Rush M.D: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Rush MD. Now, this game came out many, many years ago at this point, uh, I think during COVID, so in 2020. And this has been one that I've always kind of been interested in because I I like realtime games actually quite a bit and it almost feels like it's a lost art. There's not many realtime games that come out, but there is also a niche market for it. I feel like a lot of people don't really go for them. Uh, but it's always been one that I've enjoyed in in uh my history of the hobby. And I think this game is a classic example of don't judge a book by its cover because when you look at this, you think it's just I don't know, maybe it's just me. I've always kind of I've been interested in it, but I'm like it's probably going to be bad. I don't know.
Uh just the the art. And then you look at the designers. Well, I'm not familiar with I mean I with Anthony or Constantinos from uh from name right off rip. I am familiar with David Turkey and that took me by surprise that he was involved with this. All that being said, this game is an absolute blast. I have really enjoyed my time with it. It does a lot of things that I I enjoy in real time games without it being overwhelming. Because sometimes in in the past, real time games have always been just go go go and then you just you're done and you have no chance for like a reprieve.
This game doesn't necessarily have that. Um how it manages real time is actually kind of twofold in that you have a timer. So, every round is only four minutes, but you also have hourglasses, and these are essentially your workers that you are managing throughout the hospital. And this is another thing I've always enjoyed in games. I like hourglasses for some reason, not as the overall timer because you're not paying attention to it. So you use a digital timer or your phone for the 4 minutes, but these work as your workers. So whenever they are actually going and doing something, you flip them over. And in my experience, the hourglasses have always worked to then do the action of what you're doing. And you can only move them whenever the timer has run out.
Weirdly enough, I know it doesn't look thematic, but I the hourglass system has always been a nice cool thing that in my head is, okay, this represents the time it's taking that worker to actually do the job. And that helps. I mean, in the real time element, you don't really have a lot of time to think thematically, but when you're looking at the game as a whole, it's I don't know, it helps. I really enjoy that whenever you send your doctor, where is it? Your doctor worker to a location. Okay, I'm taking them over here to have them get a a CAT scan and the doctor one takes a little bit. I think they take a little bit longer. I haven't officially timed it. I wish the rule book would actually say how long it takes, but I'm pretty sure the doctor ones take a lot longer. But that makes sense.
they're doing a lot more. Um, so whenever they're helping out a patient, uh, you know, for their allergy test or for their their, you know, whatever, I can't remember all the all the different names of the spots, but it actually makes sense that they would take longer, but they can also only do specific actions. Um, I I just thoroughly enjoy that as a system. Um, but yeah, they they've done a really good job with this game managing the different hourglasses uh while also doing some really cool uh systems so that whenever you're going to a location to bring in new patients. I like how they have an outpatient clinic for like quick uh quick effects, but they're not uh they're not just simple, okay, we're going to do this for a point or something. Some of them might be, but yeah, they're going to be easier to help because you don't have to run anything else. You don't have to admit them into the hospital. You don't have to give them a bed. They just come in for a flu shot or something and then you just have to kind of give that to them. Uh but it takes up just as much resources as everyone else that is in the hospital.
The main difference is again you don't have to administer them into a ward into a bed to then bring them to whatever they might need. Um but at the same time the nurse or the doctor can help out these people but then whereas the doctor can only be the one to administer them to a bed and then you have to bring them uh to another spot of the hospital whether it's the lab rooms and then they might need surgery. So, while the game itself doesn't feel thematic because it is literally moving around and uh you know flipping hourglasses, so [snorts] the actions you're taking, it's weird. The actions you're taking, I've never once felt like I was in a hospital while playing the game, but as you're talking about it and the things you're talking about back and forth with the players does bring out that same feel, if that makes sense.
because sometimes there are games where you are doing actions and stuff that you're like, "Oh, cool. No, this 100% feels, you know, thematic to the game. Um, but this game weirdly kind of has that blend of being mechanical while also whenever you are talking about what needs to be done or whenever you bring in a patient and you're like, "This patient needs surgery and he needs a new heart or we need lungs. Uh, we're out. We have to go to the cold storage." So, someone doctor needs to go out and get that. Uh, and then, oh great, we need blood, so we need to send a nurse over to the blood area to get more blood to put in, or we need medication, whatever it might be. All of that feels thematic. So, I think they did an excellent job blending both of those systems.
