Criminal Capers Reviews | Soda Smugglers, Pumafiosi, and Hot Lead
Transcript
hello everyone Carlo here from all you can board and today I'm reviewing the criminal Capers collection here from bitewing games so these three games were released in 2022 and these are review copies that were sent to us by the publisher so before I get into actually talking about the games and going to the reviews um I need to start with talking about a little bit of context and bias about uh sort of how I've approach these and just a little bit of context with our history with the publisher and this designer and that kind of thing after that I'll give you a brief overview of the trilogy kind of how these tie together and as far as the collection goes then I'm going to talk about them one at a time in depth we'll go soda Smugglers puma fosi and hot lead I will give you a kind of brief overview as to how they play and then tell you what I think of them and then to close out the video I'm just going to go through a few categories very quickly and tell you which game kind of best fits that category or that specific type of situation this review is not paid for in any way however I do think it's important to um you know mention that we have done paid preview content for bitewing games in the past so we did paid previews for Trailblazers Gussy gorillas and zuv vatas you can go check those out on the channel if you'd like um in general we've moved away from doing any sort of paid coverage on the channel uh any coverage we did previously was very very limited and when we did they were not opinionated videos anytime we've done any paid um coverage they were never for reviews we've only done a few paid previews for Kickstarter and in those we tried to stay free uh at all costs of you know giving our opinions on the games they were sort of just informative videos trying to tell you about the game and what you might or might not like and leave the decision up to you as to whether or not you wanted to back those
and the other thing is that um you know Riner Kenia is my favorite designer by far like it's the more games I've played by Riner kitzia and by other designers that Gap continues to widen and I realize more and more how much his designs uh truly are among my absolute favorites that being said he's designed hundreds of games and uh not all of them are are hits are are you know are all classics um you know some of there's plenty of his games that I have not enjoyed in the past so you know I'm still going to be as critical as I possibly can and you'll see by the end of this video that I don't unanimously love these games across the board um but I think it's important to to just give you that context with Riner Kenia and bitewing games before we get into these all right so now let's talk about this Trilogy and this collection so um just so you know when I say it's a Trilogy these aren't necessarily sold all as a package you can buy any of these individually um but they were kind of released at the same time on crowdfunding at the same time and they all feature this kind of obviously cap crime uh theme um they all have artwork by Paul K hon and again they're all published by Whitewing games all three of them designed by Riner kitzia uh soda Smugglers is a three to eight player bluffing game where you're basically trying to smuggle Goods um without a border agent kind of uh catching you in the act of smuggling Puma fosi is a two to five player uh sort of trick-taking and push your luck game about trying to sort of jostle for position in the hierarchy of a mafia and hot lead is also a two to five play player card game similar to Puma fosi um but this one is kind of hand management um kind of sealed auction or bidding where you're
playing cards face down and then when you reveal you're kind of uh taking cards from a display trying to investigate crimes so um other than the kind of artwork and the Caper theme and that sort of thing the main thing that I would say ties these together is that they all have this aspect of assessing value and most of your decisions come from looking at something in your hand or on the board and trying to decide you know how much something matters to you how much something matters to the other players and you know sort of assessing that value of things in order to determine what you're going to do and those values kind of change throughout the game so that's that's kind of how they're Loosely tied together um otherwise you know they're they kind of stand on their own so with that being said let's get into it let's talk about soda Smugglers which is game number one in this collection so in soda Smugglers again this is for 3 to eight players and the basic idea is it plays over uh a series of rounds depending on the number of players you're playing with every round one player is going to be the Border agent and all the other players will be Smugglers with their Five Card hand they're going to take three of those five cards two of them are going to be face down they're going to place face down in front of them as their luggage cards which is the luggage that they're trying to bring through and then the third card they're going to place in front of the luggage which is going to be uh their bribe so that's also going to be face down when they place them then the other two cards are going to get discarded when everyone has made their selection everyone is going to flip their bribe cards face up the Border agent is basically going to have a chance to accept uh bribes from any of
