Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 35:42

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for brazil imperial this was uh portals one of portals newest games that they've released at gen con uh one that's well this is kind of in their wheelhouse this isn't so out of the realm i don't think they haven't i mean if you've played like imperial settlers like it it kind of has that ring in terms of different civilizations that you're building up um except it's tile based and a little bit uh well it's actually not i think about it it's kind of in the same ballpark but this has more of a sieve feel because of the actual tactile nature of moving around and building onto various uh terrain uh overall i think it's great i think it's i think it's pretty solid uh for a civ light game like you don't have to deal with tech trees or anything like that or people coming in attacking destroying everything that you own so it's like what's the point um of where i'm hung up though is like i don't know if i would always want to keep playing it you know it feels very limiting uh there's a couple things that were definitely high not really highlighted but that were more apparent to me on on a repeat playthrough than the first time uh but we'll we'll get to that what do you guys think i have so i have i have two glaring problems

um the factions are not even uh you're talking about the uh the actual player yeah and i didn't say this before the game because i wanted to try it out but the green factions are the weakest this is something that somebody i don't know it is the weakest player so we can't always judge it that way well i wondered initially if your player board was supposed to be the same color because they that balanced it out but it seems like every board is somewhat similar because you get different attack power different abilities different attack power and like yours are less attack power but they they're cheaper at least they're gold mine are higher attack power but i need science yeah to get them out which this game is very railroaded it's like oh when can i get science uh good question you can't unless you collect a bunch of resources you can trade for a minute you can trade for them or if you get lucky and it's like oh man lucky me there's a science that like i'm ahead of everyone it's very puzzly as far as like getting the right [ __ ] that you need but this wasn't so overpowered that i just felt like it was easy i also played my faction wrong that last time i think i took half the amount of resources that i was supposed to take because i didn't realize every time you you put somebody out that you got a resource i thought it was like the first time um but this power is just flat stronger than most of the green powers uh you're talking about like when you're saying powers the the the monarch yeah the monarch abilities so every time i i use i can use one combat card every turn for a gold or i

can use two combat cards for two resources or i can use three combat cards as a golden a science yeah over and over and over again which is very similar to napoleon's yeah um and i would say the two of them are balanced because of the flexibility versus the i'll grab the monarchs for okay uh yeah because mine well it was funny because i had my first era goal and i needed trading posts so i built those and then halfway through the game i was not halfway but like earlier in the game i was thinking wait a minute i get extra points for sawmills uh so luckily i was because i got the science from the amazon i was able to get the guy who let me build additionally so then i was like oh okay then i just pumped out sawmills real quick in one turn right so i should not have chosen one of these to go with the green board i don't think it would matter that's what i thought initially i don't think it actually matters because it doesn't say in the rule book yeah they're just interchangeable and i thought these were weak because that board was stronger but they all even up because i looked at it before the game started yeah like collect one science and earn one victory point for the first and second missions that you complete that's pretty decent it's not bad but it's also like here's my glaring issue with this is when we we saw it like well one my biggest negative and i hate this really in any game because a lot of games the players dictate they're not a lot of games but some games players dictate the speed but everyone's aware of that everyone's aware okay like at any given point someone could just like try and end it right now this game wants to have that but it

doesn't because no one knows where anyone is at any given point because these are completely random yeah so to have a hard stop like that on top of you don't know when the game is going to end and not have that one extra turn yeah a lot of games get right it's just like nope finish the round and the game's over that's very annoying um you know you got cheated out of the ability right because i didn't know he was going to end it so i i was building to i mean i was very close and scythe kind of works the same way doesn't it but you could see okay there's five stars there someone someone's gonna probably put a sixth one out yeah at any given point um you're you're very good at sight though and even true i'm fairly experienced at scythe and even whenever i played topher a while ago i had trouble seeing him ending the game because he got four four missions at the end if you're really really talented at it you can you can kind of push that yeah all the objectives are still very visible like i had no idea what i mean there's like eight of these except for your cards oh oh you're you're actually you only can get one star from that unless you're the black faction right right but so yes that's the one one piece of randomness but this is like you're building up towards that and you can build up towards it the entire game in fact my second and third one i could have realistically built out and then just been like boom boom and it's like i don't like the fact that there's both like either have these random and give everyone an extra turn in case because we were all relatively close like um to finishing our third era but it was like i had this finish before everybody did i just didn't flip it

