Game Manufacturing Q&A with Anne Kinner of Leder Games
Transcript
All right. So, allegedly we are live. Uh if uh if anybody out there is, you know, hanging out in the comments, please comment to let me know that you're out there. I'll be pleased to hear from you. Uh but hey everybody, I'm Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire. Um and I don't know anything about game manufacturing, so I brought in an expert. Uh this is Ann Kenner. They are my colleague at Leader Games. And uh Ann, do you want to tell us what your official job position is? Yeah. What that what it means? Yes. So, I am the director of production and logistics at Leader Games. Um, and that means that I am in charge of all our manufacturing for our games. Um, and everything that has to do that. So, that includes like quoting, R&D for componentry for new games. That includes all of our reprints for things that already exist. Um, and also like safety testing and all sorts of that. So, if it comes to making the physical game, that's in my zone. Um I also do the um I manage our localization printings with our language partners. Um and then I also uh do the logistics from our factories to then our um warehouses in our different territories.
That's awesome. It's a lot of stuff. That is a lot of stuff. Okay. So, I mean, obviously we're here having this conversation because an absolutely bonkers quantity of tariffs have been uh placed on imports from China by our lovely orange overlord. Um, and so I think the the first question that most people ask is the question of why don't you just publish board games in the United States? Why do you do it in China? So, this is a big question. Yes. But let's just let's just dive in. Let's do it. Yeah. So, it is a big question and uh the answer is so like complex um for so many different reasons like there are historical reasons why it's happening. There are like so many there's so many different reasons. that the biggest reason why you cannot just move the board game production that someone is currently doing uh to a US factory is is literally that the ability to make the same project product does not exist in the US. So for example at Leader one of the games that we print the most is Root and I could not make Root in the US currently without without material that came from China.
So, I might be able to even make the product in the US, but I would still have to pay like there's no way that I would be able to get that material other than from China. So, what are the materials that we're talking about? I actually think it's important because these are everyday materials. Yeah. Uh, and I I would like to say that this is not um either unique to our industry either. This is something that's going to affect tons of different industries is where okay, the product's made in the US, but a lot of the materials are not. Um and for us uh in board gaming the biggest one is going to be plastics. Um plastics production and certainly plastics production on the scale and the intricacy that is required for things like you know a minis game doesn't exist in the US and it certainly doesn't exist at a price point that is doable for people to make board games.
Um but that's also things like that includes like um certain kinds of dice. Um, so you know, if you're doing like injection molded dice, that's going to be more difficult. If you're doing things like metal coins, that's going to be very difficult. Um, if you're doing other things like um even things like punchboard, there are certain kinds of like more um complex punch board uh that certain that US manufacturers just don't have the equipment to do. Um, and it can range for all sorts of things. you want to do holographic card, like a Pokemon holographic card, there aren't going to be a lot of places that are able to do that for you. Wait, really? Even the holographic cards? Yeah. So, there's certain kinds of things they'll be able to do, but certain kinds um especially like the the masking that happens in like Pokemon cards or if you're wanting to print on top of a holo foil, those are going to be more difficult. You might find people who can do it. Um, but it also and then that might be okay, they can do it, but they're like an artisan studio and if you're planning to like order let's say 60k of these, well, you might have to wait two years. Oh god. So, so this is it's not necessarily about like, okay, somebody might be able to do this, but their ability does not necessarily match what is currently what someone is capable of in um, China. So, there's that as well.
Makes sense. And you know, we talked a bit about cost, but um so what kind of cost differences are we talking about? Like if you're going to try to print I guess even a card game in the United States, could you do that for comparable pricing? Yeah, so I haven't priced anything in the US recently. Um uh but I would say that it probably ranges um to like five to 10 times as much as it costs um to print in China. Now that obviously the um what we think the landed cost so like the cost of what it takes to actually get a game to like its final destination aka a warehouse is probably much much less uh from when you're actually shipping from you know one place in the US to the other. So, so that will decrease the overall landed cost of a game, but not enough. Um, in fact, that 10% if you were doing a simple card game and that card game, you know, retails for $15, well, let's say it was 98 in in China. Well, now it's $10. So, now you have a $5 margin, which is not a margin you want on a product uh of that kind. So, you know, it's it's very different and it's a much of a price difference that the tariffs that we're currently seeing, it still could be cheaper to print your game in China even with the tariffs.
Okay. So, so like obviously there's a whole range of things that people of differences in board games. Um, but there are certain ones where it there's no way you would be able to make it here. So, what about options outside of the United States? Like I noticed there's a bit of excited chatter on Blue Sky the last couple days about Oh, well, I heard from Longpac and they said that they're going to be have they have a factory in Vietnam and they're ready to print. So yes uh I am getting so many emails about people who want to tell me about their um factories in Vietnam. So and which uh is true a lot of the Vietnam has been a um some place that people have had a rising interest in opening factories.
There are some people who even have had factories in like the last couple years. It's something you're seeing more of. Um people have been working to sort of diversify where printing happens for a little while. That's certainly been part of the conversation in the industry. But um the thing about uh the Vietn Vietnam is not a um country that has had a lot of printing. Um Vietnam is in terms of um manufacturing is really known for clothing. Um so it does not have the same um expertise in the country. It also does not have literally have the equipment. Um, a lot of printing equipment is very large and very specialized and so you not only need to have that equipment on like a um in like a large warehouse where you're going to have it as like set up for like a production line. Um, but you also need the people who know how to use that equipment and who are skilled and who like have the project management experience and who have the communication experience. Another thing about Vietnam is also um uh the ports.
So are your where is your port in relation to your factory? Do those are those ports like set up to handle things like board games? Um also when you're thinking about producing in places like China and Vietnam, um paper's greatest enemy is of course moisture. Um what does Vietnam have a lot of uh moisture? Uh so that's also a consideration where there it may be more difficult to um do certain things that require a lot of paper drying. For example, like um punch board is one um uh game boards are sort of the nemesis uh as everybody wants a nice flat game board. Nobody wants a nobody wants a wobbly board. But um you know you introduce some moisture into the process of making one at any point and anytime that that board goes somewhere else that has a different moisture level it can warp even years later. So that's a big concern and that is something that like then needs to be managed but if you don't have the expertise that's going to be something that you may see. So like there is going to be this rise but it is also this like how capable is that factory of giving you the same quality uh that you have come to expect and that's not just as a that's not just as a publisher but that's for our consumers and it's the same problem that you have when you talk about um us as well because it's it's about the end product being what people expect and that's not necessarily
possible although I'm Sure. I'm sure with the Vietnam factories that as most of them are run by folks who are experienced in the market that they will very quickly um if not already are are getting up to speed. Nice. Okay. So, we talked about you mentioned expertise. So, when you when you're talking about expertise in um in uh Olivier um Okay. So, um, when we're talking about expertise, what range of expertise are we talking about? Because I remember you and I had like a casual chat the other day that actually made me want to have this conversation about how even like printing on neoprene versus printing on card stock requires different knowledge and like a different ability to Yes. to work that equipment. Correct. Um, well like neoprene so working with neoprene versus working anytime you're working with a different material. So like paper, old paper is similarish um in that like you kind of it has similar properties um and neoprene being a fabric is completely different of course um and um uses a completely different um printing process. When you print on neoprene it is um a process called sublimination which is completely different than the fourcolor CMY um in in publishing generally use something called offset lithography. um or digital for some things. Um and they're completely different. They like have no
relationship to each other basically in the terms of like how you manage colors, how you um deal with that and like expertise. And so, you know, that's it's very different for those things. Um, and when you're talking about expertise, that is something that like uh I very much rely on the people that I work with who are so much more knowledgeable than I am, especially about the particular equipment that they're working with. Um, and is invaluable and also sort of a secret kind of the secret part of like the cost of a product or the secret part of like choosing a factory. Um, and like even as someone for me, you know, I've been working in print for like 15 years now. And I'm also a print artist. So like I'm very nerdy about print. I know a lot about print, but there's still a lot of stuff that like I don't know about like, you know, and stuff that like, you know, plastics is something I've learned a lot about, but there's still a ton about plastics I don't know about. Um, and there's still a ton about paper I'm sure I don't know about. Um and and that there's a big reliance um on that partnership with a factory in relying on their expertise.
Um and when talking about like printing the US, that expertise just doesn't exist. Yeah. The other thing I want to kind of circle back to you is you talked about things not being the quality that um consumers and publishers here in the United States expect. When you say that, what is like a range of things that would fall under that comment? Yeah. So, I think one of the biggest things is um which seems so small um but is so important is actually card stock when you're thinking about like a card. Um for example, like I have right next to me I have a Pokemon card. Um and there is a particular way. So there's a very particular stock that they use for these. And that stock is part of the feel of that card and it is what makes that card feel a certain way. And this is the same with like magic or like any other of the like tcgs is that is so intrinsic to the feel of the card to the weight of the and like people will know like just feeling a card you'd be able to feel the difference for people like consumers are people who actually do these and um to I lost my light um to like not be able to um like use the same core is a huge difference and that is of course also So, if you have to match between an expansion and a uh and a base game um where you need to like mix the decks
together, if those decks are not of the same exact um stock, that can completely like change the feel of the game. Um and so that's a huge thing that our consumers are don't know, they're used to, but they are used to a very particular stock and if you change it on them, they will notice. And let me tell you, people will tell you about it. They will email customer service so many times. I'm really glad I don't work on that end of the office. Yeah. I mean, and I'm even I've even offset from our our customer service team. I've uh you know, being in production, I I never directly get the emails. I just get the the sad walking into my office and them telling me about it or I get the spreadsheet with like all the different complaints about things and but it's still very sad when it happens. Um but yeah, so there is that particular quality um of like just yeah and the basis level card stock and then of course for all other materials as well. So that could be like the cardboard um that a game box is made of like whether if that's thinner or thicker and like its availability in that territory. Um because you know there's a lot of stock you know stock can be very regional like paper stock um for example you know if you are working in Europe you're going to be using stock like European stock for the most part um and then of course there's Chinese paper stock there's all sorts oh my god there's so many different kinds of paper
and if you change those in any way it will make the game feel different it can make like the inks feel different so you might have to do different color correcting for your printing to make sure that like a board that was nice and blue last time hasn't gone completely green or completely red. Um, you know, these are all the things that happen. It's it's not just as easy as like, oh, well, you just make it somewhere else. It's like that has become an entirely new product at that point because it is using completely different material. Um, so much so that like you could not submit the same safety testing. I would have to completely say new do new safety testing because it would be considered uh entirely new material. Wow. Okay. I want to circle back to safety testing a second, but Olivia has a question. Uh are all Leader games using the same stock for the cards? Um yes. So we use a standard So they don't only use the same stock because we use multiple manufacturers. So they are not exactly the same in like in like you know you can buy like different brands of paper but they have the same properties. So, for example, our cards are generally 310 um GSM. Um and that is the same across uh all of our games, at least as far as since I've been here. Um I think it's for all of them.
Um who knows about Fort because I've done Fort. Um but that is certainly and that's generally true. So, I also worked at FFG and uh I worked at Asma Day, but I mostly worked on FFG stuff. And like the cards for all of their um like a lot of their games are all the same stock. Um and that's like to keep that same feel. It also like it can contribute to like the feel of a studio. Um so like obviously a studio that uses a heavier stock like we do. So like a 300 and above that's a very nice that's a nice stock. uh if you're using more like a 250, that's a lot thinner. Um and so like that's going to feel cheaper, that's going to feel less nice. And you know, depending on your game, that's going to be fine. Like you know, if you're doing Cards Against Humanity, you don't need to do a 310 GSM card. Um but it is um you know, it is something in it leader that like we do try to keep that very similar. In fact, um when I'm writing um RFQS or requests for quotes, so like when we request um pricing from a factory and that means I have to give them like the specs, um I a lot of times I'm literally just copying and pasting from something old because I don't want to accidentally give them the wrong one.
So I'll be like, "Okay, this is the stock we used for like this kind of thing last time." Then I'll just straight copy and paste it. Makes sense. Okay. So safety testing, you know, the other thing that I think people I've seen a lot of comments kind of floating around about, oh well, you should make higher quality American things and like we've already been talking about quality, but like not, you know, in addition to China like sort of being optimized to produce like high quality board games because of so many years of relationship with factories, things that come to the United States are also safety tested. So what does that entail for a game like ours? Thank god we're not marketing to like tiny children. Oh my god. No. Uh that's why our games are 14 plus. Um also because our games should be 14 plus. Um uh so yeah, safety testing is something that you have to do for all the different territories that you actually sell your game into. So we don't just safety test for US regulations. We also safety test for UK um because they left EU and EU regulations. So we generally test for we test for all three. Um and that is not just for us but that's also like for us selling it into different territories for so for like our distribution partners as well so they don't have to worry about that. Um and that's something we have to so that's something that actually our manufacturers will I I ask them to do that at the end and then they arrange that for me for the most part. You can have safety testing done in the US. I I've done that when uh I've found products in like a catalog that
have needed that or they haven't had it done or there's a regulation changes that that also happens all the time where regulations get updated and you're like well now I need to get this other test. Um so that happens but safety testing is a big thing and that's also um making sure that the products that you're being made are going to pass that safety testing. Um there isn't anything that uh I've never had anything fail safety testing. Um so like it's it's not likely to happen. Uh especially because most of our uh things are pretty um most of the things in board games aren't that dangerous. Um the things that would be the things that you're going to get caught on are generally age grading things. Um so if and that's for like kids games. Um they're going to have the most burden of that. If you're doing uh a game, you know, like Root or Oath, which is a, you know, designed for adults, uh, is mostly paper products and then is like, you know, some wooden plastic that is not sharp at all. Um, although that's actually an age rating things, too. Hey, you can have whatever you want that's sharp in a 14 plus game, I guess. Bring back lawn darts. Yeah, bring back lawn darts. This is my political stance from now on. Bring back lawn darts. Um but yeah, so it's it's not that big a deal for us, but certainly for other um publishers that may make games for younger ages especially, that's a much bigger deal for them. And and that is it can be quite an expense as well. So
Amanda has a question. Which country has the most stringent testing requirements? That's um a good question. I would probably say that the EU does. Um, the UK is also doing some stuff right now that is annoying. Um, uh, that's been a nightmare. Um, but I would say probably the EU. Uh, and that's because they require they have a lot more requirements, um, for some of the chemical and like flammability testing stuff. Um, and that's also just like the EU tends to be a little bit more regulatory about chemical stuff, uh, chemicals than the US does, especially in like consumer products. So that's just a kind of a basic difference between like the US and the EU. Um, but uh, a lot of the testing is really standardized, so it's really easy to like ask a factory um, and be like, okay, what do I need? And then also it's um, you know, by territory. So, if you only ever plan to sell in the US, you don't have to do that other testing, but you better only ever want to sell in the US because it can be a big problem if you try to be you can you can actually uh have it stopped and not be able to be sold. Wow. Okay. So, I'm going to put Tim's uh comment up here, but uh I actually want to ask a question regarding this. So um he said that you know I've long thought US consumers have
become too alienated from the process of making to your point shown by the thinking that you can somehow magically just transport tools without the knowledge. So how long would it take if we were going to invest in manufacturing United States? Like let's say that the money part isn't even the issue. Yeah. Even aside from it costing a lot way more than people are willing to like absorb when buying. Yes. What would this involve? Wow. Um, so it would involve, so there's a couple different things that it would involve. First of all, it would involve, uh, so there's all the tech, all the machinery. Um, so that would have to come in. And guess where that would be coming from? From China. Um, so that is where the bulk of those machines are.
Some of those machines are incredibly specialized. Um, also the ability to fix those machines. uh the manuals for those machines which may only be available in Chinese um traditional or simplified um and neither of which I speak uh or read uh and uh the replacement parts uh may not be available in the US. So if that ever breaks, you are going to be waiting two to six weeks uh probably for that piece because that piece might not be might have to be machined um if it's specialty enough. So that's part of it. Um there's also the expertise obviously in those machines which is not here. Um and it's not just the expertise in the machines themselves but the process. So the actual process of so one of the things that you can have made in the US but uh is not up to the standard that I would expect most of the time from what I have seen is punch board. Um, so simple punch that you like punch the pieces out and throw away the skeleton.
That that is something that like most people don't think about, but let me tell you, when you see really really crunchy, not great punch board, you'll notice. Um, and I've seen it and it's gross. Um, it makes me sad inside. Uh and like that's you know making punch board is is an art because it requires as I said paper is very sensitive to moisture. When you make punch board you have to put glue on stuff and that means moisture and so you have to glue paper on both sides of a piece of chipboard. Um which is what the punch is made out of. Um, and then you have to cut it and you have to have very sharp knives and you have to have people who know how to make those knives cuz it's basically like you're making a cookie cutter every time they make those dyes for a punch board. They're basically making little very sharp cookie cutters for all those little shapes and then they're putting it on like a board and then pressing it down into the punch and that's how you get punch. If that is not made well, if people don't know about how to do the tolerances well, if they don't know how to center that punch um on the on the on the knife, um if they don't know how to make sure that the front piece of paper and the back piece of paper are aligned correctly so that when you punch it out, the front piece and the back piece are both centered on both sides. That's all expertise. That's all has to do with learning that on the job about knowing what that is and then also having someone who teaches you that there. Um
that's oh my gosh, please don't eat the punch board. At least if you do, do not tell me about it. Um and it has been safety tested. Um but not for human consumption. Uh but yeah, so there's this like so that's starting with literally just the machinery and sort of the people power behind that um machinery because like that is one of the most important things that like you can't import um you can't import experience. Um you can't import like institutional knowledge. Uh you can't do that. And it's also like you need the warehouse space to do this. You need to live, you need to be able to like um have this place in a place that's by somewhere where you can get paper stock reasonably. You need to be somewhere where you can ship stuff pretty easily. So that means either by track or by rail. Um you uh so there's there's all that kind of stuff that goes into that. Um obviously if you have this, you're also going to need to have safety OSHA stuff in your own place. So that means you're going to have to know those kinds of things to like start a warehouse or a building like this. Um and so that's all sort of experience that is very hard to just suddenly have.
Um, you know, if if someone today was like, "Okay, it's my goal that I'm going to like start a new um factory that's like comparable to like one of the like best or better Chinese uh publishing factories or board game factories. Um, I would say you would need at least 5 to 10 years." Oh god. you would need at least 5 to 10 years and you would have to actually like hire people um as consultants to come in to do that. So for context, I'm going to say it took me six years to do my doctoral program. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Because it's there's there's so much stuff and that's like not even getting into plastics. Oh god. Especially for like minis. So, like the US does injection molding plastic, but like minis are so complex.
Um, and they're so detailed and they have really complex things like like weird undercuts and like all sorts of these things about like how you actually form this piece together. And then if they're multi-arted and all that different stuff. And so like that that machinery is also very specialized. And then also the people like sculptors and people who know how to look at this and know whether or not it can be made and all this different stuff and that's and then also you still would have the problem of okay so you've made this beautiful factory but the infrastructure for the paper stock or the ABS plastic pellets or the glues for these things or the holographic film if that doesn't exist in your in your space it's it's the same problem where you're still going to have to be going to China to get these materials.
That's wild to comp to contemplate. So just I don't I don't know if you can answer this question. Like maybe you can. I don't I don't know if it's okay. So when you're paying for manufacturing in China, you know, we're talking about the cost of importing materials. Um how much of the cost is the materials versus the labor? Like is there any world where that would be worth it? So generally when I see pricing I am seeing pricing that is um material based um depending on the factory they will give it to me as itemized. So that means like that each component has a price listed or they'll give it to me where it's just like one big lump. So I can usually ask for itemized if I want to but some factories are different about the way they automatically give it to you. However, that price is kind of a lie because it doesn't include the sort of intangibles of the relationship. So, it doesn't include things like um the time that my rep spends and answering all my emails. It doesn't the time for pre-press stuff that someone does at the factory. So, it includes these sort of like unnoted costs to it. Now, most of the time, like you pay for samples, you might pay upfront or it might just be part of like the larger like fee that you pay or sometimes we'll just roll it into some other like express costs in an invoice. Um, but like you might you
might pay for those or you might it might look seem like they're free. Uh, so like the price you see isn't necessarily a great reflection of like the real actual costs of things. Um, I would love for a manufacturer to sit down and like talk to me about how they actually do pricing and all that stuff, but like I I you know, I know it's there, but I don't I don't actually get to see it in pricing, unfortunately. Um, so I don't I don't have a good way to like to talk about that. Yeah, I mean, it's it's worth asking. Uh before I circle around to like another kind of topic but like set of questions about working with Chinese factories. Um you know other people have talked about oh well I you could use Europe. There are factories in Europe.
So what is I guess kind of the the situation if we were to print there both in terms of cost uh but also in terms of like the options for components that are available there. Yeah. So Europe has a long-standing especially like Germany and France have long-standing printing traditions. I mean Germany is home to the Gutenber Gutenberg press. Uh I could talk about German printing forever. Um but have long-standing print print traditions. So it's no surprise that often that German games and like French games and other games h have been printed in the ter their territories for a long time. Um and that has given those particular especially in Germany which is a huge game gaming place um has given uh those consumers a specific um sort of brand or specific expectations of what those games look like. Those expectations do not match what a US consumer would necessarily want out of a we'll say a non Euro style game. So there is an expectation of like Euro style games that they might be in like you know it's going to have a simple cardboard box. It's going to have like simple barely flimsy like rule sheets that are like folded maybe. It's going to have maybe some punch but it like it's not going to have a fancy tray. It's not going to have a lot of fancy plastics. It's not going to like have an organizer, you know? You're not
going to get like um really fancy chits or something like that. It's going to be more wood, more the things. And like I like that style, but it's not the style of every game. And so the problem is is there there are there's kind of almost like a cultural difference that's happening there. Um where they're really good at that. Um, and if you want that style of game and if that's like your publisher style, in fact, like Root has a lot of similarities with those styles of games. Um, like that's that's a great place. That's a great option, but that's not going to work for everybody. That's not the only style of game that's out there. And so that's not going to be a valid choice for people, especially moving a product that already exists.
Um, it's far different if you're considering a new product and you're like, "Okay, I have these, you know, I have to go within these specifications." But you can't move a game that has a lot of plastics or you can't move a game that has like special trays um to just like a completely different manufacturer that doesn't necessarily have those capabilities. Yeah. Um, kind of on that note, uh, you're mentioning uh that um you know it's hard to transport like again it's already been manufactured in one place to another. Um yeah, can we talk some more about that? Like could you even get something like root from one factory to a neighboring factory and have that be not a hot mess?
So in terms of like moving production from one factory to another. So, uh, moving the production of an existing product is one of the most annoying things that I've had to do as a um, as a production person. Um, because it basically means completely redoing the game. So, it is like working on a new game. Um, because you have to uh, you know, give the new factory all the specs. You have to do all of the like what would be R&D in a new game, but now you have to like be okay. You have to take this piece and I need you to exactly match it. But this factory may not buy stock from the same place. They might not buy the same paper stock. It might not get their plastics from the same place. It might not have the exact same capability. Um or like you know it could be hey you had um excuse me you had done like a screen print on this thing before but they can't sprint and print over here or I mean that's probably not going to be one but for something that like some specialty thing or like you have a silk screen or like um something like that where one factory can do it and the other one can't. Um, so that would either require that you change something. So you make a change like that and that's not something you like to do. Uh, unless you're doing like a new addition of a game in general. Um, or if you're doing like um or if you're doing it as part of like a you can make
those changes if it was like for example like root has a has a plastic dye in it and like let's say that we changed that to wood. That wouldn't be that weird for us because wood is a part of our stuff already and people really like wood. Um, but it would be a big change and it would be something we would probably have to warn people about before they opened it up and were like, "What is this? Is this like a fraud copy? Like this would die in here." Um, and so it's just such a hassle. And then I won't get into color issues because we could talk about that for like three hours, but like having to match color from printer to printer is incredibly difficult and it's very time consuming because if I'm working in China or anywhere there's a time difference um and I can't go there.