One thing that I thoroughly enjoy is there's there's a lot of moving parts and everyone has to be on it and it's not just one person's uh specific role. Yeah, the doctor can only go to these specific spots and the nurses can only go to these specific spots [snorts] but it's not one person who is doing that uh or it's not like okay this is my role, this is my special ability or anything. It's if I am sending my doctor, you know, to uh to do a a particular lab test um and then, you know, I succeed and I'm doing the the miniame action and then I flip the the card over and it's like, okay, cool. This is assigned to this bed. And a side note, neat little thing is you're moving uh these little beds around. So, as someone who had surgery about 6 months ago, it is kind of interesting of that's just how they move you around is within a bed. Uh, so you do that and then you're like, "Okay, great. After running this lab test, I found out that they actually need surgery, so we need another doctor." And that would be another player who would take their doctor hourglass or it might be the same one. uh you're kind of all over the place, which feels hectic, but really works cuz again, if someone is doing a bunch of other stuff and you're waiting for them and then you look over and realize, oh, my doctor is now available because he just did that lab
test. I'm going to, okay, I'll just go ahead and get this guy prepped for surgery. Bring him over into the uh surgery room. You can do all that. You can have one person hyperfixate on one specific patient or because I'm doing the lab test and I succeeded and they're ready to go, another doctor can swoop in and, you know, get them into surgery in this case to [snorts] start providing that to where they can grab a syringe and put in, you know, this guy needs two blood in a syringe and he also needs a heart. So then, okay, cool. That means a third doctor if you're playing with more people can come in, go grab the heart, so then it's all available. Um, I just really like that dynamic. Uh, how it you have to be flexible while you're playing the game. And the one major rule is you can't move someone else's doctor, so they have to be the ones to do that.
Uh, which makes sense. But the nurses anyone can use. It just works out extremely extremely well that it's just kind of and it's short burst chaotic fun. So even if you're kind of getting overwhelmed, which again ties to the theme, I mean it's over in 4 minutes and then and that 4 minutes goes by really quick. So yeah, I I love all the different mini games that the game brings. you know, the for the core game, it's uh I really should know what these are, but for the red one, it is you have a stack of of tokens that you're flipping over to find the one that's on the back of that card. Uh they're all relatively simple when you overall think about it. But in the grand scheme of things, they're hectic, so you're just quickly trying to find it. I would say that the mini gamess, those are not thematic.
They're clearly, you know, a mechanical to the game, but I think they work. I don't know how you would even try to make thematic without just making the game not fun. So, [snorts] yeah, you're flipping tokens to find the one. You're like, "Okay, cool. I found it. Boom. We're ready to go." Uh, the yellow one is you have this uh you have this Oh, where is it? Right here. You have this thing that has white and red uh things in it. And there's a pattern on the back of the yellow one that you have to take tweezers. I haven't even talked about the tweezers. Uh, and you have to pick those up and put them in the the orientation that is on the back. Once you do that, you flip it over. The X-ray I remember that one on the back of the X-ray cards. It shows uh bed numbers and you have to find a card that doesn't have the bed number on it. Then you can flip it. And then the last one is more of a physical kind of challenge. It's incredibly easy where you take a disc uh you take this disc and you have to balance it on the corner and you have to put your doctor um on it and then once the timer runs out uh then you can flip the card. So I I mean I enjoy those.