done before everybody else i didn't flip it because i was waiting because i wanted to look like it was i was lagging behind and i knew that you were going to probably beat me if i let it go any longer so i needed to finish it right because i had the ability to be able to like i i renovated to get the gold and then i was going to build next turn because um i had that double build all i needed was two churches um so i could have double built the two churches out and then just ended it yeah um but yeah so it's it's really annoying especially in a civilization game when you're like the whole game is you building up to something and then someone's just like and it's over all right guys what do you think it's like uh i feel like i'm annoyed because that even happened last time like i was standing to make like five or seven points or something yeah it wouldn't have made a huge difference but but i was last to go and i was like okay i'm gonna end it and it's like oh okay that's just it and i definitely wouldn't have made that move if i hadn't known it was my last shot yeah because that was five points yeah exactly so i would like other more and i guess they try to compensate by being like no no you still get the score for each one you complete it's like woo one to three points like that almost it's like that's just come on like and on one side like i think that the combat is there are rewards for it but it doesn't incentivize it very heavily which i like personally and i i realized like after i ended that i could have moved up to that spot and boom boom moved into that gold

spot and taken it over right as i'm sure it was my last move and i was like [ __ ] i could have done that uh it would only been two points it wouldn't make that big of a difference but yeah um i will say one of the benefits and positives of this game is it does reward alternate play styles and very heavy sip games civilization for one it's like i want to go religion build okay i'm gonna kill all of your zealots so like basically if if you know someone's going heavy combat in the game in my experience which is not a lot like i'm not a sieve master but in my experience if someone's going combat you immediately have to like course correct to then start building your army yeah so you can defend yourself to do something else and it's just like the game's already long enough just found myself doing that in this game and it wasn't necessary at all oh building up your armor he's like oh [ __ ] somebody has a monarch i should prepare and yeah nothing happens yeah i took a combat heavy roll and i immediately took some some combat bonuses but my thinking behind that was i'm going to be spending these combat cards so i'm going to take a passive bonus yeah and not worry about which is smart because you just have an inherent just defense but you it could look like i'm building up this huge workforce but yeah of course i never deployed anyone yeah i only deployed units um because that's exactly what i needed like my second one needed three units on the map and my third one needed four units on the map so i just went unit heavy and i realized these are absolute ass because i picked the purple one it would have been that would have been disgusting for him because it's just gold gold gold gold all right they're all out yeah this one was like gold gold oh [ __ ] i need to you can very

with the right combination of cards which is surprisingly for there being multiple cards not that difficult you can lock yourself into having an easy one that's and that was my second negative on the game was the fact that it's not so much and the same thing is possible in scythe and a lot of other games um i was i was trying to quickly think because you can win tech wise i think you have to build space exploration and say if you win by killing everyone uh religion i think there's also and there's a [ __ ] ton of expansions for it um but all of those are known and everyone knows and should that okay this is the route to actually win in these three different ways here just because these are just so random that if the the two i get drawn for each era just oh man that's perfect like if they're just progressional while everyone else just happened to randomly get ones that don't really mix together they're gonna have a harder time they're not gonna have any edge or flow or any cohesiveness for their sieve that like and that happened with you in the last game your third one was had nothing to do with the other two so it's like you you do all this stuff throughout three fourths of the game then you have to now weirdly do some other stuff i think all the error three cards tend to be always a little off from what your first two are and i think that's consistent throughout the game because you always have to build something i needed three and four units for these two um the only difficulty was

