Skip to main content
Loading video...

River of Gold First Impressions - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 52:30

hey everyone welcome to Friendly ties we are going sailing today on the shiniest River you've ever been on it is the river of gold uh yeah so so we're going to chat River of gold today uh I'm I just finished playing my very first game I'm the rookie here John you've played two times now right and Anastasia yeah I'm a season veteran yeah yeah and Anastasia you got into it and started jamming it on on BGA BGA yeah this is my fifth play in I think 48 Hours like I think when did we did we think John and I play this on Monday night and it's Wednesday so true I think that's true yes so still relatively new but yeah Reon I've been curious about this one for a while it came out at uh Gen Con just a couple of months ago and then yeah in the St and I were like let's play something just arbitrarily and I was like I've heard this game is cool and we did this thing that I've never done before where we turn on board game arena and we skimmed the rules for like three minutes and then we just started trying to play the game because board game arena click tells you what to do and we got through a full game in 80 minutes and we were both we both like chatted about it for like 20 minutes after and then we roped Nick in and yeah we literally stopped our first game like 15 minutes ago and we we sore self to silence we haven't said anything about our impressions of this lik it I don't know anything yeah this is our yeah this is going to be all caught live here wa give me give me some facts is this a is this a publish or designer that I know the designer is uh

Keith uh pigot I believe and I am not familiar with them they have at five credits on uh BGG but the publisher is office do and they are a couple of years old uh they were a branch a new kind of subsidiary of asade day so they've got big big backing and all that kind of stuff and they've put out some uh good-looking games uh but not a whole lot of games overall so far and uh I heard about this game because it just just like minor Buzz essentially just on the internet just like I don't know social media just I kept hearing like River of gold good River of gold good and then um we had the opportunity to try it and and I I really liked it I I've really enjoyed it we'll talk about that more soon but um yeah I guess the hype machine worked here well we've only played it online but I do have to say after we played it I did look up some pictures of it and my goodness does it look like it is very pretty in person so I think when you said shiny River you weren't kidding the board is like shin River they have like the Fig thing like they do with the um what's the other game they do that in the cge game c Ora that's right yes also a shiny game yeah it looks fantastic in fact I've already got a copy on my wish list which is just going to speak to what I thought of the game the fact that it's on your wish list and not in your mailbox is the part that actually is maybe surprising yeah middling review you haven't it's not your house yet guys I am a new woman I you know what

I'm going to try and trade for it that's not I'm gonna I'm gonna wait until it's close enough to Christmas that I can call it a Christmas gift or I might buy it tomorrow and play with my friend on Friday we'll see I I'd like to do just like an incredibly quick um just high level overview of this game uh just to get people in line with it and actually I'm going to start this by saying it's a surprisingly quick teach like there's a lot of icons and stuff like that but shockingly simple for how complex it looks yeah the core of the game is you have a long skinny board with a river going down the middle of it with a whole bunch of spaces like stops on that River everyone has two boats and it's a loop essentially and on your turn you will have a die that's rolled it's a D6 and you going to either sail down the river equal to that amount so if you're all three you move exactly three spaces then you get everything where you landed or you can use that three to build in the three area and then that's going to be on the river so then when people sail to that spot you get stuff and they get stuff and the third thing is you can play a card from your hand that has a three on it to then spend your resources to play the card gives you stuff gives you ongoing stuff victory points but you may have noticed the through line is you roll a three on your die and all of the actions that you do are associated with a three but at the beginning of your turn you can spend a resource divine intervention to change the value of that die and then you roll the die at the end of your turn the next person goes and uh you just you just do that for a while yeah instead of uh instead of multi-use cards it's a multi-use die right and essentially yeah it's it's interesting because the right there's three actions

you describ building moving and uh playing a card out of your hand and building spends the money playing card out of your hand spends resources like your what is it like Silk and Porcelain and rice goods different goods and then moving in the river gets you resources and you got two different boats that you can move so it's three actions but four options because you have you have uh two boats to two different boats in like different spaces which gives you a a limited number of choices but quite like I I think that like on your turn getting to choose three to four options is like a very good decision space I think that's like I if I was going to put one thing on a pedestal the most in this game it is that they nail the space that your decision making is it it feels really appropriate and of those action choices the one that's like playing a card from your hand is kind of binary because it's like does the number on the die match the number in your hand if you're going to complain about bad luck in this game it's going to be because the die is not matching the number you want to play the card in your hand but you can absolutely make something work with your boats sailing um or by choosing to take the build action in like a various different region based on your die roll so um I I really like the space that roll a die and then react to this creates for a player yeah and roll a die at the end of your turn abut so you're you're thinking