the players so if you see you know a bribe might have one or two or three bottles you can take that bribe gain those bottles and then that player is going to be able to sort of be let through and whatever they had in there they're going to flip their cards over and whatever was there they're going to take those uh bottle caps as points and then they won't be able to be inspected or arrested for the rest of the round um then you can in insect you for the number of inspect tokens you have you can choose any player and then pick one of their specific face down suitcases you get to flip it over and see what's there and then once you get to your arrest tokens you can choose to arrest a player for each of the tokens you have you can arrest a player who hasn't been inspected yet you can arrest a player that has had one of their suitcases arrested uh inspected pardon me it's really up to you how you decide to play that so the round's going to kind of play out in this way and then you know you're going to go clockwise around the table the next player is going to be the Border agent and again most points at the end wins so that's basically the way the game works there's also a little optional module in this game where you can basically have these event cards where every round there's going to be an event that will kind of change up the rules a little bit and we'll just tweak uh what's going on there so uh this gets compared a lot to sherff of notingham um and rightfully so because again you're trying to smuggle something past um someone who's trying to basically catch you in the act of of Deceit um I like this quite a bit more than Sheriff of notingham for a couple reasons one being that sheriff of n uh felt like it was really always encouraging you to be honest um that seemed the easiest route to Victory Sheriff of Nottingham also took a lot longer than I'd like soda
Smugglers all of these games actually play in about 15 to 20 minutes but soda Smugglers yeah I would say about right around the 20 minute range um and it's a very social game uh you know everyone at the table the times I've played it has you know been smiling been there's been a lot of laughing a lot of trash talking a lot of people trying to say like oh don't worry you should be going after this player kind of thing um there's there's a lot like here that being said the decision space the more you play it like it's it's not a very deep complex game you know once you've played it you know two three four times you've probably seen all there is to see and that's not to say that the game doesn't you know have any value beyond that point some of my favorite games I've played hundreds of times and are ones where you feel like you've seen everything after a few plays but if they're good enough you just keep going back to them over and over and over um you know Soda Smugglers has some aspects where you know because the points are all open information you can see who who's in the lead who's falling behind so you kind of know who you might want to Target um who you might want to arrest uh or that kind of thing and one thing I really like there there is some depth that starts to reveal itself over more plays um for example let's say you know you're far back and you're you know you're not one of let's say there's two other players that are kind of competing for the lead and you're kind of you know maybe you're in last that sort of thing you can be really bold you can try to you know bring in a lot of Contraband you can try to smuggle in a lot of soda because chances are you know you're not going to be targeted by the border agent they're probably going to try and you know sniff out the players that are in the lead um so that they have a better chance of winning so you kind of get a Target on your back uh the more you get
ahead early and that kind of thing um but keep in mind that you are kind of at the mercy of your cards like there really isn't a ton of variety in the cards in the deck because you know again the cards will have anywhere from zero to three uh bottles of soda on them and ultimately you know you're stuck with what you get in your hand so out of your five cards that you're dealt maybe you don't have any that have zero or maybe they're all zeros and ones so you can't even really smuggle even if you wanted to smuggle a lot in there so it's not it's not the type of game where you know the best player is always going to win and that's that's fine I don't say that as a negative at all I know for some people that's very important for me especially for filler games I like it when everyone has kind of an equal chance to win I like when games have a certain degree of Randomness when they're just quick playing uh you know filler games something light like this um overall I enjoyed my time with soda Smugglers I don't think it's something I'm going to be you know clamoring to come back and play often it's not something that I'm going to necessarily be keeping in my collection long term um but that's maybe just a matter of personal preference I think it's a well-designed game and a good alternative to something like Sheriff of Nottingham especially if you found that that one was maybe um you know took too long or you're looking for something that uh plays well at like better at higher player counts um I'd say three and four players is okay for this game but I'd say five six seven is probably the ideal range four is still quite good I don't know if I'd really care to play it with three um and eight and even seven might be a little much just because you know there's going to be more time like the game will take a lot longer to go through everyone's turns um but yeah that is soda Smugglers so now let's talk about Puma
fosi so Puma fosi is for two to five players and this is kind of a trick-taking kind of push your luck game that plays over three rounds so uh it has a deck of numbered cards numbered 1 through 55 um at the beginning of the game every player is going to be dealt three cards that are going to be in their hand and then they're each going to get seven more cards that are going to be in a face down deck there's going to be a kind of hierarchy that represents this Mafia and there's going to be cards there's going to be a negative3 card um and then there's going to be one card each from numbers 1 through 10 except there is no four and no nine and the idea here is it's trick-taking but without suits so you're going to take turns playing cards they're going to be face up and once everyone has played a card the second highest card not the highest but but the second highest card is going to basically win the round so the other players will just discard their cards and set it aside and that second highest card will be placed somewhere in that hierarchy you're either going to place it next to an empty slot for one of those numbers or you can place it next to a slot that already has a card next to it as long as the card there previously is lower now what's going to happen wherever you place your card if you place it next to a card that's already there it's going to bump that card down um and you're marking the cards when you you know put when in the hierarchy you're putting one of your player tokens there to show who owns that card basically which person is in the mafia there when you get bumped down you're going to get a negative Point um and there can be this cascading effect where you get bumped down once and you get a negative point but that ends up in a row
