure. Like I Yeah. The combat, the modularity, like I like of the combat I've engaged in so far, I've liked a little bit better than atto in several instances.

Oh, really? Yeah. Like just combat wise cuz

dude we haven't even fought this sexy pregnant vampire chick

with a little pot belly.

God that that's doing it over.

Uh we haven't fought these pumpkin head monstrosities. They've been they've been available. Uh we haven't fought this white ape troll.

Yeah.

We haven't fought the first men the first men warriors. There's so many enemies. I mean I mean don't get me wrong. I love that the options of enemies are here because it's not

Oh yeah. It's not that you get two for the rest of your [ __ ] days. This whole cycle

definitely felt underwhelming because we fought the same enemies twice and so then there was

right cuz we had less options better.

Oh yeah. No, you're right. Yeah. With the looting being tied specifically to the enemies you fight. It's like hey here are five enemies that you could potentially fight. Okay. Can we No. Iron Cast did

cuz it was our first Yeah. It was everyone's first like quest and it just that's kind of how it's opening up is you fight the undead, you know, the generic undead foe and then

Yeah. your Runescape first enemy.

Yeah, cuz like mine uh like my foe in my story was Wasn't he Was he random?

Was it this guy by chance or was he scheduled? I don't think he was scheduled.

You got I thought he was scheduled.

Was he? Oh, that's right. It was because you had that expansion. It was this guy.

Oh, yeah. There was something that was like if Surf if he had hadn't finished his quest

or if he had finished his quest, he would have gone to a completely different section. Yes.

So, it's like I guess thematically this is the same night we encountered at

because wasn't it also at the cathedral?

Yeah, I was going to say

this would have been this like the kind of like the same guy, but it's like well we whooped his ass.

Should have been my quest first but we didn't know that.

But you would know. You would know.

How would we have known? which again is is a great testament to the the writing is that for replay if you ever replayed this game again. You you could have we could start with you to then get a completely different story experience even though yeah there the the story structure is the night like this is all in one one story. Um, you get choices. Like my very first one was I get to choose to stay with the caravan and help them and make sure they live or uh [ __ ] them and go uh gain glory for myself. Yeah.

And obviously I just killed the people in the caravan just

as you should

just to rid myself of the guilt [snorts]

and and that opens up a lot more where you I mean they still have the choice matrix which I absolutely love. Oh, hey look at that. You successful investigations. Oh,

down at the bottom.

Um, so there you go. Uh, that's there. But yeah, you have uh you get your choice matrix, which will be pulled into later stories, which is always exciting whenever you're like, "Hey, that's the choice I made. Can't wait for you to uh see the dead bodies of all those people at the caravan that you stole from."

Dead the corpses letter the ground. the carrying beast flutter about.

What is that from? Something. Okay. I'm like, who is this narrator? Um, but yeah, it maybe maybe we just got horrible horrible luck.

Yeah, maybe it was just like could be like I'm just like the same enemies over and over.

Same thing to the same enemies. Yeah,

I'm at I'm going to give it like I'm still having a good time. I'm still looking forward to playing this. So, I'm going to give it an eight right now. I'm at an eight.

Um,

getting so easy to please.

I kind of am. Um, you think it's even similar to King Death?

I can't I can't I'm too I'm in too deep.

Oh, yeah. Uh, what was I going to say? But yeah. Um, yeah, Dell Face needs something. It's too long. The sessions are just so bad. If it was if it was literally the Dell phase up to the full clash, I would have no problem with it.

Yeah,

it's because it's Dell phase and then you have to do a quicker exhibition fight. It's like, oh, how much how much damage do does he start with? Um,

one.

One. Cool. We still have to deal.

So quick.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, later on, like at level two, the stonemason knight has 10 health and starts with four.

Yeah.

And so it's like, okay, but it's so it's six wounds actually. Wait a minute. It's the same [ __ ] thing because in level one he has eight health and he starts with two wounds. So it's still six wounds you have to deal.

Yeah.

So it actually isn't quicker. It's the exact same no matter what level he's at.

Um but yeah, if it was just the Dell phase and you got your whole story stuff until the full clash, boom, you're done.

Uh I could stomach that. That that feels like it'd be a good pace. But because it's a full Dell phase to a halfass exhibition and then another full Dell phase and to a full clash, it's like

Yeah, it's just Yeah.

All for no rewards at the end. All for literally nothing those

except a card. Hey, you got a card. I got a fortitude. You got I don't know what you got. A card, I think.

Like it's like a helmet.

Yeah. Helmet and a card.

Yeah.

Yeah. Investigation one from the loots. I got an upgrade. We had half the loot deck in our in our scavenge deck. I got one upgrade and six money.

Mhm.

Five money.

Money.

Yippi. Which again could just be the shitty mob tier. I am hoping if I I swear though, if Vassel tier is this, I might call it.

Yeah, that's fair. like it is not worth the time investment, which sucks to even think about because I love ATO so much and this company, I mean, pumps out great stuff, but man, it's not incentivizing me so far to to be excited except that I'm just like I I hope it's good.

Um, I'm at a six.

Six.

Yeah. I mean, I'm kind of more in in like I was thinking seven, but then I'm thinking on this whole [ __ ] 45minut discussion, none of it was mainly that positive.

Negative.

It It's a lot of time for not getting a lot.

Yeah.