about what you're going to do when everybody else is going yep which really helps with the AP I think like that that just that subtle thing you know you know and obviously you can do that in a lot of games I do like that that is just like called out of me to like end your turn roll your die and then sit there and and Ponder your choices so you're always thinking and this game has you know one of the ways that these pieces kind of work together together is that when you build those buildings you're going to build them on this River of gold and and the buildings have these really lovely incentives where you you get something when you build them but you also create an opportunity for other people to get things from them when they sail and for you to continue getting an ongoing benefit when people activate them so I love a game like that it it it's funny Boon lake is probably not the best example of this but for some reason this reminded me quite a bit Boon Lake of something you know but also that idea of like when you do something it does something for other people and it's it's interesting because it's not in the actual mechanics of the game but it is you know it's not like action selection where you know I do an action and then someone else gets a benefit but still those little benefits that you can get on other people's turns it's just there's always kind of something happening so that really helps with what could be otherwise a little bit of an AP Fest it never really drags like that because you always have something to think about and you're getting little benefits depending on what someone does and it's reverse it's reverse Great Western Trail right where it's like instead of paying taxes you land on someone building they just get a Benny from example yeah it's it's kind of like

a communal engine it's not an engine but like it's a communal incentivize it's an incentivize because like the river starts out mostly empty there's some like basic buildings and stuff that like here's a buck or two bucks or whatever um but yeah it really fills in and going back like the reason I kind of emphasized the die rolling at the end of your turn and said at the beginning is because in this play that we just did the three-player game it's only my second play I would say on a quarter to a third of my turns I was sitting there like a kid on Christmas waiting for it to be my turn you know the turn order was like Nick then me then Anastasia then Nick then me and in numerous times not because you two were taking too long in your turns you weren't at all but I like like i' rolled the diet in my turn I was like yes I got exactly what I wanted or within one and I could manipulate it and I'm just like sitting there waiting waiting waiting and the Nick says he's done with his turn I'm like yeah all right here we go bang bang bang bang bang I'm doing this I'm doing that I'm like so excited to do the thing and uh and I think it's it's because you could think about it when it's not your turn and also I think it's because this game is just get stuff just get stuff get stuff get stuff and it lets you do stuff so while while you're trying to get silk or something like that you're also just happen to be getting money and then you turn around you're like wait I got 15 bucks I could spend this stuff and you spend the money and sudden you have like two porcelain like wait a minute I could spend that to play a card from my hand I I was surprised at Le especially my first play a little bit less than this one but in the first play I felt like every time I wanted to do something I had exactly enough stuff to do it and

that's not necessarily a bad thing it was kind of fun it was just like I I wanted to do the cool thing and it kept letting me do the cool thing in the second play that we just did there were a couple times was like I need one more rice so I'm going to go out there and get one more rice but even then it wasn't a huge stretch to try and do the things that I wanted to do yeah yeah I wait what do you guys think this mechanism is called this like roll one day so I want to call it like like dice action selection but it is it like it isn't that like I I I love that it's just one like roll a die but it has the feeling for me like all of my favorite like dice placement games like everyone take a shot when I mention Grand Austria Hotel um I but you draft a dys in Grand asria hotel right I think actually castles of burgundy is maybe a little bit close because you roll and then you have to decide based on the num is going to be a theme for tonight I'm going to come up with an example of a game and Nick's going to come up with a better one yeah that occurred to me that's a perfect example excellent that is a perfect example Castle the bringer is a great example of this okay but but to make my grand Austria Hotel point just in Vibe right like I love a game where the dice are dictating your actions but you still feel like you have a lot of choice because what so interesting about this is that sure I rolled a one but I don't just do one thing with it right which is exactly why castles of burgundy is such a great example of this it's like it's more so that what of the what

of the action types do I want to do with this one die like because it dictates where you can build on the river it dictates the card you can play it dictates how far you can sail like I I just think that is so clever and done so well here and again to reiterate Nick's point just in a decision space that just wide enough to be really thinky but not so wide that it's completely overwhelming yeah it almost feels like I I probably didn't start this way but it almost feels like a modern roll and move game you know because you have these three actions and one of them is move and you have to move the exact amount that you rolled but you can modify it with this kind of resource but then it kind of expounds from that like oh well there's two different pawns that you can move okay cool but then there's these other things that you can do but also if you really want to build but you rolled poorly for it or you really want to deliver but you rolled poorly for for it your fallback is move and get stuff uh and then you have two options for that as well so I I really like how that kind of worked out so we've talked about moving and we talked about dice but buildings are really fascinating in this game um there's a ton of building spots down this River like 25 I I didn't count it I'm just looking at an image it's a lot of different spots and every position that you move your boat onto has four different benefits every position is touching four different buildings as you go down this River and then you activate all four things so that's another good thing about the moving but the buildings as we kind of alluded to like if I build a building then there's an owner's bonus and then there's an everyone bonus and so if Anastasia goes onto my building she gets the everyone bonus and then I get the

