Carnegie {Solo Variant}: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the solar variant of Carnegie which was a a game that I was like okay how are they going to end up doing a a solo variant for this because it seems like this is definitely one that is geared a little bit more towards multiplayer but I gotta say the solo variant is extremely good like so for the run through that we did I did it as a two-player run through and both of us agreed that in a multiplayer game three players is probably uh is is gonna be the sweet spot like for this kind of game in a two-player game it's a little bit too free for like in the donations for example it's like most people are going to be able to get the donations that they want so then it's just the same amount of swing and oh I got 12. you got 12 I got 12. you got 12 yada yada and it just goes like that and in a three player game more people are being contentious for donations so it's like oh I got 12 okay well because of that he took that one so that got him 12 and not you and it's just more points being spread out across multiple people but uh and so in the solo variant you of course set it up as a two-player game and you're going against the dummy and I found this to be way better as a two-player solo game you know the solo variant way better than the actual two
um the two-player multiplayer experience which is very strange for any of you who have watched my channel for a long time and you especially watch my solo variants and solo discussions you know that I actually tend to hate AIS that get stuff for free you know where you have to struggle for you know constant upkeep you have to struggle with money or food or uh or resources and the bot is just like oh take this take this take this take this and that's exactly what Carnegie does because he doesn't have to worry about he doesn't worry about study points he doesn't have to worry about um you know money he doesn't have to worry about cubes he doesn't have to worry about you know any of this he just gets to do his actions and yeah they and you would think that that would be extremely annoying because you do have to manage money you do have to manage your cubes and you have to manage your workers he doesn't have any workers and I find that the way that this game does it is in a very it's not annoying and I think the reason is because you have quite a bit of information and it replicates what you think about in a multiplayer in a multiplayer game as well because in a multiplayer game you're trying to be as efficient with choosing your actions so that you maximize your turn better than everyone else because it's one of those games where this is the action that you pick it's your turn to pick everyone else
does that action as well and the solar variant is no different when you pick an action you're you do your action like normal and then he also follows based off the cards he also follows the same action it's just now weaker and I think that that is extremely fascinating I I think it's I think it's awesome because whenever you look at his cards you see on the back oh this is the action he wants to construct so he's going to do a really powerful construct action if you let him so if you also want to construct you better make sure that you're going to be able to do a bomb like a bomb ass construction that is going to at least compensate for what he's doing now you don't know exactly where he's going just like you wouldn't know exactly where someone else is going in a multiplayer game so in this case it's like okay I'm gonna do I'm gonna risk it I'm gonna be able to do the construct action because I can pull people to get a lot of income and then use all that stuff to be able to do an action and I'm I get to place I have enough cubes and I have three workers I'm gonna be able to place here and take up some spots and then he flips it over it's like well you did the construct action so he's gonna place an Albany New York Washington and Pittsburgh and it's like [ __ ] that uh that kind of sucks because that's essentially like you can add up the points because if that was Albany New York Washington and Pittsburgh then it's that would be
three four five six seven eight um 9 10. that's that's a 10 point swing effectively is what that action does so you better hope that whatever you did is gonna at least equal or lead to you equaling more than 10 points but and if and if he always got to do the action then that would just be annoying he would just be way too overpowered and the the game rules specifically State like and your Carnegie himself will be the virtual opponent it goes without saying it will be difficult to win against him yeah like I thought I had this in the bag with the leap of just in-game points that I had and I won by three now again I forgot to set up funny enough I forgot to set up one my my starting house uh so I kind of compensated by I'm like okay I'll give myself two points so if I didn't do that then I actually would have just won by one point uh but it's extremely fascinating because you're looking at what you can do and then you get to see here is what he wants to do because every at the beginning of every round you always take the next card and you put it over at least whenever you're choosing you you move the card over onto the zero Victory Point track and you go okay that's the action he wants to do can I do anything else because it's like I guess I'll do human resources because I can do this and this and this and then you flip that card over it's like oh okay because it's Human Resources he does that action it just moves over one
