Time of Legends: Joan of Arc - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we're doing a no run through review for joan of art time or time of legends joan of arc yeah we have a couple of the expansion like the apocalypse we have everything everything everything well isn't there like a whole other half of it or is that not that was a uh it was an update because mythic games loves to release games before they're finished uh so erratas like their rulebooks are always [ __ ] on release um but no this there was like a 1.5 okay uh so uh this i mean this game came out a while ago and the reason why we're doing a no run-through review is because uh kind of the same reason that i did for uh uh twilight imperium i just don't much care for uploading six hour videos anymore because i don't like doing parts and uh but so we decided to do uh the armageddon one which is insane it is easily their biggest battle uh good versus evil um and it's a skirmish game open world or not open world open map dudes dudes on the map moving them to fight skirmish game uh which if you're a fan of the channel you know i tend to not like i don't hate this game but to be very blunt this game is a [ __ ] mess like of a skirmish game yeah
and everything that i do have a problem is just accentuated because of how clunky and how like unclear everything is um and how much of a setup everything is that it definitely overshadows uh the things that i do like so i don't know how you feel we'll uh we'll let you start this is actually this is your game uh so we will yeah what do you think of joan of arc what do i i i have very limited experience in like full-blown war games right anything i've played with you i've you know i've looked into warhammer just because i'm like been a true miniature
um but i mean from what i've seen like warhammer and other uh war games i mean it definitely feels like a war game yeah i mean you are you know you activate the units i do like the area activation rather than the individual unit which is just tedious right you know moving them all very specifically i mean at least we don't have to take a [ __ ] tape measure yeah that is true so we go by hexes they do very much streamline combat yeah but i mean which is both a good thing and a bad thing yeah i mean we went i mean we went whole hog we we did their biggest [ __ ] their biggest structured fight that they'd created right i mean that i believe is in the book and that's that is the apocalypse or apocalypse why is that armageddon armageddon i just like to say the apocalypse apocalypse but the fight is called armageddon yes um so we did their biggest thing so it may have been a little overwhelming for us neophytes here in this in this uh kind of game yeah um but yeah it is definitely a messy um a lot of units a lot of unique cards a lot of rules to take into uh take into account a lot of keywords definitely like you want to play this several times before jumping into something so big sure it's definitely a lot almost uh you know bit off a little more we can shoot there right because it's like oh yeah you got a lot six hours for this [ __ ] yeah but it's also it's it's key words and i'm not holding that against him at all uh what the biggest thing about the
clunkiness is and i and i like i like it initially uh but in practice it sucks ass having the two and three peg holders is so [ __ ] messy it's so stupid it should have just been a mold it should have been one unit like have a little unit and this it doesn't you don't need this to represent uh like three people yeah yeah it doesn't need to be there one because each section like based off how many areas there are they can hold a certain number but these circle bases can't hold that amount like this can't hold like six unless you're like really scrunching it in and then it just makes the board look busy the other problem is because you have three in each section you can't easily identify what no you cannot what units they are so to be streamlined which they try to do in some areas they really mess up in others because it's like okay i'm attacking that area oh okay so yeah which units that's that's card they have okay they they get and because the the best thing about combat is that attacker just takes all their dice and roll them and then apply their effects defender does the same all their defense dice roll them apply their effects and then any disrupts or kills that are left over they get applied according to the defender that's all fine um but then whenever
it's like okay i'm attacking this area okay so that has that has my plague bearers they have they have support they have terror too oh [ __ ] i forgot the terror like it's so bad yeah when you could have easily just had one unit to represent plague bearers like if if i get four plague bearers i have four units not three things or four things of three you know and if you want to be like wart because warhammer is like if i think they actually do have like infantry on like one base but it's molded like so you don't have to piece every single one of these tiny things i mean it's yeah it's like they have an individual they have like they have been like squads yeah i don't know the intricacies please i'm sorry yeah sorry i'm sorry i just watched a few videos i'm sorry it's like i always i was enjoying i'm a semi fan i'm kind of like a fanboy i like to look at the miniatures and how well they're painted oh yeah but anyway but yeah you have to paint them if you want to play yes you do um but they have them in like squads essentially but like each one looks unique right but it's like a six-man squad you move them as a group exactly yeah and they're like on like a rectangle base and so you just be like oh moving this one um but also because you don't have that many like the tape measure isn't that big of a hassle to be like oh he can move this much and then boom i know they have the what was it warhammer uh kill shot or kill squad or whatever yeah kill team it was supposed to be like a condensed streamlined version of warhammer uh anyway that makes setup