owner's bonus if I go onto my own building I get the everyone bonus and the owner's bonus so you by constructing things you give yourself spots that you really want to go to because it's really good to you but also you're making really good spots for other people and we saw that big time in this second game you know I played two players and three players just once each and I remember when we finished our two-player game my first thought was a that was fun and B I really want to try this with more people not because it was bad at two because we weren't really activating each other's buildings that much because there's only two of us and I really wanted to see more of that and we so did in this play that we just did like we constructed a decent amount and we were activating each other's buildings like crazy so I won just privace that I don't want to talk about it I beat in St by three points but I go and play it on BGA I'm undefeated I'm feeling so good I'm like guys I'm coming into this with four plays I'm gonna win right like I've got a leg up I practice I trained so by I'm not I'm not gloating I I'm saying this to make a point in that you constructed three buildings around a single River spot that also had a starting building on it so there are four different good things when you go there and you got a bunch of good stuff there but what was also there was seven victory points between two twos and a three that you put down and I hit that spot three times throughout the game like my final score is 103 21 points of that 103 a quarter of my score came because of the buildings you built and I

think that's really interesting it's it's fun because it's communal and so you you really are creating this River of gold for everyone and sure you get a little extra benefit but you're not like it's not so good for your opponents that you're going to like avoid going to their spes and I I really like that yeah I'm curious what the answer to that would be with people who are playing a lot more I think one thing yeah um that that I want to highlight most that John already mentioned is that this Dynamic makes a two-player game or a four-player game I think feel very very different from each other is my suspicion having just played once at three players but I think I think that like that that like you get stuff versus I think I suspect the math there from like what I can sus out is that in a two-player game it's probably bad to land on your opponent's building almost every time but in a four-player game that turns around differently not because the rewards are different but because of the relative difference you're making against your other opponents versus the one who's getting all the bennies um yeah also you probably like can't throw a rock without hitting somebody's building in a four player game right exactly it's just gonna like fill up so much yeah I mean I think that I I will say this so I played it the the the so the five times so four

of those times were two-player and then this last time obviously we just finished was three player and after my first two-player game with John I I had the same I you know I had the same thought as you like I was like I think it's going to be better with three there'll be more interaction um there will be more spaces on the board you know I just that was kind of my takeaway having played it more a two player I started to see that what's really cool about this game is that sometimes you're focused on the river sometimes we haven't even touched on the tracks we're going to talk about that in a second I'm sure but sometime you're focused on the tracks sometimes you're focused on your cards because you know you get points at the end of the game for the number of customers that you played and they each have additional endgame points and you know we're going to talk about that there are three Mastery goals and in two-player it's I get it and you don't get it right and so there's there's a kind of a different Focus that comes in on each game and so while you know yes the river could be more interesting with more players that's just if that happens to be the focus of the game that you're playing like I was a little worried that this game was going to be a little bit syy and I I have realized as I played it I'm like yes sure lots of things are the same and you know but there's there's quite a bit of difference and because it's not an overly long game that's another beauty of it like we just played it in an hour you know and it's it's a fast game but the kind of the beauty of that of the small economy that it's making is that if there's a lot of goods

at play then maybe you're building more customers if there's a lot of money at play then maybe you're building more buildings and it's kind of dictated by the things that come out and kind of points the game in a a little bit of just a subtle direction that does it feel little bit time and I think thats uh kind of balance it out at the player counts yeah I've Loved this conversation already because of two comparisons that were made a castles of burgundy and the other is uh Great Western Trail and I just want to kind of highlight that because Nick said Great Western Trail and my my brain just kind of exploded I'm really enjoying this game I played it twice and the primary thing I complained about in our episode about Great Western Trail was that I I desperately wanted a Rondell game where we all built something cool together and it varied as opposed to and I'm like oh my gosh I didn't even realize it but I just played the game that I think I wanted Great Western Trail to be I mean it's much lighter designed your great w it's much lighter and whatnot but just going like kind of dovetailing and supporting what you just said Yeah in our first play I ended with six customers and you get a pile of points for put putting out customer cards and it actually caps at six if you get a seventh customer you don't get more points and I think in had like five and the game we just played I had four I guess Nick did get five down and in s got three but it just felt like we were putting down less and it might just be because of the emergent game state that we were putting less stuff down and I think part of the reason Nick put so many people down is because he put these victory points on spots where he got resources and we kept going there and like Nick you couldn't you couldn't spend him fast enough right yeah yeah I

mean I that was that was why I came in De last in this game is I I didn't understand the resource flow and actually like Dov tailes really nicely into a point that I want to make that I don't think is I'm not I actually don't think is good or bad but is important for people playing this game to like understand um you know games have like arcs right like they have a certain like flow to them and like Great Western Tri you brought up like is Rondell it's like you build your system and you're going to like hit this like a couple times like iterating the same cycle and this River does have a loop like you'll go to the bottom and then go to the top again and continue down but you're not going to have that long the game is pretty fastpaced anything you're developing in the game you know the buildings essentially are the the counter of the track and every time you hit the bottom it like flushes those things through so you're not building something that you're going to hit a lot of times the game is definitely more on the um tactical rather than strategic side of things in the sense of like you're trying to get your value get in get out you're getting you know the amount of like resources that you're getting are I think quite manageable numbers and you trying to just get like kind of the right things at the right time get them out you know and move through the game but you're not building a system that you're going to like hit over and over and over again uh you know it's it's not the the river is long enough that you know you build your super spot and yes you have two boats but you're only going to be able to hit that spot two three

