Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pillars Of The Earth Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 9:50

Hello. Welcome back to the channel, and this is a channel where we give you reviews, playthroughs, unboxings, which we really like to talk a lot of bollocks. Tabletop gaming in general. And in this video, we're going to be talking about a reasonably old worker placement game. We're going to be talking about Pillars of the Earth. And in this game, you will be placing your workers out of the board to take a variety of actions that will give you points that will allow you to win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview. And we're also going to tell you what we do like, we don't like. We'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Pillars of the Earth is still worth your time and bother today and in the future. So, remember, if you are new here, you better consider subscribing to this channel. Leave a comment in that section down below. Hit the like button and all that YouTube We'll see you after this bollocks.

So, Pillars of the Earth, how do you play this game? So, Pillars of the Earth is a worker placement game at heart. You're going to have two sets of workers. You're going to have your master builders, which will go into a black bag at the beginning of the game. And then you're going to have your bog standard proletarian workers that are going to go out of a cutting down wood in the forest. They're going to go to the gravel pit to get sand, or they're going to go to the quarry to get stone, right? So, when you set the game up, you will chuck out a couple of craftsmen from a deck. And then you'll supplement that with a bunch of resource cards. First thing you're going to do on your turn is you're going to select one of the resource cards or craftsmen that's out there. If you select one of the resource cards, then you'll have to put that many workers that the card asks for on the relevant space on the board. So, if you choose the eight stone card, then you'll stick eight workers on the quarry. If you choose a craftsman, then you'll have to pay that much money and you'll put a craftsman in front of you.

But you've got to remember that you can only have five craftsmen at one time. So, if you want to buy a new craftsman, you'll have to swap out one of the old ones. If you do this and you swap out a stone cutter, you won't be able to sell stone at the market. If you swap out a wood cutter, then you won't be able to buy wood at the market. And if you swap out a mortar mixer, then you won't be able to get victory points from any masons that you've got in your tableau, right? You'll see that the cards you choose will give you a certain number of resources. You'll get these in the action resolution. So, you keep doing this until all players have passed and then you'll move on to the master builders assignment phase. In this phase, the first player will draw a master builder from the bag and they will give the owner of that master builder an option. They can either pay the amount of gold on the relevant track. So, if the black market is on the seventh space of that track, they have to pay seven gold to place their master builder on the board immediately or they can pass, in which case their master builder will be stuck on that space and you'll move black marker one space down.

And this means that subsequent draws will become cheaper. You keep doing this, going round and round and round until all the master builders have been pulled from the bag. They'll either be on the semicircle or they'll be placed onto the board. So, once you've done this, then you'll move on to the action resolution phase. You'll start at number one and you'll go all the way around to number 14. Action number one is the event resolution action. Everybody will have to partake in this. The first player will will draw an event card and they'll resolve the effect. These can have a positive effect or they can have a negative effect. Everybody might suddenly find a load of gold down a crack in a sofa or the king might decide that he's feeling a little bit grumpy and everybody might lose some gold through taxes, right? Action space number two is the archbishop's office. You've got your master builder here, then you are immune to the negative effects of the event. If you are a sado-masochist, then you can apply the negative effect and you can just take a resource from the marketplace, right?

Next space is the war mill. This is where all the workers will be placed if you pass and if you've got workers here, you'll get one gold each of them, right? So, the next space is King's Bridge. You've got a master builder here, then you'll take the card next to the action space. These are called privilege cards and they give you a positive effect that may be used one time or it may have a permanent effect. You might be able to get eight gold immediately or you might be able to get Otto Blackface, in which case he will provide you with an extra worker each round. Next space is the King's Bridge Priory. You will simply get one or two victory points depending on what space you've been to. Then you got the forest, the quarry, and the gravel pit. This is where you'll get your resources. You'll look at the resource card that you drew at the beginning of the round and you'll get that many resources on that card. The next space is a king's court space. The player who's cuddled up closest to the king will get the metal cube that's on the space and every other player will be immune from taxes. You'll find out how much tax you got to pay by rolling the die and every player that's not at king's court will have to pay that many taxes. So, our next place is the shoring. This is where you'll be able to get extra craftsmen. You've got a master builder here. You will get one of the craftsmen there for free. And the same rules apply. If you've got more than five craftsmen, you'll have to swap one out. Next space is the shoring castle.