insane um and not only that the scenarios they have it's it's quantity over quality like we know for a fact not every scenario is great and they have to rework a bunch of scenarios to make it work if your scenario says three or four it's wrong this is a two player game especially three three is awful that was like i think it's like the only scenario at least three oh it's one of the few it is i think there's like one or two yeah and it was like the tarasque and like it was awful and i was like oh this will be cool it was not it was not cool um so with skirmish games i i've found one that i have genuinely enjoyed and it was mythic battles which i'll eventually get but um my always pro my problem with skirmish games like this is you spend so much time on your turn especially in this game and in this particular scenario doing stuff deciding which units to activate trying to strategize utilizing your cubes this is the best part of the game by the way the cubes which we'll talk about um and so you do all that just to position and then you roll dice and you miss and you're like i wasted 30 minutes to to fail every single time and it's not that there's not mitigation there's uh keywords and stuff to let you re-roll
um but also the worst part especially depending on certain scenarios and this one in particular it was i had to kill very specific units of yours and uh you just had to hold out which isn't a horrible um victory condition on either side okay uh i never felt it was gonna be like one side was winning over the other it felt very thematic the holy site i mean it makes sense always said would do well against the evil side because it's you know angels versus demons but in practice for me it was kind of like okay i gotta do this i just need to kill one of your units i haven't kids round three i need to [ __ ] just kill one okay oh you interrupted and ran off okay i'm gonna i'm gonna try and shoot okay i roll my dice two hits oh you got defense okay all right i guess i get to do nothing yeah and that's just not fun for me i don't know i don't know what do you think of the combat um i like i mean you said you're getting to the cube system but i do enjoy the cube system yeah i mean in a big battle like this you're trying to figure out all the [ __ ] [ __ ] i mean just all the different guys look very similar yeah they do so i mean i was a little frustrated on my part because all my eyes look very similar and trying to identify um each one individually i mean if that was a little more streamlined yeah and they maybe made some of this a little more obvious yeah because it doesn't need to be bigger like the tiles or anything the units just don't need to be individual three pieces right um but otherwise like the dice i mean if i could streamline that somehow i mean
and unique abilities there's only so many that you can only handle so many in a different area yeah um it gets a little more complicated when you're activating you know command characters yeah and it's like okay so you they're activated and now this many people around them can activate and then you just have a big ol swarm uh so it's just confusing that you have to keep track of all of that yeah uh but it's interesting it has a little bit of extra depth and makes your commanding characters a little much more commanding it's like oh yes the boss you who you want to move who you want to engage with yeah carries along the the little schlubs the you know your infantry units yeah they're coming with him yeah and that's great i like that mechanic it's just there's a lot going on yeah but war game but um i do enjoy the combat i'm not as peeved with the dice um but uh i definitely see where you're coming from yeah yeah i think it definitely and like it's not that we were rolling bad like you had some bad roles i had some bad roles you had good rules i had good roles i mean it washed out but in a long game that that's essentially what it always boils down to it's like i can position myself great in fact you could always roll defense and then always never get shield yeah and then you're gonna start dying i mean you have to kind of go with the flow of the dice yeah i mean these games because it's like definitely in the early game when you came with the beast i mean you like wiped the whole [ __ ] right hex in one go right and then like this this last few rounds uh like mike you couldn't touch my griffin yeah he is rolling shields like a beast i was rolling shields all over the place which is amazing yeah but that's you know when