They're they're simple. They're easy to learn, easy to understand what you have to do, but in the grand scheme of things again it is all incredibly chaotic. Now couple things. The what's really cool is some patients have multiple uh lab tests that they have to run. So if you flip them over and you realize, okay, they they're yellow and red, you have to do both of those tests and then whichever one has a higher value, that's the one that is getting assigned to them. So that gets really crazy. But uh the one thing that I don't enjoy about this game, and this is probably I would imagine a lot of people's complaints with it is because as I just said as a positive, all doctors and nurses and stuff are kind of free flowing where we see what patient we need and okay, we realize that uh this patient is we needs to be tested for yellow which is using this one. Again, the problem is you run into a table space issue where if you are playing with multiple people, you can play this solo, then it's probably a lot easier.
If you're playing with multiple people, even at two, it's almost as if some of the mini games are assigned to a particular person because you can't I mean, you don't have the time to sit there and hand someone, oh, okay, you went to the yellow test. Okay, here's this and here's the the four, you know, the three white disc and the three red discs. Now, now reassemble them while also using your tweezers. It just doesn't necessarily work that way. And there's a lot of times where you also have resources to manage the pills and the the syringe liquid stuff that that you're trying to put in where you can't really have everyone contribute to that. At least not in the way that I found.
I'm actually currently 3D printing something to at least help with some organization. But the problem comes down to it almost falls on one person to manage a lot of that. If someone is putting a nurse in the uh in the supply area and they're like, "Okay, I need I need three yellow." It's they can't necessarily grab it, which in a real-time game, you want everyone to have access to all the stuff. And this game just doesn't seem to actually allow for that. So, in the way I've been handling it is kind of assigning labs to particular players and they're the ones that manage the miniame. Whether or not that's actually what you're supposed to do, even if it's my doctor going into the the the Yeah, I'll just keep using yellow to do the yellow. This is in front of someone else. So then they're the ones who kind of have to pause and look at the the yellow miniame and do that for that person even though they're not the ones who are actually doing the tests. Or alternatively, I just handle yellow patients, which again can also be tied thematic to the game in that that's just my doctor's specialty.
So whenever a patient comes in who requires a yellow lab test, that's the one that I'm administering, that's the one I'm sending over. And once I figure that out, then we can move them to a bed and now we can all kind of work on what they need. That does thematically work. But again, mechanically, it can be kind of frustrating whenever someone is trying to just help and play the game and they grab a patient and move them over and then they're trying to figure out, oh, you over there on the opposite side of the table, you have the yellow thing and I need that or um you have the the red discs. I mean, those are really like the only two when they're physical extra tokens. The the other two is I mean, yeah, you can toss someone a disc and they that one's easy enough, but the X-ray, that one's easy cuz everyone can just see what the bed number is and figure that out. But whenever they're physical components, yeah, it it is kind of it is weird.
Maybe that was by design so that it adds to the chaos of working in a hospital. But I that was one thing I definitely noticed in that it's just this game is an insane table hog. And that's also kind of weird because the whole design of the game is different boards. So, you know, the two different wards are separate boards. Uh, you know, the out the clinic one board, the operating room, one board. I know what they were going for because it's a hospital. You have a bunch of different uh rooms all over the place. And you can technically orient it in a way that makes sense for your gaming space. But the problem gets incredibly wonky. The way I've done it is just one long layout. But theoretically, you don't have to do it that way. You can actually have people have their assigned rooms in front of them, which I don't know why you would do that, but you could. You could uh, you know, have one section of three and another section of three and have one horizontal and have one long ways. You could do whatever you want with it. But uh it is kind of weird how they decided to go this route instead of just one big board, you know, where you have it's it's the standard four, you know, folded four quadrant board and you just have
all these rooms in one specific space. I probably would have just preferred that. And I think their next game that they did, Kitchen Rush, does just that. it's just one big board. And I think that would have made the game cleaner because then you would have a spot for the cards to go. You would have a spot for the patients to come in. You would have a I mean you like how you have it all laid out here. You would have just in a centralized location that wouldn't take away from anything. In fact, this layout does kind of take away from trying to remember where everything is at. Now, at after your first game, it ends up just kind of becoming second nature, and this is the layout that works for the players. So, I don't hate it, but it definitely kind of surprised me that a game like this would have this much table space, almost requiring you to go out and get those clear plastic containers so you can organize the the syringe stuff, which is probably my biggest hate of the components is the fact that these are so cylindrical that a lot of times they're just rolling all over the place. I know again why they designed them that way.
