Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:33

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to ward games unlocking we are doing a no run through review for dreadful circus and oh boy is this game dreadful i was working really hard on that one uh man um i think portal games and bruno uh fiduti just totally dropped the ball on on this this is uh this game's a load of this game is just not great um if this game was the only of its kind i think it would be like wow and it also came out 10 years ago it'd be like wow but there's already games that have came out that do the same kind of concept and you know you know hit the nail on the head this is proof that you can make a game you can and sell it if you have if you ever if you have a well-known name and you have a publisher like backing it then yeah you'll you'll sell it you can make a game i sold it over four copies already so normally i don't take into any stock really with board game geek ratings just because you have the dumb asses who were rated the one for no reason and the rate of 10 for no reason but i was very intrigued and we were talking about this before we played it was well this is a six and i'm like it's brand new and normally brand new games always skew higher yeah uh more than i sometimes think they should but in this case not many people are

very happy with it mainly in terms of production quality uh the way the card effects and just lack of understanding of what some of them do because it's like yeah you made the game that's simple but you didn't put any thought behind it how much is this game uh i don't remember i'll look that up uh while you guys tell me what you think zack you you and i tend to disagree on games i think this is a prime example of a party game that's rated low uh anytime i see a party game even if it's new it'll rate a little bit higher and then it drops down i've seen great party games that are rated at five like bang bang is one of my favorite games of all time it's rated horribly i love it yeah i've never played it this game's not uh i watched the video prior to even playing it they make it look great and the art is really great the art's really cool um i can see eight people sitting in a table and drinking and having fun with this game but it's not balanced at all it's just completely random it's one of those times we'll see and and the argument i'll make for that is you're not wrong you can play this game and have a good time because it's very light and it's more about just hanging out with your buddies but a lot of people say that about like online multiplayer games it's just like oh this game's a blast with your friends literally anything is fun with your friends joining a cult is fun with your friends like uh so i don't i don't give that a lot of stock into anything because it's it obviously means nothing now could i bring this out in a group of people that aren't my friends and have a good time probably not because especially what this game wants

to bring out i'm feeling is that sense of negotiation and bluffing and deduction except it does none of that well well in how much this was we didn't um uh we didn't start playing into that um and but it really isn't part of the mechanic like for example sheriff of nottingham it's a core part of the mechanic right that's the whole point strategy because well that's the thing is bluffing and then thinking that you're not even bluffing so uh it goes for 40 regular but on miniature market it's 28. so which is used no that's new no normally you used copies out there already they've returned ding and dent uh well because in sheriff of nottingham there is a consequence to you bluffing yes like and then this if i'm like hey i put a lot of money in there you can be like oh okay let me check no you didn't i'm not taking that and it's like oh all right why did i lie it's like it's like the sheriff is trying to bluff themselves yeah because you go do i want this or do i want but what's behind door number two right i don't know yeah i got a few sheriff from nottingham is one of those that's really easy to teach and has a high level of mastery we already learned the meta in this game yes you go for the tokens if you get token cards you're probably going to do well yeah accordingly right because in in one of the games it was literally like brett had a [ __ ] ton of money you had the great you and cap both had great combinations and i only had contracts

and i won by i mean it was like five points was the point spread from first to second but still it was like okay yeah lucky me yeah so you opened the box and you picked well i guess i guess so i mean or i happen to use all my money wisely to to get cards that let me take these from people it was just like it's stupid these contracts do nothing and to be fair i don't much care for a lot of set collection games because it ends up being just that um kind of my same thing with uh like furnace for example it's an engine builder solid engine builder but i want the engine to do something like i like that in like uh in addition to a lot of other things uh same with set collection uh champions of midgard has a set collection thing but you do stuff in the game to collect those sets here it's just like oh yeah here's two it's coins [ __ ] arbitrary cat what do you think of your favorite game right yo yeah you could tell best of 2021 yeah i was so engaged the whole time um i couldn't take my eyes off of my own stuff yeah uh because there's nothing else to look at except for the nice art yeah yeah the nice art even the box cover i think is solid this is a theme that i would love in like a heavy work replacement like or like even like a dinosaur island but with a creepy uh carnival um and we see that a lot i feel like i feel like brett and i have played games where i was like i just want this theme in better games