you're chucking dice you know they back and forth yeah so yeah i understand yeah and with skirmish games the ones that i have like the most it comes down to strategy like okay is my strategy better than your strategy or your strategy better than mine and we'll see which one comes out better that's why i like a lot of euro games and stuff like that uh instead of being like well your dice rolled better that was six hours of nothing uh so that's one of the biggest like because we like each combat it's like even then like my my beast is still alive or was still alive and it's like i could have technically just keep trying okay push you out and then just keep following you um just to get your your angels out of the way but it's also kind of like well that's using up all my cubes so i really want to do that which brings me to the cube system easily the best part this is unique i haven't seen this in any any game um and uh yeah i like this i like that what you're able to do is based off of the cubes that come out and mostly everyone is equal uh there's no like i mean there's a few ways that you can get extra cubes but it's not like oh man i have all my gray cubes and you only have two you know uh yeah you can only carry over three so if you did have a conservative turn you know you could have a big slam dang and turn but not that big yeah
yeah i think the the most you could get is no uh yeah seven because there's one with four if that came out and you carried over three you could be like oh man i'm gonna get to activate seven units plus whatever extras i get and do one big massive turn which is uh which is not nothing like i i very much like that strategy the problem that i also think that happened in this scenario actually what what do you think of that that cube system cube system oh i mean i'm a fan of it yeah it felt really streamlined yeah uh sort of you know trying to identify your units which is kind of a pain right uh and then the awkwardness of the six don't really fit there yeah you can put six there i almost would have liked it so you haven't played twilight imperium but and it's not just that one but a lot of other games they do it to where you activate an area and all adjacent units can move to that area i much prefer that over picking an area and they move from that um just because you get i feel like you get more bang for your buck than uh just being like okay well because that's why all these units i had in the back i never wanted to move them because they were always so far away and i'm like well that's a waste of a cube it's going to be a while before they even get involved but if for example we did areas and it's like i want to do this one i want to activate that area and then i can move them in i can move them in i can move them in that's that's my preferred method uh granted in those scenarios usually units in an affected area can't be moved out
so if that was the case then they'd move in and unless effects got me to remove the token then they could be activated again yeah but then you have these i think they're i mean i think that they're what they tried to do to have a similar effect are these command guys that can draw in essentially when they activate being drawn three dudes true come with him yeah uh because the command yeah you pick them and then they can at you you activate those away so like conquest he can do three areas away in two uh and and yeah that that is true so it does bring these scrubs out um quite a little bit more but then it just kind of becomes all congested in one area and it's like and they definitely don't give you enough bases to put on they did not to be like so they don't accommodate for each scenario because it's like i mean at that case it would have been a little bit better to have like okay you know battle you know no man's no man's zone or no man's land in the middle and we have our forces come up and there are people in the sky the game is very thematic it's very cool uh whenever you can get things going oh god like yeah that giant beast is of course attacking oh like all those angels christ uh he was he's a mean boy and then he eventually just gets and then you brought up all your angels into the sky we had our cockatrice and griffin like dog fighting uh my horsemen were coming coming in yeah it's really cool uh but
i don't know i just don't want to play a dice chucker for first you know four to six hours um yeah that's um i mean i'm trying to think like pretty much like that's that's pretty much that's pretty much it there's i mean there there is a lot of stuff in here uh i just don't think that they streamline it funny enough i hear no one talking about this game anymore yeah that could just be because everyone's sold it everyone's making war games everyone's making more games everyone's trying to make these skirmish games a lot more streamlined uh if i want to do a war game i'm definitely going to play i mean ti is a 4x game not a game like this but there is fighting in it i'd rather play that i'd rather do rising sun or blood rage those streamlined conquest negotiation games versus the head head if i want to do a head-to-head i'd rather it be fair um not the dice i mean dice are unfair for really both sides but it's potential that it can't be yeah one of us could just always roll hits but it does also include the disrupt which is like units are wounded and they go in there and then you run in the campaigns where they potentially have smaller armies it feels less like oh i'm so [ __ ] i mean i know this one changed quite a few things yeah a disrupt is a kill yeah and you just you don't hold them over normally they might come back later or they might die or they might just sit there for a while yeah um but in this game it was just instant
