Fortunes of Scoundrel Bay - How It Balances Speed vs Strategy. Board Game Review
Transcript
Is it a pirate themed game? Yes. Is it a merry trash pirate team game? No. This is a Euro game with pirate theme. Fortunes of Scandrel Bay from Chili Fox game. This is going to be one of SN 2025 releases.
And hi, I'm Terrence
and Stella here from MLE University. Today in this video, we are going to review. We're going to give you an overview first and then what we think of the game. So Chili Fox Games has been one of our favorite publishers. We always get their games from Essence Spiel and this year this is their big releases. Last year's they have things like Come Together, Saltfield
and Footprints.
Yes. So um this is the 2025 release. Let's get to it, Tara.
So here we have Scoundrel Bay and all of the surrounds. And we're going to be sailing our pirate ships along this map. going to be encountering encountering lots of enemies as we go along the way. Uh these are very Euro style enemies as we'll see. And as we're going to be doing this, we'll be building up our pirate ships, recruiting new people to our crew.
Sure, Taran. This looks like from Finland, and this person probably looks like from England. You're all looking enemy
indeed. and we're going to be stopping off at all the various ports along the way to take actions. This is a carddriven game and on any turn you'll have three cards in your hand and they're multi-use so or they have m multiple functions. So you'll play one of them to take one of three actions and you can't take the same action on consecutive turns. So, you track it like this, unless you spend one of these locks, which you get a couple of through the game.
It's not easy to get.
Yes. And then once your turn is done, you gain a new card from the display, which could be free. You could spend rum to get uh one that's come out earlier. Or you could even pick the color of your choice if you really need a certain color and pay three rum and just draw until you get one. Fundamentally, there's three things you can do. You can recruit and build up your ship. So, when you play a card for recruiting, it goes below your board. It will give you some new pirate meeples. These are basically what you'll need to spend to take actions out in Scoundrel Bay. And it will increase a couple of your ship statistics like guns and swords and cooking.
Is this a cooking game?
It has cooking in it. It is a feed your meatballs game. That is that is something to watch for. You do need to uh
try not to have to feed the meles at all.
This boo is not part of the review. It's just like my reaction for all the games that has feed your meeples game.
Yes. Uh so that's the first thing you could do. The second option is you could go sailing. So you would play the card here. The color doesn't matter. And then you can move up to three spaces along the river.
You gain
a river. Well, it looks like a river.
See a river
body of water.
So, it's like a river pirate. Excellent.
River pirates.
Uh, then you gain a sailing reward. And these are better the slower you go. So, if you move three spaces and really gun it along the river, you'll get kind of a feeble reward. Uh, but all the better stuff is up the other end. So, you might try to get there first.
Or you could go slowly and you get some really nice rewards off these cards. Uh, the third thing you could do is you could invade a nearby port. And I'm in the wrong space to give my example. I'll do that. Uh, so pretend this were in my hand.
Sure. Sure.
Let's slide to do it properly.
You do only have three cards.
I do only have three cards. Yeah. Uh, so to invade a port, and this is kind of where all the onboard stuff is going to happen. You can from where you are, you can invade any adjacent regions that share the flag color of the card you played. You can place combined between all those spots up to as many pirates to invade as you have flags of that color. And then you take the action in wherever you choose at the strength of your total number of pirates there. And that has this interesting mechanism because you can visit the same place multiple times. You'll see there's five ways into this port. So later on I could come around here, invade with another one, and now my action is at a strength of two. And you can even move p there's an action that even lets you move pirates around adjacent land masses. So that is the core thing you're trying to work out here on the map.
But how about all these monsters? They look dangerous, especially this one. Look. Um, a skeleton from Germany. I don't know. Australia, whatever. Oh, this is Euro again. All right. Germany.