that already had a card so now the another one gets bumped down and another player maybe gets a negative point so every time you're getting bumped you get negative points um each numbered slot Can Only Hold one card except for the number three slot at the bottom that can hold an unlimited number of cards and so at the end of the round all the cards down there will get3 three points and then for the other corresponding numbers you know the players will get points based on which cards are in which numbered slots and then you're going to carry that over and you're going to play three rounds that way and the player with the most points at the end wins so that is the basic premise of the game um I'll start with what I like about it one thing is I like the fact that you're playing um where the second highest card wins the trick I think that's pretty interesting and I haven't really seen that in any other game um I haven't played a ton of trick d games so I don't know if it's necessarily entirely unique but for me I haven't seen it done that way before thematically the reason is that you know you don't want to be the the mob boss with a Target on your back because you'll either get arrested or you know a rival a rival mob Mafia will come after you kind of thing so you want to have a you know a prominent role in this Mafia but not you don't want to be the leader necessarily with a big Target on your back so I think that works really well um the fact that you always have three cards in your hand to choose from gives you a little bit of selection but it's not too much I think this is a pretty it can be a pretty thinky game um more than hot lead which I'm going to talk about in a moment which where we have a bigger hand of cards so I think the choice to have three cards in your hand with you know your deck in front of you where you don't know what else is there yet kind of helps move the game along at a good Pace it's of the trilogy it's definitely
the thinkest one here um and the one that maybe takes the most plays to kind of wrap your head around um there's also an optional module here that you can include where you basically have these other tokens there's like a machine gun that can increase the value of one of your cards there's a bulletproof vest that will prevent you from losing points when you get bumped down the hierarchy um there's also a notebook and a wedding ring I won't get into what those do but um they add some interesting wrinkles to the game and and uh those I I do recommend playing with especially once you've gone past maybe your second or third play that kind of thing um so I found the ideal player count for this one is probably three or four um this is even though it goes down to two players I don't think it's a game I would care to play with to um and with five I think it would still work fine but I just think it would take a little bit longer so I think three or four four is probably the Sweet Spot although I think five is probably still still pretty good it's a sort of an updated version on a game that was previous previously released I believe in 2004 called rooster booster um and this has kind of been redeveloped and re redesigned a little bit so um I enjoyed my time with pum FOC a fair bit um I would say similarly to soda Smugglers I don't think it's a game that I necessarily feel as a mustone for me I don't think I'm going to be the one to request to play it but I did enjoy it more than soda Smugglers and I think it's a pretty novel unique take on trick taking and card playing that I haven't seen I think the way that that hierarchy works is interesting um and you know there there's some interesting choices too where when you go to play a card you can kind of you know sometimes when if you're the last player to play and you
already see all the cards that have been played sometimes you can determine whether you're going to you know win the trick yourself you're going to play the second highest one or you might not want to win it based on the cards you have in your hand you might be able to play you know a really high card card which will make one player win the trick or you could play a low card that will make a different player win it so you have a decent amount of control sometimes in terms of who you're getting to actually win you know win the trick get that second place so I feel like it's one that the more you play you start to kind of understand the strategy and the depth of the game and you start to have a little more control you should at least give this one a try to see what it does that kind of sets it apart um especially for someone who's designed so many games to have something like this that kind of feels fairly unique is uh is quite impressive so um yeah that is puma fosi and now let's talk about the third game in this collection here that is hot lead so this is of the three I forgot to mention previously about soda Smugglers that was also kind of a re-implementation of a of a German game that had a very limited release in 2019 hot lead is the only one from this collection that is an entirely new design from Riner kitzia so this isn't uh you know piggybacking off of anything or reiterating off of anything he designed previously so similar to Puma fosi this is also for two to five players uh this one takes about 15 minutes to play and the idea it also has a numbered deck of cards from 1 through 55 similar to Puma fosi but in this one you're going to be dealt 11 cards each from this deck uh you're going to have them all in your hand right from the start unlike in Puma fosi so you're
