Skip to main content
Loading video...

Guild of Merchant Explorers: Discussion

Transcript 21:33

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlike and we are doing a no run through review for The Guild of merchant explorers which actually has oh trademarked trademarked TM good deal just in case anyone else wanted to steal this fantastic name that is it does fit on the box it does that's what it does and it's actually funny enough I actually really like this cover um it is kind of like beige immediately but I don't know I I mean I like the the banner and I like the the little it's like hey that's that's what you're doing you are a guild of merchants and you explore that's true so this was a game uh I have a hilarious story about this one it's really not all that funny but oh my dead mother uh so take that as you will um oh boy if there's a story I love hearing yeah it's it's the one where she was massacred uh sorry so uh Gen Con this this past year I went to AEG and this was kind of just on display and I immediately just boom it's not even and there was another game that came out called wormholes and one of the guys I was working for the company I was like hey you wouldn't explain wormholes to me and then he was and I think he could immediately kind of like tell I checked out uh because it was just kind of a whatever light gate Gateway game and I was like I'm not interested at all

and then so I hide him like so what about this one he's like oh okay so this gave my like a lot better and he like immediately sells it up and I'm like all right special powers and uh like Q placement different maps all right I'll give it a shot I think there's a lot a lot of people's like surprise games of 2022 because that title does not do anything for anyone yes but I think I personally think the title does it more Justice than it deserves uh well I mean it whenever but like if you were to like think of games like the Guild of merchant explorers it's like really the generic genericism of generikia yes I guess yeah yes yeah the game of placing things and doing stuff yeah and like if you do that too where it's basically it's like an X of X and X is right and it's like instead of a short title like four yeah yeah and so it was like a mouthful and there's this there's that stigma of like Euro games or trading in the Mediterranean it's like God I mean how how lame can we get however I think this game is quite nice I thoroughly enjoy it what do you guys think it is Pleasant I like Trucking around the map I like um trying to maximize what you're given basically um I will say the only thing deceptive about it is I don't I don't really see why you needed to name it Merchant like you make the theme up in your head you're like how do you make the trade

routes yeah and you're collecting money yeah yeah I guess it could have been the Guild of explorers or Traders yeah or yeah if you want to be real picky about it but no it is a it is a pleasant little little yeah it doesn't overstay it's welcome like yeah very nice light enough and short enough that it works well yeah like public objectives to just kind of race four be the first one to do and it's like hey you know what if multiple people get it you all get them the most points that's always nice that's pretty much it and each map has its own deck of of objectives and there's there's not just the three there's like I don't know six or seven per map right so there's always three that are gonna be out and it's just like yeah they're they're there it's enough thought that like I don't feel like you're going through the motions when playing right but it's nice right what do you think you like it I agree um I did play it a few times before um and the first couple of times was like just doing through motions just picking up stuff I'm not getting what I'm supposed to be doing really um it was so light and simple that I didn't even think about it but this time I was like okay now I can see why I'm putting that there and why I want to fill in this area um for looking for the future and these overpowered things that keep coming up but they're so limited in how they can use right very well designed I think

that this game was better designed and play tested than comes out in the final playthrough because I think you know so if these are for each map there are different objective cards because that has to do with the placement on the map and that's the kind of thing where this looks simple and cartoonish but there's a lot of thought put into each map and the number of hexes and the arrangement of the lines based on what the movements are no exactly that's and that's because the game comes with I think three eight double-sided Maps so four so four different Maps Okay um but then an expansion added I think two two more so you have um six different maps that you can play on now of course everyone plays on the same map whenever you're going through but like can I see your thing real quick like obviously it's it might be immediately apparent but like at a quick glance in order to be like no yeah you're like that's the same because you've got a more a lot more grasslands down in the corner right yeah but for the first glance yeah the same color scheme so yeah yeah I got it and it's what's really fascinating about that is because Brett and I had just played this uh the other day and then we were playing this one on the we start we played it on the uh avena map avenia map and then we played on acon hey uh uh his Island and Akon's a rapper from like the early 2000s just in case anyone oh didn't get

that very lame joke you're older than I am but what was really nice is it was just like deceptively different it wasn't like you you didn't need to be like wow this is so radically different but as you're playing you're just like oh yeah I am having a little bit more difficulty getting to certain areas than I was last time or easier or easier for certain objectives yeah and here's how you know I think these maps are really balanced even though yeah you kind of play relative obviously you play the same way it's the five different drains my score was the exact same each time uh on both Maps which I thought was quite humorous yeah I but yeah overall like what do you guys think of the if this game didn't have the individual like unique player Powers I probably would kind of be like yeah too limited mm-hmm but what do you guys think of the the player powers I like it I like it's nice that they're all busted that way like we all have our own um it makes it more fair but like we're all able to really do something right yeah it adds an asymmetry but there it's not a consistent asymmustry so it's not like I can study your powers as your player and figure out how to get it right whatever comes up yeah and you know at one point whenever we try to eat whenever we use them you should pick one yeah and I like the fact that you get two whenever the air comes down you're like oh like the first one that came out I'm like ah ah I could okay I could use this one here uh but which one's gonna