Yes. Um, they do look dangerous. And I forgot to mention. So, when you are sailing, uh, wherever you finish up, you have to fight the enemy that's present. And you check the bottom. There is a little bit of a random element here. There will be some amount of pistols that you need to defeat it and some amount of shields you need to avoid getting hurt. and you add what's on the bottom of the uh stande to whatever you roll on the die.
And um if you want to know the stat, there's that table in that board and it will tell you the strength and the shield.
Yes. So whether you win or not, it comes off the board. If you win, if you have enough pistols, then you get rewards, which gives you some reputation among the pirates and things like that. And if you don't have enough shields, then your ship takes damage, your pirates die,
and then you lose the game. No, it's not.
Well, it may lead to you lose points. You lose money, and money is points in this game, and so that may lead to uh defeat,
but it's not actually that bad. There are ways to mitigate as well.
Yes. So, things you can do out here, you can spend treasure maps to dig up buried treasure. That's pretty good. They're quite valuable. Uh they're first come, first serve. But if you leave pirates on the beaches, then they die at the end of
thirst in the beach. No water, no fresh water, and they die.
Very dangerous.
There's a lot of dying in this game already.
Yep. Uh you can visit the villages and you can plunder the villages of these crates. You can just crack those crates open and steal the stuff that's inside them.
Sure.
Or you can go to the ports and you can deliver them there. And that's one of the main actions in the ports. You can deliver crates and they will give you money. So that's again money is points. So that's a big way of getting points.
Wow, a nice pirate. Never heard of that.
Well, they're I mean I think they stole it from here and then they're sending us. They're actually just fencing the goods.
Okay, that's actually makes sense.
Uh the ports also have a have majority points for being there and you can trade food for extra resources and actions and things like that. And then there's all these various hideouts that you can fight your way into and you score based on how many of your meeples end up in those hideouts and how widely spread they are across hideouts by the end of the game.
Uh there's there's a series of events that will resolve when these spaces get crossed and you'll draw these event cards. Some of them just give everyone a bonus. Some of them have a bid. So you will bid money. Oops. You will bid money. Someone will gain the reward. Someone will potentially get a penalty for uh being the one who bid the least. And interestingly, the money goes up to Scoundrel Bay itself and that can get redistributed in final scoring. So, it has a
interesting mechanism.
This could be lucrative. I mean, the name of the game is Fortunes of Scandrel Bay. So, go figure.
Yes. The game continues in that way until someone has reached the fifth line. You all take two more turns and then you add up all your scores. So all the money you've collected points for various majorities and being in hideouts and reputation and all sorts of things. It's a highscoring game. Multiple hundreds of dollars. I think uh I think you won our first game with about 330. So just win from you.
See this is very much a euro game. You are with multi-use cards. There's well, you know, you do this. It's kind of like sight a little bit. You need to pick pick one action and then the next turn you need to pick a different action and then you engine build at the bottom here. The more you have the stronger your action is potentially at some locations and then you have this um I don't know like the they are they are shooting but they're like euro shooting. It's not like very big massive battles like very easy, very quick to resolve and just, you know, um what is it? Gun versus gun, shield versus se shield and then
yeah, you can probably think of it as being a feast for Odin style of die rolling. So, it's going to you weigh up luck a little bit in terms of uh whether you'll take a bit of a penalty or gain a bit less of a reward, but it's not going to stop you taking your action or sink your ship or anything catastrophic.
Yes. And the track advancement, obviously, Euro style track advancement is really satisfying where you just um you know, there are different stats you can advance and then if you max out, you're not going to waste it. you advance your track. There are lots of stuff in the game if you first see it. But it's actually not that complex.
No, it's not. It's not that complex. It's an interesting uh puzzle over the whole length of the game to work out where you want to put things and where you want to specialize. But ultimately, yeah, the actions will come to you pretty quickly as you go.