I mean,

and I and it's not even

I mean I I have a decent tolerance for grind and time. Like I I still enjoy like as long as I'm enjoying the combat, I'm enjoying the gameplay. Mh. Um, but it's definitely it it feels it's a lot for what little [clears throat] we're getting.

Like I mean I I love the writing. I do love the combat. Um it's more of Yeah. I mean like Kyle said, it it it could get better.

It could get a lot better based off out of getting out of mob tier, but man, if it's just like, hey, Vassel tier is pretty much mob tier with higher numbers, it's like okay. Mhm.

Like we [clears throat] just we can only see, but as of right now, we're we're a ways into this. We're we're definitely 10 plus hours over and and yeah, it's not which it's it's it's leaving me disappointed. I don't know. And there's a ton of there's a ton of nights. We got one more. Sue uh Sir Ubar is is one and then three. So, we have four extra nights that haven't been touched

that are referenced in a bunch of stuff. Other I mean, other expansions were mentioned, which I guess is great that they're already included for later later releases, but it's like is this game really kind of just okay until you get all the content?

That's true.

How much I mean this is a $700 game

just already what you have

with everything. I think everything is like that's a $700 money sync. I mean atto with literally everything is a a thousand.

Yeah.

So it's a sh

Yeah. We

get on my [ __ ] level you [ __ ] god.

Where's your Oh, you have kids. Sorry.

Yeah, we haven't used kingdom death.

There's an entire function in the Dell phase like that we can't use yet. Yeah, these these the Hulk are um

like there's they're not used at all in this current phase. So,

is it kind of literally like they didn't have as much content like it's a it's a shrink down version of content, so they just stretched it out to like make it worth. Uh

yeah,

I I don't know. I mean, again, there's there's a lot of stuff that reference the nightmare kingdom or hey, like even even in the 10,000 succulent furists, it's like, hey, here's an icon. Maybe that's for future stuff.

But then again, it's like if that's for future stuff, why do you even have it as a section in the [ __ ] rule book? It's like, or shortcuts is a good example. How does shortcuts work? Gear lets you use it. Well, how does it work then?

[clears throat]

You got to move there.

It's a secret. Guess you could move. Okay. Well, what about enemies? How do they follow us? Oh, they just teleport.

Oh, okay.

At least we did find clarification for that.

We did, but it was on a completely unrelated

Right. It was not in the shortcut section,

right? So, it's just it's so it's so bizarre. The only thing I can do is trust that the same company who made a on trespass odyssey knows what they're doing and we just have to wait and see. But uh but yeah, for a preliminary discussion, I'm not that high on it. And I mean on board gamegeeek, you guys want to take a g take a guess at what this is rated?

Nine. 10.

It is a nine. It's higher than atto.

Wow.

Um

I'm I'm surprised about that.

Yeah. Kingdoms for Lauren. Uh yeah, it is at a Okay, it's gone down a little bit. It was at a 9.2. It's at a 9.1.

Yeah.

And with with 369 rankings. Uh so that's not a lot. AON. So

I mean if they thinned down the Delve.

Yeah. [snorts]

And I mean kept the combat the same. Like it would feel so much better.

Yeah. Aon Trespass, for the record, has a nine with 2.6,000 6,000 rankings, meaning that the average is a lot higher for uh atto settle at a nine where it's like, okay, you have less than 500 views. So that's I mean cuz first I mean I have K Kingdom Fortn as a nine out of when I ranked it as a kind of like first impressions after our first game or something.

But it's like damn, now the more you play it, the more it feels like the cracks kind of start to show. Yeah, I mean we'll we'll it's going to be you know what's going to be funny is because as of as of right now we will be able to at least see what Vassel tier is directly after this is reviewed and watch it's going to be like damn it's great now

our whole like we're quitting

we still quit

but yeah it's it's I I hope that's the case I hope this this discussion becomes does not age well.

But that's that's where we're sitting

right now, unfortunately.

And we didn't even talk about the squires. I don't care. I don't care to talk about them. They're they exist.

The streamlined, you know, if you need that attacked on, they're really not that bad.

Yeah, the squires.

You don't linger on the character too much. It's nice that they didn't make them fancy.

They make it quick. Yeah. Make it easy.

Yeah. But with the with the structure of each gameplay, I'd rather just two-hand another night because at least that means, oh, hey, we get to do another story section and everyone gets to do their third investigation besides house ruling and be like, well, let's just give us all a

sure. I mean, cuz then you're you're juggling another set of cards. You're juggling another set of

At least I feel like I get to play cards.

Yeah,

but that would be more night rapport. That'd be more opportunities for someone to pop in to interact and stuff. The squires are just there. Well, if we want to go back to the Prince Valley of Stone again, I guess so.

Yeah.

And find the Iron Cast dead in the

night. Maybe maybe the egg knight. He might show up at that.

Yeah. Stonemason stonemason egg.

That'd be Yeah, that'd be funny. So, we'll see. Uh what was it? Eight. 865.

I'm still holding my eight. Uh and we'll see. Come vassel.

Yeah. All right. You guys got anything else you wanted to bring up?

I don't think so.

All right, Devin, you good?

Yeah,

we good. All right. Well, that is our thoughts on Kingdoms forlororn, Dragons, Devils, and Kings right now. Um, so stick around. We're going to continue the series. I I'm I'm hoping it it improves significantly. But, uh, yeah, stick around for the rest of the series. And like, comment, share, subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of the day it is for you.

Progress saved