going to have all these 11 cards in your hand ranging with different values and you're going to be shuffling up this deck of I believe they're called investigator cards you're going to be shuffling them up and for each based on the number of players available in are playing the game you're going to flip that number of cards from the deck each round um and you're not going to this is kind of a mixture I would say between the second phase of for sale and six NY where you're so you're going to put these cards face up that are on offer everyone is going to pick one of their cards in their hand put it face down and then once everyone has picked their card you're going to simultaneously reveal the cards the highest card is going to get the topmost cards so in other words the one that's closest to the deck the second highest value will get the second card that's closest to the deck Etc so you're not necessarily playing the highest card to get the best card you know the one that's closest to the deck might not be the best card you're trying to you know try to determine which card you want you know the cards out there might not all hold the same value for all the players because the way the scoring works is your the cards that are these investigation cards basically there's five different colors each corresponding to a different crime so there's like you know Grand Theft Auto and like fraud um and things like that and you're collecting these cards and you get a certain number of uh you get some bonus points at the end of the game if you collect one of each color you also get bonus points if you get uh three of the same color but once you take a fourth card of a color you immediately have to lose all of those cards from your possession you just get rid of them they go straight back to the box so sometimes you know players are
playing cards in a way that they're specifically trying not to take a card of a specific color because they know that if someone else takes it that player is going to lose a bunch of points so again I I I really like how the kind of values of these things are changing throughout and you're trying to assess out which cards to play at what time you know what I like a lot about this too is it kind of for a game that plays so quickly it mixes um a decent amount of strategy and tactics I use the word strategy lightly because it's such a quick filler game that it's not like a grand strategy but what I mean is because you get all of your 11 cards at the start of the game you know depending what you you can sort of form a plan you know again these are numbered 1 through 55 so you might have you know the one the three the seven the eight you know a bunch of the low cards and you might only have like a 48 as your highest card and then the next highest card is maybe a 25 or something so you might be playing in a certain way thinking I really have to save this this one high card for when I really need it and how am I going to you know what am I going to do with all these low cards or you might have the opposite you know you might have a bunch of high cards not many low ones so you can kind of form a plan based on that kind of you know the the 11 card hand that you have at the start you're only going to play 10 Rounds though so you're not going to play all the 11 cards which is also a smart choice because even in the 10th round you're not just automatically having to play you know a card in your hand you still have two cards to choose from so you still have a choice in the last round you're not just forced to play the last card you have left sort of thing so I think it feels like a very um trimmed
down very finely edited refined game which for viewers of the Channel people who have watched this channel for a while you know that's something I really really appreciate it's one of the things I look for most in games is games where it feels like all the fluff has been kind of cut out um and it's just been kind of distilled down to like the essence of what makes the game truly tick and it feels like they've kind of struck gold here with hot lead so this one comes with two small modules in it one being these um back alley cards uh which are there's two different types of cards but basically um there's informant cards that will when you flip them you might have you know I mentioned before that you have like the cards sorted from the deck down um if you flip these informance cards they basically get added to uh a certain color so you might actually have an offer that has you know two three cards or whatnot um so it's just basically adding to the you know number of cards that you might end up getting from that type of color and it's kind of sweetening the pot sometimes where you might want uh more cards or it's kind of making certain things more or less valuable and then there's the dead end cards which are just negative points ranging from I believe neg3 to7 and sometimes those get added so maybe now that you know offer in the second slot it might have that red card you really want but it also might have like a number a negative3 card so that's one of the modules and the other one is these uh I believe they're called investigation stars and those ones are basically they're very simple uh it's just the first player to reach two of the same color uh card or crime in their possession gets one of these uh Sheriff Stars at the end of the game they're
worth Five Points each so the modules are super easy to incorporate um and I think once you've played the game once or twice like you should definitely incorporate both of them I think they both um add a lot of you know they add a lot to the game without really complicating things much I think one of the smartest things about the game is the fact that you know higher cards aren't necessarily like inherently better than low value cards it's all about again assessing what's out there what you have left in your hands what the other players have collected and what they may or may not want and so even though it's such simple rules and every round you're playing simultaneously there's basically no downtime um you know you still have difficult decisions to make in terms of which cards to play at what time and as far as player count for this one I would say it's almost similar to almost the exact same as Puma fosi I don't think I would really care to play it with two I've played it from every count from three to five I think it works really well at all counts three or four is probably the Sweet Spot similar to Puma fosi um but I would happily play it with five any day as well so now that we've talked about them all let's go through a couple of quick categories here and talk about uh which one of these stands out most in those so um which one is the most social game uh that one's a no-brainer soda Smugglers if you're looking for let's say like an icebreaker type game or you know you want to just get people talking get people laughing that kind of thing um you know Soda Smugglers is definitely the the standout for that um which one has the most replay value that's a really tough call um just between puma fosi and hot lead I
