Skip to main content
Loading video...

Threaded: soft yarn, hard logistics - TCbH Review

Transcript 7:01

Currency is the backbone of good board game design. Well, actually, economics is. And technically, economics is the backbone of pretty much everything. But specifically for our purposes, I mean currency by way of actions, resources, exchange, limitations. These are the points of control, the lens through which almost all satisfying gameplay is derived, which there are a lot of games that do fascinating things with abstract economics, but it's really how threaded Osprey's new game of needles and points manages currency and the limitations there within that really caught my eye. In broadest terms, Threaded is a programmed worker placement game where each round players take turns adding their workers to available spaces. Then, only after everyone's added their workers, you start resolving each of those depots in sequential order with players who place earlier getting priority. Several of the spots have to do with acquiring thread in different ways. From choosing from the random pulls at the beginning of the round to trading out with discarded scrap to getting whatever unclaimed slop spits out of the rather adorable bargain bin dice tower-l like device. With this thread, you'll be crafting tapestries, your main source of points in the game, though fundamentally worthless until you also claim commissions, which dictate the points you get at the end of the game for different colors or patterns included in your completed tapestries.

And aside from some one-time use tools to be claimed that allow you to bend the rules of certain depots, that's pretty much the game loop. place workers, resolve depots to get threads, tools, and commissions. Or spend thread to claim and create tapestries, which once a player has completed their fifth tapestry, the game ends at the end of the round and the player with the most points wins, which all of that would be dandy if a little run-of-the-mill if it weren't for the fact that all of your thread can exist in just two states. You can have a poultry four hovering in your supply or up to six can be placed into the slotted space at the top of your player board, aka your needle. And while more can be added to your needle, it must always be threaded from the left or right. Meaning the sequence of colors must remain consistent. You see where I'm going with this? So, of course, when paying for your tapestries, it's not enough that you have the appropriate colors or amounts of thread hovering somewhere in your needle. No, it's that you must construct it using thread paid directly from your needle, either all from the left or right in the sequence of colors your claim tapestry card in hand requires from left to right. And thus the clever and depending on your perspective diabolical game of preparation, sequencing, and perfectly um well threading the needle comes to pass. Threaded really commits to the bit in a way I appreciate. Altogether, it's pretty abstract, but you get why you're

doing what you're doing, and it evokes the thematic implications really well, which in turn makes understanding what the game wants you to do pretty simple. Though, actually pulling it off is a pretty tough nut to crack. Fortunately, for the game's fairly methodic and idiosyncratic nature, there are a couple points of slack that can make your ruinous mistakes a bit easier to recover from. The thread on your needle can be bumped off once you hit capacity, adding to the left and bumping off the right, or vice versa. And likewise, as the game goes, the scrap pile becomes more and more abundant with discarded thread. And the rate of exchange when grabbing the scrap is incredibly generous. You're still limited by your capacity, but it gives you ways to start setting yourself up quite a bit better. All things considered, I found Threaded to be pretty clever and a little bit challenging. a tad crunchy, but certainly not cozy. At least not in the way that we may have been collectively trained to think of threadcraft in general or more mundane themes. That sounds terrible to say, but you know, no orcs or goblins or spacecrafts in this one, but I find myself in conflict with that feeling that something about tapestries would have to be cozy.

Certainly, there are cozy and comforting elements to the history and legacy of anything to do with threadcraft. But at the same time, textile manufacturing is one of the oldest forms of cultural expression, artistic expression that our human civilization has. So, of course, it has room to be storied, technical, and deep. and why should it have to be dumbed down just because it's not what hardcore games typically look like? But on the other hand, I think it's still worth pointing out that this is a game that you're just not going to be sitting down with your non-gameoriented nana to play with just because she busts out three quilts for charity on a weekly basis. And beyond that, this game is rigid in the way that some spatial arrangement games can be without it being a spatial arrangement game. That meticulous sequencing of thread, everything coming from the left or right and having to push things back and forth was something that broke Mrs. TCBH's freaking brain in playing this game. And she routinely hangs out in Gloom Haven and Ark Nova with no problems whatsoever. She didn't say that she hated it, but let's just say I'm not expecting her to be dying for this to hit the table again real soon. That said, she did enjoy the supplied material for the make your own first player token and commitment to the bit.

Though, prepare for individually stickering your cubes if you want the textured look on them. So, if the theme is appealing to you and you like games where it's a relatively narrow rule set, but the challenge and fun comes from navigating your way past the rigid obstacles the game sets up in front of you and having to ring the most out of the tools that you're given. Especially if you have an interest in sequencing and interesting ways of managing currency and resources, then threaded is likely going to be up your alley. And that's our review. But let me know what is your favorite game where there's been an interesting rift in how resources or currency are managed. Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for doing all the things that help us grow. All of those likes, comments, subscribes, checking out our Patreon, and of course sharing just our videos across the interwebs, all helps us do what we do. But beyond everything else, thanks for being such an amazing community. You know, I've been Jack for the cardboard Harold.

Progress saved