death if you [ __ ] up and you don't have the shields for it yeah yeah and i mean don't get me wrong this scenario wasn't bad yeah i think if it uh if it wasn't like midnight yeah like we wouldn't have been like oh all right i mean because yeah he would have died i would have basically burnt this whole turn to keep activating him to try and at least get a few of your angels dead um but then you would have of course killed him but then i had this guy leviathan uh yeah he was basically going to start yeah and start running that way he i knew he was coming yeah and he ignores push and he has two damage and he but he rolls four white and in an automatic push oh cool um and then what's his versus this one roll three red right yeah or his gigantic dice either of them could be yeah each of them can roll the the gigantic die uh each time the leviathan attacks on an area containing a terrain element uh it gets destroyed each time the leviathan performs a gigantic attack i can spend one destiny token to reroll up to three r uh three purple and units disrupted by the leviathan are put on its board instead of in the infirmary so that that doesn't matter um so yeah that uh and he only costs one to activate with 16 health and uh they have the night and day phase so for the first four rounds you essentially had no range
um and then in the last four uh i had me i had no range uh but i mean essentially that that didn't affect me at all like because i had all of them here in the turtle right so that uh i don't know how much that would have come into play you probably shot my horses down um because they they there's no i don't know how i feel though about like all defense especially with the gigantic creatures because it's like you swarm them and it's like okay i'd much rather have more dice to roll than just a static two yeah uh because like they like because i know they have a lot of health and every other hero has like three or four but like your judgment i think it was your judgment he had 12 health and got to black oh okay well never mind that essentially equates that to the same but but then again these guys can't be can't be defended so it's like oh okay well i rolled shitty on my attack oh okay i got one attack you got one or two attacking one defense i'll put on this little scrub guy it's like oh god i just have to trudge through your [ __ ] weak people yeah and i'll meet you yep the meat shields and you just had to wait it out yep definitely made me play like more reactive versus yeah so it's just like okay turtle up
don't die right defeat the threats that are immediately at our doorstep and hold out yeah that's true it it's uh i mean it feels balanced i mean even like all of them have cool abilities the antichrist i could have spent a destiny to designate an adjacent enemy troop and roll a black if it's a shield then uh if it comes under my control nice so he just starts turning people and i was trying to get him in there um but he only has three health because immortal immortal does nothing in this scenario uh because it doesn't go into the disrupted area so he was essentially a three healther the one thing about the scenario that i really didn't like though is because i you have so many meat shields and so many ways for me to not kill your people with art which already have health on their own uh was the fact that you got reinforcements that was kind of the first thing where i was like all right i'm kind of done with that it took me three rounds to kill one to go one [ __ ] person and then oh hey more units it's like i don't get more units like half of my [ __ ] people are over here doing nothing so not a bad skirmish game i just never want to play it again so do you have anything anything else you want to add oh you think cool cool about joe navarro i mean i i don't hate it yeah it's not bad it's definitely uh uh i mean it's the one more game i don't
like oh cool i can do it yeah um but yeah good luck devin getting anyone else into this but no it's not not terrible yeah i like the feel i like certain streamline elements but yeah i'm not super huge fan of the miniatures because the setup was abysmal yeah um i like what do you think about do you like the fact that it's mystical like it's it's about legends so there are these beasts it's not it's not like real like historically accurate medieval yeah well i mean yeah i like this one that was you know mystical i mean and then they have optional scenarios that are you know real world grounded you know uh french and english i think a few others i think they're releasing a few others but yeah well yeah i i like the multiple aspects you can approach it either way it's like okay more grounded you know let's just you know move troops and fight and defend traditionally or it's like i'm gonna throw a giant flying by-headed beast at you yeah yeah that was pretty much what i did i mean he lasted i mean he's he's almost he's a great disrupter i mean you know when i have a giant defensive line with a bunch of small troops that's who you send yeah it's uh what was i gonna say yeah i i forgot she put him out here and then stressed me out and then approached with that guy and then had me in a bottle and then have me like two-pronged well that was the problem is like this guy because like they can't push people out of the way to move and he can't jump or anything like it was i mean basically my placement of him but yeah he uh
