Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arcs* is Obviously the Best Game of the Year

Transcript 18:33

the truth is ARS is obviously the best game of 2024 but and I know you've already spotted it there's that tiny asteris that asteris that's what I want to talk to you about today because this box right here is fantastic I could go on for 30 minutes about the brilliant trick taken the thrilling dice rolls or the fast-paced Tactical combative gameplay but I won't why because while the single box is an excellent experience it's not my game of the year that's where this asterisk comes in the blighted reach expansion this colossal box is cardboard at its most indulgent it's luxurious overthe toop and audacious it's an ambitious Vision brought to life through paper and ink if the base game is a finely tuned tightly designed masterclass in game design arcs with the blighted reach is sheer Madness manifested into cardboard form it's a wild and unrestrained EXP mention that redefines the game in ways you wouldn't expect that's my game of the year and that's what I want to talk to you about today what is the blighted reach it can be tough to summarize the blighted reach so I'll give you an analogy the base game of arcs it's like a perfectly composed instrumental track clean logical and inviting enough to draw you in it's elegant and smooth and it's fairly easy to dig digest the

blighted reach expansion though that's the break core remix of the same song The Familiar piano Melody is there but it's torn apart rearranged and slammed with chaotic pounding drum beats it's a wild disorienting cacophony of noise and Rhythm like being thrown into a schizophrenic nightmare but if you look closely enough there's a sense of structure to the madness the additions take a core that is extremely strong and then layer on this amazing story and a symmetry that is both equal parts Madness and genius the BL reach doesn't just add more stuff like a typical expansion it completely redefines what the game of arcs is so yeah the base game the one the developers want you to play first is all the core mechanics it's the dice rolls the court cards the trick taken it's everything you need to learn to play well I wouldn't say it's an easy game it sits squarely in about level five out of 10 complexity then after three or four games of vanilla arcs you can start incorporating the leaders and low expansion this adds characters with unique abilities that add pretty neat player asymmetry into the game you can mix and match these leader cards with the various lore cards to make a nice little unique player build that you can then experiment with and since you already have a strong understanding of the game it's easy to Dive Right In it doesn't increase the complex too much so it's about a 6 out

of 10 level of complexity now now here's where it gets dicey for most people this form of arcs is already The Sweet Spot you can play hundreds of games of arcs with leaders and lore and have a fantastic time but then there's us the obsessive ones the ones who crave more the ones drawn to the insanity that is the bed reach the bed reach is a three act mini campaign game You'll Play three games of arcs with the same people back to back until one of you is crowned the winner simple enough right wrong the blighted reach cranks up that complexity dial to about 9 out of 10 it explodes your decision space bends your fragile little gamer brain until all you can whisper is asymmetry it is a giant messy 10 to 16h hour Excursion that will push the limits of what a board game should be and I godamn love it for that so I wanted to discuss the three key aspects that makes ARs and the B reach my game of the year and also talk about a few reasons that it might not be your game of the year which is totally cool Act One embrace the mess look the truth is that you need to come to terms with the mess of it all the blighted reach can get pretty gnarly and at times can make you feel like an illiterate fool trying to keep up there's just so much weirdness from the bizarre fate abilities and player objectives to the multiple political factions that can be at play and the huge variety of events all of this is left out of the rule book and thrown at you as you go creating an

unpredictable and constantly evolving mess of things happening around you blighted reach challenges you to Grapple with how its mechanics interact the ru book covers the basics but there's no handhold in with the 24 Fates and their unique functions and rules you'll need to stumble through and learn as you play but that's part of the fun it's a complex mess that eventually clicks into place uh slowly revealing the Brilliance behind the chaos the scope of it all is purely obscene over the course of three games there's so much variety so many things going on and so many potential Pathways that sometimes you'll just need to absorb the mess and sit back and enjoy the ride this also means that mistakes will happen a lot of rules can be confusing things like the council call to order negotiation actions event cards edicts Summits and general the first Regent and outlaws it can all seem muddled when you read the rule book or watch how to play but once you're actually playing it does start to click some other aspects like the blight and the Free People they're easier to grasp but they still add another additional layer of mental weight top all of this off with the Extreme Rule breaking that each fate can introduce all of the exceptions all of the one-off cases it takes actual patience to Think Through the interactions that each player can do and then find out what it means in a given scenario I know I've made errors but I needed to sit down focus and process it all but in time a great thing started to happen the mess became art