Um so it takes a lot of time. It takes a lot of back and forth and it's um it's just really difficult and you're just trying to ma matching anything is just really really hard and it just takes a lot of time and a lot of effort. Um and it it turns something that can be a simple retrint into basically having to do a whole new product. So what I'm hearing is that even if we were to start printing new games in other places, ones that have been previously printed in China, it's not an easy transition. No, not at all. like it would it would be it would be an incredible drain on my time and also probably on graphic design's time as well. Um, so that I mean it's a it's it's a big deal and it's also like there's also this funny thing where um depending on how old a product is um and how well documented that product was um so many little details can get lost um in sort of the years. uh especially for products that were like done um when a company was newer and maybe didn't have like the best processes or like the best um uh like sort of paperwork upkeep. So sometimes you're like I literally have no idea like what colors these are supposed to be. Like I know what colors they are now, but that might not necessarily be, you know, colors can slip over time. And so like I don't know that anymore. And it's like, well, I can measure like the piece now, but the
piece now is like that could also change a little bit because in manufacturing there's always a little bit of a wiggle room. Um, and that could be really difficult or like okay, I know this is plastic, but I don't know which one. And so those little details can get lost. And those the kind of things that like you know the factory might have the institutional knowledge of this product but this new factory doesn't right and so that's another sort of like hidden little part of a product that you don't think about. So on that note Olivier wanted to know and I think we talked about this a bit curious how this is affecting games in the pipelines like the oath expansion. From what I understand, we are just going to continue and hope that by the time we send things to print, uh things aren't quite as crazy. Yeah. And that's the thing is like we we weren't we're not ready for any of those like at the moment to like immediately handprint and go production. you know, we're already working on those projects with the factory, but they haven't sort of they they become sort of a critical point in like our new projects where it kind of leaves creative zone and then it kind of comes instead of being like I'm not really involved very in the beginning and then once like the game becomes less of like a dream and an idea and becomes like more physical then I get involved and then I get more and more and more and more and more involved and then eventually it just becomes mine basically or it becomes like 90% mine because I still rely on our our creative team for like, you know, approvals. Does
this look good? Is this what you wanted? Have all your dreams come true? Um, but it ends up in my zone and that we weren't close to that with either of them. So, um, you know, it's it's kind of a hope hope by the time we get there that um the tariffs will have uh hopefully come down at least um from where they are right now. Uh but you know it's it's one of those things where it's kind of like you know we we plan to make these products and we will. Uh and then a question this might be difficult to measure right now. Is there any sense that Chinese manufacturers are panicking as much as state side publishers are? Um you know I I I I can't speak to to what they are feeling but I I can talk a little bit about what I've seen. Um I I would say and I have very good relationships with their manufacturers. I've been working the two main ones that we work with I've been working with for like at least four years if not longer for some of them. Um so I know them really well. So we have good relationships. So there's been a lot of commiserating back and forth uh in emails and like uh you know people reaching out to me um and doing that and so there's definitely they definitely know what's happening obviously they you know they work with a lot of US companies um and I think that there is a lot of worry uh I have certainly gotten lots of emails as I said before about working about people opening up factories in Vietnam and sort
of alternate sort of strategies. Um, I've also gotten uh emails about like strategies that factories are doing to like things that they might be able to help us with. Um, and then also other things like I've been getting so many logistics emails lately, which is the logistics company we work with I love. So, I'm like, "No, we're not going anywhere." Um, but yeah, so there's been a lot of a lot of the like chatter in my email of people like reaching out to me has really like been bumped up a notch, but um, so it definitely seems like there's stuff going on there. But it's also it's hard because um as a as a as a medium large publisher in the industry, we're probably a little bit more um equipped than the much smaller and more independent firms to sort of uh work within this the political space at the moment. Um, so that's also I think that they we're not the ones that they're that they're reaching out to as much.
Um, which in some ways is nice for me, but also doesn't make me feel great about other people what they're going through. Yeah. All right. So, this kind of leads around to, I think, a harder question, and it's one I wanted to ask you because it comes up in comments all the time. Um, so let's be real, like the same people who don't think that minimum wage needs to go for the United States, uh, are now kind of pulling the well, you know, maybe we should have become so dependent on cheap labor from people we're taking advantage of in other countries. So, what's the the economic reality of that business relationship with China? Like yes, it's a lot cheaper to produce things over there. Mhm. But is that still a fair exchange?
Yeah. So, it's a it's such a interesting it's such an interesting question. Um the larger question, not the stupid questions that people ask about this that aren't really questions and are just then saying nonsense. Um but it's it's a it's a question that so much has to do with sort of the historical um background of sort of manufacturing in the US and also just generally in like how societies that like grow in terms of like individual like how how societies grow and like through industrialization and through sort of manufacturing into sort of more um higher wage um and like technology based jobs. So this is something that happens and like what happens is that they once you sort of cross into this like higher level um technology sort of and other jobs people don't want to go back to uh working in a factory people don't want to do industrial work. So like there's also this question of like you can see this in lots of different industries it is difficult to hire people to do manufacturing in lots of different jobs that still do sort of small US-based manufacturing.
