Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mansions of Madness 2nd Edition Review: The Good, The Bad, The Eldritch.

Transcript 13:59

hello I'm Farrell this is tally we're at Board of it and today we're reviewing a real Enigma of a game Manchester demand the second edition for one to five planets this is a terrifyingly thematic exceptionally engaging and at times immensely infuriating game it's Friday Fantasy Flight and set in their lovecraftian universe and it's going to see you solving Mysteries solving murders and also fighting Cosmic Horrors each game will have you choose one of the available scenarios and play with your chosen character maybe you'll be exploring a creepy old mansion looking for Clues regarding an Arcane ritual or maybe you'll be on the run from some scary monsters in a spooky coastal town yep and important to note this game is app driven

foreign you'll begin by picking an available scenario in the app and then inputting the characters that you've chosen the app will then spit out some starting items that you get and Away you go the map will be built out as you play the game and it usually starts with a single tile on your turn you get two actions and for most of the game these are going to be move which allows you to move two spaces and what we call interact which allows you to interact with the tokens that are littered across the board which indicates something of Interest or new areas to explore you'll start out with very limited information you probably won't really know what's going on so what you're going to be doing in terms of gameplay is you're going to be moving around the map revealing the map exploring discovering Clues maybe talking to people or fighting monsters depending on the scenario and eventually you'll hopefully get an idea of what is going on and there'll usually be something you have to stop or do and there's always a secret timer in the background counting down so you have a limited amount of time to do it in and if you don't get it done in that amount of time you'll fail and you'll get some kind of story ending that is not good for the world once all the players have had their two actions it'll be the

Mythos phase which is the standard phase where bad stuff happens to everyone you know this is where monsters are going to activate they'll chase after you and maybe just some horrific random events and you're continuing this way alternating between player turns and Mythos phases until either the players complete the scenario or they fail it because the time has run out alternately you could lose somewhere in the middle because a player dies in which case you have one turn to complete the scenario or else you lose the app runs the game telling you what tiles to place where to place tokens what the monsters are up to along with keeping track of all kinds of bits and pieces the app is deeply integrated into the game and you'll spend a lot of time clicking through it as we alluded to at the beginning of this review mountains of Madness is a bit of a weird proposition there are many rough edges but it's almost unparalleled in terms of theme and player interaction some of the scenarios run two hours plus but it certainly doesn't feel like it the characters the artwork the story and even the background noises in the app all work together to effortlessly draw you into the world of Horror and most of the man this makes it rather easy to role play and this means there's more player engagement and importantly more fun the characters are well fleshed out and individualistic the items are

full of character and the scenarios full of mystery and great story time the best part about this game is that it's basically just Scooby-Doo the board game because you're usually exploring a mansion finding Clues and solving Mysteries there's just more existential horror and real monsters than in Scooby-Doo but I mean who doesn't want to play Scooby-Doo the board game a key element of what makes Mansions of Madness so great and what keeps players involved is its simplicity there are about 10 actions that you can do but it's likely that for about 90 of the game you are just going to be moving and interacting with tokens it makes playing light Breezy and simple so it really allows you to focus on the mood the story and the role playing we introduce this to a friend on Halloween and we can honestly say that Farrell only had to explain for about two minutes and then we were able to jump right into playing it's really easy to introduce to others so it is almost a shame that they are likely going to get gobbled up by an otherworldly horror we really enjoy how all of the items and spells are thematic and at times Darkly humorous you get a nice little progression because you'll be collecting different bits and Bobs which means as the game goes on you'll have more options but you'll also likely become more and more injured and more unhinged so it's a nice balance all of the characters have special abilities and different stats so it's really fun to mix them up and see how

the scenarios can turn out differently and all this combines to make managers to manage the game that facilitates some great table talk you know in fact All in This Together means that you're going to have a lot of discussion about how to define and Conquer who's going to go where maybe the best way to defeat an enemy and even how to help each other out and we found that this is a better Court proposition than say Eldritch Horror or some of these other Arkham Horror games just because as we said before of how kind of fluid and interactive and dynamic it is whereas those can get a bit bogged down in round structure rules and what you can can't do turning to the app it's okay it's not the best app in a board game but it is pretty solid which is important because it carries most of the game to the point where you could pretty much just play Within the app so if you don't like apps in board games then this is not going to be for you one good thing about the app is that it randomizes parts of the scenario such as the layout and minor story beats so it does provide more replayability than other scenario driven games as an example in a murder mystery each time you play the murder will be different so it gives you a different puzzle to solve another way the replayability is increased is through the difficulty I'm surprisingly for an Arkham Horror Game Manchester vandus is tough as males and you probably are not going to win