that's the beauty of it this constantly evolving monstrosity of a game expands into every nook and crevice of your psyche very few games are able to completely take hold of my thoughts like the blighted reach did and after every game all I wanted to do was dive back in and explore this cardboard monster in a new way the blighted reach takes a game that is understandable he focused then adds so much mess that sometimes it's hard to see what's really going on it's challenging in a way that is divisive but this messiness is exactly what lets you see the game in a new light every time you play it opens up and allows you to explore the game in a way that you might have not thought was possible it's an evolving complex work that takes a level of patience to cut through and see that Brilliance behind the fussiness so yeah the mess is the first aspect of why it's so good and let's keep going act two The Narrative storytelling in games is often undervalued in games like brass or Dune Imperium The Narrative is often secondary and more of a flavor than a drive in force but some other games though aim to make memories through a story games like Twilight emperium or War of the Ring are designed to create moments where there's a narrative fork in the road and how a decision you make will shape the story being told arc's the base game is more like like the former yes there's personality in these leaders and lore but being the rebel isn't about leading a rebellion or when you play as the overseer you definitely

feel oppressive but it never feels like there's a narrative to your horribleness it's a consequence of wanting a tight game but still trying to incorporate a decent amount of asymmetry there's just not much of a story being told on the other hand the blighted reach though is much like the ladder it has that added benefit of a longer play time about 8 hours more than a typical game but it uses this time to create a journey for each of your faction called Fates each fate is immensely unique and asymmetrical and the beauty of this system is that it truly does feel like an evolving story for example in a recent game I was the advocate in act one but I failed my mission and was unable to prove myself to the Guild overseers in my anguish I had to change my fate in act two and take the role of a pirate so I gathered my forces boarded my flak ship and pillaged all my rivals from that success I went on to the third act as a formidable pirate but now I needed to hide my treasure with a secret map only providing hints when absolutely necessary to all of my rivals of where I hid everything in one piece even when a fate is unsuccessful you still feel that ripple effect take the magnet for example they have a brutally difficult mission in act two but the monopolies created still persist even after they fail in act three or the belie believer if they don't make it through Act One their cards still exist in the action deck an everpresent reminder of their failure in other words there are consequences to decisions and to

failures or to success which is key to creating a memorable story plus the three act structure is Practically Perfect for storytelling by the time everyone reaches that third act there is legitimate interest in genuine care about seeing how their fate unfolds with 24 fats eight available for each Act there exists a mind-numbingly large permutations of what Fates might exist throughout the three acts of any campaign the sheer variety of stories that can be told is functionally endless it's an honest design miracle that everything holds together and creates a real feeling of narrative the real weight to decisions it forms a shared Journey that people are eager to see unfold and is an excellent vehicle for a memorable experience act three immensely engaging for 12 plus hours like I said earlier the blight reach Builds on arcs at its core even though the box for the bed reach is about four times as large the beef and potatoes of this Buffet is still the fast-paced tense aggressive game that ARS masterfully crafted with this the fundamentals of the BL reach is still a ruthless and deep knife fight but the pace slows down enough to allow for more deliberate sense of narrative the blighted reach introduces a ton of new game mechanisms meant to enable people to explore their fate for example at the very start of the game everyone is sectioned off into one corner of the Galaxy and in a normal game this would be absolute chaos but here players are prevented from attacking one another

through the watchful eyes of the Imperial ships this gives a bit of breathing room for people to set a plan into motion likewise not all combat will be directed at Players themselves the titular blight is a tough opponent that can wreck Mayhem if left unchecked and it creates a mutual enemy for most Fates to have to contend with with it isn't until later into the First Act that players really start to throw daggers at one another and by this point the game board has a fully evolved into a complex state of Imperial ships player units free cities and blight as Ambitions become set the tensions ramp up and what was once a slow burn explodes into an allout blood bath with massive swings and threats from all sides while the pace may be slower than the base game the constant risk of losing everything and the pressure to achieve your Fate's goal leads to a high highly engaging struggle for control that last for hours and hours and look there's only so much I can say but time itself is valuable and if I'm going to have myself and three other people sit in a room for potentially 12 plus hours that interaction has to be meaningful the blighted reach delivers and all that great momentto moment gameplay you find in the Bas arcs but then amplifies the story the tension and all of the sheer volume of content thanks to that ingenious Fai system every decision feels impactful and the growing own tension just adds to the player's interactions it's an experience that Rivals some of the best moments I've ever had in games now let's talk about some cons I would say there's really three main cons that I would like to