so hard yeah he would have eventually kind of gotten there the only reason he got in so quick was because i was able to fly into the sky and then it's pretty amazing yeah i mean that's essentially what i would have done uh because there would have been way more rounds to have him come in uh and basically have the four horsemen because i mean i mean the death i could just whenever i activate him i could spend an xp to heal nice so i could have uh kept him kind of going reactivate death over and over and over upside down yeah the big minis are bad ass yeah they are so cool uh and this is definitely a lot better than like hate ugh hate was hate was awful yeah um and then uh yeah so i mean it's like i could have i could have kept reactivating death and just keep healing the beast over and over but i will say one thing about the the cubes is i like i like the system a lot um but i also at the same time don't like how it's determined by the cards like i would have much rather had a static amount of cubes versus like oh yeah because then it becomes very i don't know lame because you have all these units and you want to fight and you want to use them but then it's like okay whether we get this round it's uh it's okay three that's not bad then two then three and then okay three
but it's like whenever the two rounds come it's like okay yeah i guess i guess we'll just do nothing uh and maybe this is more accentuated in a bigger battle with so many units because you can't activate them all so i feel like just a condensed streamlined game which this is this is not it at all so yeah kind of a letdown it's not horrible i definitely can see if people were like oh i love this game i'd be like oh okay yeah but oh the other thing i was going to say was there are so many scenarios that you you have to kind of trudge through games to figure out the good ones and i'd much rather there be less scenarios and them all be solid instead of just be like well okay let's set this whole game up and these can probably be glued but you have no way of storing them yeah at that point i mean if you want to do the whole foam cube business or like sections oh yeah hardcore with it yeah that's a little much um
these are too too tiny yeah which i like the tiniest for scaling like it makes them feel smaller compared to these massive things that's that's neat i just think in practice it's so bad yeah so yeah you have to set it up you have to play it hope the scenario is balanced and good chances are it probably isn't and then you just mark that one out oh yeah don't they do they have a mode where it's just like a point by system essentially probably there's so many different right like you can simply craft your own army yeah and then just go at it from there which is how the all the other war game well that's how warhammer works yeah that's how the the dog fighting star were x-wing it was it was based off a certain amount of points that you could spend to build your your set um but yeah i mean you could do that which i would imagine most people are doing that with this but they have a lot of scenarios and that are some are historically accurate others aren't and then you just have to have to just hope it's good yeah so i think at the end of the day this game is exhausting for me yeah and uh and that's that i mean uh you got anything else oh no i don't got anything else all right uh all right your game on a scale of one to ten what would you give it uh i don't know i don't know i want to give
besides making it smaller and i understand they want to make it grand and yeah feel big like you have a big army with a lot of guys we also didn't mention the fact that it has an rpg element not really you can have quests yeah like they have like npcs you can go talk to uh which is cool you never see that in a skirmish fighting game like the fact that you can have it yeah so how was the bread today right yeah there were there are buildings i mean there wasn't any in this one but there are buildings that can be destroyed people can like because you have the the uh um the insides of the building oh the inlay in light and then you have a building on top of that people can sit in there uh so that that's a cool idea there's been other kind of skirmish games where it's a war game we have heroes that move around and they can finish quests uh what was that one called rune wars that was a pretty good one but yeah you had heroes who could help in fighting but then they could also move on their own and complete quests and you got points that way yeah um and then so that that is an element of the game that is very unique i haven't seen that a whole lot uh but yeah i would never i would never set this up i would imagine that since our infantry since infantry get put on the on the three base say you could just glue these into a three base but there's another game i had called battles of westeros that was between it was game of thrones the skirmish game of thrones that one was a [ __ ] monster the setup too because it had bases they
had to put the minis and i just super glue them in and then they had little banners and oh man i got rid of that one pretty quick yeah even though that was a pretty good one because you had individual heroes that benefited um fantasy 5 actually released a uh song of ice and fire skirmish game and you had the different armies that you could uh which which probably is solid i've never played it um but it's kind of a warhammer thing like you have them on like a rectangular base and they fit all in like one thing oh yeah just move them all forward uh i don't think it's warhammer that does that you might be thinking about that must have been that yeah uh that i was thinking because i know rectangular bases were it's part of it so it must be the same yeah a lot i know a lot of like the ones that use a bunch of small units like to be real like war scale you know to move them out with your giant yeah yeah that's uh and you said you have to dress the part you have a monocle um i think we're gonna move this unit if we send the germans over here if we send the orcs that way then oh and uh let's see what happens in our blanks i guess they miss i guess they suck stupid execute them um artillery strike on that unit sir those are our own forces they have displeased me and then the people you're playing with are dressed up normal they're like who the [ __ ] is this guy christ but yeah uh okay you never gave your oh i'm like i'm torn between like i'm gonna say six or seven i don't know about seven i'll give it a