the first time you play a scenario just because there's a timer and you'll almost certainly waste too much time figuring out what is going on getting the layout of the place following kind of red herrings and false Clues so even when you do know what you're doing you still are going to need a pinch of luck to successfully complete the scenario because you're going to have everything going against you horrific events terrifying monsters and also just finding the right things on the map before we go any further we have to talk about the mammoth in the room the price and the sales model of Manchester's about this because new you're not likely to get this for less than 70 pounds and to be quite Frank it's not really worth that I mean the base game comes with four scenarios four and I know he said it's replayable but it's not that replayable and maybe you'll say well what about the Miniatures aren't there a lot of Miniatures yeah but they're widely regarded as kind of not great and pretty useless and it's not that they're necessarily bad Miniatures it's just that they have a really stupid system you have to put them onto these little plastic trays which honestly they don't work too well they tend to fall off it's a bit tedious and annoying and in these trays you're supposed to pop in the monster details on the bottom but it inevitably is covered up by the actual miniature so then you can't see permanent information so even if you like Miniatures I don't

think you're going to be happy with these because they're not really the ones that you can paint and just put out somewhere on a Shelf what the game is really crying out for is removing the plastic cutting the price and just having the already existing monster tiles on little stands which gives you a nice picture and allows you to easily see all the pertinent information there's this General Aura of trying to put as little as possible in the Box for as much money as possible and it's a bit annoying and one example of this that really pisses me off is that they've only included and remember this is a game you've paid so many pounds for five dice in the Box do you know what you do every turn and something that probably every player will do at least once if not more around roll dice so what this means is that you have to constantly pass the dice around the players and let me tell you our three of the game when it's slowing down the game because you're having to reach over for and pass it who needs how many it gets really tedious annoying and I just don't know why you know they couldn't have had double triple the number I mean it's dice right and when you come to the expansions things get even more apparent because they're basically just assigned to price guide you because you're paying the price in some cases of a normal game in

other cases more than a normal game for the expansions and all you're getting is a sliver of new content you know four new investigators a couple of new tiles maybe three scenarios and what's worse is that some of the best content is in these expansions so it's really tough proposition because you're expecting people to pay another 50 pounds on top of again they already paid 70 pounds for just to get some longevity out of it but this isn't a perfect game there are certainly annoyances there's a big element of luck which isn't necessarily a negative but it can be frustrating in our last game my character's special ability was to re-roll one dice per round and not once not a single time did any of those rerolls land on a success interacting with the map can also be frustrating at times because whilst it's fine that you don't have time to interact and explore everything the game can be remarkably unhelpful in letting you know what might be important so this means you could find everything you need for a scenario quite early on just by luck or never find one of the items that you need before you run out of time and lose also it's not well balanced for low play accounts sure the in-game timer does increase but it's still much slower to explore with just two people and

you're worse off in terms of diversity in skills and abilities not to mention it's much easier to combat when you've got multiple people beating down on a monster it is a little Annoying that it isn't better addressed but we do just get around it by playing with two characters each then and this is a personal thing for us the combat is a little bit Bland you just roll the dice that the app tells you then input the result and it can sometimes feel like the combat is in the way of the actual thumb so for us sometimes a very combat heavy scenarios can feel like a bit of a slog whereas the investigational ones are a joy important to note though that some people really love the combat heavy scenarios and getting to shoot a monster in the face with a shotgun so take this with a pinch of salt final thoughts we really want to recommend this game but it's a tough one you know we love the mystery we love the Intrigue we love the storytelling it's great how the rules are simplistic allowing players to just kind of Dive Right In and start role playing without worrying about too much rules overhead but if we're being answer ourselves it's probably not worth the price tag particularly because so much of the game is on the app you could almost Jerry rig it to download the app for free and figure out a way to play the game just through that yeah and through one which

to mention the and even more frustrating some of the best scenarios are in the expansions and we probably would fully recommend the horrific Journeys expansion if it wasn't for the price so if you're interested maybe try to get Mansions of Madness second hand or give it a go at a board game Cafe and that was our review of mansions of Madness if you enjoyed this video we really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up subscribe to our Channel if you're not already and please feel free to ask us anything about the game down below in the comments or tell us your favorite scenario yes favorite character Etc we're gonna go because the dogs two monsters here that we need to say I think they're going man see you next time bye

Progress saved