touch base with you before I conclude one arcs plus leaders and lore versus arcs plus blighted reach in a weird way we need to differentiate the forms of arcs into two different games ARs and its mini expansion of leaders and LS does feel substantially different than ARs and the reach unlike your typical expansion like ti4 and prophecy of Kings where new stuff is added new mechanics new units and new content but the essence of the game Remains the Same the blighted reach changes the very nature of the experience there's a new level of diplomacy a new level of asymmetry but at the cost of time and complexity it's not really fair to assume that if someone likes arcs they will automatically like the bled reach and vice versa while both games share the same core mechanics once you sit down at the table with three other people you'll realize how different these two excellent games are and I've touched on this in another video I made but the base game of arcs really is the bed reach with everything extra Stripped Away it's the game at its absolute simplest the B reach is on the Other Extreme though it's everything you could mechanically hope to add on to the base game there are two sides of the spectrum of game design where one is tight controlled fast and the other is messy lengthy and paced for a deeper narrative ultimately it comes down to a matter of preference I know which form of arcs I enjoyed more but I can completely understand if people prefer the snappy 2-hour version over the often convoluted

12-hour version Point number two King Mak is still a thing it shouldn't come as a surprise that the designer of root isn't afraid of kingm in his games and arcs is no different while I think kingm is toned down in arcs compared to root there is still a very noticeable presence and it can be frustrating to some people for example in a recent campaign we were on the final chapter in act 3 when a Vox card crisis activated populace demands this led to the highest ambition marker to be reset and the very next turn the next player had a chance to declare for two different Ambitions the thing is it was so late in the game and our forces had been so white it was starting to become known what the path of victory was for each player that player who had to choose and declare an ambition had the opport to pick between two different ones and it was obvious that selecting either one would practically ensure a win for two different players likewise if they picked no ambition a third player might have taken the lead none of these paths seemed to lead to their own Victory but in the end they picked the more friendly rival and that player ended up winning the whole campaign thanks to that final ambition marker this isn't inherently bad game design but it can lead to some bitterness among certain types of players it can feel like the outcome was ultimately decided by one player making someone King the experience as a whole was still narratively satisfying and the moment to moment was still enthralling but I can see why people might find this form of kingming or King slaying to be a

bit frustrated it's a divisive aspect of game design that I would love to hear your opinion on con number three component issues while not a major critique there are some component related issues in ARs and the bad reach which I did find a bit annoying I'll give three really quick examples first multiple people myself included has noticed that the board is strangely warped maybe not warped but it just doesn't sit right on the table I've had this board out for well over 100 hours and it just isn't properly resting I might just have to put a book on it or something but this is actually fairly unusual from highquality game design companies second some pieces were just flat out damage when I open the box like take a look at this ship it's as if it was built in a system controlled by your opponent it doesn't affect the gaml but I am a little worried about quality control when I don't usually see this kind of stuff I've started using the plastic pieces exclusively but I just feel like I need to mention this third there's a few aradas and misprints in the blighted reach that just feel a bit weird one card for the steward is just a complete misprint another card that we had proms with was Gil loyalty which is a lore card that mentions you do not bury Gil cards which led to a brief discussion and a real book confusion about what happens when outrage actually occurs we also encountered the term blockaded from our boys at tet Imperium it only appears once on one lore card but it was still enough for us to be like I don't remember seeing this in the

arc rule book now I know it's a complex new game so I expect some aradas and fixes and quality control issues but I just feel like I have to mention these things for the sake of my own sanity They Don't Really ruin the experience for me but there were brief moments of frustration and if you don't realize these zeratas exist at all you might be legitimately confused with some of these cards conclusion arcs and the blighted reach are both brilliant games and both absolutely deserve game of the year the thing is I do see them as two distinct and unique experiences independent of one another there are people I know who would be more inclined just to play arcs and leaders and lore and other people who would be super down to play Bad reach and the thing is I'm I'm a bad reach kind of boy I love that long sh experience the journey The Narrative the tension and exploring that mess it's all so good and so well-designed and it took a fair bit of actual work to get a hang of the game and to understand the mechanics and everything that the B reach incorporates but it does have a certain acquired taste that you get which just makes it a bit hard to go back to the base arcs truthfully I have a strong admiration for the bed reaches ambition and design it is clear that there is a powerful vision and the team behind it had the resources and dedication to bring it to life it isn't very often that something as large and as impactful comes out I think if you're looking for something to eat away at your mind instead of Doom squirreling your Knights away give ARs and the bad

reach a go in conclusion arcs the base game is 8.5 out of 10 with leaders and lore it's 9 out of 10 the blighted reach is a thunderous 9.8 out of 10 and my game of the year for 2024 thank you for watching as always and bye

Progress saved