and they never are yeah and i feel like it's it's just so easy to have a good idea and not be able to execute it like it's it's so easy to be like oh yeah okay this is what we've got like it's gonna be a dreadful circus and then it's just so like yeah it is like yeah i don't know i i was not impressed it wasn't really fun right and to be completely honest this is the pace one theme the theme has absolutely nothing to do with anything in the game yeah um it's what's selling it exactly yeah yeah that's that's what drew me to it and i and i knew the designer and i knew the company i was like okay that sounds like it'll be a good combination so it is my fault for not looking into what the game is about but i do that a lot i back a [ __ ] ton of kickstarter games and i'm like what's that about i don't remember i just backed it and usually designers and companies feel like they have a reputation to uphold yeah this one apparently doesn't no it really really totally drops the ball i mean even if you take another game that technically kind of has a paces on theme but this set collection carnival of monsters have you guys played that it's a richard garfield and it has an air of magic that you can feel because it's richard garfield but the set collection with capturing you know magical monsters oh yeah we've talked about that yeah uh monsters monster expedition is another smaller box game set collection but those do it well there is substance to the game here the only i'm trying to think of things that i'd like and if i were to even say potentially the card effects

it it can't even be that because you have your own hand of cards and you're like man i want to use all of these but i you don't get to yeah so you have to hope that other people play cards that are useful to you but your hand is literally just an offer row you might as well just lay them out and then just you know just randomly draw one except for the three that you refuse to let anyone have exactly yeah and in a game that's about bidding and trying to kind of like i'll sky it where you have like the tokens behind it's like okay so i know they really want that one so i'm gonna really you know like there's some strategy to putting money behind it here you're like well that's really good okay you might have a lot of gold i'll bid that and you have to make me an offer i can't refuse and then you did okay so that's it that's that's that's that's the game yeah yeah there's so many games that are set collection games that are that have done this better like chinatown i think about two um where that game is is aggressive from the beginning to the end but you're still having fun because you're kind of talking [ __ ] with your friends and and this is just like okay we did a thing it's really casual so that's kind of not knock both against it and and for it yeah you're not investing that much so it's not it's not like you're losing that much at the end of the day right i think the first game that we played with learning it took us 40 minutes yeah 45 minutes um and that's what it says it does say 45 minutes and i mean honestly i would rather play splendor than this at least

i think this has zero thought behind it at least splendor there's some there's and replayability at least in splendor there's some decision to make in terms of the tokens you take uh yeah and you are aware of what other people are trying to do yeah you can interfere yeah you know they're they're yeah that's a good the taking mechanic works because it makes sense in splendor yeah yeah and then this that's the yeah good i'm bringing that up because this game just has take that for zero reason no there's no strategy it's definitely not a strategy game at all it just feels more mean and i and i get that's in the you know inherently in the concept of take that but it's more like all right yeah i'm just gonna steal that from you and it's like great i worked i played 20 minutes just to get my second tableau card yeah there was a card that allowed you to pick one type of token and that with the way that you have to collect things would completely ruin someone's game yeah you're basically going to watch the entire game there's no coming back from that yeah um and i happened to have that card and i was the only one going for contracts so because you you like maybe an offer i think it was like of money and green and purple and i'm like even if i took that you're just gonna be like oh purple and then just take all the ones i had which would have been all four of them right and yeah you're right so even the take that cards are just like lucky me i have that anyway i'm just this is just a wash none of you are gonna offer me anything that i'm gonna take so then the take that just becomes