be better in the long term yeah uh and then how can I build knowing that that's coming up in the future yeah and I guarantee my last one I got where it was a continuous path of mountain in spaces that that probably was what sealed the victory in this game because I was like all in the mountain regions and these happen to be with like about mountains and I'm like how am I like you only get the place in one mountain spot yeah like how am I gonna fill in this region over here oh it's just it's so nice because there's a game that came out a few years ago called Voyages of Marco Polo I don't think you've played that but the stick is is a it's a general dice work replacement game but it is touted as almost in my opinion the best example of a uh asymmetrical player Powers they're all broken and it's in that idea like The Incredibles of like if everyone's power is broken then none of them are broken right because you're sitting there and you're like [ __ ] you can do that yeah and then but then you're like looking at mine and you're like what the [ __ ] you can do that and we're all looking at cats like what I wonder what this is no it's not as far as that game because that game is more complex than this but these just kind of do that yeah and it's really neat and I'm always intrigued like oh man what's yours and we I mean we say they're busted and they're Godlike and they're not really no but they're like two to three times what a standard move is yeah because it's like hey I mean literally the only Mountain one you get I mean theoretically if you use the two

any adjacent yeah but if you don't use it for mountains you only can place one mountain well I literally have an ability that gives me four continuous Mountain spots yeah uh it's just so cool um what is kind of weird to me though about these is it is just a shared deck and I almost would have liked it to be tiered based off eras I don't know if you guys agree but I kind of were like hey here's your level one era um and maybe that I don't know if they maybe they tried that and they couldn't figure out a balance of like do we have arrow ones being less less powerful I would have to assume that by the time you got to like era three they're like everyone's sweeping yeah I don't know it might just take the fun out of it like when it's too easy yeah yeah that's true because especially if it's too easy and everyone is it's nice to see your friends win but also when you're playing a competitive game you're like stop that yeah like error three everyone's just like right take on all remaining cubes for them wherever right all right no I that's probably what happened because they would have had to do it in a way where they get increasing and more powerful because by Era three it's not popping off all the time right so it would need to be really powerful hey cover a whole region yes but I think that's that's right that it would be like okay obviously everyone's doing like that would be annoying if that was like what they went where it's like oh man look at that that's how many people oh I won points is that what I got 30 yeah every turn yeah yeah so so yeah but I

that's kind of what I would initially think is hey era one is Arrow one abilities but nope it just I mean the fact that they pops off more is better than an individual era specific power because the error one is going off what do we say four times yeah that is nice it definitely helps right for sure but I mean it's the Trap of Randomness which is somebody could get something amazing somebody else could get something kind of weak yeah and then you just have to figure out how to make use of it in the future yeah and there's always a way to do that because I think that there are the other ones that I've seen have all been fairly well balanced yeah you know like the one Explorer five regions but it has to be in a continuous line it has to be only these two types like that's huge but limited at the same time yeah I mean and also like similar to mine but still slightly different this is only four uh four regions so minus four in any single region oh that's cool I didn't even see it so yours is limited to mountains mine was mine was similar to your arrow one of explore continuous path of up to four mountain and or C spaces oh Mountain RC okay but so it's Mountain C but it's four spaces mountains is more valuable than deserts right um but yeah I think I think with this game being as a surprise hit as it is I I mean they already made like a special expansion that had that adds uh uh specialized like special rules based off the maps like and then they also

have uh other rules that add like crystals on oh other other Maps and also this is one of those games that because you can go get treasure yeah um the one they're limited yeah and this is one of those games that I don't mind if other people top deck you know where it's like oh man two coins yeah okay because it's not that big of a deal yeah none of them none of the treasures are that great yeah but they like I think I got up to a few points I might have been this game I had eight eight uh villages out so that was like four points from that I think I might have gotten like six six points out of my end of game scoring yeah stuff um but like 10 but I just happened to I got a whole whopping one for my cities for your oh you're only just for villages Yeah Yeah well yeah I mean because also it's their their additions it's not like this all or nothing it's like yeah you get a coin for every Tower you go to but you also went out and got three towers so that was you know uh 24 points and only one of them after I drew that oh really yeah yeah so it's like this that's kind of I also think the idea of villages increasing in value this is interesting that's yeah that's a good bonus because initially you would think the opposite like they should diminishing value but it's like well it's like do I want to build a village now it's like yeah you probably should because you're not going to get as far

