Skip to main content
Loading video...

Carnival of Monsters: Discussion

Transcript 32:09

viewer discretion is advised everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free on your book with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video hey everyone welcome to this discussion for Richard Garfield carnival of monsters not a terrible game no I like I thought it was actually a lot of fun Josh go ahead am I already talking over here Kat said she liked this that's a big thing ken doesn't I mean for a game of like I would think this type this wouldn't I was really thinking camera well you like seven wonders don't you we I'm sorry that we play 88 games a year yeah but the good ones stand out like 71 I mean this this one is pretty much right up my alley like I absolutely love card card drafting and I think games of this ilk life like I mentioned seven Wonders and other card drafting games it's it's my favorite mechanism so it's there's just always a lot of thought to it and I I love being able to get a hand of cards obviously have multiple options in your hand you're like I want all of these like there was a combo in during the run

through it was like you that that crab monster you had and also like a high-end cave with it and it's like I want both of these so you have to make the decision of okay do I want to take one and then like play it and hope that that card comes back around to me and in the lower player game in a three-player game you have that opportunity this can play up to five and it still always eight cards yeah so you're the change that you kid in the card that you want Tekken lungs is way higher that's people exactly so it's uh so I like it I like that this also worked out what really well three people most card drafting games to do because there's not a lot of interaction like I'm not screwing you guys over really directly like it's like well I also like it's up there's no well okay well I'm just gonna take that monster from you or any [ __ ] like that oh I'm gonna destroy your lands or no that so so yeah like it worked for me what do you guys think yeah I think it was I think it was a solid game um I I still don't know how to feel about the loan system just because when they said like they they basically made it sound like it was going to be impossible to not take a loan which I don't like being forced to do things yeah I was forced to take a loan a kind of just bad luck bad planning um you know just I got one it just happened that one of my secret goals was to never get one so I was

really upset right but I don't like the fact that you're you're probably never gonna not take a loan in this game because mine was just by accident yeah so and you cannot pay them back I think that's also coupled with the fact you campaign I kind of like that which I understand why you couldn't pay it back because if this game does go so quickly I really like to use the game that it goes so fast you wouldn't really have time to pay it off so I get it but yeah uh to counteract that I see wo you're saying with nope nope it does say some may say like said stop stop the chances of you getting a loan is relatively high but there is a strategy to ensure you do not never play dangerous danger or or if you do have a yeah like it I mean get a crate I hope that the Kings sends some people to help you out and if not I mean you can't Bank on that because it's mostly blank dice but if you are gonna go danger then don't stack it like I did at the end world life is danger because I had all these abominations from the dream lands and I'm just like hopefully he rolls well I have a lot of money but it was like I was not quite enough because I almost put the whole game without alone yeah yeah so yeah it was just we were like I remember just when you were going over the rules I was like what was it it was Brown was a season three when you reread

the rule about dreamland yes if if we had understood that this game possibly could have went out very differently yeah I think so cuz I almost took that that dreamland creatures like I totally know it was season it was it was season

I read it early on because we played the dream lanes and we we mixed it up we thought the dream lanes was a wild for other creatures but don't know it's a monster and then those big guys came out so I mean wild you know because you cuz the big guy was ironing out the yeah yes because oh when I okay yes when I played him oh no you're right yeah you're right because you said oh so that means or someone says you like no because what happened I rewrote it twice oh I did the first time when we first played a dream once then I was like I wanted to verify and I'm like oh is that how that works cuz I kept him yeah because I wasn't going for that rule I was going oh so good Dreamlands came out yeah yeah it on mic wait a minute does that actually work and that's that's how it came out granted I mean the point spread for the game was actually 23 points no sorry from first to second was 23 points still 34 points he just means that we probably would have played a lot heavier like we probably would have pumped out a lot more yeah but then not also you guys never had cages you raise money so that I had money they want to have me dangerous that's why I had six danger at the end of the game I didn't care because one of my cards was about well yeah which actually kind of sucks because it doesn't negate your lung no it doesn't it lessens what it does help yeah but it we got it you got two points hurry for long so I got eight so I only ended up taking 12 instead of 20 yeah negative which so

