Skip to main content
Loading video...

Estoril City Of Spies Board Game Review

Transcript 10:29

Hello. Welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, don't do any more playthroughs, but we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks. Tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a game that is now 10 years old. [ __ ] me. We're talking about Estoril: The City of Spies and in this game you'll be putting your tiles out onto the board and taking actions that will hopefully allow you to take control of other spies that will give you victory points that will hopefully allow you to win the game. So in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules, but tell you what we do like, what we don't like. Then we'll come back and we'll say whether or not Estoril: City of Spies is still worth your time and bother 10 years after or maybe 11 years after its first release. So remember, if you know it, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button and all of that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you after this.

Bollocks. So Estoril: City of Spies, how do you play this game? So effectively, Estoril: City of Spies is a very very simple tile placement game. You're going to put a bunch of location tiles out into the center of the table. You'll be able to orient these any which way you want. And each player is going to get a generic set of six spies. Depending on how many players you're playing with, you're going to get a number of cubes and you will take a variable number of mission tiles and put them next to the board, right? So on your turn, you're going to have one of two options. You're going to be able to take one of your agent tiles and you're going to have to put it out onto the board. You'll see the location tiles are split into a number of different zones. You've got zone one, zone two, zone three. And if you've got the expansion, you'll have a tile with zone four on it. And then you'll have a space where you'll put a reward tile, which is basically like a more powerful spy tile.

And these will either be face up or face down depending on whether or not you've got top secret on the tile, right? So you're going to put one of your tiles out onto the board in one of those three spots and then you put one of your cubes on top of it, right? The second option that you've got that you could put one of your tiles out into the inner region. You'll always have to put one of your spy tiles out into the outer region. And the only way you're going to be able to put spy tiles in the inner region is if you've already got a spy tile that is adjacent to the space you want to go to in the inner region, right? So, you have to sort of trace a little pathway to where you want to get to. Once everybody has put all of their spy tiles out, then you will activate the locations, right? You'll see each of the location tiles has got a number on it. You'll start at zero if you got expansion, if not, you start at number one. And then you end at the highest number, right? You've also got to remember that most of the location tiles will have an action associated with them. These will be activated at various points in the game, right? So, if there's any spaces with toxic on it, you're going to turn all these over, and then you will look to see who has the highest strength on that location tile, right? This is going to be messed about with by taking all the different actions, right? You'll see that each of the spy tiles has got an action associated with it. And I'll give you a few examples of what some of these mean, right? So, if you have got Marilyn Monroe, she has got two very, very prominent actions associated with her, right? She has got the seduction action, right? This means that you can pull another tile onto a location tile. And this is a good way of like either bolstering your strength on a specific tile or removing strength from another tile. And it doesn't really matter whether or not the tiles have been activated or not, right? So, you got the assassination action, right? This is

like a little gun thing, and this allows you to take a tile off the board and put it back into the hand of your opponent or yourself. You want to kill yourself, I suppose. I wouldn't recommend it, all right? There's also toxic on it, you're going to turn all these over, and then you will look to see who has the highest strength on that location tile, right? This is going to about with by taking all the different actions, right? You'll see that each of the spy tiles has got an action

This improves the strength plus one for every other character that's got the same flag on it as your character, yeah? And it doesn't even matter if it's your character or not. It could be somebody else's character, yeah? So, that's [ __ ] mental. So, that is most of the actions. There's another one called double agent if you've got the expansion. I remember picking it up when it was released and it was basically just a couple of tiles, some extra characters, stuff for a fifth player for like 25 quid sort of 9 years ago. I said it's a [ __ ] rip off then and I dare say it's a [ __ ] rip off now. So, you'll keep doing this for four rounds. You also got to remember that you have to discard down to six tiles. So, you're going to have to make a decision on which ones you want to dump. If you dump them, you stick them in your discard pile. And at the end of the fourth round, you do some final scoring. You get one victory point for every tile that you discarded.

You'll get the victory points on your character cards. And if you accomplish any of the missions, these are basically the most of say if you've got the most abduction icons or the most assassination icons or whatever, then you'll get six points for them and then whoever's got the most points will be the winner of Esteren City of Spies. So, do we like Esteren City of Spies? So, the first thing that we quite like about this is that the mechanics are [ __ ] simple, right? It's more simple than Joey Deacon on Blue Peter in the '80s. You're going to take a tile and you're going to put it on a space, yeah? And the only complication is that any outie thing, right? Not talking about clits. Not talking about belly buttons either, you dirty bastards. So, if you don't understand that, then there really is no helping you. You might as well just stuff your face full of Monster Munch and turn lights off in here. So, on paper, the first perusal, this game doesn't really have any rules to it at all. And as I get older and I was going to say wiser, but that's not true. I don't really see the attraction of overly complicated games anymore, yeah?