so that only gives him a one point because you effectively took nine points away from him because you didn't do the construct action and again they found a really awesome balance of you get to see what he wants to do you don't do that you capitalize off that but then well he does get a turn so then he goes and then it doesn't matter what you want because that very next card which you can see he wants to do because you can see the next card he flips it over and it's like okay he's moving three over in the South uh so he's gonna get a powerful turn the new pick and you could give him a powerful term uh uh if you so choose but if you're constantly giving him what he wants trying to cop I you you cannot match him I do not believe that if you were to do this you know all the same actions that he wanted to do when it's your turn you just there's no way he does get too much free stuff he would place too many cubes he would place because eventually he runs out of uh discs so if he runs out of discs it's not like you stop him like he has these discs placed out and then now when he can't place discs then he just moves that card over so that's just more points for him at the end of the game anyway so I found that you you have to balance it and it is such an awesome brain exercise if you
watch my run through I did not do particularly well funny enough before we had done the run through I was like you know what I want to try something and I tried the strategy I did in the solo run through where it's like can you do well by getting in-game victory points if that was your entire strategy and you can like I mean 129 points is uh is is a good score I think um I was struggling like for the most part I was like okay I need I need money I need I need cubes but what was great is every time he did something it wasn't like oh I can't do anything oh I can't do anything I was struggling but I was still able to keep it manageable and because you can see what he wants to do then you're like oh he wants to do this action so therefore I'm gonna do this action which lets me place people out on missions so then because I know he's doing that action that's going to cause it to go into the West so then I can pull my person get my income get my six four the six points and just kind of do that so I can use what I see from him to benefit me which you can do in a multiplayer game that's that's the most fascinating part about this uh the game takes just as long it it equates to about the length of a two-player game if not quicker just because you don't have to wait for someone else to think you can just okay well let's hit okay the boom it's my turn I'm gonna do this it's his turn I'm gonna do that and I'm just I'm just blown away by by the
solar variant the anybody whenever he was taking development tiles like I wasn't sitting here going oh great I can't take any I had I mean if I wanted specific tiles then I should have gotten them like and he always takes the lowest so if the ones that are out you can see if okay if there's one that's very low then I should probably try and grab that first it doesn't say whether or not he takes duplicates I assumed he did uh that's so that might be a mistake on my end like if there's two threes left and he's taken three tiles from Human Resources does he take the two threes or does he do a three and a four because you can't have two tiles of the same type I assume that that rule didn't apply to him because he just kept a stack of them but it's so funny because you would think and it's it's possible how he's gonna score you would think that he would get a lot of points from the cards that are actually moving across and again this was normal difficulty and I barely beat him I mean I'd probably just get whooped in difficult or expert but he didn't get as many points from the actual cars he only got three out to the number ten which is still 30 points uh like 36 39 40 for him he got 43 points from the cards which was I think a little under how many I got in terms of in-game victory points the number one not necessarily complaint but the number one weird thing I can see that would
annoy a lot of people is how his donations work because he obviously doesn't have to deal with money or cubes and I actually prefer the way they did it here than what normal games would do so whenever a donation happens obviously he you just flip the card and it's like okay that's the one he takes if he can't then this just moves over it's really nice that it isn't like oh if you can't take that one he takes the one less it's just nope he's gonna compensate by getting victory points uh but what's really interesting is the fact that his donations he gets points based off what you do which is so bizarre and I even read it in the run through of their tip which I'm so glad that they have tips in here uh for that because it's like wait a minute why does he get why does he get points based off the industry buildings that I've placed like just because I mean that's just the way they did it it's uh I mean they tried to make it thematic where it's like yeah you know businessmen of Andrew's caliber don't care but what's fascinating is I like the fact that they didn't just make it oh every donation he just gets 12 points he just always gets the max amount of points that would just be dog [ __ ] uh because that would effectively mean he could potentially get a total of eight cubes out or eight discs out and then just get what is that 88 94 he would just get 94 points if that
was the case so again similar to how you could see what actions he wants to take okay donation coming out you don't know which one he's gonna take but then you can see it and be like okay well he's gonna get points for industry buildings that are now out I'm not gonna do that because that's just gonna get him but you know potentially 12 points if I followed that so I actually don't mind it which is super weird because he would think I would hate it because it's like well that's not fair like why does he get points just for doing what I what I'm doing and you could get screwed you could get one where you were doing like I mean like he took the one it was two points per small city which was my entire strategy of getting to Chicago to connect it and it's like that was 10 points for him and I didn't get the 10 points but I think it's also compensated by the fact that he doesn't do links like uh just because of the way that he places his out it he's not gonna get like he just gets six points if he's maxed out on the end of all the tracks uh or each track he gets six points I like the fact that they didn't try and make it to where oh how many did he link to and then all that because that would also be a little bit broken so I think that's why they also put the donations is he gets points based off what you do to compensate for the fact that I mean I got 18 points because I am able to try and link up cities I mean potentially if I went a little bit more into that I could have connected them all maybe not
