Iliad Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
At number three, I have Iliad. So, this is the first of the Mythos collection by Bitewing Games. Uh, this is a two-player only abstract strategy game by Ryan Kitier, you know, one of my favorite designers of all time. And what you're doing in this game is that you are trying to complete rows and columns on this grid to collect tiles or or these kind of point scoring tiles on the edges of those particular rows and columns. uh if you have the highest value of player pieces in that particular row on column when it is completed then you'll get the best tile and your opponent will get the kind of the second or the next one or the other one. And what you're trying to do here is that you are trying to collect a whole set of these different types of gods. If you do that and your opponent doesn't then you you will win instantly. If you both do it then it will come down to point scoring. Um, so no, it does have this kind of chicken mechanism where you have to bet on yourself to be able to get them all. If you don't have that confidence to get them all, you might want to do a U-turn and really focus on not only blocking your opponent from getting the tiles that they want, but also obviously building up your points cash as well.
Um, so that you have an advantage in that realm of the of the victory. Uh, mechanism wise, so easy. And you know, all you do is you have, I think it's two tiles in your hand at any time. Uh, and then you're going to be placing that tile onto somewhere onto that grid as long as it is edgetoedge with another tile on the map. Now, the tiles themselves come in, I think it's five different strength levels. Uh, the five itself is obviously very powerful, but it does not have a special ability, and all the other tiles do have special abilities. So, I think the number one tile allows you to move your a tile of your opponents somewhere on that grid to another space. The two let you move another one of yours. Uh the three let you swap one of your scoring tokens with one from the kind of central reserve and the four allows you to force your opponent to flip over an adjacent tile but you have do to do the same meaning that those tiles are worth nothing. Um but I do like the way that you are each tile is fighting on two fronts. So of course you are contributing to the vertical axis as well as the horizontal axis meaning that you really want to exploit those higher higher power powered and higher valued uh tokens especially if you can make something score and then move that token again to make it to use that higher power power token in another line or column. So some good little tricks you can pull off here some good powers and you know it's a very cerebral game. um my and again gameplay-wise I think it's super well
super refined really. It's very clever. Um but for me it came across as a little bit too mathy. Uh you you look at the board and there's just a whole bunch of numbers thrown at you. You're constantly calculating and recalculating the values of not only your opponent but yourself in each line and column. Um, it's hard to just look at the map at a gaze and see, uh, you know, I need this particular god. Um, and I'm doing that there, but I'm not doing well there, but I might get that, but I might not get that. So, I don't know if I want that god yet, and so on. So, it's quite overwhelming. Of course, if you are more abstract gameatured, then you're probably going to get a kick out of that. Um, and it's definitely going to be a game where the best player will win. And I think it's again it's very cerebral, very thinky, and very head-to-head in the feel and vibe of the game. So, weirdly enough, um I would have probably preferred this game if it didn't have some of those powers. If it was just simply numbers and you tried to opt optimally place each number, but um yeah, I think the actual shifting of the tiles around actually didn't improve the game. I thought it made although maybe the richness of the game went up in terms of its complexities um I thought it made it a little bit messy um and it just kind of felt a bit fiddly moving things around and again recalculating again and again and again.
Um production wise it's a mixed bag for me. Um I'm I've got no idea why the publisher decided to go with these cloth mats rather than a board. Um, especially because this is like a game where you especially need the map to lie flat because of the way the tiles are placed. Um, and it's just like bumpy and all the tiles are just kinkedked up and don't quite lay flat and it doesn't doesn't look right. Um, and it's hard to reach in and pull tiles out or move them to other spaces. Um, also the artwork of the tiles, although, you know, they're clearly blue and red, it would have been nice to see more variety in the art style as well based on the two different clans that you are playing. It sounds like I'm giving this game a negative review or negative thoughts. I don't think it's that at all. I think it's more of a matter of um the game not being right for me, but me objectively liking what it does. But I would like to see and I know Kitia does this. I would like to see this game again but based or or doing without those special abilities or maybe making those abilities slightly different um rather than shifting tiles that have already been placed. I I didn't like that part of the game at all if I'm honest. But I know a lot of people are going to like this one and to be honest I thought I was going to love it. For me it was just decent. Uh that is Iliad at number