Skip to main content
Loading video...

Leaf Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 15:27

hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Leaf which is a Wonder four player board game that takes 30 to 45 minutes to play uh this one is designed by Tim Eisner and published by weird City games now before I get started on my review of leaf I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor

ker.com okay so once set up Leaf is going to look something like this where you'll have a number of different boards the first of which is this board here that holds these animal cards which you are trying to collect throughout the game for set collection bonuses at the top of that board you have this sunrack which is this kind of um game end counter where once you get past the winter Mark by cashing in Sun tokens it will trigger the end of uh the game and depending on the Play account you're going to use a different side of the board or even start on different spots uh there you have a leaf board which holds the different leaves that you'll be placing throughout the game as well as the leaf cards associated to those you have this tree board here where each person will put their little starting squirrel at the uh start marker and throughout the game you'll be trying to climb the track getting bonuses as you go and if you end the game highest on the track and you'll get some bonus points in second place you'll also get some uh secondary points as well you're going to start with two of the starting leaves in the following uh formation just to give you a little um starting spot to build from each player is going to have their little player board with the little turn overview as well as their endgame scoring summary there as well as some starting cards now there are also some additional components such as the sun Tokens The acor Tokens which are your point tokens as well as your personal mushroom tokens which you'll be deploying on those

Central uh Leaf uh tokens the turn structure of this game is actually very simple where all you'll do on your turn is you'll select uh one of your Leaf card so in this example I have this tulip pop pillar that I will discard and I'll take the next matching Leaf of that type and place it onto that Central display um of leaves and take corresponding actions as to where I place or where I match these Leaf points or the kind of Pinnacles of these leaves so for example I could do something like like this and because I touch at this point here and this point here I'll get those corresponding actions so I'd get to draw a leaf card and take an animal card but you can be quite creative or try to be as optimize these as much as possible by maybe doing something uh let's say like this now I'm touching at multiple points so I'm touching here here here and here and get multiples of those actions so in this example I would get two Leaf actions cuz I'm touching on two points as well as two animal actions now optionally if you discard two matching cards again you always have to play at least one but if you do two matching you can instantly Place one of your small mushroom tokens on the towel that you've just play so I could do something like this which is important for subsequent turns as you will soon find out now at this point if you have three or more of these Sun tokens you can choose to cash them in in

order to progress uh the round token like this and get this many corresponding uh acons and when the game progresses it will look something like this but let's talk about some more of those actions so we've already touched on the leaf symbol here and when you touch those um points you will get to draw the leaf cards to refill your hand and increase your options if you ever get to a point where you don't have any Leaf cards in your hand um and your for for to play with that with nothing there you will take some negative points you know these three negative points and draw two new cards from the deck uh we've talked about the animal cards and when you take the animal cards you're going to take a look at the display and draw them like so so if I had two I would take these two cards um which relate to the scoring track here if you remember when you cash in those Sun tokens uh when you cross these thresholds you'll get to bank one animal typee and secure those as victory points and they will score you points based on this sliding scale what you can see here in your winter Den um if you have one card it be one point two cards three points three cards six points and for every card above beyond that will be one additional point for that particular animal type you have the sun token here and when you touch those you'll simply get to take one of those Suns from the supply and if you remember you cash those in in order to progress um that track you have have the tree action which allows you to climb uh the tree

and if every point you touch you'll climb up these and get additional Suns or additional animal cards additional acorns Leaf cards Etc and if you remember if you're the highest up there you'll get some additional points at the end of the game and I suppose the most involved action is the mushroom action and when you take that mushroom action by touching those points you will get to deploy these mushrooms onto the board and when you deploy them first they'll have to go on the little side up but for additional action points you can choose to flip them uh over now these are important not only because you're going to score points based on the networks you have on the board at the end of the game so you can see I've got two uh large mushrooms next to each other much like the animal cards you're going to score these based on a sliding scale but they're going to be worth slightly uh more points and but more importantly in future turns if people wanted to say take an action let's just say a player wanted to go here like so uh because the leaf they're touching has one of my mushrooms on and I'm I've got either the biggest or equal biggest mushroom on there then I will get a sun token so um that's another way to get some passive income in terms of those Sun tokens and that is essentially how the game works you're going to keep on taking actions until somebody triggers the end of the round by Crossing that winter threshold or until three of the stacks of leaves have been depleted you're going to have one last chance to bank an animal type and then you're going to work out who has the most points uh based on and

who's climbed the highest up the tree uh the mushroom networks the um the animal card points as well as getting an additional point for every um pair of either Leaf cards or sun tokens left and the player with the most acorns at the end of the game will be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on leaf and I think we should start with the kind of key mechanism of the game which is this Leaf placement mechanism where you're touching the tips of the different leaves to get the actions this is undeniably fun and it's very satisfying the way they all kind of slot into each other and trying to maximize those placements but not only is it like a actual fun thing to try and place onto the board there is actually some decision space behind your placement here because what you have to consider is that when you place these leaves you're not actually getting the action of the leaf that you place but only the ones that you touch meaning that the subsequent players to to follow you you are creating opportunities for because if there's a big drought of leaf cards for example and you've got plenty and then you place your Leaf card in a position where there's tons of the different kind of tips pointing out there ready for the other players to latch on to that might not be such an optimal decision to make so and I love the way it all just fits together it slots together it looks cool on the table and it's just a very nice satisfying mechanism and on top of that when you add on the the mushroom deployment um as I said if there's a particular action that's running dry and that you know the other players want if