feeling six it's like i like the game and uh you know it's a nice condensed war game that doesn't have a lot of the things that i hated about other skirmish games yeah i know because i know i really hated i didn't like hate hate hate sucks i didn't like hate and what was that other hate board and [ __ ] was ugly as sick it was weird their minis were they were they were like buy our minis yeah pretty much actually yeah yeah those are definitely the best looking like just chunk of plastic yeah they really were um i was like look at this armored war pig you can see the chain link yeah like yeah that was it i'm like man i might keep this for the minis and i obviously did what was the one that we played not too long it had a lot of hexes and different sized units what was that one like i was oh oh man what was that called yeah i know what you're talking about because it was like d yeah they were like demons and stuff yeah and that one's i don't know i it was weird i couldn't get used to the demons it wasn't it wasn't great and then their campaign essentially made the loser like weaken and the winner got stronger so if you're already sucking and losing yeah you keep losing yeah yeah yeah it was like okay it was not great but i definitely know i know what you're talking about but i cannot remember the end of it though yeah that one wasn't great the best skirmish game that i have played is mythic battles pantheon which is uh
and i'll be able to get that because i backed mythic battles ragnarok and it's pantheon is everything greek mythology okay and you have very little units and you have a few major so essentially you have like three small units and then three named people and i think like a hero somewhere in there so you have a few gods and then you have you can have like achilles so you can have hades achilles and then some some troops okay and then you can either win by i think killing the opponent's god or you can win by gathering these tokens and i think you need the majority of the tokens and there's like three l on the board so you can go grab those and bring them back to your base okay and imagine the keywords and stuff that you like about this the combo and it's card based which is what i also really like yeah so how you activate units is based off the card so you there's a slight uh element of deck building okay in there that is so by far the best where i felt i think there's dice i've only played it like twice but i think there's dice but the dice don't feel the determining factor like it does in this one um so that's easily been the best and there's so much [ __ ] for it and then ragnarok comes out and it's norse mythology and you can combine them okay so you could have uh zeus versus odin okay did you play that at um i played that gun no okay so that hasn't released yet no uh pantheon is all out oh god ragnarok hasn't because i haven't seen it yeah okay a friend of mine in in town he owns it and i went over to his house and played it i might see if he'll let me
borrow it just to have you give it a shot yeah um but it's a storage hog like this [ __ ] beast it's insane but what you like from this uh is is in that but it's condensed you don't have i mean you have a board and then you just you still have units but man there's a not annoying to set up you have stupid yeah so that's been that's always that's been the only skirmish game that i'm like i need to get this and figure out how to store it um so you're sitting on a six yeah they're about 6.5 honestly that's kind of where i'm at too like between a five and a six uh so i mean it's it's average slightly above average for me uh it does a lot of good things i definitely don't hate it even though i've been kind of i've been more just eh like i've just been exhausted uh talking about it like you can definitely get the really cool theme in it even whenever i kept not killing your griffin you can just imagine them dog fighting in there like my grip my cocker just can't quite nip yeah at your griffin the cube system is innovative and really unique uh dice are annoying um but yeah it's just a lot for for me very little payoff at the end at the end of the day like if you were i mean the only way for me to play this which i i mean if someone was like hey like if you're like hey do you want to come over and and game i'll be like sure and then you're like i'll set up joe like if you didn't
oh you set up a small scenario that'll only take a couple hours sure right i mean like then i would i would play and i and i probably have a good time um but other than that no i never want to touch it again so oh i'll give it a six like i'm not pissed at it like some skirmish games where i'm just like [ __ ] this yeah so all right you got anything else nope cool well that's our thoughts on time of legends joan of arc let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful every time update is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you