Castle Nightingale Review | A Tense Samurai vs Ninja Duel
Transcript
Castle Nightingale is a tense stealth duel with ninjas trying to steal relics from a mansion guarded by a samurai. But, does the gameplay live up to the theme? I'm Dr. Brian McDonald. This is Brains on Games. Let's talk about Castle Nightingale from Sandcastle Games.
Castle Nightingale does come from Sandcastle Games. This is a review copy that was sent in to me by the folks over at Asmodee. It's a game with a modular board. Everything's kind of randomized at the start of this game. This is a two-player game that works for players aged 10 and up. Games take 20 to 30 minutes to play. This is a light asymmetric hidden movement game. What you're trying to do as the ninjas are to steal these vases that may contain a relic. There are eight of these around the table. Two of them are empty and have nothing. So, out of the remaining six, you need to get five of these in order for the ninjas to win the game. The samurai, of course, is attempting to catch those ninjas before they manage to steal everything. And the samurai wins by capturing all three ninjas before they're able to get those five relics.
This one has a very simple rule set and each player is very asymmetric, too. But, each player does have a good cheat sheet that indicates what all the icons on their cards are going to do. And very simply, what you're doing here, well, you you begin by setting up the map. The samurai player is going to cover up two of these secret entrances on the board, and then they place their mini somewhere on there. And the ninja then is going to position themselves on one of these secret tunnels, these secret entrances on the board before the first turn begins. Each of the players is also going to start with one piece of equipment. They've got a little equipment deck here. These equipment pieces are single-use only, so you discard them in order to use them, but they do each of them also has two actual uses. On the ninja side, if they discard their equipment with this side facing up, and all of the backs of the deck are the same, this allows them to jump over a space on the board, which could be very important. But, of course, all of the equipment on the other side are quite different. Sometimes you might be able to open a closed secret passage. You might be able to prevent the samurai from moving that turn. The samurai equipment will allow the samurai to either increase or decrease their move by one, or of course, if you flip it over, you're going to get other kinds of equipment like a net that will allow you to capture the ninja, for example. And then there's a bit of action programming here. So, players are each going to start with three cards, and the cards
have an action and a movement on them. So, the ninjas always go first, and then the samurai follow up. One thing that's interesting and asymmetric about this game is the way that these cards are designed. I don't know if you'll be able to tell here, but the way these cards are designed is that the ninja takes an action first and then moves, but all of the samurai cards, they move first and then they take their action. The figures move differently, too. The ninja are moving one square at a time on the board. You can see that the floors are divided into squares, whereas the samurai, they move by color groups. So, they'll move across an entire floor. There was They'll be counting one from blue to yellow, two from yellow to blue again, and then three over to green. So, that it's it's quite different how they operate, and of course, the guards need to move quickly in order to catch those ninjas. On your turn, each player is going to choose an action. They place it face down so that the other player doesn't know what it is. The The samurai also have these nightingale floor tiles, and that's going to indicate which floor colors are going to set off an alarm.
So, you'll be sort of looking at where the ninja is or where they might be going, and then you'll be making an effort to choose the best option that will stop them in their tracks. The ninja's placing their one card down. The samurai is placing not only their card, but also which floor is going to set off the alarm. And that's really where you're able to bluff maybe a little bit, and you're trying to deduce where the other player is going to want to go. The ninjas always act first. This card is going to allow me to draw another equipment piece, and then I'm going to move four spaces on the board. And the movement here is interesting for the ninjas as well. This card indicates that my ninja needs to move exactly four spaces. Now, maybe I could use this equipment that I just picked up. You can use it on the same turn that you get it.
Maybe I'm going to want to jump over a space in order to potentially avoid getting caught by that nightingale floor. So, I think I'm going to try and grab that vase that's right beside my ninja figurine. I'm going to place these four paw print tokens adjacent in a pathway next to that ninja. I'm going to be able to grab that vase, and secretly, without showing the samurai, I'm going to check to see if this one's empty or not. And luckily, it's not. So, now I've got the first of five of these relics that I need to get my hands on. If I had stepped on the floor of a color that matches the tile that the samurai placed, I have to immediately stop my move. My character would become visible, so I'm going to take all of all of these pieces off as soon as the alarm goes off. It was If it was green, I'd be stuck here. I wouldn't be able to continue moving. I wouldn't put any paw prints on the board. But in this case, it was blue. The samurai may be thinking that I was going to move down here. Once the ninja's paw prints are placed, they come off the board. They're no longer visible. They're in hiding right now and then the samurai does their turn. And what we have here is another card where I get to pick up a piece of equipment, but I can't do that until after I move.