all of them but at least one more to make it four which would have been 27 points but I didn't go that strategy so I I think it's actually brilliant I think it works out extremely well to be completely honest I do not have any complaints with the solo variant it's it you still get to play the way you want to play which is my always my positive it's not hard at all to play him uh it might be hard to beat him just because playing on normal and there's two more difficulties which just lower and it's super simple to set up it's the number of normal cards versus advanced in an expert game I believe it's what 10 Advanced and 10 normal yeah 10 and 10 expert is five normal and 15 advance and there's enough in here so like all the advanced cards are I mean there's it's all these and then I think there's five more so because there's a beginner if in a beginner it's all normal cards so you can predict everything he's gonna do in normal of course there's five parts you don't know what he's gonna do then expert or difficult it's 10 cards you don't know what he's gonna do and expert all of them you have no idea what actions he's taking so you can't predict what he's doing at all I should have done an expert just to see how badly I just got annihilated um and that seems a little much just because in a multiplayer game you can see what someone potentially might do or
try and you know hedge your bets but it and no but just no idea no idea yep that's Andrew Carnegie uh he's that's why he's the elite businessman uh so yeah anyway it allows you to play like normal you can try a various number of strategies I don't see any reason why you couldn't put in the expansion stuff because because he doesn't need to worry about a building board so he does it doesn't matter which departments you have um the modules or not the modules the donation spots changing shouldn't matter either because he's just going to take them so that now it it only applies to what you as a player do yeah it's it's extremely um and I think I won just by happenstance like because had I I never did industry and I thought about doing it multiple times but because I was using my cubes for the Public Public infrastructure I didn't have the cubes to do industry but literally if I had done the very first one we would have tied and I'll even know what the tiebreaker is um I have never tied so let me check oh nope uh no tiebreakers type players must shake hands and Savor their shared victory so yeah just yeah we would have tied and I'd be like all right good good good going me uh yeah and the other cool thing in this solar variant because you you actually
alternate taking turns is you can keep track like you always start so there were multiple times where I was like crap did he just go or did I just go okay well me him me him oh okay it's a certain oh I forgot to move that even in the run through I forgot to move it one time and I'm like crap me him me him okay there's me and then I just move it back so clean so so freaking clean and yeah I mean this is this is a solo variant that it's like okay do I have three players to play Carnegie no okay I think I'll just play it solo like I would much rather play this over a two-player multiplayer game like it's just that much that much cleaner and the board felt less restrictive and I think that's just because or not restrictive it felt more restrictive which is actually a good thing because I didn't know where he was gonna go uh and because if he does a construct action he does a lot of cities that he does fill up the board quite a bit um that it felt like that I had to really get to my cities like quicker than normal and the donations because you didn't know which donation he was going to take it it felt more like a you know kind of like I don't know I just like the fact that it was a little bit more restrictive because in a multiplayer game you could be like oh well they have a lot of cities in the East so they're gonna take that one should I take that because you
can't cut through a play against him because you just don't know what he's gonna do you just get to you have limited information you know what action he's going to do best on if you do that you're probably going to get burned so do something else but he still gets something it's fascinating uh Carnegie solo variant on a scale of 1 to 10 is a 10. I I really really like it um just the sheer amount of variety because also multi-use cards is great just because this is the one where he wants to do a construction action and yeah that would get him three tiles which is effectively six points that doesn't mean that you know you know it's going to be three you don't know what the human resource is going to do you don't know what the construction is you don't know what r d is going to do because between both of these they're different like this one right here on the r d he moves it one on the west this one he moves a two in Midwest and because of that let's say he moves the two and Midwest but the previous action caused him to move it all the way to the end well now he now moves it twice so that's three points for him it's it's fantastic like this is a game that I would actually recommend to go out and get just for the solo variant like it's it's that fascinating so so if uh if what's his face Xavier George's if he's the one who designed the solo variant as well because normally in
other games it's here's the main designer and this person did the solar variant if he designed the multiplayer game and the solar variant he he did a he did a stellar job so yeah can't really think of any any other negatives it's it's super good so that is my thoughts on the solo variant for Carnegie let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like I'm gonna share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you