otherwise yeah the earlier you do them the more valuable they inherently are so the less coinage you get right we'll say I and I think on the other end is um as you have the opportunity to spread outwards you're going into more foreign lands so the goods are going to be oh Richard oh man look at you putting some theme in this theme I freaking love Geography okay I love it I I love the it it's not based on history it's like it's so I was like this is my favorite world uh agon yep oh it's not even a c I said Akon like an idiot you did I thought you just said no it's aegon uh egg on the Conqueror we all known so yeah like I it's here's here's the other thing though this is kind of a weird no it's not it's not a negative because it works but this game should have been uh flipping right well because I know we talked about that but it's like I'm gonna call it an I'm gonna call it a negative just not a huge one okay I'm just picking up the cubes and not touching the other stuff right because you almost I mean it's just as easy as doing this but you can't because you have the trade routes and you have little treasures and yeah I felt like we should have had like little tweets yeah if everything about the cubes was a dry erase Mark I could see that working and then yeah and then you just clear the board and leave all the marks yeah uh yeah and I get it because they wanted it to be like obviously it would

still be annoying as a as a flipping right because you would have to permanently Mark out like the ruined space but then you'd have to erase around it but it still would be quicker just going all right those are all gone but yeah sometimes you're sitting there with a bunch of tokens and you're like okay let me let me get around it and and I knocked it off all right let's put it back on it's just weird that'd be fun on a map too like if you could make like those little dashes of like oh you're traveling no I know yeah and I think that's why what they were trying to get was like you visually get to see it or like and it's also like physical but I think it'd be in cubes kind of just muddies it up versus if it was written yeah yeah and I'm not I'm not gonna give him like any leeway I really think that their design was we just don't want to do another flip and write so they went a different route and it's like yeah but what you you would you like you kind of made it a little more fiddly than it needed to be and I will say this is one of those fiddlies that does like after a while you're just like something up and you're like having a fat hand day or something yeah like knocking everything over or you drop a cube and it knocks the flash into another spot yeah and you're like where was that yeah and also the reason why we didn't do this as a run-through is because there is no interaction even a little yeah so it's like it's not entertaining to watch everyone's just kind of playing their own game and then it's like everyone all right oh

hey guys I didn't even know you were here sometimes there's a sidebar conversation about school is there a solo variant there is a solo variant actually of course is it score the most points you can get uh that's actually a good question I don't score more than five points I don't know there's a solar 150 you were trying to reach uh no you're trying to reach a uh coin threshold okay by completing all three goals but if I was setting my difficulty each time hard you need 150 points so I've hit exactly that so you need to play it solo and then show us you're like this is so hard um yeah it's a it's a multiplayer solitaire game you're not really interacting with each other it the physicality of the cubes doesn't enhance anything I like the towers being placed I almost would have liked it if the if they had little cities so like everything as you like explored the uh landmarks locations like Treasures if they because I don't know why they made Towers like 3D it's like why don't you give us little ship tokens I was like a neutral color why didn't you give us a little city token so that as we explore side of the map it kind of Pops like it's 3D if you wanted to do that that would give us our little city tokens these are Villages but I'm talking about like these like it's like it's weird that they had a 3D element for the towers but nothing else because those are more important like or they're more rare so yeah I

actually think you get more points with trade routes like I got no I was thinking of points I was just thinking of actually creating them physically oh there's only four Macs per player yeah so they don't have to make nearly as many of them and they're out on the edges so they're not like gonna be in the way anybody yeah Traders we each got three or four or five yeah and as far as I know I do not think this was this one on Kickstarter uh I could be completely wrong there but I'm I'm pretty sure it didn't that is a rarity in this day uh so Angie Kickstart almost everything They Don't Really Kickstart a whole lot actually they they're bigger games like uh dead reckoning yeah was kick-started and Edge of Darkness and those were kick-started I'm trying to look for the games to make sure that they're even this is dead reckoning oh there's yeah that is AEG so they're Thunderstone quests like they do Kickstart kind of expansions or games like that but yeah I don't I don't quote me but I'm pretty sure this wasn't and if it was it probably didn't do well don't worry it's not going the internet yeah we're deleting deleted oh okay so yeah I think I'm very curious I'm very curious if these designers are gonna do more with this I think of course map packs are always great that'd be easy a little bit more complexity maybe do more I mean obviously have like a different region completely like change up the color scheme is what I mean by that yeah maybe if they're like they realize that people actually like played in liked it and they're like oh [ __ ] it was like that

was kind of that was our backup plan let's make a real game yeah those were my that was my joke game now we're gonna come out with a rolling right version like when you play like a burner card in a card game you're just like this is stupid and then yeah I'll get it I'll get rid of it let's just yeah it's been table for so long let's just push it out yeah it's still viable so we'll do it and then everyone loves it and you're like what yeah we worked so hard on this yeah God thank God there was a labor of love all the elements were completed uh you definitely weren't gonna have cities and trade markers and ships so yeah I think they could definitely do map packs you have the maps have special rules like this midi expansion does and obviously more player Powers Yeah because that's always that's the best part yeah you guys get anything else any any other negatives any other any other comments questions comments concerns yeah yeah scale of one to ten what would you guys give the Guild of merchant explorers eight eight that's where I'm at that is also where I am at it is an eight out of ten extremely solid glad to set the tone so that's our thoughts on the Guild of merchant explorers last time we think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever kind of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken

to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved