Viticulture Bordeaux Board Game Expansion Review
Transcript
Hello, welcome back to the channel. And this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, but we might do a few playthroughs in the near future if you behave yourselves. Actually, we probably won't. But today, we're going to be looking at the latest expansion for the longunning saga that has become Viticulture. We're going to be looking at the Bordeaux map pack. And in this expansion, James Stemire has added a bunch of new [ __ ] that will level up your game of vitulture. and hopefully well give you a bit of a semi you know what I mean. So in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of what's new. We'll do something a little bit different because in his infinite wisdom Jamie Stigmar has given some design ambition. So we'll be seeing whether or not he has succeeded with those aims. We'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like. Then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Vita Culture Bordeaux is worth your time of bother today and in the future. So remember if you're new here consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you after this
poll.
So, Vic Culture Bordeaux, how do you play this expansion? So, Victor Culture Bordeaux is a well, effectively it's a map pack here. On one side, you got the new Bordeaux map or board. And on the reverse, you've got a recreation of a printing of the original vitulture board that now allows you to toss away to your heart's content, the original board into the recycling bin and send it off on a bar somewhere, but it'll probably end up in a Bangladeshi landfill. So, let's have a look at what is new in this expansion. Right, there's a few extra things in the startup. Players are going to start with a grape token and a wine token already on their board. Yeah, it's going to give you a little bit of a leg up. The initial player order is going to be randomized this time. Nobody's going to be able to take the number one slot. So, it's number two or bust, right? The new gameplay elements that are on offer, you're going to have a couple of face up cards on the board, right? You're going to have a couple of vine cards and you're going to have a couple of wine all the cards here. So, you can go blind or you can take the ones that are face up, right? On the residual track, if you pass a certain number, you'll get a victory point. And legend has it, if you go back on the residual track and then you go forward again, you'll be able to get the victory points twice. Right?
There's a couple of weird bits on the wake up chart. There's now some benefits for all players. So if you take the number one slot on the wake up track, then you're going to be able to share the love with your opponents. In our experience, nobody really wanted to do this. So basically the number two slot became the number one slot cuz nobody wanted to gift anybody anything. In spring, there's a new action. You can hire an expert. The way this works is you will take a cube and you'll place it on one of the expert slots and this will give you a benefit every time you subsequently go there with a worker. Right? So, these benefits range from the sublime to the ridiculous, whatever that means. And uh yeah, you might be able to combine two wines of the same type. Yeah. So, you might have a two and a three red wine. If you go to this expert spot, you'll be able to combine them for a five strength wine. Yeah. Ordinarily, you wouldn't be able to do this unless you have blush or sparkling wine.
There's the option of making a trade. Basically, you got like a matrix thing and you're going to fogg what's here and then you'll buy what's here and then you'll put a little marble thing on it and then that space isn't available anymore. There's an extra action for the summer where you can buy or harvest a field and you can do this in autumn as well but with one or two fields here. And there's an alteration to the sell wine. Take this action in winter then you get to sell it for what's on a little chart that's next to the action. Right. And at the end of the game, you get to trade in all the [ __ ] you didn't use for victory points if you got enough of it. And that's basically everything that's included in this Bordeaux expansion. So, what do we like about the Bitter Culture Bordeaux expansion? So, the first thing that we quite like about it is that you get to be a swampy type eco warrior and you get to recycle your old board. Yeah, glad they did this because not that I'm sort of ecologically minded in any way apart from recycling my soil milk cartons. It meant that I could fit everything in the box. Yeah, if Stone M games had done this, then you'd have one of them situations where the box wouldn't quite sit nicely on the thing. So yeah, just out of convenience really, but I suppose deep down I suppose I am a little bit green. Probably with envy. I'm not entirely sure at this moment in time. So the second thing that we quite like about it is that you get to eliminate the frustration of the first couple of turns of it of course because you get a little bit of a leg up yeah okay it is a little bit feeble. You're only going to be getting some lowquality [ __ ] but it does mean that you can sort of start
thinking ahead more quickly than had you not had these wine tokens and grape tokens and all that sort of thing. Yeah. So you could have house ruled this in. I suppose this is nothing to stop you from doing it but we don't like house rules. So the fact that the Messiah has given us permission to do this is a blessing. So, the final thing that we quite like about this Bordeaux map pack is your little expo cubes give you more and more options. Yeah. Okay. It does come with a few caveats. Yeah, which we'll talk about in a little bit. But the fact that the game has given you more things to think about in a sense and given you more things to aim for is a really good thing. Yeah, because plonking your worker out on the spot doing what it says. A little bit of an ancient mechanism, isn't it? That's what we like. Bit of culture. Bordo. So, the first thing that we don't like about it, and this is sort of the same sort of thing that pissed us off about V culture world, is that the map now feels a bit like a spreadsheet. Yeah. If you flip the board over and have a look at the original V culture board, it feels more organic here. The action spaces sort of blend in with the map more and it's more atmospheric here. The spreadsheet design of this one sort of detracts from the game and it takes you out of the immersive experience here and I don't like that at all. So, the second thing that we don't really like about this is that I'm struggling to think why this has been made 13 years after the first game. I thought Vit Culture was done and dusted. I thought that the Tuskany expansion closed the game up. It was fantastic. And then suddenly out of the blue, we're greeted with this. I had to get it because I love Vic Culture.