I'm going to be able to move three colored spaces here and so I could do as I said 1 2 3 and try to move towards where this ninja has started their turn. Then I pick up my equipment and now I've got two different things that I can do. One of them is a net. One of them is a set of keys. The one I just picked up is this set of keys. I can discard that to allow me to move through the garden. This garden is usually impassable. It's in the middle of the board. You can't usually go through it unless the samurai guard has keys. They can use those keys to walk through that as a colored space. Or of course you can discard it back to the box in order to maybe increase your move by one extra color group, so I'm that much closer to catching that ninja.
Once everyone's done their turn, if the ninja didn't set off the alarm with the nightingale floor, you're going to flip over that token and now I've revealed that blue tiles would have set off the alarm on that last turn. But now what's revealed, because this stays here after the first turn, there's always going to be one tile face up, one tile that the samurai doesn't have access to, the ninja player knows now in round two, blue spaces are going to be safe because that's face up. The samurai doesn't have access to those as one of the cards that they're going to play face down here. The second round proceeds in the same way. You're going to keep playing until one of the characters has achieved their goal of either capturing all the ninjas or getting those five relics. You always draw up to three cards before you do your next turn just so that you've always got those three different actions to choose from. Once there's some footprints on the table, the ninja's turn changes a a bit. If there are no footprints and there's no visible ninja on the board, you can take any one There's only ever going to be one ninja on the table at a time, but if there's no footprints, you could place your ninja and start the turn on any one of those secret passages that's open. You can't start from a closed secret space.
But if there are footprints on the table, I have to start from one of these four spaces. So in my second turn now, I have a movement of five. I've got a a piece of equipment now that I can get another one this time. It looks like I've got throwing stars. I'm very I'm starting very close to the samurai. I know that blue tiles are safe. I'm going to discard one of my equipments in order to jump over that orange tile cuz I don't know if orange is safe or not, and then I'm going to start moving towards that vase. I'll put my paw prints here. I need to put five of them down until I get to that vase. I'm going to take a peek of that at that and see if it's empty or not, and I've got my second relic. But as soon as I step on that green that green floor, the alarm is going to go off.
What happens now is that I have to finish my move. I'm getting rid of all of my footprints now, but the ninja's visible because he stepped on that squeaky floor, and I'm in big trouble because I'm very close to the samurai. The samurai has a movement of two, but I've got this great big green zone in the middle of this floor here. As soon as I walk onto the same zone as a visible ninja, that ninja gets captured. Now the samurai has caught their first ninja. I'll finish my move, and maybe what I'm going to want to do is move onto this secret passageway and block that off by ending my turn there. The action on my card though says that I also get to block off another one of those secret passages. So now all of a sudden I've got these a couple of areas where the ninja can't start their turn. If I do manage to close all of these up, I'll capture the ninja, so that could be my second ninja captured. So, I'm slowly moving this samurai around, maybe in an effort to catch the ninja or get close to them, but maybe I'm just trying to get to these secret passageways and close things up. The ninja's captured, the samurai's closed two doors, and that limits where the ninja can start their turn or where they can go on their turn.
I'm going to talk about those secret passageways in a moment, but the other thing that happens is because the ninja was captured on a turn that they picked up a vase, that vase now goes to the samurai who can put it on an open space on their floorboard. So, now I didn't get to hang on to that vase because of the green nightingale floor that set off the alarm and got me captured on that same turn that I picked up the vase. Now, if I had if I had managed to last one more turn and I didn't pick up any on the on the third turn, I would have been okay, and I wouldn't have had to give anything up. I don't have to give up the first one because I've managed to squirrel that relic away before the samurai caught me. In the next round, I'll take one of my other ninja figurines and they're going to start on a secret passageway. And these passageways are like tunnels that are adjacent to each other. So, if they're open, I could start my move now instead of on these adjacent spaces, I could move to an entirely different tile and put things out this way, and maybe I would get a third vase, well, a second vase cuz I lost the second one that I took earlier. Maybe I get another vase that way. Unfortunately, a smart samurai could turn the secret passageways into a nightingale floor, and that would set off the alarm if I tried to do that.
What skills are you practicing by playing a game like Castle Nightingale? Um well, this is about planning and deduction. So, you're trying as the ninja to figure out not only where will the samurai be trying to move, but also which floor is going to set off the alarm, whereas the the samurai is really trying to bluff the ninja and maybe try and get them to guess wrong so that you can trap and capture them. You've got the planning that's required to get your ninja to those vases without setting off the alarm, or to close off all of these secret doors so that you can catch the ninja before he can get away. So, there is a lot of deduction here, and you're also doing some planning in terms of how are you going to get into position to do what you need to do without getting yourself caught.
And even the samurai has to be careful about not getting caught out by a ninja who manages to move all the way across the board and grab some extra vases before the samurai can catch him. So, it really is a strategic duel where that planning is very important and deducing what the other player is going to do is very important, too. Final thoughts, though, about Castle Nightingale. I thematically this is a an excellent game. I really like that ninja versus samurai element, and Nightingale floors are something I've read novels about characters who are trying to sneak across these floors in order to pass a test. You've got the great table presence with a red panda samurai and three different ninja poses. The ninjas are cats, which is I I think it's it makes it more fun. Maybe it makes it look more like a kids' game, but it was all adults who were playing this one, and we had a good time playing it. So, you've got this tense two-player duel where there's hidden movement and there's deduction and bluffing, and some strategic planning that's required there, too. And we thought the first time we played that it seems like the the ninja was having such an easy time kind of evading the samurai, but once the samurai started closing more of those doors, it became harder and harder for the ninja to do what they wanted it to what they wanted to do. And it was quite interesting because it wound up being a situation where the ninja in our
first game was able to quickly grab three of those vases, maybe even four vases, but they only had three relics in them. I don't remember exactly what the final tally was there, but at the end, it was really down to the last turn. Two ninjas were captured, leaving only one, but the ninja had four out of the five relics that they needed. And so, it really was tense at the end. And interesting tension for such a short game. There are quite a few icons to keep track of, but the cheat sheets make that pretty easy. And some of the abilities here of this equipment were pretty powerful, being able to stop the samurai from moving, or being able to capture the a ninja from a distance with a net.
I mean, we had a lot of fun playing this game, I have to say. And it's got that table presence. It's got great art on the cards. I really like the art style that they've chosen. And even though the red panda and the cats make it look sort of like a kids game, and it is approachable for kids, for sure, but it's not only for kids, I would say. You know, a 10-year-old might be able to play this game, but I think that the adults are still going to have a good time playing it, too. It has been a while since I played a hidden movement game. I think the most recent one was Run, and that was a few years ago. Now, Run is my favorite hidden movement game. Um just because I I do like the kinds of clues that the runner has to give, and the cards that the patrol, the officer with the helicopter has to play in order to take their actions. So, I think the asymmetry in that game is a bit different in terms of the the clues that are available to be used for the deduction. But, this is my number two, for sure. Definitely the best hidden movement game I played in a long time, and second only to my very most favorite one. That's the I mean This is a good game. I love the theme. I I love these pieces. That Nightingale floor idea with one floor that's always going to be safe after the first turn is really something that adds to the deduction and the bluffing that you can do here. So, um I mean, I think even once the samurai starts some of
their cards allow them to move vases around on the board, and they're going to put those on certain colored spaces, and maybe those are the spaces that are learned. This was a good time, you know? And for a quick game, still pretty tense. I think this is a great addition to the hidden movement genre. My second favorite hidden movement game is this one. It's and it is easily accessible. It's I think it's a good entry for for folks who want to kind of try out these hidden movement games. It's also one that has, at least for me, has some staying power because I do want to play it again. I want to try it out with, you know, different players and see, you know, and and to play as the samurai versus my son as the ninja instead of the other way around. You know, we had a good time. I really like this game. I have to thank Asmodee for sending it my way. The downside here is that it is a two-player game. It's two-player only. You can't play solo, and you can't play it multiplayer. I really enjoyed this thing. If you have any questions or comments about Castle Nightingale or anything else to do with Brains On Games, you can leave them in the comments section below the video, or you can email me at Brian@brainsongames.ca.
Brainsongames.ca is the website. That's where future episodes are going, and the previous ones are already up there. Brains on Games is the X handle and Facebook page and the Instagram feed. So, we're all over the place. And if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones, you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button. Thanks for joining me, and hopefully I'll see you next time.