i mean i guess so that's really the only connection because i needed two manufactured octagons which my initial thing i built the hexagon and i was like son of a [ __ ] that's on the octagon and then i needed two churches yeah but uh each of these required me to have units on the map one three then four yeah and i was like oh okay we'll just see how that goes and i mean one turned behind but yeah pretty much the clincher seems to be the uh if you get your third one out it's like who cares about the points it's really the palace you get to place out yeah um could be a significant amount of points maybe not and i will say on the flip side of things i think the benefits that you gain from manufacturing are i always wonder if those types of things and you if you seed into those early in the game that you're just going to run over everybody i think these cards are are equal to those for the most part if you get the right cards they can be very much more powerful or less powerful depending on what you get so you always have to pay attention to what's out um i mean the last game i had i needed plantations i needed a [ __ ] ton of plantations so i got them out then i got this palace out that made them worth more and then i got the sea dragon so i just had a never-ending supply of gold which is pretty much just the way you're going to clinch it yeah i mean i ended up winning that game but it's like i don't know it it seems kind of more turn-based like because turn order doesn't change

what they think just the structure of this game is odd to me the way that the hard stop the uncertainty and ending and then the fact that the player turned order doesn't change i feel like the tweaking any one of those would drastically help because it's not like i mean these are top deck and i mean yeah you gotta pay some for them some they can be free but it's like if i needed plantations i get those out and then you know brett buys one of these carts and then this comes out and it's my turn it's like oh well thank you it just fell right in my lap unless you were painting last time that's true unless unless i took a painting the last time then i just have to hope no one sees it until it comes back around in my turn yeah um brett what do you think um so from the perspective of a non-hero gamer it's not bad yeah it's it's definitely playable um second time through went a lot smoother but i also realized that again me and my limited vision is there's still too many rules too many options too many things i don't even know if i got reported my full score because i don't i'm not seeing all the different ways that oh yeah that changed that and that and then yeah the scoring is not super intuitive they have these different categories and then it's like it's like hey all right tell us what your palaces give you but those are in relation to manufacturing what but there's a manufacturing section on the scoring really i think the outliers are just how the palaces affect everything your cards

and if you have gold cards if you check those three things you're good pretty much um overall i mean like i said it's civ light i think uh i mean you you pick up whatever you pick a guy yeah a monarch or uh um some famous person in history you pick them then you uh just kind of build really how you want to it's very limiting there's not a whole lot of buildings there's um what is that two four six eight nine eight buildings and then cities which don't do anything except give you points um and that's kind of where i'm at it's like the the combat route i really there's just no point it's like you don't lose units they just kind of i mean like they pop off and then you deploy and then they just come back so it's really just kind of like a it deters you it's like okay well now to get those out you have to do the deploy but then you can threaten people and force them to take non-optimal actions and you can also if they scavenge resources if they don't even out their actions and they they haven't deployed units into areas where there are resources you can very easily take them yeah i guess that's just it for me it's that's never i feel like that that would be a trap for new players or you could get victory points at the end of the game if you if you there there could be a crazy four-player like mass movement and the last player could be like okay i'm gonna move all these things well maybe move two units because that's the maximum that you can do i assume you

could make two different movements with two people so you could take over two tiles which could just [ __ ] somebody but yeah it's like steal victory points from them and i and i realize in in uh the games that we've played um i didn't explore once in fact the only thing time i was gonna explore i was just gonna build on that um just for the two points uh but again didn't know when the game was ending so i didn't build there um because in my head and like because i i think i yeah i renovated and then i was like i could have built and just built onto here but i was trying to end the game as well so i deployed instead to get my fourth unit out to go the game's over cool so i wasted my my last turn without knowing it was my last turn yeah uh exploration is kind of whatever it's not super exciting it's like 18 different species and then a thing to fight for uh gold it's like oh whoa how old how exhilarating yeah there's not a lot to it last game i took that path and it paid off but i think that basically the first person to jump on it will let him have it right yeah there's not much competition because really the the mat the i mean yeah he got eight points from having all the species so that would have been deterred had anyone else just also started moving out there and taken them but this is a free movement every round so you might as well take it right it's also there's not much to have a point in deploying early other than getting a combat card yeah but i also think moving

and that's what i'm saying it's like new players might fall into the trap especially if they haven't played scythe if they're just leaving their resources out on the board it's like okay well now i'm just obviously going to go after like the one time i was able to get a bunch of science out but you couldn't quite get to and then it's like okay i just spent it all real quick yeah it's like okay well never mind because it's so slow you can't get over there to take resources um this is less predictable if we were to go into combat it never it hasn't happened has it happened once i think we did once you fought uh no i don't think so i don't think i no one's fought each other um i mean you guys have fought these guys like those experts in the expedition tiles but you were coming at me and i knew exactly why i had four signs there why wouldn't you uh but because you couldn't jump on it immediately it's like okay well i'm gonna make sure i do all these actions to burn those resources yeah and that since moving near someone is a free action you can just threaten someone for a reason yeah it seems like ever like especially well in combat it's more of just you just puffing your chest out you're not actually gonna find you have three combat cards then that could i mean depending on the units that you have that could look scary but because of that it's like okay so you're there like let's say you know you had a unit here and you're just like oh man am i gonna go take your take your gold i'm like all right i'm gonna deploy boom boom now i'm also a threat so then it's like okay i guess i'll take like even if you did take it like i just don't play any of my cards let you have it then i just come in because your turn's now over but even if you kill

that unit if i you get to use that gold beforehand that's worth it but because you have to move yeah that's that's the issue so then it just you just have to hope i can't fight you know fend you off um and i'm i know movement is after the action so if you could move before the action then it would be potentially that change at all right um yeah because you can insight scythe because it's like because you can do those the top and bottom action in any order it's like uh you know you you move into a spine then do the action that lets you spend those resources and i think this is topher and i have talked about like how a lot of designs lately are iterations of every other design like race for the galaxy is only an iteration of puerto rico yeah uh every ever stars of acarios is basically gloomhaven in space yeah and i think you know you can compare this to site like we talked about on the first game this this designer feels to me like they have something going for them i think they're probably going to go first design games as far as i know that's what's listed on bgg and i think this is this is a really great first game if it is there yeah for sure um i'd like to see what else they do because usually people's first designs are not not their magnum opus but well yeah sometimes they are elizabeth hargrave when they just do that yeah and then they're just like well or isaac childress well he designed some few games before that yeah but he's like glue haven't all right i'm [ __ ] i

admittedly really yeah um well that has him and rob davio and he has a bunch of people that are in on it it's not just him uh but yeah in terms of if it's a first designer uh it's solid i think a few more expansions uh would make this game very solid like right now it's pretty good uh it has it has the bones i mean basive is also not you know amazing it's just whenever you add their seven expansions that really grow it into a true like the echelon of civ games i'd like to see not having to follow the rulebook to set up a map i'd like to just see some preset maps that you can memorize and there's enough variables in there that it would make it even for all the players yeah so interesting yeah in terms of pre-designed maps i think it's not too bad at first i thought i was kind of off my own but then i was like well you guys are really like also equal equal distance away from each other uh also once again in terms of like player order the setup is also kind of weird it's okay randomize who goes first and then they get to pick first and if they pick the tile that gives them a resource and lets them go first this is like so whoever's going last just gets the [ __ ] end of the stick it's like wait why don't we wait i don't think so because like you can end the game abruptly so if you're the last player you have that advantage i guess

so in some ways like you took that card that i was looking at i was like that's the first thing i'm going to do and then you took that card but also like if you if you're towards the the last player count then yeah you can prematurely end the game yeah i think i think more of these cards um i would have something else that's also kind of strange is i wish because we're all relatively the same uh like civilization power i guess is my so whenever someone's in first era and then someone else goes to second you can also now go into second uh but only until someone does that i wish there were ways that you could build to actually it's like well i'm just more advanced than you like i wish for my third one it's like i wish there was a way for me to like actively start building churches you know before everyone else well first of all why do i have to wait till error three to build a church but that would be kind of neat give give you some diversity oh hey i'm different than you because now i have this ability that i have churches out before everyone else right i see why he didn't do that because of cards like this where it's just like then i really just run the board yeah but we're all relatively on the same playing field and it to me that's kind of boring yeah like what makes civ fun for me is kind of oh how am i gonna be different than everyone else yeah what is my civilization going to be like from what i understand of civ games though they tend to run what twice this length oh my god they're they're days long yeah this was uh