times maybe over the course of the game just enough to make it feel good but not so much that you're like you know you got to make it happen and then make it happen because the game's going to end before you can hit it than that and if you're the kind of player who's like looking for a game where you like develop an infrastructure like this game isn't going to give you the space to do that um which is I think I think good uh I think it works for this game but it is it is important to understand about it yeah yeah that makes sense I do think the game is just long enough to give you the satisfaction of building an infrastructure and let you use it just enough to like feel good it's not like you just got to use it once you can use it two or three times or in my case have John use it two or three times um thank you but it it's just long enough to do that without then overstaying its welcome that is one thing that I really do want to compliment on it like in both this play and my first play with John and and it's hard to tell once you start just like playing it on BGA but like you know these plays we had where we were like live and and talking through them there was like this moment about two-third of the way through where I was like or even halfway where I was like oh my gosh the game's going to be over and then the game lasted just long enough beyond that again by the the natural pacing of the game it's like we built a bunch of buildings but then we're all broke so we stopped building them and the the buildings are what trigger the end game and I was like okay now there's like we're doing a couple of things so you feel that tension like the end game is coming and and it can come upon you very quickly and in in a game you know that does play and you know 45 to you know 75 minutes that's fantastic that's

what you want um but I I I I do want to complement it on like being just the perfect amount of time to be like nope I still kind of got to do everything I wanted to do I feel good okay game's ending it's not too long it's not too short it just it really did hit like a nice sweet spot for me and it's very hard for games to do that in my opinion in this first play I had the opposite emotion I felt that the game did not give me enough time but I but I do think that's a reflection of a lack of experience and it's not to say that I didn't have fun with it um but it yeah it it definitely gave me a an emotion of being pressed uh in a way that I did not expect from from the Like rules teacher at the beginning which was very easy I was like oh okay cool we're going to like build this stuff up right like um the game that when you buy your buildings on the river they have different prices based on how many different spots on the river they touch essentially and I was like oh cool I'll buy one of the expensive ones because it touches many spots and that was a rookie mistake you know that is also I should say another factor between three and two is even though I think the game is paced out longer there are more boats I do think but I just think naturally when you have three people people doing things you're going to do a little bit less and I did feel that ever so slightly in this game where I was like yep I didn't get to go quite as much the same number of build there's more there are more it's not the same number of buildings there are four more buildings in a three-player game than there is in a two player game um and there's like it 23 total or something so four is not a

tiny amount but also not a lot when you consider you added an entire another person definitely Anastasia's point of like it's it's uh uh you don't have the same amount of time in the different player accounts right exactly it's still yeah it's still balanced for that but not quite as much yeah yeah and I think part of it also probably has to do with some of the the strategy that can come into play like this is a pretty tactical game you're rolling a die to see what you can do on your next turn and again you can inrw something to let you modify it but if you really need a two and you roll a five and you only have one of the manipulation then you got to come up with a new plan but in this play I got three Merchants down actually I want to talk about the the deliveries the clients a little bit um yeah there there are five different types um and they all have kind of Vibes with different things within them but the the merchants activate they give you a benefit when you loop around the track and I started the game with two merchants in my hand you always have two in your hand and I drew a third one as soon as I played the first merchant down and I got all three of my Merchants down before I looped the track once like I was really slowly working down with my first two boats and I managed to get three of these things down I'm still not even sure how I did that without actually crossing over I think I just inched down the river and my with my plan being like I'm building a loop around the river engine now I have three of these people uh one of them gave me a point for every person I'd put down every time I went around one of them gave me the change your die juice another one gave me reputation which we'll talk about soon and and I got that third person down and I looked up and the game was like two3 over it

felt like like halfway over and I was like wait but I just did the cool thing now now I want to run the cool thing like what Nick was just saying and I think I did manage to hit it three times but also once I had that built I was just like slamming the river which probably really pushed the end game because every time you cross go every time you Loop you push the end game trigger some more so like Nick you were saying it just seemed like that that we were just going going going and like Anastasia kept constructing buildings which pushed the end game and I was I was trying to make my my boats be speed boats because I because I had that benefit for it maybe it won't be quite as fast I mean we played in 60 minutes which is blisteringly fast and also just to clarify especially for the mental space just to clarify this was 60 Minutes on tabletop simulator um like BGA does all the math and stuff but this was essentially like we were sitting around a table playing the game yeah I'm going to bet it's not going to be it's going to be you know probably an hour you know maybe 90 minutes slow people maybe it gets up to 90 yeah I mean I guess this is sort of a question for Nick but it's like at least the way Jonathan and I felt when we sat down it was like there are a lot of symbols there are a lot of things it feels like it it looks and feels like it's going to be a lot more overwhelming than what the game actually yeah the icon wall is real um but the icons mostly don't they're not they're not like too difficult and they aren't the core right the the core system to since we're talking about Great Western Trail like you need to understand the icons because every building has the icons and that's the action that you're taking this one the