And I just struggling to think why this has been made. Yeah. After all of the fantastic stuff that's been done up to this point, then a piece of cardboard appears with a color cubes. Yeah. So, the final thing that we don't really like about this expansion is that the additions are largely underwhelming. Yeah, the trade matrix is well, what's so special about that? Yeah, I don't really understand that. It's just largely boring. But like we said, the spreadsheet design isn't that great. The tweaks, the things that you could have implemented yourself. The main draw is the experts. But the problem with that is that you find people analyzing the board more and it drags the game down. Yeah. Okay. More options are welcome, but there's so many of these [ __ ] options. I found myself going boss eye trying to see what they do and all that sort of stuff. Yeah. So, there's probably too many of them and maybe you're not even going to be able to use them. Yeah. Because the strategy that you think you're going to have at the beginning when you're going to have to get them because everyone else is clamoring for that expert space may not be the strategy that you have embarked on later on in the game. So, you're stuck with an expert that does largely [ __ ] all. And let's be honest, most experts do talk out their ass. Before my battery runs out cuz it's in the red, let's have a look at some of the design goals and see if Mr. Stegmire has succeeded in his ambitions. Right. So, first of all, he wanted to have a faster game. And I don't actually believe that that's actually happening. And he says, especially at five to six players. Well, the experts drag the game down like we said and it actually makes the game longer. Yeah. So, I don't think that that has happened. Giving players more agency specifically for the card draw.
Well, obviously that's going to happen because now you've got two cards face up. Yeah, I mean that's not really anything special, is it? Providing greater incentive to use the wine- making process. Well, the game's about making wine, isn't it? Why would there not be an incentive already to use the wine- making process? What? Increasing the impact of coins on engine building and victory, right? Okay. Why? It's not really said why that's meant to be the case. It might be the case, but I didn't really notice being overly reliant on coins. Okay, you get more of them. There's more spaces to go there, but why? I mean, you're just going to end up hoarding them for the end of game victory points. Is that what you're saying? I don't really understand that. It needs more meat on the bones. That one adding a compelling alternative path to getting workers. Were you going to train them? But you did in the old one, unless I'm missing something. Making more actions relevant later on in the game. Well, again, I didn't really notice that I was relying on certain actions later on in the game than I was at the beginning because V culture is a game of adapting your strategy dependent on whether or not you get blocked at certain spaces. So, that's largely by the buy, is it? Anyway, to summarize, so to summarize, is bitter culture Bordeaux worth your time and bother today and in the future.
So, we are going to say no. Bitter culture the Bordeaux map pack is something of an anomaly. While we ordinarily welcome map packs in inverted commas, it seems bizarre that this has been released when the game is pretty much done and dusted. Sorry, 13 years after the original game was released, the additions are well basically lackluster. Yeah. and the move towards a spreadsheet design in terms of the way the board is laid out destroys the theme in my humble opinion. That said, the experts add more options and you do get to save the planet by recycling a piece of cardboard. But overall, this is a strange offering that adds very little to the Vita Culture series. And as such, does anybody want a free copy? So there you go. That is Vita Culture the Bordeaux board. Remember, if you are new here, consider subscribing to this channel. Hit the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] We will see you next time.