I if we're talking about negatives as well John section what do you think so flavor game love it artwork on cards love it for the most part yes I think the people they're kind of like it seems like they oh they have different no they don't these two are the same artists may but they have a bunch of different artists actually um so both of both my people have the same artist and I can tell because of excellent face works yeah it actually looks like for each type of card there was a specific artists like the forest it's as Michael Menzel I I feel like I recognize some of these artists from magic yeah yeah I don't necessarily find how the people look it's just because they're not bad it's just they're not you know realistic like we're used to like the wool like every other piece of art is realistic the monsters look realistic the land looks realistic the people look very very cartoon whimsical realistic I would not think that this looks realistic at all because it looks more cartoony than anything versus the darkness I mean like that looks real oh yeah oh so do the [ __ ] eerie cards or area or whatever they are like why mr. heartland yeah like they look great yeah the public's the most cartoony out of all of them yeah but I mean if we talk about the artwork it's so really good yeah I like

the monsters I think we're awesome to look at and have small little details and the like this giant this gray Kraken actually has a little there's a little submarine that's need for a minutes like oh that's her right thing and they like shine the light on it it's like oh oh it's the baby it's the already dead baby um yeah I like I like the flavor of the game I artworks great whoo can I say one thing while you're talking about our work Meyer I have I have three different worm links they're all different they're all different yeah I know I noticed that which is really neat one looks like a bubble and the rest of us looks like we're home so that was a right there that was a big thing that uh pissed a lot of collector people off when unstable came out because he was he was brought in for that there's I think there's a cart with seven different pieces of art on it same card same name same everything that's got different art there's a card that has different flavor text on it for different times there's uh and it's it's bad quote-unquote for collectors because it's like well I have to have the same card seven times well they don't have to they get a better hardcore yeah I mean like a collector or not as in like financial value but as in like I'm having every card in the same no yeah

but I I do like that my biggest thing was interacting with people I knew I was gonna bring that up um and that's more negative than them positive i but I do I really like this game I like this game if we're comparing Richard Garfield games I like this far more far more than game boards i I would agree I'm gonna I'm gonna bounce off what John just said real quick because I think that might be why I like this game is he said the interaction with people thing I [ __ ] hate mean games I don't like to be mean I don't like to get picked on I wanted to be a nice clean game maybe that's why I liked it because it sets tried to get me to play magic not really tried to get you to play magic but would have me demo things with him and so I just get my ass stomped but this I felt like we could do our own [ __ ] we could enjoy it and then the interaction is very indirect like there were hearts I kept specifically some of you guys couldn't get them Wow hey draft are you [ __ ] and but hey traffic but I planned on using them that was the thing there was never a car that I I asked them aggressive passive aggressive crafter I guess cuz hate drafting is literally on keeping this jessica's [ __ ] you yeah and I and I despise that like but I kept cards like okay I know he can play this now but I will aim to play it later so and and I was gonna bring that up exactly because

I that it can be negative for a lot of people hey well we're essentially playing solo games and eat the guy who was selling the game told me that he's like there's hardly any interaction between players and I'm like there's really not a lot of interaction and seven wonders either except you compare military strength yeah and it's like oh I have the most and you only fight your neighbors so in this game if I'm the most military then you know if they you like if Devin was here you would only find candy yeah and then but we don't really fight nothing gets destroyed this is I have more military so you guys get - two points mm something like that uh so with this one it's just like okay like but some people think it's a negative thinking of its party yeah um depends on the game for well the interaction part but that's also stemming from things in magic language this isn't about magic I try and I'm gonna bring it up because Richard Garfield I ain't Mac and I hate that his names on this I will how do you do I think yeah because his name is on it I think it's totally fair that Josh wants to compare it so much to magic because I'm not I I don't it'll I don't know a lot about magic but yeah like it is very obvious the fact that everything is colored there are lands like my god is inspiration from magic but I will say I'm very very glad that he made a radically different game yes yeah and I actually really appreciate it too yeah Mikey forge where you're like okay like there's no there's another competitive card game and it's nothing like magic it's subpar at best and that's magic light yeah or what not even

