Art Society Review: Art connoisSEUR
Transcript
Hello everybody welcome back to board game Budz today My Name Is Karly and I'm Kim and today we're going to be revie reviewing reviewing going to do like vocal exercises like news reporter okay I got this three two one hi friends welcome back to board game Buzz today my name is Carly and I'm Kim and today we're going to be reviewing the two to four player game art Society for Mighty boards games
in art Society you taking on the role of an art art oh my gosh okay art coniss connoisseur con connoisseur yeah connoisseur okay let's try this again that sounds like a dinosaur connoisseur now I'm it's not a Conor connoisseur how do you spell it I don't know c o n I know there's some s's in there do they have like a little voice thing like that can you tap that oh maybe you're right connoisseur connoisseur wait do that again connoisseur I was wrong con connoisseur I still can't connoisseur so ignore everything I saidur an art connoisseur I'm going to say it wrong art connoisseur an art connoisseur connoisseur coniss sir like sir yeah like that is also an math art an art connoisseur say three an art connoisseur an art coniss Ur all right let's try this again in art Society you are taking on the role of an art connoisseur and you are trying your best to get the appropriate art pieces that you need to build out your wall to make it the most appealing before we share our thoughts on this game though we're going to be giving you a really quick overview of how this game plays and then we'll jump back here and we'll share our thoughts on Art Society so this game does play from 2 to 4 four we're going to be kind I'm going to kind of be demonstrating based on a two-player game um but I'm only going to keep this one player board here in the frame cuz it doesn't really matter too much with the other um what your
opponent's boards look like everybody starts with um a starting a starting uh piece of art that you can place on your board you will also hand every player um uh this set of auction discs um these are numbered from 1 to 20 which will be very important throughout the game and so we'll talk about these later so we're going to kind of quickly go over what round looks like um so the beginning of every round one of the players is going to act as the auctioneer who will actually be selecting the paintings that will be available for auction so if I was acting as the auctioneer I would come over here and I would choose let's say I choose this one this one and we'll do this one okay so these are the three that I um have selected for this round now once the auctioner has chosen these tiles now these tiles get flipped over and placed um based on their value so for example this one would be placed here this one here and then this piece of art would be placed here now once that has been completed now we come to the auction um portion of the game um so if you remember everybody has these auction tiles they're numbered 1 through 20 and everybody will secretly pick a number and then reveal it at the same time based on your number Whoever has the highest number you're actually not B bidding on pieces of artwork you're just bidding on turn order so whoever bid highest could pick one and then it would slowly go down through the rest of the numbers and whoever had the lowest number would go last now what makes this auction phase slightly tricky is that once you use a number that auction disc actually gets removed from the game at that point so again you have 1 through
20 so you want to kind of be resourceful in regards to what um what numbers you are playing um because once you play it then you lose it now if you notice I picked three pieces of artwork and the reason why I did that is I'm pretending like we're in a two player game um because you always pick one more piece of artwork than there are players at the table so if I picked 10 and let's pretend that somebody else around the table picked 19 as their auction um they would go ahead and they would select a tile so they would go ahead and let's say they select this one um and then it would be down to me and I would have two options so I'm going to go ahead and select this now when you are placing pieces of artwork onto your wall there's a couple things you have to be aware of the first is the the artwork has to be fully inside this little grid here it cannot be overhanging at all um it also has to touch at least one other tile alongside a flat Edge so Corners would not count um like for example that would not count it has to be touching another previously P placed painting on one of the sides um it also has to be oriented the correct way so the artwork is upright you also want to match up similar frames so there are four frames that are found throughout the game there are um silver a silver frame there's a wooden frame this gold frame which is shown right here and then also this seashell kind of white frame when you are able to pair up or match up um one or more or I guess two two or more frames then you come over here and you get these little bonus pieces of Decor that you can hang on your wall that um again they kind of help fill in little empty gaps that might appear throughout
the game but they also give you little bonus points at the end of the game so those are really nice so while you want to be matching up frames you actually don't want to be matching up similar types of artwork um so there are there are four different types of artwork found throughout the game there are if you can see right here there are yellow artwork which is like still life red artwork which is portraits blue which are classified as City life photos and then green that is that um is classified as a landscape photo you are never at any time allowed to place two of the same types of artwork um in such a way that they are touching on your board so now if you take a look at the board there's one piece of artwork that is left over um that piece of artwork is actually then acquired by the museum so what that means is the the museum takes um will take uh own ownership of this piece of art and then the value of this type of photo will increase so this is um a landscape painting or sorry a cityscape painting and it is worth Five Points so it comes right here indicating that the museum has acquired it and then that type of um um painting will now increase by five um so as the game goes on this little board here um is was always kind of fluctuating based on the piece of art that is left over and was unclaimed after the museum acquires that final leftover piece of artwork then um that that triggers the end of the round and then the player who is next um or on
the left of the old auctioner becomes the new auctioner and they begin the next round by selecting um the paintings for the next auction as the board goes on your wall here will fill up more and more with paintings making it harder and harder to place paintings in the future so if at any point you acquire a painting that you can't place anywhere on your board there's a couple things that you can do the first is you could hand your painting off to your assistant you can actually do this at any point in the game um if you ever acquire painting that you don't want to place at that at that exact moment you could allow your assistant to hold it for you um but just keep in mind that any leftover piece of artwork that is hold that your assistant is holding at the end of the game will be worth negative points for you so you don't really want to hold on to these too long um because yeah they'll be worth negative points but there's another thing that you can do if you acquire a piece of artwork that is unable to fit on your board at the time of acquiring it so the other thing that you can do um is you can actually swap it with um a painting that is in the Museum of the same type so because this painting does not fit on my wall I could hypothetically switch it for this smaller one um which now fits um on my board um so that is something that you can do is these paintings that are acquired by the museum are not technically out of the game you still can use them if you need to at a future round and so obviously that's very general of how rounds work but you'll be um take um players will take turns taking on the role of the auctioneer selecting tiles placing them um then the auction phase will occur which then
you'll select your F painting adding them to your board and then whatever is left over will come up here and the museum uh will increase the value of whatever painting was left over at the end of the round so that will just keep going and going and going until um a couple things happen that triggers the end of the game so the first thing that can happen is if a player any player has no empty space left on your personal Gallery wall another thing that can happen is that if a player stores their second excess painting um that can also trigger the end of the game and also if players have no more um auction bids left in their hand um so if any of those three things happen then that triggers the end of the game um we can we you finish the round um or the current round that you are in and then it proceeds to end game scoring so when you are scoring up at the end of the game the first thing you're going to do is you're going to come to to this again Museum board and you're going to um Slide the the values of the paintings up to the their appropriate spots so in this example blue was first so blue gets slid right there green came in second yellow came in third and then red came in first so now players are going to go through and score their paintings on their board based on the value that ended up at the Museum so for this current example all blue will go through and score and they'll be worth Five Points each greens will be worth four yellows will be worth three and then Reds will be worth two you also want to keep in mind that whatever um type of painting ends up the highest so in this current example it's blue whatever blue paintings you have
that are hanging or placed in your eyeline level of your board which is this kind of lighter blue section those all worth are worth um double points for you I believe every um painting that is overhanging in this eyeline um is worth an additional three points um so these two um uh pieces of artwork right here will be um an additional three points each because they are in our eyeline all of your little extra little bonus Decor pieces go through and you score um one point per shield on these if you have any corners of your board that are revealed um those are actually worth negative points for you at the end of the game so for example this would be worth you know my um negative negative six points for me any excess paintings or paintings um left over that you were unable to place are also worth negative points those are worth -2 each and then if you are able to fully complete your wall that's actually an additional five points for doing that so everybody goes through and scores up their points and whoever has the most points wins all right so hopefully that overview gives you kind of a general idea of how this game plays um but we're going to go ahead and kind of share our thoughts on Art society and Jame Beckham is over there just talking away so you might hear a little bit of him um but okay so in regards to what we liked Kim do you want to take it away yes so first off I enjoy a good tile Lane game one of the things that I found really interesting with this being a Tha Lane game is that it's not the pieces you're not able to
just like turn them how you want to fit the board um they're pictures so thematically they have to be like and they they're the way that they're supposed to when you put them when you hang them on the wall right hang of the the correct way they're supposed to be yes so um I like that aspect and then also just like the whole puzzle of it add a layer I guess of a of the tiling games and also I like that there's like a positive matching system and then a negative matching system when it comes to placing the tiles so you want to match the frames and then the negative is like you don't want the same kind of artwork to be placed next to each other it just adds like a nice little I guess puzzle to the tile placement game and that there are more things that I have to think about than just like oh how does this fit nicely in my board I'm going to go grab Beckham okay so Beckham's going to join us for a little bit here but um in regards to something that I liked about the tile placement I really like how we as the players we are the ones that are choosing what specific tiles are going to be available for auction for the next round and I like that because it adds an interesting element in regards to especially like if you really want to screw over your opponent or try to push the end game a little bit by you know getting bigger tiles that won't fit um on people's on on people's boards and so they're forced to you know for the most part put that in their like overflow or their their Reserve area my like how we
as the players actually get to kind of choose um and it also made it nice because towards the end if there was a color like let's pretend you had a lot of red on your board and the red was really really low you could potentially pick big ones just hoping that a red comes out hoping that nobody gets it and then hoping that that will you know especially if you choose to bid lower then you make maybe could leave that Red behind hoping to increase the value of that um so I liked I like just the puzzle of choosing of choosing the tiles from the box there's an appropriate amount of like strategy versus Randomness in my opinion with the game when it's your turn you can pick uh which tiles you want what's revealed this kind of random but then you get to pick like what numbers you want when you're bidding and then how that places on the board and then also she was talking about the strategy of leaving it over like so that it can affect this I really really love the theme in this game I love like decorating and I love I don't know so something about just like collecting art and hanging it up in your wall and like making it like visually appealing and trying to match your frames like I I just Lov loved the theme so much in this game um actually when I first saw the box art and kind of and the board I think that's what I saw the box art and the board and I knew it was about like hanging paintings on a wall I was like that's an instant bite for me like I'm instantly I think I literally
went onto their website I haven't even I didn't even watch a review I just went on the website and I ordered it I pre-ordered it because I knew I just needed this in my collection and it was funny cuz I talked to my mom too I was like Mom I just ordered this board game name it's called Art society and she pulled up the picture and she's like where do I order this my mom ordered one too I can definitely relate to like seeing the cover of a board game and be like oh I need that because that's what I did with fabl and I got the cover and I was like oh my goodness it's like actual pieces of art it's like double layered like the whole cover like it's just it's it's beautiful like I just I loved it so much I also want to take a moment and just can we just appreciate this insert I love this this insert this uh my goodness velvet insert um I just loved how efficient it was in regards to you could just when when you wanted to play the game you just open up the box hand everybody a card and really you're good to go because you don't have to go through and sort all these into you know individual player trads or everything I think just the whole production I think it just worked really really well for this game very little setup I mean there is more to put away at the end yeah putting away putting away the game that's kind of where the time but even that it's not terrible but it does it does take a little bit but the thing that matters is getting at the ease of bringing something to the table something that I really liked especially in regards to like thinking about this for new Gamers is I like how forgiving this auction system is because you're not necessarily bidding for a painting
and if you don't get that then you lose out you're always going to get something you're really just bidding for turn order and um I think I think it's really forgiving because even if you do get like the pretend I got this that couldn't fit on my board I could then turn to the museum and if I could potentially Swap this out for something that would fit on my board so I think it's a very like I said I think forgiving is just the best word for a forgiving auction system that I think is really approachable especially for new Gamers or people who might not play a bunch of games there's not ever necessarily going to be like super heavy disappointment yeah with this game you might have a little bit like oh man like I I should have bit higher or man I just wasted a high number whenever every one else fit super low um or like oh no there's no colors that I need right now so there like there's a little bit of that but it's not like to the point of like where it feels like catastrophic to your game it's not it's not a hard game to teach it's not a hard game to learn and it's not you it's not long either one of my big Pros is that the the Simplicity level but with the fun level is really high for me so what do you feel about player count like what cuz I know you've played it we' I've played it on at all player counts have you played at all the player counts I've played two and four two and four okay so what what would you prefer I honestly I'm not sure I felt like it played fine at two players yeah I think so too um but I think like pardon me wers like I feel like it probably could go up to five and I maybe
almost wish it did go up to five especially when it comes to bidding games I like a little bit more of suspense I don't know how that would affect like the tiles and how big the box would need to be to add one more player but I feel like you could play it out of five player I was actually surprised that this didn't go up to five I had the same thought because I feel like most auction games at least the ones that I like they they do play great at high counts because you have that tension um so I do I I wish that this would go up to five and maybe there would be an expansion that would do that um and I I think I do prefer it at the higher player counts just because you have more artwork on the table and kind of more more options and there's kind of more tension in regards to the bidding system um or the auctions the the auction part of the game but I do think it played fine at two as well I just don't think there was as much tension maybe the only reason it doesn't is because of because you're picking the tiles and so you have less say in what is going on in the auction and and then what would go on in your board maybe yeah I guess this kind of leads into another thing that I do really like it I do like the bidding system system in this game a lot having is it 1 to 20 or two yeah it was one one one through 20 1 through 20 um and being able to like look at what numbers you have available to you still and like try to think about what what is on everyone else's boards and what's available to pick from and kind of think okay do I think Carly's gonna want to like bit
high this time or is she going to pick a low number so and knowing that once you use that once you use that number it's gone forever so you kind of have that attention too all right so now we're going to kind of jump into stuff that we didn't like or potentially could see others not liking with this game uh do you want to start or do you want me to start um sure I can I can start something that I realized in in my plays of this game is that like bigger is not always better so like in my mind I'm like I want to fill up my whole board right like I want to get these big pictures down to fill up my board because like in my mind like because of I guess tiling games in general that's like what I'm like I just feel like this need to fill up the whole thing but if you're playing like the bigger ones if that actually isn't necessarily better cuz it makes it harder for you to or it makes it so that like you're more likely to run into like same picture problem it's harder to keep them separate from each other when you have like big frames of the of that color on them there and the big frames don't necessarily score you more points at end right no they don't they actually like score you I feel like less points well if it well again the big the big pictures are taking up more space that potentially you could have like five smaller ones which would give you way more points than one big one right so it it kind of it's flip-flopped a little
bit in my brain tiny bonus picture you have that's like a victory point at the end of the game so like and each type of picture you have is also going to score you points so having a lot of smaller ones and filling up your board that way that's going to end up giving you more points I like the the idea of the eyeline thematically like oh yeah the one where you're like don't see it right in front of you but I don't know in terms of like I guess for me like the point of it in the game it's so hard to strategize it this is this part is really random because you have no idea what color is going to be the winning color until like the end of the last couple rounds of the game and you can't really strategize that eyeline idea I like what you said in regards to it's hard to strategize because for me I think one of my biggest things against this game I really like this game but for me the second half of the game is way more interesting than the first half of the game because the second half of the game that's when it's kind of like getting down to crunch time you don't your your your board isn't as wide open so you really have are looking for specific things and you you're kind of more aware of what most likely is going to score lots of points versus at the beginning you're like I could put anything down and you just I feel like I don't really have a direction at the beginning of the game and I guess like I'm like a little bit like I don't feel strongly about the point system in this game either I'm not sure how I would have done it differently I guess I wish
that there would have been more ways to score points versus just this like I I really feel like this game needs like Secret objectives oh yeah like so badly I don't mind this but I wish there just would have been a secondary way to score points because then you would have like different goals that you're going towards or something else and that would solve the problem like at the beginning of the game where you're like I don't know what I'm like I'm just placing things because I need to but if you had like a set secret mission like you need like like I don't know like three big you know like three big um art pieces or something on your wall and then something else combined with that and then you get like 15 points secretly or something like then that would have added even more tension because you don't know what other people are going for and the and the particular paintings that you're pulling out you don't know if you're going to be kind of handing them over points or you know what I mean so I think I think this game really needs something like that yeah or I'm thinking like if you had this like where a set of 15 turns potentially and like each five turns you like did some kind of scoring like some kind of mid game scoring I think could be then it wouldn't come all down to end game then from the very beginning yeah you could you're you're aware that that scoring is coming up soon so you need to kind of manipulate the market a little bit and it doesn't just all come down to that end game another thing is sometimes it's kind of hard to judge like the size of the paintings do you have any issues with
like size of paintings I don't know why it was like a hard thing for me sorry no it was for me yeah I don't know why like either cuz I guess I look at this and for whatever reason I think oh this fits in the eyeline but it doesn't like like it just I feel like it hangs over a tad bit more than it should sometimes I think it's because like I look for me I think where my brain goes I'm not looking at the outside I see that there's three notches here and so I think three spaces one two three yes maybe that's what it is and it has that extra overhang I feel like they're always like a half size bigger than I think they're going to be yes I think the other thing is I do think that this game kind of gets a little syy from game to game I don't feel like there's too like I don't feel like every time like okay I'm going to do this different or this different and this different again I think maybe having like secret objectives or variable player powers or something like that would help a little bit my last little thing is a little bit of a nitpick it would have just been cool if they just could have paid a little homage I think that is that the word I'm looking for to the original art for I'm having emotion a little I don't know why a little homage to the like original art for the game because I mean I'm an artist myself so I just think that would have been really cool and then I could have learned more about art and like what these different these little silly pictures what the actual inspiration was I think that would have been I like I wish that had been included that would
have been cool all right so let's go ahead and go into our final thoughts so what did you think about art Society what would you what would you rate it I am coming in at a solid seven um I I felt like I played it and I was like this is a seven sometimes I'm like I don't know but I'm like the the the the rating was a little bit easier for me to just like come to terms with because I I it's a fun game I enjoyed it it has bitting which I like I like the tiling those are aspects of games that I tend to enjoy in fact I on my drive here I was trying to think is there a bidding game I don't like but then the only ones I could think of were power GD and furnace and like trick ticking games and like what other ones are there I don't know you have yet to play an OP one you don't like I've yet to play one I don't like um and so like so those are just like overall enjoyable aspects of the game and like I mentioned in my Pros it's easy to pull out we can play a quick game and I actually like in my mind it's like a same easiness level and simplicity as wingspan they're very very different games like in my mind that's where it like Falls in in terms of like the the weightiness of the game and we can play it like at 7:00 before we have to go to bed at 8 you know so I like that aspect of it um and but like but it's not one that I just like and makes me excited like I
don't I don't feel excited and usually it has to make me feel like excited to get to that eight level so for me personally I'm coming in a little bit higher I was kind of between a 7.5 and an eight and I think I'm going to get this one an eight and the reason why I think that I just love the theme so much in this and again maybe it's just because I like love decorating and stuff um but I love the theme I I really do enjoy the puzzle what is kind of pulling it down for me is how I I do enjoy the second half more than the first half personally um I do you know there there a little bit of you know kind of some nitpicks that I have I do think that having a little like micro expansion that adds you know simply like personal goals or something that you're trying to achieve that could give you you know more points or something I think that this could become a nine game for me personally if there is you know little some expansions or stuff that could kind of change it up a little bit maybe make I don't know make the in make the decisions a little bit more interesting especially at the beginning of the game um because I really do love this game I love the artwork on it I love the theme it's super easy to pull out and teach people um as far as like a heavy strategic game this is obviously not it but for like a lighter kind of you know intro game especially intro to like an auction game um or tile placement I would I would choose this personally I really liked this um and I think it does kind of fit it fits that Niche personally in my collection so that's why I'm giving it it all right so those were our thoughts on Art Society from mighty board games how do I end
if you liked this video subscribe like comment all the things all the things to help support us it would mean so much if you have played art Society please let us know what your thoughts are in the in the um comments below we hope you have a great rest of your day and we'll see you next time hi hi pee yeah oh oh my goodness all righty we're not going to review smiling we're just going to play with baby we just going to play with the baby yeah look at you smiling