Cuz they're just a [ __ ] waste of time, aren't they? Do you know what I mean? You spend half your time learning all the rules, 2 hours playing a game and it turns out to be [ __ ] dog [ __ ] Second thing that we quite like about this game is that where the locations are divided up into number order, the activation is going to be done in number order. That means you've got to place your tiles strategically, right? Usually, when you put them on number one, you're going to be able to activate them first. Of course, you're going to be able to activate them first, but usually, you're not going to get any kind of sort of bonus action you can take. Whereas, if you put them on number two or number three, you're going to get a more powerful action like being able to peek at cards on that tile or adjacent tiles, yeah? So, you've got to sort of weigh up whether or not you want to be first out the gate or whether or not you want to uncover some of that hidden information this game sort of thrives on, you know what I mean? So, the final thing that we do indeed quite like about this game is that there is an element of strategic blocking in this game. Where you've got that inner outer duality, you've got to plot your paths really, really carefully, yeah? Cuz you're thinking, "I need to get into that middle space, but if I put my character on the space that allows me to do that, then I'm going to activate it second. And if I put an assassin there, then I'm not going to be able to do anything." So, you're constantly sort of second-guessing what your opponent is doing based on what they put out, whether or not they're choosing to utilize the fact that they've got a female character or whether or not they're using the location tiles that give you plus one strength if you're British or German or whatever. Even though there's a lot of hidden information in this game, you can kind of deduce what the most important aspects of what you need to know are or

not. So, don't be like, "But Estoril City of Spies." So, the first thing that I [ __ ] hate about this game is there's too many [ __ ] icons, yeah? Where there's no like icon summary in the box, you have to go to some [ __ ] dirty grubby little website to pick up some files, yeah? Where there's no iconography sheet in the box, you've got to try and get people to remember what all the [ __ ] icons mean, yeah? And even if I've got a cheat sheet, I'm still looking at the [ __ ] icon thinking, "What the [ __ ] was that again?" Especially the [ __ ] on the board, yeah? Because sometimes the icons on the board get covered up by those tiles cuz they just sort of slide around a little bit, you know what I mean? So, yeah, there's too many icons in this game. There's always going to be one big [ __ ] out there going, "Well, I didn't have any trouble remembering icons." Well, [ __ ] whoop-de-do. I hope you join [ __ ] Mensa and start working with BAE Systems on the latest [ __ ] cruise missile or something, yeah? I can't [ __ ] remember it, and that's all that matters. So, the second thing that we didn't like about this game is that there's no real scaling of character powers here. You're just going to be shuffling all the characters into a big deck, and they're going to come out randomly, yeah? And it would have been nice if you'd had like tier one, tier two, tier three, tier four characters, so you felt as if there was like a structured sort of growth to the power of the characters, but there isn't. So, those full strength characters, they're going to have like a a really good strength or really good special ability, but they're going to be worth [ __ ] all.

The opposite is true of low strength characters. They're going to be worth more victory points, yeah? So, the way that they come out is completely randomized, and I just wish that there'd been some kind of like upward trajectory in terms of how powerful these characters get. So, the final thing that we don't like about Estoril City Spies is that where there's so much going on, I just end up just thinking, "Well, I'll chuck that character here." And just hope for the best. It's like a hit-and-hope game because there's so many moving parts, so many different variables, so many different ways that the game could [ __ ] with your plans that it's just too much hard work trying to keep track of it all, yeah? And the fun came from just chucking a character out and hoping that either it wasn't going to get challenged or that you [ __ ] somebody else's plans up, yeah? That's where the fun comes in this. It's nothing to do with your personal fulfillment of the missions or trying to win the game. It's the sadistic nature of ruining somebody else's grip on a location, yeah? If you're a [ __ ] sociopath, then I highly recommend that you buy this game. If you're a pacifist, then you're probably better off going to play Isle of Cats or [ __ ] Everdell, any one of those plethora of what they call cozy [ __ ] games, you know what I mean? So, to summarize, is Estoril City Spies worth your time and bother today and in the future?

So, we are going to say maybe maybe not. Do you know what? I'm at a real crossroads with this one. There are real flashes of brilliance, but it never really shines brightly enough to evoke that like elusive wow factor, you know? The lack of staggered tension and the maddening array of icons counteracts the simple tile placement mechanism this game offers you out of box, yeah? This happens to such a degree that what could have been a real excellent game turns out to be just a well, I was going to say good game, but just an average sort of tile placement Euro game, you know, what I mean? So, there you go. That is Estoril City Spies. Remember, if you know it, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, all that YouTube [ __ ] See you next time.

Progress saved