3 Board Game Reviews - Lancelot, Ten, Cartagena
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm doing something a little bit different and taking a look at three ball games and reviewing them back to back in quick succession i'm doing this really as a catch-up tool because i've got so many games building up that i need to review i just haven't had a chance to get to so you might see a few of these coming up in the near future after the three games i'm looking at in this video are lancelot 10 and cartagena so without further ado let's get into those reviews here we have lancelot which is a 2-4 player game takes 60 to 90 minutes to play published by wizkids this one is a kind of point to point movement style game that takes place on a board like this where you're going to have your player piece and you are going to go as far as you want clockwise around this island here stopping off at these spots if you wish to so you can stop here at the joust and when you do you're gonna have to stop at the first spot and collect the items as you go so you can collect like a a helmet and maybe your next turn you can push on to the next spot and get a sword you're next enough for that you're going to get nothing and after that you're going to get a shield or you can just kind of um go to a certain point and move on to your next thing should you want to the um strong stronghold here works in a very similar way where you can collect different weapons and again the longer you wait you can get better weapons at the end of these different columns and you can visit the distant lands here where you can collect these different boats of these different colors the merlin spot here lets you collect these potions lake here lets you potentially grab excalibur and you've got these two spots here which work very similarly the percival
one here is to complete a mission and the galahad one is to pick up a new mission i might be getting those two mixed up but that doesn't really matter and then you can stop off at the dragon here where you can trade in all the different weapons and potions you've collected and maybe even excalibur to get a number of points and once you're done with that you can potentially go to morgana here which will let you go around the board one more time if you've invested in it and after that you'll stop off at the grail spot here which is actually my favorite part of the game where if you end up finishing the little rondelle the little track before the other players do you're going to sit here and you're basically going to farm almost like a points currency up this track where every time it gets to your turn you will move your marker another spot or if you're not in the first place you can move two spots so you're kind of incentivized to push as fast as you can to the end and because you can end up getting rewards for doing so but of course you're going to be sacrificing taking other actions so again your pace is going to be dictated by the other players other than getting points from slaying these dragons by trading in these weapons you're gonna have a virtue board here where you can have a bunch of different objectives that you're going to be working towards so for example this one here is have the most of any type of weapon have one of each one of each ship um you know have the most of the pink ships um you know have seven of these white ships or and the most helmets or joint most helmets and so it's all very simple little missions you're going to be able to complete any of those or all of the
missions once and no more than that and you'll get the number of points here in this small shield now the big shield relates to another part of the game where when you get back to the round table you're going to have the option to invest in a boon relating to any of the different objectives by placing your disk on the relevant spot so let's just say i wanted to um boost my ability in the um let's see uh benavir action which relates to the joust i'm going to put my little um disc on the child to show that i'm better at that action and that can be i'll go to and fro throughout the game so somebody could snatch it off me if they wanted to in a later round but that means that from now on i'm going to be able to move twice down the dike um down the jazz track so i'm not so stalled by the passage of time the same applies to the stronghold where you can move two at a time and the merlin one you're going to get one of these potions instantly and you've got ones that just give you victory points the arthur one lets you invest in one of the virtues by getting the bigger amount of points so if i visited arthur i could put my disc on this on a mission which means if i complete it by the end of the game i'm gonna get seven points rather than the five so it's a good way to get more points out of your turn it wasn't that you collect shipped cards faster and all the different things like that and that is essentially how the game plays out you're going to keep going for a number of rounds and then you're going to tally your points from your dragons from any missions you've completed and from the difference between the grail track so when i mentioned that each time you're going to go up this grail track um the person
