Etherstone: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Etherstone. Is it upside down? Nope. There we go. which is a game that I was really hoping to get played in 2025. Uh so it could make my top 10 games of the year because it most certainly would have. There's no reason why that that I would have disliked this game. Um but it's an interesting one because I remember it going on Kickstarter and for some reason I was just like, eh. Probably because I have millions of [ __ ] campaign games backed and I'm like I just can't I can't get another one. Um, even though this isn't a campaign game, but yeah, this is designed by Vo Giggley, who I don't know off the top of my head, but I do recognize Simone Lucani, who is a phenomenal designer. And if you're looking into this game, you are probably going to hear tons of comparisons to Rez Arcana, which was a game designed by Tom Lumen, Tom Layman. Um, and it is very similar to that. Now, the question is going to become should you own both? And I'll answer that at the end of this. But either stone is a game about uh where you have a hand of eight cards and you are trying your best to build an engine out of those eight cards uh by utilizing dice and these uh these
ether stones. Um what makes this game absolutely fantastic is the sheer amount of cards that the game comes with. And each of them are unique. So like these are all the different cards that you could potentially have. Now, what's really cool is that whenever you're setting up the game, you actually will draft your hand of eight. Uh unlike or seven. Sorry, I keep saying eight. Oh, one two three four five six seven. Yeah, you you draft your hand of seven [snorts] um out of So what happens is if you're playing your game, you will shuffle this entire deck and deal each player seven cards and then you will also be dealt two leaders. Uh and your leaders are incredibly important. They're kind of like commanders in uh in Magic the Gathering where you kind of want to draft your hand to to uh work well with your leader. Now, you don't necessarily have to, but it probably would benefit you to do so. Um and so you you will get two leaders to look at and then you do the draft phase. So, what's really cool is, like I said, each one of these cards are 100% unique with uh, you know, different abilities, whether it's based off the die number you draft, the die color you draft, um, what cards you already have out, what cards that you might bring out, and
you're drafting your entire hand of seven, and then you play the game. Um, the biggest difference between this and Res Arcana already is the fact of that drafting phase. Now, in Resarchcana, you're just dealt eight cards. You just shuffle all the cards, deal someone a deck of eight, and you have you have your eight cards. Now, you're meant to look through those and and see what the synergy is, but that is also your deck. Um, so Res Arcana, you have a deck. You draw from Ether Stone, you have a hand, and those are just in your hand to play. Uh, this type of gameplay has always just been amazing for me. There's a reason why some of my favorite games that aren't campaign narrative driven campaign games are card games like this because even though now we're in a we're in an era of more and more, and I'm gonna say it, I want them to support this. I want more expansions.
You really don't need it. you can actually just go out and get this because we're in this yeah mindset of like really this is it? This is a [ __ ] ton of cards. Like when in comparison to the fact that you only will ever get seven. Now if you're playing with four people that's 28 cards that you're going to see, but you could literally play with those same 28 cards and draft differently and have a different game out of this entire deck of cards. on top of the fact that those same 28 cards hypothetically would work differently [clears throat] based off the different leaders. Now, there aren't as many uh leaders in this game. God, this insert is not awesome, but there's a decent amount. I'm trying to find Yep, there they are. Oh, nope.
Almost. Yep. So, like these are all the leaders. So 2 4 6 8 10 11. So 13 total leaders that you get to uh only ever pick one of you'll get drafted to, but you get to pick one. So one of my favorite things about this game is the the multiuse cards depending on how you're going to utilize them depending on the synergies that you have since drafted. [snorts] Um so it gives the players a lot of agency. you're not dealt a random deck of cards and you're like, "Well, I hope these work out." Uh, but at the same time, like I mentioned with Res Arcana, the biggest difference here is that you the the cards are the synergy within themselves. There's no external tokens or tiles that you take uh that can aid you and make some cards useful. uh because there might be a chance that you're looking for a specific card uh or a specific type of card in the drafting phase and it's just not coming your way.
So, you might have seven cards and one or two of them might be completely useless to you that don't work well. In res arcana, they have ways to make bum cards actually useful, which should be there because, like I said, you're only dealt eight at random and you're not drafting it. So you do have way more agency in the hand you are drafting. So what's the what's what's the whole point of actually drafting these cards? Well, there's a couple ways that this game ends. It is either when all the uh all the cards in your hand have been played that triggers the end of the game when the there's a point uh pile. So these point tokens right here. um these when there's a certain number of those that could be taken when that pile runs out, the end game triggers or whenever the threat cards are removed from the deck that triggers the end of the game.
Now, the only thing that I'm not quite sure on on on how I feel is actually how this game ends. In Res Arcana, you're aiming for a specific number of points. So, it's first person to get to this point value triggers the end of the game. Um, [clears throat] in here there are so many ways that the game can end, it feels, it still feels good, don't get me wrong, but like in the way that the game has ended for us when we've been playing is it's almost always playing all the cards from your hand, which feels a little weird because it's like, well, I drafted all of these cards to be synergized well with one another, so I kind of want to get them all out and use them all. But once you do that, it's like, oh, end game's triggered. Okay. So, you almost always have one card in your hand that you're just kind of like holding on to that you don't want to play cuz you don't want to trigger the end of the game cuz you're enjoying the engine of your cards. Uh, so that part's just kind of weird to me.
I would have much rather had it kind of either be victory point based like the token the point pile or the threat pile versus playing all the cards from your hand. Uh because I mean one of the two is going to happen regardless. It's not like oh well we can keep doing stuff that's going to prevent you know threats not being killed or points not being taken. One of those is just going to happen. So I would much rather have it to be where playing the last card in someone's hand doesn't trigger the end of the game. Um, so yeah, the threats are a very nice addition uh of this game because they actually give you something to do. Like you have followers that can go out and attack. Your leader can be very helpful to help attack. Um, it's another way for you to get kind of free actions cuz you only do one action on your turn and that might be to take a die, that might be to rest cards or refresh cards. But like eventually you're going to want to attack with some followers.
And these give you either a significant amount of points or uh an extra ability like or some extra gems. So if you're kind of starved for gems and you don't want to just do every single turn draft a die, draft a die cuz these cards can be very expensive. They can go up to I mean this one can cost six. It's six wilds but it it is six tokens. [snorts] So that'd be like three full turns of just drafting a die. Or you might be able to have some followers kill a threat and that gives you one of each type and you're like, "Okay, cool. So by defeating that, I now immediately have four four gems. So I just need to draft one die to get the six I need." So and there are there I mean it's not just gaining gems. Some of them can give you two points. Some of them can cause your opponent to lose some your opponents lose health. Some of them can let you cast another follower, whatever it might be. And there's a decent amount of threats. There's levels one, two, and three. Um, and you only have a certain number out depending on number of players, and they increase in their health. Uh, so you might actually have an entire build designed around threats, but you uh but you might not have the the strength to actually do it. My latest build of this game was all about um trying to generate points because I got extra points from the reserve every time I did. Um and there was one where it's
like I actually had some cards that were meant to deal damage to my opponent and whenever you're and then there was one card that dealt five damage to it and if you actually cause them to be corrupted basically means they go down to zero. Uh you got three points. So then by that I got an extra one. So it was four points and that causes your opponent to have to do a void packed or void cleanse void packed which means they basically reset to full uh full health value but they get a void pack token and these are negative seven at the end of the game. So that was kind of an 11 point swing in just one you know one card and and that's just one example of the cards that I was trying to get. It didn't even work to the best of its ability just because I didn't the cards that were available in the draft weren't quite as good, but it was still a decent a decent hand. Uh so yeah, so the the action system is very very cool. I like the threats.
[snorts] Um I like the threats being there. Uh they're not they're like I said, they're a way to end the game eventually. I can guess I guess I can see now that I'm talking about it. I guess I can see why they have the hand thing because of the same reason I just said. My entire build was not I was capped at a certain strength. I didn't have any way to buff my leader or not enough power of all the followers. I think my max could have been 13 and the level three threats go up to 16 or the highest one in this game that I'm seeing right now is 16. So I couldn't even kill the level threes. So, in that case, I'd have to rely on other people to hopefully kill them and end the game. And let's say they can't do it. Okay. Well, then we have the point pile. Well, that's actually a strategy as well. And if you don't build that strategy, then you're not taking any points from the point pile. So, I guess it makes sense now why they have play all the cards in your hand to end the game because you might not have a strategy designed for one or the other.
Um, yeah, it's just and and one thing I absolutely have to say, this art is is absolutely amazing. Like it it's pretty much the focal point. Honestly, if you were to show like this box doesn't really do things uh like doesn't do a whole lot for me and I think it actually kind of does it a disservice for the art that is on these cards. They are absolutely stunning. I I I don't know who the artist is. Paulo Vodto. I don't think I've ever seen his art game on stuff before, but it I mean these I would take actual prints of these. They are amazing looking.
Uh I wish almost they went a route of kind of like Arboreia. Like I almost want this box to be super busy uh with this art cuz it's just amazing. Uh, the game does have some lore that I tried reading. It's it's a it's a paragraph of stuff, but I just did not care. Like, I started reading half of it and I'm like, never mind. It's it doesn't matter. But yeah, and then I guess the one thing that I haven't even talked about is the dice. So, in in Res Arcana, there's no dice. You literally gain resources, which would be the equivalent of these gems based off the cards. And there's, you know, card effects that have you gain certain amount of of resources at the start of your turn. Um, here you have this dice system, which I wasn't quite sure how it was going to how I was going to like it. Uh, I think it's really cool. So, they have the five different colored dice. The rings don't mean anything, but the as as an action, you can actually take one of the available dice. And these are actually multi-use. One, the color determines how like not how many, but the type of stones you get, which you always get two of the color. It doesn't matter what the value is, but the value will actually trigger abilities on your cards. So, like this one is called Rebirth. If you draft a one for each ritual you have in play, you can ready a follower of yours
and gain a life. So, in this case, it's like, oh, I'm going to draft this black one. Or better yet, let's do this. I'm going to draft this red one because let's just say these are all the cards that I have out because that's going to trigger this. There are three rituals in play. So, that would let me ready three followers and gain three life. Okay, that was a one. Well, that's off the value, but they also can trigger abilities based off the color. And this all happens. It's not like you pick which one you want to do. You could pick they they would all trigger. So this red one would do that. Then this erupting land opponents lose a life. You gain a point if you have three or more threats in your spoil stack. Oh well, look at that. I have three or more threats. So I got a point. Oh, neat. Uh this grid devour as a red dye gains me a red gem. Oh, the smith of your I gain a point for each technology I have in play. I have one technology in play. So, boom. On top of the fact that I got two red two two red two red gems just from drafting this. Uh, that is insanely cool to be able to trigger things like that based off just one die when you get the engine going that you're wanting. Um because then it's like, okay, on my next turn I'm going to attack with my Grit
Devour and he when he attacks I can lose red gems to give it plus X depending on how many I lose. Oh, I'll lose all three of those. So this is now a seven attack uh just from the one die I got on the previous turn. Um it is a very engineheavy comboheavy type of game. And what's again really neat, I was not expecting the box to be that thin. Like I was expecting, you know, a bigger box. So it's just really neat. The the one thing is so resarch does have player interaction. It seems very little like there's very few, at least in the games I've always played, there's very few cards that are meant to directly hurt uh your opponent.
This game has more cards that are player interactionheavy, but nothing in the sense of like when you do your attack action, you don't attack other players. You you have cards that cause your opponents to lose health. Um, and that's pretty much the only type of player interaction. Like you're not I mean besides stealing threat cards uh or drafting dice that they might want, which you could see what they have. It's like, "Oh [ __ ] I know that they want red and wow, they want ones as well. It's my turn. I'm going to draft this red one." So they uh red one signing off. Uh whenever you So So they can't do that. That's kind of the the peak of player interaction. But the dice are also kind of interesting because there's this purple one. That's the void one. It's a wild. Let you take any two of any color, but it costs a life to do so. If you don't like the results, like my uh my cards were needed fives or sixes, preferably fives. Didn't matter what color. If I rolled, let's say there were like these two that were already taken, and it's my turn and there's no fives there. Well, I could pay life equal to the amount of dice that are left to roll. So, it's like, okay, I'm going to pay three life to roll all of these and hope that, you know, a five comes out, which it didn't. So that is kind of the pros and cons of the dice. Like the combos when you do get
the the values or the colors that you need is really cool, but if you are relying heavily on a certain type and prefer I mean it's mainly the numbers like yeah I guess the numbers are more specific but there's a chance that there are more of them versus the colors that will only ever be that one color. Uh, but it did happen a couple times where it's like all the rules like this one were three twoin ones and it's like [ __ ] I'm not getting anything from these. But I I do actually really like the dice system in this game a lot more. It just adds more of like uh variability, if that's even a word, to the uniqueness of the cards here. So I the question does now come to if you have res arcana should you go out and get either stone. Um and that's actually a tough question to answer because they are very similar.
Um, if you it it kind of comes down to if you like combat because Res Arcana, unless you're playing Resarchana for its combat, uh, which would just be kind of odd, the if you like the resource management of of Res Arcana and actually go into a certain amount of points uh, to tri the game. And if you like the fact that, oh, here are my eight cards that I just get, you know, boom, you know, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 eight. Cool. Let me look through them and let me draw and try and utilize them and be more euro about it. Uh, you might not like this one. This one does have the randomness of the dice. It does have the drafting phase where you might have to try and build something better, you know, or something great yourself. it does have um player interaction, not in a positive way. So, if you don't have ways to gain life and a lot of your opponents have direct damage attacks, you might be constantly gaining these void pack tokens. So, you might just be losing seven points. This does have that element of it's a little bit it feels like a it's a little bit more mean than Res Arcana. Uh, I'm gonna own both because I actually I mean I I do really really like this game. Um, and I guess I mean there's no reason why you couldn't
just one two three four five six why you couldn't just shuffle this deck and draw seven and do the exact same res arcana thing. But I feel like these cards are a little bit more um specific, if that makes sense. Uh that getting a hand of eight, you might be like the none of these work together. So it it feels like it's designed more around the draft. Uh but you could uh well, what's what's also interesting is this game has like a as a first game kind of thing, which most games do. Hey, for your first game, do this. they have like four or five pre-made hands where it tells you pick this leader, pick these seven cards. Um, but which that's nothing new. What's more interesting about that is it tells you, hey, these cards are actually more powerful than your on average drafted hand. So it it tells you that you might be led astray by thinking that every single hand you get is going to be this really god combo hand of cards. So it even says you should probably jump to the drafting part as quickly as possible. Like just do this first game thing to learn the icons and learn how the game kind of works, then don't ever do this again and actually play the game. So that was kind of interesting. Now, they told you, "Hey, we're just kind of making your first hand really powerful, but don't expect it to actually work out this way in other games." And that's very true.
Like, but what's really cool is whenever you do play your first game, you're going to sit there and play your cards and do it and do a certain thing and be like, "Oh man, I actually kind of see three or four different ways I could have just used these seven cards with the pre-made hand versus the way I did it." Uh now, not to toot my own horn, my our our second game after playing the first one, I did s I've done better each time that I've played the the first game. So, it's like maybe I just played that first hand wrong or I just got lucky in other games. But, I don't know. I don't know. I'm just saying I'm pretty cool. Uh, the other thing that they have in this game that is kind of weird, um, they have I don't think their icons are I mean there's not a lot of icons, uh, but they're enough that it feels like the wording on these cards is a little strange [snorts] and that rulebook clearly doesn't answer a lot of questions. Um, like there's a good there's a card where it says you can summon a cast a follower with a discount of two purple. And it's like, okay, that could be taken a couple ways. This smith of your card costs two red and two purple. Does that mean that by using that card, it only costs me two red? Or because purple as a icon is
wild, so does that mean that I can cast a follower at a discount of two just wild? Does that mean I don't actually need Well, sorry, this is I thought it was two. It's four red, but you get you get my point. Does that mean that because it's showing that icon and in the rule book it says voids are any color, does that mean that I can summon a follower at a discount of just two two of any color? I have no idea. I've been playing it as because there's purple as an icon on here, it reduces the cost of the I of the purple icons, which that's probably how it's meant to be played, but just things like that that's going to come up in a game like this that just are not answered in that rule book. Um, so the wording is weird on this game. And the the icons are they literally have an icon for called I mean there's not a lot in here but there it's a precast icon which means that so like for example this module keeper is cast this card at a discount of one black for each technology you have in play. So he's six. self before casting them. It has an icon literally to show you that it has a pre-cast ability, which would mean if you have a bunch of technologies to play, let's say you have three technologies to play, he only costs three black and then you pop him out. Um, which you don't need an icon for that.
You It could just not have the stupid icon. So, they they have not a lot of icons, but the icons aren't super intuitive. Luckily, there's a player, the opposite side of the player, it has them, and it's pretty quick to see what they mean, and you learn them quickly enough. But yeah, in a game like this, it just feels like they could have made some things a little bit easier uh to to uh be more intuitive. Anyway, all that being said, I think this game is absolutely fantastic. What will put this over res arcana for me is if they actually support it. Like I I mean even though like I said this is more than enough cards. Um but you want them you want kind of these kinds of games to kind of keep expanding and keep being uh innovative with things that they can do. Um you want more factions to come out. you want more uh you know newness in the game to uh to keep it fresh. Um I mean hell Res Arcana obviously is the older game and it has two expansions that just improved upon it each time you threw them in there. Uh in this case like you would want more leaders uh to make to to synergize with previously made cards. You want obviously more cards, maybe a new faction uh that comes out because there
are technically five factions based off the colors. Um you definitely want more threats uh because there's actually not that many threats even though they're not that big of a deal in the game. Uh you want more threats. Maybe you want more dice, different types of dice colors, different dice effects. you just want more things to kind of keep the the the game going, which I mean it is Thunder Griff as [snorts] a company. I if I'm not mistaken, I think they support their games pretty well. Uh Simone Luciani as a designer is I don't know how much of a hand he had in it, but I mean, as far as I'm aware, he does at least a pretty good job. and this game doesn't seem like it would be that uh cumbersome to actually support. Uh so yeah, I mean we'll see that. Again, this game just came out, so it came out last year, so we'll see uh what they decide to do with it in the future, but I think that they have a fantastic game already.
And yeah, so on a scale of 1 to 10, um either someone's going to get a nine for me. I really really like this one. It's It's quick as well to play, quick to set up. Like, this is a a very awesome compact game that differentiates itself enough from [snorts] kind of what is clearly the inspiration of Res Arcana, uh, that you don't feel like you're just playing Res Arcana, you know, which is awesome. So, yeah, that's it, everyone. That's my thoughts on Etherstone. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time my update is for you.