So um so you can talk about it from that standpoint of like you know people talk about like oh build up American manufacturing well like it's not that easy and there are like larger societal like historical movements that happened that made that happen in the US. Um and there's also the part um that talks about um Chinese workers. So, and that's the part that can get my hackles set because it often I think is couched in in terms which are often um I would say quite racist um against Chinese people and Asian people in general. Um and uh it's very you know when you consider the fact that like people talk about like unskilled like slave labor and manufacturing in China but they want to bring that same manufacturer to US workers. So are they unskilled or are they you know skilled American manufacturing workers bluecollar salt of the earth people like which one are they? Um, and so that's like the language that is used to talk about um, people who work in factories in China is often like really upsets me.
Um, that's also because I have been working with people in China for uh, in doing board game manufacturing for eight years now. I have been working with some of those people for like I think I've been working like for eight years uh or for six years with like one of the people we finally got to meet last gen con and it was so nice um and like that's that's my work colleague like those are work colleagues of mine who are incredibly like skilled who are talented who are professionals in the same way that anyone who would be doing a job they are the same as me they are exactly the same. And when you even talk about people who are if you're talking about people who are working in the factories, they often they are also very skilled. They are often very talented.
Like there are people there who know these machines. They know how to do these things. They are incredibly detail- oriented in packing our games. Um uh you know that these are also like you know these are often people who are recontracted every year when the contract negotiating goes up. Um also uh high rates of women working in uh manu in uh uh board game factories. Um so that's also something a lot of people don't know. Um but also like in terms of wages and other things like I can't speak to that. I that's not a part of my relationship with them. Um but also wages are different in different countries as different countries have different economic you know backgrounds or different economic situations. So like people getting paid differently in different countries is a reflection of that. Um whether or not that's like good or bad or whatever I that's not a question I can answer. Um sorry I don't have the answer to geopolitics. Um but uh there are things that like people can do and people have done to make sure that factory work is is safe for people.
Um part of that is safety certifications that factories can get. For example, there's something called the Fama certification which is family and something I can't remember. Sorry. Uh but it is a Disney certification. Um, Disney is actually one of the stricter certifications that can be done and that is for any manufacturing partner who makes Disney merch because obviously Disney does not want a scandal where you find out that your Frozen 2 doll is made with child labor. Um, so that is uh one of the big things actually one of the big thing is child labor in that. So making sure that that's not happening and making sure that like even even workers that are younger because of course different countries have different working ages regulations um are protected. Um it also has to do with safety protection. There's also there's a bunch of different certifications one I think it's the BSI.
Um and so there are all these different things and like making sure a factory has those making sure that it's workers. Um and part of that is also people coming back. So, um, people coming back to a factory is something. So, if people work there for a really long time, that's a great sign because it means that like that job is work roofing. Now, do we all work jobs that we don't necessarily love? Yes. Can I guarantee that everyone loves their job in a factory? No. But not everybody loves their job. That's just the way of the world. But I I I do think that a lot of the there can be a a sort of undercurrent in that conversation that devalues the um expertise of of the people uh of of Chinese people who we work with in production. And that is really really upsetting and is is quite frankly just not based in reality.
Yeah. So, what I'm hearing here is that we're not talking about unskilled labor at all. These is this is highly specialized work from people who have spent years developing their abilities in this area, getting certifications in this area, like evolving alongside our industry to help bring our products to market. Yeah. And there certainly are areas like in any manufacturing where there is a level there's a level of skill. Obviously somebody who's you know doing a packout so putting the different components in a box has a different skill level than someone who's like you know running a press but that's still a skill like that being able believe me being able to sit and pack out a bunch of boxes with different componenties for a game that is not in your language that you have no idea what these things mean.
like I don't know what these little bits of wood mean and like how they relate to each other and I don't know if there's supposed to be 17 or 19 of them in this game, you know? Um because most of the time they're like prepacked, you know. That's that's a skill too. That's very much a skill and should be um you know given just as much uh you know respect as anything else and as much respect as it would get if you were talking about somebody doing that in the US. um talking about bringing manufacturing. Well, that's part of it. And if you're going to respect someone in the US for having a bluecollar worker job and all that like you know pull up your bootstraps talk that people do like you have to then do that have that same respect for someone in another country who is doing that same exact work.
Yes. Um I also do want to point out like one thing that we you and I aren't experts on this but the fact is too the exchange rates like when we talk about salaries and payment one of the reasons things in China are cheaper manufacturer is simply that the um sorry my child like please please this is my life at work um but um um you know I think about this, you know, people who have traveled. You know, I used to go to Egypt and be amazed at how far my dollar went. Um, but it was big money to the people that I was spending my money on. And it's simply in part an exchange rate matter.