You'll get two extra workers for the next round. These are temporary workers. Think of it as a medieval Deliveroo. Next space is a king's bridge market. You'll be able to buy and sell your excess here. You can't buy metal and each player will get one action over a buy or sell action. You move on to the next player and you'll carry on until each player has passed. So, next action we look to do simultaneously when we get our resources, we put the cubes on the actual craftsmen. And you'll be able to trade in those cubes for victory points. So, for instance, you might have a mason who lets you trade one stone cube three times for one victory point. And the final space is the start player space. If you put somebody here, then you will become start player next round. Ain't hard, is it? So, after you've done all the actions, you will add a piece of cathedral to the board and then you'll do a a bit of cleanup. You'll keep doing this for six rounds and then the player with the most victory points will be the winner Pillars of the Earth.

So, do we like Pillars of the Earth? So, first thing that we really like about this game is that the turn order mechanism continues to be the standout feature of this game after all these years. I mean, we've been playing this game for, I don't know, when did we get it? Way back when in the early 2010s, right? And the anticipation of not seeing your bishop's finger being pulled out of the bag meaning you'll get a move for cheap or the fact that you might be groaning if that happens because the space that you want to go to has already been paid for by that bastard opposite you, right? So, the choice that you've got to make between money being absolutely vital in this game and grabbing the most lucrative spots first is a choice that still perplexes us to this day. So, the thing you like about this game is that the addition of the privilege cards, the event cards, and extra craftsman cards means that there's loads and loads of ways to augment your engine as you are building it. When you add more powerful craftsman to your engine, you're going to be able to get more victory points, but then you're going to be forced into a position where you're going to have to get more resources to accommodate them, right?

So, the delicious choice is do you waste an action going for an expensive privilege card or one of the master builder cards, or do you try and mitigate the damaging effects of the taxes or the possibility of a negative event? So, there's all these different things going on your mind, but you can't do everything. So, final thing that we like about this game is that Michael Menzel's artwork is always a joy to behold. This is the geezer that did the artwork for Stone Age and Legends of Andor, and also that piece of crap game, The Adventures of Robin Hood. There's so much detail here. You get up close and personal to the board you'll see all sorts of little things going on. And this is a common theme with Michael Menzel's art here. It's got a distinctive style and it's just pleasing to the eye. And if this was just sort of like a bland offering, say like you know, the Castles of Burgundy sort of thing, then I think this game would lose a chunk of its appeal. So, what don't we like about Pillars of the Earth?

First thing that we don't like about Pillars of the Earth is this game can feel a little bit empty towards the end game. Once a lot of the master builders have been placed, there's not really that many places to go, and you might feel that you are just placing your master builder out onto the board just for the sake of placing it out onto the board, right? This is more apparent in a four-player game. I've never played this with two players. I'm sure that there's some way of like blocking spaces off or doing something like that, but in a four-player game, competition for spaces is tight, and it just feels like there's just something missing towards the end of each round. Second thing we don't like about this game is that the wooden cathedral is nothing but a round timer. There's no mechanical purpose or it being there in the game. And truth be told, it looks like a giant humongous So, the final thing we don't like about Pillars of the Earth is that the rulebook, whilst it's quite easy to follow, there's lots of terminology in there that isn't immediately clear.

There isn't like an FAQ available. We had to search online for the answers, and we did find that somebody amalgamated a lot of the questions that have been answered by creating a comprehensive document, but even then, a lot of questions that we had weren't answered in that FAQ, right? So, like for instance, the game talks about the capacity of builders, and it's not really apparent what that is. Is it the amount of resources that I produce, or is it the amount of times that you can get victory points for trading in resources? Similarly, it talks about extra production. If you've got a certain privilege, you are going to get an extra resource produced. Do you have to actually go on to the space, produce a resource to get the extra one, or do you just get it for nothing? It's not actually answered in the rulebook. And that's a real frustration for such a simple game. So, to summarize, is Pillars of the Earth still worth your time or bother today and in the future?

So, we are going to say yes. We've been playing this regularly for many, many years. It's a soothing worker placement game that is the ideal antidote to crazy complex games from Alexander Pfister and Vitale Sard right? Pillars of the Earth exists on its own ethereal level due to its extremely simple rule set and its zen-like mechanisms, yeah? Every game we play to this is a close and tense affair. You never really know who is going to come out on top until the very end. And there's a definite feeling of this game giving you more and more as the game progresses, right? That's get a little bit crowded with four players, which funnily enough is its best player count. And as such, you might feel like some of your turns are wasted towards the end of each round. Answer that Pillars of the Earth is a simple timeless classic that we keep coming back to again and again and again. So, you got us Pillars of the Earth. Remember, if you knew it, subscribe to this channel, right? Hit like button and all that YouTube See you next time.

Progress saved