core system of the actions that you're taking doesn't require you to actually understand the icons um the icons are more like okay why do I care about playing this specific card well I'll just get the resources and play you know like you can you can kind of muddle your way there in your first play and halfway through you'll be like okay cool I understand what everything is um so I agree that it looks very intimidating uh even the rule book's pretty skinny but like just looking at all things you're like I don't know how this connects to that but it is more accessible than it appears on the surface while we I just mentioned customers and I want to say kind of one last thing about them I think they're really cool it sounds silly to be like oh the the recipe fulfillment is cool but when you put a customer down they give you something immediately they also give you an ongoing power and they give you an endgame Victory Point thing usually there there's one that's just all about endgame points but I think that's so cool because I think often times in games where like you get a bunch of resources then you spend them for the card that's going to get you points points are boring but in this game it gets you points and stuff immediately and stuff ongoing I think it's cool that every single one of these cards is like that like I would have expected some cards to be ongoing and some cards to be endgame and some cards to be like a big thing immediately and this game just wraps all three of those things into most of the cards which makes them even more fun to play and then they give you a bunch of points yeah the contracts are are more interesting than they are in many games I agree you know we haven't talked about is the six tracks on the board talked about the six tracks on the

board yeah let's talk about those yeah it's um we we mentioned reputation and we mentioned that it's a six-sided die and when you roll a three that lets you build in the three area every time you construct a building you also usually get reputation in that area so I build a building has a three on it now I get three three reputation I probably shouldn't keep saying three but essentially by doing by by constructing in the three Zone I get reputation on the three track that's why there are six different tracks and they are standard majority tracks you know there's points on them the person who goes farthest on the track gets big points second farthest gets middle points maybe third gets small points um but you get this reputation from building but also from activating the buildings and there's also Benny's on those tracks like oh if I go here the Benny I'm going to get a pot and then that's cool or I get the two money that I needed the tracks are probably my least favorite part on first pass I don't generally like tracks in games and it's Scott it does the um it's not area majority scoring but it kind of is area majority scoring which is like one my scoring mechanisms in a game so I it's you know every game needs to figure out a way that they convert all these actions that you're doing into points and this is the way that this game is figured it out to me it's it's not terribly inspiring um it but it also is like familiar so it uh it it allows you

to focus more on the parts of the game that are interesting by making this kind of scoring system be in in my opinion kind of boring I agree with you Nick that this is the way that the game has come up with to give you points right absolutely but what I most like the the tracks for is that on the second space of every track is a resource and so the fact that when you build a building that's the only thing you get when you build the building we talk about the bonuses you get from the buildings when you're sailing but the only thing you get when you build them is this reputation and I love that there have been points when I've been playing where I'm like man all I need is one silk and I'm like you know the best way to get that Silk I'm going to go build you know a building in the six area and I'm going to move up the six track and that's going to give me a silk fantastic and not only do I have that Silk now I'm ahead of my opponents and because they haven't built yet and I'm kind of pushing Along on that track and then everyone on the fist Bas gives you coins they're very just enough but not so much much that it also doesn't add a ridiculous amount of additional thought it seems like it's going to but they're all kind of the same and so you can kind of look at them and kind of be like this is just another opportunity for me to get a little bit of money or for me to get an extra divine intervention and as you kind of keep going up I've only seen this happen in one of my games but when you get all the way to the end you actually get I think it's three points per resource very hard to do that but it is three points and a resource of your

choice wow oh I've never I've never even gotten close but that sounds good yeah I mean I don't like a track just for the sake of a track but I do think that when you're starting to kind of get into more of like how are you going to play this game to not only have fun with it but also to win with it you know I think I think there's some interesting interesting things to find in those tracks and I and and I like that I I'm pretty ambivalent towards them I think I I lean a little bit more towards the Nick my biggest problem with them is that there are six of them which is a lot it's a lot a lot it is a lot I mean it is a lot when we played on board game arena which is you know very flat kind of 2D I just straight up ignored them which I could do because board game arena took care of everything for me uh and and it was just too much not because I was like overwhelmed by the game it just I don't know just something about it just seemed like I kept talk joking it was like a bridge too far um for me to care about in that first play um and then our scores are really close at the end and then in this play we're in tabletop simulator so we have that three-dimensional Vibe we're all very experienced with CTS so we're not slow in it like it feels like we're at the table and it was able I was able to see the tokens pop a little bit more better able to tell but it's still so many tracks and I think one time in this entire game I did I had like option A or B and a moved me up the tree track and B moved me up the fish track and I was like the fish track's better and so I did the thing and I went up the fish

track every other time I gained reputation it's cuz I I was doing something else to go up and we did final scoring and I was like oh wow I was number one and the the the best one because it's variable number of points and one of them was 12 points for being highest up and and I was surprised I didn't even notice I was just like oh I happened to be a majority I'm literally the best one but six tracks is so many it's just it's a lot and there Snake tracks too which makes it even harder to parse like at a glance like if they were just a straight track I like that would be a littleit EAS to just like over but they're trying to cram a lot on a long board and so I understand why the tracks are as they are but yeah um I do want to talk about something uh that that we didn't play with in our game tonight and I know that uh Jonathan you haven't played with in either of your games either but I I did get a chance to play with um in my other games and that is I think it's called the clan patrons mini expansion basically it it's it's asymmetric Powers that's what it is it's it's an optional thing that you can play with um it is something I read the designer diary on this and I guess it's something that they added in based on feedback I went and uh watched The Dice Tower uh talking about it they were like you should always play with this like we love them always play with them and they also pointed out something that I guess one of the complaints is that maybe it makes the game a little bit too easy my feeling is that it adds a little bit too much overhead to a game that already has quite a bit of overhead in your first

play or even your early plays because it's just like one more thing to think about but I'm I'm really curious if you think that having these would have helped you at all or been interesting for you at all because they each one gives a little bit of a different power that you get it's a little bit of focus but it's also a little gamebreaking ability and I honestly don't know where I fall on them sorry I hate it when I do that cuz I wish I knew um cuz I liked it both ways anyways I'm curious your guys thoughts uh you know just taking a look at them my gut instinct is that playing these in the first game like is is not a good call they're playing just like the the core game is there's plenty enough to to pay attention to that like using my special power uh it could be like a trap sometimes right or you like learn a bad lesson when you're learning a game so I I wouldn't have used these in a first game playing with someone my mind immediately jumps on seeing these to the the capitalists INF furnace um where it's like they have this little It Breaks the Rules with the game references comparisons are on point um yeah on point tonight I mean this game is so Euro that it's like how could I not compare it to these other Euros right uh yeah and and I I suspect that it will feel the same as those furnace leaders where like mostly they feel fun and different and you know not too obtrusive but definitely powerful and then people

will figure out that like H this one feels like it's definitely better than these other ones uh just on quick glance like there are a few that like perked my eyes a little bit more than than the rest of them I I have not played with them but I had the similar feeling I mean I I'm a bit of a asymmetric player power hater in Euros so I guess it's not too surprising but yeah I'm I like some of them like like one of them it just like get an extra three points every time you deliver a customer and like we already talked about like customers are really good you should be doing that already and when this person's kind of focused on it another person is like here's 10 bucks at the beginning well first customer I want to every time you deliver the first customer in a region so it it is it limits a little bit yeah yeah keep going just like a glance over another one gets you a bunch of money and then when you build you can build anywhere you're not restricted by the Die Another One lets you set the die by spending so like yeah it they seem like they yeah break each little element of the the game but I just worry that like if I had the get 10 bucks and you can build anywhere person like Nick said the Trap like I'm just going to be like I got to keep building I got to keep building because I can because that's my thing whereas yeah I I kind of yeah I I guess my my my hot take is I would probably never play with them unless I played with people who really wanted to because I like starting with symmetry in Euro games like I I I like feeling like if I won I did it because I made really good choices not well my my power feels

like it might be a little bit better or like in this specific situation um like sometimes a power is good in game a and bad in game B but like both of those don't feel great if you feel like you won because of your power or you lost because of your power yeah I mean I might be reading into it too much maybe they're perfectly balanced but that's kind of where I land looking at these overall yeah yeah I mean I think you know obviously I I talked about my experience with them a little bit and I think you know just you know you just described kind of the the essence of kind of like what you get from them I think that if you're playing this game and you're enjoying kind of the kind of micro engine building element that you can kind of do for yourself and you want to lean into that a little bit harder I think playing with these Clan patrons would give you that a little bit more in the game at least that's been my experience it's push you in a different direction and it's also going to you know give your opponent an equally quote unquote game Breaky right or changing some major element of the game but the furnace example is a perfect one it's like the system I think works really well as it is and I what I do really like about having them included in the game is that if you do play it a lot and you think it's a little syy then you have these and that is going to create a very different experience each time that's something you want to lean into or you kind of bounce off the the base game and want like a little bit more um I do think they make things a little bit looser and and give you even more abilities so they're fun to play with one thing I'm kind of curious to hear about from Anastasia just because you were the the the wisened expert at this

game with your five plays 48 hour is is how the scores have played out with doing different things like my data set is I played this game twice and in the first game I I was I was I like to think I was not complaining but I was just like oh I think I'm losing like Anastasia had like 30 points and I had like 16 going into final scoring and it felt like she was further ahead on me all these on all these tracks that I wasn't really paying attention to and then the dust settled on scoring and I I beat you by a handful of points and we were both like what and it's like well I wasn't doing this but that's because I was doing that and then in this game like we briefly mentioned there are these goals that you race towards you know uh in this one first person to build three of the same type of building gets seven points second person gets Five Points um and I barely did that in this game and at one point I was like I wonder if I could win by doing none of these I ended up doing doing one of them I got a second place in in one of the three I didn't even put my token down on the others whereas Anastasia got your token down on all three of them two of them in the very first spot so you got a ton of points from that and I beat you by three points again not gloating just like it's interesting the way the scores line up and I'm curious from your other plays like does it seem like the scores are kind of tight no matter what you're doing so looking at the three games I played last night on BGA it looks like all of the scores were in the 70s and ' 80s so all very close I mean you got to love like I love love me some BGA data

