Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dinosaur Island Debate: So Preoccupied With Whether They Could, Didn't Think Whether They Should

Transcript 1:02:15

hello everyone talian farrell here from board of it and today we're going to be discussing dinosaur island now if you've seen us before this video is not going to be our usual concise scripted review format for a couple of reasons firstly there's so many weird design choices in dinosaur island that we really just want to discuss them all secondly and the main reason is that usually farrell and i pretty much agree on most things in most games so the review is our shared opinion however with dinosaur island we disagree on a lot so that's kind of hard to write up in a review so once we've explained how the game works we're just gonna kind of go free form and discuss and debate their mechanisms and design choices yeah so dinosaur island is full between one to four players and you could essentially describe it as jurassic park roller coaster tycoon the board game well there's nothing really new or innovative here the theme is really cool and it does do a lot of heavy lifting and there is fun to be had with that theme mechanistically though it's a bit strange because rather than being like a game of a single focus it's more like four games on each other's shoulders wearing a trench coat and pretending to be a game it's it's you know is it dice drafting or is it work placement is it time laying or is it economic park management like what's going on and it just seems like the designers took a bunch of mechanisms they really enjoyed and shoehorned it all into one box but what's weird is that it's actually a functional game and it kind of works

but so there's just essentially a lot to discuss here so this video is quite long and we cover from start to finish so we started like phase one of the game and the setup and we continue to the end game so we're sorry if it's a bit long but we just had a lot of fun talking about it and before we get into that though let's show you how to play players begin with a few scientists hello a few workers an empty park and some basic dna hello everyone scientist here i would just like to inform you that there is no such thing as basic dna and advanced dna even when it comes to creating dinosaurs so i will be awarding this game -1 science point the game is played over a series of rounds which continue indefinitely until a certain number of required endgame objectives are met and then the game will end at the end of that round in each round there are four phases in phase one you will use your scientists to obtain dna obtain dinosaur recipes and to increase the amount of dna you can hold in storage i would also like to point out that there is no need to increase your cold storage to allow you to hold more

dinosaur dna because dna is microscopic and it makes no sense in terms of scientists working in a lab minus two science points i would also like to point out lastly that the fact that you have an action for obtaining a dinosaur recipe and obtaining dna makes no sense because the dinosaur recipe would be dna of the dinosaur so it's a bit superfluous mine's three science points in phase two you go to a shared marketplace where you can buy various things such as specialists which usually give you a special action and an extra worker some attractions and amusement tiles which will help you get more people into your park and some laboratory upgrades which give you variable options when you come to phase three the worker placement phase this is done simultaneously around the table and each player just does work placement on their own personal player board this is also the phase where you'll be creating dinosaurs and filling out your park for every dinosaur you create your excitement level will rise which means that more people will be coming to your park so you'll get more money and vp however every dinosaur you create will also lead to an increase of your park's threat level and it becomes a constant battle to match your security level to your threat level to prevent your patrons from being eaten in faithful patrons come to visit your

park and you will draw them out of this bag and place them outside your park you will either draw patrons which are the gold people or you'll draw hooligans which are the pink and for every patron you draw you get one dollar and nothing for the hooligans then you start putting people inside your park who begins first into spaces that can fit them and then once all the people that can get in your park are there you'll count them up excluding hooligans and take that many vp then at the end of the game you'll be scoring up the end game objectives and scoring for dinosaurs in your park which is printed on the tile they come with now i guess we're ready for the debate so i think we're just going to go through um bit by bit so i think we'll start with like phase one and go through and then at the end we'll talk about some of the overall mechanics and storage and stuff like that but so yeah in phase one as we said you have your little scientists and you kind of use them to get uh dna and dinosaurs and one thing i personally like about this is that they're all weighted with different numbers so a three if you use that to get this dna then you get three of that dna or you have to use a three to get a large carnival and so they're all kind of weighted and

it prevents presents quite interesting dilemmas like more than you usually would and because this could be considered a classic work placement phase where one person puts a scientist down grabs something and then your next person decides what they want to do yeah except it's scaled yeah the weighting of the scientists yeah yeah i think it's quite good as well that they give you the opportunity to just pass and not spend a scientist um and that means you can actually use one of your scientists as a worker in phase four which we'll obviously talk about when we get good point actually phase three yeah so another thing i guess is just a weird design choice and there's a few littered around but this is just like an example right so this is like classic worker placement right you'd agree because there's only a limited number of things spaces and so they give you these kind of crappy little tokens but then over here in phase three when you have like a solo worker placement they give you proper people and i don't understand why they either didn't do both or make this the phase where you have the workers where it's like more important to be seen what's like you know being done because here in phase three you could literally have like little action cubes or something to say you have six actions and then they just put them down it's just it's just like a really really weird design choice for me right yeah i get your point but i personally would never even thought about it if you didn't bring it up so now you've

mentioned it yeah it is a little bit strange there it's just happened stinky right i just it's just i don't they have to write one two and three on it yeah but you could have a you could have a meeple with one two and three on them in big numbers right i guess so but also another thing that's annoying about these as a side note is what happens is it's like tough to take them back right and you throw them at people and then what happens is the back isn't the same as the front so they get thrown somewhere and then people are going oh where's my scientists where's what happened yesterday right where's my scientist and because you're looking for a number and it's like sat on something yeah anyway just solution to that is don't throw the tokens at me well yeah but it's just still an annoyance right sometimes you can't help it people are firing one thing i really like and i think is very interesting in phase one is that the dice that you can choose um has pips on it which indicate threat level in this game and whatever is remaining here the highest threat level comes over here and everyone gets an increase in threat level at the end of the round so sometimes you end up taking the dna with um the highest threat level to like take one for the team as we say i'll take that dna yeah well we do say that all the time you're right it's almost although like to be getting the dinosaurs which you'll come to is the main part that's like tough right that's tight yeah but the dna is never so much maybe someone wants

something but it's not that bad so you do say oh i'll take that for the team i'll take this for the team because dna is just easy to get and this is a theme we'll come to throughout that make some balance issues but dna is easy like if someone takes a blue one and that's last one you're like whatever like you it's never yeah no it's good point as well yeah so the dinosaurs you can only take like one per level each round so once the herbivore has gone here and once someone's taken one then that's it you can no longer take one and then you have the small carnivore and the large carnivore so i'll let you talk about that pharaoh all right yeah so this is one of my personal pet peeves and where i think the game's a bit broken and i know a lot of other people agree online um i know the design forces said they've play-tested it loads and um you know it's not an issue but if everyone thinks it's an issue then isn't it an issue i mean i love this game i will i will agree with what you're about to say but it's just this point of like you can't tell people it's not an issue if they think it's an issue right yeah like well generally nowadays but so you've got your you've got your hair before right and you get two excitement points and two vp per herbivore increases your threat one level you've got small carnival so the main cost is more and more dna to build these and again dna is very easy to come by so you get

small carnivore you get two excitement you get four vp per dinosaur and an increase of two threat levels now you come to the large carnivore you get three excitement you get seven vp and you get an increase of two threat levels not three it doesn't make any sense because it just nerfs everything behind it because you do this all the time and there's just no almost no point getting anything other than a large carnivore if you can because it's only two threat levels right and you get seven vp for it and three excitement small carnival same issues way less of everything and like the herbivore is all right like you know um it's quite balanced there's only one threat and you get two excitement which is pretty good for what it is less vp but but i find this i i still can't believe this because it really does feel like because as tally said you can only get one when someone takes it like it's just like they're ahead right kind of for that round yeah and there's an issue with this taking it because the first first person kind of gets to take it right this is something we'll come to later but it's a big issue uh with the turn order which kind of exacerbates this problem yeah i don't know yeah i will agree that the small carnivores are a bit silly i mean it's supposed to balance out by like you said the level of dna

so so the large carnivores advance there yeah and this is one advantage are harder to harder to build build from the dna but it's not that hard that you would ever want to take the small carnivore and still increase your threat level by by two because it is actually pretty hard to manage your threat level with the higher security level is the hardest part it's just not worth it it would be more beneficial to just if you couldn't ever get the large carnival to just take the herbivore and and create more dinosaurs rather than having um the small kind of oil but i guess it's supposed to balance out because you can't just keep taking large carnivores without building them i like saying build build a dancer um like deploy deploying calisthenics or caledonia um if you have an empty enclosure without a dinosaur at the end then you lose 10 vp right so that's supposed to negate people just taking those enclosures because you do have to think okay can i actually build the dinosaur by the end of the game but it's never a problem really like you say to to build the dinosaurs because the dna is quite easy to if there is a limit to building them it's not to do with the dna it's to do with maybe the work placement spaces you have or the work is available or you know because when you get to the second phase you can also buy dna so again it's like if you really need to

but but yeah i know a lot of people have also said this claim about the uh you know the small carnivore and to me it's just the fact that it's just the lack of a third threat level to it's just really crazy to me yeah um okay agree but it doesn't it's not a pet peeve like you because if someone just kept taking the large carnivore if i was in a game i would then just keep taking herbivores and just building more of them in the one enclosure so i know there are some strategies but it's just do you think though that if if say everyone kept getting carnivore ahead of you do you think you could ever win with just herbivores i'm pretty sure i've done it do you ask her before so no carnivals let me think maybe i just built a lot of them but i guess it ties into what the objectives are yeah um okay so i think is there anything else in phase one we've covered pretty much everything it's called cold storage is it's fine right to increase because you start quite limited to what you can especially considering you have this three worker and you could like if i did this i'd get nine dna right so it's quite limiting but also it's something you only do because you have to there's like no fun in it or um difficulty it's like not challenging it's not like oh tally's increased occult storage right it's fine like it's not something to complain about but it's like it's just something to be annoying almost to increase it it's not fun it's not strategic to increase i

guess there is some strategy in deciding which to increase though like do you increase the basic dna and then hold more basic dna because then you can refine the dna later on to make advanced dna or do you just increase the cold stretch of the advanced dna and just accumulate it from the beginning and therefore save the worker in the end because you have to use a worker to get refined dna or spend more money in phase two to get advanced so there is a bit of strategy what i usually find is i increase it once or twice or even once just using the three-letter scientists increase it three times and then that's probably set for the game a lot of the time because you can never acquire like that much dna like not that you can you cannot require a lot of dna you don't need to because you can only maybe make one or two dinosaurs per round so you only ever really need to hold that much dna to make one you always come to this phase yeah so but also just side note the these dice are pretty cool and hefty like they're i guess it's supposed to be amber but they're just something i really like about the game one thing to note actually that it doesn't it doesn't bother me and i guess not you but i know people were a bit disappointed that the dinosaurs are all functionally the same like like this dinosaur is no different than this dinosaur like in terms of any challenges face it's just that it costs more dna and but it doesn't take up any more space or any more difficulty besides the threat level i think people really thought that and originally all these dinosaurs were going to be different so like i don't know if you have a giant

brontsaurus it's a herbivore but it might take up two spaces instead of one and it's like you know things you have to think about but that doesn't happen but this isn't something that bothers us there's so much else to think about about that it's just i saw people have like weren't happy so it's worth dressing now it doesn't bother us i get it though once they're out yeah they're the same yeah it's just they're building them that is so i guess yeah we'll get to the components later so phase two here is the marketplace shared marketplace it's not too bad i quite like the mechanic that if you pass you get two dollars so you can like sometimes you pass and then buy something the second time round yeah what i quite like about it is you get two actions in this phase so you do get two opportunities to purchase a variety of things so you can buy lab upgrades which help you in your phase stream a placement you can buy attractions to fill in your park which can sometimes hold patrons or just give you vp and you can buy uh staff specialists um which is probably the least interesting right you only buy them to get more workers it's never usually yeah i mean they're okay but it comes out like there's quite a lot of cards so that's quite nice yeah it can be different every game um i don't know i think this is a little bit strategic as well because basically whenever they are taken by another player they shift up next round though yeah so if these were taken in the next round these would move up and that would mean they're cheaper

because it goes from yeah so there's down to five it's more expensive the lower you get so that's quite interesting because it's do you risk you know this is five dollars this one but you really want it do you just pay it or take a risk and hope that nobody no other players buy it and then it will move up around and it will be cheaper um yeah the i think the only thing is with the attractions i find is they can be quite expensive yeah um but you do need them so yeah so i guess one issue that comes in the final phase is that your excitement level goes up say you build a carnival large carnivore and your excitement level goes up three but you can only hold one person per dinosaur so now right you have a difference of two there so you need extra spaces so you do need these attraction tiles and sometimes it can be quite fire over them who gets to go first which again will come to you later with the turn order issue but one thing i would say is that i've you know these there's some attraction tiles that basically just give you vp and take up space in your park it's like kind of okay if there's an objective but generally they're a bit useless because as we just said you need spaces you need more space and they only give you vp so it's like unless it's like the final round and you have spare money yeah you would almost i would anybody but there's like a lot of them it's not like one like in this half of them are um yeah half of them have no spaces it's just vp and it's like

what i think is quite good though is that there are certain lab upgrades that are always available um so you don't have to worry about that so like for instance this one is create one dinosaur so you already have that in your phase three player map but it's more expensive for cosmo workers whereas this gives you opportunity to i mean place one worker so you could build three dinosaurs in a round if you had the dna so it's quite nice that those two lab upgrades are always available yeah um and you can buy dna in this round as well as like like we were saying with the dice if you didn't get what you wanted you can always purchase dna in this round so that's quite nice as a as a bit of a fail-safe yeah i think so yeah one thing about these lab upgrades is that they're probably my most favorite of the three things you can buy here the most interesting because they give you alternate actions when you come to the worker next phase but they're not all equal for sure because as we say security is the hardest part of this game right increasing your security level uh to match with your threat level and there's certain ones like i think they're actually both here so this one is increase your security by one level at no cost you can do it twice but it will cost three workers total and so that can honestly save you up to about ten dollars and money in this game is surprisingly tight it's really tight probably more than that actually because it's three every yeah yeah sorry not three billion yeah yeah money every level yeah yeah um and then you've got like this one

which is basically it kind of is similar to this but you can just increase your security at discounted cost and anything like this to security is like way more valuable than anything else if you see it someone's going to buy it like it's not getting left there so it's just kind of quite clear and sometimes if you can get it early enough it might influence the entire game really because again it's the hardest part you have to put a lot of money and effort into increasing your security if someone can get it free for the whole game then it's just like i guess again it ties back to the objectives because yesterday we played a game one of the objectives was to get your security level to 10. yep so i purchased that lab upgrade because that was like going to make it easier for me to do that but to be fair like even though it is difficult to manage the threat versus security you know if there was an objective have 15 dna in your storage which i think that has been like that one could actually be better yeah so there is actually a little bit of balance there and to be fair they're not unique so they when they get cleared out they get replaced so like this one i've seen be out on the table like twice so yeah i didn't know you had it yesterday actually it's not like you're completely shut out i mean i guess you've got to be a bit lucky that it gets then redrawn but they're not they're not unique so i mean there's three on here now that relate to security yeah so okay maybe someone takes that but then just take that yeah but i think there are levels so but yeah and some are

some are fine some are not like it's just but i just think that i i mean they're okay they're interesting enough but it's just like something like this one's a good example it says you may hire one additional specialist because you can only have three of these specialists but it's like are you going to get three in a game it's pretty rare with everything else right oh you might but it's it's like a weird thing right where is it worth paying two dollars for this to then pay another like a month to get a fourth one and i don't know it seems like a very rare use one right yeah if you know what i mean in terms of no that's useless but very rare that it would be something you go for over anything else what do you think of this mechanic where if you purchase the dna you discard one of the things from from the row yeah i think it's a bit superfluous yeah i think it's interesting because again it's just like it depends on the tunnel it's like so much this game depends on the turn order because you're either gonna and also what dna you want it's like so situational because it's like you need to go no one's going to go oh i want 2 dna but if i get 3 dna i can discard this and stop tally getting it because money is just tight and you're like i'm not going to waste that dollar yeah well it depends i guess i totally would do i'm totally worried not in this game not in this game i need the money too bad but um yeah it's fine like it's fun

if you were going to get dna anyway and that you know there's something that someone wants then it's like an alliance there's good fun and i think like it's not a useless mechanic but it's superfluous because it's not something that i think people will be doing very often tactically because remember you only get two turns here you can gain money and there's like what 4 8 12 um 16 actions you can take and are you going to be using the one and someone else you know it's just yeah what do you think yeah i don't yeah i think it's a little bit pointless because also you don't often know what other players are aiming for particularly so you wouldn't tactically go oh yeah i am going to spend an extra dollar to get rid of something from the from the three dollar road because i have no idea what you you want i mean some of them are clearly better than others so maybe then you would be like oh someone's gonna like buy that yeah i'm gonna get it out of the game i mean i did i did do that yesterday i think i got some advanced dna and there was like uh it was like a roller coaster or something that would give someone five spaces and i'll never afford that but maybe italian bar have can yeah so then yeah i just like discarded it so it's tactical but it's only because they're able to afford it anyway because it they're like those sorts of spaces and tiles they are really expensive so it's only because i was there it's only because yeah yeah yeah yeah okay so i think yeah yeah this is the marketplace i think is fine um

like i said securities lab upgrade tiles they vary in usefulness and some are way better than others i think um pointless kind of attractions but yeah i think there's specialists whatever but yeah so phase three uh is where you do the work placement thing on your board and it's like you can refine dna so tally said basic into advanced dna create a dinosaur you can yeah you so if you want to get like second third fourth dinosaur in your paddocks you need to upgrade the panic so you pay a bit of money and you get extra spaces you can do that here you can upgrade security you can get money from the bank um so i guess one thing that i'm really not a fan of this round i guess you you won't care about too much but is that you do it everyone does it simultaneously so it's a solo endeavor so you sit there and you're like right i'm gonna make a dinosaur put one in your park and all this and you just sit there and then you look up and like oh everyone's done okay and what i dislike about this is classically if you do work replacement it's like you know you take it in turn order because you see what people do um i guess it's like nice in one way that no one can block you off but i hate that it's simultaneous because what tends to happen uh it's hard to explain without going to the endgame goals really um just go for it no in context no i think i'll leave background but yeah i mean the whole thing's fine right let's say this let's go on a different

act i think it could be a worry for some people that it's a very easy round to cheat in i think i don't think it's been a consideration ever for us but i think that if someone that you play with or you know i don't know a family member who's not interested they could very easily cheat massively in this part because there's no supervision you you never have any idea how much dna anyone else has or something it's like not really easy to see unless you stand up and look you don't know their dinosaur recipes you don't know what they can make you don't know if they're paying proper money yeah so if you're trying to teach it as well it's very not even cheating people could unintentionally be wrong very easily unless you're staring over them all the time because sometimes you might like just be like oh i'm going to refine dna and then you do it and they're like oh make dance oh no that was the wrong thing so you like move it back and then i don't know you know what i mean yeah um so this is definitely a situation i think yeah so i think we'll have to loot back to this but yeah this is where you can increase your threat and your uh security level you make dinosaurs you follow the recipe yeah i think we'll come back to it later but i don't have um because obviously it needs to be in contact so i don't have that much yeah so the solo thing doesn't bother me too much like i know what you mean about worker placement and usually others are blocking you but but here you've only got limited spaces so you need to manage like your own spaces rather than worrying about whether other people take the spaces so it's not like you can still just do whatever you want with your workers you

have to consider you know you've only got a limited amount you've got some um areas on your player board are actually unlimited so if you had unlimited workers you could go there but some are restricted especially when you you know start getting more of the lab upgrades so you do have to consider do i want to spend one worker to go here or here so there's still a little bit of like you know challenge and getting the workers to the right places for your own yeah i think you're right there's a good there's a good choice here um when you go through lab upgrades good decisions to be made it's like tough sometimes sometimes you're like oh how can i optimize the number of workers i have but i think unless we'll have to loop back to this the main part because there's not much here it's just putting works down doing actions and the actions are varied and interesting like it all kind of feels in the game but one thing that i do really like is there's a a venture capital space a space where you can always get money and i like that because i do you know i wish you could upgrade it that'd be great get like six money next time or something yeah yeah there isn't an upgrade for that right yeah but it's always giving you guys to get a bit of money and that who doesn't like that i don't even have to explain why that's good i think it's a space that gets used every round yeah so one thing i will say though about the uh the threat levels so as you build deploy whatever we're going to say correct more create deploy more coins dinosaurs you move your threat level up according

to whatever the dinosaur recipe is is saying you do have to then remember to go back to what we mentioned in phase one if the um yeah and there's two or three it can be two or three threat level you have to sort of remember that and just add it on to your own threat level i mean you could move your cube in line with it just to check that it's in line with your security level and it doesn't overtake it but then it's like okay new round oh i'll move it back or i'll just remember it and yeah i don't know i don't know what the solution would be but it is a bit jarring i mean i guess that's something that in the reverse actually this is in first where something that's just never bothered me actually it's quite funny because um i just look at it i'm like right too and i'm like yeah i'm saying no it makes me feel like i'm not oh i hope i've got it right and it's not untidy no yeah um but yeah that's actually never bothered me so i mean there's a point i think it would annoy people but it's never bothered me i just look but yeah all right so phase four which is where you draw patrons out of the bank um i think yeah so go first you like draw as many excitement level as you have and you'll get uh hooligans and patrons yeah i know and we'll get to that and we like you line them up outside and then you get money for each one and um then you have to obviously fit them in all the spaces you can and the hooligans go first because they're slight and sneaky and they don't pay again but

thematically i find this a bit strange because everyone pays money to get in your park and then they don't go in the park i always get confused every time you get this game out i have to be like farrell does everyone pay even if yeah it's so weird yeah that's the main way you get money right but i just i really feel like thematically it would make much more sense if you had like a little square or something where they um they're in the parking lot yeah no just because obviously you have people walking around right it's just like you could say that uh you get a vp which is like a good review for seeing the dinosaur right and that's where you get vp and they don't see the dinosaur it's too busy so they're just walking around so it'd be like it would make more sense to have like a little square where you you just put them or something right yeah yeah or they just died around like in between places or like there's little trails or something but i just find it very strange that they all pay and then they don't get in um i agree with that one yeah it is very weird and it always confuses me i'm like totally right they pay they don't come in the park well it's great it's great for me but not for them outside here aren't they in the queue great for me not for them so then yeah not much happens here really one thing that is a bit um funny is that if if your security no if your threat level is higher than your security level the difference is how many patrons will be eaten and then they don't give you uh you get the money for them but they don't give you vp and in fact they give you

negative vp um so that's something to be aware of but i guess my main problem with this and it's like a summary of the game as a whole almost a little bit mainly this one okay it's like played out it's like a mix of like american euro game right like almost bits of it are like kind of luck and bits of it like a lot of its strategy but when it comes down to this it's like obviously total luck draw of the bag so you know this draw i got here means i get three less vps than i would have done and to be fair there's not that many hooligans in the bag comparatively so drawing three out of eight is huge right that's a huge like that's unfortunate and my point is is that this game i think honestly one time i lost because in the final round you got like one hooligan and i got like four and like the difference in vp was that much and it's just like for me it it's not something that's super bothered me but it might bother people uh but it's just like you have this big strategic game what lab upgrades do i get what dinosaurs do i get what dna do i get how do i do it should i get that specialist you know what action should i do on the player board and then it comes to the final final bit and you have the final turn of the game and then it's like oh well tally got all patrons and i got four hooligans and it's like well that's it then that's the game but you can get specialists like isn't it the pr manager

and the security guard or something like that that mean if you do have hooligans in your park you won't lose vp or they let you put a hooligan back and redraw or something like that and to be fair if you went for a strategy where you over spaced had lots of spaces in your park then yeah it's annoying that you might draw them but then at least it's not the expense of the patrons because you can fit everyone in so it really just depends like if you don't have enough space in your park so the the paying patrons are waiting outside then yeah you're going to lose vp but if you've got space in your park you've built lots of dinosaurs everyone can fit in yeah it's annoying that they don't give you vp or pay but at least you can fit everyone in so there is a strategy there in like maybe yeah having lots of spaces in your in your pocket or compensate for the hooligans you do get i guess specialists that you know i think there's a security guard or something that yeah you can put them on but then again it comes back to like double randomness right where you have this bag random is that guy going to come up are you going to be able to get the security guard like true yeah are you going to be able to negate it basically and you're right if you have a lot of spaces then it's like fine right but it's also it's still it doesn't matter because i'm still losing 3vp either way if you know what i mean true it's not my biggest peak with the game but it's just something that i think definitely would piss people off right um so yeah anything else about phase four because it's pretty straightforward really like that's all you do you put them up it's fun it's definitely a fun phase for

sure to like see what you get and line them up and be like oh no i can't fit two of them in like kind of thing it can be quite fun as well depending on what you purchase in phase two but some of the attractions let you choose between money and vp i've never actually done that i've never done that i got one yesterday and um i actually chose to get money in the beginning round because it would help me obviously improve the park yeah yeah um so that's quite interesting yeah that's good good point all right so shall we go to the favorite topic favorite topic of mine and the thing i hate most so i play this game every time and the reason i'm a bit down on it sometimes is that i beat him sure but it's because 85 percent of the game and the mechanisms are fun and then you there's 15 of them that drive me nuts and it just sucks all enjoyment and it provides only frustration and i always then end the game like miserable and salty and i'm just like when i think of playing it next time like oh i don't want to go through that again so this is what i hate most about dinosaur island and it is that you have these end game objectives and this is what ends the game so so in this case there's five of them laid out when four of them are claimed you the game ends immediately at the end of that round and they basically can only be claimed

in the phase when the first person claims them so if tally claims this one i can only do that at the same time in that phase or else it's gone forever it's locked and so what happens though is that a lot of them come down to like this phase here where you work solo so a lot of them will be like have nine dinosaurs or uh you know like get an excitement level of 10 or get security level of 10 whatever right and all of that happens here where you play solo and no one knows what you're doing so it becomes impossible for a lot of objectives for anyone else to know if anyone else can score them or not so what can literally happen is it can be like this they're all empty going into this worker phase and at the end of the phase the game's like ending and there's no way to know and i find it crazy with this design that there is no way to know when the game will end because almost every game does it it has like a trigger or a track or rounds or and usually if they do this what they do is they have a final round to like you know so yeah um to kind of end things up and they don't do that here so it just ends and if you get caught like everything you've done for the last hour hour and a half out the window it doesn't matter and one thing worse is that because you

don't do this work placement in turn order so you like you can't see what people are doing as i said i think earlier you have no idea how much dna they have you have no idea what dinosaurs they can create or how many you have no idea really what they're doing and so you kind of do your thing and then suddenly someone's like oh yeah i've done this this and this and like the game's over and then you're like it's like this dilemma right of it's like you could have done that and i know you're going to say this it's like i could have done that and i would have if i known the game was going to end but i didn't know it was going to end so i didn't do that and what my problem is that it basically it creates a system where you play the game because you want to create a lovely dinosaur park and what happens is it becomes a race to get objectives like most other games ever don't understand your problem but the objectives are at the cost of having fun building apartments they are they totally are no they're not they totally are no because some of them so i disagree right because i always actively work towards the objectives i don't just sit there and build dinosaurs for the good of my health i always listen to the objectives and i see which ones i like or you know how the game plays out and i actively go for them because as well as ending the game i mean it's not that i particularly want to end the game it's more because they're just they're worth good victory points so yesterday in the game i think i claimed three that's 21 victory points so i play the

game with the objectives in mind not to end the game but because their score for vp and the fact that they in the game just happens to be part and parcel of the game for me um so that it just it just doesn't bother me because i feel like if you didn't have objectives you there's no direction i i use that as direction for one okay so for me they're like a big part of the game i kind of get what you mean like maybe there should be another final round so everyone gets a chance to do one more round once the trigger has has started but yeah just i use those for direction in the game otherwise i'd just be like oh i'll make a dinosaur oh what shall i do now and it's like yes you have no direction for me it's just like i just play the game like how can i get the the most vps like how am i going to get this big park with lots of dinosaurs i'm getting like loads of people in and i've got like big money dinosaurs and i'm trying to like create a really like nice thriving park and for me it's more that it's not one thing and this is because all these weird mechanics right like we didn't touch in it but you know you've got like dice drafting and fake work placement real work placement and marketplace and like park building um it is it's basically that all of these weird design choices come together in a really like unholy way it's like the fact that you can only claim them in that one phase or else they're gone forever the fact

that they're worth so many vps in consideration of the game itself the fact that you can't know if anyone is able to claim them and just you know the fact that you have this solo round it they all combine to me to make like this horrible unfun mess where like i to be fair i get your point more now that you're like oh they give me direction so i work towards them but like i for me i want to play the game to enjoy the game and build like the best dinosaur park i i don't sorry no hold on i don't know i just don't want to play it towards some arbitrary arbitrary objective so i would disagree that they're arbitrary i think if you're not doing those things you've got problems in your part no like it increases security yeah you have to you have to do that okay because uh otherwise you're not getting good enough dinosaurs yeah yeah counter counterpoint though counterpoint though yeah is that because of these objectives like i think we can both agree that a lot of them can be very unbalanced in terms of ease of doing them it's compared compared to length of game remember when yeah yeah yeah well i don't think it's like that they're easy it's more about the length of the game no i know but i'm saying some of them you can literally complete in round two in a medium game when you should have like i don't know six seven eight others you complete and you'll take like 12 rounds yeah you know what i mean yeah yeah like i remember once we played either a medium a long game

and tally literally got one in the second round and it i think you weren't even particularly like you were aiming for it but it wasn't your main goal and it was like get like 13 dna or something and it was nice and it was just like she got in the second round it's like and this is my point is that if one of them i think one of them's like have three attractions right and i can sit there every round for the first three rounds and get an attraction tile right and i claim that yeah but like but then i have to get an attraction tile every round i don't i want a lav upgrade i want a specialist but that's the choice that's the choice but it's my point that for me the game is forcing me down a route that i'm not interested in what would you have how would you have the end trigger then instead you would you would you have like no objectives i i would honestly i'd probably just either no i think yeah either a set number of rounds i think but that would be so boring to me to just sit and make the same okay maybe every game it would just be oh make a dinosaur make a dinosaur all right fine but i would at least minimum if we keep it like this i would just open them up for the entirety of the game yeah okay or maybe even have like you know like you could score two people could score this one unless they do in the same round or something you know something like that yeah because the way it is now it for me it's literally that you need to do them and you need them as soon as possible because there's so many vp there

that for me just you get to the end of the game and then you know everyone's rushed to do these and it just sucks personally for me this is personal like not for you it just sucks the fun out of the game to like have to be like right well i know tally's going to do this so now i have to buy a lav upgrade every time if i even want to keep my head above the wall the same ones as me there's always a choice right like we don't have to go for the same things as you know and okay you could go for that one and i could go for that one yeah but so if we just take these as an example this you can do in four rounds all of the rest no you can't buy four lab upgrades in because they're expensive like it it's not that easy it's not like you just sit and choose i'll choose that i'll choose that it's not as easy as that because you have to manage your money it's expensive if you go for it if you went for it you could do it because one two like three four easy but then you wouldn't be able to do any other objectives for me it's about like the balancing of them like yeah okay you could just choose one objective and go for it but then you'd be a bit screwed once you've got that because you wouldn't have done anything else so i think it's interesting because you have to balance all of these things in the rounds okay i like the look of these two objectives i could do that with how the games played out maybe i went first and i could choose that okay but if i do that one only i'm not gonna be able to do any more and you have to sort of go through and balance everything out to make sure that you're hitting the objectives right at the right time so you don't lock yourself out of the other ones i can appreciate your point i think it's just

nothing is more crushing in any game to me then in this one where you do your entire work placement phase and then you look up and the game's gone from like one objective being claimed to five being claimed and like it's over and you just like and because like it's like i say you just wasted your time like everything you did was pointless like it's in the game it's like that's like it's more like that's how it ends right but yeah i definitely think they could be altered and to be fair in the expansion they even added like some sort of errata that because they knew that like it wasn't enough that i think they made you add more cards depending on players and stuff to make it more far-reaching yeah which is a bit better but so the next big thing is the turn order problem so whoever's last in vp um goes first and they go first throughout the entire round so it means they get first pick of dinosaurs and dice they get first pick of any tiles they want uh well i guess that's exactly these two phases but um it's just it kind of and they get to choose their patrons first yeah doesn't matter so much because it is pure luck but so the issue is is that dinosaur island's not really a game where you get big points until like the final scoring when you do the objectives because what tends to happen is maybe someone takes a preparatory first first round and they don't they only get like one

patron in and they get one vp for that and someone else builds like two dinos two basic dinosaurs and they get like three n and then they go ahead and then you know they might kind of build up their engine a bit but generally it's not like you really ever have someone if they're all equally experienced getting like 10 patrons in and five patrons in they'll usually be like 10 to 8 or something else and it just doesn't really so what i'm saying is the turn order doesn't change mm-hmm once someone's ahead yeah that's not a game where like this round tally will get five points next round i'll get seven points and she'll get three points it it just stays like more or less the same with tiny increments equally so once someone's behind it by a few vp they stay behind by a few vp so they get first pick of everything all game and then what happens is because they've got first pick of all the best tiles of all the best dinosaurs and everything else they essentially leap out in the final scoring because they've got like all the best dinosaurs and all the best upgrades and they've been like creating this amazing park and they claim all the objectives or whatever right and they yeah they basically just leap ahead of everyone and it's like a runaway like last place problem i disagree last night dinosaur queen again oh i was lost the entire game i don't think that's no were you no you first seen thai game no because i was last on the vp track no sorry first first

but yeah but that's because we were playing with um someone it was like his first game yeah and he did terribly i don't think you can count him in in the context of the competition fair enough but do you not agree then that yeah no i agree that it can be it's a huge advantage if you can do it and there's actually a strategy online that i've seen that people actively get people eaten to drop back in the vp early on to do this right it's a genuine strategy i don't think we've ever done it purposely but again didn't even think about that but like it's so strong and yeah it's just it's a nice idea but it really doesn't work in practice and it's like yeah it's just it should really just be rotating turn order or something yeah yeah probably i think they're the only thing that i get the idea of that yeah the the only place i find that annoying is the dinosaurs because it really is only one per dinosaur available i don't find it particularly annoying with the tiles and the lab upgrades and everything because like i said before i think they are a lot of them do similar things it doesn't annoy me that much if someone takes one because okay i'll just take the other one and if this one down here is too expensive next round it's going to be up here i mean i guess they could buy it again but then they wouldn't buy it again because if it does something similar no one would buy the same sort of upgrade so even if you don't get it that round there is a good chance that you might

get a similar upgrade in the next round because people don't you don't need to buy lab upgrades that are the same we'll do the same thing all right so i guess final thing and this well not final thing so we'll talk about the components bit but the final i guess game mechanism thing that we can end on a good night i think is these plot twist cards where you draw too randomly at the start of every game and they shake things up and it might be like start with an extra worker or um uh you know some of them are ongoing aren't they like everyone gains dna at the end yeah yeah yeah so they're quite good actually they i personally really like them i think they really change up like each game to game they're a really nice little thing and they're all quite interesting and cool um and yeah i just think they're really like nice little addition and we'll always play with them and there's quite a lot of them particularly if you get the expansion um but yeah i just don't know what you think about the plot twists i think they're good but yeah no i think they're good i think some of them are just a bit like meh yeah for sure like this hooligan one we got last night or even the specialist well i don't think i yeah like this is like you can hire one additional specialist and it's like we said before i mean it's like you'd have to really be going for them to get four and it'd be an issue right and there's also a tile as well yeah but some of them are pretty helpful they're nice they add

a variety yeah i think i like them so yeah just coming on to the components it's a bit it's a bit like weird right this is real mishmash and we touched on this that you get like crappy tokens for scientists but then you get little workers for the work placement like why are they why don't you get the same thing for both also i'm not found that like everything's plastic right i always prefer wood personally and like better for the environment and not happy that you get like 100 plastic meeples and 100 plastic dinosaurs yeah and then one annoying thing is that all the dinosaurs are the same dinosaur like i i would have much rather they'd be like yeah i don't know even like two or three different ones it's just kind of boring to just have um a hundred triceratops on every boards right you're like you've built i've built a t-rex and it's just yeah no that's one of the most disappointing things i think that it's they're not different nor that i wanted a hundred different dinosaurs or a special one just like three would have been good yeah you could have had herbivore yeah large large and small card yeah and then it's just i just yeah it's kind of like i don't know like it is really random like the player board is really nice divots you know how we love divots i love a divot i'm a big fan and it's nice and thick and it's just really nice isn't it but then it's great yeah some other but then you get like dinky dinky scoreboard and like other player board like they just i don't know they're not they don't ooze quality right yeah and then you have so many so many

tiles of everything and tiles are like so annoying to work with especially when you need to randomize them uh and then randomly just have these as cards and so i was thinking about this because i was like it would have been way better if everything was cards but obviously because you need to put the tiles here you can't which is fine but um it's just yeah and then you get this lovely like felt bag but then really nice but then the plastic like things aren't that great quality like there's like little marks on them and you know like they're just not perfect right yeah this is this is a bit annoying isn't it i mean yeah i'll take a smaller box over having huge board in something to be fair but yeah you could have a foldable board and this would lay on the board and yeah this could have divots just being laid out on the table picking up from this as well actually is a good point that i don't know why these weren't all just put on like one board and this is a table hog it doesn't look like it now maybe but if you play with like three people the entire table because of all the stuff you have to make room you've got these cards and you've got yours and yeah it's just you right if it was a big board it would have been better um and i guess the final note is the storage and it's the worst storage of any game we own do we agree on that agreed it's the it's like the only game i've considered buying like like a custom insert for but i also don't want a bike because i don't think the game deserves it if that makes sense it's like not a worthy game to have to go through that

money and effort but it's so painful it is really like because i have all these tiles it's the only game that when we put it away for the first time i repackaged three times couldn't get it closed and then i had to look online on boardgamegeek to figure it out um yeah there's no way of like well we tried to keep the tiles together with rubber bands but then they didn't fit properly because the space is that tight and then you've got three three plus tiles you've got four plus player tiles it's which like you want to separate depending on what you're doing and then you want to include them and shuffle them if you do have that many it's just like it's horrendous getting them all back in and making it close it's a bit better because we have the expansion and um and obviously there's two boxes but the expansion box is like the same size as normal game which is not great either but you can't get rid of it because all the stuff barely doesn't really fit in the main game because obviously there's so much cardboard it all comes stacked in little uh sheets and so they're all nice and flat but then you pop them all out and stack them it's like oh it doesn't there's no thought really put into the storage of this game and it's yeah it's just the worst storage solution it's the most difficult to get back in it's like such a long setup it's such a long put away time yeah yeah all right all right final four final thoughts from tally man no no all right all right let you go first we've debated a lot yeah but would you recommend this

game farrell what's up do you know what overall summary it's it's a weird one because i was a big fan of roller coaster tycoon when i was growing up and it really reminds me of that and like yeah jurassic park i guess a theme and all of these little mechanics they're all kind of fine like obviously have some big issues with how it ends but obviously that that ruins my enjoyment retrospectively because like i don't like how it ends and like being unprepared and then because we touched on this a bit on our kanban review that i just don't i like to know how long it's gonna last strategize but yeah i mean i have fun playing it it's just at the end kind of ruins it for me and there's obviously like a few little niggles i don't think you'd ever be in like my top 20 list or something but i'm also not sure it'd be one like i'd be like yeah let's get rid of it uh it wouldn't hurt it would hover hover around like the bottom of that like you know cut-off point but i don't think i would get rid of it just because interesting and like thematic one thing i find a bit annoying actually is that you would think it was a theme it would be quite a family-friendly game and it's actually quite difficult and complex not difficult but it's because as we say each thing is like a separate thing it's like teaching four games for the four phases so even running through it to friends who like played it once i think last night it's just like it's like oh this does that and then you do this here and then you do that totally different thing here and it's that that's a bit annoying it would have been a bit nicer if it's a bit easier to include like more casual gamers

because as it is i found this is in this weird position where if you're like moderate hardcore gamer you'll be annoyed with some of the things because you've played better things and nothing is new here but if you're a beginner gamer it's like a bit too difficult and fidgety and like complex it's that weird middle space where but anyway so well i wouldn't get rid of it i do enjoy playing it um i just yeah i often end disappointed and i don't know how many times i want to end disappointed but yeah that's usually because i've yes yes but last last point for me is i've seen people put this in like their top 10 games of all time so it's definitely for someone and i think the theme does a lot of heavy lifting but you know then it's fine i think people will like it uh it's not my favorite yeah i like it i i think when we first got it it was in maybe my top five maybe now we've got other games it might have slipped out of there i think it definitely has that to be honest yeah you've got you've put two in there in the last like three weeks true bull game of problems right yeah but i think it's a fun little game the problems that you have it you know i i recognize that they are maybe like faults and issues but it for me it just doesn't bother me so if those things that farrell was mentioning don't wouldn't bother you then i would recommend it i think the theme is really cool like whenever we were

getting it out like just to set up for this i thought oh this makes me so happy and then you cry as you set it up for 20 minutes it's really cool and just like little things like you know it's quite it's quite comical right and like yeah the little tile uh attractions like this one's called dinosaur fry land because it's a fry store yeah there is some fun that's funny and i really like that i like games that are maybe a little bit more like have a comical thing light-hearted um yeah i understand the issues but i think it's it's just really fun to me so if you can take like a little bit of randomness at the end and with the cards and everything can you just want something fun with a fun theme then get it all right oh thanks for watching uh i guess well not apologizing for rambling on for a long time but yeah so this is what you voted for um if you're a regular viewer um but yeah so like we said i mean hopefully you can see there's a lot of weird stuff and things to talk about it's like it sounds too positive if i say it's one of the most interesting games i've ever played but yeah it's just so much to yeah because because it is this weird game with like four different games in it it's just so much to discuss yeah so thanks for watching thank you and we'll be back with a regular review i think next week but thank you

Progress saved