maybe an hour it says 100 minutes and i feel like we've gotten through especially this game i think it was under 100 minutes i think so too i don't actually look at the time but yeah i know after like a first place through and then like you play on yeah the game is very quick so if you have that itch for a civilization style game i think this is definitely one to grab because through the ages is very good yeah it's also very long and it's so much like civilization i'd rather just play the pc game yeah so it's like why do i have to play this um i haven't played the new clash of cultures uh but that one and through the ages were kind of like the board game equivalent of civilization uh so i think this is definitely one that people should check out it's less heavy lighter gives you that gives you that itch has a it has some variety i was gonna say decent but not really uh so yeah the variety it doesn't imbalance anything yeah um i think it's like it's like a weak version of asymmetric you know because we each have slightly different things but none of them are particularly powerful yeah they're not they're not broken they didn't like change the the course of the game um i mean the fact that i was able to ramp up sawmills and they gave me gold um i would have liked it if there were actual like i don't like the secondary abilities on any of these like i don't like the extra deploy i don't like the whatever paintings i

don't like the renovate doesn't cost anything i don't really like any of those now those are exciting or cool i would have liked it if you could have built in such a way that it's like like this guy this guy who gave me plus one building like if you could actually ramp oh you can renovate more uh areas it's like why are we so slow why is it why do i why can i only get resources back on one sawmill yeah uh again i think he wanted to make it simpler lighter uh so that's why these kinds of games it's like oh this is pretty good all right i'm done like i i don't know i don't really want to play it again yeah not that that means it's a bad game it just means it's showing me everything it has to offer that's fair so and the fact i mean i was only probably even in the race because i got the amazon first which then let me get the guy that built a lot but he's not i mean how is this guy useful by era 3 what does he do again he lets you build you can build plus one building paying its uh cost plus one resource but it costs a science to get and the only way you're getting a science is if you save up a bunch of stuff to then trade for a science oh okay so it's like he was only like he's hard to hoard resources like that well exactly and so it's like they make science so tight to get until error three and by that point the game's over yeah so or it's coming to an end so if i didn't get lucky with the amazon

then uh then i i do not view his ability as being as good if i had to save up for resources to trade for one science then spend that science on on this guy yeah uh so i don't know might be a little bit too tight as well for resources i'm not really for resources everything that's good is uh is a science and the science is a kind of a pain in the ass to get unless you get lucky and this guy happens to be you know over here by me and then i just go kill him but uh i mean you explored literally everything found every single species but then kind of just stopped there yeah it's like this one oh hey lucky me it's right next to somewhere i can build there's yeah i had an invest i was invested in paintings and manufacturing so much that i didn't have a combat card engine really yeah so i had no way to take anything out plus i didn't have a dragoon or whatever that third unit is the horse oh mines is called cavalry yeah so it's dragoon on green i think yeah yeah and mine i mean mine are super like they're they're worth a lot of points uh when i get them out but they cost science so i think again like two big box expansions for this would probably really do it justice gives you more variety in error cards gives you more monarchs gives you more cards

uh expiration tiles like just just more really i think would would help it out um more map placements like more whatever they're called like these things yeah i think could be could be neat and portal does a pretty good job about expansions yeah imperial settlers had like seven and empires of the north had has quite a bit yeah but yeah um you guys got anything else yeah you haven't mentioned theme at all you've been talking about as an abstract game the whole time uh i i mean there was actually a reason why i mean i i really don't this could have been called literally anything and i wouldn't have cared um but i'm also not a history buff like history's my was my least favorite subject uh i like very specific aspects of history uh this unfortunately isn't one of them um and i know but you also don't know anything i mean not many people do know anything about brazil exactly yeah american public school we don't talk about south america yeah if it happens in portugal yeah revolutionary war in civil war and that's it oh and how we beat germany's ass in world war ii that's right america we [ __ ] did it uh so yeah this and i'm i mean i'm sure that's a selling point for quite a few people they're like oh thank god you know uh i'm very surprised this hasn't been like oh i know why

