Heroes of the Shire: Light & Shadow (B) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Okay. Anyhow, final grade. Am I Am I taking crazy pills? Let me check this. Phantom B pop. Yeah, should say 9,000. Yeah, right there. Right there. Where was it? It was not there? Yeah, it's not there. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So, I'm not I was like, yeah, it's normally there. There's no way they get rid of it. People love that sort of stuff. Okay. Final grade. Do I want it? Yeah, I do. I feel like the video is really well made. Uh did a great job like getting me immersed into it. Can you do it? You've done it before. You've released it before. This looks like a big ambitious project, but you put out another one. And you have $126,000. And you're not doing minis. You're doing acrylics, which is a whole different ballgame.
So, yeah. I'm not too worried about the can you do it. And then the how much is it? It doesn't feel great. And I think that's a lot on just how you presented it at different points. Like I want to go back to that video. And my first impression was this is a smaller game. And I like that. Like it's not huge.
Welcome to hero.
And maybe it's just at the angle. But yeah, they don't I don't think Whatever. Uh and then we get to like the $270 price shock. But then eventually, like 20 minutes in, we finally get to all right, here here we go. Like these are like the good stuff. And I just felt like it could have been better interweaved throughout and should have. So, final grade still solid. And the main image I feel like is definitely poor. I feel like it's a bad main image. There's so much great stuff to potentially showcase. You know, you're hitting stretch goals. You have like a really awesome table presence with the game. You have a nice shot of what the box insert is going to look like. And we get a couple minis that you might not even notice if you if you're just not then it's just spice it up. Give me something here. All right, like look at that showcase of those components. The Queen Alice. Like that looks I would Look at those Look at those freaking wooden pieces. Those look gorgeous.
Show me the acrylics. Show me the money. Show me 35 of them. Give me Give me the playtoy thing. Uh so final grade is B. I think it's a B. Cuz at the end of the day, I feel like this could be an A if we just kind of do what I like to call shotgunning all the information at people where it's like, all right, we're going to front-load We're going to front-load. So every single awesome thing about this that's going to convince you that you should pay $216 or whatever it is is just going to be pop pop pop pop pop really quick. Oh, it's up here. Good I did not see that. So I'm glad it's up there. But you know, is everybody going to Is everybody going to take the time to look at all six of these? Like this one where it says not the back now. Where's the other one? Up to 88 acrylic cities. Like that was a great piece of information that was only there once and it blink and you miss it. And most people aren't going to look there.
47 tactical combat maps. I don't think this is the great spot to spot like that good stuff. Uh I feel like it should have been like right here as I'm scrolling down. And they did to a certain degree, but I don't feel like they did it nearly as well as they could have done it. And so at the end of the day, I think it's a B. But I could see this being an easy A. Yeah, I'm going to go with a B. I I'm leaning B minus, but I really like the fact that they said to their audience, "Hey, let's just put it to a vote. See what people think about this." I personally love that sort of stuff. But let me know in the comments below what you thought of my grade for Hero of the Shire Light and Shadow or check out their game found link down below. Or click to follow my Kickstarter link down below cuz I'm doing one later this year to help do game found origins. And also, if you have some ideas of what potentially I could do because I was just going to do digital stuff, but I think I am going to work on a couple pieces of merchandise that I personally think are pretty cool. Uh but any suggestions are appreciated. Have yourself a good one.