but like love a game that like you know you're coming in and you're just seeing your scores be really tight I'm just looking at these two-player games and I'm 30% of my score seemed to be my in-game score of course that that varied and then 30% of my score came from my customers and the customer bonuses and then the other 30% came from the majorities and it's just where where was I able to kind of like Edge that a little bit higher MH this is one of those games where like you can get points from a bunch of different places I happen to really like that because I like that I was scoring a bunch of points in the game and then John went and ended up beating me because he got points elsewhere in the game right like I thought like that made it really balanced I liked that like you know when I felt like I was a little behind in a different game I was playing I was like oh but I'm ahead on all the tracks cool I'm like still in it so you can see like that balances it out I think you just kind of bumped into something that I want to expand upon a little bit and that was like interaction I never paid attention to what your dice were I never paid attention to where your Boats were the only thing I paid attention to and I mentioned the first game I didn't at all was the tracks I think that's intentional like I think this is and and I kind of wanted to highlight that because you know a lot of Euro games have a lot of indirect interaction where you know work rep placement like I'm going to go on that spot now you can't go on that spot I don't think there's a single moment in this game where anybody did something and somebody else said ah dang it like we never but but the multiple times where somebody did something and and somebody else said oo and I think that's just lot of positive inter A vibe of the game I kind of wanted to highlight because some people

aren't going to like that but Al but I I like I like interaction I like getting in other people's way sometimes but also sometimes I just like a game that's just a fire hose of stuff but not too much like it it maybe not a fire hose it's like a a running tap that I'm able to drink exactly the right amount of um even when it's even when it's not my turn which means you know some people might not think it's crazy competitive or whatnot like it's incredibly multiplayer solitire I guess is like from an action perspective but it also means you can't really block my turn which I like yeah there's not there's not that like getting in your way I guess the only way you could block someone is if you built a building they want to build but the buildings are close enough to each other that you could just like proxy into something else seem so unlikely and it'll be an accident if it happens yeah and you're like racing for you know the points in these various areas I do think that there is like interaction in the sense of like oh I'm might choose to like change my die to this number and do this in this order rather than waiting for it because I am racing with you so I think that there is definitely space for players who are looking for that interactivity but the game allows you to not care about what other people are doing and still live your life just fine yeah yeah yeah I think it I think I think the two major places where you're going to feel the interaction the most other than obviously the tracks and you know that kind of but the two places you're going to feel it are in the masteries and then the end game I think is the other thing and it it it reminds me a little bit of ano 1800 in that way where it's like sure you know we're we're not the major points of interaction in that game or again like

are you going to take the thing that I need right but also when are you going to end the game and I think that that's really what plays out here like when when is when are you going to end the game will I have time to do everything that I want to do and then also like in 1800 the other space is a lot of that positive interaction it's you know what am I going to get what am I going to get from you doing this you know what what are your building is going to give me and so I I actually feel like this is for as much as you are just kind of focused on the thing you're doing this is actually one of the least Solitaire feeling multiplayer solitire games you know that that you know that I played yeah I mean probably partly because you get a lot of stuff when it's not your turn so like you're not sitting there and does yeah yeah did this game remind either of you of White Castle yeah for sure no like but I get it yeah I mean I totally get it I feel like I've just been like blind to comparisons all this whole podcast I'm like oh yeah oh yeah oh my God White Castle totally but it reminded you Nick yeah I mean for a couple reasons uh the the one I think that is the the big picture is that both of them are pretty quick pack a fair amount of game Euro like in an hour or 9 minutes you get like a lot of these sort of mechanics both of them have a tight number of actions but like Benny trails that just give you stuff along the way both of them are basically

themeless you know Point scoring games with beautiful components and this like rich Asian art like it's it's they're gorgeous games and dice and they both they both do the same thing they and dice right well but like the point is that like the dice are semic controllable right yep change them nope dice dictated actions tight spaces not overly long really interesting decisions and then all the pieces kind of like fitting together yeah that interconnection inter connection you do this and it kind of feeds into this and do this my take on this game the funny thing is that like for as much as this game reminds me of White Castle they are both they're also both so different like so that for me like one of the reasons I liked it so much is I'm actually a really big fan of of White Castle and which is a game that if you're not familiar that came out last year which we actually never did an episode on we kept talking about doing an episode and we kept not doing it we still might we might now we're we might so uh okay well we might do that um but it's uh it's I think there's a playthrough of it on John's channel so you can you can check that out if you want to see a a comparison but what is what what what I my description for this game is like and I think one of the reasons I liked it so much is it's like I just d games where