But just to have them I would just much rather have them in their own individual containers which is what I'm working on. But yeah, that's probably my biggest negative is the fact that the design the table the the table hog of this game is insane. And then the fact that while the mini gamess are a lot of fun and I enjoy them uh for this style of game, I think it's kind of it could be in the way of a lot of people's enjoyment because they're they're they're they want to do the mini games, but because they it's a physical thing, they have to be in the way or they have to be in someone's play area. So then you have to lose valuable time by handing it to someone with the physical components and then they have to scramble at all versus it already being set up. or this just becomes a game that's a lot more physical where everyone's standing up, which is actually how I've played this entire game, which sucks because as I'm getting older, uh, my [ __ ] back hurts by standing like this and then like I put a lot of strain on my lower back, but I don't see a way you play this game with this layout and you're sitting the entire time.
So yeah, maybe this is just a game for people in their 20s. Um the only other thing that I don't like uh which was kind of fixed in the expansion, which I'll have a separate review on the expansion, um it were the objectives. I uh they have objectives for different player counts and for different difficulties, but some of them were pretty similar. The objectives were either okay, help a certain number of patients or get a certain number of points. Um, the point system, it is kind of weird. I know why they were going that that route, but I felt the objectives could have just been more exciting. They're very bland and they're it almost felt like they were trying to figure out how to make you win the game. Uh, I almost would have just rather had it cuz there's two tracks that you keep track of. your victory points and your medical points. And you start with a certain number of medical points based off of your difficulty. And every time you make a medical error, which is either not providing patients the right amount of care or providing them too much care or whatever it might be, you lose medical points because each patient comes in with a condition, mild, serious, or critical.
And those all give you negative victory points or negative medical points if you mess up. So mild is minus one, serious minus three, critical is minus 8 uh cuz they die. And not only do they get worse if you don't help them then uh you that's how you can also lose the game by the medical points hitting zero. It is I like the medical point system uh because that makes sense. you're not helping patients who are coming in being administered but at the same time I find that the game itself is not overly difficult. Uh and and the way the reason I say that is because you decide as players how many patients to administer. It's an actual action that you go to um you know to bring them in. So it's okay a combination of one one to three blue and red patients. Well, if you're, you know, struggling, you can decide. I mean, yes, you have a victory point threshold to get. So, obviously, if you don't get hit that by the end of round four, then you also lose. So, you do have to bring patience in to be able to meet them. But then sometimes you have to balance that of, okay, we need to bring in two red and one blue. And that's always been in my games the the easiest way to manage it.
And it does generally get you the most points. Red patients that come in also have a point value. And then because they get conditions uh from the lab test that also gives you more points, whereas the blue doesn't require all that extra stuff, but they only get you a max of three. So, I I feel like this this could have been, you know, modified a different way. While it's cool that for some players, they get to dictate the difficulty of a round, uh, when you look at your victory points and it's like, okay, for our difficulty level, we need 55 points [snorts] and we're at 25. So, we need 20 points in the next two rounds. So, we need to really start bringing in some patience. So, you have some control over that.
In my experience, it's been relatively easy to game in the sense that, okay, if we get two red in and one blue, you know, generally we're probably going to get five points each. We only need 15 points. So, okay, that's going to be, you know, at, you know, on average five points per red and maybe two points. So, we got we got 12 points right there. So, cool. I that's the one thing that maybe is less thematic in that I mean I guess may maybe hospitals do actually get to control who they administer in but I always thought that you have that they have to provide medical assistance to whoever comes in. So I almost would have preferred kind of a system where patients are trickling in every round. Maybe you there's a separate side deck that you flip and it tells you who's coming in.