why is it even in the game this game kind of sucks i love the art though the art is is very very good um component quality is kind of ass these these wagons which or whatever they're called um are very thin and very cheap they didn't even go with cardboard it's already kind of ripping oh well yes because the thin tuck things i had to like kind of push them in to get them to stay um this this is just this is kind of mind-boggling like and it makes me sad because typically these kinds of themes are always wasted on shitty games uh so hopefully someone takes this theme and does something great with it you can make a fantastic card game about this yeah um i wish i had an example like i feel like i've seen something like this before uh kind of like did you guys ever play abomination era frankenstein this reminds me of modern art too you uh you auction different cards and there's different styles of auctions depending on what card that you play okay um it's well thought out it's very simple but and it takes about the exact amount of time if you're thinking about getting this game going it's a much better game yeah or get cheaper i think yeah or literally get sheriff of knowing him if you want that party kind of style where it's not a drinking game because party games are

always kind of like hey we're probably going to start drinking soon this is kind of loosen up uh this doesn't have that um sheriff of nottingham definitely can especially if you want to open up because there's a lot of negotiation in that uh and it's like man hmm are you lying to me if you're [ __ ] lying to me for example if somebody looked at my bid in this game my my wagon and refused it i say okay let me let me give you two more coins right sweeten the pot as it goes but that's not you know built in as an option we would have thrown that in and you can't do that and sheriff yes encouraged yeah and there were uh i mean there was one instance where like when when zach made me an offer and i was like okay if i take this are you gonna use it and he's just like no uh nope nope that was the only instance where we laughed the rest of it was half the time it was just like not or shaking an empty yes there wasn't even a time where cat put the car down and brett and i were like yeah there you go there's nothing it's just and that's not i don't think that's that's nothing the game brought out so um we had fun despite the game yeah that's true only because we're friends so that's why all right i don't want to talk about this anymore than we have to i literally get anything else i could keep going for another hour please don't i wouldn't

play whether i'm gonna play better games that's all we got uh all right on a scale of one to ten um i'll go and start i'm gonna give it a three i think it's i think it's in here i gave splendor a five um i thought it was an average game which a lot of people are like five what that's a worse score it's like no there's there's literally four numbers lower than that um splendor's about an average game i wouldn't ever really be like ah like if someone wanted me to play i'd be like all right uh i would actively say no to this uh it's like no i don't want to sit around and hear them what the [ __ ] you said you ever talk to me here's the other thing that makes this game inherently bad you need at least four people yeah it's a four to eight player game if i'm and i i mean now it's easier to get four people over than it has been for me in the past but if i'm getting at least four people i would own captain sonar because that requires at least four people um it's fantastic it's a it's honestly one of the best gaming experiences i never own it because it's best with eight um you can do six and be pretty pretty all right but six or eight uh the fact that you need four is another reason why it's lower because four is about below like it's slightly below average but i think this is a below average game um so that's uh yeah that's that's my score right uh art eight it is really good actual game i'm gonna i'll i'll say two two oh god

damn yeah i'm not gonna slap somebody for i will grudgingly go along with it once and then say ever ask me again then i'll slap you see i can see people playing it for the first time and going well getting into it enjoying it if they don't play real games after it going i can't imagine anyone wanting to play it again i'm just going wow wow well i'll be leaving now that just like i know we had a whole game day planned i'm done the bathroom

all right zach i give it a four yeah i i didn't hate my time with it it was entertaining but um it's definitely at the lower end of my list as far as four player games that i could play yeah absolutely yeah i'm actually right there with him i was going to give him four four honestly like a three three initially would be like a four is where i was sitting at but the the requirement of player count and then also i really don't like games where there's a meta in fact if there's something i hate more than just kind of going through the motions of games is having a meta because then at least going through the motions there's still different decisions to make meta games it's like wow there was literally no reason for me to play this ever again yeah uh so so yeah so three two one i wasn't expecting it too but that's funny wow and that's our thoughts on dreadful circus let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved