Aliens Return in Extinction Protocol, an expansion to A Message from the Stars - TCbH Review
Transcript
One of the first reviews I did when I joined the Cardboard Herald was a message from the Star All Plays extraterrestrial themed letter deduction game. In that review, I noted that while I liked the game cipher mechanic and theme, I just I wished it was more difficult and more engaging. And oh boy, did this solve that issue. A message from the Stars: Extinction Protocol adds a twist that's intended to up the difficulty of the base game. There are two new added scoring mechanisms to the trust, amplify, and suspicion letters for a total of three possible options that make it a little bit fiddly to figure out what letter in a word is contributing to the score and in what way. So instead of a trust letter adding one to a score, it may add two or the amplify letter may add three instead of doubling. The expansion suggest two ways of playing with these new scoring mechanisms. With a friendly alien and with a hostile alien, though, the only difference in how these play is that the friendly alien tells the Earthlings what scoring mechanisms it's using, while the hostile alien does not. In either case, the goal is the same. get the Earthlings to correctly guess the trust, amplify, and suspicion letters, as well as both sides conveying their secret message. Having played with both a friendly and hostile alien, I'm not really sure there is any
situation where I'd prefer to play with a friendly alien. In fact, I also don't really see many situations where I'd prefer to play the base game without the hostile alien. It's so good for the game. The variable scoring parameters give the game a a breath of fresh air. It's so much more thinky and puzzly when you're going back and forth between a few different ways on how to score a word. I had to use brackets, flowcharts, if then statements to deduce the different ways a word score could be true in a way that the base game just never made me work for. I do think it's a hair too far for people on the lower end of the game's suggested age range. And I also think if you want to introduce people to the game, the hostile alien may be a bit too difficult to start off with.
Additionally, I really wish that the new included scoring mechanism overlay actually overlaid the original scoring. Like, for some reason, it's just not big enough to cover up the old scoring rules on the player boards. So, you have to just scribble over those to make sure nobody's confused on which you're using. Looping back to my original review, I said that the competitive version of A Message from the Stars was the the one that I leaned towards with dueling scientist teams trying to solve the puzzle. I pointed to the fact that it made the scoring matter and added a layer of difficulty that I liked. This expansion has immediately taken the top spot as my favorite way to play the game. Except for these scenarios, I don't see myself playing this game without the Extinction Protocol expansion joining it on the table. If you want more out of a message from the stars, I highly recommend this expansion.