So, you can still pre plan. You don't want it to just be random [ __ ] that's hopping in. Um, but it'd be cool if you flip a card and it says, "Okay, two red and two blue are coming in this round." So, we know who's coming in. We can kind of manage that. And then for the setup portion of a round, not that there really is one, but you flip that many at the start of a round and then you start the timer. So that would be kind of nice so that you then you couldn't just really dictate how a round was going. I don't know. Maybe that is something they toyed with but it and it just became overwhelming. So I don't know. Again it is the objective for the medical points of losing that that makes sense. Going for victory points also kind of makes sense. I just find the objectives relatively straightforward and kind of boring. The other thing, well, they also do have a task deck that you can throw in. So, that does kind of add a little bit of to the objectives. They're side objectives where you have tasks that you have to kind of perform on top of everything else. So, maybe that's kind of the alternative to what I'm thinking of. Um, yeah. One other thing that I really enjoy with this game. I'm Oh, nope.
There's one right here. I love the syringe uh aspect. I wonder. I haven't tried to see if these actually work, but I think this is a very very neat uh element of a game cuz I feel like I I do enjoy games. This is why I like realtime games cuz they always feel more involved than a standard board game. I mean, this game could have easily just been, you know, a Euro game managing a hospital. But I don't know. I really like the fact that you have to pop these out and then if you need blood, it'll say, "Oh, they need three blood or this person needs two blood." So then you actually and you have to use the tweezers to be able to do that. Then you have to pop it in and everything you do, everything you provide to a patient actually goes into their hospital bed. It's just it's a nice aesthetic. I think that's cool.
Now, for some reason, this hurts my hand actually messing with it, but and sometimes the the wooden things do get um do get stuck. They're a little bit too big, but it hasn't been anything that's been gamebreaking or okay, cool. That's just stuck in there now. I've had one instance where it was really stuck and I was like, and it came out. But, I don't know. The syringe thing is is very, very nice. I love how they say discard after use, which I'm pretty sure syringes actually say. Um, but you do that in the game as well. Uh, it's it's a very very nice, pleasing aesthetic. So, overall, I thoroughly enjoy this game. I didn't think I was going to. I'm not necessarily a fan of the art, but yeah, there was there was there was just something about this one that after I was playing it, it doesn't last long either. I mean, four minute rounds and that's it. So, you have four you have four rounds at four minutes, so the game takes technically 16 minutes to play, but you you're playing in like 30 minutes.
It really doesn't have a whole lot of things that I actively dislike. Uh, but I can I can see this being a game that is probably divisive that some people just really don't like it because it's a lot of fiddliness with the with the tweezers, even though I enjoy that. The syringes having to actually fill stuff in the the table layout uh definitely is probably a deal breakaker for a lot of people. But if you're looking for a hospital themed realtime game that apparently they actually Well, maybe they didn't. Did they donate proceeds to anything? Maybe they didn't. I know they had a they had a thing on their rule book that was thinking the medical staff that was working during COVID, which perfect game for this to come out. Maybe it was No, I think it was uh released in 2020.
Uh but yeah, that is uh that's that's just this one's just a shocker to me. Even though I said I was kind of always intrigued by it, I just felt it was going to be bad. And to me, it is not by any means. I like this one a lot. So, which is great because this game this game came out six years ago. So, I have no excuse to be like, "Oh, it came out. It's brand new. It's the best game ever made, which is definitely not for any game. And so on a scale of 1 to 10, I'm going to give this one an eight. I really I really like it. I can see it possibly, you know, getting stale after a while. But they have two expansions for it. Um they have the ICU one and then another one that I don't have. I didn't even know it existed, the maternity one. um which I'm going to have to pick up. But yeah, I I dropped the tweezers. Anyway, yeah, I like this one. Eight out of 10 for me.
So that's it. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.