And so one of the issues with bringing manufacturer here to the United States, it's that we have to pay in a currency that doesn't go the same distance here as it does in another country and like correct. May that remain the same um with our dollar kind of in flux right now. Yeah, there is, you know, there's a larger economic conversation that obviously comes apart of that and it's one of those things where like, you know, we make product in a system. We are all part of a system unfortunately. Um, and like, you know, the greater the greater like exchange rate question is, you know, a larger question about like capitalism and those kind of things, which we probably don't have time to talk about. Um, but it is, yeah, that's part of it too. And that's that's certainly a part that like it should be talked about, but you know is also like a very big question uh for a um a very small little board game industry. So I don't it's not one that we are personally going to solve. Um although the question is very important and I think talking about the sort of economic realities of both like um uh the dollar as like a power in the world and what that means um both historically and also what it will maybe mean in the future.
Yes. All right. So um if anybody has any remaining questions now is the time to ask. But uh just to kind of sum up if we don't get any um no we cannot just magically transport manufacturing to other countries. You can't even do that from factory to factory without significant consequences. Yeah. Um uh the labor that goes into Borgi manufacturing in China is incredibly specialized and done by people who are working in ways that we can't fathom without years of investment. And uh anything else? Um be nice to all your production people right now. Uh all of our plans have been ruined. Uh the day the first Harris were uh announced, I had spent like an hour and a half that morning um basically sitting down and planning out like our print numbers for the rest of year and our scheduling for everything, which not only affects me but affects like our finance team, our sales team, uh our conference team, like having the bandwidth to do like changes and reprints and stuff like that. And yeah, so got to have to redo all that. And also, but also I don't know what's going to happen in the next two months. So, uh, be nice any stuff right now. It would be nice to know. We have no idea what we're No, I don't know what I'm doing right now. Who knows?
Uh, and then here is a question. Do you think more people will move more to card games? Um, I think if so I definitely think that if these tariffs exist for longer than like I would say six months just because of the how long it takes a game to like get through like come to market from from like the original iteration. I would say I if they last more than six months um that we will definitely see a change in like what sorts of games get published um in terms of like complexity of componentry. So you will I think we will see a lot simpler games come to market or designs that have been a lot more stripped down um from what they might have been cons like um conceptually originally. Um, I think people's I think people's asks in terms of what they want in a product will get a lot smaller. Um, so I think that that will it'll absolutely definitely have an effect on what uh sorts of games publish and also what sorts of games like um are popular or what sorts of games um sort of get bought by retailers and like distributors and stuff like that because also it's like if you can manufacture in the US then you might like have a better you might be able to get a distribution where if you print in China you may not be able to go distribution to like retain more of that um on that margin.
So I think it'll definitely have an effect. The followup was do you think that publishers will not distribute to the US anymore? Oh so I I don't really know mostly because I has so little to do with our distribution channels. Um that is that's that is clay our sales um our sales director or sales managers um uh sweet spot. So I don't really deal with that but I I I can imagine that it is going to have an effect on um the distribution there. Um the only thing is for uh so I don't know how like tariffs I don't know how tariffs effect like other company like a UK company sending games here that were made in China like I'd assume that still has tariffs but I don't know. Uh I I I don't know if that's true. And so if that uh if that is true, like that will absolutely affect it. But if they don't get tariffs, then it would actually behoove them. And also the US is a huge market um for board games and tabletop RPGs. So like a lot of people in other countries, I've heard this before, are really worried because a lot of their customers are US based. um we just have a lot of people who play board games. We have a lot of people and a lot of them play board games. Um and so it's a huge market to sort of be closed off from distribution. But I think yeah, some people are going to have to shut up distribution channels just because they
can't make the numbers work with tariffs. Yes. Uh sadly that's a slightly bleak note to end on. I wish that I had something more helpful. Uh maybe the news will change, but um let us hope, right? I I live in hope. Look, we just got cut off from rare earth medals and China isn't buying all the planes from Boeing that it was supposed to buy. Maybe we'll crack soon. We'll see. Um but but Ann, I want to thank you so much for coming on and talking to us uh about all this because I feel like it's there's just so many things that people don't know, including me. like I work at Leader now. I didn't know. Um so thank expertise with us. Yeah, thanks for having me on. I I'm so glad we uh you know, we ended up chatting about this at work and you're like, well, let's come talk somewhere else, too. And um yeah, it's really fun. Like I I do love talking about this stuff um usually in happier times. Um but yeah, I think it's really important for people to know like ho how the production actually works and like how sort of globalized it is and how like you know no product exists uh without globalization. Um and we are a very interconnected world and even the little industry of board games connects to so many different places in the world and that's both a good thing and currently sort of a bad thing.
You know what? I'm going to take this advice. We can end on all power to the worker. Oh, all power to the worker. Absolutely. Every worker everywhere, all across the world. Uh, thanks again, Ann. Thanks everybody for coming. Um, and as usual, if you're watching this later, please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming. Bye, folks.