Emberleaf review (review copy provided)
Transcript
Hey, this is Mike with the OneTop Co-op Shop and today I'm doing a review of Emberleaf's solo and competitive play. And disclaimer that I got a review copy of this one. In Emberleaf, one to five players are competing to home as many of their animal friends as they can with these different buildings. And the main action of the game is controlled with these hero cards that you can add to throughout the game. And on your turn, you'll either play one card down for an immediate effect, or as your entire turn, you'll slide every card to resolve other actions. And when cards slide all the way off, they come back to your hand to be played again. And those heroes are going to let you do the main actions in the game. Attacking these banners, moving around the different clearings, building buildings to put your friends in, and at the end of the game, whoever has the most victory points wins. So, let's discuss five key things to know about Emberleaf. So, my number five point, the least important to know, but still important enough to be included in the review, is the Automa bot. And this is a mix for my taste. So, on the positive side, the bot is very quick to resolve. This is a game of micro turns where you're not doing a lot. So, all you do is you flip up one card and it'll have them move or attack or build certain buildings or mess with different offers. So, it interacts with the player in all the ways that a regular player would. And then on the potentially positive side, they have these basic and advanced favor cards. And you'll use a certain number of these at the beginning of the game based on your difficulty level. And it will have the bot score extra points based on things you did or did not do in the game. So, it gives nice variety to the game and forces you down different paths each time you play.
And in a similar vein, the different buildings you can build are going to be worth different points each game. And you'll find out which ones are worth more or less as the game goes along. But this is where the mix comes in for me because a lot of the stuff the bot is doing is just punishing you for doing certain things or not doing certain things. And while it does change up the strategy game to game, it can also feel punitive and like the game is sort of taking away fun choices you can make because some things are just so negative for you and so punished point-wise that there's no point in pursuing them. My number four point is also a mix and those are the trophies that trigger the end of the game and that you are chasing after. So whenever a clearing gets finished, when every spot is full of buildings or whenever enough of these banners have been defeated to move this token down to the bottom, the active player who finished the thing is going to pick one of these trophies. It'll get them a bunch of victory points, but it gives every other player a little consolation prize, this bottom effect here. And when all six have been taken, the game end is triggered. Everyone finishes out the round. It's an okay mechanic. It definitely encourages more player interaction or even interaction with the solo bot because you really have to watch when things are potentially about to finish. Many can jump in and grab the trophy for yourself. But that's also where some of the negatives come in because I have felt especially in competitive play that I sometimes like don't want to build because I know that somebody else is going to finish the clearing before me or I don't want to attack a banner because I'm setting somebody else up for a bigger prize. Kind of like the solo bot. It sort of pushes me away from some plays which is not my favorite. And additionally, sometimes the game feels like it goes a bit longer than it needs to. Especially in our earlier games, we found that around like the four or five trophy mark, we were kind of doing the
same thing and just sort of rushing to finish the game. So, for my personal taste, I wish the game was just a few rounds shorter to keep things a bit tighter. For number three point, I'm looking at the favors in the game. And this is also a mix for my taste. So, these are cards that are going to get you endgame scoring. And throughout the game, you have the chance to take them from an offer of five cards. And that offer is constantly cycling. And on the positive side, kind of like the solo bot favors, these push you down very different directions, have you try to do certain things or avoid doing certain things too much. And just to emphasize, these are really important. They will often make up up to 50% of your points in the entire game, just favor scoring at the end. But on the negative side, I felt this is the biggest source of swinginess in the game because sometimes as new favors come out, you'll get one that is worth like 10 or 12 points and perfectly matches something you've already done. And if you have a favor token still on the board, you can just grab it. Whoops. 10 free points for me.
Now, don't get me wrong, that can be a fun, positive occurrence, but it doesn't always feel like you earned it. Well, let's get to some full pros to finish things up. My first one is the homing of animals, and this is along with the combat kind of the main thing you're trying to do in the game. So, you're going to be building up these resources, and you are limited in how many you can hold, although if you get an upgrade, you can get more. And as you buildings from your board or the general supply, first of all, you are getting upgrades and unlocking new actions for yourself. But also, you're putting out these animals and getting little bonuses for them, making your combat easier, getting you more resources, getting you victory points. And the placement of the animals can earn you a lot of victory points. It's going to interact with a lot of your favor cards. So, it's a nice mix of fun tactical choices mixed with a solid feeling of leveling up and improving your engine. Although, one small caveat here, I do find that even when I pursue different strategies, I tend to get most of the animals every game. Maybe that's just our group think. So, there's not necessarily a ton of variety in how you kind of upgrade your board. And finally, my number one point, the most important thing to know about the game, and this is also a full pro, and those are the hero cards and the core action system of the game because there's a really cool system that I've never seen before done quite like this. So, as I mentioned, on your turn, you either put a card down and resolve any of its lightning bolt on play abilities, or you slide every card that's already on your board one at a time. Any of their little green abilities get resolved as you slide them. You can also have people fall off the board and get these drop off abilities. And when people come off the board, they go back into your hand. So you can play them again and repeat the entire cycle. It's a really fun action system. It lets you combo things together. And several times throughout the game, you'll have the chance to draft a new hero to your hand and then
kind of add them to their engine. Although this is for me the one mix part of the game because your six starting people tend to be pretty similar. There's five different starting decks, but they have most of the same abilities. And then while there are some standouts in these other hero cards, a lot of them just do similar stuff to what your starting heroes already did. As I said, you aren't adding a ton of them to your deck each game. most of your cards are going to be your starting cards. So, this doesn't feel like a cool tableau builder with combos of cards, as much as I might like, but the actual action system remains pretty dang awesome. Overall, if you want a fun euro with interesting tile placement and card management choices, Ember Leaf might be for you. But if you're worried about the punitive and potentially swingy nature of the bot, or if you love tons of strategic variety in your euros, this might be one to avoid. And if you want to see the game in action, check out my recent playthrough on the channel. Thanks for watching everybody. Good gaming and I'll see you at the next