white it's like minuscule yes the magic minuscule so and that can like greatly you praised this game because people couldn't look at it and be like oh it's Richard Garfield that's gonna sell it and then hopefully people will be like well not compared to magic but that could be its greatest downfall - it's like good this is nothing like magic it's trash it's like yeah he can make other [ __ ] yeah yeah what metallics sucks now but all their songs sound the same you want something different - no it's different you hate it um I will say fun fun tidbit I don't know how many people know this I said it during the during or either before um and it has to do with magic magic the gathering almost had a sixth color and it was gonna be purple and it's in this game which is pretty neat I do like that fun little tidbit yep yeah protects way in the back here they have the designers and the artists I like how they have the pictures because I like to put faces right so richard garfield designed the first training card game Magic the Gathering yep have you ever heard of that only for the last 26 years published in 1993 as old as I am at the time he was a math professor but the success of Magic the Gathering led to him leaving academics and going into game design full-time and then they have the other the other artists here which is pretty neat uh but there is something okay so let's talk about some negatives because I do think there is at least there's a few there's there's really one

that sends out to me and maybe I missed in the rules but I'm pretty sure I didn't is that you if you cannot play a card so whenever you pass out you're like your your hand and then punished for it well you either can hope you get lucky and can play it or you have to keep it and you have to pay for it and it's like but I didn't want this card so why should I have why should I be forced to I think that happened to me relatively soon I was like I was like I can't play this so I guess we have to we have to pay for and keep it I mean it gives you a goal somewhat just to strive for at the UH I mean throughout the game but it's like it's really annoying because I mean I have this Nephilim Nephilim Nephilim card that hey if I have any dark lands that would have been fantastic but I never did so I was like always hoping it would come back to me yeah I think this like knows one of the cards that I happen to oh I guess I have to keep you cycled through all right so that's it that's a negative am i sounded big negative because it didn't really matter a lot for me anyway but if you have to take loans to like negative five points essentially for a card that you didn't want that you were they are forced to keep yeah that that's kind of annoying so my biggest negative is kind of that my least favorite way to play magic is which is drafting um mostly because it's

luck yeah at a point or so like the fact that cat got all Aries early in the game she hated it but come the end she got a secret objectives I gave her seven points um which that was a look oh yeah hit had I got well special caves I would have probably took it yeah I got extra points but it's okay so to argue against I definitely thought you're saying and you're not entirely wrong it's not all luck because she didn't draw all of them I was willingly she I was willingly passing her stuff yeah we're passing them to me so I understand that so at some point that's kind of where the hate drafting comes in because it's like okay like she's getting a lot of those and it comes with experience there there's uh how many there's like two there's two hundred fifteen carnival cards yeah and in the whole deck so there's definitely a better variety so that's that's a plus I guess but that's also a lot of cards that you have to be like okay I know that that's a secret card and but you'll also never know if someone has that but you can at least guess if they're trying to stack a bunch and you're like okay they're probably going for that so you try to halt them yeah and I did that card was in there and the reason I got so many areas because I got a lot within like the first season and I was like okay and then the second season I was like I might as well just you know keep this trade I don't know what it was like for her to get that yeah and I think you you must have started with that because I don't remember you willingly gave her

that yes I do understand that um but I'd say nicely that's where the luck comes in like because I didn't have to pick it well I just kind of took it and I was like okay look yeah other thing is amount of cards being passed Hey cards I feel like is too little because in Italy drafting in magic you take out the token and the land hmm so past thirteen cards yeah and it's usually three or four packs depending on how the pressure pot is but you're also drafting between how many people in the draft three or four people really pods afford you yeah so um I would think two more carts ten passing ten would do a lot more there is plenty of cars that's just me I'm making comparisons but that's just me yeah I would increase the limit to ten but I think the size was okay I mean yeah I didn't have a problem with with eight I think it kept it kept the well that's more cards that you're potentially having to keep all right I know but I don't know here's me here's another one it's not my person well it kind of was at one point but the other difference is is sorry I didn't get up chest you're not building a deck in this rain that's my biggest downfall that's true you actually made a statement at the end of the run through that I want to talk about pace of rounds not