think hot lead has you know because of how quick it is and how difficult the decision still are I think this one has a lot of legs similar to something like for sale and six NY where even though it's you feel like you've seen everything there is to see within a couple plays because of how quick it is and how involved you always feel because of the lack of downtime um it feels like something that's easy to come back to and you want to play over and over however Puma fosi definitely has the more more depth it's a more intricate game and I think you know your 10th play of this you're still going to be figuring stuff out and and coming across things you haven't seen before or making clever plays um whereas in hot Lead You Know by your 10th play that you're not going to necessarily be seeing new things even though you might still be enjoying the game so it would probably be a tie between these two in terms of which one has uh you know the more more replay value which one is the quickest to play no question it's hot lead um on the boxes so does Smugglers and Puma fosi say 20 minutes I think that's pretty spoton hot lead says 15 minutes I think that is even even high I'll say right now I I made note of this the first time I played with a group of three players so it was the first time all three of us had played the game before I looked at the time when I took the game out of my bag from the time I took it out of my bag set up the game taught the rules we played the game and had it put away I kid you not it was 12 minutes now I've played you know hundreds of board games at this point and I think there I can only count on maybe one hand how many games I've played that can be played in under 15
minutes and the other ones are like nowhere near as good as hot lead like it's not even close what this manages to accomplish in less than 15 minutes is pretty much unheard of in this hobby um I I try I'm trying not to be too like sort of hyperbolic here because you know this isn't the greatest game ever designed or anything like that but I think it really achieves something that is tough to do in gaming um whether it's a a board game that actually has a board and bunch of components or just a small quick playing card game so I think it's really worth highlighting that aspect of hot lead so my final verdict here um as a collection I think there all solid products I think the amount of um I should say to the the artwork in here in all three of them is really really enjoyable it's it's stunning there's some overlap there's kind of some characters that you'll see across um you know two or three of the games the component quality is really really high I mean you don't really find many filler games these days that play this quickly that have such simple rules that look this nice and have such a nice kind of tactile feel to them um however it does come with a cost obviously like these types of games games in this kind of uh level of complexity and play time usually you're in the kind of you know $10 to $15 range maybe upwards of $20 I'm talking Canadian dollars here um and these ones are kind of around that I think these are all priced right around $25 so it is sort of maybe a more premium Deluxe uh filler game so if cost is really important to you uh money is tight that kind of thing and you're just looking for the cheapest games out there
for filler games then these might not be for you but you know if you're okay spending the extra few bucks like you definitely get your money's worth because everything in here is again really really nicely produced and it gives a nice tactile feel and helps you just feel a little more immersed um in the theme as well it really helps the theme kind of pop and come to life so for me personally if I had to rank these hot lead is the one I enjoy most uh by quite a quite a fair margin I I would say it's not even close hot lead is one that um I mentioned again that these are review copies um and I will be fighting Dylan and bradden to keep this one in my collection um and if I lose that fight then and I will definitely be buying a cofy for myself at some point one day because um again it's just a really really good filler game that plays so quickly I like pretty much everything about it and I can see myself playing this many many times over the years next favorite would be Puma fosi um it's a conflicting game for me because the level of thinkness and teaching new players like I feel like it's one that I'm not going to always want to be teaching to new people because the more one person has played it like the the difference in experience the Gap in experience is going to sort of come to fruition like the players that have played it most or who are best at it are probably going to win a lot more often and as I mentioned before you can kind of fall behind and feel like the game is out of your grasp so I think if you like this game a lot it's going to have a ton of replay value if you kind of if you just think it's like a pretty good game and you're not going to play it all the time um it just falls into a space where I don't feel the need to maybe necessarily keep this one in my collection going forward but I would
happily play it any time soda Smugglers would round out the bottom um I still enjoyed soda Smugglers a fair bit it's it's a good game I think it's welld designed this one I think is just the least for me like this is the least this is the one that hits the least amount of um the notes that I enjoy in a game um mostly because again I'm not a big fan of bluffing games and I also find that just overall the depth of this one isn't quite there in the same level as these other two games so that's it that's the criminal Capers collection um I hope you enjoyed this video I hope this was helpful to you um please let me know your thoughts on these games do any of these stand out to you have you played these uh if so I'm curious to hear which is your favorite or um you know do your thoughts align with mine are you completely on the opposite end of the spectrum um and I want to thank bwing games again for sending us these review copies if you have any questions about any of these games feel free to leave a comment below and I will get back to you as soon as possible otherwise as always thank you so much for watching and we will see you next
time