furthest in the lead is going to compare the difference to the person furthest behind and you're going to get those points equal to half the distance between you so another way to get victory points so i'm going to be brutally honest with my review here this one was dull as dishwater this is pretty much as bland as you can get for a kind of euro star game i suppose the only interesting thing about the game is that grail track when i didn't really think it played a big enough part i'd have loved to see this just be pure victory puts or something and balance the rest of the game out accordingly because i love that idea of you know i want to be quick because i want to start farming these points but i still need to achieve all the other stuff and what's going to be the biggest advantage for me to do am i going to go slow and focus on doing missions and slaying dragons well i'm just going to go boost right to the end again and start gaining those points without doing any work at all and i also do like this idea of boosting all your different regions or your ability to participate in those different regions but i thought a lot of them were pretty minor in what you could do and they weren't terribly interesting but i didn't know that i didn't dislike that part of the game um some bits i did dislike were how kind of low and insignificant the point scoring was you know it didn't really feel like you were achieving much in this game it's a very low scoring game um and the missions themselves are pretty damn bland you know just having you know one one shield and five red five red ships it's just it's just not interesting stuff though the objectives are just so straightforward collect these um rewards and so on and because
they all fluctuate as the game goes on like if you could only ever have say um seven ships at any time then people are automatically gonna start getting rid of their cars which means that it's gonna be easy for you to achieve certain objectives later in the game because people have already achieved them and moving on to the next thing so by the end of the game it always works out that everybody's kind of achieved the same thing but at different times and you're not really worried about what you have to do there's not much competition to get these done so yeah despite there being nothing you know overtly wrong with the game it's just not interesting it's just a very vanilla game and one that's not really worth your time in my opinion so that is lancelot here we have 10 which is a small box card game for one to five players takes around 30 minutes to play and this is from the design team who brought us point salad which i thought was a solid little set collection style game so i had some quite high promise for this one so the objective of this game is to try and collect these four different colors and you're trying to create runs of consecutive numbers and your biggest run in each number is going to be points at the end of the game so you can see here my green i've got a run of four so that'll give me four points if i bridge that gap you know if i end up gaining a five and a six that would be a run of seven um this is only gonna get me one point that's going to get me two points and that one's going to get me three points again you're trying to get as many different runs as you can and the way you do that is you are going to be using a pushy like system by drawing cards from this deck so you're going to basically keep
drawing cards and or stop when you like and you are trying not to go over the value of 10 because as soon as you do you are going to bust and something will happen which we'll talk about shortly however there are two different types of cards in the deck not only the numbers but you've also got these currency cards as well and which will actually subtract from your total value so this will actually be six and then minus four so i'm actually at two so i've got a lot more room and um scope to keep pushing my luck so that'll keep it up that'll keep it moving until i go up to four now but maybe i really want this six because it's going to add to my blue run i really want that too because it's going to add to my red run there as well so again i can keep pushing my like or i could take the cards so when i take the cards i can do one of two things i can either take the numbers here or i could take the currency so let's just say i took the cards here i added this six to my run adding it here like this adding the two to my run okay getting you more and more points but then each other player who isn't whose turn it currently is not are gonna take a number of these tokens from the bank and add them to their basically their pool of money and those tokens are going to be really useful because as the game goes on and people potentially bust you know if they drew too many cars and they went over 10 or whatever there is going to be a bank for me um which at the end of your turn if you choose to take cards you can spend a number of these tokens in order to purchase specific cards you want so maybe i really wanted this four
here so i could spend my four tokens and end up buying that one and adding it to my score zone so that's why you want currency now you additionally want currency in order to purchase some cars that come out instantly so whenever you flip cards from the deck and you get one of these wild cards here so this is basically any seven so it can go with with any of the colors which could be obviously very useful and very flexible and you don't even have to commit these until the end but as soon as you reveal one of these whoever's turn is is going to be interrupted and there's going to be an auction that takes place place where people are going to be using these bid tokens in order to acquire those cars and of course the highest bidder is going to gain that card now additionally when you end up busting you will take one of these white tokens which are going to account for three currency it's going to get going to give you a lot more pull when it comes to those auctions and when it comes to buying cards from the market um normally you can only ever keep a total value of 10 of these tokens in your pool but those white tokens do not contribute towards that limit so you're going to keep on taking turns until the whole deck has run out and then you're going to calculate points as discussed before so i'm just getting to my thoughts um on 10.
so generally as a rule i tend to enjoy pushy like style games i think they're generally a lot of fun and it's pretty hard to get them wrong and i'm going to say this is a good quality pushy like style game however i do have some issues with it i think it's slightly over engineered um there's some things i do like the extra layers they've added on here like i really do like this idea of when you draw these currency cards if i can just find one here that they actually subtract from your limit so you've got this kind of push and pull thing where you're gaining that gaining gaining and all of a sudden you go back down and end up pushing your leg even more to acquire more cards so i do like that kind of fluctuating value that's really cool and when i also like the dual currency system you know do you want the points or do you want the actual um tokens themselves to give you some more leverage when it comes to the auctions and when it comes to buying very specific cards you need from the market that's very cool now the one thing i really don't think this game needed and i think it's it feels very thumbed in and it feels completely jarring to the rest of the game is when these wild cards are drawn so when you draw these wild cards an auction is instantly going to start and it just brings the whole game to a halt and it feels very frustrating at times when it's your go and auction card there's a big building around and another auction card a big building round it just brings the game to a kind of um almost like a a chandering kind of staggering pace which is like completely just completely blows the momentum of the game out the window and just does not feel like it fits the
rest of the game at all now i can understand why they do it because it gives more kind of value to the actual tokens themselves but you know what i would have been fine if they just added the tokens in just to buy cards from the market that's completely fine and again i thought this was just an extra layer that the game just did not need and it just again it felt jarring to the rest of the game i like the idea of keep pushing your luck until you get certain cards and building these runs but yeah everything is fine apart from that auction thing which just did not feel entirely it didn't feel right for the game for me um i also think that this one maybe has uh it kind of stays a bit too far away from being what it is really i think there's other games out there in the market that do what 10 does but in a lot more streamlined and a lot more simple way i'm talking about games such as coloretto games such as push i think they're just slightly cleaner designs that work a bit quicker a lot easier to explain because they don't have that there's extra levels of rules which aren't going to be so intuitive to some newer gamers who you'll probably probably be playing this game with so again it just felt a little bit jarring in a number of ways but again if those other games didn't exist i would say this one is a good um kind of collection worthy game but ultimately for me it's not quite up to the standards of his other tried and tested designs so that is 10.
here we have cartagena which is a simple family weight racing style game two to five players takes 30 to 45 minutes to play designed by leo colovini so this game you are going to build up this uh modular track basically and you can vary this map on depending on how long you want the game to be ranging from you know four tiles to say eight tiles um and you can see each player here takes control of a color of these pirates so each player is going to have six of their player pieces in their color and the objective of the game is to try and get all of your pirates from the jail cell here all the way to the escape boat the first person to get all of their six there will be the winner and the way that you move these pirates is to play cards from your hand so all the cards you're going to acquire throughout the game are going to match symbols which are on the board here so you can see you've got the hooks and you've got the little tankers and the chests and so you're on your turn you're going to play one of these cards and put it on the discard part so let's just say for example i played this treasure chest onto the discard pile as the yellow player and i'm going to have a look at any of my pieces any of my yellow player pieces and move to the next uncovered so the next revealed treasure chest earth and i can pick any of my porridge to do that so i could move this piece to this treasure chest i could move this piece to that same treasure chest because there's none in the way bearing in mind that we are going to skip over any treasure chest already stood on or of course i could do this one this one or i could even choose the
one right at the back so let's just say for example i chose the one right at the back because this when i play this one i'm going to jump all the way to this spot here so the idea is that we're trying to be as efficient as we can by utilizing the position of other people's pieces and your own pieces to jump as far as you can with a single card play now if there's not a single one of those symbols in my way let's say i played this gun card here and i played this one then i can move straight to the boat because i got nothing as an obstacle of that card type now sooner or later you are going to run out of cards because you are not acquiring them when you play them and when you do that you are going to choose one of your people on the board and you are actually going to move them back on the track and that is going to depend on the amount of cards that you get so let's just say the black player here chose to move this character back they're going to move all the way back until there's a spot with somebody else on there but a maximum of two other pieces so let's just say this player wants to move back now they'd have to go all the way back past this group of three and then share a spot with this one and that's going to determine how many cards you pick up so if you've gone on a group with two other pieces then you're going to draw two new cards into your hand to play with to move in further turns and if you go with one other person then you're only going to draw the single card and that is essentially how the game is going to play you're going to keep playing cards till one person has all of their pieces onto that escape ship at the end so i actually think that cartagena is