Yeah. Yes, I'll talk a little bit about the interaction and the timing because that's always something that interests me is how interactive is a game or in what ways is it interactive? And on the surface, this isn't that interactive. Uh there's a it's more things you're racing for. So, if you're the first to go into a certain space, you're the one who gets to fight that monster or you're the one who has to suffer that monster depending on whether you're strong enough to do that or not. Uh, the buried treasure is a race, but the crates are not a race. They keep getting replenished. Ports are not a race because you can always do what you want there. And in fact, you kind of want to hang back from a port standpoint because then you know how many meeples to put there to win the majorities.
However, if you're racing ahead, all the good stuff is up at the end, and you want to get there and leave the other players fewer turns to get there. So, if you get towards the end where it's dangerous, uh you can control when the game ends. You can try to get the higher scoring things and leave other people behind. And I really like that.
That has a very Marboy sort of feel. If you remember in Maraco, you can move short distances and then you get to take more village actions at once. Here, if you're moving short distances, I alluded to this before, the actions on your the cards that let you sail are much stronger,
but you're going to be down the low end of the board for much longer.
I'm going to follow that with my own note in terms of timing. So there's a really I think it's there's a really good balance for building your engine which is getting your actions very strong play recruit actions a lot and then having lots of meeples but you're going to end up with cannot feeding your meeples and that's going to hurt you quite badly. So, if you see one player keep building their engine without moving and then the other player can just like move forward fast and then they're going to trigger this um they're going to go past this trigger feeding the mele action and then you're screwed. So, that balance there is really good like you there's and then the person that's actually rushing ahead as well, they're probably going to be struggling as well potentially because that means that the engine is not that strong and then they don't have lots of flag and they can't they're not and they haven't actually been doing anything around here if they're racing forward. Yep. Or they haven't been building up their cooking capabilities, so they don't actually generate much food.
It was very amusing the first time we played, and we were like, "All right, I've got 10 meles. I've got 11. Hang on. The moment one of us crosses that line, uh, we're going to have to pay heaps and heaps of food."
And then I was like, "Oh, Ter, let's just like um um temporary cooperation. Let's just not cross that line." And you crossed that line. I did wait for meles. Um it's and it's not again it's not gamebreaking to do that. Meeples get sick. It means you can't use them for one feeding cycle, but if you've got enough food by the second feeding cycle, then you can heal them
or let them die. It takes two consecutive nonfeedings for them to die.
Yeah. And I thought that shooting the monster is hard, but it's actually not that hard. Especially it's quite easy to gain a mitigation token that lets you reroll the die. Pirate ring also a wild resource.
All right. I honestly scared of dice rolling, right? Like every time like I swear you you can fetch for me that I roll badly. If I need high, I roll low. So in this game I had no issue. I had enough mitigation and it's like sometimes you I think you at some point you rush ahead and sometimes I rush ahead at you at the end. It's good to actually fight the monsters. You get um you get the track advance. you got some bonus um for fighting monsters and you kind kind of wouldn't want that.
Yeah. Lots of good stuff up there for uh for pirate reputation.
Yeah, because like that reputation, look at that. That 40 at the top there. If you keep gaining it, you get five points. Five coins or five points. Points is coins. Coins are points. So that's really really interesting that you know you're going to have to look around. So I guess the interaction comes from looking around at your opponents. See where they are at. Do you think they are going to raise their head and then cause you misery?
Yes.
I mean, not that misery, but
the game's got a really nice It's just restrictive enough. I think you have three cards in your hand. There are four different colors. you are, you can see where you want to go and you sometimes have to spend more rum to snatch the cards that will let you go there cuz it's the most restrictive part of the game is that you can't invade unless you have the correct color.
Yes. That's why there's this action, right? Um to pay three runs and then you can look for the right color.
Yes.
Yes.
And both of those things, it actually does take me a little bit back to footprints. You can kind of see that this has the fingerprints of footprints of Yeah. The
the footprints of footprints.
It has the It has the DNA of
footprints of footprints.