by deploying your mushrooms on there you are going to get some passive income when players start latching onto it by gathering those Suns which of course will get you a nice little injection of acorns when you C when it comes to your turn and you cash them into so a nice little touch of some passive interaction there again by strategically placing uh those mushrooms on the most lucrative spots on the board I think this game is a very fun game to teach to new players because they're going to love and latch on to this part um of the game and each individual part of the game you know all the different colored actions are very simple in their own right know simple set collection I know clim the tree um Place some mushrooms on the board draw some new cards now this is all very simple Gateway um stuff there and that's probably where I start getting kind of um maybe losing interest in this one because I think it might be a little bit too simple for me I would love to have seen this Central mechanism be linked to slightly more uh involved mini games if you want to put it that way maybe a little area control game a bit more cross contamination or synergies between each of the moving parts of this one because again in their own right it's all super simple stuff place a mushroom on the board draw some cards um Etc so definitely is tailored to more of a Gateway Market and I think if you played a lot of games um this one is going to have a shelf life I think the meaningful decisions in this game are limited as I

mentioned before you can try to gamify it through uh more tactical placement to try and restrict your opponent's next placement but even then I think you are reaching to find that strategy or find that gaminess um of it you know all in all if you take the animal action you're going to try and collect the same animal types it's not it's not rocket science just try and collect the most types as you can and when you reach that three you might want to start reaching for the next one because the you know efficiency is a lot better um up to those three cards and beyond that the return Isn't So great but I suppose I do like the fact that you can only bank one animal type so sometimes you can tactically try to push it beyond the um the threshold and catch your opponents off guard so that they have to bank something when they're not quite prepared to and therefore they might have to waste their whole next turn bolstering that animal type rather than starting a fresh one so again a very small touch there but still it's very simple um stuff climbing the tree you know nothing to it just try and get as far up uput as you can um you always want a fresh hand of card so that you can fit them in the most optimal spaces um so yeah I mean and even for me um the mushroom placement I'm always mostly leaning towards the um the networks because eight points for three mushrooms is is quite nice um you have to bear in mind that spreading spreading your kind of um your coverage a bit thinner on the board might benefit you by placing it on leaves that other

people are going to use therefore you're going to get that passive income through those Suns um or are you going to keep on trying to spam in the same area so you get that chain of those um fully grown mushrooms and get points that way uh instead so I think all in all that's quite a well balanced game where Everything feels as lucrative as the next part but it all feels like you know the central mechanism is cool and the rest of it is almost like tacked on tried and tested mechanisms that have been done to kind of nauseum really the player interaction in the game is fine you know you are again cutting people off at times by using the spots that they were looking um to use you have got that mushroom thing going on the competition to climb the tree perhaps you are trying to go for the same animal as your opponent um you know very standard uh stuff there in terms of the scalability I think the game does actually improve um when you get to that three or four player Mark I have played it at two um I found it a little bit too loose especially when it came to collecting um the sets of animals because it seems like you get way too many animals um too easily um and you just have just surplus of animals ready to be banked when you only have a few opportunities to actually Bank them so um yeah when it came to three players it was a bit more difficult to get everything done or everything you wanted done and that being said I do think the um game is played in a nice succinct amount of time it does not out say it's welcome you know you are looking at around 40 minutes to play this with you know three or four players which is nice you know anything beyond that I think it would start outstaying its welcome so it

knows what it's going for here the production for this game is fantastic as you can see it looks wonderful on the table and once all the leaves are deployed it just looks it looks fantastic you know the card quality is decent um the tokens are all good um the artwork is nice it has quite a distinct um you know visual appeal uh to this one the Box the game Sorry the game does come with all these kind of boxes that you can put your stuff in and just slips right into the main box which is a nice little touch and you know a great value for money game in my opinion okay so let's share some final thoughts on leaf and this is a difficult game for me to comment on because I really wanted to love this one and I think it's fine um for the Right audience so this is certainly a Gateway game and sometimes it's hard for me to um maybe objectively look at a game of this Simplicity because I played so many and I want to I want more involved games personally um this Central puzzle is fantastic and I would love to see a more involved game built around this this is amazing um great if you had something with the complexity of say traing with all those mini gamess but you're using those actions through this mechanism sign me up I'm all in on that but for me these actions are just too basic there's nothing interesting um going on here and you know that being tied hand in hand with the uniqueness and just the the innovativeness of this for me is a crying shame because I just want to see more of this and not so much of this um

but all in all you know when I played this with other Gamers they've enjoyed it um especially you know when I played it with my girlfriend she really enjoyed it because she's really intro into gaming and she thought this was really novel and fun so again take my opinion with a grain of salt because I like heavy Euros this one isn't that style of game so um I think if you're looking for a Gateway game to get again friends or maybe younger family members into board gaming um and you want that hook to keep them interested this is going to do that so full props to that it's beyond a gimmick it's you know it's not a gimmick at all it's it's actually a really cool mechanism um and the way they slot together is quite fascinating again great value for money great table presence I'm really colorful um and yeah it moves at a Brisk pace and you know it is what it is and it does what it does extremely well but it's not the style of game that I'm personally looking for in my collection um at this time so um I can respect it I I like it but it could have been so much more if they urii it and made again a heavy game built around this fantastic Central at Leaf mechanism so that is my final thoughts on leaf

Progress saved