quite a clever little game and because there is some quite interesting decisions here on how you're going to manage your hand of cards now if you keep getting the same card it's great because you can almost stand on these blocking spots and if you play that card again you're always going to go to the next spot so you can use them quite efficiently and fly up the track with a single card play but you have to bear in mind that players behind you you know your opponents are also good might have those cards in their hand and capitalize on your position on the board obviously again going really far up the track with a single card play so you almost want to keep moving up but as you move your kind of last piece up you want to be creating gaps between you in order to be obstacles and kind of um you know barriers for people to play cards so efficiently so that's quite interesting on how the way that works you know sometimes you're taking these very long satisfying turns as people get neglected at the back you might start taking more kind of fiddly finicky turns where you're only going one or two spaces up at a time so balancing the two is quite important to make sure that you haven't got any stragglers right at the back meaning that you're going to be really inefficient and moving them together you always kind of as you're only as fast as the person at the back now i also like the economy on how you actually get the cards back into your hand in the first place because yeah you can push really far but sooner or later you are going to run out of cards and you're going to have to fall back and start taking other cards but you know knowing which one to play um or knowing which piece to move back is quite important because you know if i played this one yeah i'm going to go back one space but i'm going to go draw one card
but if i've only got chests then i'm only going to go one space when i play my next card so again it's always important to know which one you want to play so that you're not going too far back but also in the future turns you can get a big boost with the cards you have in your hand by skipping over loads of different spots so yeah i do like that kind of play interaction on moving backwards and forwards utilizing the current situation on the board and reading it to get the must the most you can with a single card play i do like the way that the game length is variable you know if you want to play a relatively quick game you can't just play with a few of these different um tiles because again they are modular and it's not going to really impact on the way you play the game to be honest i think optimally i would not ever play with the full arrangement of these tiles because it does start to take a bit too long despite me really appreciating how simple the game is and how fun the game is to be honest it is quite one note you know once you've done it you've done it and it really isn't much more to explore again you are always just reacting to the cards you have in your hand sometimes you're not going to have the cards you want which is just going to be the luck of the draw really but that's you know that's not really a slight on the game because it is so simple it is a family weight they're tailored towards a lighter audience which is yeah fine i'm not too um i'm not gonna criticize the game based on that luck factor um but yeah i think once you've played this one two three four times you've pretty much seen everything it has to offer but maybe if you like that familiarity of playing the same game again and again something with no rules blow very simple straightforward but it feels different you know i don't really know any other game that uses this system of you know
reading the board and jumping up and falling back it's quite a straightforward very intuitive game but again my only issue is that it is um a very a very direct game that you can clearly see what the game has to offer after a couple of plays and that you're not going to find some miraculous hidden strategy that that wasn't there visible before so again very one note but still a decent design the uptime for the game is very good because you are simply just playing a card from your hand or moving one back and you're pretty much done with your turn so you're not just sitting there waiting for other people to resolve their actions you know even in a five player game you can't play this one pretty rapidly and not be bored when it's not your turn um aesthetically i like the way the game looks you know very clear symbology on the board um it's nice that these are modular so each game is going to be different you're not always playing with the same symbols and there is some added variability in the game box with some little kind of rules tweaks and even like a little scenario you can play through but to be honest it is all just slightly built on this key mechanism and how the game works so to be honest if i'm going to pull out a game like this i want to play it in its simplest purest form which is the version i've showed you here i also feel that you need at least three players to get the most from this game i wouldn't really consider playing with two um but you know four i'll be more than happy where then five maybe a little bit too long for me but still i've got no real issue playing at that length and you could always just cut the ball down to make it a shorter game anyway so actually just scale pretty well um that is if you're not playing with two players so overall i actually think that cartahania is a very good family weight gain i don't think it's going to really
cut it if you're always playing with just you know just dedicated gamers i think it might get old quite quickly which it has done with my group if i'm honest but if i had say a young family you know you'll start to introduce games like this to to them and you want something with a bit more meat on the bones there is actually some decisions to be made here and you can actually learn a lot from the way you play these cards and how to play them at the right time to get the most from them so there's actually not you know despite being very simple in fact almost as simple as it gets it's not a brainless game and there is actually some quite interesting decisions here i particularly like the way that you have to get cars back in your hand by pushing things back and when is the best time to do that but yeah a nice design and one that's not quite right for my collection but i wouldn't really hesitate recommending this one to um you know to that family weight niche you know people who do want to introduce these games to their family and younger children so that is cartagena actually a very pleasant experience