It has the DNA of footprints in it because that was a game where you had
it was your own deck, but you had quite a bit of restriction on what you wanted to do. you had that choice to race ahead and get towards the end or to hang back and block people off and and complete objectives and that was always a foot footprints was it didn't feel like your typical Euro
was a it was a
well like a racing game or not really racing game
it was racing mixed with Euro and it was sometimes difficult to
uh fully place it whereas this one very much is that DNA
in a clear euro. So,
so don't get fooled by the appearance. This game is definitely 1,000% Euro game. Yes.
All right. With die rolling, whatever.
With little bits of d with feast for Odin level of die rolling.
Yeah.
Um there really are important things up at the end.
Yeah.
And the and there's there's even one here. If you get to the end, you can cash in your leftover resources for two points per resource. It's this huge amount of
lots. You got 50 50 coins out of that one time.
And but you've got to get all the way to the end. So, two steps past the endgame trigger space to actually get there. So, if someone guns it and you're stuck back here and you don't have enough unlock tokens to sail in extra time, that's just out of your grasp and you've got to focus on points in other places.
Totally. I do enjoy games that drive the end by other people's actions that makes you like always like on the edge like, okay, what's that person's going to do? I mean, to a certain degree, it's kind of like Great Western Trail, but it's not the same. But you know like if people keep going to the what is it? Station.
Yeah.
Depends which version you have. The station. I think all of them are called stations. Everyone's going to the station and it's going to drive the game faster and quicker. And that's why you need to really, you know, get ready for it. But if you are the one that drive the game quicker, are you ready? Do you think you're going to win?
It's very interesting. Like it's it's really enjoyable to play it. I mean, pirate theme. Um, it is it thematic, Taran?
I think it's relatively thematic. Um, yeah, buried treasure, plundering, it has that pirate sort of feel. Um, feeding your pirates. I think it does uh fit its I think it fits within its theme very well.
Yeah.
The one thing that may surprise you on your first time through, it certainly did on our first time through. Neither of us was gunning to the end. We were just like, la do everything. Uh, get good majorities here. I'll deliver like three caros here. Oh, I'm out of pirates.
We both ran out of pirates when we were about here and we're like, "Ah,
this game is designed to gun it a little bit faster along the track because we were at the point where we didn't have the meles left
that you needed to invade to even do these good things up here. So this this limit I'm sure with experienced players you'll get nowhere near this limit but as you're slow if you really slow play you will run out.
Yeah I mean this is like oh you don't want to have the you don't want to hoard lots of pirates here that means you have to feed them but then if you're out of it all the good stuff at the end you're probably going to miss. So that's sort of like so up your cooking skill but then up your fighting skills. And this is why it's like your engine is up more because you're like la. But then when you gun in it, it's like it's not as quick because
you're more likely to take damage and things like that.
There are also some extra modules that you can add into the game. So there are uh
objectives that you can race for and they'll give you upgrades. Uh you have a captain who's worth two strength when invading and there's also powers you can give to that captain. And so they uh you have a player power while your captain's with you and then you score an objective when the captain leaves.
Uh doesn't add that much extra complexity to the game, but it adds these extra things to think about.
Yes. Captain
and I and I do particularly like the the ones where you are racing for specific objectives because
yeah, you've got pirate you've got buried treasure and you could choose whether to do it or not, but if that's one of your objectives, then you've got specific things to go and race each other for. So that's a nice addition.
You say captain. Captain 8. It's like this one. Lemonade.
So is this game worth getting? I think so. If you like, you know, if you like the sound of what we just described and review. Once again, it is going to be available from Essence Spill 2025. If you are going there, not sure when I am actually releasing this video. Maybe during Spill, maybe later. at the time. Tomorrow I'll be flying to Assen Spiel, so we'll see how it goes. Hopefully you enjoyed that. What do you think? What's your favorite Euro pirate game? Is there such thing as pirate Euro game? Let us know in the comments. Well, thanks so much for watching.
Pirates of America.
That is totally true. Okay, beside Pirates of Maro, what else? Pirate team Eurogame. No, stop it. That's it. Thanks for watching. Bye.