specifically I guess not just pacing but slow like you need to have a group that can establish a flow because when it's when it's free like that where you're like okay we do it simultaneously I don't think it should be simultaneously I think you should well the card drafting should be simultaneous but laying your car yeah it was kind of like when that was mine because there were times where you'd like it there'd be like two cars left or three cards left and then Josh would be like okay I'm just gonna do that and you'd still be holding cards I'm like I don't know are those from your kept from like where is everything or like yeah like if somebody carries you just don't see that somebody's still choosing and you and you're like okay well then let's start like it's just easy to for sure yeah and that's definitely a card drafting kind of downfall they just be like okay boom I'm gonna do this and then it's like and then like I pick up that I cast it so they cat now has two decks and she's like what's gonna happen I feel like no were you held onto a deck and I was like am I gonna get past yeah oh do I have time so this is something that players you have to have - yeah you have to have good mitigation good my favorite thing about this game is the keep mechanic they keep mechanic but you complained about it earlier I complained about you have to keep the very last car than a draft that's the shitty part about it because it's like you can't just so if I if you'll have any caves and that final card well that sucks the suck you have to pay a coin oh you don't have any ok debt to pay for a card that I don't want to keep - five points you can't pay it back that's the shitty part about it other than that it's still my favorite

because of the fact that you can plan ahead and you're not stifled by the way you're keeping like okay I got a ten strength monster that I can't afford right now I'll pay a coin keep them and I'll just win and then you can okay or all you know I'll keep some some staff around and I'll pay for them and then oh wait lucky me I got that one so in the secret cards that you you get to keep so I really like that because other than that this game would not work like you would you'd have to be super then there's all your luck like if this if you couldn't keep like oh I sure hope I get some enchanted forest to be able to play all I never did so I guess this is just going around for no reason so I mean you guys like to keep mechanic other than yeah I mean I would say the only reason I like it is because I got a secret card that gave me points and loans yeah I would say that I'm just kind of neutral about it I I mean I didn't really actually think about it too much I just took at us you know a rule and I roll with it so I did not have any problems with my biggest problem is that I compared this too much yeah yeah it really is yeah y'all head so with that being said you made a statement that this game would work better as a dump deck builder oh you would have to edit rules you'd have to make a completely different game yeah like I'm mistaken I was taking this seemly be [ __ ] fantastic for a work replacement yeah

that would be really neat like how doesn't a theme the mechanics not at all little creatures though yeah cool yeah like the theme itself would work really well as a mechanic but I think it's beautiful as it is I think if you made a deck builder then be just like another it'd be a night of magic ripoff and yeah I don't I don't want that he's good it's fantastic I like for magic no like amazing this theme is great thing yeah imbued with like theme and thing and it's because I see his name I'm comparing it by itself this game is fantastic yeah like no comparisons at all like it's by itself it this is great it's really quick to the was see it says it is it doesn't say a time I think well it says 1212 enough for ages and to the five players we're uh the time I do I say I'm crazy about this I am I'm curious yeah it's it's super quick very very in it to be very simple other another comparison to a magic is that the point system because in magic you have life this is my victory points cuz it's yeah right um which is really different for him because and he forged its first of three open three cages hideous three keys through six either a

key I think I did too but other than that I mean that's the thing like eyewitness services like the theme the overarching theme but that's the thing is this game could have literally been about anything so so the theme of the game I think is really neat but the game itself is not somatic I should say but yeah looks so crazy yeah yeah and I don't know so that could be a negative for a lot of people to the fact that okay well you really don't have kind of a strategy because you're just going from a deck of of cards you got 215 cards for the most part yeah that's see giant so yeah yeah I mean and like you just get a [ __ ] ton of points so other than that I I don't really have a whole lot I think the staff were okay like I picked three of them and bring the incredibly balanced I've been checking all these oh really there are no cards that say you win okay I don't expect it very well or what if there's like a card in there there's like one card it's like 30 points like yeah it's all balanced all the creatures there all the seasons are timelines yeah like lumps are static like your your Chan like the high level ones are and funny enough actually need