uh stonemeyer didn't do it so that's why there was no flack on it yeah like because if he if they did this uh he probably would have just been [ __ ] on but for some reason no one's attacking portal games it's like this is well the designer is brazilian so that makes sense whereas the designer of viticulture is a white dude so it looks a little bit ickier in that sense yeah yeah yeah uh i think one yeah about these like people cranie's mom was telling me about them the person right here is actually a woman and it was kind of it she was a hero in some war but it was a woman who dressed up like a man to join the army and she was like a war hero and the gentleman over on the left hand side was he had an african mother and a brazilian father something like that but he was the first black nobleman in brazil which i think he's on one of the cards i think yeah but a lot of the people in it have yeah interesting backstories andre read much about it yeah no and so what's really cool about the the theme if you do like history is one they gave you a a separate rule book talking about a bit of history and then pretty much like almost every card like especially every monarch for sure but like the sea dragon card he's in here uh like not every card but um quite a few i was very surprised oh maria quittaria de jesus is her yeah uh

and i think it's really cool i think that's the route you definitely go you don't do some blurb or some flavor text to describe someone's historical significance and they do the same thing with a lot of these games as they kind of like smooth over like yeah they killed ten thousand like natives and probably way more than that actually but here's your benefit for playing their car takeover brazil religion yeah uh at the beginning they have a message to the players which i know viticulture world had that but it wasn't enough uh because i don't know that's that's that's a slope i don't really want to get into uh but this this is the route you take if people want to throw their fit about games just don't play the [ __ ] game and move on um now i just found it interesting that you know beautiful artwork um not non-intrusive but but very very nice yeah very thematic deep deeply thematic historical perspective but it had nothing to do with gameplay no not at all it was it was i mean i'm guessing i was going to say people's abilities might have had to do but now we read my dumb man wells and i'm like okay so why are sawmills worth an extra point and why do they give me gold they famously love their wood the brazilian wood yeah it may have had something to do with the actual person i think that guy for that dutch or portuguese i don't know uh portuguese only the ones listen to my thing only the ones in green are brazilian oh really okay

i don't those two are french i think he's uh portuguese these two are dutch i'm pretty sure queen victoria was not french yeah the same thing pretty close honestly this hand wave it western europe's pretty much all one thing yeah those are the uh one of those people is from it's a country that spain now encompasses i forget what it's called maybe you know that i don't know spain took them over they used to exist as a company maybe maybe they still exist no that it's like it's like attached to spain it says maurice of nassau that's on the back of this one your first three cane fields are worth three victory points and produce three sugar canes i can't remember because i thought originally that the colors were were connected to like what country they were coming from and they're they're mostly they mostly are but these two come from the same area i think oops western europe so maybe these are she's from spain castile so probably just western europe and he's that's this isn't the dutch right that's a dutch dutch arm yeah yeah butcher norway but norway weren't known for their exploration at the time yeah i mean in terms of you know the theme or even the title that was the the main reason why i didn't even look at it like i i mean i remember they were selling it was this in gutenberg and i was like oh brazil okay have you seen the board for gutenberg no i don't know why anyone

would buy gutenberg because it is just everything is brown yeah it's like the area is brown all the cards are brown the board's brown everything first good this in comparison the artwork is oh yeah this is very impressive bright and vibrant and yeah and and like like brett said it's not like overbearing like skatepark or summerskate or whatever that game was called where you're like oh my god my eyes here it's like man everything's just so clean because like what's also pretty nice about you just have all the boards or all the cities here which is actually probably one of the reasons why they're not going to do expansions because then you have to reprint these but you don't have to be like oh god what does that why does this cost again you know you can just oh hey that's it's right there it costs one of those uh but yeah uh i mean i'll be excited if they do make expansions that i'd give those a shot yeah this is just kind of another game that was made uh but let's get a one to ten would you guys give brazil i would say for gameplay seven but for the art and the way everything integrates i'm gonna bump that up to an eight overall eight all right all right good deal i'll go with a 7.5 7.5 um yeah i'm feeling seven as well i could see six if i if someone were like hey you want to play brazil again i'd be like no no i don't i'm so bored did we do that last month yeah so i think

i think overall for the the plays that we've had seven is pretty solid so so that's our thoughts on brazil imperial let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day this view hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day that's for you

Progress saved