you select your actions based on dice is is just one of my top mechanics probably is my top mechanic I I just love it I love adding luck into a game like that and for me what this game is it it's White Castle if if if you played if you played White Castle and you were like there's only nine turns and like it's agonizing decisions and like of course it pops off and all of these crazy ways and it's it's a great game but if you want to play White Castle but and have a totally different experience and a totally different game but with a similar Vibe and a s similar level of satisfaction but get to take less agonizing turns because you strictly just get to take more of them then I think you're really going to like this and I really liked it and I I I very carefully am making that comparison and saying like I can own both of those games and feel like they are very different this is not a versus for me this is a White Castle is a great game and I think this is a great game and I've just really enjoyed them both yeah I I like the comparison um they are definitely quite different in uh in the interaction like there's lots of swearing when I play White Castle it's definitely a TI game things can be blocked and whatnot but yeah I mean I think that they a good point they hit a very similar feel I mean I guess to kind of wrap up my feelings on this game uh I'm gonna get it I I don't know how but like this game is like we were halfway through our three player game and I was just like yep I'm buying this

like this is so cool there's a little more glowing praise that you can give than that yeah exactly um and you know especially like in this conversation when like you mentioned Great Western Trail and I was like that's right that like that that's I think that's the big reason this is hitting a button that I've been wanting to be hit for a while for me and and also as a rules teacher we haven't really harped on this too much but like it's so simple to teach this game is like easier to teach than White Castle and I feel like White Castle is surprisingly easy to teach um and the other thing that you know from like an endorphin hit perspective and again I think one of the reasons I like it so much and why I'm going to be getting a copy that that reminds me of White Castle is that um it gives do a lot of little things at the same time um White Castle is a pop offy game I'm not going to go into details of that but there's a there's a subtle thing in that game that like makes you it cheats you it lies to you into making you think that you did more on your turn and river of gold does that every time you move down that River because every spot is next to four spots it's not like oh I go onto the spot what's on the spot I get three bucks cool I'm done every single spot is next to four things at the start of the game most of them give you a dollar so like you go to the thing you're like 1 plus 1 plus 1 plus three4 but still four and again it tricks you because it's 1 plus 1 plus 1 plus two reputation it's not three koku I guess it's called in this game and I think that's like this is not a pop offy game there a couple moments I was able to build a little bit of an engine every time I circled around where I I had a

long term because I was kind of popping off in that moment but in general it isn't but it makes me feel like it is like almost like like every time I move down the river it feels like I did a combo even though I didn't and I think that's kind of brilliant so yeah I mean I'm I'm I'm a really big fan I played it for the first time two days ago and uh I'm I'm sold yeah I mean I'm excited to play it again which I thought was really high prais until you said you were going to buy it so comp compare with that so yeah I'm excited to to play it some more and see what it looks like I suspect like with most multi like two to four player games I'm going to prefer it at four players rather than two players and that's totally fine I liked that you know that interaction of like how the buildings work and everything like that um with multiple people so I suspect that's going to be where I land I think the the I said this right at the beginning but I really want to hit at home because it's definitely my favorite part about this game the roll the die and then you have four possible actions maybe three possible actions depending on how Cooperative your die is or your hand is or anything like that and then that is enough space to make an interesting choice and I I really like how discre the actions in this game are that's part of the thing that lends to its snappiness um that makes you feel like you played a full game in a pretty tight period of time yep couldn't agree with you more I love every single comparison that that Nick made tonight um Great

Western Trail top 10 game castles of burgundy top 10 15 game like you know like even some of the ways even when John was teaching it he was like oh it kind of it's got like a little Concordia feel it has nothing to do with Concordia but there's there's a similar feel in the Simplicity of your turn and the way the game ends I made an connection to ano 1800 it reminds me of grand AA Hotel I mean like I just listed off a bunch of my you know top 10 games and it just it gives me little Vibes of that and it's it's it's really fun to you know every year more games come out and you know I know we joke like it's not already in my mailbox but like I've actually really stopped you know kind of really kind of in a like cool I'm going to kind of just kind of shave down my collection I'm really kind of not trying to add and I didn't expect you know every year I'm like I don't know a bunch of new games we'll see and it's just it's so fun to come across a game that again continues to innovate and continues to take little pieces from a bunch of different euros and we could say Okay Franken Euro another Franken Euro but like done it in a really cool way that's really fun feels fresh and just like White Castle last year just kind of takes takes it and and and plays with and has made a great fast God I love a Euro that can play in 60 minutes and you know you can do two games in a row and I just I I love that and um I've really been enjoying it so I'm looking forward to it I think I'm probably going to go buy it right now so I can

oops great so that'll bring us to the end of our our Impressions uh conversation on river of gold if you are listening to the podcast version of this and you want to weigh in uh head on over to the YouTube version so you can drop a comment we'd love to hear like have you played this game what was your impression what's stood out to you and thanks for listening everybody yeah thanks all bye

Progress saved