the 10 the 10 the tenner that I got it was only 13 points yeah my my biggest one would be what you got in the two free cards and I really like that mechanic I thought the the ability to let you draw two and play them for free or keep them for free I thought that was really cool so it was like huh he's not worth a lot of points but I could get two free bit of it and risk that three three damage the the definite strong like point and it's strong in his other games is drawn getting to get extra cards sure I thought that ability was the strongest and in my opening hand I had to decide to either keep keep a white creature that I believe she ended up getting white white monster Airy mom yeah uh that let her draw a card or pick a land which is it depends on how you like to play that's the other thing some people like late-game and some people like to get it done as early as possible close the game out real quick yeah um my strategy was definitely monsters like AI and whenever you guys had a bunch of secret goals I'm like oh no like I'm hey I might lose this one it's good to have secret like as many as secret goals as you can yes you kind of just like this is what happens to me in a lot of games you just fall into them weird yeah you just have oh thank god okay I did meet this yeah I liked her

they have the seasons that you can try and plan for that I do like that there's a limit yeah or four seasons are there other seasons there are other season okay the only one think there are how many are that's fantastic there are seven seven season cards and you shuffle between them and just put four out there and I think these dice are crazy there's a 1 1 1 1 2 and then 4 or blanks yes so you can't really rely on that no so you're guaranteed at 25% chance of getting either doubles or 1 yeah yeah um other than that you guys didn't have anything else I can't really think of anything else so on a scale of 1 to 10 cat I'm gonna go to 9 I had damn near no complaints and I actually enjoyed myself because when I sit down and do this I hate to do it but I always do I was like this is gonna be a long game this is not gonna be fun I that's a good mindset I just keep you out of run throughs now well it's because what I know why you don't enjoy game why here is we come in with a mindset like that and mindset is everything when it comes to board games for sure awesome that's re wavefront yeah might as Excel are gonna be a little funny that's my next it might be lower than both yours it probably will I'm point five nine point five is that because it's rich if

this didn't have Richard Garfield's name no it's solid by itself um all of my complaints are purely because his names on it yeah I think that's that's that was a selling point I think that's actually gonna hurt the game a lot more because I would say anyone talking about this um yeah like I really I actually really enjoyed this um a lot of we've played it a few times I would uh I would hope to do a lot better like for sure the load alone system kind of want that [ __ ] you like in the end and at the at the end of game I still I still put with a pulled ahead but by three points mmm-hmm you get minus twenty at the end of the game so you would've had 96 but still it was been a lot closer and who knows like you said if you guys remember the Dreamlands monster thing but I mean that took a [ __ ] ton of my lands it did I was like okay I hope I get lucky and get a car do you have him to pass me one that you could've easily probably but even know I had that that's a lie mechanic so so the whole thought process between seeing you that land and this was I was thinking there was one more round so I picked a person Oh gotcha otherwise I would have picked the wind gotcha but that's why I asked after I passed it to you so thank you Mike there isn't another round of this is there I'm like nope yay so that's what screwed me yeah um I'm going to give it an 8.5 that's fair it's like yeah I mean I can't really

think of any any other reason I think at 8.5 spits for me it's not like at the end of the day this game is solid it's fun it's quick very little complaints but it's not like stellar like it's but for me it's not like wow it's a card drafting game at the end of the day and I've played a lot of them and wasn't just as fun as the rest sure but yeah I mean it was it was it was that and it was a really neat one and I can't really think of anything that would make this game like phenomenal like two words like wow and you need it no it's a different type of card drafting not really but it's still really good and and I enjoyed it and I'm glad we all liked it so that its current full of monsters every yep Carnival of monsters everyone Richard Garfield's carnival monsters if you are watching this basically omit his name like otherwise he will compare it to magic or key Forge please don't I mean it's just in there because you're gonna be trying to find those ties which suck like I I don't think the only thing that compares to this to magic is that there are monsters and lanter cult lambs other than that there i'll aber yeah and but I don't think mechanically they're not even close no cuz like monsters don't have ability don't have abilities they I mean they kind of do the draw in the danger

yeah like thanks yeah I mean that probably would have actually made this game a little bit better for me is if they're if they did have abilities you know like kind of giving you a little bit more than like oh this lets me do this but also I could get this because a lot of points just just a little a little boom you know I'm saying on the cards interactivity is my big thing yeah it actually a positive for me in a game like this just because not to the point we're like it's basically me like to get over yeah yeah something that like affects everybody that's against you trick like an enchantment magic sure so yeah but that's it everyone lost some of you think of Carnival of monsters in the comments below other than that like I'm insurance and have a wonderful with every type of datas for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you

Progress saved